Professional Documents
Culture Documents
APPENDIX
ELECTRONIC CUSTOMER
RELATIONSHIP
MANAGEMENT
Learning Objectives
Upon completion of this appendix, you will be
Content able to:
B.1 CRM and Its Relationship with EC 1. Define CRM and describe its types, scope,
B.2 Delivering Customer Service benefits, and limitations.
in Cyberspace: CRM Applications 2. Describe e-CRM, its usage, and
and Tools implementation.
Managerial Issues 3. Relate CRM to EC and customer service.
Real-World Case: 1-800-FLOWERS.com Uses 4. Explain CRM analytics.
Data Mining to Foster Customer 5. Understand e-CRM applications by category.
Relationship Management
6. List and describe the tools for customer-
facing applications.
7. Describe customer-touching applications
and tools.
8. Describe the major customer-centric
applications and tools.
9. Explain mobile and on-demand CRM.
B-2 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
customer relationship Customer relationship management (CRM) is a business strategy to select and
management (CRM) manage customers to optimize long-term value. CRM requires a customer-centric
A customer service business philosophy and culture to support effective marketing, sales, and service
approach that focuses processes. (CRMguru.com 2007)
on building long-term
and sustainable Types and Classification of CRM
customer relationships
Three types of CRM activities can be distinguished: operational, analytical, and
that add value both
collaborative. Operational CRM relates to typical business functions involving
for the customer and
customer services, order management, invoice or billing, or sales and marketing
the selling company.
automation and management. Analytical CRM involves activities that capture, store,
extract, process, analyze, interpret, and report customer data to a user who then
analyzes them as needed. Collaborative CRM deals with all the necessary communi-
cation, coordination, and collaboration between vendors and customers. For details,
see mariosalexandrou.com/definition/crm.asp.
Tan et al. (2002) and Payne (2005) distinguish the following classifications of
CRM programs:
◗ Loyalty programs. These programs try to increase customer loyalty. An example is
the frequent-flyer points given by airlines.
◗ Prospecting. These promotion programs try to win new, first-time customers
(see Chapter 4).
◗ Save or win back. These are programs that try to convince customers not to leave or,
if they have left, to rejoin. When one of the authors of this book left AOL, for
example, the company’s representative offered many incentives to return.
◗ Cross-sell or up-sell. By offering complementary products (cross-sell) or enhanced
products (up-sell) that customers would like, companies make customers happy and
increase their own revenue.
Another classification of CRM programs divides them by the service or product
they offer (e.g., self-configuration, account tracking, call centers). Section B.2 presents
these programs.
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-3
e-CRM
Managing customer relationships is a business activity that corporations have practiced for
generations. As evidenced by the many successful businesses that existed before the
computer, companies were not required to manage one’s customers well. However, since the
mid-1990s competition has intensified, and CRM has enhanced various types of informa-
tion technologies. CRM technology is an evolutionary response to environmental changes,
making use of new IT devices and tools. The term e-CRM was coined in the mid-1990s e-CRM
when customers started using Web browsers, the Internet, and other electronic touch points Customer relationship
(e-mail, POS terminals, call centers, and direct sales). e-CRM also includes online management conducted
process applications, such as segmentation and personalization. The use of the Internet, electronically.
intranets, and extranets made customer services, as well as services to partners (see PRM in
Chapter 5), much more effective and efficient than before the Internet.
Through Internet technologies, data generated about customers can easily be fed into
marketing, sales, and customer service databases for analysis. The success or failure of
CRM efforts can now be measured and modified in real time, further elevating customer
expectations. In the Internet-connected world, e-CRM has become frequently a require-
ment for survival, not just a competitive advantage. e-CRM covers a broad range of top-
ics, tools, and methods, ranging from the proper design of digital products and services to
pricing and loyalty programs (e.g., see e-sj.org; jsr.sagepub.com, and e-crmguide.com).
Note that e-CRM is sometimes referred to as e-service. However, the term e-service has
several other meanings. For example, some define e-service as EC in service industries, such
as banking, hospitals, and government, whereas others confine its use to e–self-service. To
avoid confusion, we prefer to use the term e-CRM rather than e-service. Note that people
use the terms e-CRM and CRM interchangeably. Most vendors use just CRM, and the
accounting profession literature uses that term most often.
Case B.1 provides several examples of how companies use e-CRM, and the Real-
World Case at the end of this chapter provides an additional example.
CASE B.1
EC Application
HOW COMPANIES USE e-CRM
Almost all large companies have a formal CRM program ◗ Employees at more than 200 Sheraton Hotels owned
(Agarwal et al. 2004). However, CRM programs may be by Starwood Hotels and Resorts are using a new e-CRM
implemented in a variety of different ways due to the large system to coordinate fast responses to guests’ com-
number of tools available (Section B.2). Here are a few plaints and unmet needs. When an employee does not
examples of how companies have implemented CRM: respond to a request or complaint within a time frame
◗ Continental Airlines monitors telephone calls to its predetermined by hotel management, the color of a
data center, using software from Witness Systems computerized notice changes from green to yellow and
(witness.com), which uses software agents to analyze possibly to red. Red triggers management to quickly
recorded conversations. The analysis tells Continental intervene and perhaps include special compensation
Airlines what customers really want. It also helps the for the guest. Starwood has reported significantly
company craft marketing plans and business strategy. better operating results since it implemented the
Results serve customers better and resolve problems system. For details, see Babcock (2004).
immediately, saving the company $1 million annually. ◗ Online-only bank NetBank Inc. uses CRM to leverage
To increase efficiency, Continental Airlines uses Call- customer contacts via the Web and call centers by
Miner, a labor-saving Witness Systems’ program analyzing customers’ profiles in real time and presenting
that automatically transcribes conversations into the employee interacting with each customer with
digitized text. potential for cross-sell and up-sell offers. The bank now
◗ Micrel Inc., a leading manufacturer of integrated can do more targeted marketing campaigns that better
circuit solutions for enterprise, consumer, industrial, address its customers’ needs.
mobile, telecommunications, automotive, and com- ◗ Boots the Chemists, a U.K. retailer of over 1,400 health
puter markets has become known for being “fast on and beauty stores, uses business intelligence and data
its feet” in responding to customer needs. To improve mining (e-CRM analytics) to learn about customers in
response time and relevancy of information delivered its e-loyalty programs. The retailer uses data mining
to customers online, the company uses a sophisticated to acquire insights into customer behavior. Customer
self-service search and navigation engine that service agents can analyze, predict, and maximize the
directs customers to the right information at the right value of each customer relationship. This enables
time to help them reach buying decisions. As a result, better one-to-one marketing efforts and reduces
Web site traffic grew by 300 percent; the retention customer dissatisfaction.
rate for new site visitors increased by 25 percent; ◗ In a similar manner, outdoor product retailer REI brings
the company saved $40,000 a year; and customer customer data into a single location and analyzes and
satisfaction increased significantly (see IBM 2006 manages it in real time. The results are used for various
for details). CRM initiatives. See Amato-McCoy (2003) for details.
(continued)
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-5
Many of these steps are valid both for B2C and for B2B EC. In B2B, CRM is known as
PRM (see Chapter 6).
Large-scale CRM implementation is neither easy nor cheap. Tan et al. (2002)
suggest five factors that are required to implement a CRM program effectively:
Agarwal et al. (2004) and Bohling et al. (2006) claim that many CRM projects are
disappointing at the beginning and require remediation because companies do not
manage them properly. They offer an extensive methodology on how to implement
CRM. See Compton (2004), CIO.com (2006), and Hagen (2006) for additional tips on
CRM implementation.
showed, it is easier to build applications using data in the warehouse than using data
residing in several internal and external databases. Finally, CRM itself collects customer
and product data, including click stream data. These need to be prepared for data
mining and other types of analysis.
The integration of ERP and CRM must include low-level data synchronization as
well as business process integration so that the integrity of business roles can be maintained
across systems and workflow tasks can pass between the systems. Such integration also
ensures that organizations can perform business intelligence across systems.
◗ Return policy. In the United States and several other countries, return policies
are a standard service. Having a return policy increases customer trust and
loyalty. The ease by which customers can make returns is important to customer
satisfaction.
◗ Navigability. A Web site must be easy to navigate. To gauge navigability, companies
might measure the number of customers who get partway into an order and then
“bail out.”
e-CRM Analytics
analytic CRM Analytic CRM refers to the use of business analytics techniques and business intelli-
Applying business gence such as data mining and online analytic processing (see Turban et al. 2008) to
analytics techniques CRM applications. Exhibit B.1 illustrates the basic concept. On the left side we see
and business the many sources of customer data including real-time Web movement activities and
intelligence such as real-time customer interaction and activities in POS and even while playing slot
data mining and online machines in the casinos. The large amount of data is processed and stored in a data
analytic processing to warehouse (Section B.2) and/or in a data mart or just in databases. Several types of
CRM applications. analytical tools can be applied to create, for example, customer profiles (Chapter 4)
used for planning advertising and marketing campaigns.
As Web sites have added a new and often faster way to interact with customers, the
opportunity and the need to turn data collected about customers into useful information
has become apparent. As a result, a number of software companies have developed
products that do customer data analysis (e.g., SAP’s Business One CRM, Microsoft’s
Dynamics CRM 3.0 or higher).
Analytics can provide customer segmentation groupings (e.g., dividing customers
into those most and least likely to repurchase a product); profitability analysis (which
customers lead to the most profit over time); personalization (the ability to market to
individual customers based on the data collected about them); event monitoring
(e.g., when a customer reaches a certain dollar volume of purchases); what-if scenarios
Call Centers
(how likely is a customer or customer category that bought one product to buy a
similar one); and predictive modeling (e.g., comparing various product development
plans in terms of likely future success given the customer knowledge base).
Benefits of CRM analytics lead not only to better and more productive customer
relations in terms of sales and service but also to improvement in advertisement planning
and analysis, marketing strategies, and supply chain management (lower inventory and
speedier delivery) and, thus, lower costs and more competitive pricing.
To derive the most benefits from e-CRM, it is necessary to properly collect and
analyze relevant customer data. Nemati et al. (2004) provide results of a study on the
integration of data in e-CRM analytics. Analytics can analyze and document online
customer or visitor patterns to acquire and retain users. Using data mining properly
provides companies with valuable information on how to serve customers online.
According to a 2004 CRM study (CIO Insight 2004), 75 percent of all large CRM users
are using or will soon use CRM with data mining and analytics.
Customers
Seller
Self-service
Campaign
Customer E-Commerce
Management
Support
Integration
Customer-Facing Systems
Customer-centric Intelligence
Sales Field
Contact
Force Service
Center
Automation Automation
Integration
Back-Office Systems
Seller
Suppliers
Supplier Systems
Source: An Executive’s Guide to CRM, Patricia Seybold Group, March 21, 2002. Used with permission.
CUSTOMER-FACING APPLICATIONS
Customer-facing applications are those where customers interact with a company. The pri-
mary application is Web-based call centers, otherwise known as customer interaction centers.
customer interaction
Customer Interaction Centers center (CIC)
A customer interaction center (CIC) is a comprehensive customer service entity in A comprehensive service
which selling companies take care of customer service issues communicated through entity in which EC
various contact channels. It allows customers to communicate and interact with a vendors address
company in whatever way they choose. Providing well-trained customer service customer-service issues
representatives who have access to data such as customer history, purchases, and previ- communicated through
ous contacts is one way to improve customer service. New products are extending various contact channels.
B-12 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
the functionality of the conventional call center to e-mail, fax, voice, and Web interac-
tivity (e.g., Web chat), integrating them into one product—the CIC.
A multichannel CIC works like this:
1. The customer makes a contact via one or more channels.
2. The system collects information and integrates it with a database, then determines a
service response.
3. The system routes the customer to self-service or to a human agent.
4. The service is provided to the customers (e.g., the customer’s problem is resolved or
the question is answered).
An example of a well-managed integrated call center is that of Bell Advanced
Communication in Canada, whose subscribers can submit customer service queries over
the Web. From the Bell Advanced Web site, a customer can fill out an e-mail form with
dropdown menus that helps pinpoint the customer’s problem. Then, the call center picks
up the e-mail and either answers the question immediately or tries to have a human
response within 1 hour. Another example is a product called Customer Service
telewebs Management Suite from epicor.com, which combines Web channels, such as automated
Call centers that combine e-mail reply, Web knowledge bases, and portal-like self-service, with call center agents or
Web channels with field service personnel. Such centers are sometimes called telewebs (see Diorio 2002).
portal-like self-service. Case B.2 provides an example of a teleweb.
CASE B.2
EC Application
DEVELOPING IBM’S TELEWEB CHANNEL
IBM’s sales of technology to large and small businesses increased customer satisfaction and decreased the need for
began in the 1960s with sales representatives, individually human agents.
or in teams, calling on customers to sell their business Specific innovations that led to the success of the
machines. A transformation of the sales and marketing TeleWeb include dedicated telecoverage representatives
channels began in the 1990s with a decrease in the cost for specific business accounts; “e-sites” customized for
of electronically offered support tools. individual accounts; online support, 24/7; and continual
Initially, in the early 1990s, 130 call centers experimentation with innovative ways of handling customer
provided support to customers in 150 countries, using needs (e.g., “click-and-connect” or “call-me-back” buttons).
5,000 agents who were available to answer questions and By integrating TeleWeb channels, putting more services
take orders by telephone. These centers were organized on the front and back ends of the buying process, and
into 25 specialized call centers by the mid-1990s, each involving humans in the middle process, IBM reaps many
specializing in areas such as multilingual support or Web benefits. Two of those benefits have been the freeing up of
responses. Concurrently, an e-commerce channel was agent time, which has saved millions of dollars, and larger
built at ibm.com. However, the company discovered that order sizes (30 percent more on Web-only transactions).
online customers were seeking help from human repre-
sentatives, and call-center use increased with Web usage. Sources: Compiled from Diorio (2002), pp. 209–213, and ibm.com
This led to the integration of the telephone-based (accessed January 2008).
system and EC by connecting Web sites with customer-
support call centers known as the TeleWeb. The TeleWeb
provides seamless service, improves selling leverage and Questions
market coverage, and reduces costs. The various communi-
1. What are the advantages of the multichannel TeleWeb?
cation channels used by customers now are integrated to
provide around-the-clock support for the programs and 2. Why is IBM so committed to the TeleWeb project?
applications offered by IBM. Such integration has 3. What were the success factors of the project?
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-13
Internet
Web Server
Product Database
Customers
Messenger Agent
Autoresponse
Sales Rep Agents
Direct Sales
and Marketing
Mail Server
B-14 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
Corporate Memory
Queries-Answers
Knowledge Base,
5 YES
Business Rules, Cases
1 Customer Autoresponse is
generated with
“I have a an answer
problem”
e-mail it to
My 2
Automatic 4
Company 6
acknowledgment: Is there a NO
“e-mail received” good
match? Send problem to a
My Company 3 Check content of human agent
message (e.g., keyword
against business rules
in the knowledge base)
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-15
CUSTOMER-TOUCHING APPLICATIONS
Customer-touching applications are those where customers use interactive computer pro-
grams rather than interacting with people. The following are popular customer-touching
applications.
E-Commerce Applications
As described in Chapter 1, e-commerce applications implement marketing, sales, and
service functions through online touch points, most typically the Web. These applications
let customers shop for products through a virtual-shopping-cart metaphor and purchase
the products in their shopping carts through a virtual-check-out metaphor. Customers
may also perform self-service support tasks such as checking order status, history inquiry,
returns processing, and customer information management. This provides convenience to
many customers and also saves them money, thus, increasing their satisfaction. Chapter 3
provides details on such EC applications.
B-16 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
CASE B.3
EC Application
AMERICAN AIRLINES OFFERS PERSONALIZED
WEB SITES
In late 1998, American Airlines (AA) unveiled a number of By using intelligent agent technology, AA built a con-
features on its Web site (aa.com) that some thought made siderable edge over its competitors. Personalizing Web
the site the most advanced (at that time) for personalized, pages offered the potential to increase customer loyalty
one-to-one interactions and transactions on the Web. The and cement relationships with customers. The Web site
site’s most innovative feature was its ability to generate also fostered the community of AA frequent flyers.
personalized Web pages for each of more than 1 million In May 2002, AA launched the new and improved
registered, travel-planning customers. How was AA able to Web site using the flexibility of Art Technology Group’s (ATG)
handle such a large amount of information and provide Relationship Management platform. The new site offers more
real-time customized Web pages for each customer? The value and convenience and greater personalization with its
answer—intelligent agents. platform upgrade, new booking engine, and improved navi-
BroadVision (broadvision.com), a major developer of gation. Today, most competitors have similar systems.
one-to-one marketing applications, developed the AA site
using a complex software called One-to-One Application. Sources: Compiled from aa.com (accessed January 2008),
One of the core components needed to generate personal- broadvision.com (accessed January 2008), and Yoon (2002).
ized Web pages is intelligent agents, which dynamically
match customer profiles (built on information supplied by
the customer, observed by the system, or derived from Questions
existing customer databases) to the database of contents. 1. What are the benefits of the personalized pages
The output of the matching process triggers the creation to AA?
of a real-time customized Web page, which for AA can
contain information on the consumer’s home airport and 2. What role do intelligent agents play in the
preferred destinations. personalization process?
Web Self-Service
The Web environment provides an opportunity for customers to serve themselves.
Web self-service Known as Web self-service, this strategy provides tools for users to execute activities
Activities conducted by previously done by corporate customer service personnel. Personalized Web pages, for
users on the Web to find example, are one tool that may support Web self-service. Self-service applications can be
answers to their used with customers (e.g., to support CRM; see rightnow.com) and with employees,
questions (e.g., suppliers, and any other business partners.
tracking) or for product A well-known example is FedEx’s self-tracking system. Previously, if customers wanted
configuration. information about the whereabouts of a package, they had to call a representative, give the
information about their shipment, and wait for an answer. Today, customers go to
fedex.com, input their airbill number, and view the status of their package shipment. Many
other examples exist, ranging from checking the arrival time of an airplane to finding the
balance of a checking account. Initially, self-service was done in voice-based customer
response systems (known as voice-activated response [VAR]; e.g., intervoice.com).Today,
these systems are integrated and complementary to Web-based systems.
Some self-service applications are done only online. Examples are using FAQs at a
Web site and self-diagnosis of computers online. Updating an address with a personnel
department can be done online or via VAR.
The benefits of Web self-service for customers are quick response time, consistent
and sometimes more accurate replies or data, the possibility of getting more details, and
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-17
less frustration and more satisfaction. The benefits for organizations are lower expenses
of providing service (up to 95 percent savings), the ability to scale service without adding
more staff, strengthening business partnerships, and improved quality of service.
It is not easy to implement large-scale self-service systems. They require a complex
blend of work processes and technology. Also, only well-defined and repeatable
procedures are well-suited for such systems. For further details and implementation tips,
see IBM (2006).
Of the various self-service tools available, three are of special interest: self-tracking,
FAQs, and self-configuration.
Self-Tracking. Self-tracking refers to systems, such as that of FedEx, where customers
can find the status of an order or service in real (or close to real) time. Most large delivery
services provide such services, as do direct marketers such as Dell, Amazon.com, and
Staples. Some auto manufacturers (e.g., Ford) allow customers to track the progress of the
production of a customized car. Some employers, universities, and public agencies will let
job applicants track the status of their job application.
Customer Self-Service Through FAQs. Every Web site needs a “frequently asked
questions”—FAQ—page that helps customers help themselves. A FAQ page lists FAQ page
questions that are frequently asked by customers and the answers to those questions. A Web page that lists
By making a FAQ page available, customers can quickly and easily find answers to questions that are
their questions, saving time and effort for both the Web site owner and the customer. frequently asked by
An effective FAQ page has the following characteristics: customers and the
answers to those
◗ The FAQ page is easy to find. The FAQ page should be available from a navigation
questions.
bar or navigation column, even if it is on a pull-down menu. Alternatively, include
a prominently placed link on the homepage and on every page offering customer
service.
◗ The FAQ page loads fast. The FAQ page should deliver answers to questions a
customer might have, and do so fast. Both purposes are best met with text; only
rarely will diagrams, pictures, or art be justified. If the number of questions or the
length of the answers increase page size enough to negatively impact loading time,
then the FAQ page should be divided into a number of smaller pages by category
(e.g., product FAQ, customer support FAQ, shipping FAQ). Alternatively, create a
FAQ index page with all the questions and link to individual pages with answers.
◗ The questions are easy to find. Do not force visitors to page down through screens
of questions and answers to find the question they want to ask. List all questions at
the top of the page and use an internal hyperlink to take the visitor to the repeated
question with an answer further down the page. After each answer, include a “back
to top” link to assist visitors who have additional questions. Questions should be
grouped by category, with headings, and in a logical order (e.g., questions about
placing an order should precede questions about shipping).
◗ The answers are written from a customer’s perspective. Answers should be written
in a simple and straightforward manner with a focus on telling the customer what to
do and how to do it. Limit the use of technical terms and clearly explain any that are
used. If the Web site serves two or more distinctive markets, more than one FAQ
page may be needed to serve each type of customer.
◗ The answers do not repeat information offered elsewhere. Writing duplicate
information is a waste of FAQ space and creates problems when the original
information is updated and the FAQ page is not. For example, the answer to the
question, “Is my credit card information safe?” should include a one-word answer—
yes—with a link to the privacy policies page. Similarly, do not be afraid to refer the
answers to complex questions to user manuals or technical documents, especially
B-18 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
if they are available online. Finally, if the answer to a question is best provided by an
external Web site, create a link to that page, but in a new window so that the
customer can easily return to the original Web site.
◗ Offer an opportunity to ask a question not on the FAQ. Because no FAQ page
can answer every question a visitor might ask, every FAQ page should also have an
e-mail address, telephone number, a “search this site” box, and a prominently placed
“ask your question here” box.
◗ The FAQ page is never done. Customer service representatives should always
be looking for new questions customers are asking that need to be added to the
FAQ page. Be open-minded in this process; many people may be asking the same
question in different ways. By definition, a FAQ page is not intended to answer
every question that is asked or submitted, but someone should be responsible for
looking for truly frequently asked questions. Similarly, at least twice each year
relevant staff should review each question to ensure that the question is still justified
and that the answer is correct. Perhaps every new staff person should be required to
read the FAQ page and suggest additions, deletions, and changes.
CUSTOMER-CENTRIC APPLICATIONS
Customer-centric applications support customer data collection, processing, and analysis.
The major applications are as follows. Data reporting and warehousing CRM data need
to be collected, processed, and stored. Here, we present two elements of the process:
reports and data warehouses.
Data Reports. Data reporting presents raw or processed CRM-related information,
which managers and analysts can view and analyze. Reports provide a range of tabular
and graphical presentation formats. Analysts can interact with the report presentation,
changing its visual format, “drilling up” into summary information or “drilling down”
into additional detail.
Data Warehouse. Medium and large corporations organize and store data in a
data warehouse central repository called a data warehouse so that it will be easy to analyze later on,
A single, server-based when needed. Online File W4.6 describes this process. Data warehouses contain both
data repository that CRM and non–CRM data. According to the Patricia Seybold Group (2002), data
allows centralized warehouses can be effective CRM tools if they contain the following information:
analysis, security, and customer information used by all operational CRM applications and by possible analytic
control over the data. applications (such as customer value scores); information about the company’s products
and services and the channels through which it offers them; information about the
company’s marketing, sales, and services initiatives and customers’ responses to them;
information about customer requests and the company’s responses; and information
about customer transactions. For more information, see Dutta and Roy (2006).
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-19
CASE B.4
EC Application
HOW HSBC MEXICO ATTRACTS NEW BUSINESS AND
MAXIMIZES EXISTING RELATIONSHIPS WITH CRM
The retail banking environment is very competitive and is Using analytic CRM (mainly data mining, due to
operating in a rapidly fluctuating business environment the large number of customers and data about each) and
(currency exchange changes, interest rate fluctuations, campaign management software (both from infor.com,
deregulations, online banking). With 1,900 branches, over a global software company for enterprise solutions),
17,000 employees, and over 6 million customers, this bank HSBC Mexico was able to improve its interactions with
faces both opportunities and stiff competition. Using CRM, customers, support the cross-selling of services, and
HSBC Mexico was able to become one of the fastest growing identify and retain the most valuable (and profitable)
financial services firms in Mexico. This is how they did it. customers. The solution also works in real time, so when
The bank’s executives decided to use EC to target an employee talks to a customer, or answers an e-mail,
customers with intelligent offers that can increase prof- the employee can find the customer’s profile online in
itability. This is done by using CRM solutions that provide a second.
the right product or service, at the right time, and through A major portion of the project was to integrate the CRM
the right channel. with other information systems as well as align it with the
In the competitive environment, it was necessary corporate business goals. Using the software, HSBC is able to
to keep the existing customers and develop more prof- plan, develop, execute, manage, and analyze the results of
itable relationships with them. The CRM targeted the multichannel marketing campaigns. The channels are: e-mail,
most valuable customers (including the ones that have a Web portal, ATMs, and face-to-face conversations. The bank
potential to become so). The company needed to find such also pushes special offers and uses relationship building
customers and then reach out to them with excellent programs (e.g., preferred relationship-based pricing). The
services and one-to-one intelligent offers—that give them information collected also helps to improve asset allocation
what they really need or want. strategies to the branches.
(continued)
B-20 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
Online Networking
Representative online networking tools and methods include the following:
◗ Forums. Available from Internet portals, such as Yahoo! and AOL, forums offer users
the opportunity to participate in discussions as well as to lead forums on a “niche” topic.
◗ Chat rooms. Found on a variety of Web sites, they offer one-to-one or many-to-
many real-time conversations.
◗ Usenet groups. These are collections of online discussions grouped into communities.
(See usenet2.org for details.)
◗ Blogs and Wikis. Blogs and wikis are becoming the major online networking tools
(see Chapters 2 and 8). Blogs enable companies to approach focused segments of
customers. In addition to Stonyfield Farm (Chapter 2), airlines, cruise companies,
banks, and similar businesses sponsor blogs for their customers. Companies can
learn from the blogs and try to improve their operations to make customers happier.
For example, by monitoring its blog U.S. Cellular learned that many teenagers were
unhappy due to the limited time on their cell phones. The company then started
offering unlimited “call me” minutes to attract the teenagers. Note that wikis can be
considered collaborative whiteboards because everyone can participate.
◗ E-mail newsletters. These newsletters usually offer the opportunity for readers
to write in, particularly in “Let us hear from you” sections. Users can find
newsletters of interest by browsing a topic in a search engine. Many newsletter
services (e.g., emarketer.com) invite you to sign in. Others (e.g., aberdeen.com)
only allow access to articles to users who register. Usually registration is an opt-in
option (i.e., a person can opt out of the list at any time).
◗ Discussion lists. A discussion list is a redistribution tool through which an e-mail is
sent to one address and then is automatically forwarded to all the people who subscribe
to the list. The following text discusses these last two networking tools in more detail.
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-21
E-Mail Newsletters
The goal of an e-mail newsletter, according to Kinnard (2002), is to build a relationship
with the subscribers. The best beginning is to focus on service by providing valuable
information about an industry, which may range from tips (“tip of the day”) to a
full-blown newsletter consisting of extensive text and graphics.
Because of the current bulk of e-mail advertising and marketing, customers may
initially be distrustful of e-mail marketing. Therefore, newsletter articles, commentary,
special offers, tips, quotes, and other pieces of information e-mailed to people must be
presented in a professional and attractive manner. As customers find that they can
trust the information provided, they will supply a company with more demographic
and personal information that the company can add to its customer database.
Sample resources for information on e-mail newsletters are list-universe.com and
new-list.com.
Discussion Lists
Discussion lists automatically forward an e-mail to all the people who subscribe to the
list so that they can react to it. Discussion lists are distributed post-by-post (each recipient
gets each e-mail from other members individually) or as digests (all e-mails are compiled
and sent out according to a schedule—for example, once per day).
The three main reasons a company may use such lists are (1) to learn more about
customers in a particular industry (assuming customers will react to the e-mail), (2) to
market the company’s products and services, and (3) to gather and share information
with a community of individuals with similar interests. If a company hosts a discussion
list, it can define the subject matter to be discussed, determine the frequency of the
publication, and even make it a revenue-gathering tool. Another source for more
information on discussion lists is edwebproject.org/lists.html.
The Creative Enterprises Network at creativethought.com, About.com’s chat site at
chatting.miningco.com, and Usenet 2 at usenet2.org provide additional information
about networking online.
Mobile CRM
Mobile CRM refers to the delivery of CRM applications to any user, whenever and mobile CRM
wherever needed, by use of the wireless infrastructure and mobile devices. The delivery of CRM
Many wireless and mobile m-commerce tools can provide customer service. applications to any user,
As described in Chapter 9, services such as finding your bank balance, stock trading, and whenever and wherever
checking airline arrival times are available with wireless devices. The major objective is to needed, by use of the
provide customer service faster and more conveniently. Furthermore, companies can use wireless infrastructure
a “push” rather than a “pull” approach to giving customers needed information (e.g., by and mobile devices.
sending SMSs). The government also is going wireless with some of its public services.
Finally, many employees’ and partners’ services are provided in a wireless environment.
The advantages of mobile CRM over traditional CRM are shown in Exhibit B.5.
Mobile video, which became commercial in 2007, also has become a platform for
fostering communication with customers.
Frustrated Users
Mobile Phone
Time Delay
Handheld
Incomplete
Pager Information
PDA
Handheld Pager
Personal Organizer
Benefits: Virtually no delay, complete information, and lower incidence of errors
Source: The Business Case for Mobile CRM: Opportunities, Pitfalls, and Solutions. Pleasanton, CA: PeopleSoft Press, 2002. © 2005 Oracle.
All rights reserved.
transmitting the text message, and then converting text found on the Web to voice.
Even more advanced systems will be available in the near future.
Imagine the following scenario: A traveler gets stuck in traffic on the way to the
airport. She calls the airport on her cell phone and hears. “All agents are busy. You are
important to us; please stay on the line.” With Visual Text to Speech technology
from AT&T, she can click on “talk to agent” on her Internet-enabled smartphone.
The smiling face of a virtual agent appears on the phone screen. The traveler tells the
agent her problem and asks to reschedule her flight. A voice confirmation is provided in
seconds, and action is taken within a short time.
Most people are more comfortable talking with a person, even a virtual one, than
they are interacting with machines. The smile and the clear pronunciation of the agent’s
voice increases shoppers’ confidence and trust. For details, see Lohr (2002).
Speech analytics, a technology that monitors word usage, analyzes voices of callers to
call centers, recognizing words such as “need assistance” and “problems,” for example.
Another technology is emotion detection, which can track voice volume and pitch to alert
managers to angry callers.
Speech recognition by computers is critical to the operation of efficient call centers
because it cuts costs considerably and enables real-time responses. The use of voice portals
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-23
such as tellme.com is increasing rapidly. Although not perfect, speech recognition is critical
for self-service. For an overview, applications, and resources, see D’Agostino (2005). Related
to speech recognition is language translation by computers.
Language Translation
Some people prefer customer service to be in their native or selected language. Web site
translation is most helpful in serving tourists. A device called InfoScope (from IBM) can
read signs, restaurant menus, and other text written in one language and translate
them into several other languages. See Wisegeek (2006). Currently, these translators are
available only for short messages. For more on this topic, see Chapter 12.
On-Demand CRM
Like several other enterprise systems, CRM can be delivered in two ways: on-premise
and on-demand. The traditional way to deliver such systems was on-premise—meaning
users purchased the system and installed it on site. This was very expensive with a large
upfront payment. Many SMEs could not justify it, especially because most CRM
benefits are intangible.
The solution to the situation, which appears in several similar variations and names,
is to lease the software. Initially, this was done by ASPs for SMEs. Later, Salesforce.com
pioneered the concept for its several CRM products (including supporting salespeople),
under the name of On-Demand CRM, offering the software over the Internet.
The concept of on-demand is known also as utility computing, and it is discussed in detail
in Online Chapter 14. On-demand CRM is basically CRM hosted by an ASP or other on-demand CRM
vendor on the vendor’s premise, in contrast to the traditional practice of buying the CRM hosted by an ASP
software and using it on site. or other vendor on the
However, according to Overby (2006), the hype surrounding hosted, on-demand vendor’s premise; in
CRM must be weighed against the following implementation problems: contrast to the
traditional practice of
◗ ASPs can go out of business, leaving customers without service.
buying the software and
◗ It is difficult, or even impossible, to modify hosted software. using it on-site.
◗ Upgrading could become a problem.
◗ Relinquishing strategic data to a hosting vendor can be risky.
◗ Integration with existing software may be difficult.
Kwok et al. (2001) developed a much more intelligent system that can answer less
structured and nonroutine questions. This is done via intelligent information retrieval
systems, using a technology called natural language processing.
For more on intelligent agents in CRM, see Chapter 4. Exhibit B.6 provides a
summary of some of the applications presented in this chapter, as well as some
additional applications.
CRM SUITES
Several vendors offer CRM software suites (see Team Assignment 2). Notable are
NetSuite CRM+ (from NetSuite), Sforce (from salesforce.com), and Siebel On Demand
(from crmondemand.com). Details on the capabilities of CRM suites are available at
Caton (2004). Also, adding visualization to CRM is useful (see Ganapathy et al. 2004).
MANAGERIAL ISSUES
1. How is our response time? Acceptable standards CRM in order to survive. The issue is how much
or metrics for response in customer service must be to provide. However, it is difficult to financially
set. For example, customers want acknowledgment justify CRM, and there are many CRM software
of their query within 24 hours. Many companies programs from which to choose. Therefore, a
seek to provide this response time and do so at a careful analysis must be done (see Holland and
minimum cost. Arbell 2005).
2. How do we measure and improve customer service? 4. Do we have to use electronically supported
The Internet provides an excellent platform for deliv- CRM? For a large company, it is a must. It is not
ery of superb customer service via a variety of tools. economically feasible to provide effective CRM
The problem is that the returns are mostly intangible otherwise. Some e-CRM programs, such as e-mail
and may only be realized in the distant future. response, are inexpensive. However, large comput-
3. Is CRM for real? How can it be justified? CRM is erized call centers are expensive to install and
a necessity; most companies must have some operate.
KEY TERMS
Analytic CRM B-8 Data warehouse B-18 Sales force automation (SFA) B-15
Autoresponders B-14 e-CRM B-3 Telewebs B-12
Customer interaction FAQ page B-17 Web self-service B-16
center (CIC) B-11 Metrics B-7
Customer relationship Mobile CRM B-21
management (CRM) B-2 On-demand CRM B-23
INTERNET EXERCISES
1. Enter dell.com and examine all the available 3. Enter oracle.com/siebel and
options. What CRM services are provided? crmondemand.com. Find what
2. Enter support.dell.com and examine all the it offers in its CRM OnDemand
services available. Examine the tracking services product. Why does Siebel collab-
Dell provides to its customers. Finally, examine orate with IBM’s OnDemand
Dell’s association with bizrate.com. Write a report program?
about customer service at Dell.
Real-World Case
1-800-FLOWERS.COM USES DATA MINING
TO FOSTER CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP
MANAGEMENT
1-800-FLOWERS.com (1800flowers.com) is a true intimate knowledge of customers. How is this accom-
Internet pioneer. It had an Internet presence in 1992 plished? SAS software spans the entire decision-
and full-fledged e-store capabilities in 1995. Online support process for managing customer relationships.
sales are a major marketing channel (in addition to Collecting data at all customer contact points, the
telephone and fax orders). Competition is very strong in company turns that data into knowledge for under-
this industry. The company’s success was based on standing and anticipating customer behavior, meeting
operational efficiency, convenience (24/7 accessibility), customer needs, building more profitable customer
and reliability. However, all major competitors provide relationships, and gaining a holistic view of a cus-
the same features today. To maintain its competitive tomer’s lifetime value. Using SAS Enterprise Miner,
advantage, the company transformed itself into a 1-800-Flowers.com sifts through data to discover
customer-intimate organization, caring for more trends, explain outcomes, and predict results so that
than 15 million customers. The challenge was to make the company can increase response rates and identify
1-800-FLOWERS.COM the only retailer that customers profitable customers. The rationale for the customer
really trust when shopping for gifts online or by phone. intimate effort is to build loyalty. In addition to sell-
The company decided to cultivate brand loyalty ing and campaign management, the ultimate goal is to
through customer relationships, which is based on make sure that when a customer wants to buy, he or
(continued)
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-27
she continues to buy from 1-800-Flowers.com and can- Many factors have contributed to the company’s
not be captured by a competitor’s marketing. To build recent revenue growth—customer relationship
that kind of loyalty, it is necessary to know your cus- management among them. The data mining analysis
tomers and build a solid relationship with each one provides rapid access to better customer information
of them. and reduces the amount of time the company needs
to spend on the phone with customers, which makes
Identifying Each Customer better use of everybody’s time. The net result is
that customer retention has increased 15 percent
At 1-800-Flowers.com, the objective is not just about
over 2 years.
getting customers to buy more. It is about making sure
that when they decide to purchase a gift online or by Sources: Compiled from Anonymous (2006), Reda (2006),
phone they do not think of going to the competition. and 1-800-flowers.com (accessed November 2006).
Loyalty is earned through the quality of the relation-
ship offered. The difficulty is that not every customer
wants the same relationship. Some want you to be Questions
more involved with them than others; some will give
you different levels of permission on how to contact 1. Why is being number one in operation effi-
them. At the end of the day, the data mining software ciency not enough to keep 1-800-Flowers.com
helps the company identify the many different types of at the top of its industry?
customers and how each would like to be treated. 2. How was the transformation to a customer-
The company plans its ad campaigns based on the intimate business accomplished?
results of the data mining done on a one-to-one basis.
3. What is the role of data mining?
For example, some customers like to be notified about
sales, others do not. Some prefer notification via 4. Why must the online presence and the telephone
e-mail. The data for the analysis is derived from the system be integrated?
data center, which is backed-up by AT&T technology. 5. How is the one-to-one relationship achieved?
REFERENCES
Agarwal, A., D. P. Harding, and J. R. Schumacher. Insights.” Journal of Service Research 9, no. 2
“Organizing for CRM.” McKinsey Quarterly, mem- (2006).
ber edition (August 2004). Boles, T. “Returned Goods Clog British Roads.” Knight
Amato-McCoy, D. M. “REI Conquers Mountains of Ridder Tribune Business News, October.
Customer Data.” Stores, September 2003. Bonde, A. “The Big Payoff from Self-Service.” ROI
Anonymous. “Ultimate Relationship in Bloom. Customer Insider, November 24, 2004.
Success: 1-800-Flowers.” SAS.com, 2006. sas.com/ Caton, M. “Hosted CRM Systems Mature.” eWeek,
success/1800flowers.html (accessed January 2008). May 31, 2004.
Babcock, C. “Five-Star Application Service.” Information CIO Insight. “A CRM 2004 Survey.” August 1, 2004.
Week, March 22, 2004. informationweek.com/ Compton, J. “How to . . . Select a CRM Implementation
news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=18400885 Partner.” Customer Relationship Management 8, no. 11
(accessed January 2008). (2004).
Berry, L. L. “The Old Pillars of New Retailing.” D’Agostino, D. “First Responders.” CIO Insight,
Harvard Business Review (April 2001). February 2006.
Bohling, T., D. Bowman, S. LaValle, V. Mittal, D’Agostino, D. “Host in Translation.” CIO Insight,
D. Narayandas, G. Ramani, and R. Varadarajan. December 2005.
“CRM Implementation: Effectiveness Issues and Diorio, S. Beyond “e.” New York: McGraw-Hill, 2002.
B-28 Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management
Dutta, A., and R. Roy. “Managing Customer Service Kwok, C., O. Etzioni, and D. S. Weld. “Scaling
Levels and Sustainable Growth: A Model for Decision Question Answering to the Web.” ACM Transactions
Support.” Proceedings of the 39th Annual Hawaiian on Information Systems 19, no. 3 (2001).
International Conference on Systems Sciences, Kauai, Lager, M. “Financial Success, Successful Finance Through
Hawaii, January 4–7, 2006. CRM.” DestinationCRM.com, September 19, 2006.
Ganapathy, S., C. Ranganathan, and B. Sankaranaryannan. destinationcrm.com/articles/default.asp?ArticleID=
“Visualization Strategies and Tools for Enhancing 6352 (accessed January 2008).
CRM.” Communications of the ACM (November 2004). Lohr, S. “The Future in Gear.” PC Magazine,
Gateau, B., D. Khadraoui, O. Boissier, and E. Dubois. September 3, 2002.
“Contract Model for Agent Mediated Electronic Nemati, R., C. D. Barko, and A. Moosa.“e-CRM Analytics:
Commerce.” Proceedings of the Third International The Role of Data Integration.” PCAI, March 2004.
Joint Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Nisbet, R. A. “Data Mining Tools: Which One Is Best
Systems, New York, July 19–23, 2004. for CRM? Part 3.” DM Review, March 21, 2006.
Greenberg, P. CRM at the Speed of Light: Capturing and Overby, S. “The Truth About On-Demand CRM.”
Keeping Customers in Internet Real Time, 3d ed. CIO Magazine, January 15, 2006.
New York: McGraw-Hill, 2004. Patricia Seybold Group. An Executive’s Guide to CRM.
Greenberg, P. “Say Goodbye to CRM as We Once Knew Boston, MA: Patricia Seybold Group, 2002.
It.” Searchcrm.com, January 4, 2006. searchcrm. e-learning.dmst.aueb.gr/mis/Cases/Chemconnect/
techtarget.com/originalContent/0,289142, sid11_ Case/Training_Files/An_Executive’s_Guide_To_
gci1155499,00.html (accessed January 2008). CRM.pdf (accessed January 2008).
Guzman, Y. “FedEx Delivers CRM.” SearchCRM.com, Patton, S., and T. Wailgum. “ABC: An Introduction to
April 14, 2004. searchcrm.techtarget.com/original CRM.” CIO Magazine, November 2, 2006. cio.com/
Content/0,289142,sid11_gci958859,00.html article/40295 (accessed January 2008).
(accessed January 2008). Payne, A. Handbook of CRM: Achieving Excellence
Hagen, P. “Creating the Relationship-Centric Organi- through Customer Management. Amsterdam: Elsevier/
zation: Nonprofit CRM.” Idealware.org, June 2006. Butterworth-Heineman, 2005.
idealware.org/articles/relationship_centric_org_ Petersen, G. S. “Positioning Your CEO in CRM
CRM.php (accessed January 2008). Implementation.” Technology Evaluation Centers,
Holland, M., and T. Abrell. “Customer Relationship November 23, 2006. technologyevaluation.com/
Management Strategies.” Technology Evaluation.com, Research/ResearchHighlights/CRM/2006/11/
February 14, 2005. technologyevaluation.com/ research_notes/MI_CR_XGP_11_23_06_1.asp
Research/ResearchHighlights/Crm/2005/02/rese (accessed January 2008).
arch_notes/MI_CR_XMH_02_17_05_1.asp Plant, R. T. E-Commerce: Foundation of Strategy. Upper
(accessed January 2008). Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2000.
Holweg, M., and F. Pil. “Successful Build-to-Order Reda, S. “1-800-Flowers.Com and AT&T Cultivate
Strategies.” MIT Sloan Management Review (Fall Relationship Rooted in Common Business Objectives.”
2001). Stores, October 2006.
IBM. “Micrel Triples Web Site Traffic with IBM Self- Reichheld, F. F., and P. Schefter. “E-Loyalty: Your
Service Module for OmniFind Discovery Edition.” Secret Weapon on the Web.” Harvard Business
June 9, 2006. ftp.software.ibm.com/common/ssi/ Review 78, no. 4 (2000).
rep_sp/6/GC380736/GC380736.PDF (accessed Scott, J., and D. Lee. Microsoft CRM 3 for Dummies.
January 2008). New York: For Dummies/Wiley, 2006.
Infor. “HSBC Mexico.” November 1, 2006. wp.bitpipe. Seybold, P. Outside Innovation: How Your Customers Will
com/resource/org_1161875403_261/InforCRM_ Co-Design Your Company’s Future. Boston, MA:
HSBC_3wp_edp.pdf?site_cd=bw (accessed January Seybold Group, 2006.
2008). Smith, A. “CRM and Customer Service: Strategic
Jagannathan, S., et al. Internet Commerce Metrics. Upper Asset or Corporate Overhead?” Handbook of Business
Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2001. Strategy 7, no. 1 (2006).
Kinnard, S. Marketing with E-Mail. Gulf Breeze, FL: Sterne, J. Web Metrics: Proven Methods for Measuring
Maximum Press, 2002. Web Site Success. New York: Wiley, 2002.
Appendix B: Electronic Customer Relationship Management B-29
Tan, X., D. C. Yen, and X. Fang. “Internet Integrated Voss, C. “Developing an eService Strategy.” Business
Customer Relationship Management.” Journal of Strategy Review 11, no. 11 (2000).
Computer Information Systems (Spring 2002). Wisegeek. “What Is an Infoscope?” 2006. wisegeek.com/
Turban, E., et al. Business Intelligence: A Managerial what-is-an-infoscope.htm (accessed January 2008).
Approach. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, Yoon, S. “Brand Names Are at the Virtual Mall.” Wall
2008. Street Journal Europe, June 13, 2002.