Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COM
PMID: 16319779 Basic Research
Received: 2005.01.25
Accepted: 2005.06.20 The antimicrobial potential of honey from United Arab BR
Published: 2005.12.01
Emirates on some microbial isolates
Authors’ Contribution: Noori S. AL-Waili1 ABDEG, Mohammod Akmal2 BF, Faiza S. AL-Waili2 BF,
A Study Design
B Data Collection
Khelod Y. Saloom1 BCEG, Amjed Ali2 EF
C Statistical Analysis
D Data Interpretation
1
Al-Waili Charitable Foundation for Science and Trading, New York, NY, U.S.A.
E Manuscript Preparation
2
Dubai Specialized Medical Center, Islamic Establishment for Education, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
F Literature Search
G Funds Collection
Source of support: Departmental sources
Summary
Background: The study investigated activity of honey towards pathogens when grown in media contained hon-
ey, or when honey was added to cultures after inoculation.
Material/Methods: 1 – Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), Streptococcus pyogenes (S. pyogenes), E.coli and Candida albicans
(C. albicans) were cultured into broth containing 10–100% (wt/v) honey concentrations. 2 – Honey
was added to broth inoculated with isolates after inoculation. 3 – Optimum growth of isolates, ther-
apeutic period of honey, and time after addition of honey that showed optimum effect was meas-
ured.
Results: The optimum growth of E. coli and C. albicans was 10 hrs and S. aureus was 12 hrs. Honey (30–70%)
prevents growth of all isolates. Honey (80%) inhibited growth of small (1 ul) and large size of in-
oculum (10 ul) of E. coli and S. aureus when added to their cultures during 24 hrs after inocula-
tion. Honey inhibited growth of C. albicans when added during 2 to 6 hrs after inoculation. Honey
delayed the appearance of microbial growth on the plates. Reculturing of specimens collected
from media that showed no growth after addition of honey yielded recovery growth for E.coli and
C. albicans, and therapeutic period of honey for E.coli and S. aureus was 2–24 hrs and for C. albicans
was 2–6 hrs.
Conclusions: Honey prevents growth of the isolates and inhibits their growth when honey was added to growing
culture. The therapeutic period of honey and recovery growth of inhibited isolates necessitates ad-
justment of honey doses according to type of isolate and grade of growth.
key words: honey • Candida albicans • Streptococcus pyogenes • Staphylococcus aureus • E. coli
Author’s address: Noori S. Al-Waili, Al-Waili Charitable Foundation for Science and Trading, New York, U.S.A., email: noori786@yahoo.com
Current Contents/Clinical Medicine • SCI Expanded • ISI Alerting System • Index Medicus/MEDLINE • EMBASE/Excerpta Medica • Chemical Abstracts BR433
Basic Research Med Sci Monit, 2005; 11(12): BR433-438
BR434
Med Sci Monit, 2005; 11(12): BR433-438 AL-Waili NS et al – The antimicrobial potential of honey from United Arab Emirates…
Table 1. Grade of microbial growth after 24 hrs culture into nutrient broth (control) and various concentrations of honey in broth.
E. coli 4+ 3+ 2+ 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 BR
S. aureus 4+ 3+ 1+ 1+ 1+ 0 0 0 0 0 0
Streptococcus
5+ 3+ 3+ 2+ 1+ 0 0 0 0 0 0
pyogens
C.albicans 5+ 3+ 3+ 3+ 1+ 1+ 1+ 0 0 0 0
Table 2. Inhibitory effect of honey (80 % wt/v) added at various times (2–24 hrs) following microbial culture (I ul of specimens of microbe
inoculated into 10 ml broth).
time needed to achieve complete inhibition ranged between ture of E.coli (between 2 and 12 hrs) completely inhibited the
2 and 10 hrs after the addition of honey. Furthermore, 80% growth of the isolate, and reduced grade of the growth from
of honey completely inhibited growth of C. albicans when 5 + to 1 + when honey added after 24 hrs. In this case when
honey was added 2 to 6 hrs after inoculation of the isolate higher concentration of honey was used (90 and 100%), no
into the broth. Honey reduced growth of C. albicans from 5 growth was observed after 12 hrs. Honey completely inhib-
+ to 1 + when added between 8 and 24 hrs after inoculation. ited growth of S. aureus when it was added during 24 hrs af-
When complete inhibition of microbial growth with addition ter inoculation of the isolate. The time required to obtained
of honey was obtained, reculturing of specimens from the complete inhibition ranged from 6 to 18 hrs. Reculturing of
media into fresh broth free of honey yielded positive growth specimens from media that showed negative growth with ad-
for E. coli and C. albicans and negative growth for S. aureus. dition of honey yielded positive growth of S. aureus and E.coli.
After 24 hrs of incubation of plates, we observed that all the The number of growing isolates may be too high after inoc-
plates streaked by specimens from the isolates taken 2–24 hrs ulation to be completely inhibited or killed by such honey
after addition of honey to their cultures yielded no growth concentration. Regarding C. albicans, the addition of honey
while control plates (without addition of honey) showed pos- after 2, 4 and 6 hrs completely inhibited the growth while
itive growth. Then after, the growth started to appear on the the addition of honey after 10 to 24 hrs reduced the growth
plates streaked by specimens from honey broth media during from 5 + to 1 + (Table 4). Increasing concentration of hon-
subsequent hours of incubation. This means that although ey to 100% completely inhibited the growth when added af-
honey did not completely inhibit growth of some isolates at ter 2 to 8 hrs and reduced the grade of growth to 1 + when
certain time it clearly delayed appearance of their growth added after 10 to 24 hrs. The higher concentration of hon-
on the solid media compared with the control. ey was not able to completely inhibit growth of growing C.
albicans. Multiple doses might be sufficient to inhibit this iso-
When higher size of inoculum (10 ul) of microbial specimens late. Reculturing in fresh broth media showed microbial re-
was used (Table 3), the addition of 80% of honey to the cul- covery growth. This means that single dose of such concentra-
BR435
Basic Research Med Sci Monit, 2005; 11(12): BR433-438
Table 3. Inhibitory effect of honey (80 % wt/v) added at various times (2–24 hrs) following microbial culture (I ul of specimens of microbe
inoculated into 10 ml broth).
Table 4. Inhibitory effect of honey (80 % and 100% wt/v) added at various times (2–24 hrs) following C. albicans culture (I0 ul of specimens
of microbe inoculated into 10 ml broth).
Candida albicans (80% honey added) Candida albicans (100% honey added)
No. Time Growth after Growth after
Growth when Growth when
of tubes (hrs)* addition of honey addition of honey
honey was honey was
added Grade Times (hr)** added Grade Times (hr)**
1 2 5+ 0 6 5+ 0 4
2 4 5+ 0 8 5+ 0 6
3 6 5+ 0 8 5+ 0 8
4 8 5+ 1+ 24 5+ 0 40
5 10 5+ 1+ 62 5+ 1+ 40
6 12 5+ 1+ 60 5+ 1+ 36
7 24 5+ 1+ 48 5+ 1+ 24
* Time after inoculation of the isolates at which honey was added to the culture media;
** Time taken to reach optimum effects of added honey.
tions of honey was not enough to kill all the isolate growing inoculated separately in broth contained honey, 2 – The
in broth media when honey added during 2–24 hrs after mi- most sensitive microorganism was E.coli when the isolates
crobial inoculation. Table 5 shows the optimum growth for were cultured separately in broth media, 3 – Honey inhib-
E.coli, S. pyogenes and C. albicans, and optimum effect of add- its microbial growth when added into media containing
ed honey to growing isolates. Therapeutic period of honey growing isolate, 4 – The optimum growth of 1 ul speci-
for C. albicans was shorter than E. coli or S. pyogenes. Except mens of E. coli and C. albicans was 10 hrs and the optimum
for small size of inoculum of S. aureus, all isolates showed re- growth of S. aureus was 12 hrs. When size of inoculum was
covery growth when re cultured in media free of honey. 10 ul, the optimum growth for E. coli and S. aureus was
10 hrs and for C. albicans was 2 hrs, 5- Reculturing of spec-
Discussion imens collected from media that showed no growth after
addition of honey yielded recovery growth for E.coli and
The study reports the main following findings; 1 – Honey C. albicans, 6 – The therapeutic period of honey for E.coli
prevents growth of large size of inoculums of microbes and S. aureus was 2–24 hrs and for C. albicans was 2–6 hrs,
BR436
Med Sci Monit, 2005; 11(12): BR433-438 AL-Waili NS et al – The antimicrobial potential of honey from United Arab Emirates…
Table 5. Times for optimum growth of various isolates and optimum effect of honey on their growth.
Size of inoculums
1 ul 10 ul
Isolates Time for
pptimum
Optimum effect of added honey
Optimum
Optimum effect of added honey BR
growth
growth Time (hrs)* Grade Reculture** (Grade 5 +) Time (hrs)* Grade Reculture**
(Grade 5 +)
E. coli 10 hrs 2–24 – 1–2+ 10 hrs 2–12 – 2–4+
S. aureus 12 hrs 2–24 – 0 10 hrs 2–24 – 1–2+
C. albicans 10 hrs 2–4 – 2–4+ 2 hrs 2–6 – 3–5+
* Time at which honey added after inoculation to obtain optimum inhibitory effects;
** Reculture in broth media free of honey.
and 7 – Multiple doses of honey might be necessary to erad- showed positive growth. Then after, the growth stared to ap-
icate tested pathogens. pear on the plates during subsequent hours. This means that
the addition of honey to the cultures of each microorganism
In all our experimentations, the test for each microorgan- does not only inhibit completely or partially the growth of
ism was duplicated to be sure that the effect is reproducible. the isolate but also delays appearance of microbial growth
Approximately similar concentrations of honey were able to on the plates, including plates that showed positive cultures
prevent growth of lower size of inoculums (1 ul) of same iso- during 2–24 hrs after the addition of honey.
lates [3]. It seems that honey has same potency to prevent
growth of low as well as high amount (10-fold) of isolates. Studies have diluted honey by distilled water to obtain var-
Honey inhibits growth of C. albicans, which was substantiated ious volume/volume concentrations of honey [12–18]. We
by earlier studies showing that honey alone or honey mixed used broth for dilution, which is closely matching wounds
with olive oil and beeswax was useful to treat cutaneous fun- that was a suitable media for microbial growth. Furthermore,
gal infection and seborrhoic dermatitis [9,10]. the percentage of honey concentration was made as weight
of honey in volume of nutrient broth. This is more accept-
Honey prevents growth of gram positive, gram negative or able since various honeys have different densities. In addi-
C. albicans. This property makes honey a good drug to be tion, In vitro studies mostly involved honey incorporated to
applied at time of closing surgical wounds or wounds due the agar plate as nutrient or brain heart infusion then in-
to various traumas. It is not necessary to wait until devel- oculate microorganism or using impregnated honey disc.
opment of sings and symptoms of established infection to As honey diffuse it will be diluted and the inhibition ob-
apply honey. This is simply because honey is a safe natural tained did not match real honey concentration used. In ad-
product. Such practice is important because wounds are li- dition, we found that disc impregnated with various con-
able for contaminations even at intensive care units. centrations of honey added to agar plate became dry due
to vaporization of fluid from the disc when media incubat-
The present study has tested whether addition of various con- ed into 73ºC for 24 h.
centrations of honey to cultures of isolates during 2–24 hrs
after inoculation could inhibit its growth and multiplica- The variations in antibacterial activity of honey can be in the
tion. This means that honey would be exposed to a larger amount of hydrogen peroxide and in the presence of ad-
number of microbes, which was expected to increase rapid- ditional antibacterial components derived from the nectar
ly during 24 hrs after inoculation. The single dose of honey source [19]. However, we have found that honey increased
added to the growing microbes was tested further to identi- nitric oxide end products in various animals and humans’
fy whether it killed the microbes or just stop their growing. biological fluids, decreased prostaglandin concentration and
It was found that bacteria could overcome the antibacterial enhanced antibody production [20–24]. We have proposed
activity of honey after a period of inhibition [11]. However, that killing of microbes by nitric oxide production might
the appearance of microbial growth after initial inhibition explain, in part, its antibacterial activity [3].
by a single dose of honey might be a result of inability of
such dose to kill all the growing isolates. This is supported The main limitation of the study is that the number of iso-
by the finding that reculturing of specimens of media that lates was not known. The use of 1 µL or 10 µL of culture
showed no growth with honey yielded mild growth of iso- broth of the organisms did not indicate the number of or-
lates. Therefore, multiple doses of honey might be neces- ganisms surviving or to be killed by honey. In order to deter-
sary to kill all the growing isolate. mine the sensitivity tests of organisms to a particular chemo-
therapeutic agent the number of organism to be eliminated
After 24 hrs of incubation of plates, it was observed that all by the chemotherapeutic agent must be in proportion with
the plates streaked by specimens from the isolates taken the agent. The weight of honey used in the experiment is
2–24 hrs after addition of honey to their cultures yielded known but the number of bacteria to be killed is not meas-
no growth while control plates (without addition of honey) ured. Therefore, measuring the number of bacteria by dilu-
BR437
Basic Research Med Sci Monit, 2005; 11(12): BR433-438
BR438