Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a
State Key Laboratory For Geo-mechanics and Deep Underground Engineering, School of Mechanics and Civil Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology,
Xuzhou, 221116, China
b
Department of Engineering Mechanics, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, 116024, China
Keywords: The Zr60Ti17Cu12Ni11 bulk metallic glass (Zr-based BMG) and Aluminum 1060 plates were welded by the un-
Zr-based bulk metallic glass derwater explosive welding technique using varied-thickness ammonium fuel oil (ANFO) explosive. The inter-
Composite material facial microstructure characterization and the element composition of the obtained composites were char-
Underwater explosive welding acterized using optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) with element analysis, high-
Weldability window
resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) and micro-hardness tester. The weldability window was
Interface microstructure
calculated to verify the weldability of Zr-based BMG/Al, and the effects of varied-thickness explosive on the
welded interface were discussed based on the kinetic energy loss theory. The results indicated that the under-
water explosive welding technique is an effective way to produce Zr-based BMG/Al composites. The Zr-based
BMG and Al plates were successfully welded without visible defects and formed about 7 μm thick transition
layer. The hardness of Zr-based BMG and Al increases near the joining interface. The obtained experimental
results are in consistent with the theoretical calculation results.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: nluo@cumt.edu.cn (L. Ning).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2019.06.035
Received 3 March 2019; Received in revised form 22 June 2019; Accepted 29 June 2019
Available online 09 July 2019
1526-6125/ © 2019 The Society of Manufacturing Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
Table 1
The related material parameters used for calculating weldability window.
Material (kg•m−3) Hv (MPa) Thickness (mm)
Al 2700 110 3
Zr-based BMG 5640 1740 5
water. The water depth from the explosive to the flyer plate was set to
30 mm using spacers placed. A special mixed ANFO explosive was
employed. The density of ANFO explosive is about 0.7 g/cm3 and the
detonation velocity is approximately 2600 m/s. The ANFO explosive
need to be placed in high-wall open boxes and was not fully submerged
in the water because it cannot be detonated under the water. In order to
study the effect of explosive thickness on welded interface, three dif-
ferent explosive thickness was designed. The thickness of explosive was
adjusted from 20 to 40 mm. The detonation velocity was measured by
recording the time interval between two probes. By detonating the
electric detonator, the underwater shock wave drove the flyer plate to
Fig. 1. The XRD pattern of Zr-based BMG plate.
the base plate and made two materials join together.
To investigate the microstructure characteristics of the joining in-
in water, but allow the water propagate explosion force to weld the terface, the specimen was cut from the resulted product parallel to the
flyer plate and base plate. The underwater explosive welding can ensure explosion direction after welding. The cross-section of the specimen
that the bulk metal glasses do not crystallize during the welding of bulk was polished using emery papers up to 3000 grit followed by diamond
metal glasses with other dissimilar materials. polishing using 1 µm diamond slurries. A HNL 300 TP L type optical
In this paper, the composite plates of Zr-based BMG and pure alu- microscope was used for the microstructure characteristic. Higher re-
minum were obtained using underwater explosive welding technique solution examination of the specimen was carried out using a FEI
with varied-thickness ANFO explosive. After welding, the interfacial Quanta TM 250 scanning electron microscope (SEM) at 30 kV with
microstructure characterization and the element composition of the Point element analysis, Line scanning analysis and Mappings. The high-
obtained composites were investigated using OM, SEM with elemental resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM) observations
analysis, HRTEM and micro-hardness tester. The weldability window were carried out using a FEI Tecnai G2 20 S-Twin transmission electron
was calculated to verify the weldability of Zr-based BMG/Al, and the microscope, the HRTEM specimen was prepared by focused ion beam
effects of varied-thickness explosive on the welded interface were dis- (FIB) system (FEI Quanta 3D FEG). The micro-hardness experiments
cussed based on the kinetic energy loss theory. were carried out using a HVS-1000A type micro-hardness testing ma-
chine (load: 4.903 N/1KG; loading time: 10 s).
2. Experimental procedures
The Zr60Ti17Cu12Ni11 (at.%) BMG (160 mm X 140 mm X 5 mm) and 3. Results and discussion
pure aluminum (160 mm X 140 mm X 3 mm) plates were prepared for
underwater explosive welding. The amorphous nature of the Zr-based 3.1. Underwater explosive weldability window theory
BMG was confirmed by X-ray diffraction (XRD) in a Bruker D8 Advance
diffractometer with Cu Ka radiation. As shown in Fig. 1, the XRD pat- During the explosive welding process, explosive detonation drived
tern shows only broad diffraction maxima, and there are no visible the flyer plate to a certain speed, and the accelerated flyer plate at a
peaks of crystalline phase, indicating an amorphous structure. As illu- velocity VP collided with the base plate at a collision angle [25]. The
strated in Fig. 2, the flyer plate and base plate were set above a stainless collision velocity VP and the collision angle are proportional based on
steel anvil with a fixed stand-off distance at 5 mm using spacers placed the following formula.
at the edges. The air gap between the bonded plates was sealed against
116
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
Table 2
Three different underwater explosive welding experimental conditions.
Test no. Flyer plate thickness (mm) Base plate thickness (mm) Stand-off distance (mm) Water depth (mm) Explosive thickness (mm)
a 3 5 5 30 20
b 3 5 5 30 30
c 3 5 5 30 40
Table 3
Three different thickness explosive weldability window calculation results.
Test no. Flyer plate velocity, Vp (m/s) Collision angle, (°) Collision point velocity, Vc (m/s) Kinetic energy loss, KE (MJ/m2)
Fig. 3. Before and after welding characteristics of Zr-based BMG plate and Zr-
based BMG/Al compsites (a) Photograph of the Zr-based BMG plate before
Fig. 4. SEM images of welded interface under different explosive thickness
welding (b) The specimen of the Zr-based BMG/Al compsite plate cut parallel to
conditions (a) 20 mm explosive thickness condition, (b) 30 mm explosive
detonation direction (c) Optical micrograph of the welded interface.
thickness condition, (c) 40 mm explosive thickness condition.
117
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
Fig. 5. (a) Weldability window of Zr-based BMG/Al showing lower limit and kinetic energy loss, (b) Magnified view of weldability window for Zr-based BMG/Al
joints using three different explosive thickness.
VP = 2VC sin
2 (1)
Where VC is collision point velocity toward horizontal direction.
The collision angle was calculated based on the following equa-
tion [26].
k+1 r
= 1 • •
k 1 2 r + 2.71 + 0.184te /s (2)
Where r is the loading ratio (mass of the explosive for unit mass of flyer
plate), te is the thickness of the explosive layer and s is the stand-off
distance between flyer plate and base plate. The parameter ‘k ’ in Eq.(2)
ranges from 1.96 to 2.6 depending on the thickness of the explosive
[26].
The energy that the bonding interface achieved is a very significant
factor contributing to the welded quality of explosive welding. In the
process of collision, the kinetic energy of the flyer plate is converted into
other forms of energy, which produce high pressure at the bonding in-
terface. The metals flows in the impact region because of the very high
Fig. 6. High-resolution SEM image of the Zr-based BMG/Al welded interface.
pressure, and promote solid-state welding [25]. To calculated the kinetic
energy lost by collision, the following equation was adopted [27].
118
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
Fig. 7. Line scan analysis across the bonding interface from Al to Zr-based BMG plate.
mD mC Vp2 energy is lower than the regular cases. The upper limit may not be
KE = considered during the design process of welding parameters [28]. The
2(mD + mC ) (3)
lower limit should be considered carefully, which was calculated using
Where mD is the mass of the flyer plate per unit area (kg/m2), mC is the the following empirical equation.
mass of the collided plate per unit area (kg/m2).
Hv
In the conventional explosive welding theory, the upper limit and sin = k1
the lower limit all should be considered to achieve the successful 2 Vc2 (4)
welding. However, in the case of underwater explosive welding tech-
Where, Hv is the Vickers hardness, is the density. The value of k1 is 0.6.
nique, because the thickness of the plates are very thin, so the kinetic
The related material parameters used for calculating weldability
119
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
obvious defects like cracks or pores are found. As shown in Fig. 4c,
when the explosive thickness inceeased to 40 mm, cracks are found in
the side of Zr-based BMG plate due to the tensile residual stress caused
during the cooling process. Hokamoto has also reported that cracks
were found in such molten zone at the side of amorphous after welding
[28].
Fig. 5 shows the weldability window with the lower limit drawn for
the present experiments and the kinetic energy loss KE . The three
points a, b and c respresent three experimental conditions of explosive
thickness 20, 30 and 40 mm respectively. The collision point velocity Vc
and the collision angle were calculated and the values were found to
be 2300 m/s, 2350 m/s, 2400 m/s and 22.6°, 23.0°, 23.3°. All three
points are above the lower limit, which indicated that underwater ex-
plosive welding technique is successful in welding Al/Zr-based BMG
Fig. 10. HRTEM image of Zr-based BMG/Al welded interface and corre- plate. The kinetic energy loss under three different explosive thickness
sponding SAED patterns (a) HRTEM image of Zr-based BMG/Al welded inter- were 2.55 MJ/m2, 2.76 MJ/m2 and 2.96 MJ/m2 respectively. With the
face, (b) the SAED patterns of the upper part of interlayer, (c) The SAED pat- increased of the kinetic energy loss, the welded interface shows dif-
terns of interlayer, (d) The SAED patterns of the lower part of interlayer. ferent characteristics. For more detailed discussions, further experi-
ments should be made in future.
window are showed in Table 1. The experimental conditions, collision
point velocity Vc , collision angle , the velocity of flyer plate Vp and the 3.2. Microstructure, elemental analysis and TEM tests of welded interface
kinetic energy loss KE are given in Table 2 and Table 3.
Using the underwater explosive welding technique, the Zr-based In order to obtained high magnification figures, SEM was used to
BMG and Al plates are successfully welded together. Fig. 3a shows the characterize the welded interface. According to Fig.6, an visible tran-
Zr-based BMG plate before welding. After welding, the specimen was sition layer with a thickness of approximate 7 μm has been formed,
cut parallel to detonation direction as shown in Fig. 3b, and no visible indicating the formation of a metallurgical bonding interface. For fur-
cracks appeared at the Zr-based BMG side. In Fig. 3c, the optical me- ther study of the transition layer, Line scan analysis across the welded
tallographic micrograph of the welded interface presents an almost flat interface from Al to Zr-based BMG side was conducted as shown in
structure, and no obvious defects or pores are found at or near the Fig. 7. The result indicates that the width of the transition layer is ap-
joining interface. proximate 7 μm, which is consistent with the size in SEM micrograph.
Interfaces of Zr-based BMG/Al plates welded under different ex- The change of elements composition is expressed linearly with different
plosive thickness of 20, 30, and 40 mm are shown in Fig. 4. As shown in color in Fig. 7. In regions far away from the bonding interface, the
Fig.4a, an almost flat interface has been formed when the explosive elements composition of Al and Zr-based BMG remain almost un-
thickness is 20 mm, and no apparent transition layer are formed. Fig. 4b changed. However, as the distance from the bonding interface de-
shows the welded interface under the explosive thickness of 30 mm. An creases, the concentration of elements gradually changed from one side
apparent transition layer was formed at the welded interface, and no to the other, which indicates that the phenomenon of elemental
120
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
interface, which is mainly due to the work hardening occurred near the
joining interface from the detonation shockwaves [30]. Otherwise, Liu
et al [17] has also studied the mechanical property of Al/
Ti60Zr25Cu12Ni3Be20 welded samples using nanomechanical tester, and
find that the hardness of Al and BMG increases near the joining inter-
face after explosive welding. The experimental results are basically si-
milar to that, and the subsequent research on the evolution mechanism
will be further revealed.
4. Conclusions
121
L. Hanliang, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 45 (2019) 115–122
using the friction welding method. J Alloys Compd 2007;434–435:102–5. [22] Feng J, Chen P, Zhou Q. Investigation on explosive welding of Zr53Cu35Al12 bulk
[13] Shao L, Datye A, Huang J, Ketkaew J, Woo Sohn S, Zhao S, et al. Pulsed laser beam metallic glass with crystalline copper. J Mater Eng Perform 2018;27:2932–7.
welding of Pd43Cu27Ni10P20 bulk metallic glass. Sci Rep-UK. 2017;7:7989. [23] Sun W, Li X, Yan H, Hokamoto K. Effect of initial hardness on interfacial features in
[14] Chen B, Shi TL, Li M, Yang F, Yan F, Liao GL. Laser welding of annealed underwater explosive welding of tool steel SKS3. J Mater Eng Perform
Zr55Cu30Ni5Al10 bulk metallic glass. Intermetallics 2014;46:111–7. 2014;23:421–8.
[15] Wang G, Huang YJ, Shagiev M, Shen J. Laser welding of Ti40Zr25Ni3Cu12Be20 [24] Zhu Y, Liao G, Shi T, Tang Z, Li M. Interdiffusion cross crystal-amorphous interface:
bulk metallic glass. Mater Sci Eng A. 2012;541:33–7. an atomistic simulation. Acta Mater 2016;112:378–89.
[16] Wang DZ, Li N, Liu L. Magnetic pulse welding of a Zr-based bulk metallic glass with [25] Manikandan P, Hokamoto K, Deribas AA, Raghukandan K, Tomoshige R. Explosive
aluminum plate. Intermetallics 2018;93:180–5. welding of Titanium/Stainless steel by controlling energetic conditions. Mater
[17] Liu KX, Liu WD, Wang JT, Yan HH, Li XJ, Huang YJ, et al. Atomic-scale bonding of Trans. 2006;8:2049–55.
bulk metallic glass to crystalline aluminum. Appl Phys Lett. 200881918. [26] Deribas A. Impact engineering and application. UK: Elsevier Science Ltd; 2001.
[18] Grignon F, Benson D, Vecchio KS, Meyers MA. Explosive welding of aluminum to [27] Hokamoto K, Fujita MKU, TACI Izuma. New explosive welding technique to weld
aluminum: analysis, computations and experiments. Int J Impact Eng aluminum alloy and stainless steel plates using a stainless steel intermediate plate
2004;30:1333–51. United States 1993. p. 2289–97.
[19] Kacar R, Acarer M. An investigation on the explosive cladding of 316L stainless [28] Hokamoto K, Nakata K, Mori A, Tsuda S, Tsumura T, Inoue A. Dissimilar material
steel-din-P355GH steel. J Mater Process Technol 2004;152:91–6. welding of rapidly solidified foil and stainless steel plate using underwater ex-
[20] Mali VI, Bataev AA, Maliutina IN, et al. Microstructure and mechanical properties of plosive welding technique. J Alloys Compd 2009;472:507–11.
Ti/Ta/Cu/Ni alloy laminate composite materials produced by explosive welding. [29] Li XJ, Mo F, Wang XH, Wang B, Liu KX. Numerical study on mechanism of explosive
Int J Adv Manuf Technol. 2017;93:4285–94. welding. Sci Technol Weld Joi. 2012;17:36–41.
[21] Ning J, Zhang LJ, Xie MX, Yang HX, Yin XQ, et al. Microstructure and property [30] Kahraman N, Gulenc B. Microstructural and mechanical properties of Cu-Ti plates
inhomogeneity investigations of bonded Zr/Ti/Steel trimetallic sheet fabricated by explosive welding process. J Mater Process Technol 2005;169:67–71.
explosive welding. J Alloys Compd 2017;698:835–51.
122