Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
data gathered from the answers to the survey questionnaires distributed to the
respondents. The said data were presented in tabular form in accordance with
This study determined the level of usage of the General Santos City
payment, online purchases, and load and internet bills, as shown in Table 1.1,
1.2, and 1.3, respectively. To do this, weighted mean and standard deviation
Table 1.1
Level of Usage in terms of Utility Payment
Indicators Mean SD Description
1. I always use online bill payment to pay
utility bills because it gives me less hassle, 3.90 1.18 High
especially on holidays.
2. It saves time and effort when paying online. 4.50 0.82 Very High
3. When doing any transaction, there are no
longer questions and does not require 4.06 0.82 High
effort.
4. I use online payment due to its real time,
4.10 1.00 High
reliable, and fast transaction.
5. The overall service of online payment is
4.16 1.08 High
what I look forward to.
Overall Mean 4.15 High
n=30
Teachers, the result revealed that they have a very high level of usage in
paying their utility bills online as it saves time and effort with a mean score of
x̃ = 4.50. This means that the Senior High School Teachers agreed that online
payment saves their time and effort when paying their utility bills as it can be
the standard deviation (σ) was found to be at 0.82, which denotes that the
responses of Senior High School Teachers are close to each other and most
Meanwhile, the results also revealed that they have high level of
usage in terms of paying utility bills because it provides less hassle in using,
especially on holidays (x̃ = 3.90); using online payment since there are no
longer questions and does not require effort in doing any transaction (x̃ =
4.06); uses online payment due to its real time, reliable, and fast transaction
(x̃ = 4.10); and, the overall service of online payment is what they look forward
to (x̃ = 3.15). This means that Senior High School Teachers agreed that
Online Payment is hassle free, requires less effort, and it is fast and reliable in
paying utility bills. The Senior High School Teachers have hectic schedules
even on holidays and online payment on the other hand, offers a hassle-free
deviation (σ) was found to be at the range of 0.82 – 1.00 which denotes that
responses of the Senior High School Teachers are close from each other and
most of the time they certainly agree in each indicator; Moreover, the
indicators with a standard deviation at the range of 1.08 – 1.18 denotes that
the responses of Senior High School Teacher are not close from each other
Generally, the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers have
high level of usage on online payment in terms of utility bills as shown by the
overall mean score x̃ = 4.15. The results imply that using online payment in
paying utility bills is preferred by the majority of the General Santos City
Senior High School Teachers because it is fast, reliable, saves time and
assurance, empathy, online security, and service quality are important factors
that can affect the usage of a customer, which is why the researchers
online payment because it can influence customers’ loyalty. Also, the study of
Digital Payment Framework for Philippine HEIs” which showed that online
Table 1.2
Level of Usage in terms of Online Purchases
Indicators Mean SD Description
1. I use online payment methods in paying for
3.60 1.13 High
every online purchase I make.
2. I use contactless payment every online
purchase I make as it is favorable because 3.70 0.98 High
of the advent of technology.
3. Online payment saves time and effort in
4.33 0.80 Very High
paying purchases.
4. I use online payment because it gives
3.66 0.84 High
special discounts, promos, and vouchers.
5. Overall security and privacy policy are what
keeps me to purchase more products 3.40 1.13 Moderate
online.
Overall Mean 3.74 High
n=30
Secondly, in terms of Online purchases, the results revealed that they
have a very high level of usage in terms of paying their online purchases
because it saves time and effort with a mean score of x̃ = 4.33. This means
that the Senior High School Teachers agreed that the usage of online
payment in paying online purchases saves their time and effort because they
can pay automatically online and it also reduces the overall workload that they
need do when paying. Also, for this indicator, the standard deviation (σ) was
found to be at 0.80, which denotes that the responses of senior high school
Teachers are close to each other and most of the time they agree in the
indicator.
Meanwhile, the results revealed that they have high level of usage in
using online bills payment for their every online purchase (x̃ = 3.60); using
the advent of technology (x̃ = 3.70); and, using online payment because they
get special discounts, promos, and vouchers (x̃ = 3.66). This means that
senior high school Teachers mostly use online payment to pay their online
indicators, the standard deviation (σ) was found to be at the range of 0.80 –
0.98 which denotes that responses of the senior high school Teachers are
close from each other and most of the time they certainly agree in each
that the responses of senior high school teacher are not close from each other
security and privacy policy it provides, that have a mean score of x̃ = 3.40.
This means that some Senior High School Teachers moderately use online
payment to pay their online purchases because of the overall security and
privacy policy that they have experienced. However, the Teachers must have
encountered issues regarding their privacy and security. In addition to that, for
this specific indicator, the standard deviation (σ) was found to be at 1.13,
which denotes that the responses of senior high school teacher are not close
Generally, the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers have
high level of usage on online payment in terms of utility bills online purchases
as shown by the overall mean score x̃ = 3.74. The results imply that using
online payment in paying online purchases is convenient but there are issues
experienced by the Senior High School Teachers in their privacy and security.
The result of the study is supported by the work of Shanti R. and Desti
that consumers feel very convenient to shop online since it frees the customer
from personally visiting the store and it reduces the effort of travelling to a
physical store. Decision can be made from home at ease looking at various
choices. In line with that, the study of Warayuanti (2015) entitled “The
current result. Through online shopping channels, it is believed that the buyer
Lastly, in terms of Load and Internet Bills , the results revealed that
they have a very high level of usage of the online payment in terms of paying
their load and internet bills (x̃ = 4.36), using online payment because of its
user-friendly environment and visually pleasing set up (x̃ = 4.43), and uses
online payment because the websites and applications for paying load and
internet bills online is very accessible (x̃ = 4.30). This means that Senior High
addition to that, for the first indicator, the standard deviation (σ) was found at
1.03, which denotes that the responses of the General Santos City Senior
High School Teachers are not close to each other and they do not agree in
the indicator; meanwhile, the standard deviation (σ) of the indicators two &
four was found at the range of 0.89 – 0.95, which denotes that the responses
of the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers are close to each
Moreover, the results also revealed that they have a high level of
usage in terms of paying their load and internet bills because they agreed that
permanently added as a mode of payment in paying load and internet bills (x̃
= 4.00). This means that Senior High School Teachers mostly prefer to pay
load and internet bills online because it is highly cost-saving as it does not
require them physically to go to the payment center. The Senior High School
load and internet bills because of the advent of technology. Furthermore, the
standard deviation (σ) of the indicator five was found at 0.94, which denotes
that responses of the senior high school Teachers are close from each other
and most of the time they certainly agree in the specific indicator; additionally,
the standard deviation (σ) of the indicator three was also found at 1.17 which
denotes that the responses of senior high school teacher for the certain
Generally, the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers have
very high level of usage on online payment in terms of load and internet bills
as shown by the overall mean score x̃ = 4.23. The results imply that the
Senior High School Teachers uses online payment in paying their load and
internet bills because of its user-friendly environment, visually pleasing set up,
highly cost-saving, and quick to access; they also agreed that they see no
internet bills.
stated that it has been noticed that the advantages of online payment
methods in paying load and internet bills are frequently related to the benefits
to the services anywhere, anytime, door-step services, easy tracking, and the
ability to avoid the queues and cash payments. In Romig (2022) it was proven
that compared to the level of usage of online payment in 2020, in the year
2021 76% of adults globally have online payment accounts. In line with that,
the study by Rahayu I. and Setiyadi D. (2022) entitled “The Effect of Trust,
Choose Shopee Pay Digital Wallet Servicesalso” stated that online bills
This study also determined the level of satisfaction of the Senior High
purchases, and load and internet bills as shown in Table 2.1, 2.2, 2.3,
School Teachers, the results revealed that they have a very high level of
of paying online and easy transferring money to pay utility bills, which has a
Table 2.1
Level of Satisfaction in terms of Utility Payment
Indicators Mean SD Description
1. Online bills payment and transferring
4.30 1.08 Very High
money for paying utility bills are easy to do.
2. It is easy to make inquiry about paying
3.90 1.18 High
utility bills online.
3. It is easy to navigate the menu while paying
4.20 1.09 High
utility bills online.
4. Navigating my payment history in paying
4.20 1.09 High
utility bills is accessible.
5. The online websites and applications for
3.70 1.08 High
paying utility bills are safe and reliable.
6. The compensation quality of paying utility
3.90 1.02 High
bills online is accurate and good.
7. I have never experienced online fraud or
software malfunction in making online 3.56 1.40 High
payment for utility bills.
8. Online bills payment has better problem
handling capacity compared to cash-based 3.53 1.10 High
payment in terms of utility bills.
9. As a customer who uses online bills
payment to pay utility bills, when I have a
3.53 0.89 High
problem, I get proper and immediate
responses.
10. Paying utility bills online is compatible with
4.10 1.04 High
my daily schedule.
Overall Mean 3.89 High
n=30
This means that the Senior High School Teachers agreed that they are
highly satisfied of the ease of paying and easy transferring money of online
payment because of its flexibility that enables them to track their payment
easily with their hectic schedules. Also, for this specific indicator, the standard
deviation (σ) was found to be at 1.08, which denotes that the responses of
senior high school are not close from each other or the responses are spread.
City National Senior High School have a high level of satisfaction in terms of
the ease of making inquiry about paying utility bills online (x̃ = 3.90); ease of
navigating the menu during online payment (x̃ = 4.20); accessible navigation
of payment history (x̃ = 4.20); safe and reliable online websites and
applications for paying utility bills (x̃ = 3.70); accurate and good compensation
quality (x̃ = 3.90); never experienced online fraud or software malfunction (x̃ =
terms of utility bills (x̃ = 3.53); gets a proper and immediate response when
having a problem (x̃ = 3.53); and compatible with the daily schedule of the
Senior High School Teacher (x̃ = 4.10). This means that the General Santos
City National Senior High School Teachers find it satisfactory to make easy
inquiries about paying utility bills online. Teachers were also satisfied in terms
online fraud or software malfunction, their nice problem handling capacity and
that the online websites and applications that are used in paying utility bills
online are safe and reliable. Lastly, Teachers are satisfied with how online
bills payment are compatible with their jam-packed schedules on paying utility
bills. In addition to that, the standard deviation (σ) for this specific indicator
was determined to be in the range of 0.89 – 1.18, indicating that senior high
school Teachers' responses were most likely spread out and is far from the
mean.
Generally, the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers have
shown by the overall mean score of x̃ = 3.89. The results imply that the Senior
High School Teachers who use online payment to pay utility bills are satisfied
in terms of their ease of using online bill payment platforms, its safe and
reliable websites and applications, and their accuracy and good compensation
quality. Additionally, they are satisfied with never experiencing online fraud or
based payment, and being able to pay utility bills online on time.
large monetary value. The swift payment process speed in comparison with
payment applications” states that E-wallet preparing is quick to the point that
you can immediately move cash to anybody over the globe. Mobile wallets
have made our carries on with a lot simpler, with its one-tap highlight and fast
handling all at one-go. Versatile wallets are intended to empower a safe and
results revealed that the Teachers of General Santos City National Senior
online payment in paying purchases (x̃ = 4.00); can purchase and pay for the
things they want using online payment (x̃ = 4.06); cost-efficiency and flexibility
Table 2.2
Level of Satisfaction in terms of Online Purchases
Indicators Mean SD Description
1. Online payment is convenient in paying
purchases as it provides wider reach and
4.00 0.78 High
frequency compared to cash-based
payment.
2. I can purchase and pay for the things I want
successfully, anytime and anywhere using 4.06 1.01 High
online bills payment.
3. Paying online purchases virtually is cost-
4.16 0.94 High
efficient and flexible.
4. Online payment for online purchases has
3.86 0.81 High
fulfilled my expectations.
5. I am more comfortable in paying my online
purchases using online bills payment 3.70 1.14 High
compared to cash-based payment.
6. Online bills payment compensation quality
is good and accurate in paying online 3.90 1.12 High
purchases.
7. Online payment for online purchases has
3.63 1.03 High
better problem handling capacity.
8. Problems in online purchases payment are
3.60 1.06 High
solved promptly and satisfactorily.
9. The website, and application for online
3.96 0.92 High
purchases payment is user-friendly.
10. Online bills payment is convenient in paying
4.03 0.96 High
online purchases.
Overall Mean 3.89 High
n=30
compensation quality of online bills payment is good and accurate in
paying online purchases (x̃ = 3.90); online payment for online purchases has
better problem handling capacity (x̃ = 3.63); the promptness and satisfaction
of solving the problems in online payment for online purchases payment (x̃ =
purchases (x̃ = 4.03). This means that the Teachers of General Santos City
payment due to the convenience of the payment process, Teachers were also
satisfied in terms of purchasing and pay for the things they want using online
payment. Senior High School Teachers are satisfied with the cost-efficiency,
Senior High School Teachers were also satisfied of the better problem
payment in paying online purchases. Lastly, Teachers are satisfied with the
(σ) for this certain indicator was determined to be in the range of 0.78 – 1.14,
It indicates that the responses from senior high school Teachers were likely
Generally, the General Santos City Senior High School Teachers have
shown by the overall mean score of x̃ = 3.89. The results indicate that the
Senior High School Teachers are highly satisfied in using online payment in
paying their online purchases. They prefer online payment in paying their
payment satisfactory because they can buy their needs and wants through
According to the study of Alam S. S., Ali M. H., Omar N. A., & Hussain
Growing Markets: An Empirical Study”, the internet offers benefits which help
payment process.
Table 2.3
Level of Satisfaction in terms of Load and Internet bills
Indicators Mean SD Description
1. Paying my load and internet bills online is
4.40 0.81 Very High
such a flawless and easy transaction.
2. The websites and application provide
periodic statements with necessary details 4.36 0.85 Very High
in making load and internet payment.
3. Provides double authentication (Link &
OTP) and real time e-receipt every 4.33 0.84 Very High
transaction.
4. The websites and application provide 4.36 0.80 Very High
immediate transaction feedback in making
load and internet payment.
5. I trust online bills payment in paying my
4.16 1.11 High
load and internet bills.
6. Paying loads and internet bills online is a
sign of modernity which is why this is my 4.20 1.12 High
most favored method of paying bills.
7. The website and application for paying load
and internet bills online is very accessible 4.23 1.00 Very High
and reliable.
8. The general ambience and comfort level of
the online payment in load and internet bills 4.33 0.84 Very High
is satisfactory.
9. As a customer who uses online bills
payment in paying load and internet bills,
4.03 0.80 High
when I have a problem, I get proper and
immediate responses.
10. I am satisfied with the level of data and
information security provided by the online 4.30 0.87 Very High
payment in paying load and internet bills.
Overall Mean 4.27 Very High
n=30
bills as shown in Table 2.3, the results revealed that they have a very high
internet bills as it has a flawless and easy transaction (x̃ = 4.40); the websites
transaction feedback (x̃ = 4.36); the ambience and comfort level of online
payment in load and internet bills is highly satisfactory (x̃ = 4.23); can get a
proper and immediate response towards problems (x̃ = 4.33); and, highly
satisfied with the level of data and information security provided by the online
payment for load and internet bills (x̃ = 4.30). This means that the Teachers of
General Santos City National Senior High School finds it highly satisfactory to
pay load and internet bills using online payment due to its flawless
transactions that automatically reconnect their internet once its paid, double
receipt on every transaction, and the general ambience and comfort level of
online payment in load and internet bills. In addition to that, the standard
deviation (σ) for this certain indicator was determined to be in the range of
0.80 – 0.87, which denotes that the responses of the General Santos City
Senior High School Teachers are close to each other, and they certainly
satisfaction in trusting online payment for their load and internet bills (x̃ =
4.16); paying load and internet bills online is a sign of modernity (x̃ = 4.20);
response towards problems (x̃ = 4.03). This means that Senior High School
advances, and it provides immediate problem feedback from the websites and
application of load and internet payment. Additionally, for the indicator four,
the standard deviation (σ) was found to be at the range of 0.80 which denotes
that responses of the senior high school Teachers are close from each other
and most of the time they certainly agree in each indicator; Moreover, the
indicator six and nine with a standard deviation at 0.11 – 1.12 denotes that the
responses from senior high school Teachers were likely spread out and far
load and internet bills as shown by the overall mean score x̃ = 4.27. The
results imply that the Senior High School Teacher is highly satisfied on using
online payment in paying their Load and Internet bills because of its
The result of the study is supported by the work of Pratap, Saroy, and
Survey Based Empirical Study” stated that when it comes to virtual payment,
it is important to build trust with your customers due to the fact that issues of
privacy are very common in virtual payments. Also, we cannot ignore the role
are good indicators from consumers’ intention to accept E-commerce and will
satisfaction and the level of satisfaction of the Senior High School Teacher on
Online Bills Payment shown in Table 3. To do this, Pearson “Product-
Table 3.
Relationship Between Teachers’ Level of Usage and Satisfaction
on Online Bills Payment
Level of Usage
Variables r 2
r p-value Remarks
Level of
0.845 0.714 0.000 Significant
Satisfaction
Results have shown that the coefficient is given by rxy = 0.845 which
denotes that there is a very strong positive linear correlation between the
level of usage and the level of satisfaction of the Senior High School Teacher
= 0.714 (or 71.4%). This means that roughly 71% of the level of usage of the
General Santos City Senior High School Teachers is satisfied with Online Bills
Payment. The results imply that if their Online Bills Payment usage came out
positively and they are satisfied with its services, the more hooked up they will
be.
Furthermore, it was found out that the p – value = 0.000 which is less
than the level of significance at 0.05. The results signify that there is strong
evidence that would support the claim that the level of usage and level of
& Shanmugam V. (2020), which stated that level of usage and level of
stated that users can attain satisfaction through e-payment services by having
to use the services. Therefore, it is evident that perceived ease of use plays
2018).