Professional Documents
Culture Documents
One of the exciting trends in building design is the growing • In addition to safety, property insurance for mass timber
use of mass timber—i.e., large solid wood panel products buildings requires an understanding of performance
such as cross-laminated timber (CLT) and nail-laminated related to things like moisture, durability and building
timber (NLT)—for floor, wall and roof construction. Mass enclosure detailing. Much of the property insurance
timber products have inherent fire resistance and can be discussion is also site-specific—e.g., Is the area prone
left exposed in many applicaions and building sizes, achieving to flooding, earthquakes or high winds? Mass timber
the triple function of structure, finish and fire resistance. has been tested against potential natural disasters, and
Because of their strength and dimensional stability, these numerous test and research reports are available.
products offer an alternative to steel, concrete and masonry This paper is intended for developers and owners seeking
for many applications, but have a much lighter carbon to purchase insurance for mass timber buildings, for
footprint. It is this combination of exposed structure and design/construction teams looking to make their designs
strength that developers and designers across the country and installation processes more insurable, and for insurance
are leveraging to create innovative designs with a warm yet industry professionals looking to alleviate their concerns
modern aesthetic. about safety and performance.
As mass timber construction has proliferated across the U.S., For developers, owners and design/construction teams, it
a number of project teams have run into the same issue: provides an overview of the insurance industry, including its
insurance companies unfamiliar with these types of buildings history, what affects premiums, how risks are analyzed, and
can be reluctant to provide insurance. how project teams can navigate coverage for mass timber
The challenge has presented itself in two forms: builder’s risk buildings. Insurance in general can seem like a mystery—
insurance (or course of construction) and property insurance what determines premium fluctuations, impacts of a
(after the building is complete and
occupied). Relative risks are assessed
differently for each, and each requires
a unique approach. For example:
Stage
Construction Started / Built
What is Mass Timber? In Design
As used in this paper, the term mass timber refers to a © 2021 Mapbox © OpenStreetMap
category of framing styles typically characterized by the use Figure 1: As of December 2020, there were 1,060 mass timber projects
of large, solid wood panels. These panels are most frequently built, under construction or in design across the U.S.
used in horizontal applications for floors and roofs, but can Source: WoodWorks
also be used vertically for bearing walls and shaft walls. They
are often paired with engineered wood beams and columns
to create an all-timber structural framework. The term heavy
timber is typically associated with large cross sections of
solid sawn members (beams, purlins and columns), often Dowel-Laminated Timber (DLT)
using tongue-and-groove decking for floors and roofs. That DLT panels are made from solid sawn lumber (2-by-4,
style of construction is not the focus of this paper. 2-by-6, etc.) stacked like the boards of NLT but friction-fit with
hardwood dowels. The dowels hold each board side-by-side,
Cross-Laminated Timber (CLT) while the friction fit adds dimensional stability. Rather than
CLT consists of layers of solid sawn lumber or structural the butt-jointed laminations found in NLT, laminations in DLT
composite lumber (typically three, five or seven plies) are typically finger-jointed,
oriented at right angles to one another and glued to form resulting in full utilization
structural panels. Panels are typically between 4 and 12 of the panel’s structural
feet wide, and between properties. DLT panels are
20 and 60 feet long. The commonly used in mass
International Building Code timber structures with
(IBC) requires that CLT used accompanying third-party
in U.S. commercial and evaluation reports that DLT panel
multi-family construction be address code compliance. Image: StructureCraft
Types
I & II Allowances
Noncombustible Structure
for Mass Timber Roof
Type
III Interior Mass Timber Structure
Noncombustible or FRTW Exterior Walls
Credit: Gensler, Oest Associates Credit: RMW Architecture & Interiors, Buehler Engineering
Images: StructureCraft, Robert Benson Photography Images: Bernard André Photography
Figure 2: Construction Types III, IV and V permit the use of exposed mass timber
throughout the structure, while Types I and II allow mass timber for the roof structure.
5
Type
IV-A Entire Mass Timber Structure
Except Shafts; No Exposed Timber
Type
IV-B Entire Mass Timber Structure
Partial Exposed Timber
Brock Commons
Vancouver, BC
Office
180 ft.
Mercantile Assembly
(12 stories)
(12 stories) Residential
• Maximum height: 18 stories; 270 feet • Maximum height: 12 stories; 180 feet
Mercantile
• Maximum area: 972,000 SF total • Maximum area: 648,000 SF total (8 stories)
building; 54,000 SF average per floor building; 54,000 SF average per floor
• Fire-rating requirements: 3-hour • Fire-rating requirements: 2-hour
primary frame; 2-hour floors primary frame; 2-hour floors
Type IV-A Type IV-B
Carbon12
Portland, OR
Project Type
Tall Wood
Low-Rise, Mid-Rise Mass Timber
Type IV-C
Credit: Kaiser+Path
Images: Andrew Pogue, Marcus Kauffman
Figure 4: Construction Types IV-A, IV-B and IV-C allow mass timber buildings up to 18 stories.
The map shows projects built and under construction, by height, across the U.S.
7
10
How Does Mass Timber Compare The insurance industry may generally understand that mass
to Other Building Materials? timber and light wood-frame construction perform diffrently,
Mass timber is a unique building system. It is combustible, but the fact that they are both wood, combined with a lack
like all wood products, but consists of large cross sections of of historic loss data associated with mass timber buildings,
material forming columns and beams, and solid slabs similar contributes to the use of light-frame insurance rates for
to those used in concrete and steel construction. However, all wood buildings. This follows the insurance industry’s
it performs differently than any other system. understandable practice of selecting the highest possible
rate when the risk is undeterminable.
Mass timber elements have inherent fire resistance, and
in most applications and buildings sizes do not need applied Often, when a project proforma is being created, the
fire protection materials such as gypsum wallboard. In a fire, insurance cost estimate is from a broker who is unfamiliar
mass timber members form a char layer on their surface with the nuances of mass timber. The broker will propose
while their interior remains undamaged and structurally aggressive costs based on the corresponding IBC
sound, allowing them to retain their load-carrying capacity. construction classification. It is rare for buyers to consider
The inherent fire-resistance capability of heavy timber has the broker’s level of expertise as an area of potential concern.
long been recognized in the IBC under Type IV construction. Rather, they tend to buy insurance based on the lowest bid or
Comparing the allowable building size limits of a Type IV relationship. This is a pervasive problem within the insurance
building to a Type II-A building in IBC Chapter 5, they are industry. There are many skilled brokers; however, discerning
very similar. the depth and breadth of insurance expertise is something
few buyers take the time to do. It is prudent for a developer
• A Type II-A building must be framed with noncombustible to spend adequate time selecting a broker and evaluating
materials and most structural elements (beams, columns, their mass timber experience, much in the same way they
floors) are required to have a 1-hour fire-resistance rating. select a general contractor.
Type II-A buildings are commonly framed with structural
steel, with spray-applied fireproofing added to the
structural framework to achieve the 1-hour rating.
• In a Type IV building, which includes exposed heavy or
mass timber elements, those elements must meet code-
specified minimum sizes. However, they are not required
to have a specific hourly fire-resistance rating or fire
protection.
11
12
13
14
15
Disclaimer: The information in this publication, including, without limitation, references to information contained in other publications or made
available by other sources (collectively “information”) should not be used or relied upon for any application without competent professional
examination and verification of its accuracy, suitability, code compliance and applicability by a licensed engineer, architect or other professional.
Neither the Wood Products Council nor its employees, consultants, nor any other individuals or entities who contributed to the information
make any warranty, representative or guarantee, expressed or implied, that the information is suitable for any general or particular use, that it
is compliant with applicable law, codes or ordinances, or that it is free from infringement of any patent(s), nor do they assume any legal liability
or responsibility for the use, application of and/or reference to the information. Anyone making use of the information in any manner assumes
all liability arising from such use.
WW-WSP-020 – Insurance for Mass Timber Construction: Assessing Risk and Providing Answers – © 2021 WoodWorks – Wood Products Council