Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00338-003-0295-4
R EP O RT
G. Neves Æ E. Omena
Received: 8 March 2002 / Accepted: 9 February 2003 / Published online: 15 April 2003
Springer-Verlag 2003
Abstract The relationships between the morphology of often food resources as a supply of organic matter to
sponges and variables describing their harbored poly- their associates (Cinar and Ergen 1998; Martin and
chaete fauna were analyzed along Rocas, the only Britayev 1998). Polychaetes may inhabit all sponge
known South Atlantic Atoll, together with the location available space: they may live attached to the sponge
on host and feeding habits. The identification and surface (epifauna) or within their canals and choano-
quantification of all the associated organisms high- some (infauna) (Pérès 1982; Cinar and Ergen 1998).
lighted the dominance of polychaetes. The adults of the The relationships between polychaetes and sponges
symbiotic species Haplosyllis spongicola were the most can be fortuitous (i.e. the involved organisms may
dominant sponge endobionts. However, both juveniles inhabit a variety of substrata and the presence of the
and epitokes (reproductive individuals) of H. spongicola ‘‘host’’ is irrelevant), but they may also involve a high
were also found, suggesting that this species completes degree of specificity, giving rise to either commensal-
its life cycle inside the host. Polychaete density was sig- istic or parasitic relationships (Martin and Britayev
nificantly greater in lobate sponges than in massive and 1998).
encrusting forms. Conversely, the highly specific sym- Sponges having a complex gross morphological
biotic mode of life of H. spongicola species seems to play structure often harbor a more abundant fauna (Frith
a major role in structuring the composition of the 1976; Cuartas and Excoffon 1993; Klitgaard 1998),
polychaete fauna in relation to sponge morphotypes while changes in sponge growth (i.e. linked to envi-
along Rocas Atoll. ronmental factors) seem to play a major role in struc-
turing its composition (Peattie and Hoare 1981; Duarte
Keywords Polychaetes Æ Morphology Æ Sponges Æ and Nalesso 1996). No direct relationship between
Porifera Æ Rocas Atoll Æ Brazil associated fauna and sponge morphology has been
previously reported. However, the differences in abun-
dance and number of species appear to be a function of
biotic interactions (viz. predation, competition, allelo-
Introduction chemical attractants, and defenses) among the fauna
within each sponge species (Koukouras et al. 1992)
Polychaetes commonly establish close associations with [allelochemical = biologically active metabolite (Mur-
sponges, because the presence of holes, grooves, icy et al. 1993)].
chambers, and channels provides a good shelter and Both amphipods and ophiuroids have been previ-
ously reported as dominant sponge-associated groups
along the Brazilian coast (Duarte and Nalesso 1996;
G. Neves (&) Æ E. Omena Ribeiro, unpublished data). A recent study on the tax-
Departamento de Invertebrados, Museu Nacional, onomy of Rocas Atoll sponge mentioned the existence
Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, of close associations between many sponge species and
Quinta da Boa Vista s/n, 22240-040 São Cristóvão, polychaetes (Moraes, personal communication). The
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
E-mail: nevesgabriela@aol.com aim of the present investigation is thus to compare the
species composition, species richness, diversity, and
Present address: G. Neves density of the polychaete fauna associated with sponges
Instituto de Biologia, Laboratório de Polychaeta do
Departamento de Zoologia, Centro de Ciências e Saúde (CCS), with different morphological features along Rocas Atoll.
Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Bloco A, Additionally, their location and feeding habits were
21940-590 Ilha do Fundão, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil analyzed.
124
idites (de Laubenfels, 1954) were classified as massive Lobate sponges showed a significantly greater density
(Fig. 2c). Associated invertebrates included seven major of polychaetes than massive and encrusting ones and
taxonomic groups (class and above) comprising 7,344 they also harbored the richest polychaete fauna. Massive
individuals, recorded on and inside a total of 1,465 cm3 sponges tended to have higher diversity than encrusting
of sponge. Polychaetes represented 96% of total indi- and lobate forms and encrusting sponges tended to have
viduals of the total associated fauna, showing a clear higher evenness than the other forms (Fig. 3). Poly-
dominance over crustaceans, ophiuroids, foraminifer- chaete density varied significantly between sponge
ans, vermetid gastropods, sipunculans, and sponges. morphotypes (Kruskal-Wallis, H=13.51, p <0.05).
Crustaceans were common by number of individuals on Juveniles, males, and female epitokes [adult repro-
the encrusting sponge Plakortis sp. 1, and the massive ductive worms showing traces of stolon formation
sponges A. dispar and Plakortis sp. 1 sheltered a great (schizogamy)], and adults (nonreproductive) of H.
number of ophiuroids and sipunculans, respectively. The spongicola were found inside the sponges. In some cases,
highest density of total associated fauna was recorded this species also exhibited the same coloration as its
on the lobate sponge Aplysina sp. (60.3 ind/cm3) sponge hosts, being purple when associated with A.
whereas the massive form A. dispar sheltered the greatest crassa; red in Aplysina sp., A. viridis, and A. compressa,
variety of groups (Table 1). and white in T. ophiraphidites. Many individuals of this
Sixteen polychaete taxa belonging to seven families species were found with projected pharynges on the
were determined. Syllids were dominant in terms of both sponge hosts.
number of taxa and abundance. Haplosyllis spongicola Three major groups were identified in the cluster
(Grube, 1855) showed the highest infestation rate, found analysis, suggesting a gradient of H. spongicola domi-
in 65% of sponges and representing 98% of the total nance within the sponge morphotypes. Group I was
associated polychaete fauna. This species reached 1,909 mainly composed of lobate sponges, showing the highest
individuals per sponge host A. crassa. All the other dominance values for this symbiont species (100% to
polychaete species occurred in a very low density (i.e. 94%). Massive and encrusting forms were more repre-
3 ind/cm3) when compared to H. spongicola (137 ind/ sentative in groups II and III, accounting for minimum
cm3) in all sponges analyzed (Table 2). H. spongicola and also null values of dominance of H. spongicola (33%
individuals were far more abundant in lobate than in to 0%), respectively (Fig. 4).
massive and encrusting forms. All the eunicids (Eunice The polychaete fauna associated to sponges were
sp. a, Eunice sp. b), the nereidid Nereis trifasciata grouped into five trophic guilds (Table 3). The carni-
(Grube, 1878), the syllid Syllis sp. c, and the cirratulids vores (i.e. syllids, eunicids, and nereidids) were dominant
were only found in lobate sponges, whereas the spionid (91%). Syllids, especially H. spongicola, were found in
Aonides sp. and the sabellid Myxicola sp. infested mas- all sponge available space whereas nereidids were only
sive forms only. The highest densities found for the taxa found on the surface. The eunicids occurred inside the
Sabellidae and Syllis sp. b among the different sponge sponges, with their prostomium protruding from the
types were found in encrusting forms. The presence of sponge choanosome. The filter-feeders and surface
some other taxa, like the syllid Branchiosyllis oculata deposit-feeders (i.e. sabellids, serpulids, spionids, and
(Ehlers, 1887) and the serpulid Filograna sp., was not cirratulids) occupied the same position as eunicids. In
related to any specific sponge growth form (Table 2). general, cirratulids and spionids were found in associa-
Table 1 List of sponges including (n) number of samples, shape and total density (ind/cm3) of the total associated fauna present in
sponges from Rocas Atoll (Cru Crustacea; Oph Ophiuroidea; For Foraminifera; VG Vermetid gastropoda; Sip Sipuncula; Spo Sponge;
Poly Polychaeta)
(ind/cm3)
tion with sponge species that produced great quantities environments (Glasby 2000). High densities of poly-
of mucus, such as A. viridis and A. dispar. chaetes in carbonate sediments from Rocas Atoll have
also been recently reported (Netto 1999). However, this
dominance mainly resulted from the occurrence of one
Discussion species, Haplosyllis spongicola, which is a common and
widespread sponge symbiont. This species presents an
The dominance of polychaetes in sponge assemblages aggregate pattern of distribution (Martin and Britayev
throughout Rocas Atoll was an expected scenario. Many 1998), reaching 1,909 individuals per sponge host
previous studies reported on the great abundance of this (present study data), and several evidences pointed to a
group within sponges (Frith 1976; Koukouras et al. probable parasitic relationship with its host sponges.
1985; Cuartas and Excoffon 1993; Duarte and Nalesso Among them, its location inside the canals of the sponge
1996; Klitgaard 1998). Polychaetes are often very aquiferous system and in the sponge tissues, and its
abundant in coral reefs, as in many types of marine and feeding activity, in which it projects its pharynges to take
estuarine habitats, largely due to their ability to adapt sponge tissue, which it probably ingests. The fact that
morphologically and reproductively to exploit these the worms exhibited the same coloration as their sponge
127
Fig. 4 Cluster analysis evidencing three main groups of polychaete The structure of the population of H. spongicola
fauna present in (E) encrusting, (M) massive, and (L) lobate found in sponges from Rocas Atoll was composed of
sponges
individuals of all life stages, including sexually mature
adults (epitokes) and many juveniles. This observation
suggests that the life cycle of H. spongicola occurs inside
hosts can also be an evidence of this feeding activity. the host. In spite of this, we could not discard the exis-
These behavioral adaptations to the parasitic way of life tence of a phase outside (e.g. swimming stolons pro-
of H. spongicola have been previously reported (Cuartas ducing planktonic larvae), which may occur in a
and Excoffon 1993; Klitgaard 1998; Martin and Britayev synchronized releasing of both male and female stolons,
1998; López et al. 2001). leading to gamete fertilization in the water column. Its
Table 3 Trophic guilds and location of polychaete taxa on sponges. Sur Surface; Cha channels. [After Fauchald and Jumars (1979)]
strategy could be connected to a highly specific symbi- densities of H. spongicola individuals without apparently
otic mode of life. In the light of these data, there is causing a decrease in its growth rate or in its sexual and
something enabling H. spongicola to become competi- asexual reproductive activities. This same author also
tively superior to other endobiotic species. López et al. reported high infestation rates of H. spongicola in
(2001) mentioned the long-lasting taxonomic contro- tropical aplysinid sponges (Aplysina corrugata, Aplysina
versy of this species and supported the existence of a fistularis, and Aplysina sp.) and in the sponge Ircinia
sibling or pseudo-sibling species complex being hidden felix which are both considered here as lobate sponges.
under the name of H. spongicola. This statement could Although we could not record the growth rate of the
suggest the possible relationship between the presence of sponges in the present work, we could not discard the
the species inside many different hosts and the existence possibility that these lobate sponges are able to grow
of different H. spongicola morphotypes. faster than massive and encrusting, allowing them to
The population of H. spongicola seemed to play a better support higher densities of H. spongicola which is
major role in structuring the composition and abun- probably feeding on its host. The relationship between
dance of the polychaete fauna. Lower densities of this the other polychaete species that apparently occurs in a
parasitic species in massive and encrusting sponges can single sponge morphotype may be accidental as we could
give place to a well-distributed polychaete assemblage, not determine how frequent these associations between
resulting in higher diversity and evenness indices. the given species and the sponge form are.
However, the differences in the sponges’ growth form Feeding guilds and location of polychaetes within
can also affect the structure of the polychaete commu- sponges are other factors that can further define the
nity. The presence of H. spongicola apparently did not nature of the interrelationships between the organisms
affect the sponges’ growth rate nor did the sponges show (Martin and Britayev 1998). In this study, the presence
abnormal morphologic structures in reaction to the of the carnivorous species H. spongicola in all sponges’
massive presence of these worms. This same observation space can also point to its parasitic way of life. The
was also viewed by López et al. (2001) in the coral reef location and specific behavior of the taxa allowed us to
sponge Cliona sp. This sponge supported extremely high suggest that the sponges probably provide habitat and
Table 4 Review of seven works about fauna assemblages from sponges, indicating the sponge species, sponge morphotypes data from
references (Morphotype1), sponge morphotypes considered in this study (Morphotype2), and density recorded from references
enhance food supply. The position of filter feeders in the Cuartas EI, Excoffon AC (1993) La fauna acompanãnte de
canals close to the sponge openings probably aids them Hymeniacidon sanguinea (Grant, 1827) (Porifera; Demospon-
giae). Neotrópica 39(101–102):3–10
in obtaining food from the waterflow created by the Duarte LFL, Nalesso RC (1996) The sponge Zygomycale parishii
sponge (Ilan et al. 1994). Surface deposit-feeders might (Bowerbank) and its endobiotic fauna. Estuarine Coastal Shelf
obtain food from the organic detritus accumulated on Sci 42:139–151
sponge canals and/or microorganisms that also live Fauchald K, Jumars P (1979) The diet of worms: a study of
polychaete feeding guilds. Oceanogr Mar Biol Annu Rev 17:
within the host. Klitgaard (1998) also pointed out the 1–109
importance of sponge complexity enhancing food supply Frith DW (1976) Animals associated with sponges at North Hay-
for the associates. ling, Hampshire. Zool J Linn Soc 58:353–362
A clear relationship between faunal densities and Gherardi DFM (1996) Recent carbonate sedimentation on the
sponge morphology was recorded. Lobate morphotypes, coralline–algal Atol das Rocas, equatorial south Brazil. PhD
Thesis, Royal Holloway University of London
which have a more complex structure, showed signifi- Glasby CJ (2000) Class Polychaeta. In: Beesley PL, Ross GJB,
cantly higher faunal densities. By comparing seven studies Glasby CJ (eds) Polychaetes and allies: the southern synthesis.
about fauna assemblage from sponges (Table 4), we could fauna of Australia. Vol 4. A Polychaeta, Myzostomida, Pog-
also demonstrate a direct relationship between sponge onophora, Echiura, Sipuncula. Commonwealth Scientific and
Industrial Research Organization, Melbourne, pp 1–8
morphology and faunal densities. Fistulose, lamellar Ilan M, Ben-Eliahu MN, Galil BS (1994) Three deep water sponges
ramifying, lobate, or sphere-shaped morphotypes, which from the eastern Mediterranean and their associated fauna.
can be considered as complex-growth sponge forms (here Ophelia 39(1):45–54
as lobate), sheltered a denser fauna than flatter, un- Klitgaard AB (1998) The fauna associated with outer shelf and
upper slope sponges (Porifera; Demospongiae) at Faroe
branched, encrusting, and massive forms. The accumu- Islands, northeastern Atlantic. Sarsia 80:1–22
lation of organic detritus and sediment on the sponges Koukouras A, Voutsiadou-Koukoura E, Chintiroglou H, Dounas
seems to explain the abundance of associates on sponges C (1985) Benthic bionomy of the north Aegen Sea. III. A
with a complex gross morphological structure (Frith comparison of the macrobenthic animal assemblages associated
1976). Although some authors have found that complex with seven sponge species. Cah Biol Mar 26(3):301–319
Koukouras A, Russo A, Voutsiadou-Koukoura E, Dounas C,
sponges supported the most individuals (per unit vol- Chintiroglou C (1992) Relationship of sponge macrofauna with
ume), it has been difficult to establish a clear relationship the sponge morphology of their hosts in the north Aegean Sea.
between density and complexity (Koukouras et al. 1992). Int Rev Hydrobiol 77:609–619
These present results show that although a more López E, Britayev TA, Martin D, San Martin G (2001)
New symbiotic associations involving Syllidae (Annelida:
abundant polychaete fauna were present in complex Polychaeta), with taxonomic and biological remarks on
gross morphological sponges, the highly specific symbi- Pionosyllis magnifica and Syllis cf. armilaris. J Mar Biol Assoc
otic mode of life of H. spongicola species seems to play a UK 81:399–409
major role in structuring the composition of the poly- Martin D, Britayev TA (1998) Symbiotic polychaetes: review of
known species. Oceanogr Mar Biol Annu Rev 36:217–340
chaete fauna in relation to sponge morphotypes along Moraes FC (2000) Taxonomia e Repartição de Porifera na Reserva
Rocas Atoll. Biológica do Atol das Rocas (RN). Monograph. Universidade
Federal do Rio de Janeiro
Acknowledgements We thank Zélia Brito from the Brazilian Muricy G, Hajdu E, Araujo FV, Hagler NA (1993) Antimicrobial
Environmental Agency IBAMA for making this work possible; activity of southwestern Atlantic shallow-water marine sponges
Eduardo Vilanova, Fernando Moraes, and Jarian for assisting with (Porifera). Sci Mar 57(4):427–432
sampling; Dr. Guilherme Muricy for technical support and iden- Netto SA, Warwick RM, Attrill MJ (1999) Meiobenthic and
tification of the sponges; Dr. Paulo Cesar de Paiva and the anon- macrobenthic community structure in carbonate sediments of
ymous reviewers for a careful read of this manuscript and helpful Rocas Atoll (north-east Brazil). Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci
suggestions. 48:39–50
Peattie ME, Hoare R (1981) The sublittoral ecology of the Menai
Strait. II. The sponge Halichondria panicea (Pallas) and its
References associated fauna. Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci 13:621–635
Pérès JM (1982) General features of organismic assemblages in
pelagial and benthal. In: Kinne O (ed) Marine ecology. IV.
Boury-Esnault N, Ruetzler K (eds) (1997) Thesaurus of sponge
morphology. Smithsonian contributions to zoology 596. Ocean management. Part I. Wiley, New York, pp 47–66
Westinga E, Hoetjes PC (1981) The intrasponge fauna of Sphe-
Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, DC, pp 1–55
Cinar ME, Ergen Z (1998) Polychaetes associated with the sponge ciospongia vesparia (Porifera, Demospongiae) at Curaçao and
Bonaire. Mar Biol 26:139–151
Sarcotragus muscarum Schmidt,1864 from the Turkish Aegen
coast. Ophelia 48(3):167–183