You are on page 1of 12

Lead Review ANicle January 2000: 1—10

Tea and Health


Siro I. Trevisanato, Ph.D., and Young-In Kim, M.D., FRCP(C)

Tea is a pleasant, popular, socially accepted, eco- tons subdivided into 2.0 million metric tons of black tea
nomical, and safe drink that is enjoyed every day
(76%), 581,011 metric tons of green tea (22%), and 54,100
by hundreds of millions of people across all conti-
metric tons of oolong tea (2%).' The three largest produc-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


nents. Sea also provides a dietary source of bio-
ers were India(704,000 metric tons), China(560,000 metric
logically active compounds that help prevent a wide
variety of diseases. It is the richest source of a tons), and Kenya (188,000 metric tons).'
class of antioxidants called tlavonoids and contains The C. sinensis bush is native to southeastern Asia
many other beneficial compounds such as vita- and has probably been used since humans discovered
mins and fluoride. A growing body of evidence how to boil water. The first historical records honor the
suggests that moderate consumption of tea may Chinese emperor Shen Nung (2737 B.C.) for introducing
protect against several forms of cancer, cardio- tea (tea is pronounced tcha in Chinese) at his court. Since
vascular diseases, the formation of kidney stones, then, its consumption extended to the nonaristocratic
bacteria/ infections, and denta/ cavities. Future classes in the country, to populations in neighboring coun-
research needs to define the actual magnitude of tries (e.g., Japan in the 9th century A.D.), and finally over-
health benefits, establish the safe range of tea seas, thanks to Dutch traders, who introduced tea to west-
consumption associated with these benefits, and ern countries in approximately 1610.
elucidate potential mechanisms of action. Today, tea is enjoyed around the world and its con-
sumption reflects local preferences and traditions. Thus,
oolong tea is most widely used in China and Taiwan, and
Introduction green tea is the preferred tea in many Asian and Northern
African countries, whereas black tea is the choice among
The popularity of tea has stood the test of time. The drink western consumers. The most hard-core aficionados are
is made from brewing leaves of the bush Camellia sinensis found in Northern Ireland (3.16 kg/person tea per year),
in hot water. Human ingenuity found that such leaves the United Kingdom (2.53 kg/person tea per year), and
could be processed in different ways to provide three dif- Kuwait (2.52 kg/person tea per year).'
ferent kinds of brews. Green tea is derived from drying Several factors are responsible for the popularity of
and steaming the fresh tea leaves directly after plucking. tea. Tea drinking is a pleasurable experience that is en-
As such, no oxidation occurs. Oxidation, also referred to
joyed either alone or shared at social gatherings. In cer-
as fermentation, occurs naturally when tea polyphenols
tain countries such as Japan, tea drinking is considered
are complexed by contact with oxygen. Oolong tea is de-
highly important, and elaborate rituals must be observed
rived when the fresh leaves are subjected to a partial oxi-
in order to serve it appropriately. In India, tea is brewed
dation stage before drying (i.e., semidried tea leaves) and
with a mix of spices (masala) for additional flavor. Tea is
steaming. Black tea undergoes a full oxidation stage be-
also considered to be safe. It is brewed by adding tea
fore drying (i.e., fully dried tea leaves) and steaming. Total
leaves to boiled water and thus provides a safe drink to
worldwide tea production in 1996 was 2.61 million metric
millions of people for whom clean water is still a luxury.
Tea does not cause intoxication. It is an inexpensive drink
and is thus affordable to all social classes in all countries.
Dr. Trevisanato is with the Banting and Best Institute Herbal teas are not true tea because they are not de-
of Medical Research, University of Toronto, Toronto, rived from the leaves of C. sinensis but rather from other
ON MSS 1A8, Canada. Dr. Kim is with the Division of sources (e.g., blossoms of linden, leaves of peppermint,
Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, University fruits of hibiscus). The original Chinese ideogram indi-
of Toronto and St. Michael’s Hospital, and Department cates that only the drink obtained from C. sinensis is to be
of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Room
considered tea. The confusion between tea and herbal tea
7258, Medical Sciences Building, One King’s College
Circle, Toronto, ON MSS 1A8, Canada. is mostly restricted to the Germanic-derived languages
Address correspondence to Dr. Kim. (e.g., English). In other linguistic groups, for instance,
within Neo-Latin languages (e.g., French), there is a clear

Nutrition Reviews•, Vol. 58, No. 1


1
contrast between tea and “herbal teas.” The former is health of consumers. Several recent review articles pro-
known as tea (the), whereas the latter is known as an infu- posed mechanisms by which tea drinking confers protec-
sion (tisane). Moreover, the specific infusion is either in- tion against cardiovascular disease and cancer.2'3 Tea
dicated as an infusion of a specific plant or becomes leaves are very rich in a wide variety of compounds, which
syn- onymous with the plant itself. An example of the first are listed in Table 1. These compounds retain their bio-
case is the brew obtained from linden flowers, which is logical activity upon immersion in hot water and are readily
known as “tisane de tilleul” in French. An example of the solubilized therein.’
second case is the brew obtained from chamomile flowers, Among these compounds, flavonoids, which are a
which in French is known as “camomille.” class of antioxidants, constitute the relative majority (36%)
of components of the leaves of C. sinensis. 5 Tea—whether
Tea and Health black, green, or oolong—is the richest source of flavonoids
In addition to the enjoyable, safe, and economical aspects in the Northern European diet, more so than regular serv-
of tea, this drink also provides a natural source of com- ings of fruits or vegetables.‘ Tea contributes approximately

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


pounds that protect against a wide array of diseases. 63% of dietary flavonoids in the diet, whereas other di-
In fact, tea’s medicinal properties have long been etary components such as dairy products, onions (sec-
known. For centuries, people drank tea when recovering ond best at 13%), fruits (mostly grapes and apples), and
from flu and flu-like illnesses. However, it is only since wine account for the remainder." 6 Because the Northern
the First International Symposium on Tea and Human European diet closely resembles the Northern American
Health, which was held in New York in 1991, that scientific diet, these data most likely reflect the contribution of tea
research has seriously looked into the correlation to the average North American intake of flavonoids as
between tea and the prevention of certain diseases.’2 well. The exceptional contribution of tea may be due to
The latest scientific insight into the beneficial aspects the fact that 69-85% of the flavonoid content becomes
provided to tea drinkers dispelled the myth that only green soluble within the first 3-5 minutes of brewing tea in hot
tea provides health benefits. All three teas provide bio- water.’ Up to an additional 19% of the flavonoids can be
logically active ingredients (e.g., flavonoids, vitamins, fluo- extracted if the same tea bag is brewed a second time.‘
ride). Flavonoids are antioxidants, a broad class of mol- Moreover, there is some evidence that flavonoids derived
ecules in our body that neutralize free radicals. Free radi- from tea are more active than the homologous compounds
cals are potent oxidizing compounds that damage the cells. from vegetables such as onions, spinach, and lettuce.’
Cell damage by oxidation is implicated in the development Flavonoids first enter the digestive tract, then the
of cardiovascular diseases and cancer. Vitamins also pos- cardiovascular system, and finally diffuse into several tis-
sess antioxidant properties and other anticarcinogenic sues.’ The mechanism of action of flavonoids on the di-
properties. Minerals such as fluoride help fight dental cavi- gestive system is poorly understood and may be related
ties and osteoporosis. to the absorption of flavonoids into the mucosal lining of
The beneficial effects of tea on human health can be the gastrointestinal tract. One such mode of action could
grouped into major and minor. In the subsequent sections, account for the proven activity of flavonoids in blocking
the major effects, namely those affecting cardiovascular heterocyclic aromatic amines from promoting gastric and
disease and cancer, are extensively discussed. The minor colorectal carcinogenesis.' These amines are formed upon
effects, namely those affecting dental cavities, kidney cooking meat and meat products and are considered to
stones, diarrhea, and immune fiinction, are briefly dis- play a role in the development of gastric and colorectal
cussed. cancers. Other intracellular mechanisms are also possible.
For instance, flavonoids were shown to protect mitochon-
Mechanisms of Action dria, control the expression of oncogenes, and prevent
the loss of 5-methylcytosine (i.e., DNA demethylation or
Research has barely scratched the surface of the potential hypomethylation).’ The last mechanism is important in
mechanisms whereby tea confers beneficial effects to the protecting DNA from high rates of mutation.’

Table 1. Composition of the Dry Weight (Expressed in %) of Tea Leaves

Polyphenols (antioxidants)
Nondigestible carbohydrates Methylxanthines (caffeines) 3.5
Proteins Lipids 2.0
15 Organic acids 1.5
Lignin 6.5 Chlorophyll 0.5
Minerals 5 Carotenoids < 0.1
Amino acids 4 Volatiles < 0.1
Note: adapted from Reference 5.

2 Nutrition Reviews•, Vol. 58, No. 1


The effect of antioxidants on the cardiovascular sys- tea drinkers than non—tea drinkers.°"' More specifically,
tem appears to be linked to several modes of action de- the incidence of ischemic heart disease (including myo-
scribed below, or any combination thereof. Overall, there cardial infarct and stroke) is lower in tea drinkers com-
is consensus that atherosclerosis and the complications pared with non—tea drinkers."" The Zutphen study, con-
it causes are due to constriction of the diameter of arteries ducted in the Netherlands, assessed 805 male patients
and/or arterioles. The constriction can be achieved by during a period of 5 years.‘ After correcting for confound-
several mechanisms. Cells of the smooth muscle layer in ing factors, which in this case were age; body weight;
the blood vessel may proliferate in response to growth cholesterol level; blood pressure; degree of regular physi-
factors released when damaged blood vessels are being cal exercise; coffee consumption; calorie intake; and in-
repaired. Antioxidants block free radicals, thus prevent- take of §-carotene, vitamins C and E, and fiber, incidence
ing such damage and avoiding the repair mechanism that of fatal and nonfatal first myocardial infarction and mor-
causes smooth muscle cells to proliferate.'° The second tality from stroke significantly decreased as intake of f1a-
mode of action of atherosclerosis involves low-density vonoids (derived mainly from tea) increased in a dose-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


lipoproteins (LDL) damaged by free radicals and hydrop- dependent manner.‘ (Table 2) A follow-up to this study
eroxides. Macrophages are recruited in the damaged ar- that looked at the risk of stroke in these patients during 15
eas and engulf the damaged LDL, generating so-called years showed that a high intake of flavonoids (derived
fatty streaks in the blood vessel. Antioxidants have been mainly from tea) significantly lowered the incidence of
observed to prevent LDL damage derived from hydroper- stroke compared with a low intake.’ The risk for develop-
oxides or other free radicals. Thus, antioxidants prevent ing stroke was 73% lower in the group with the highest
a large number of monocytes from being recruited in the intake of flavonoids (> 28.6 mg flavonoids/day) than in
damaged areas, thereby better regulating the efflux of the group with the lowest intake (< 18.3 mg flavonoids/
macrophages from the artery walls and minimizing the en- day).‘
gulfment of LDL and the formation of fatty streaks in the Another recent case-control study from Boston (the
blood vessel. l' The third mechanism of atherosclerosis Boston Area Health Study) supports the protective effect
involves the cytotoxic activity of oxidized LDL, which of tea on cardiovascu1ardisease.l’ This study investigated
appears to increase platelet adherence and release growth the association of tea with myocardial infarction in 340
factors promoting hyperproliferation of the smooth muscle cases and age-, sex-, and community-matched controls.
layer of the blood vessel. Antioxidants have been shown Extensive information obtained on coronary artery dis-
to inhibit the cytotoxic activity of oxidized LDL.'0 ease risk factors and average dietary intake during the
Besides these mechanisms of action, antioxidants have previous year was accurately assessed by a 116-item
been linked to two additional risk factors implicated in semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire. Individu-
cardiovascular disease. Antioxidants appear to lower cho- als drinking ñ 1 cup of tea per day had a 44% lower risk of
lesterol levels in normal subjects and in patients with hy- myocardial infarction than those drinking no tea; results
percholesterolemia.' l i3 Antioxidants have also been ob- were independent of known coronary artery disease risk
served to lower plasma or serum concentrations of factors."
ho- mocysteine, which has been implicated in the As discussed in the previous section, the protection
develop- ment of cardiovascular diseases and stroke.'4 conferred by flavonoids seems quite complex and may
involve homocysteine, cholesterol, atherogenesis, and the
Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease
protection of LDL."'"" 7 The findings pertaining to the
Overall, cardiovascular health appears to be better among effects of tea on cholesterol and homocysteine levels are

Table 2. Incidence of Myocardial Infarction and Mortality from Coronary Disease Linked to Low, Medium, and
High Flavonoid Consumption
Flavonoid Intake(mg/day)
0—19.0 19.1—29.9 > 29.9
Mortality for stroke
Number of men 269
Deaths 11 10
Mortality rate (1000 persons/year) 18.5 8.7 7.8
Incidence of fatal and nonfatal first myocardial infarction
Number of men 231 231 231
Cases 16 14 8
Mortality rate (1000 persons/year) 16.2 13.8 7.6
Source: reference 6.

Nutr‘ition Reviews•, \/oI. 58, No. 1 3


of particular importance. In a prospective study, a cohort menopausal women between 55 and 69 years of age in
of Norwegians was divided into five groups on the basis Iowa (the Iowa Women’s Study). 23 These women were
of tea consumption." Nondrinkers provided the baseline followed for 8 years. Although the incidence of some can-
levels for subsequent comparisons. The other four groups
cers (melanoma, breast, some respiratory tract, ovarian,
were defined as low consumers of tea (< 1 cup/day), mod-
and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma) seemed unrelated to tea
erate consumers (1—2 cups/day), moderate-to-high con-
consumption, other cancers (digestive tract, including the
sumers (3-7 cups/day), and high consumers (> 8 cups/
pancreas; gynecological, including the cervix and
day). Plasma cholesterol levels were inversely correlated
uterus; urinary tract; and leukemia) were inversely
with tea consumption; serum cholesterol concentrations
correlated with tea consumption. 23 This study showed that
were decreased by 6%, 12%, 19%, and 28%, respectively,
a daily intake of two or more cups of tea per day
in the four groups compared with non—tea drinkers. 14 The
reduced the develop- ment of digestive and urinary tract
effect of tea on plasma homocysteine levels was slightly
cancers by 60% and 32%, respectively, compared with non
different. The low consumers had a 6% reduction, moder-
—tea drinkers.°' More specifically, there was an inverse

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


ate consumers a 20% reduction, and moderate-to-high
consumers a 31% reduction, whereas high consumers had relationship between tea drinking and cancers of the
a 9% increase in plasma homocysteine concentrations mouth, esophagus, stomach, pancreas, colorectum,
compared with non—tea drinkers." Other human studies bladder, and prostate. 2' In the fol- lowing section,
showed that tea drinking lowers cholesterol concentra- evidence from human and animal studies pertaining to
tions in normal subjects and in patients with hypercholes- the effect of tea on the development of can- cer is
terolemia.' ' i' " The human data were confirmed by an discussed in a site-specific manner (Table 3).
animal study. Hara'6 reported that the polyphenols in tea Mouth
(mainly catechins and theaflavins) lowered hypercholes- Tea flavonoids were shown to be beneficial to the mu-
terolemia to normal levels, reduced blood pressure, and cosal lining of the mouth. The incidence of superficial
decreased the risk of seoke in susceptible rats. precancerous lesions (leukoplakia) was inversely corre-
Another study from Norway studied the relationship lated with tea flavonoids. 2’ In one published study, 59
between black tea consumption and serum cholesterol patients with leukoplakia were treated with either a tea
concentration, systolic blood pressure, and mortality from extract (29 patients) or with extracts from vegetables
all causes of coronary heart disease in 9856 men and 10,233 rich in antioxidants (30 patients); there was no true
women, ages 35—49, in the county of Oppland, Norway. i9 placebo group in this study. The effects of the treatment
Increasing tea consumption was significantly associated were as- sessed after 6 months of intervention. Patients
with decreased mean serum cholesterol and decreased who re- ceived the tea had a significantly higher rate of
systolic blood pressure. The mortality rate was reduced, leuko- plakia regression compared with patients who
although not statistically significantly, in persons drink- received the vegetable extracts (37.9% versus 10.0%, P <
ing * 1 cup/day compared with persons drinking no tea or 0.05), as illustrated in Table 4.24 This study may constitute
< 1 cup/day. In men, deaths from coronary heart disease the only attempt to use tea not as a preventive means to
were significantly reduced (by 40%) for tea drinkers k 1 decrease the risk of cancer but rather as a therapeutic agent
cup/day) versus nondrinkers (< 1 cup/day). against established precancerous lesions. A larger number
Some human studies, however, have not shown pro- of sub- jects and a true control group followed for a
tective effects of tea consumption on serum lipid pro- longer dura- tion, however, are needed to confirm this
files2''2' and coronary heart disease morbidity and mortal- preliminary re- sult.
ity.22 Nevertheless, the overall picture emerging from pub-
lished studies is that tea confers protective effects on the Esophagus
cardiovascular system. This is supported by observations A higher incidence of cancer of the esophagus was previ-
that tea drinking significantly reduces the risk of ischemic ously linked to tea consumption.” Recent studies, how-
heart disease and stroke as well as serum or plasma con- ever, do not confirm this earlier finding. In fact, a large
centrations of cholesterol and homocysteine. Japanese study on both green tea and black tea showed
that once potential confounding factors (gender, age, year
Prevention of Cancer and season of first hospitalization, smoking, alcohol, regu-
larity of physical exercise, and intake of fruit, rice, and
In addition to beneficial effects on the cardiovascular sys-
beef) are corrected, tea drinking does not increase the
tem, tea also appears to provide protective effects
development of esophageal cancer.2' It now appears that
against several cancers. A recently published large
the development of esophageal cancer is related to the
prospective epidemiologic study conducted in the
high temperature at which the drink is consumed rather
American Midwest suggests a beneficial effect of tea
than the nature of the drink. 2’ Thus, it was suggested
drinking on cancer. This study was conducted in a large
that any drink consumed at hot temperatures (> 60°C)
group (> 35,000) of post-
may result in irritation of the esophagus and a higher
inci-
4
Nutrition Reviews•, Voi. 58, No. 1
Table 3. Correlation Between Specific Cancers and Tea Drinking
Site Type ofstudy Type ofTea Effect Magaitude ofEffect Reference
Nlouth Human intervention Green $ 37.9% partial regression of lesions 24
after 6 months treatment
Esophagus Human epidemiologic Green and black No effect 25
Stomach Human epidemiologic Green and black Decrease in incidence of cancer by 25
31% only when consuming seven
cups green tea or more per day
Pancreas Human epidemiologic Green < 200 g/month: 12% decrease
in males, 53% in females;
> 200 g/month: 43% decrease in
males, 47% in females
Colorectal Human epidemiologic Black Reduction by 4% in the colon, 27
44% in the rectum, and 21% in the

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


colorectum
Skin Animal study Black 30—42% fewer keratoacanthomas, 28
26—33% fewer squamous cell
carcinomas
Lung Animal study Black 24% fewer tumors, 38% reduction 29,30
in size in present tumors
Prostate Human epidemiologic Black and green 30% reduction in cancer incidence 31
among heavy tea drinkers
(> 500 g/day)
Urinary Human epidemiologic Green 50% reduction in females 32
bladder
Legend: = means no change; 1 means decrease; † means increase.

dence of esophageal cancer." 3‘ In fact, a number of case- Pancreas


control studies found no relationship between tea con- Pancreatic cancer is one of the deadliest cancers. Tea con-
sumption at normal temperatures (37—45°C) and esoph- sumption was correlated to a lower incidence of pancre-
ageal cancer, but ingestion of very hot tea (55—67°C) in- atic cancer in humans. A clear inverse correlation was shown
creased risk by two- to threefold. 3' The increased risk for by a Chinese study in which 451 cases of pancreatic can-
esophageal cancer associated with consumption of tea at cer were compared with 1552 matched controls without
high temperatures may be due to enhanced cell prolifera- pancreatic cancer.26 Regular drinkers of tea experienced a
tion in response to cell death from scalding of the esoph- 12% and 53% lower incidence of cancer among males and
ageal mucosa.” females, respectively, compared with non—tea drinkers. 2‘
When the intake of tea exceeded 200 g/month, the risk
Stomach reduction remained unchanged among women, whereas
Stomach cancer is relatively uncommon in North America as the incidence of pancreatic cancer was further decreased
opposed to its high prevalence in China, Japan, Korea, and by 43% in men." This study was limited, however, by an
South American countries. The effects of tea on gastric ma- incomplete correction of confounding factors, including
lignancy appear to be conflicting. Some studies suggest an occupational risk factors. Another case-control study from
inverse relationship between tea consumption and stomach Poland reported a significant reduction in risk of pancre-
cancer, whereas others show either no correlation or a posi- atic cancer with increasing lifetime consumption of tea (P
tive correlation.34 Owing to the methodologic limitations, no < 0.001).3‘
definite conclusion can be drawn. Large prospective studies
that can correct for potential confounding factors are neces-
sary to define the relationship between stomach cancer and
tea. The only such study published is the aforementioned
Table 4. Leukoplakia Patients Treated with Tea
study by Inoue et al.25 The results were corrected for con-
Extracts Versus Vegetable Extracts
founding factors (see above). Investigators concluded that
Tea Vegetable
there was no association between tea consumption and stom-
ach cancer." However, consumption of seven or more cups Regression 37.9°Zo 10.0%
per day of green tea significantly decreased the risk of Unchanged status 58.6% 83.3%
Deterioration 3.4% 6.7%
stom- ach cancer (by 31%) compared with no green tea
consump- ti Onq 2b Source: reference 24.

Nutr’ition Reviews•, Vol. 58, No. 1 5


Colorectal Cancer incidence ofprostate cancer(by 11%) compared with non-
Tea consumption is inversely related to the development drinkers, whereas a medium to high daily consumption of
of colorectal cancer. In a case-control study from Sweden, tea further reduced the incidence of prostate cancer by
the protective effect of tea was observed with consump- 70% vis-á-vis the level of the control group."
tion of two or more cups per day.2’ The incidence of can-
cer was reduced by 4% in the colon, 44% in the rectum, Urinary bladder
and 21% in the colorectum compared with non—tea drink- The protection conferred by tea on urinary bladder cancer
ers.2' However, low tea consumption (fewer than two cups appears to be more pronounced in females than in males.
per day) offered no protective effect on the development Although the data are scarce, published studies report a
of colorectal cancer compared with norr—tea drinkers.2' 50% reduction in the incidence of bladder cancer in female
Evidence from another study suggests that tea exerts its but not in male tea drinkers compared with non—tea drink-
protective effect in later stages of colorectal carcinogen- ers, even after confounding factors, such as tabagism, are
esis because no risk reduction was observed for small taken into consideration." However, tea appears to im-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


adenomas, the well-established precursors of colorectal prove 5-year survival in male patients with bladder can-
cancer.°7 In a recent large Chinese study, women demon- cer; male tea drinkers had twofold higher 5-year survival
strated a greater degree of risk reduction in the develop- rates than non—tea drinkers.°•
ment of colorectal adenoma than males at every level of
tea consumption.2""‘ Other Health Benefits
Skin Tea contains 0.1 mg fluoride/cup." Thus, potential health
There is a lack of human studies examining the relation- benefits associated with fluoride, which prompted North
ship between tea drinking and skin cancer. The best stud- American health authorities to add this element to potable
ies pertaining to the relationship between tea consump- water supplies, can be expected from drinking tea.""’
tion and skin cancer involve work conducted in mice. Drink- Tea also plays a role in the prevention of kidney
ing tea seems to protect mice from the carcinogenic ef- stones. A recent study of 1750 women followed for 5
fects derived from prolonged exposure to UV light. In one years" showed that the consumption of beverages rich in
such study, UV-irradiated mice (for 22 weeks) that drank antioxidants drastically reduced the risk of developing
tea developed 3M2% fewer keratoaeanthomas and 2W kidney stones. Thus, red wine, which is avery rich source
33% fewer squamous cell carcinomas compared with simi- of antioxidants, albeit different from those found in tea.
larly irradiated mice that drank water.^ provided a 45% reduction when drunk in moderation (I
glass/day). Tea in the amount of 2—3 cups/day also lo» -
Lm s ered the relative risk of developing kidney stones, by
Several studies compared groups of mice treated with the 31%.’
tobacco-specific carcinogen 4-(methylnitrosamino)-l-(3- Tea may have antimicrobial properties; it was sug-
gested that microorganisms that cause diarrhea are af-
PV’d l)-1-butanone (NKK) and randomized to receive ei-
ther water or water enriched with tea-derived antioxidants. fected by tea." It is possible that tea’s antimicrobial mecha-
Tea-treated mice developed 24% fewer lung tumors and nism involves a chelating action on iron rather than a bac-
the average size of the lung tumors was 38% smaller tericidal activity against the intestinal flora (the relation-
com- pared with the control(water-fed) mice."°' The ship between tea and iron adsorption is discussed be-
protective effect of tea was confirmed by a subsequent low). In addition, one study implicated tea as an immune
study in which mice treated with the same carcinogen, system enhancer.’2 Obviously, more work needs to be done
NKK, were ran- domized to receive either water or a 2% to clarify these provocative relationships.
black tea solution. Rodents fed the 2% black tea solu on
developed 60% fewer tumors than rodents fed water.2' Potential Health Concerns Associated with Tea
There are three main issues that must be clarified before
Prostate promoting tea for human health. These issues are the role
The risk for prostate cancer appears to be inversely re- of caffeine in tea, the iron-chelating activity of tea, and Her
lated to tea consumption. One of the few published stud- high content of aluminum iti tea leaves.
ies was a case-control study involving three groups of tea The average daily consumption of caffeine by North
drinkers from three different areas of Canada.°' The study American adults is estimated to be 186—238 mg/day and
compared non—tea drinkers with low-consumption (< 2 derived from coffee (60%), tea (30%), and a mix of other
cups/day or < 500 g/day) and high-consumption (* 2 sources such as cola drinks, chocolate, and drugs (10%).“-
cups/ day or ñ 500 g/day) tea drinkers. The risk of Whereas the concentration of caffeine in tea can › in
prostate can- cer among non—tea drinkers was used as considerably depending on blend and strength of bre»‘. a
the baseline. A low daily consumption of tea cup of tea (170 mL) contains 25.5—34 mg ofcaffeine,^'
significantly reduced the

Nutrition Reviews•, Vol. 58, No. 1


6
i.e., roughly one-third of the caffeine found in an equal taneously with foods containing nonheme iron. Tea drink-
amount of coffee. The degree of caffeine consumption ing between meals, therefore, has no effect on iron ab-
associated with tea drinking is well within the limits of sorption. In addition, the chelating activity of tea is inhib-
Canada’s Food Guide to Healthy Eating,46'47 which indi- ited by the presence of ascorbic acid.’ ' The probable
cates that an excess of400—450 mg caffeine/day may pose
cause resides in the lower pH of the drink, which would
some risks. The proposed upper level of safe daily caf-
affect the charges at the binding sites of chelators in tea,
feine intake represents the average intake from l11-12 cups
thereby rendering them inoperative. Inhibition of the
of tea.‘3 Therefore, normal tea consumption does not ap-
chelating activity of tea also can be achieved by adding
pear to pose any risk associated with caffeine exposure.
milk.62 This is probably because milk is very rich in miner-
Although some concerns regarding the effects ofcaf-
als and tea would first bind the milk-derived ions. Thus,
feine on osteoporosis have been raised, it is now estab-
the chelating activity of tea would be saturated and the
lished that caffeine does not promote osteoporosis as
drink would no longer sequester iron from food. Whereas
shown by a study in which bone mineral measurements of
it is clear that polyphenols in tea decrease iron absorp-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


three groups of menopausal women were compared. 4'
tion, it is not likely to cause iron deficiency anemia in
There was no difference among the groups with a low
healthy individuals consuming a well-balanced diet that
caffeine consumption, a moderate caffeine consumption,
and a high caffeine consumption.4'A control group, which includes readily available sources of heme iron. In prac-
consumed no caffeine, however, was not included in this tice, this issue only concerns people who consume little
study. Caffeine has not been linked to cancer risk; there is or no meat and meat products. Because tea does seques-
no statistically significant difference in the incidence of ter iron, however, vegetarians should not drink it while
cancer between high-caffeine consumers and no-caffeine consuming meals, in order to avoid the chelation of the
consumers .‘9'' 0 In some instances, caffeine consumption iron present in the food.^" Vegetarians and other people at
was shown to reduce colorectal cancer risk." Although risk for iron deficiency anemia (infants, young children,
the association between caffeine consumption and the and pregnant women) should be encouraged to include
risk of cardiovascular disease has been suggested in some plenty of iron-rich foods in their diets, drink tea between
epidemiologic studies, recent large epidemiologic studies meals, and add milk or squeeze a lemon wedge in their tea
and meta-analyses found no evidence of this putative to increase ascorbic acid content.
association.’ 2'' 3 Teratogenic effects associated with caf- The third concern regarding tea stems from the high
feine in humans are observed with consumption of greater level of aluminum in tea leaves.* Most plants do not ab-
than 50 mg/kg of body weight.^ Thus, for an adult weigh- sorb aluminum from soil; many produce a gelatinous mu-
ing 70 kg, these effects would be observed with consump- cilage around their roots that binds aluminum. 6' The tea
tion of 3500 mg caffeine/day, i.e., approximately 100 cups plant, however, accumulates and stores aluminum as alu-
of tea/day. Although a link between caffeine and malfor- minum-hydroxide in epidermal cells of their leaves. 6‘ As
mation in fetuses was not unequivocally proven, there are such, the tea plant contains high concentrations of alumi-
some concerns that a fetus may be affected by excessive num and has raised concern about a possible link between
caffeine consumption." Caffeine is lipolytic and crosses tea consumption and Alzheimer’s disease. For most indi-
the lipid bilayer of cells; it will therefore cross the placenta viduals, however, food is the major contributor of alumi-
and reach the fetus. Caution should therefore be exer- num.“ Beverages represent only a moderate source of
cised by pregnant women; they may want to reduce their aluminum to the diet. Whereas tea leaves may be high in
consumption of caffeine. Human population studies and aluminum, tea consumption is not a major contributor of
animal studies have not shown any evidence that caf- dietary aluminum. 6‘ Rather, foods such as processed
feine, when consumed in moderation, causes intrauterine cheese, grain products, and desserts are larger contribu-
growth retardation, low birth weight, preterm birth, spon- tors of this mineral.“
taneous abortion, or birth defects.""° The data available thus far appear to indicate that tea
is safe for two reasons. First, the incidence ofAlzheimer’s
Consumption of tea has been shown to decrease
in individuals or countries with high tea consumption is
iron absorption in the gastrointestinal tract. Polyphenols
not significantly different from that in those with lower tea
in tea are believed to form insoluble complexes with iron
consumption.•’ 6' Thus, Ireland and Turkey, where the per
within the gastrointestinal tract and render the iron un-
capita consumption of tea is 3 kg/person per year and 2.25
available for absorption. It was demonstrated that polyphe-
kg/person per year, respectively, do not have higher rates
nols in tea reduce the bioavailability ofnonheme iron when
ofAlzheimer’s disease than Canada, where the consump-
consumed with meals.’ 7 " Dietary iron exists in two forms:
tion of tea is five- to sixfold lower (0.49 kg/person per
heme iron and nonheme iron (inorganic iron). Heme iron is
year)."" The second reason relates to the physiologic
better absorbed than nonheme iron and is derived from
absorption of aluminum by tea drinkers. Unlike flavonoids,
animal foods (meat, fish, poultry, and eggs). However, tea
which are readily dissolved in water, the aluminum found
only inhibits iron absorption when it is consumed simul-
in tea leaves is not.69 The quantity of this metal that can be

Nutrition Reviews ®, Vol. 58, No. 1


derived from tea for absorption is minimal. Moreover, its ing orange or grapefruit juice with tea or adding lemon
presence in the blood continues to be minimal after drink- or milk to the tea would obviate the iron-sequestering
ing copious amounts of tea." For instance, even when the ability of tea. The fear of developing Alzheimer’s disease
dietary intake of aluminum from tea doubled, the plasma as a result of drinking tea rests on the sole fact that tea
level of aluminum remained unchanged." Furthermore, leaves are rich in aluminum. Drinking tea, however, does
much of the extractable aluminum in brewed tea is bound not in- crease the level of aluminum in the plasma, a
to large organic species such as theaflavins, therubigins, necessary condition for aluminum to accumulate in
and other polyphenolic fermentation products that are human tissues. There is no evidence to support the role
not easily absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract. of tea in the pathogenesis ofAlzheimer’s disease.
Clearly, at present there are insufficient scientific data to The image tea has gained through the centuries is
indicate that tea consumption is associated with one of pleasure, which can be beneficial at times of illness
increased risk of Alzheimer’s disease. such as flu and flu-like diseases. Current scientific research
has reinforced this perception, shedding some light on

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


Conclusion the extent of the benefits tea can provide to humans and
Tea seems to fit the description of an ideal component of the mechanisms by which it provides these benefits. Un-
a healthy dietary habit that can be used to promote human like self-indulgent pastimes, drinking tea contains approxi-
health. It is easily ingested, palatable, inexpensive, widely mately zero calories (which would come from either added
available, and tasty. Tea also appears to be safe and sugar or milk), has less caffeine than coffee on a per cup
with- out significant side effects. Above all, tea is basis, has no significant side effects, and provides sev-
abundantly rich in antioxidants. However, research has eral health benefits.
consistently shown that no single dietary or lifestyle
1. Weisburger JH. Second International Scientific
factor can pro- vide the “magic bullet” to present chronic Symposium on Tea and Health: an introduction.
diseases such as cancer and cardiovaseular disease. Tea Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1999;220:193—4
may be used together with a variety of other foods and 2. Ahmad N, Mukhtar H. Green tea polyphenols and
drinks as part of a healthy diet to promote healthy cancer: biologic mechanisms and practical impli-
living. cations. Nutr Rev 1999;57:78—83
3. Jankun J, Selman SH, Swiercz R, Skrzypczak-
Both animal and epidemiologic studies suggest prom- Jankun E. Why drinking the green tea could pre-
ising protective effects of tea against several diseases vent cancer. Nature 1997;2387:561
including cardiovascular disorders and cancer. Tea con- 4. Keli SO, Hertog MGL, Feskens EJM, Kromhout D.
tains several important biological compounds that are ef- Dietary flavonoids, antioxidant vitamins, and inci-
fective against the development of many pathologie pro- dence of stroke. Arch Intern Med. 1996;156:637—
42
cesses. Among thèse, flavonoids appear to be pivotal for 5. Graham HN. Green tea composition, consumption,
the beneficial effects associated with tea in humans. They and polyphenol chemistry. Prev Med 1992;21 :334—
act as antioxidants and present tissues from being dam- 50
aged by free radicals. Within cells, flavonoids block ef- 6. Hertog MGL, Feskens EJM, Hollman PCH, et at.
fects of known carcinogens. Flavonoids also appear to Dietary antioxidant flavonoids and risk of coronary
disease: the Zutphen Elderly Study. Lancet
protect gènes from mutagenic effects of environmental 1993;342:1007—11
factors. All of thèse effects may contribute to the mainte- 7. Cao G, Sofic E, Prior RL. Antioxidant capacity of tea
nance of the healthy state of cells. There also is prelimi- and common vegetables. J Agric Food Chem
nary evidence that tea can be used not only as a preven- 1996;44:3426—31
tive agent but also as a therapeutic agent against prema- 8. Stavric B, Matula TI, Klassen R, Downie RH. The
effect of teas on the in vitro mutagenic potential of
lignant lesions in the mouth (i.e., oral leukoplakia). More heterocyclic aromatic amines. Food Chem Toxicol
studies are needed to further elucidate the therapeutic 1996;34:515—23
effects of tea. 9. Yang KC, Li X, Tsui ZC. The relationship between
There are three main concems vis-à-vis the consump- nutritional antioxidants and serum lipid peroxides
tion oLtea: the robe ofcaffeine, iron absorption by the gut,
and a possible link to Alzheimer’s disease. If tea consump- in cancer patients. In Vivo T 989;3.2T 1—4
tion is less than 10—12 cups/day, the level of caffeine is 10. Harris WS. The prevention of atherosclerosis with
antioxidants. Clin Cardiol 1992;15:636—40
within the safe boundaries (< 400-450 mg/day) suggested 11. Green MS, Jucha G. Association of serum lipids
by Canadian Health authorities. Iron absorption is an is- with coftee, tea, and egg consumption in free living
sue for vegetarians, whose diet is restricted to iron in the subjects. J Epidemiol Community Health 1986;40:
324—9
rionheme Non, md Nez individuels aiüz4 DIö#yr1DpFg
0o volt v, ñe/l11er #, L6k nTO, afar. Coff9’9’, diefay
iron deficiency anemia. Thèse people should not drink tea habits and serum cholesterol among men and
with meaJs because the iron in the food is chelated by the women 35—49 years of age. Am J Epidemiol 1989;
tea. Altematively, they can drink tea between meals. Drink- 129:1277—88
Nutrition Revïeyrse, Vol. 58, No. 1
13. Young W, Hotovec RL, Romero AG. Tea and athero- (methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyI)-1-butanone-in-
sclerosis. Nature 1967;216:1015—6 duced lung tumorigenesis model with A/J mice.
14. Nygârd OS, Refsum H, Ueland PM, et al. Cofiee Cancer Res 1997;57:1889—94
consumption and plasma total homocysteine: the 31. Jain MG, Hislop GT, Howe GR, et al. Alcohol and
Hordaland homocysteine study. Am J Clin Nutr other beverage use and prostate cancer risk among
1997;65:136—43 Canadian men. Int J Cancer 1998;78:707—11
15. Sesso HD, Gazlano JM, Buring JE, Hennekens CH. 32. Ohno Y, Aoki K, Obata K, Morrison S. A case-con-
Coffee and tea intake and the risk of myocardial trol study of urinary bladder cancer in metropolitan
infarction. Am J Epidemiol 1999;149:162—7 Nagoya. NCI Monograph. J Natl Cancer Inst 1985;
16. Hara Y. The effect of tea polyphenols on cardiovas- 69:224—34
cular disease. Prev Med 1992;21:333 33. Ghadirian IN Thermal irritation and esophageal can-
17. van het Hof KH, Wiseman SA, Yang CS, Tijburg cer in Northern Iran. Cancer 1987;60:1909—14
LBM. Plasma and lipoprotein levels of tea catechins 34. Bushman JL. Green tea and cancer in humans: a
following repeated tea consumption. Proc Soc Exp review of the literature. Nutr Cancer 1998;31 :151—
Biol Med 1999;22O:203—9 9
18. Kono S, Shinchi K, Ikeda N, et al. Green tea

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


35. Yang CS, Wang Z-Y. Tea and cancer. J Natl Cancer
con- sumption and serum lipid profiles: a cross- Inst 1993;85:1038—49
sectional study in northern Kyushu, Japan. Prev 36. Zatonski WA, Boyle P, Przewozniak K, et al. Ciga-
Med 1992; 21 :526—31 rette smoking, alcohol, tea and cofiee consump-
19. Stensvold I, Tverdal A, Solvoll K, Foss OI? Tea con- tion and pancreas cancer risk: a case-control study
sumption, relationship to cholesterol, blood from Opole, Poland. Int J Cancer 1993;53:601—7
pres- sure, and coronary and total mortality. 37. Baron JA, Greenberg ER, Haile R, et al. Coffee and
Prev Med 1992;21 :546—53 tea and the risk of recurrent colorectal adenomas.
20. Aro A, Kostiairen E, Huttunen JK, et al. Effects Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1997;6:7—10
of coffee and tea on lipoproteins and 38. Stagg GV, Millin DJ. The nutritional and therapeutic
prostanoids. Atherosclerosis 1985;57:123—8 value of tea: a review. J Sci Food Agric 1975;26:
21. Green MS, Harari G. Association of serum lipopro- 111—8
teins and health-related habits with coffee and tea 39. Das DN, Gosh JJ, Guha BC. Studies on tea. Part I.
consumption in free-living subjects examined in Nutritional aspects. Ind J Appl Chem 1964;27:6
the Israeli CORDIS study. Prev Med 1992;21:532 40. Curhan GC, Willett WC, Speizer FE, Stampfer MJ.
45 Beverage use and risk for kidney stones in women.
22. Woodward M, Tunstall-Pedoe H. Cofiee and tea Ann Intern Med 1998;128:534—40
consumption in the Scottish Heart Health Study 41. Toda M, Okubo S, lkigai H, et al. The protective
follow-up: conflicting relations with coronary risk activity of tea catechins against experimental in-
factors, coronary disease, and all cause mortality. fection by Vibrio cholerae 01. Microbiol Immunol
J Epidemiol Community Health 1999;53:481—7 1992;36:999—1001
23. Zheng W, Doyle TJ, Kushi LH, et al. Tea consump- 42. Hu Z-Q, Toda M, Okubo S, et al. Mitogenic activity
tion and cancer incidence in a prospective cohort of (-) epigallocatechin gallate on B-cells and in-
study of postmenopausal women. Am J Epidemiol vestigation of its structure-function relationship. Int
1996;1 44:175—81 J lmmunopharmacol 1992;14:1399—407
24. Li N, Sun X, Han C, Chen J. The chemopreventive 43. Gilbert GM. Caffeine consumption. Prog Clin Biol
effects of tea on human oral precancerous mucosa Res 1984;158:185—213
lesions. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1999;220:21&-24 44. Graham DM. Caffein its identity, dietary sources,
25. Inoue M, Tajima K, Hirose K, et al. Tea and coffee intake and biological effects. Nutr Rev 1978;36:97—
consumption and the risk of digestive tract can- 102
cers: data from a comparative case-referent study 45. Lelo A, Miners JO, Robson R, Birkett DJ. Assess-
in Japan. Cancer Causes Control 1998;9:209—16 ment of caffeine exposure: caffeine content of bev-
26. Ji BT, Chow WH, Hsing AW, et al. Green tea con- erages. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1986;39:54—9
sumption and the risk of pancreatic and colorectal 46. Health and Welfare Canada. Nutrition recommen-
cancers. Int J Cancer 1997;70:255—8 dations—report of the Scientific Review Commit-
27. Baron JA, Gerhardsson de Verdier M, Ekbom A. tee. Ottawa, 1990;194—6
Coffee, tea, tobacco and cancer of the large bowel. 47. Health and Welfare Canada. Food guide facts back-
Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1994;3:565— ground for educators and communicators. Fact
70 Sheet 6. Canada's food guide to healthy eating.
28. Conney AH, Lu Y-P, Lou Y-R, et al. Inhibitory effect of Ottawa, 1992
green and black tea on tumor growth. Proc Soc 48. Lloyd T, Rollings N, Eggli DF, et al. Dietary caffeine
Exp Biol Med 1999;220:229—33 intake and bone status of menopausal women. Am
29. Yang G, Liu Z, Seril DN, et al. Black tea J Clin Nutr 1997;65:1826—30
constitu- ents, theaflavins, inhibit 4- 49. Jacobsen BK, Bjelke E, Kvale G, Heuch 1. Coffee
(methyInitrosamino)-1- (3-pyridyI)-1-butanone drinking, mortality, and cancer incidence: results
(NNK)-induced lung tumori- genesis in A/J mice. from a Norwegian prospective study. J Natl Cancer
Carcinogenesis 1997;18: 2361—5 Inst 1986;76:823—31
30. Yang G, Wang Z-Y, Kim S, et al. Characterization of 50. Nomura A, Hellbrun LK, Stemmermann GN. Pro-
early pulmonary hyperproliferation and tumor pro- spective study of coffee consumption and the risk
gression and their inhibition by black tea in a 4- of cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 1986;76:587—90

Nutrition Reviewse , Vol. 58, No. 1


51. Giovannucci E. Meta-analysis of coffee consump- Nutr 1979;32:2484—9
tion and risk of colorectal cancer. Am J Epidemiol 62. Farkas CS, Harding ie Riche W. Effect of tea and
1998;1 47:1 043—52 coffee consumption on non-heme iron absorption:
52. Klatsky AL, Friedman GD, Armstrong MA. Coffee some questions about milk. Hum Nutr Clin Nutr
use prior to myocardial infarction restudied: 1987;44:161—3
heavier intake may increase the risk. Am J 63. Helman AD, Darnton-Hill I. Vitamin and iron status
Epidemiol 1990;132:479—88 in new vegetarians. Am J Clin Nutr 1987;45:785—9
53. Myers MG, Basinski A. Coffee and coronary heart 64. Matsumoto H, Hirasawa E, Morimura S, Takahashi
disease. Arch Intern Med 1992;152:1767—72 E. Localization of aluminum in tea leaves. Plant
54. Berger A. Effects of caffeine consumption on preg- Cell Physiol 1976;17:627
nancy outcome. J Reprod Med 1988;33:945—56 65. Horst WJ, Wagner A, Marschner H. Mucilage pro-
55. Brooke OG, Anderson HR, Blarel JM, et al. Effects
tects root meristems from aluminum injury. Z
on birth weight of smoking, alcohol, caffeine, so- Pflanzenphysiol 1982;105:435
cioeconomic factors, and psychosocial stress. BMJ 66. Pennington JAT, Jones JW. Dietary intahe of alumi-
1989;298:795—801 num. In: Gitelman HJ, ed. Aluminum and health.
56. Mills JL, Homes LB, Aaron JH. Moderate caffeine

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/58/1/1/1926564 by guest on 17 February 2023


New York: Marcel Dekker, 1989;67—100
use and the risk of spontaneous abortion and in- 67. Rogers MA, Simon DG. A preliminary study of
trauterine growth retardation. JAMA 1993;269:593— di- etary aluminum intake and risk of Alzheimer’s
7 dis- ease. Age Ageing 1999;28:205—9
57. Hallberg L, Rossander L. Effects of different drin[‹s 68. Forster DP, Newens AJ, Kay DW, Edwardson JA.
on the absorption of non-heme iron from compos- Risk factors in clinically diagnosed presenile de-
ite meals. Hum Nutr Appl Nutr 1982;36:116—23 mentia of the Alzheimer’s type: a case control study
58. Sheu R, Kies C. Niacin, thiamin, iron and in Northern England. J Epidemiol Community
protein status of humans is affected by the Health 1995;49:253—8
consumption of tea Camellia sinensis) infusions. 69. Fairweather-Tait SJ, Poper Z, Fatemi FJ, Moore GR.
Plant Foods Hum Nutr 1991;41:337—53 The effect of tea on iron and aluminum metabolism
59. Anderson TR, Toverud SU, Price JB, et al. Effects of in the rat. Br J Nutr 1991 ;65:61—8
iron and ascorbic acid on acid phosphatases of 70. Drewitt PN, Butterworth KR, Springall C D,
the enamel organ of rat molars. Arch Oral Biol Moorhouse SR. Plasma levels of aluminum after
1982;27:255—9 tea ingestion in healthy volunteers. Food Chem
60. Hallberg L, Brune M, Rossander L. Effect of ascor- Toxicol 1993;31 :19—23
bic acid on iron absorption from different types 71. Butterworth KR, Drewitt PN, Sp ringall C D,
of meals. Studies with ascorbic acid rich foods Moorhouse SR. Bioavailability of aluminum. Lan-
and synthetic ascorbic acid given in different cet 1992;339:1489
amounts in different meals. Hum Nutr Appl Nutr 72. First International Symposium on Tea and Health.
1986;40:97— 113 Proceedings to the First International Symposium
61. Rossander L, Hallberg L, Biorn-Rasmussen E. Ab- on Tea and Health. Prev Med 1992;21 :319—91, 503
sorption of iron from breakfast meals. Am J Clin —53

10 Nutrition Reviews•, Vol. 58, No. 1

You might also like