Professional Documents
Culture Documents
9 Springer-Verlag 1981
Abstract. The suggestion has been made that the daily taking therefore examined the influence of large doses of ascorbic
of large doses of Vitamin C may decrease the likelihood of acid on a series of psychological tasks.
contracting a wide range of human disorders. The present
study has examined the possible psychological side-effects of
large doses of this vitamin. Evidence is presented that these
large doses produce a disruption of psychological functioning Materials and Methods
resulting in decreased reaction times and psychomotor
coordination. The subjects were 37 undergraduates (mean age 19.6 years),
who were subjected to the series of tests described below. Half
Key words: Ascorbic acid - Vitamin C - Reaction-times - the subjects were male and half female, but as there were no
Motor coordination sex differences the results are pooled. Exactly I week later
the subjects were divided, using a double blind procedure,
into three treatment groups receiving a placebo, 1 g or 2 g of
Vitamin C. The drug was an effervescent preparation (Boots,
Ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) is sythesized in a variety of plants Nottingham, UK) dissolved in orange concentrate diluted
and many animals. Man, the other primates and the guinea with water (any Vitamin C in the concentrate was destroyed
pig are exceptions in that they are unable to produce the by prolonged boiling). The placebo was soda water added to
compound for themselves. The most clearly established role the orange concentrate. One-and-a-half hours after drug
for the vitamin is in maintaining the intercellular material of administration, the same series of psychological tests was
cartilage, dentine and bone, although it is thought to be given for a second time. Simple reaction times were measured
required for a variety of metabolic processes. using an electronic counter by taking the time to press a single
Although the recommended daily dose of Vitamin C is button when a single light appeared. The subjects were given a
75 mg for an adult male and 70 mg for a female (Food and series of ten trials; the stimuli appeared without warning at
Nutrition Board ofU. S. National Research Council) various inter-trial intervals that varied randomly from 5-10 s. A mean
popular books (Pauling 1970; Webster 1971) have recom- value for each subject was obtained.
mended doses well in excess of these figures. The contentious Complex reaction times were obtained using a console
suggestions have been made that daily doses from 1 - 1 0 g that had ten lights in a straight line, with a button under each
may act as a prophylactic or actually cure disorders induding one. Using his preferred hand, the time in ms the subject took
alcoholism, allergies, anaemia, burns, cardiovascular disease, to press the button underneath the light switched on was the
cancers of the bladder and lungs, dermatitis, miscarriage, measure taken. A series of 20 warm-up trials was given,
multiple sclerosis and tuberculosis (Webster 1971). The most followed by ten experimental trials. A mean of the experimen-
widely proposed view is that Vitamin C may protect against tal trials was calculated.
the common cold. Pauling (1970) argues that primitive man The pursuit rotor task consisted of a turntable 12 in. in
ate much more Vitamin C-rich vegetation than is usual today diameter that revolved clockwise at 60 rpm. The target was
and that the medically recommended doses, although suf- 1 in. in diameter, 4 in. from the centre. The task involved
ficient to prevent the deficiency disorder scurvy, ignore the trying to keep an articulated metal stylus on the target for a
benefits of high doses. 30 s test period. When the stylus was in contact with the target
Although many of the suggested benefits of Vitamin C it activated a counter.
iack a scientific basis, the drug industry has answered the A Spiral After Image was measured using a 9 in. disc with
demand for high doses of ascorbic acid; these are readily an Archimedes spiral drawn on it, that revolved at 60 rpm for
available without prescription. Although there is little evi- 30 s (Holland 1969). The spiral was a black line drawn on a
dence that physiological side-effects resulLfrom even very white background. The subject stood 1 m from the spiral and
large doses, there is reason to suspect that behavioural while it was revolving, experienced the sensation that it was
influences may occur. Pfeiffer et al. (1968) found that oral shrinking, that is, the lines were returning to the centre. They
doses of 1 or 3 g of Vitamin C caused changes in elec- were told that when the disc was abruptly stopped they would
troencephalogram (EEG) recordings, producing an effect have the sensation that the spiral was expanding. The subjects
typical of Sedative drugs that lasted for the 6 h of testing. The reported when the expansion "after image" stopped, and this
report that Vitamin C influenced EEG records suggested the period was measured in s. This task is known to be susceptible
possibility of behavioural side-effects. The present study has to stimulant and depressant drugs (Holland 1969).
0033-3158/81/0075/0098/$01.00
99
Table 1. The influenceof Vitamin C on psy~l~otogicalfunctioning. All results are differencesbetween the first and second testing-sessionsexpressed as a
percentage of the score on the first test. The results are analysed using Kruskal-Wallis one-way analysis of variance. The results are mean percentage
change + SD. Note that positive.valuesreflect a disruption of performance in the reaction time tasks, but an improved performance-onthe pursuit rotor
Test Placebo 1g 2g
(N = ]'3) (N = 12) (N = 12)