Professional Documents
Culture Documents
quality
journalism
Digital News Innovation Fund Report 2018
European innovation
supporting quality
journalism
There are few things more important to society
than a free and thriving press. As the digital world
evolves, journalists and publishers are facing new
opportunities as well as new challenges.
Google’s mission, to organise the world’s information and make it
universally useful and accessible, shares the same core values that
29
European countries
461
underpin quality journalism. As our CEO Sundar Pichai publicly stated:
“Google cares deeply about journalism. We believe deeply in spreading
knowledge to make life better for everyone. It’s at the heart of Google’s
mission. It’s the mission of publishers and journalists. Put simply, our
futures are tied.”
Entering its third year, the DNI Fund is coming of age, and a community of
successful project owners has flourished. We’ve seen projects transform
from ideas to remarkable and highly impactful solutions that are already
making a difference in newsrooms.
€94m
Projects
In this report, you’ll find a full overview of DNI Fund activity as well as details
of many brilliant concepts from across Europe that are tackling four key
industry challenges: battling misinformation, telling local stories, boosting
digital revenues and exploring new technologies. We hope you enjoy reading
about them.
Funding
Austria Belgium Bulgaria Croatia
TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND
breakdown
PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS
12 14 4 3
Cyprus Czech Republic Denmark Finland
TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND
1 9 10 14
Battling 31 France Germany Greece Hungary
€10.2m
TOTAL FUND
€14.9m
TOTAL FUND
€1.8m
TOTAL FUND
€1.3m
Projects that work to defend and protect quality
journalism by using fact checking and other €5.1m PROJECTS
41
PROJECTS
67
PROJECTS
8
PROJECTS
13
technologies to combat misinformation. Amount of funding
€1.2m
TOTAL FUND
€7.8m
TOTAL FUND
€200k
TOTAL FUND
€545k
local stories No. of projects PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS
8 31 4 4
Projects that use innovation to ensure that local
and smaller publishers have a louder voice in the €13.2m
digital space. Amount of funding Luxembourg Netherlands Norway Poland
TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND
1 23 18 22
digital revenues No. of projects
21 10 4 5
Exploring 108
new technologies No. of projects Spain Sweden Switzerland United Kingdom
€21.5m
TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND TOTAL FUND
Projects that use digital technology to automate
workstreams or content in order to support original €8.2m €2m €3.3m €10.3m
journalism or improve the reader experience. Amount of funding
PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS PROJECTS
33 11 12 58
product/new community, newsletter
marketplace, video, audio, mobile, ne
06 07
Impartial 25,000+
Full Fact is generally recognised deliberately mislead the public –
as an organisation that has done they can misread the data and
more than most to highlight the make genuine mistakes.”
issue of ‘fake news’, which is
probably more usefully described Now Full Fact has been awarded
as ‘misinformation’. In 2016, the a further tranche of funding from
media items processed
and effective
DNI Fund supported the early the DNI Fund, for a new idea.
a week by Full Fact. beginnings of Full Fact’s “The project will help us develop
automated fact-checking tools. a set of standards for sharing fact
This was instrumental in building checks and evaluate automated
10-12
the technology that has since fact checking to ensure that the
been widely featured in the systems provide results in a
media, for example, when Full consistently balanced way,” adds
Fact live fact checks a TV Mevan. “This is part research
broadcast. Since the original project, part editorial creation, and
funding, Full Fact has flourished, it aims to explore how our findings
with the team doubling in size can best be disseminated. The
fact checks produced a week. to 16. objective is to make sure that fact
checking at internet scale is
“Full Fact is a registered charity balanced and fair, even though
12 hours
that’s funded by ordinary people, we don’t control when or where
by charitable trusts, and by others,” or how our fact checks appear.
explains Mevan Babakar, Head of So we’re carrying out research
Automated Factchecking at Full into how people experience fact
Fact. “Google was the first to fund checks in different products,
our automated fact checking and formats, and contexts – and
actually that was quite brave of we’re also developing and testing
the average time it takes them. That initial pot of money different fact check formats that
for one fact check. gave us the traction to build the could automatically appear on
first prototypes – and that spurred social networks. The end game
everyone else on to come round is to implement all these ideas
to our way of thinking.” and initiatives across all aspects
“ That initial pot of money gave “We undertake around ten fact
of our work.”
us the traction to build the first checks per week at the moment, As a charity, the sharing of
prototypes – and that spurred including claims made on regular
TV programmes such as BBC
experience, expertise and
tools across the fact-checking
everyone else on to come Question Time. We’re independent, community is a key goal for Full
round to our way of thinking.” impartial and effective. And there
are many examples of how our
Fact. Mevan and the team are
currently working closely with
work has led to retractions or similar organisations in South
corrections from a wide range Africa and Argentina, and hope to
Mevan Babakar of people and organisations, be in a position to present some of
Head of Automated Factchecking at Full Fact including a former prime minister the findings inspired by the latest
and also a political party that funding from the DNI Fund at the
had actually underestimated the Global Fact-Checking Summit in
effectiveness of a particular policy. June 2018.
Sometimes it’s not that people
Quick facts
Full Fact
Full Fact is a charity
that provides free tools,
information and advice
so that anyone can check “The objective is to make sure that fact
the claims of politicians
and the media.
checking at internet scale is balanced and
fair, even though we don’t control when or
Country:
United Kingdom
where or how our fact checks appear.”
Fund awarded:
2016 and 2017
Amount awarded:
€50,000 and €300,000
10 11
A question
of trust
In a world where deadlines rule, “Although TrustServista has only
media professionals often been in operation since the end
struggle to find the time or of 2017, we’ve already achieved
resources to distinguish the fake some significant results,” says
from the real. And that means George Bara, Chief Strategy
they can inadvertently distribute Officer. “For example, when news
content that misleads readers outlets reported a crash involving
and jeopardises the hard-won an airplane and a helicopter just
reputation of their organisation. above the Rothschild’s family
home in the UK, a couple of
In Romania, a fact-checking conspiracy websites were quick
project supported by the DNI Fund to announce the news of Jacob
is currently fact checking around Rothschild’s death. These reports
60,000 articles per day – and is rapidly gathered over 27,000
“ We believe we’re making a scaling up to more than treble
that number.
Facebook engagements. We
correctly identified the information
real difference by helping news source (with Patient Zero) and
organisations and other media TrustServista uses advanced
artificial intelligence (AI)
automatically scored these
articles as having a low-to-
professionals provide a better, algorithms to determine the medium content quality.”
more accurate and verified news trustworthiness of news stories.
Customers submit a URL or raw “We believe we’re making a
service to their readers.” text and the algorithms analyse real difference by helping news
the article, identifying semantic organisations and other media
similarities, links and references professionals provide a better,
George Bara between it and other content on more accurate and verified
Chief Strategy Officer at TrustServista the web before generating a set news service to their readers.
of trustworthiness metrics. These This simply wouldn’t have been
include a TrustLevel score – which possible without the Digital News
indicates the content’s degree of Innovation Fund. Our parent
trustworthiness – and Patient company, Zetta Cloud, would
Zero, which identifies the original never have been able to spend
source of the article. This could €50,000 on developing a prototype
Quick facts be anything from social media that may not have worked. But
or blog posts to website pages it did work – and thanks to the
TrustServista or news outlets. DNI Fund, Zetta Cloud had the
TrustServista uses confidence to invest a further
advanced artificial Because TrustServista is delivered €150,000. We now employ three
intelligence algorithms as Software as a Service (SaaS), full-time members of staff and are
to determine the it’s easy to adopt and use. It can moving towards being a financially
trustworthiness also be integrated into third-party sustainable business, which we
of news stories. software systems, such as expect to happen in the next 18
newsroom technologies, social months to two years.”
Country: media platforms or customer-
Romania centric widgets and web
browser add-ons.
Fund awarded:
2016
60,000+
Amount awarded:
€50,000
Because In silicon
facts matter there is truth
As highlighted in last year’s Currently, Factmata’s main focus A new system currently being As a name, Veritas In Silico (VIS,
report, funding received from is on using AI to analyse millions pioneered by one of Italy’s or In Silicon There is Truth) neatly
the Digital News Innovation Fund of URLs every day, assessing leading publishers could explains the project’s objectives.
in 2016 played a major role in content on a sentence-by- revolutionise the fact-checking Supported by the DNI Fund as well
establishing Factmata as one sentence level to assess the process for journalists while as investments from the publisher,
of the leading players in the risk to advertisers of appearing also becoming a revenue VIS is currently in the testing phase,
fact-checking arena. Today, alongside what could be generator in its own right. with go-live anticipated by January
Factmata has grown from a inappropriate content. For 2018, 2019. At that point, VIS is likely
one-man band into a business the company is launching Briefr, “Our group has 360 journalists to be a text-only solution, using
with fourteen full-time members a news-sharing platform for and even more freelancers who semantic recognition to check the
of staff, and venture capital collaborative discussion that’s produce thousands of stories for veracity of different sources and
funding of $1 million. focused on quality and credibility print and the web each day,” says identify the most relevant one. But
instead of likes and popularity. Alvise Zanardi, Project Director as the project progresses, Alvise
“The DNI Fund allowed us to Factmata is also in the process at Caltagirone Editore which and his team are keen to explore
“ The DNI Fund allowed us to work work on this opportunity full
time,” says Dhruv Ghulati, CEO
of launching an open research
initiative that will make its data
“ Our editors wanted to see if we could publishes six newspapers and
their associated websites. “This
how the capabilities of VIS could be
extended to embrace photographs
on this opportunity full time.” and Research Scientist at available to other parties. develop an interface that could help team draws on input from a huge and video by using a mix of facial,
Factmata. “It raised our profile
and gave us credibility. That Over the last two years, Dhruv
journalists check facts in real time range of sources including social
media, the internet, agencies and
image and keyword recognition
technologies.
Dhruv Ghulati enabled us to encourage and his team have gathered an – and which used machine learning other publishers. Fact checking
CEO and Research Scientist at Factmata engineers, developers and
designers to work on the
impressive portfolio of media
coverage and an even more
to become faster and more accurate these sources needs knowledge
and a thorough verification process,
“Looking at the business
opportunities, our digital
project and helped us to build impressive list of backers, over the months and years.” and that takes time and resources. department is already experienced
momentum – which is really including Biz Stone, co-founder Our editors wanted to see if we in selling IT services to the broader
important in start-ups.” of Twitter, as well as the founders could develop an interface that market in Italy. We believe that VIS
of organisations such as Alvise Zanardi could help journalists check facts has great commercial potential to
Broadcast.com, Craigslist, Project Director at Caltagirone Editore in real time – and which used improve quality and cut costs –
Zynga, Mulesoft, Brightmail machine learning to become as machine learning improves the
and Flycast Communications. faster and more accurate over quality of VIS, we’ll be evaluating
the months and years.” how we can best market it.”
14
Quick facts Quick facts
100%
community and ingenuity learning to help journalists
to protect people and verify news sources.
businesses from deceptive full-time members of staff
or misleading content online. Country:
now work for Factmata,
Italy
Country: which started as a team
United Kingdom of one. Fund awarded:
2017
Fund awarded:
2016 Amount awarded:
of journalists at Caltagirone Editore
€350,000
Amount awarded: will use VIS.
€50,000
product/new community, newsletter
/marketplace, video, audio, mobile, n
14 15
Holding power
Local journalists play an “Having the tools to access and into the data, collaborate with the “The Bureau is a constant work in
important role in democratic analyse this data is now critical for local community and scrutinise progress and we’ve received lots
society by holding power to effective reporting,” says Megan the actions of those in power, of interest from other countries
account. However, newsrooms Lucero, Director of The Bureau such as the local council. as well as from regional groups
have fewer resources to dedicate Local. “There are many powerful within the UK, who are all excited
to much-needed investigative public interest stories out there “After our first year, the Bureau by the possibilities of data
to account
reporting. At the same time, the that will only be discovered if community already extends to journalism. We’ve proved our point
digitisation of information has traditional investigative techniques over 650 people across the UK,” – that collaborative journalism can
grown exponentially. In every are combined with technology.” Megan explains. “They come hold power to account. The news
area of life, information that was from all walks of life. As well industry may be in flux, but it’s
previously found on paper now Established in 2017 with support as journalists, they’re lawyers vitally important that good local
exists online – and there’s far from the DNI Fund, the Bureau and teachers, mums and journalism doesn’t disappear.
more of it. Local consists of four skilled grandparents – a cross-section And the people in power had
and experienced data journalists. of people who’ve been affected better recognise that.”
The Bureau Local is a not-for-profit This team does the heavy lifting, by particular issues. We’ve helped
network of journalists and tech opening up the datasets of public this network publish over 170
experts who work together to find bodies and helping The Bureau exclusive local stories – covering
and tell the stories that matter network to navigate and everything from identifying the
to local communities. The interrogate it – to inform the public county councils close to financial
technology they use can unearth on the state of their communities ruin, to exposing the huge
more pieces of information than and to unveil systemic wrong when disparities in how local police
an individual journalist can, and it exists. Even if a journalist has forces protect women
allows journalists to dig deeper, never looked at a dataset or knows from violent partners.”
get stories faster and unravel nothing about Excel, the Bureau
complexity in a way never team can show them how to dig
possible before.
Quick facts
Country:
United Kingdom
Fund awarded:
2016
Amount awarded:
€600,000
170 the number of local stories published
by The Bureau Local network covering
everything from identifying the county
councils close to financial ruin, to
exposing the huge disparities in how
local police forces protect women
from violent partners.
Your local
digest
A man is tripped, a whistle Hyperlocal Listener drills down
blows, a finger points, a penalty into social media and other
is given... communications channels,
keeping us in touch with what
Viewed from a national local people are reading and
perspective, it’s a meaningless posting about. Community
incident in a game of football. Manager then enables us to
But for people living in the local publish the stories we create
communities of Galicia in northern from that information in the most
Spain, knowing the outcome of appropriate media mix – whether
this relegation battle isn’t just that’s in our newspaper, on our
desirable – it’s hugely important. website or through general or
specialist social media groups.
“Although solutions are available So those of our 11 million unique
“ We wanted to explore how new to identify content for major
national and global stories, they
users who want to know the
details about a particular football
technology could help us deliver a don’t work well for journalists match, or any other local news
more relevant local news service.” covering small and hyperlocal
communities,” explains Tomás
items, get the stories they really
need, delivered via their
García Morán, Project Director. favourite channels.”
“We wanted to explore how new
Tomás García Morán technology could help us deliver a The team at La Voz de Galicia
Project Director at La Voz de Galicia more relevant local news service.” aim to roll out the project
to journalists in regional
“Hyperlocal Listener and newsrooms this summer.
Community Manager are
software solutions that sit on the (...they missed the penalty,
smartphones of our reporters. by the way.)
190
Quick facts
La Voz de Galicia
Two projects which enable
journalists to identify and
publish stories that are
most relevant to local
audiences.
Country:
Spain
Fund awarded:
2016
Amount awarded:
€350,000
the number of journalists using the new software
to bring more relevant stories to local communities.
20 21
12 40%
Entrepreneur and Founder of Talk About Local Project Leader at Tagesspiegel LEUTE
Country:
Country:
United Kingdom
2016 2017 2017 Germany
Fund awarded:
Funding awarded. Prototype launched. Open source code 2016
Fund awarded: made available to
2016 Amount awarded:
wider public on GitHub. €550,000
Amount awarded:
€50,000
/new community, newsletter/mail, vo
22 23
Ready,
steady, go
In the midst of an evolving digital “It’s one thing for a journalist to
200
Project impact
landscape, one of the biggest be great at reporting, but another
challenges publishers and entirely for them to master online
journalists face is monetising marketing, recurring payment
their content. issues and membership
management,” adds Philipp.
But there is cause for optimism. “That experience was the
Supported by the DNI Fund, a inspiration behind Steady, because
users including journalists, bloggers,
small start-up in Germany is we realised that there are many
providing journalists with the more ‘Krautreporters’ out there YouTubers and podcasters are now
technology and marketing tools that need some support. Using earning regularly thanks to Steady.
they need to build a membership Steady, publishers can easily earn
base and generate revenue. The monthly payments from their
6
DNI Fund delivered two-thirds of supporters while retaining full
“ Using Steady, publishers can easily the money the team needed to
write the code and take the first
control over their projects,
copyright and content. There’s
earn monthly payments from their steps to market. It also provided no such thing as a typical Steady +
supporters while retaining full the momentum to keep the project
on track. Already, over 200
publisher – they cover a wide
range of topics and while some
control over their projects, copyright journalists and other content of them are one-man-shows
team grew by 6.
and content.” creators, such as YouTubers and
podcasters, are earning a regular
earning just a few hundred Euros
a month, others are teams of up
income thanks to Steady. to 15 people bringing in regular
26,000
five-figure monthly revenues.
Philipp Schwörbel “Our goal is to promote and enable What they all have in common is
Founder and Managing Director at Steady media that is funded by an access to a range of tools from
audience, not by big business, Steady that they can integrate
online ads or influential directly in their websites and
benefactors,” explains Founder blogs to gain memberships.”
and Managing Director Philipp
Schwörbel. “We call it ‘people- The results make impressive users of the platform since project launch.
powered media’, because it is the reading. As well as the 200+
readers or viewers who are the people now earning an income
98%
Quick facts ones that make it financially from their publishing activities,
possible.” the growth of the project has led
Steady to the creation of six new jobs
Steady enables digital Philipp and his business partner at Steady and the receipt of
publishers to monetise have personal experience of how a further €500,000 in funding
their content by building difficult it is for new publishers to from other backers.
a revenue stream from make a living. Even though their
subscriptions. online magazine Krautreporter
of subscribers retained monthly.
was funded by Germany’s most
Country: successful crowdfunding
Germany campaign, it came close to failure.
Fund awarded:
2016
Amount awarded:
€350,000
26 27
Pooling Opening up
resources opportunities
With digital channels accounting use this to create a compelling When 45 Slovakian journalists “We’ve developed new open
for an increasing percentage of proposition for advertisers,” quit their jobs in 2014 to set up a source software that will help
total advertising spend, Portugal’s says Mario Matos, Co-Project rival newspaper, they learnt some more publishers sell online
six largest media owners are Leader at Nonio. hard lessons about turning subscriptions,” explains Tomas
teaming up to pool their online high-quality content into Bella, Head of Online at Dennik N.
resources, put their differences “Already, over 500,000 users have something that would pay the “Firstly, REMP 2 will provide
aside and create a powerful signed up to Nonio. Our target is rent. But they learnt fast and they journalists with more details
consortium of over 70 websites for all four million adults who are learnt well. Within three years, on what readers consider to be
and apps that can reach 85% of touched by our consortium’s Dennik N turned a profit, building quality content that they will be
the country’s 6.5 million monthly publications to register as users.” a subscriber base thanks to a set happy to pay for. It also improves
active internet users. Such an extensive pool of of tools developed in conjunction the way that publishers can
aggregated data segments with a small group of software manage their paying customers.
Supported by the DNI Fund as will give Nonio a viable offer to developers. Finally, REMP 2 aims to predict
well as by €1.3 million worth of present to advertisers and this which readers are most likely
“ We need to work together to create free coverage in its members’
publications, the Nonio
could boost advertising rates. “ We’ve developed new open source Support from the DNI Fund in
2015 enabled the staff of Dennik N
to become subscribers, so
publishers can focus their efforts.”
an advertising marketplace that’s consortium has built a data Mario believes there is room in software that will help more to make these free, open source
safe for brands.” management platform and single
sign-on facility. Users simply log
the market for both technology
companies and independent
publishers sell online subscriptions.” tools available to publishers
through a project known as
The size of the team at Dennik N
has now grown to 60, mostly
in to one of their sites – and they media companies to thrive. REMP (Readers’ Engagement made up of software developers.
will be recognised across all the “We need to work together to and Monetisation Platform). The new, improved version of
Mario Matos other sites operated by the create an advertising marketplace Tomas Bella Now a second tranche of funding REMP was launched in March
Co-Project Leader at Nonio consortium without needing to log that’s safe for brands,” he adds. Head of Online at Dennik N from the DNI Fund is supporting 2018, and featured over 1,000
in multiple times. “This process “This can be a win/win situation.” REMP 2, which aims to improve changes or revisions to the
means we can collect a wide the software to the point where original software.
range of data on our users and it can rival world-leading
e-commerce solutions.
85% 1,000+
Quick facts Quick facts
Nonio REMP
Nonio is a collaboration REMP is a set of open
between Portugal’s top source tools that enables
six media companies that digital publishers to turn
aims to create a compelling users into subscribers.
digital proposition for of the local market has been reached by Nonio.
advertisers. Country:
Slovakia ‘commits’ made to REMP open source tools via GitHub.
500,000 10
Country:
Portugal Fund awarded:
2015 and 2017
Fund awarded:
2017 Amount awarded:
€350,000 and €755,000
Amount awarded:
€900,000
A sporting Weekenders
chance to subscribers
“ What surprised us was that while A new channel is giving one
of France’s leading publishers
issue, La Numérique was in fact
an excellent tool to encourage
In Norway, cabins are a way of
life. Every Friday, thousands of
Espen’s team – which thanks to
the DNI Fund’s support has grown
people were reluctant to pay for more than a sporting chance of people to subscribe to the total city dwellers pack skis, bikes and to include a full-time journalist as
each issue, La Numérique was in monetising its valuable content. L’Equipe offering.” provisions into their cars and
head out to rural cabins for a
well as a project group – initially
considered creating an app before
fact an excellent tool to encourage Selected by the DNI Fund, Since its first editions hit screens couple of days of fun activities. opting for a website because of
people to subscribe to the total La Numérique was originally
conceived as the ideal complement
during the 2016 Rio Olympic
Games, La Numérique has helped
While the doubling of its
population every weekend has
the opportunities to reuse existing
content. Within a few weeks of
L’Equipe offering.” to the L’Equipe morning newspaper drive up the L’Equipe subscriber long supported the economy in launch in March 2018, GDhytte.no
– an evening dose of digital sport base to over 120,000, each of Lillehammer, it’s now also the had already gained 3,350
that readers would pay for on whom is paying €1 for the first inspiration for a digital initiative subscribers, each paying 39
Vincent Briot an issue-by-issue basis. month, and then a €9.99 monthly that is set to transform the Kroner (€5+) per month. The site
Head of Product at L’Equipe fee. La Numérique has 50,000 financial prospects of the town’s also carries paid-for advertising.
But the team at L’Equipe quickly users per day, and almost half of long-established daily magazine.
realised that they had more on
their hands than just a new way for
all L’Equipe subscribers access
La Numérique at least once
“ The funding enabled us to work “We believed that weekend visitors
Espen now has plans to roll out the
concept to other niche audiences
fans to access content. “We knew a month. with a digital consultancy, evaluate were a huge market for both our in the Lillehammer area over the
that people would welcome an
evening sports update, delivered to “Innovation like this requires time
the options available and build existing stories and for content
targeted around their interests and
next six months. “GDFamilie and
GDUtflytter will target families
their mobile devices just when they and resources,” adds Vincent. “La a solution.” needs,” comments Espen Rønning, and young people,” he adds. “Our
were unwinding after the day’s Numérique is constantly evolving Business Developer at parent company Amedia, which
work,” comments Vincent Briot, – it now includes video, for Gudbrandsdølen Dagningen (GD). has 64 titles across Norway, is
Head of Product at L’Equipe. “What example – but it was that initial Espen Rønning “We wanted to discover the best following our progress with great
surprised us was that while people support from the DNI Fund that Business Developer at Gudbrandsdølen Dagningen (GD) way to reach these weekenders, interest so the long-term impact
were reluctant to pay for each gave us the impetus and support and whether they’d subscribe to of GD could be significant.”
we needed at the very beginning.” this sort of content. The DNI Fund
enabled us to work with a digital
consultancy, evaluate the
options available and build
an appropriate solution.”
50,000 3,350
Quick facts Quick facts
La Numérique Gudbrandsdølen
A new paid-for evening Dagningen
digital edition published by GD is a digital magazine
L’Equipe, the leading sports project targeted at niche
publication in France. audiences and generating
La Numérique users revenue through
Country: subscriptions.
France every day. subscribers gained within a few weeks of launch.
Country:
€5+
Fund awarded: Norway
2016
Fund awarded:
Amount awarded: 2017
€210,000
Amount awarded:
€300,000
Charting
growth
Every publisher and journalist already contributing gross annual Project impact
knows the value of charts and revenue of around €100,000 for
wants more of them. Done well, our publisher. We now have the
charts throw light on difficult revenue stream to support
topics – they make stories easy Frames’ continued operation
to read by breaking up oceans of as a standalone business.”
text. The reality is different. Busy
newsrooms don’t always have This is how Frames works...
the tools or skills to create great
charts. And in a world of daily, A dedicated team in the Frames
if not hourly, deadlines, they newsroom continually monitors
50%
often don’t have the time. current events and decides what
charts could best help readers
Frames is a new business make sense of them. If there’s an
“ We now have the revenue stream established by Portugal’s leading
online newspaper with support
earthquake in Mexico, for example,
the team might create a chart
to support Frames’ continued from the DNI Fund. Its mission showing the magnitude of
operation as a standalone is not only to make great charts
simple to incorporate – but to
previous earthquakes. Meanwhile,
a journalist at the publisher writes before Frames, charts featured in very
business.” increase page views and generate up the earthquake story exactly as few articles on observador.pt – but today,
revenue at the same time. usual. Software on the content almost one in two articles include a chart.
Leo Xavier
€100k
Founder, Frames and CTO, Observador
“Together with some financial support from
parent company Observador, support from
the DNI Fund has enabled five people to work
full time on the Frames concept since 2016.”
the amount Frames has contributed
in gross annual revenue for the
“Together with some financial management system analyses
Quick facts
team’s publisher.
support from parent company the story and, as the journalist is
Observador, support from the DNI typing, if there’s a good match the
Frames
5.6%
Fund has enabled five people to software automatically integrates
Frames provides the online work full time on the Frames a relevant chart – in this case, one
publishing industry with concept since 2016,” says Leo about earthquake magnitude
innovative charts that Xavier, the CTO at Observador. "It’s – into the layout. That’s all there is
improve understanding funding that’s already delivering to it. There’s no extra work for the
and generate revenue. benefits. Before we started journalist. And he or she can
Frames, only a small fraction of delete or edit the chart if they
Country: articles on observador.pt used don’t feel it adds to the story. more page views on Observador
Portugal charts. Today, that figure is closer
generated by the charts, as well
to 50%. As well as improving We think that Frames has
Fund awarded: reader understanding of complex applications right across the as improving reader understanding
2016 issues, the charts are generating industry,” Leo adds. “So we’re now of complex issues.
5.6% more page views. Even more in the process of using Observador
Amount awarded: impressively, they’ve created a new as a case study and talking to
€415,000 revenue stream for Observador. publishers in other countries,
Companies such as Vodafone, explaining how Frames can make a
Deloitte and SportTV are now real difference to their newsrooms
sponsoring charts relevant to and their readers – and make
their businesses – and this is money at the same time.”
34 35
Showing
While the personalisation The Buzzard website has already Right now, that’s an extremely “This could be the start of a digital
of content is recognised as built a strong following for curating time-consuming process that marketplace for journalism that
a powerful advantage for articles manually, balancing out requires extensive research via links readers and publishers via
publishers and readers alike, political bias. “Journalism just RSS readers, databases and our online platform, as well as
it can mean that people aren’t needs the power to make itself search engines. However, support an app. Journalism was made
often exposed to a range of better heard in times when from the DNI Fund has enabled by humans to reveal what the
all sides
viewpoints on a particular everyone is screaming for The Buzzard to build the first powerful do and we aim to make
subject. In Leipzig, Germany, attention online,” says CEO Felix prototype of a technological sure that tradition continues.
a team of journalists and web Friedrich, who co-founded The solution that uses an algorithm The potential is huge – our initial
developers are using €50,000 Buzzard with Editor-in-Chief Dario to find different viewpoints up thoughts are that we could be
received from the DNI Fund Nassal. “We’re interested in to 16 times faster than before. achieving revenue of up to
to train a machine-learning showing all sides of the argument “But these are just the first steps,” €100 million in five years.”
algorithm to burst those bubbles. around the biggest debates on our Felix adds. “We plan to launch our
planet, such as climate change, opinion navigator internally at the
global inequality, capitalism, end of May 2018. Then we aim
globalisation and sustainability.” to fully launch it in 2019, rolling
it out across Europe and then
16x
South and North America.”
faster
the speed at which The Buzzard's new
solution can find different viewpoints.
“ Journalism just needs the power
10,000+
to make itself better heard in times
when everyone is screaming for
attention online.”
Felix Friedrich the amount of articles analysed by
Co-Founder and CEO at The Buzzard
The Buzzard every month.
Quick facts
The Buzzard
500
global news websites and blogs
analysed every day.
The team behind
The Buzzard news website
7
is training a machine-
learning algorithm to
include all sides of a debate
and provide users with a
balanced, holistic overview.
Country:
Germany new people have joined the team since the
project began.
Fund awarded:
2017
Amount awarded:
€50,000
36 37
1 in 6
automatically produce text and
Nicolas Becquet graphics. More than 50% of
Project Director at Mediafin Mediafin subscribers are already
fully digital, and the expectation
is that QuoteBot will increase
that still further.
100% 30 mins
opportunities offered automatically producing
by new media. personalised articles and
structured data.
Country:
Italy Country:
Belgium
Fund awarded:
2016 Fund awarded:
2018
Amount awarded:
€315,000 of Il Secolo’s journalists will Amount awarded: time saved per journalist per day by using
take part in the course. €210,000 QuoteBot. This allows them to focus on analysis
and value-added content.
38 39
Council Funded
members organisations
AUSTRIA DENMARK RES PUBLICA L’EQUIPE 24/24
APA-DEFACTO DATENBANK & ALTINGET ROBERT HEINECKE, SASCHA LA NOUVELLE RÉPUBLIQUE DU
CONTENTMANAGEMENT BØRSEN KUNTZE UND JAN RÜBBELKE CENTRE OUEST
DOSSIER DANWATCH RP DIGITAL LE FIGARO
FUTUREZONE INFORMATION SCHLESWIG-HOLSTEINISCHER LE MONDE
KRONE MULTIMEDIA ZEITUNGSVERLAG LE PARISIEN
INTERNATIONAL MEDIA
NIMEH & PARTNERS SUPPORT SCHWÄBISCH MEDIA DIGITAL LE PARISIEN LIBÉRÉ
PROSIEBENSAT.1 PULS 4 KRISTELIGT DAGBLAD SCIENCE MEDIA CENTER LES JOURS
GERMANY
RUSSMEDIA DIGITAL MEDIEHUSET HERNING M6
FOLKEBLAD SPECTRM PUBLISHING
STANDARD MEDIEN MELTYGROUP
USABLE MACHINE SPIEGEL ONLINE
João Palmeiro Veit Dengler Rosalia Lloret Bruno Patino STANDARD
TAZ DIE TAGESZEITUNG
METEO CONSULT
VERLAGSGESELLSCHAFT VIDENSKAB.DK MONDAY NOTE
President of the Executive board member, Head of Institutional Dean of Sciences Po STYRIA CONTENT CREATION ZETLAND TEXTOMATIC
NEXTINTERACTIVE
Portuguese Publishers Bauer Media Group and Public Relations at Journalism School TELEKURIER ONLINE MEDIEN THE BUZZARD
PLAYPLAY
GERMANY VERLAG DER TAGESSPIEGEL
Association, Chair of Online Publishers USERNEWSNET - SOCIAL MEDIA
AELA CALLAN
POOOL
NEWS AGENCY VRAGMENTS
the DNI Fund Association, Europe AKINGO EUROPE
PRISMA MEDIA
WAN-IFRA
BELGIUM RADIO FRANCE
AUGSBURGER ALLGEMEINE WE-BUILD.CITY
DE PERSGROEP THE CONVERSATION FRANCE
BAUHAUS-UNIVERSITÄT WEIMAR WIRTSCHAFTSWOCHE
DE PERSGROEP ADVERTISING USBEK & RICA
BEN SHAW YPSILON.IO
AND MEDIAHUIS CONNECT VOXEUROP
BERLINER MORGENPOST ZE.TT
INMA WEDODATA
BERLINER WOCHENBLATT ZEIT ONLINE
LA PRESSE.BE – ALLIANCE DES WORLDCRUNCH
BRYAN MCLEOD
MÉDIAS D’INFORMATION
CAMPAIGN TRAIL FINLAND
MEDIAFIN GREECE
CORRECTIV AATOS PRODUCTIONS
MEDIAHUIS ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY OF
DANIEL MAYER ALLER MEDIA THESSALONIKI
ROULARTA MEDIA GROUP
DATENFREUNDE ALMA MEDIA ATHENS TECHNOLOGY CENTER
SANOMA MEDIA BELGIUM
DER TAGESSPIEGEL HELSINGIN SANOMAT DEMOKRITOS – NATIONAL
VRT
DIGITAL MEDIA HUB HUMAK UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED CENTER FOR SCIENTIFIC
Madhav Chinnappa Miriam Meckel Arianna Ciccone Anthony Nakache VRT NWS SCIENCES RESEARCH
DPA-INFOCOM
Director of News and Publisher of Founder and Director, Director, Online BULGARIA DUMONT
IIDA TIKKA ENIKOS
IMAKE FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH
Publishers, EMEA WirtschaftsWoche and Perugia International Partnerships Group EMEA, 168 HOURS LTD, PART OF MEDIA EDENSPIEKERMANN
AND TECHNOLOGY HELLAS
GROUP BULGARIA HOLDING LONG PLAY MEDIA
Partnerships, Google Professor for Media and Journalism Festival Google FOLLOWISTIC
LUCIFY LIQUID MEDIA
ECONOMEDIA FRANK WESTPHAL
Communication Management INVESTOR.BG MEDIAKUNTA OSAKUNTA UNIVERSITY OF PIRAEUS
FRANKFURTER ALLGEMEINE RESEARCH CENTER
SHYN ON ZEITUNG PICKS
FUNKE DIGITAL SUOMEN TIETOTOIMISTO (STT)
CROATIA TALENTUM
GOLEM MEDIA
GONG
GRUNER + JAHR
STYRIA MEDIA GROUP FRANCE
HANDELSBLATT
TOMISLAV SIMPOVIC 20 MINUTES
HEADLINE24
AGENCE FRANCE PRESSE
CYPRUS HEILBRONNER STIMME
ATANAS TCHOBANOV
CYPRUS NEWS AGENCY HEISE MEDIEN
BAYARD PRESSE
HMS HAMBURG MEDIA SCHOOL
CZECH REPUBLIC CAMERA LUCIDA PRODUCTIONS
IRIGHTS.LAB
DOUGLAS ARELLANES AND CASUS LUDI
Bartosz Hojka Murdoch MacLennan Torsten Schuppe Bart Brouwers JAKOB VICARI
PETE HAUGHIE CCM BENCHMARK GROUP
JOURNALISM++
Chief Executive Officer, Non-Executive Chairman, VP, Marketing EMEA, Professor in Journalism, ECONOMIA COSAVOSTRA
LIQUID NEWSROOM
GENEEA ANALYTICS EURONEWS
Agora S.A. Independent News Google Groningen University, MEDIEN HOLDING: NORD
JAROSLAV BENC FRONTLINE MEDIA
& Media, IE and owner of Media52 MITTELBAYERISCHER VERLAG
GEN TRAINING & CONSULTING
PROJECT SYNDICATE
MITTELRHEIN-VERLAG
REGIE RADIO MUSIC GROUPE LA DÉPÊCHE DU MIDI
NUZZERA
SOURCEFABRIC GROUPE LES ECHOS
More information can be found online at ONE EIGHTY
TRANSITIONS IJSBERGPRESS
newsinitiative.withgoogle.com/dnifund PAYPEANUTS
40
Funded
organisations
HUNGARY POLIGRAFICI EDITORIALE – NORWAY PLATAFORMA DE MEDIA SPAIN SWEDEN UNITED KINGDOM PRESS ASSOCIATION
ATLATSZO.HU GRUPPO MONRIF AMEDIA PRIVADOS 93 METROS 24 MEDIA NETWORK AL JAZEERA INTERNATIONAL PROJECT FOR STUDY OF THE
CENTER FOR MEDIA, DATA AND RADIO RADICALE, CENTRO DI AMEDIA UTVIKLING PÚBLICO ACTIVIDADES DIGITAL MEDIA BAMBUSER ARCHANT 21ST CENTURY
SOCIETY AT THE CENTRAL PRODUZIONE PÚBLICO – COMUNICAÇÃO SERELAY
APTOMA COLECTIVO 5W DAGENS INDUSTRI ASSOCIATED PRESS TELEVISION
EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY, RCS MEDIAGROUP SOCIAL NEWS SNAPPD
BAKKEN & BÆCK CORPORACION PUBLICITARIA DE EXPRESSEN
BUDAPEST HUNGARY RCS MEDIAGROUP – DIREZIONE RICARDO LAFUENTE
DAGBLADET MEDIOS DIGITALES JOURNALISM ROBOTICS BELLINGCAT SOUTH WEST NEWS SERVICE
DAVID KORANYI MEDIA SEDE LEGALE UNIVERSITY OF PORTO
DB MEDIALAB CUONDA STOCKHOLM BELOW THE RADAR STUART GOULDEN
FÜGGETLEN ÚJSÁGÍRÓK SOCIETÀ ATHESIS VISAPRESS
FRONT KOMMUNIKASJON DATADISTA MITTMEDIA BISTROMATHICS TALK ABOUT LOCAL
ALAPÍTVÁNYA TORLONE GIANFRANCO
GUDBRANDSDØLEN DAGNINGEN DIARIO LA GRADA EDICIONES NEWSREPS CAERPHILLY MEDIA TAPEWRITE
INDEX.HU VISUP EX ROMANIA
MEDIACONNECT EDITORIAL ECOPRENSA STADSPORTEN CITYGATE CITY, UNIVERSITY OF LONDON TELEGRAPH MEDIA GROUP
K-MONITOR ASSOCIATION VIZ&CHIPS ENTREPRENEURSHIP
MEDIEHUSET NETTAVISEN EL CONFIDENCIAL / TITANIA SYDSVENSKA DAGBLADETS COUNTERPOINTING UK THE BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIVE
MAGYAR JETI BLUE INSIGHT
COMPAÑÍA EDITORIAL COVENTRY UNIVERSITY JOURNALISM
MERTEK MEDIAELEMZO MUHELY LATVIA MUML HILDE GUDVANGEN CENTRUL ROMAN PENTRU
EL LEÓN DE EL ESPAÑOL SWITZERLAND THE FERRET MEDIA
ADEVO NORSK TELEGRAMBYRÅ (NTB) JURNALISM DE INVESTIGATIE DENNIS PUBLISHING
RUSSMEDIA AZ MANAGEMENT SERVICES
ELDIARIO.ES EXPLAAIN THE IRISH NEWS
SZAZAD MEDIA THE BALTIC CENTER FOR PUBLISH LAB CONVERGENT MEDIA
EUROPA PRESS COMUNICACION AZ MEDIEN THE TIMES AND THE SUNDAY
INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM SOCIUS JOURNALISM DEVELOPMENT FACTMATA
TRANSPARENCY BLASTING SAGL TIMES
RE:BALTICA NETWORK (ORGANIZED CRIME GRUPO HERALDO FINANCIAL TIMES
INTERNATIONAL HUNGARY TEKNISK UKEBLAD MEDIA
RENARS LIEPINS AND CORRUPTION REPORTING HENNEO FIXXPUNKT THE WORLD WEEKLY MEDIA
FULL FACT
IRELAND SULTAN SULEIMANOV POLAND PROJECT) LA VOZ DE GALICIA LE TEMPS THOMSON REUTERS
GLITCH DIGITAL
CONOR MOLUMBY 302POLITYKA MEDIA BIT SOFTWARE MINUSHU NEUE ZÜRCHER ZEITUNG TOMAS PETRICEK
IMMERSIVEIP
LITHUANIA RINGIER ROMANIA SCITEC-MEDIA TRINITY MIRROR (REACH)
ERNESTO DIAZ-AVILES AGORA POLITIBOT INNOVACIÓN INTERNATIONAL PRESS
360 LAIPSNIU FILMAI RISE PROJECT / PAUL-CRISTIAN TAGESWOCHE TRINT LTD
INDEPENDENT NEWS & MEDIA E-KIOSK PRISA TELECOMMUNICATIONS
DELFI ASSOCIATION FOR SOCIAL RISE TAMEDIA COUNCIL TRUE 212
INVESTIGATIONS UNIT – RADIO EUROZET PRODIGIOSO VOLCÁN
EESTI MEEDIA PROJECT / PAUL-CRISTIAN RADU
TEILIFIS EIREANN FRATRIA PÚBLICO.ES JAMES DURSTON TURI MUNTHE
ŠIAULIAI PLIUS WEBCRUMBZ
THE IRISH TIMES FUNDACJA EPAŃSTWO QUALITY MEDIA PRODUCCIONES JOHNSTON PRESS UK CITIZENS ONLINE
ZA CLOUD DEMOCRACY (MYSOCIETY)
NEWSLINN LUXEMBOURG GLOB360 SIMA APPLIED TECHNOLOGIES KALEIDA NETWORKS
STEVE DEMPSEY GREMI MEDIA KENDRA FOUNDATION UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL
SAINT-PAUL LUXEMBOURG SLOVAKIA SPAIN MEDIA MAGAZINE
LANCASHIRE (UCLAN)
GRUPA RMF ĽUBOMÍR ŠULKO, JANA THINKSIZE MAGNUM PHOTOS
ITALY NETHERLANDS VERIFEYE MEDIA
GRUPA ZPR MEDIA TUTKOVÁ, VERONIKA ŠOLTINSKÁ UNIDAD EDITORIAL METAGENI
AGI AGENZIA GIORNALSITICA ADRIANA HOMOLOVA VIVARTA
PMPG POLSKIE MEDIA N PRESS MGN
ITALIA WIKITRIBUNE
ALGEMEEN NEDERLANDS POLITYKA PETIT PRESS ORION TECHNOLOGIES
ALICE CORONA PERSBUREAU
CARLO STRAPPARAVA POLSKA PRESS
BLENDLE SLOVENIA
CATCHY STOWARZYSZENIE GAZET
BUSINESS NIEUWS HOLDING DANES JE NOV DAN, INŠTITUT
LOKALNYCH
CED DIGITAL & SERVIZI BUTCH & SUNDANCE MEDIA ZA DRUGA VPRAŠANJA
TVN
CEFRIEL CARTOON MOVEMENT E.B.S.I.-EVROPSKI INŠTITUT ZA
WEBNALIST VEDENJSKE ŠTUDIJE
CORRIERE DELLA SERA, PART OF COÖPERATIE HOUSE OF
RCS MEDIAGROUP WIRTUALNA POLSKA MEDIA EVENT REGISTRY
JOURNALISM
ELEMEDIA DUIC & DIG MILVUM PORTUGAL FINSPECTOR / NEOLAB
GEDI GRUPPO EDITORIALE FOLLOW THE MONEY ALBERTO PEREIRA HONIRE, INOVATIVNE
IL SOLE 24ORE INFORMACIJSKE TEHNOLOGIJE
HET FINANCIEELE DAGBLAD COFINA MEDIA
INVESTIGATIVE REPORTING KATALYSIS EMPRESA JORNALÍSTICA
PROJECT ITALY REGIÃO DE LEIRIA
NRC MEDIA
ITEDI/IL SECOLO XIX GLOBAL NOTÍCIAS
NWZER
ITEDI/LA STAMPA GLOBAL NOTÍCIAS PUBLICAÇÕES
OPEN STATE FOUNDATION
LA STAMPA IMPRESA
PUBLICISM
LITTLESEA IMPRESA PUBLISHING
REBLR
MEDIA VOX POP INESC TEC
STICHTING FREE PRESS
MITECUBE UNLIMITED JOÃO ANTUNES
MONDADORI SCIENZA STICHTING GLOBAL VOICES LUSA – AGÊNCIA DE NOTÍCIAS DE
NEWS3.0 STICHTING LOKALE PORTUGAL
ONDATA ONDERZOEKSJOURNALISTIEK MOURA & VILHENA
VPRO OBSERVADOR ONTIME
Digital News Innovation Fund