Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3391
Abstract
Living environment, and especially dwellings, affect directly and indirectly health in several ways end
represent one of the key social determinants of health. The relationship between health and housing has
long been recognized and, in the last decades, researchers developed several conceptual models to put in
relation the numerous housing factors able to impact on inhabitants’ health. For some authors, factors linked
to housing and neighborhood conditions that influence health, can be grouped into four broad categories:
first considers the health impacts of not having a stable home (residential instability); second, the financial
burdens resulting from high-cost housing (affordability); third, the health impacts of conditions inside the
home (the housing’ safety and quality); lastly, the health impacts of neighborhoods, including both the
environmental and social characteristics of where people live (neighborhood). It is evident that the theme
of “housing and health” nowadays needs to be assessed with a multidisciplinary approach, because of the
complexity and wideness of its components. Moreover it is today clear that to guarantee good health stan-
dards it is indispensable to direct political and administrative choices to improve the overall conditions of
the neighborhood and of the buildings, and, At the same time, to dispose of a clear and updated regulatory
system, since key factor to ensure Public Health protection and social justice.
Department of Civil Building and Environmental Engineering, Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
1
18 D. D’Alessandro et al.
of communicable disease and illness has For these reasons in the last decades rese-
grown, so has the awareness of the impor- archers developed several conceptual models
tance of dwelling quality to physical and to put in relation the numerous housing
mental wellbeing, as recently reaffirmed factors able to impact on inhabitants’ health
in the WHO’ guidelines (5) and has been (2, 10-13). Starting from the UN declaration
sadly documented by the recent COVID-19 of ‘90 - who considered housing as a basic
pandemic (6). human right, in terms of legal security of
During last century, the fall in mortality house’s tenure; availability of services,
for communicable diseases and the excep- facilities, infrastructure; affordability; ha-
tional life prolongation explain why chronic bitability; accessibility; cultural adequacy,
diseases became the predominant cause of etc. - the relationship between “housing &
death. Built environment and housing in health” moved from a vision centered on
particular, considering the duration of perma- physical-biological-chemical factors, typical
nence of residents, assume a central role in of classic hygiene, to a multidisciplinary
terms of source of indoor pollutants, mainly vision aimed to include also other health
in degraded housing where generally live determinants. In fact, it is known that much
economically disadvantaged people. In 2011 research has shown the close relationship
WHO estimated – per 100,000 population between social, economic, political factors
–13 deaths due to low indoor temperatures, 7 and housing wellbeing.
deaths due to Environmental Tobacco Smoke Although some basic models continue to
(ETS), and 2-3 deaths due to radon per year be valid, with the knowledge advances the
in the world. The use of solid fuels as a hou- models’ structure often has required to be
sehold energy source is responsible for 17 de- integrated or modified, amplifying its com-
aths and causes 577 Disability-Adjusted Life plexity. In fact, causal pathways are often
Years (DALY) per year per 100,000 children two-way and complex in their operation or
under the age of five. Mould in homes leads connected with the negative health impacts
to the loss of 40 DALY per 100,000 children of poverty or other external factors, so there
each year, while traffic noise exposure and is still a need to clarify some aspects of these
lack of home safety features cause an annual relationship to define the real association
loss of 31 and 22 DALY per 100,000 popu- level with housing (14).
lation, respectively (7). Coming back to the models, for some
A key point to consider is the large chan- Authors (11, 12), factors linked to housing
ge in health problems during time. Today and neighborhood conditions that influence
health can mean different things to different health, can be grouped into three broad cate-
people. One of the most pertinent definitions gories: area characteristics, internal housing
of health is that from the 1948 Constitution conditions and housing tenure; all of these
of the World Health Organization (8). This factors have been shown to have independent
statement is the evidence that 70 years ago, effects on health (2). More recently, Taylor
public health moved progressively away (10), based on new evidence, modified and
from the medical model - focused on the integrated these categories (called path-
individual and on interventions targeted to ways). In particular, she identified four of
treat disease - back towards a social model, them: first considered the health impacts of
considering health as an outcome of the not having a stable home (residential insta-
effects of socioeconomic status, culture, bility); second, the financial burden resulting
environmental conditions, employment, from high-cost housing (affordability); third,
community influences, but also housing the health impacts of conditions inside the
condition in a broad term (8, 9). home (the housing’s safety and quality);
Housing and health 19
lastly, the health impacts of neighborhoods, poorer self-rated health, health care ac-
including both the environmental and the cess, and mental health outcomes (15-17).
social characteristics of where people live Children and adolescents are particularly
(neighborhood). Figure 1 show the factors vulnerable from impacts of residential in-
connecting housing and health. The arrows’ stability. This condition has been related to
thickness indicates the level of evidence of children poorer overall health, developmen-
health impact. tal and behavioral problems, lower school
Regarding stability, it encompasses readiness and educational outcomes (15, 18,
residents’ capacity to willingly remain in 19). In the context of climate change also,
their homes free from harassment or dispos- natural disasters are increasingly a major
session. Scientific literature shows lots of threat for displacement, as they can instan-
evidence regarding its influence on health tly damage and destroy massive amounts
(15, 31). While individuals may move vo- of housing, causing significant increases of
luntarily for many reasons (e.g., for a new health consequences (20, 21).
job or a larger home, for fear of crime), there Affordability refers to the opportunity to
are a number of conditions that involuntary get affordable housing options. Affordability
moves (displacement) could occur, including can affect families’ ability to make other
inability to afford rising rents or mortgage essential expenses and can create serious
payments, eviction or foreclosure, natural financial strains. Living in an unafforda-
disasters, and government policies (15). ble housing is related to poorer self-rated
Housing instability is associated with a wide health, hypertension, arthritis, and mental
range of adverse health outcomes, including health (15, 22). Low-income families with
Figure 1 – Factor connecting housing and health (from Taylor 2018, modified)
20 D. D’Alessandro et al.
difficulty paying their rent or mortgage or several chronic diseases and cancer (5, 7).
their utility bills are less likely to have a Substandard housing conditions due to water
usual source of medical care and are more leaks, poor ventilation, dirty carpets, and
likely to postpone needed treatment than pest infestation have been associated with
those who enjoy more-affordable housing poor health outcomes, most notably those
(10). Additionally, unaffordability impacts related to allergic sensitization and asthma
health indirectly by draining financial re- (3, 5, 7, 31, 33). Most of these problems
sources that could otherwise be used for show highest prevalence in the homes of
health-related expenses such as food (15, disadvantaged people, because they often
23) and child development resources (24). A live in damaged housing (15, 31, 34).
common coping strategy among low-income Additionally, exposure to high or low
people to reduce high rent burdens is to temperatures is correlated with adverse he-
share housing with someone else, frequently alth events, including cardiovascular events,
leading to overcrowding (15). Despite the particularly among the elderly. Residential
financial advantages, overcrowding is asso- crowding has also been linked to both phy-
ciated with adverse health effects, including sical illness (for example, infectious disease)
mental health outcomes (5, 25) infectious and psychological distress (5).
diseases (e.g. tuberculosis) (5, 7), behavio- Regarding these factors, a large number of
ral issues such as hostility (26) and scarce interventional studies, including randomized
children’s educational outcomes, due to the controlled trials (RCT), demonstrate the he-
impossibility to satisfy their need for quiet alth’s improvements related to a positive va-
space to concentrate on schoolwork (27-29). riation of housing quality and safety (10, 15,
However, the affordability issue shows some 31). Studies in which asthma triggers are re-
aspects needing other studies, in order to moved have repeatedly demonstrated health
understand how people set priorities among improvements and cost reductions among
basic needs and make decisions in conditions both children and adults. Interventions that
of scarcity. improve thermal comfort (e.g., insulating)
Internal housing conditions refer to the significantly improve physical and mental
numerous physical characteristics of housing health and have been robustly examined in
correlated with poor health. Immigrants and the literature (35-37).
marginalized populations are at higher risk, Injuries in the home is an important he-
since they are more likely to live in deterio- alth burden worldwide too (35-37). Injuries
rate housing stock, outdated infrastructure, in the home include falls, burns, poisonings,
and lack of maintenance; such exposures are ingestion of foreign objects, smoke inha-
often exacerbated by unequal power dynami- lation, drowning, cuts and collisions with
cs between landlords and tenants (10, 15, 30, objects, and crushing and fractured bones
31). Frequently they live in semibasements as a result of structural collapse. Based
or garrets, with insufficient heating, lighting on available evidence, WHO (5) suggests
and spaces and other several environmental housing to be equipped with safety devi-
problems (31, 32). ces (such as smoke and carbon monoxide
In-home exposure to chemical pollutants alarms, stair gates and window guards) and
(e.g. lead, volatile organic compounds - to take measure to reduce hazards that lead
VOCs, combustion pollutants, etc.), induces to unintentional injuries.
several effects: from airways and mucous Several evidences of the risks associated
membrane irritation (e.g. by VOCs), to ir- with housing deficits and the potential health
reversibly damages the brains and nervous gains of providing housing or improving
systems of children (e.g. lead), but also conditions inside the home are available,
Housing and health 21
although many of the studied interventions hand, the widespread city, with a low density,
targeted health impacts more frequently than defined in relation to health as Obesogenic
cost impacts for health systems, payers, or Urban Form (40), is generally characterized
society. More integrated research projects, by residential areas, commercial and offices
aimed to carry-out cost-benefits analysis far from one another, which requires daily
of housing interventions, could add useful travel, mostly by private transportation, re-
information for the decision makers. As ducing active mobility, with the potential to
Taylor argued (10), these evaluations should increase several environmental pollutants.
consider costs related to social services and In terms of health impacts, WHO reco-
the criminal justice system also. gnizes the influence that adequate living
The potential of “area characteristics conditions have on public health (41). Air
(context)” on health is a something reco- quality, noise, water supply, management
gnized from long time, with an increasing and collection of municipal solid waste,
evidence in the last few years. The context transportation, green and blue areas, etc.
includes a broad set of structural, cultural represent features of the built environment
and functional aspects of the physical and directly and indirectly impact on citizens’
social environment whose impact on the health (42, 43). If well managed these factors
health of individuals is difficult to quantify contribute to fight climate changes (44), and
as a whole, but which, nevertheless, exerts their consequences, like natural disasters.
a powerful influence on how a society di- Adequate living conditions thus necessi-
stributes resources among its members and tate healthy environments and promoters
consequently on the health opportunities of of active lifestyles (45). At the same time,
the population. in order to reach sustainable development
The relevant aspects of the “context” goals (SDGs) for 2030, a strong synergy
can be summarized in the following main among local governance and community is
elements: physical characteristics of area, required.
culture and social values, but also governan- Inequalities across and within cities
ce, social and economic policies. In order to are one aspect of social injustice in health
better understand the relationship between (46-48). Those that are consequences of
living environment, human behavior and he- environmental inequalities are part of the
alth, it is necessary to underline the comple- so-called environmental justice domain (47).
xity and the interactivity of the relationship Environmental hazards (e.g., waste proces-
between context and individual. sing facilities) are mainly located in periphe-
Frequently, in the scientific literature, ral areas, where generally live low-income
the compact city with high density has been communities. In these context it is easy to
considered facilitating healthier choices, at find urban voids, abandoned buildings and
least in terms of attitude toward physical degraded lots, all conditions related to segre-
activity, than urban forms characterized by gation and to an increased risk of violent as-
scattered settlements and low residential sault (42, 49). Neighborhood segregation is
density; in fact, the presence of a land-use also related to health disparities by determi-
mix, the frequent road intersections between ning access to schools, jobs, and health care;
residential and commercial areas, etc., fa- influencing health behaviors; and increasing
cilitate direct pedestrian paths between the crime (15, 50). In particular, fear of crime is
various destinations (38, 39). At the same one of the most significant social problems
time, density can increase air pollution, heat in cities, negatively influencing people’s
island and noise, if neighborhoods are not habits and lifestyle (51). In general, this
well projected and managed. On the other type of urban insecurity is related to other
22 D. D’Alessandro et al.
which has undoubtedly had the merit of ha- È evidente che il tema “casa e salute” oggi necessita
ving reduced the impact of the disease, has di essere valutato con un approccio multidisciplinare,
per la complessità e l’ampiezza delle sue componenti.
brought to everybody’s attention the housing Inoltre, è oggi chiaro che per garantire buoni standard
crisis of the whole country (6). Indeed, the sanitari è indispensabile indirizzare scelte politiche ed
consequences of the pandemic, and the immi- amministrative per migliorare le condizioni generali del
nent risk of its repetition, highlight the need quartiere e degli edifici, e, al contempo, disporre di un
to apply a new concept of health, in terms of sistema normativo chiaro e aggiornato, poiché fattore
indoor well-being, to housing policy. Some chiave per garantire la protezione della salute pubblica
e la giustizia sociale.
dwelling’ characteristics, like the availability
of visible and accessible green elements and
spaces, the housing spaces flexibility and the Funding: CCM 2015 Project “Identification of best
implementation of wifi systems and automa- practices and health performance objectives, in terms
tion, need for more research in tems of health of sustainability and eco-compatibility in the buil-
impact, feasibility and safety. dings’ construction and renovation actions, aimed to
Health care sector, businesses, commu- draft the further building hygiene codes”. Codex CUP:
B86D15001870001
nity-based organizations, and government
each of them have a unique roles to play in
improving housing conditions. In fact, to References
face up to complex issues like this, whose
1. United Nations. 1991. The Right to Adequate
causes lie beyond the traditional remit of Housing. Fact Sheet n. 21/Rev. 1. Available on:
the health sector, it is necessary to share https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/
knowledge from many sectors (9, 59, 60). FS21_rev_1_Housing_en.pdf (Last accessed:
Therefore, collaborative activities involving 2020, Oct 7).
professionals trained in different cultural 2. Shaw M. Housing and public health. Annu Rev
areas need to be further implemented in the Public Health 2004; 25: 397-418. doi: 10.1146/
next future (9). annurev.publhealth.25.101802.123036.
3. Ranson R. Healthy Housing. A practical guide.
E&FN SPON e WHO Europe, London, 2005.
Riassunto 4. D’Alessandro D, Appolloni L, Capasso L. Public
health and urban planning: a powerful alliance to
Abitazioni e salute: una panoramica be enhanced in Italy. Ann Ig 2017; 29(5): 453-63.
doi:10.7416/ai.2017:2177.
L’ambiente di vita, e in particolare le abitazioni, 5. World Health Organization (WHO). Housing
influenzano direttamente e indirettamente la salute in and health guidelines. Geneva: WHO, 2018.
diversi modi e rappresentano uno dei determinanti sociali Available on: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/
chiave della salute. Il rapporto tra salute e abitazione è handle/10665/ 276001/9789241550376-eng.pdf
da tempo riconosciuto e negli ultimi decenni i ricercatori (Last accessed: 2020, Oct 7).
hanno sviluppato diversi modelli concettuali per met- 6. D’Alessandro D, Gola M, Appolloni L, et al.
tere in relazione i numerosi fattori abitativi in grado di COVID-19 and living space challenge. Well-
impattare sulla salute degli abitanti. Per alcuni autori, i being and public health recommendations for
fattori legati alle condizioni abitative e di vicinato che a healthy, safe, and sustainable housing. Acta
influenzano la salute, possono essere raggruppati in quat- Biomed 2020; 91(9-S): 61-75. https://doi.
tro grandi categorie: in primo luogo considera gli impatti org/10.23750/abm.v91i9-S.10115.
sulla salute del non avere una casa stabile (instabilità
7. Braubach M, Jacobs DE, Ormandy D. Envi-
residenziale); secondo, gli oneri finanziari derivanti da
ronmental Burden of Disease Associated with
alloggi ad alto costo (accessibilità economica); terzo, gli
Inadequate Housing: A Method Guide to the
impatti sulla salute delle condizioni all’interno della casa
(sicurezza e qualità degli alloggi); infine, gli impatti sulla Quantification of Health Effects of Selected
salute dei quartieri, comprese le caratteristiche ambientali Housing Risks in the WHO European Region.
e sociali del luogo in cui le persone vivono (quartiere). WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2011. Avai-
24 D. D’Alessandro et al.
used as dwellings: hygienic considerations and Healthy design and urban planning strategies,
analysis of the regulations. Ann Ig 2014; 26(1): action and policy to chieve salutogenic cities.
3-9. doi: 10.7416/ai.2014.19553. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018; 15(12):
33. Do DC, Zhao Y, Gao P. Cockroach allergen ex- 2698. doi: 10.3390/ijerph15122698.
posure and risk of asthma. Allergy 2016; 71(4): 43. D’Alessandro D, Buffoli M, Capasso L, et al.
463-74. 10.1111/all.12827. Green areas and public health: improving well-
34. Peters JL, Levy JI, Rogers CA, Burge HA, being and physical activity in the urban context.
Spengler JD, 2007 Determinants of allergen con- Epidemiol Prev 2015; 39(4 Suppl 1): 8-13.
centrations in apartments of asthmatic children 44. World Health Organization (WHO). International
living in public housing. J Urban Health 2007; Workshop on Housing, Health and Climate Chan-
84(2): 185-97. 10.1007/s11524-006-9146-2. ge. Developing Guidance for Health Protection in
35. Liddell C, Guiney C. Living in a cold and damp the Built Environment Mitigation and Adaptation
home: frameworks for understanding impacts on Responses. Geneva, 13-15 October 2010. Mee-
mental well-being. Public Health 2015; 129(3): ting report. New York (NY): WHO, 2010.
191-9. 10.1016/j.puhe.2014.11.007. 45. McMichael AJ. The urban environment and
36. Thomson H, Thomas S, Sellstrom E, Petticrew health in a world of increasing globalization:
M. Housing improvements for health and as- Issues for developing countries. Bull World
sociated socio-economic outcomes. Cochrane Health Organ 2000; 78(9): 1117-26.
Database Syst Rev 2013; (2): CD008657. doi: 46. World Health Organization (WHO). Addressing
10.1002/14651858.CD008657.pub2. the social determinants of health: The urban
37. Howden-Chapman P, Matheson A, Crane J, et dimension and the role of local government.
al. Effect of insulating existing houses on health WHO, 2012. ISBN 9789289002691. Avai-
inequality: cluster randomised study in the com- lable on: https://www.euro.who.int/__data/
munity. BMJ 2007; 334(7607): 0. doi:10.1136/ assets/pdf_file/0005/166136/UrbanDimensions.
bmj.39070.573032.80. pdf?ua=1&gathStatIcon=true (Last accessed:
38. Swinburn BA, Sacks, G, Hall KD, et al. The 2020, Oct 7).
global obesity pandemic: shaped by global 47. World Health Organization (WHO). Environmen-
drivers and local environments. Lancet 2011; tal Health Inequalities in Europe. Assessment
378(9793): 804-14. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736- report. WHO, 2012. ISBN 9789289002608.
(11)60813-1. Available on: https://www.euro.who.int/__data/
39. D’Alessandro D, Assenso M, Appolloni L, assets/pdf_file/0010/157969/e96194.pdf (Last
Cappuccitti A. The Walking Suitability Index accessed: 2020, Oct 7).
of the Territory (T- WSI): A new tool to eva- 48. Maas R, M, Espnes GA. The application of sa-
luate urban neighborhood walkability. Ann Ig lutogenesis in Cities and Towns. In: Mittelmark
2015; 27(4): 678-87. https://doi.org/10.7416/ MB, Sagy S, Eriksson M, et al., eds. The Hand-
ai.2015.2059. book of salutogenesis. Cham (CH): Springer,
40. Takano T, Nakamura K, Watanabe M. Urban 2017. Chapter 18.
residential environments and senior citizens’ 49. Branas CC, South E, Kondo MC, et al. Citywide
longevity in megacity areas: the importance of cluster randomized trial to restore blighted va-
walkable green spaces. J Epidemiol Commu- cant land and its effects on violence, crime, and
nity Health 2002; 56(12): 913-8. doi: 10.1136/ fear. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2018; 115(12):
jech.56.12.913. 2946-51. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1718503115.
41. World Health Organization (WHO). Health as 50. Iorio S, Salvatori LM, Barnocchi A, et al. Social
the Pulse of the New Urban Agenda: United inequalities in the metropolitan area of Rome.
Nations conference on housing and sustainable A multidisciplinary analysis of the urban seg-
urban development. Quito, October 2016. WHO, regation of the “formerly-Bastogi” compound.
2016. Available on: http://apps.who.int/iris/ Ann Ig 2019; 31(2): 211-29. doi: 10.7416/
bitstream/handle/10665/250367/978924151144 ai.2019.2284.
5-eng.pdf;jsessionid= 07F882D99F1E1AF399B 51. Valera S, Guàrdia J. Perceived insecurity and fear
57D5546EEB2BB?sequence=1 (Last accessed: of crime in a city with low-crime rates. J Envi-
2020, Oct 7). ron Psychol 2014; 38: 195-205. doi: 10.1016/j.
42. Capolongo S, Rebecchi A, Dettori M, et al. jenvp.2014.02.002.
26 D. D’Alessandro et al.
52. Krieger J, Higgins DL. Housing and health: 57. Capasso A, Faggioli A, Rebecchi A, et al.
Time and again for public health action. Am Aspetti igienico-sanitari in ambito urbanistico:
Public Health 2002; 92(5): 758-68. doi: 10.2105/ Conflittualità nelle norme urbanistiche nazionali
ajph.92.5.758. e locali in tema di sanità pubblica. Epidemiol
53. Lawrence RJ. Constancy and change: key issues Prev 2018; 42(1): 60-4. https://doi.org/10.19191/
in housing and health research, 1987-2017. Int J EP18.1.P060.016.
Environ Res Public Health 2017; 14(7): 763-9. 58. Popov VI, Capasso L, Klepikov OV, Appolloni
doi: 10.3390/ijerph14070763. L, D’Alessandro D. Hygienic Requirements of
54. Settimo G, D’Alessandro D. (European com- Urban Living Environment in the Russian Fed-
munity guidelines and standards in indoor air eration and in Italy: a comparison. Ann Ig 2018;
quality: what proposals for Italy). Epidemiol 30(5): 421-30. doi: 10.7416/ai.2018.2242.
Prev 2014; 38(6 Suppl 2): 36-41. 59. Capolongo S, Rebecchi A, Buffoli M, et al.
55. Capasso L, Gaeta M, Appolloni L, D’Alessandro COVID-19 and cities: from urban health strate-
D. Health inequalities and inadequate housing: gies to the pandemic challenge. A decalogue of
the case of exceptions to hygienic requirements public health opportunities. Acta Biomed 2020;
for dwellings in Italy. Ann Ig 2017; 29(4): 323- 91(2): 13-22. https://doi.org/10.23750/abm.
31. https://doi.org/10.7416/ai.2017.2159. v91i2.9615.
56. Capasso L, Capolongo S, Faggioli A, Petronio 60. Appolloni L, Corazza MV, D’Alessandro D. The
MG, D’Alessandro D. Do Italian housing pleasure of walking: An innovative methodology
regulations and policies protect poor people’s to assess appropriate walkable performance
health? Ann Ig 2015; 27(4): 688-9. https://doi. in urban areas to support transport planning.
org/10.7416/ai.2015.2060. Sustainability 2019; 11(12) 3467. doi: 10.3390/
su11123467
Corresponding author: Prof. Daniela D’Alessandro, Department of Civil Building Environmental Engineering, Sa-
pienza University of Rome, Via Eudossiana, 18, 00186 Rome, Italy
e-mail: daniela.dalessandro@uniroma1.it