Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SOCIO-CULTURAL AWAKENING
Progress of Education:
Although Odisha had been under British Administration
since 1803, the education in Odisha was more backward than
any other province in India of equal importance by 1866.
There were in 1866 in all 77 schools of all grades and the
number of pupils was 3,536.
Page | 6
The extremely backward state of education was mainly
due to the indifference of Company’s Government. There was
total absence of any attempt on the part of the Government to
provide the people with the means of education, even though
vast sums were annually expended in other parts of Bengal.
On the negligence of the Government to develop education,
Dr. E. Roer, the Inspector of Schools, South-West Division,
said: “It is to be regretted that no new educational operations
can be carried out, for Odisha is at a disadvantage, compared
with other districts. For the whole of Odisha, with an area of
52,995 square miles and a population of 4,534,813 souls, less
is expended than for the small district of Howrah, with an area
of 800 square miles, and a population of 7,50,000 souls…….
”1
Page | 7
case in any district of Bengal proper, and in carrying out
remedial measures.” Government was well aware of the risk
of a general want of enlightenment of the people. After the
famine, a policy of progress was adopted for the material and
moral improvement of the people of Odisha. Measures were
adopted for the spread of modern education in Odisha.
Page | 8
system aimed at quantity, not quality. With a view to
improving elementary schools, it was decided to adopt the so
called Midnapur system in place of system of monthly grant.
It was also called the system of payment by result. When the
aid was given, not in the form of monthly stipends, but as a
distinct reward of success, coming once a year, the teachers
would have much more desire to take interest in the affairs of
the schools and pupils.
Page | 9
In November 1895, the third grade training schools at
Puri and Balasore were abolished. The Guru Training Classes
attached to middle schools were closed in 1897. Henceforth,
the first grade training school at Cuttack served the needs of
the upper classes of primary schools and lower classes of
secondary schools. The four Guru Training Schools including
once attached to the First Grade Training School at Cuttack
were mainly the institutions to supply trained teachers to the
primary schools of Odisha”.
Page | 10
hardly better in 1905 than in 1866. As many as 97% of the
Odias were illiterate.
Page | 11
disadvantages. They had no place in the lower services of
British bureaucratic machinery. People from outside Odisha
monopolized all kinds of services. Without English education,
the people of Odisha had little contact with outside provinces.
In view of many such drawbacks, the introduction of higher
western education resulted in a gradual transformation of the
mental horizon of people. In course of time, as everywhere in
India, there developed a political consciousness based on
western ideas. The leading minds of Odisha Bengal to think of
social changes in the wake of western education. The
influence of English literature on modern Odia literature
became clearly perceptible towards the later years of 19 th
century. Three eminent writers, namely, Fakir Mohan
Senapati (1843-1918), Radhanath Ray (1848-1908) and
Madhu Sudan Roy (1858-1912), who are considered pioneers
of modern consciousness in Odisha, revealed in their literature
the profound influence of western ideas on their thought. The
rise of modern journalism towards the later part of the 19 th
century, the publication of a number of periodicals and
newspapers, and the new literate trends were the indirect
outcome of the spread of English education. In brief, the
Page | 12
foundation of modern Odisha is to be traced back to the first
half of the Crown’s rule.
Page | 13
Odisha was the middle vernacular scholarship standard. The
slow progress of female education was mainly due to the lack
of required Government aid, and conservatism of the people.
Page | 14
On the whole, it can be said that, the state of education in
Odisha in 1905 was not satisfactory both from the quantitative
and qualitative points of view. This was mainly because of the
fact that, Government tried, half-heartedly and hesitatingly to
educate the people of Odisha after 1866.2
Page | 15
gradual unfolding of an educational system covering different
sections of people.
Page | 16
Consequent developments were affected by different phases.
Though the desired objective remained far from attainment,
experiments were carried on to improve matters.
Page | 17
to the improvement of those already established. The greatest
drawback of the primary system of this period was the
wastage and stagnation. This was attributed to different causes
such as poor teaching, irregular attendance of the pupils, the
admission of very young children and lack of interest on the
part of parents.
Page | 18
assisted by grants-in-aid and subject to certain control.
Because of Odisha’s comparative economic backwardness, it
did not give required response here as it did in Bengal or
Bihar. Hence, the state of secondary education was hopelessly
bad from quantitative point of view by 1936. Bit in the other
hand, as a result of the reorganization of First Grade Training
School at Cuttack, the opening of training college at Cuttack
the provision of vocational subjects in the curriculum,
emphasis on teaching of science and physical education, and
strengthening of inspecting staff, the improvement in quality
of secondary education was perceptible.
Page | 19
beginning of co-education and high sense of discipline of the
students.
Page | 20
For the promotion of female education, co-education was
encouraged as far as practicable. The girls’ schools ere
established in case of necessity. The special inspecting agency
for the female education was created. Attention was paid to
provide the girls schools with trained teachers. Even then
female education presented a disappointing picture. As late as
1936, the percentage of literacy among the Odia women was
only 2.4. Of course, the opening of Intermediate classes in the
Ravenshaw Girls’ School was a concrete step towards the
promotion of higher education among the women of Odisha.
Page | 21
The Muslims formed about 16.6 percent of the total
population of Odisha. But the percentage of Muslim pupils to
the Muslim population was roughly 7.6. 713 Muslim pupils
were under instruction in different stages in 1936. But no
Muslim girl passed the Matriculation Examination by 1936.
However, the Muslims of Odisha did not lag behind others in
race for progress.
Page | 22
One of the most notable events in the history of
education in Odisha from 1905 to 1936 was the establishment
of Satyabadi Vihar commonly known as Satyabadi Bidyalaya.
It was the outcome of a serious experiment to educate the
people of Odisha on indigenous lines. As a new experiment in
sound national education, the Satyabadi Vihar had certain
peculiar features, entirely distinct from the educational
institutions in Odisha. They were the open-air system of
educations, the seat arrangements for students, the residential
character of the institution and the sacrificing spirit of the
workers. The highly educated and selfless workers of
Satyabadi Vihar made educational advancement of the people
a mission of their life. Their contributions to the building up
and strengthening of the national life and character of Odisha
were remarkable3.
Page | 23
remained still to be done in expanding and improving the
education of Odisha. The number of schools and the
percentage of school going children did not show any great
change between 1905 and 1936. In 1936, the percentage of
children at School to the total population was 9.1.
Page | 24
opportunity to avoid the required attention. Fifthly, because of
the remoteness of rural areas and lack of communication,
proper supervision and inspection of schools by the
educational agencies could not be possible. Many schools
remained out of sight and many came under scanty attention.
Sixthly, the growing poverty of the people continued to be a
stumbling block in the path of education progress. Seventhly,
the case prejudices continued to be strong in every part of
Odisha and the children of the so-called lower class did not
find it easy to enter the schools. The growth of education in a
complex and caste ridden society was no smooth matter. It
was one thing for an enlightened mind to appreciate the value
of education, it was altogether a different thing to carry the
same value to the minds of extreme conservatives or primitive
dwellers in the hills. Eighthly, in the matters of female
education the genuine conservatism of the people in general
stood in the way of progress. The education of girls could
mean differently to different persons of the same caste or even
to different members of the same family. Lastly, the main
difficulties in the way of the spread of education among the
tribes were that the literary medium was not their mother-
tongue, that qualified teachers were difficult to obtain, and
Page | 25
supervision was hampered by the scattered nature of the
population.
Page | 26
Even though quantitative growth was yet a far cry by
1936, the qualitative growth had received standard shape. On
the basis of those qualitative achievements, the quantitative
growth became almost phenomenal in the post-independence
era. In that sense the period under review can be described as
the formative period for the education system of Odisha.
Cultural Trends:
The parameters of Odisha’s cultural development in the
second half of the nineteenth century were determined by her
territorial and administrative position under the colonial rule.
While Odisha division, called Odisha proper, remained a part
of the Bengal Presidency from 1803 to 1912, South Odisha
remained a part of the Madras Presidency till 1936,
Sambalpur district remained in Central Provinces till 1905,
and there were a number of feudatory States, Intermingled
with the British-rules territories. Being a minority in Bengal,
Madras, and central Provinces, the Odias found it difficult to
maintain their linguistic and cultural identity. Although the
maintenance and development of regional cultural identity
was
4. an important
Review concern
of the Education in of the conscious
Bengal, intelligential
1892-93, pp 88-102 class,
yet there was a simultaneous perception of the cultural
Page | 27
wakening a part of the general nineteenth century
phenomenon of awakening because of operation of such
factors as growth of English and Vernacular education,
growth of Print media and formation of public associations.
As Pyarimohan Acharya (1852-81), the young social activist
observed in 1878: “Now Odisha is taking strides towards
progress. Progress is the hall mark of this age, i.e. nineteenth
century. Today everywhere we see signs of progress”.
Page | 28
sympathetic. The British authorities considered the Odias to
be politically safe. Analysing the public opinion of Odisha in
1893-94, the Commissioner of the Odia division and John
beams the Collector of Balasore and Cuttack districts
respectively towards the growth of Odia press and literature
was sympathetic. The British authorities considered the Odias
to be politically safe. Analyzing the public opinion of Odisha
in 1893-94, the Commissioner of the Odia division observed
that in Odisha the people kept aloof from the politics of the
country as a whole, were only interested in solving the local
problems and had firm belief in the Government, and that the
education people in Odisha, unlike their counterparts in
Bengal were not politically dangerous5.
Page | 29
apparent glamour of western civilization created an urge for
English Education among the certain sections of the
population. A Brahmin Sanskrit Scholar of Puri, named Pandit
Harihar Das (1842-74_ learnt English, Greek and latin, made
arrangement for teaching English, Greek and Latin, made
arrangement for teaching English to the Bramhin boys in his
Sanskrit tol at Puri, and in defiance of caste rules were
western dresses and himself planned to visit England. The
Pandit’s plan to visit England could not materialize because of
his sudden illness which caused his physical and mental ruin
as well as premature death. In a public meeting, held on 24 th
June, 1870 at Cuttack, this was attended by five Englishmen
including the Commissioner T.E. Ravenshaw, appeals were
made to the Government to spend more money on the spread
of English education, as English education was supposed to
have produced tangible good results on mental make-up,
social life, politics and religion, and development of
Vernacular literature would be possible through the efforts of
English-educated native people. (3) by the early seventies
English journals, such as Cuttack Argus and Cuttack
Chronicles were published at Cuttack and associations such s
Cuttack Debating Club and Cuttack young Men’s Literary
Page | 30
Association were formed to foster interest in English language
and literature and speech.
Page | 31
Many guardians could not afford to pay school fees and
buy books for their children. The conservative people not only
hesitated to send their children to the missionary schools for
fear of losing religion but also to the schools, established by a
Christin Government. Slow progress of education delayed the
emergence of indigenous intelligentia class. In the late sixties
when Odisha was in the grip of a severe famine the
Commissioner, T.E. Ravenshaw observed:
Page | 32
“English education has weakened us in all possible ways.
It has made Hindus a race of Babus (gentlemen). Babus are
reluctant to do any physical work. The Hindu youths are
pleased with this Babu title. Anybody who owns a zamindari
is a Babu; one who carried on money-lending business on
even a small scale is a Babu. Finer the clothes one wears,
greater one becomes as a Babu. It is regrettable that these
Babus are being liked, even though they are the symptoms of
the weakness of Hindi Society and country”.
Page | 33
its subscribers is limited to 140, because the English-educated
youths look down upon it as a Vernacular journal and others
have not realized the utility of news papers. In such a state of
affairs Vernacular language cannot make progress6.
Page | 34
6. Utkal Dipika, 8th September, 1894.
7. Natabar Samantaray, Odia Sahitya Itihas (1803-1920)
developing in rural villages proper indigenous education, that
is, regarding, writing and arithmetic in the real indigenous
language and character of each province”. On the whole, in
spite of opposition the Campbell scheme proved to be a break-
through in the growth of primary education. Sanskrit system
of education enjoyed the patronage of the Rajas, Zamindars
and Mohants of Puri. After the visit of Mahesh Chandra
Nyayaratna, the Principal of the Sanskrit College of Calcutta
in spring of 1893 some belated steps were taken to streamline
Sanskrit system of education. Although there was a traditional
contempt for the vernacular language among the Sanskrit
scholars, the Sanskrit scholars could not afford to ignore the
Vernacular, the living language of the people and some
Sanskrit scholars contributed to Odia language. As a result of
the growth of indigenous press in the late half of the
nineteenth century efforts were made to bring out the palm
leaf manuscripts in Sanskrit and rick Odia Kavya literature of
the medieval period in printed form. We may mention here
the work of Samanta Chandra Sekhar (1835-1904) an
astrologer and a typical product of the indigenous system of
Vernacular and Sanskrit education. A scion of the ruling
family of the princely state of Khgandapada, and conservative
Page | 35
in social outlook, he proved himself to be scientific in his
astronomical investigations. By 1869 he had scribed his
astronomical work, titled Siddhanta Darpan in Sanskrit
language and in palm leaf “in way of our ancient Siddhanta”.
In this work, on the basis of direct observation Chandra
Sekhar pointed out some errors of the ancient astrologers.
About his scientific approach and acumen Jogesh Chandra
Roy, Professor of Physics in Ravenshaw College, with whose
editorial help (and financial help of Raja of Athmallik) the
Siddhanta Darpan was published at Calcutta in 1899 observed
in his introduction to the book:
Page | 36
worked his way in such a difficult science as mathematics. It
is a unique experience in the department of national
development to find a man really striving after knowledge for
its own sake under difficulties whose magnitude is no less
starting than the boldness of his attempt”.
Page | 37
aiming at the development of Odia language and literature.
The Baptist missionaries had established their press at Cuttack
as early as 1837. Gaurishankar Ray was the first Oriya to
establish a press at Cuttack. With capital shares, collected
from some Rajas and Zamindars he organized Cuttack
printing Company on 1st July 1866. Since inception, for fifty
years it was edited by Gauri Shankar Ray, and it continued to
reflect the Public life of Odisha till its closing in 1936. Fakir
Mohan Senapati, the Father of Modern Odia prose literature
started press at Balsore in 1868. He has narrated in his
autobiography how he organized public meetings at Balasore
to raise capital shares for the establishment of press. During
the last thirty years of the nineteenth century thirteen more
presses were established and fifty-eight journals were
published most of which proved to be short-lived.
Page | 38
abolish Odia medium of instruction from the schools of
Odisha. The Bengalis who held many Government posts in
Odisha wanted their children to be taught in Bengali medium.
Their main argument for the abolition of Odia medium from
the schools of Odisha was want of text books in Odia
language. Rajendra Lal Mitra, the famous antiquarian scholar
of Bengal argued that a small population of twenty lacs of
Oriyas could not afford to have a separate language as the
medium of instruction in 1869. In a meeting addressed by him
at Cuttack he put forth his views for the abolition of Odia
medium of instruction from the schools of Odisha. The efforts
of Bengalis which did not fructify because of the sympathy of
colonial authorities for the Odias stimulated the writing of text
books in Odia. The father figures of Modern Odia Literature,
such as a Radhanath Rai, Fakir Mohan Senapati, and
Madhusudan Rao began their literary career a text books in
Odia. The father figures of Modern Odia Literature, such as
Radhanath Rai, Fakir Mohan Senapati, and Madhusudan Rao
began their literary career as text book writers and afterwards
switched over to writing poems, novels and short stories for
the general public. While modern literature took time to grow,
earnest efforts were made to transform old literary and
Page | 39
religious texts from palm leaf manuscripts into printed books.
In this Endeavour Gauri Shankar Roy’s Cuttack Printing
Company played an important role. In a meeting of Utkal
Bhasoddipani Sabha (Association for the Development of
Odia Language) held on the 5 th July 1875, the speakers laid
stress on the collection, publication and study of old Odia
Kavyas. In 1877 Utkal Sabha was formed for reviewing old
Odia Kavyas. In 1878 Utkal Sabha brought out a monthly
journal, titled Utkal Madhupa for the review of the Kavyas
written by the most noted classical poet Upendra Bhanja. It
was observed in Utkal Dipika, dated the 12th April 1884:
Page | 40
and legends into the Odia literature. Fakir Mohan Senapati,
the pioneering novelist proved remarkably successful in
depicting the new social situation in the colloquial language.
He depicted the evil influence of English education upon the
youth and exploitation of the simple rural folk by the
zamindars and money-lenders under the British rule.
Radhanath Rai successfully assimilated western influence into
the Odia poetic literature.
Page | 41
prose-writers-Fakir Mohan Senapati, Biswanath Kar and
Chandra Mohan Maharana modern Odia literature could find
its roots. In May 1903, in a public meeting called at Cuttack
by Madhusudan Rao the Alochana Sabha was transformed
into a wider organization, called Utkal Sahitya Samaj for
holding discussion on old and new forms of Odia literature
and for rousing people’s interest in Odia language and
literature.
Page | 42
Utkal Sahitya Samaj hereafter got associated with Utkal
Sammilani, holding its annual meeting along with the latter.
Page | 43
Theatre movement, through it started later than the
literary movement, became a more popular movement
towards the closing years of the nineteenth century. For
sometime due to lack of Odia dramas Bengali dramas were
being staged at Cuttack. A Bengali drama titled Ramabhiseka
(Coronation of Rama) written by Manmohan Basu was staged
at Cuttack in February 1878. This drama was again enacted in
the Lieutenant Governor’s Durbar at Cuttack on 4 th March
1878. In 1877 Jaganmohan Lala formed the first theatre
company in his native village Mahanga in the Cuttack district.
He also wrote the first Odia drama, titled Babaji. Lala
Jaganmohan and Ramashankar Roy were the pioneering
dramatists of Odisha. Ramshankar wrote his first Odia drama
on the Kanchi-Kaberi legend of Lord Jagannath of Puri, which
was staged in the house of Gopal Prasad Mitra at Cuttack on
7th February 1881. Dramas were staged in the premises of
prominent citizens of Cuttack town. Ameteur theatre groups
were formed in towns and villages. About the popularity of
theatre movement, an anonymous letter-writer wrote in Utkal
Dipika in 1888:
Page | 44
“On seeing the waves of theatres in the towns and
villages today one cannot but believe that this unfortunate
province will one day be the peer of other provinces of
Bengal”
Page | 45
The Rajas and Zamindars, the elite class in the colonial
power-structure had nexus with the new intelligentia class as
well as the conservative Brahmins. They collaborated to a
certain extent with the new intelligentia class in establishment
of press, publication of books and journals and spread of
education. They also extended patronage to the Brahmins.
Some Rajas were printing Sanskrit religious texts for
distributing them mainly among the Brahmins8.
Page | 46
movement not only failed to make any successful inroad into
stronghold of Brahmanical orthodoxy but also failed to have
significant impact on the general public. Its influence was
confined to certain persons of intelligentia class many of
whom happened to be Bengalis. The leading Odia elites who
were influenced by Brahmo faith included Fakir Mohan
Senapati (novelist). Madhusudan Rao (a poet and secretary of
Utkal Brahmo Samaj), Prayi Mohan Acharya, Chatrubhuj
Pattnaik (who wrote a number of books on Brahmanism),
Bishwanath Kar and Nandakishore Bal. Among the rulers of
princely states, Maharaja Bhagirathi Mahendra Bhadur of
Dhenjanal extended patronage to Brahmoism by giving
donation for the construction of Brahmo Mandir at Cuttack.
Maharaja ShriramaChandra Bhanjadeo of Mayurbhanja
accepted Brahmo faith, Sudhaldev Basudev, the ruler of
Bamanda was a staunch critic of Brahmo faith. The Brahmos
were able to draw students to their meetings and sankirtans,
which was liked by their guardians. As Utkal Dipika observe,
There is no wide proposition of Brahmonism in Odisha, and
as most of its adherents are school students: their guardians
have expressed resentment against it and some people have
complained to us”. According to a report in Utkal Dipika,
Page | 47
dated the 12th May 1883 Sunday congregational prayers of
Cuttack Brahmo Mandir were being attended by 13 or 14
persons and Brahmo preachers from Bengal were going back
as their influence was waning.
Page | 48
temple. Against this move there were protests from the public.
Jagannath Sanatan Dharma Rakshini Sabha was organized to
carry on movement to foil Government’s plan to take over the
management of the temple. Madhudusan Das, the leading
Odia Lawyer and Public leader acted as the attorney on behalf
of the Rani Suryaman Patamahadei in the law-suit, filed
against the Government’s plan. Even though a Christian by
faith, Madhudusan Das took up the case, as he felt that
Jagannatha had become the symbol of Odia identity was
further enhanced by the literary works of Ram Shanar Roy
and Radhanath Rai. The Raja of Puri was elevated to the
topmost position in the traditional hierarchy being respected
as the Chalanti Vishnu (Living Vishnu) and Adya Sevaka
(Forest Servant) of Lord Jagannatha. Educated Odias, being
mostly Hindus and striving for Odia identity, sought to derive
inspiration from Lord Jagannatha as the symbol of past glory
of Odisha.
Page | 49
there was a public uproar against Brahmo Samaj in general
and Madhusudan Rao, the Deputy Inspector of Schools in
particular (as he was the Acharya of the Brahmo Samaj) over
the conversion of some students of Cuttack Academy School
and Medical School to Brahmo faith. In a meeting held in
Gopalji Mandir of Cuttac, Bhagbat Bhakti pradayuini Sabha
passed a resolution criticizing the conversion and holding
Madhusudan Rao responsible for it. This meeting resolved
that this matter be brought to the notice of the Commissioner.
Finally the Collector, with concurrence of the Lieutenant
Governor ordered that Madhusudan Rao could not act as the
Acharya or Minister of Bramho Samaj while holding the post
of Deputy Inspector of Schools. On the whole the reformist
trends among the intelligentia were not strong enough to
offset the Brahmanical orthodoxy.
It is interesting to note however that in last quarter of the
nineteenth century an indigenous religious cult, prevalent
among the lower castes and tribals of the hilly regions of
central and western Odisha, called Mahima Dharma gave an
unqualified challenge to Brahmanical orthodoxy. About this
cult Annchariott Eschmann observed:
Page | 50
“Mahima Dharma is a Hindu reform movement that
turned against Jagannath worship in particular. Unlike the so-
called neo-Hindu reform movement, as for instance the
Brahmo Samaj which came into being as a sequel to the
encounter with Christianity and the philosophies of the west
and obtained form there, i.e. from outside, the criteria of their
criticism of its own tradition, no intrinsic direct western
influence in the emergence of Mahima Dharma can be traced.
In the Contrary, this movement derives its criticism of the
Hindu tradition directly from the tradition itself, thus standing
in an almost paradoxical two-fold relation to the tradition
which it accepts on the one hand and rejects on the other.
Page | 51
without Support (Mahima) (radiance, glory), all of which
already appear in the medieval Odia literature for describing
Sunya Brahma or as synomyms for Him”. This religion
opposed idolatry, poly-theism, priest craft, Brahmanical
dominance, and caste system. It preaches philanthropy and the
uplift of the down-trodden. Bhima Bhoi wrote in the twenty-
seventh Boli of his Stuti Chintamani.
Page | 52
and barborous people who have no distinction of caste such as
the defendants are not allowed to enter the temple of
Jagannatha. No priest was taken into account for this incident.
After this incident the Commissioner of Odisha called for
reports from Banki, Angul and Dhenkanal State where
Mahima Swami spent a number of years reported that “The
followers of this religion are almost all ignorant and illiterate
people of the lower class of the Hindu Community”. He
further reported, “The disciples and followers who had left
their homes and had been outcasted could not go back to their
families and were obliged to continue in the new life they had
adopted. The Tahasildar of Angul reported: The followers of
Mahima appear to have been scattered in almost all the
Gurjats of Odisha, in the Chhatisagar Division of Central
Province, in the regulation districts of Odisha, and Ganjam.
Among the Gurjats their members are more numerous in the
estate of Dhenkanal, Banki. Hindol, Angul than elsewhere. He
noted that the Pans of Angul, a caste notorious for stealing
seemed to have given up their hereditary profession of
burglary under the influence of Mahima religion, but the
followers of this new religion were “seen to have been
outcasted or ex-communicated by their Hindu brethren and to
Page | 53
have formed a community of themselves. The Mahima faith
failed to make inroads into the Brahmanical orthodoxy. The
followers of this faith were reported to have been tortured by
the Brahmins and some Zamindars. This faith however came
to limelight in the eighties and became popular through the
lyrical bhajans, composed by Bhima Bhoi. It established itself
as a radical socio-religious doctrine of the sub-alter classes.
9. Utkal
The Dipika, 13thawakening
cultural March 1881.of the late nineteenth century
Page | 54
Odia Intelligentia (of which domiciled Bengalis constituted an
important part) was also considerably influenced by Bengali
literature and culture. While attempts were made to revive the
old Kavya literature, western ideas and influence was
assimilated into modern literature. Attempts were begun to
portray the new social situation in the colloquial language,
Reformist trends on the whole remained incipient and failed
to transform the orthodox society.
*********
Page | 55