Professional Documents
Culture Documents
▪ Philosophy is from the Greek words “Philo” Which UNDERSTANDING THE SELF
means loving - and “Sophia” – which means ▪ Prominent philosophers have different views
knowledge or wisdom. Putting it together, regarding the nature of the self.
philosophy is “loving knowledge” or “loving ▪ The ancient philosophers explained the self from
wisdom”. their conceptual understanding
▪ The study of the fundamental nature of of the world since scientific evidence was hard to
knowledge, reality, and existence, especially in an obtain due to lack of measures.
academic discipline. ▪ Meanwhile, contemporary philosophers have
▪ A particular theory that someone has about how incorporated science to their theories in the light of
to live or how to deal with a particular situation. the technological advancements they have been
▪ Academic discipline concerned with exposed to.
investigating the nature of significance of ordinary
and scientific beliefs. SOCRATES
▪ Investigates the legitimacy of concepts by ▪ known to be the OG “Father of Western Thought.”
rational argument concerning their implications, ▪ Believes in DUALISTIC principle.
relationships as well as reality, knowledge, moral 2 kinds of existence:
judgment, etc. 1.)Body (visible, always changing)
▪ Much of philosophy concerns with the 2.)Soul (invisible, remains constant, invisible to
fundamental nature of self. humans yet understood by the mind)
▪ Body (imperfect, impermanent) + Soul (perfect,
EMPIRICISM AND RATIONALISM permanent)= MAN (an individual)
▪ The philosophy of the self has been defined ▪ He was known for the Socratic Method – it is a
through two (2) distinct approaches: empiricism method of inquiry in testing an idea or the act of
and rationalism. questioning that promotes critical thinking.
▪ “The unexamined life is not worth living”
EMPIRICISM ▪ Concerned with the problem of the self
▪ In empiricism, there is no such thing as innate ▪ “The virtuous man is a happy man.”
knowledge; instead knowledge is derived from ▪ The true task of the philosopher is to know oneself
experience – either perceived with the five (5) ▪ The self consists of two (2) dichotomous realms:
senses or processed with the brain. physical and ideal realms
▪ One knows things because he or she has ▪ The physical realm – changeable, transient, and
experienced it through sensory and bodily imperfect,
experiences. ▪ The ideal realm – unchanging, eternal, and
immortal.
RATIONALISM ▪ The soul – is the immortal entity, the essence of
▪ Rationalism argues that there is innate the self.
knowledge; however there are different resources ▪ Self-knowledge is the ultimate virtue.
of innate knowledge. ▪ I KNOW THAT I DON'T KNOW
▪ Rationalism explains self from the standpoint of
what is “ideal” and “true”, and not rooted in what
is felt by the senses or body. Conclusions are
derived through logic and reasoning.
PLATO RENE DESCARTES
▪ Student of Socrates who believed that the self is
▪ Father of Modern Western Philosophy.
synonymous with the soul.
▪ “I think, therefore I am.” or “Cogito ergo sum ”–
▪ He is the most the important influence of the
the keystone of Descartes’ concept of self.
Western concept of “Self”.
▪ Cogito - the things that thinks, which is the mind
▪ Known for his “Theory of Forms ”
▪ Extenza - extension of the mind which is the body
▪ Introduced the idea of a three-part soul:
▪ Human Person/Self = Body (machine) + Mind
APPETITIVE SOUL, RATIONAL SOUL, AND SPIRITUAL
(controls the body)
SOUL.
▪ The Mind
▪ The appetitive (sensual) – The element which is
1. It is a conscious, thinking substance that is
the human ' s most basic desires (food, drink, sleep,
unaffected by time.
sexual needs, etc.)
2. It is known only to itself (only you know your own
▪ The rational (reasoning) – The element that is the
mental state and thoughts)
reason and intellect to govern affairs, the part that
3. It is NOT made up of parts. It is both conscious
loves truth, hence, considered to be the should
and aware of itself.
rule over the other parts of the soul through the use
▪ The Body
of reason
1. It is a material substance that changes through
▪ The spirited/spiritual (feeling) – The element that is
time.
inclined toward reason but understands the
2. It can be doubted. The public can correct
demands of passion; in-charge of emotions like
claims about the body.
love, anger, ambitions, etc.
3. It is made up of physical, quantifiable, divisible
▪ BALANCE BETWEEN MIND AND BODY.
parts.
▪ The essence of the human self is a thinking entity
ST. AUGUSTINE that doubts, understands,
▪ Followed the view of Plato but adds Christianity. analyzes, questions and reasons.
▪ As a religious philosopher, he contemplated on
the nature of man with an emphasis on the soul as
JOHN LOCKE
an important element of man.
▪ one of the most influential Enlightenment
▪ Humankind is created in the image and likeness
Thinkers.
of God.
▪ The human mind at birth is tabula rasa or blank
▪ “Knowledge can only come by seeing the truth
slate. Human mind at birth is a tabula rasa, which
that dwells within us.”
means that knowledge is derived from experience
▪ The Body - dies on earth + soul-lives eternally in
▪ expounded Descartes description of the "Self" as
spiritual bliss with "God" = Man
a thinking thing to the self being a "thinking thing
▪ His ideas of the soul are the following:
with memories "
i) It is able to be aware of itself
▪ the premise that the self has memories, this
ii) It recognizes itself as a holistic one
means that the person existing now is the same
iii) It is aware of its unity
person yesterday because he remembers the
▪ ALL KNOWLEDGE LEADS TO GOD
thoughts, experiences, or actions of the past self.
▪ Body + Mind (ability to think + memories and
experiences) = SELF / Personal Identity
▪ The self or personal identity is constructed
primarily from sense experience – specifically,
what people see, hear, smell, taste and feel.
▪ KNOWLEDGE IS DERIVE FROM EXPERIENCE
DAVID HUME 2) Consciousness of oneself and one ' s states by
▪ Hume was a Scottish philosopher, economist, and performing acts of apperception
historian during the Age of Enlightenment ▪ Apperception is the mental process by which a
▪ ALL KNOWLEDGE IS DERIVE FROM HUMAN SENSES person makes sense of an idea by assimilating it to
▪ He proposed the bundle theory where he the body of ideas he or she already possesses.
described the self or person or mind as a bundle or ▪ For Kant what truly exist are your ideas and your
collection of different perceptions that are moving knowledge of your ideas; that you perceive the
in a very fast and successive manner or in a outside world through the self with your ideas.
perpetual flux ▪ Two components of the " self" :
▪ Self/ Human Person = combination of all 1) Inner Self - the " self" by which you are aware of
experiences with a particular person alterations in your own state. This includes your
▪ He sees the self through these two categories: rational intellect and your psychological state,
1) Impressions - These are the perceptions that are such as moods, feelings, and sensations, pleasure,
the most strong. They enter the senses with most and pain.
force. These are directly experienced; they result 2) Outer Self- It includes your senses and the
from inward and outward sentiments. physical world. It is the common boundary
2) Ideas- These are the less forcible and less lively between the external world and the inner self. It
counterparts of impressions. These are mechanisms gathers information from the external world
that copy and reproduce sense data formulated through the senses, which the inner self interprets
based upon the previously perceived impressions. and coherently expresses.
▪ "Self" was nothing but a series of incoherent ▪ the " self" organizes information in three ways:
impressions received by the senses. 1) Raw perceptual input,
▪ "Self" is not just one impression but a mix and a 2) Recognizing the concept, and
loose cohesion of various personal experiences 3)Reproducing in the imagination
and ideas ▪ a "unified" point of self-reference. Meaning you
are conscious of yourself as the subject, and you
are conscious of yourself as a common subject of
IMMANUEL KANT
different representations.
▪ Reason is the final authority of morality. Morality is
achieved only when there is absence of war
because of the result of enlightenment. SIGMUND FREUD
▪ Kant is a central figure in modern philosophy. He ▪ a philosopher, physiologist, and psychologist and
proposed that the human mind creates the one of the most influential thinkers of the 20th
structure of human experiences. century.
▪ " self" as transcendental meaning it is spiritual or in ▪ focused on the " psyche " or "I" which is the
the nonphysical realm. totality of the human mind, both conscious (what
▪ " self" is not in the body, but rather it is outside of you think you know and are aware of) and
it. However, the body and its qualities are rooted unconscious (the things you don 't know that you
to the " self". What bridges the " self" and the know or aware of).
material things or body is Knowledge. ▪ Self is multi-layered and represented thru the "
▪ Self = Body + Mind (impressions and experiences psyche" He distinguished three levels of the psyche
that are processed through mental understanding :
of what happened) 1) Conscious - deals with the awareness of present
▪ two kinds of consciousness of self (rationality): perceptions, feelings, thoughts, memories, and
1) Consciousness of oneself and one ' s fantasies at any particular moment;
psychological states in inner sense,
2) Preconscious/subconscious - related to data or PAUL CHURCHLAND
information that can readily be brought to ▪ known for his studies in
consciousness and are nonthreatening neurophilosophy and the philosophy of mind.
3) Unconscious - part of the mind or psyche that ▪ He believes that if something can be seen, felt,
contains the basic instinctual drives of a person heard, touched, or tasted - all experienced by the
including sexuality, aggressiveness, traumatic sensory, then it exists.
experiences, unfulfilled wishes and childhood ▪ He proposed the idea of eliminative materialism
desires that would be considered not appropriate which he states that the "mind" and its mental
to talk about. states do not exist. Rather, only the "brain " exists,
▪ known for his psychoanalytic theory, a personality producing electrochemical signals this producing
theory based on the idea that a person gets the " self".
motivated to act by unseen forces, controlled by ▪ The brain, not the mind, is responsible for the self.
the conscious, and the rational thought. What is ▪ Body + Brain Activity= Self
unique about this theory is that he proposed the ▪ "The physical brain and NOT the imaginary mind
existence of the unconscious as: gives us our sense of self"
1) A database for traumatic repressed memories;
2) The source of anxiety-provoking drives that is
MAURICE MERLEAU-PONTY
socially or ethically unacceptable to the
▪ Maurice Merleau-Ponty was a philosopher and
individual.
author.
▪ Freud further structured the dimension (or
▪ " self" as an embodied subjectivity. From the word
personality) of"self" (Id, ego,superego)
itself, embodied means to give a body to, while
▪ the superego consists of two systems:
subjectivity is the state of being a subject-
CONSCIENCE, AND IDEAL SELF.
meaning an entity that possesses conscious
▪ "Wish Fulfillment is the road to the unconscious "
experiences, such as perspectives, feelings,
▪ Preconscious (easily retrievable memories and
beliefs, and desires. What' s more is that a subject
information) + Conscious (Ego, Superego, Present
acts upon or can affect other entity - or known as
Moment, Awareness) + Unconscious (Id, traumatic
object.
events, repressed moments) = Self or "I
▪ believed that the mind and body are connected.
▪ He notes that everything that people are aware
GILBERT RYLE of is contained within the consciousness.
▪ Gilbert Ryle is a philosopher and a professor. ▪ He is convinced that consciousness, the world,
▪ He described the distinction between mind and body and the body are intricately intertwined in
as the "dogma of the ghost in the machine" where
perceiving the world.
he explained that there is no hidden entity or ghost
called " soul" (or mind or self) in a machine called ▪ Living body + conscious mind with thoughts and
"body ". its understanding of the surroundings + the external
▪ Overt Actions and Behaviors = Self or Man world = Self or individual.
▪ The self is best understood as a pattern of ▪ "Physical body is an important part of the self.
behavior, the tendency for a person to behave in
a certain way in certain circumstances.
▪ “I act, therefore I am.”
SOCIOLOGY
Key Characteristics of a modern society
▪ According to American Sociological Association,
▪ Industrialism – The social relations implied in the
SOCIOLOGY is the study of social life, social
extensive use of material power and machinery in
change, and the social causes and consequences
all processes of production.
of human behavior. Sociologists investigate the
▪ Capitalism – A production system involving both
structure of groups, organizations, and societies
competitive product markets and the
and how people interact to within these context
commodification (putting a price tag) of labor
▪ Understanding Sociology in the question "Who am
power.
I?" - we learn how socially formed norms, beliefs,
▪ Institution of surveillance – The massive increase
and values come to exist within the person to a
of power and reach by institutions, especially in
degree where these become natural and normal
government.
(Elwell, 2003) and thereby developing the person's
▪ Dynamism – Most evident characteristic of
self-identity.
modern society. Dynamism is characterized as
having vigorous activity and progress.
The Sociological Concepts affecting the
self ▪ In a modern society, life is not a predetermined
▪ Modernization, Social group and social networks path with limited options, it is a society full of
and, mead and social self. possibilities. Everything is subject to change, and
changes happen much more rapidly than ever
MODERNIZATION before in human history. And with this rapid
Pre-modern Society changes, it is also affecting how one's self is being
▪ Concerned on one thing: SURVIVAL and that brought up, developed, and formed.
created a mindset that everything is LIMITED in
options in their choices.
▪ People behaved according to social rules and SOCIAL GROUP AND SOCIAL NETWORKS
traditions while the family and the immediate
environment provided supervisions on how to get
GEORGE SIMMEL
through life. Choosing where to live, what line of
▪ George Simmel was a German Sociologist,
work to do, and even who to marry was very
philosopher, and critic.
limited. (Hermannsdottir, 2011).
▪ He expressed that people create social networks
by joining social groups.
Modern Society
▪ Social Groups - Described as having two or more
▪ Significantly changed society by improving
people interacting with one another, sharing
people's living condition.
similar characteristics, and whose members
▪ There is freedom to choose where to live, what to
identify themselves as part of the group.
do, and who to be with because of the plenty of
EX. Ranz and Niana Family, Cardo Dalisay and
possibilities and options out there.
family, BTS , Golden State Warriors
▪ May have decreased in traditions and support
▪ Social Networks - refers to the ties or connections
system, such as family connections, because of
that link you to your social group. The connection
the increase in independence.
you have with your family is blood relation; you are
▪ Modernization has significantly changed society,
connected with your barkada because of your
and this has affected how an individual builds and
friendship, and the connection you have with your
develops his or her self-identity.
classmates is your common interest to learn.
MEAD AND SOCIAL SELF
EX. familial, blood-related, neighbors in the
GEORGE HERBERT MEAD
community, Common interest in music /
▪ George Herbert Mead was a sociologist from the
basketball.
late 1800s.
▪ He was well known for his "Theory of the
Social Group
Social Self" which is based on the perspective
▪ Organic Group that the self is a product of social interactions +
– Naturally occurring Highly influenced by family internalizing the other people's views along with
Formed in traditional societies the one's personal view about oneself.
– You join this group because your family is part of ▪He believed that the "self" is not present at
thoughts, and why you feel certain emotions genes and body developing) and environmental
experience (what we learn from our surroundings
will definitely help you manage and become
and life experiences)
better versions of yourself and answer the
▪ He believes that children construct an
question - Who am I?
understanding of the world around them,
experience inconsistencies between what they
already know and what they discover in their
The Domains of Psychology affecting the environment, and then adjust their ideas
self accordingly - and this help them shape their self.
True Self
▪ True self flourishes in infancy if the mother is
positively responsive to the child's spontaneous
expressions (Winnicott, 1960; Jones-Smith, 2011).
▪ Winnicott described true self as a sense of “self”
based on “spontaneous authentic experience."
▪ The True Self has a sense of integrity, of
connected wholeness. True self is a sense of being
alive and real in one's mind and body, having
feelings that are spontaneous and unforced.
▪ A child whose mother is positively responsive and
supports the child's natural process of individuation
will grow up as an adult with a TRUE SELF with a
stable self-image; views other people realistically;
and accepts both the positive and negative side
of every person including himself/herself.
False Self
▪ The false self is the product of early experience. It
is a defensive organization formed by the infant
because of inadequate mothering or failures in
empathy.
▪ The false self is also based on being completely
obedient to the parents' wishes. Winnicott asserted
that when the child is constantly expected to
follow rules, a false self develops.
▪ The false self is a mask or a persona. It is a form of
defense that constantly seeks to anticipate others'
demands and complies with them, as a way of
protecting the true self from a world that is felt to
be unsafe.
▪ However, when the person has a false self but
can still function both as an individual and in the
society, then he or she has a healthy false self. The
healthy false self feels that it is still connected with
the true self. Thus, it can be compliant without
feeling guilty that it abandoned its true self.
▪ On the other hand, there is also the unhealthy
false self. An individual who may seem happy and
comfortable in his or her environment but actually
feels forced to fit in and constantly needs to adjust
his or her behavior to adapt to the social situation
is said to have an unhealthy false self.
The last field that we will understand is how the ▪ The western concept of self is anchored on
SELF is viewed in the lens of the western and ancient philosophers ' (remember our first
eastern perspectives. We learn from the perspective?) beliefs that the body constitutes
perspective in Anthropology that a person’s individuality.
cultural background can affect how a person sees ▪ The epitome of the Western idea of self came
himself or herself. Researchers reported that from Rene Descartes ’ famous line “I think,
people are shaped by their culture, and their therefore I am, ”
culture is also shaped by them. To go deeper to ▪ The western tradition is generally acknowledged
the categories of culture, the predominant to be “imbued” with a style of thinking based on
thoughts are the Western and Eastern view. One of dichotomy and binary opposition.” (Ha unsa daw
the major proponents of cultural psychology, maam?) Meaning their idea about the self is similar
Richard Shweder, wrote “Cultural traditions and to duality – heart and soul, mind and body
social practices regulate, express, and transform ▪ There is a distinct line between the person
the human psyche, resulting less psychic unity for (observer) and his observed reality. Westerners
humankind .' - this make us unique individuals from often think that they can separate from reality
one another in a global scale and also contribute based on their decisions and choices in life.
to the shaping of one's self.
4 categories on how the term “ self” is used in
We are all individuals who think, feel, and behave contemporary western discussion according to
similar as that of the members of his or her Frank Johnson:
community. However, each community has its
own standards, expectations, and rules that shape 1. Analytical – The “ self” is an observer separate
its members. If we divide the world into two and distinct from external objects (Me versus Other
thoughts, there is a distinct perspective from the mentality)
western versus eastern thought, from the way we 2.Monotheistic – Involved the tendency toward
eat, how we live, the principles we abide by, and unitary explanations of phenomena and a closed
even how one sees one ’ s self. Learning this will system view of “ self”. (Mentality that all must
help us better understand and be compassionate believe that we come from one omnipotent
with ourselves as we strive to become better power or that evolution has happened because of
individuals. one single entity versus different factors
combined).
C. Individualistic vs. Collective Self ▪ Societies that focus on the person create an
individualistic self-concept where the person sees
▪ Individualistic Self and Collective Self are two
the personal difference of traits and characteristics
dominant self-concepts that is highly formed by
that distinguish the individual within his or her social
culture. Culture plays a very significant role in the
context.
development of the self-concept. It embodies
▪ Individualistic orientation tends to rely on
specific values, thoughts, or ideas that play a
interpersonal comparison and is associated with
central role in determining a person ’ s sense of “
the motive of protecting or enhancing the person
self”.
psychologically.
▪ Individualism refers to the extent that you value
independence and personal uniqueness. Highly
Collectivism
individualistic people value personal freedom, self
▪ Eastern culture practiced by countries in Asia (like
sufficiency, control over their own lives, and
us in the Philippines) base their values and
appreciation of the unique qualities that distinguish
self-concept in a collectivist view.
them from others.
▪ People in collectivistic culture emphasize
▪ Collectivism refers to the extent that we value our
interdependence and harmonious relatedness
duty to groups to which we belong, and to group
with one another (family, coworkers, friends, etc.)
harmony. Highly collectivist people define
▪ It is of utmost importance to be part of and
themselves by their group membership and value
maintain social networks, maintain good
harmonious relationships within those groups.
relationships, and fulfill obligations.
▪ Patricia Licaucan, a Filipino psychologist and
educator, determined that one of the strengths of
the Filipino character is our deep love and
III. Individualistic vs. Collective Self
concern for the family – not just your immediate
family but extending to your extended family such
Individualism
as you grandparents, uncles, aunts, cousins, etc.
▪ “I am my own man” and “I am the master of my
▪ The Filipino is dominantly a collective culture as
fate; I am the captain of my soul”
one’s family is the source of personal identity, the
source of emotional and material support, and the
person’s main commitment and all responsibility.
D. The Self as embedded in
Individualistic vs. Collective Self Relationships and through Spiritual
Development in Confucian Thought
▪ Some contemporary self-concept theories
attempted to close the gap between cultural
▪ The Confucian tradition as a way of thinking and
concepts as it can ’t be all black and white or
lifestyle is still an inspiration to many East Asian
purely individualistic and collectivist orientation.
Societies.
(Diba? Can you say you are purely collectivistic in
▪ The Confucian concept of Li often rendered as “
nature as a Filipino?)
proper conduct” or “ propriety ” was originally
▪ Roy Baumeister proposed that self-concept could
denoted as court rites or rituals performed to
be organized in three aspects:
sustain social and cosmic order.
Private – refers to the mental processes that
▪ In the Confucian sense, self-development is a
perceive one ’ s own traits or behaviors (ex. I am
lifelong commitment to learning. However, it is not
honest)
only about reading books or taking exams, it is also
Public – refers to the generalized view of the self,
about ritual practice. It involves practicing
such as the perception of how others view you (ex.
discipline for the mind and body to love life not as
People think I’ m honest)
an isolated individual but as an active participant
Collective – refers to the view of self in a collective
in the living community.
concept (ex. My family and friends expects me to
▪ The most important concept of the self in
be honest)
Confucian thought is the view that the “ self” is the
▪ According to Baumeister, it is assumed that these
center of relationships. The idea is that it is only by
three aspects exists in every person. However, a
continually opening the self to others that the “
dominant aspect would probably present itself
self” maintains its wholeness and identity
depending on one ’ s culture. Thus, in an
individualistic culture, the person would
predominantly show the private self and will have
according to personal beliefs, feelings, philosophy,
etc. While in a collectivist culture, the person would
present “the collective self” more and is thus more
inclined to behave according to rules, norms, and
customs expected of him/her.