Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12633-023-02355-0
ORIGINAL PAPER
Abstract
The purpose of this review is to summarize the characterization and properties of porous silicon (PS) for hydrogen storage.
In silicon porosification technology, the importance of hydrogen as an intermediate product is highlighted. In this respect,
this study explored what hydrogen bonding in PS is like and how it can be used to store hydrogen. The comprehension of
hydrogen storage with PS and an understanding of potential future solutions can both benefit from such a review.
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
1. Obtaining hydrogen from fossil fuels such as coal, natu- Fig. 2 Hydrogen Storage Technologies [21]
ral gas, gasoline by thermochemical methods. The steam
reaction method is the most used method. Here, the fos- Hydrogen storage technologies are classified in Fig. 2.
sil fuel reacts with steam via a nickel-based catalyst and However, as shown in Fig. 3., chemical methods and
hydrogen is released. In addition, hydrogen is obtained hybrid methods are material-based methods.
from bio-oil obtained from biomass by the pyrolysis Existing hydrogen storage technologies include lique-
method, similarly by reaction with steam. faction [23, 24] and high pressure tanks. However, these
2. Obtaining hydrogen by electrolysis of water. Using elec- storage systems necessitate extremely low temperatures or
trical energy, water is split into hydrogen and oxygen. high hydrogen pressures, which raises the costs and risks
3. Obtaining hydrogen from solar energy by photoelectro- of using them to store hydrogen.
chemical method. It is similar to the electrolysis method. Other approaches include gas compression [25–28]
Electric current is obtained from solar cells immersed and adsorption on very porous materials (carbon nano-
in water. It is more efficient than the normal electrolysis structures, metal or complex hydride production, metallo-
method. organic networks) [29–33].
4. Obtaining hydrogen by using natural photosynthesis Although hydrogen can be transported, stored, or used
activities from green algae by photobiological method. as a liquid or gas, gas storage needs very large amounts. Up
5. Obtaining hydrogen from various hydride compounds to 15% of the hydrogen energy stored is spent on compres-
by chemical methods. The most important of these is sion. In addition, a high pressure storage tank is needed
sodium borohydride. and these tanks are manufactured from woven carbon
nanofibers, which are very costly. This leads to huge sizes
Hydrogen storage technologies are given in Fig. 2. Each of devices and vehicles where hydrogen is thought to be
of the methods given here has its own characteristics. used as a fuel [20].
13
Storage as a liquid creates both very high pressure and reversible gas storage with quick kinetics and stability over
high cost. 30% of the stored hydrogen energy is spent for many cycles is maximized by hydrogen physisorption within
liquefaction. The liquid hydrogen tank must be well insu- a light, porous, large surface area, and durable material. Sev-
lated to minimize heat transfer from the environment. An eral investigations are being made into innovative materials
attractive method for storing hydrogen is solid-state stor- with incredibly huge surface areas that are being tested for
age. In an ideal world, hydrogen storage materials would their capacity to store hydrogen [9].
be able to physisorb or chemisorb hydrogen into them- Most metal hydrides weigh a lot and some of them are
selves, storing it safely and effectively. Usable hydrogen extremely stable substances that need high dehydrogenation
storage capacity, price, reaction temperatures, and kinet- temperatures of over 300 °C [34, 35]. Solid-state porous
ics are the performance parameters to be assessed for the materials called metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) can
materials [5]. store hydrogen at temperatures ranging from 196 degrees
The focus of hydrogen storage applications has recently Celsius to 25 degrees Celsius. However, because of their
been on storage by absorption processes on the surface of weak hydrogen interactions, MOFs may not be able to store
materials because of the materials' low weight and relatively hydrogen for a long time at higher temperatures [36]. Conse-
low binding energy, which make it easier for hydrogen to quently, a cheap, porous hydrogen storage material that can
be released from confinement [9]. The possibility of highly operate at ambient temperature would be ideal [9].
13
According to the literature, silicon (Si), the most (1 0 0), and solitary Si–H species for direction (111). On
researched semiconductor, is a prominent contender for defects like Si tips, trihydrides ( SiH 3) are visible. The
hydrogen storage research due to its widespread availability number of dangling Si• bonds that become passivated
in nature, low cost and interaction with hydrogen. In order with hydrogen as a result of increased porosity increases
to show the poor affinity of a pure silicon surface to hydro- along with the sharpening of surface roughness. The sur-
gen, scientists looked at the adsorption energy between those face changes to a fractal state and the Si crystallites shrink
arrays [6, 37]. as porosity rises, increasing the amount of bound hydro-
Si–Si connections are not broken when hydrogen atoms gen. These characteristics enable estimation of the porous
establish dangling bonds with Si surfaces. Theoretically, for media to crystalline core ratio in etched Si powders. As a
x:1, 2, and 3, the wt % (weight percent) hydrogen in a S iHx result, hydrogen may account for up to 6 mass percent of
system is 3.44, 6.65, and 9.65 [9]. Porous media [38] and the final product [39].
other structures have been reported as storage systems [6]. Every form of hydrogen bonding in PS has specific
Among the superior features of porous silicon are that it energies for activation and dissociation, as well as vibra-
is suitable for mass production, is compatible with micro- tional modes and other characteristics that can be studied
production techniques and can be easily integrated into (Fig. 6) [39].
systems. Moreover, It can be obtained by easy etching pro-
cesses. It has a high characteristic surface area, favorable
surface chemistry, and important optical and electrical prop-
erties. Due to these properties, it can be used in the fields 3 Hydrogen Extraction
of optics and photonics. It is biocompatible, biodegradable
and biorepairable, and has low toxicity. For these reasons, In the storage of hydrogen, it is important that the hydro-
it can be used in biosensing applications. Additionally PS gen bonds to the PS as well as breaking the bonds and
has the potential to be a very efficient solid-state hydrogen making them ready for use. Several methods are used for
storage material [12]. Because the surface of PS produced by this. Heating is the most commonly utilized method for
electrochemical etching is coated with S iHx silane groups, producing H2 from PS.
this material has the potential to be used as a solid-state Heating [39]: Thermal S iHx bond dissociation and the
hydrogen reservoir [39]. Although PS is a very good candi- desorption of physically bound atomic and molecular
date for hydrogen storage, efficiency improvement studies hydrogen occur concurrently with this process. The benefit
are ongoing. In one of the studies, doping into the pores was of this approach is temperature-based process control. The
used for this purpose. hydrogen that was held on defects and Si–H-B complexes
Hydrogen storage with PS is a chemical hydrogen storage desorbs at temperatures between 150 and 200 °C. Silane
method and is realized by physical adsorption. species break down at higher temperatures: SiH3 and SiH2
at 250–350 °C and SiH at 450 °C and above. The mor-
phology and age of the samples affect temperature results.
2 Hydrogen‑Si Bonds Formation The disadvantage is the requirement for a high vacuum
(due to the potential for oxidation) and high temperatures
PS is produced as a result of processing in a hydrogen fluo- (between 250 and 600 °C).
ride solution [24]. With electrochemical etching (anodiza-
tion), the most common preparation method, pore formation • Chemical reaction with water [39]: Hydrogen is gen-
activities are greatly assisted by an electrical current. erated due to the PS and water reaction. Even small
The electrochemical etching procedure relies on the elec- catalytic quantities of bases significantly speed up the
trical field-assisted reaction between HF and Si atoms. Fig- process. Hydrated silicon oxide is the PS conversion's
ure 4 depicts the reaction’s flow chart [39]. end result.
The morphology and chemical structure of obtained PS is • Illumination [39]: Desorption of H 2 occurs when pho-
determined by the preparation method and the characteristics tons with energies equivalent to or greater than the
of the employed Si wafers. As mentioned, during the etching corresponding binding energies of SiHx species are
procedure, hydrogen coats the Si dangling bonds. On the absorbed. Usually, PS is exposed to intense infrared
surface of the obtained PS, Consequently, silane SiHx (x = 1, radiation, visible light, or ultraviolet laser, the frequen-
2, 3) groups are generated. The surface morphology of these cies of which are matched to the vibrational modes of
groups determines their kinds (Fig. 5). silane groups. The benefit of such a technique is the
Crystalline planes are often covered with dimer mono- ability to selectively extract H 2 from a chosen kind of
hydrides (H-Si–Si-H) or dihydrides ( SiH2) for direction SiHx species; the disadvantages are the slow hydrogen
desorption rate and cost for high power.
13
The silicon tetrafluoride reacts with two HF molecules to give H2SiF6 and
then ionizes.
13
13
PS 1.2–1.3
PS + 1%Pd 0.90–1.14
PS + 1%Pd with H2 treatment 1.04–1.27
PS + 10%Pd 0.52–0.65
PS + 10%Pd with H2 treatment 0.17–0.65
13
S1 3 2.58 664.9 69
S2 5 3.31 710.3 73
S3 7 3.58 590.6 67
S4 10 5.50 510.9 62
13
[52]. Transitional metals, especially V catalysts, boost the hydrogen reservoirs based on PS make this material a useful
hydrogen storage capacity (HSC) of structures by atomizing hydrogen source. Additional hydrogen buildup in PS, its use
hydrogen molecules via the spillover process [61]. Metal in fuel cells, and other future research topics are still being
nanoparticles, like Pd have an inherent void volume that explored in this area.
makes them potential hydrogen reservoirs [52]. In the light of the above findings, his research argues that
hydrogen offers PS specific characteristics and applications
that are advantageous for current employment and conse-
5 Other Application Areas of ps quently for future research.
13
9. Kale P, Gangal AC, Edla R, Sharma P (2012) Investigation of 31. Dalebrook AF, Gan W, Grasemann M, Moret S, Laurenczy G
hydrogen storage behavior of silicon nanoparticles. Int J Hydrog (2013) Hydrogen storage: beyond conventional methods. Chem
Energy 37(4):3741–3747 Commun 49(78):8735–8751
10. Schlapbach L, Züttel A (2001) Hydrogen-storage materials for 32. Huang J, Liang Y, Dong H, Hu H, Yu P, Peng L, Liu Y (2018)
mobile applications. Nature 414(6861):353–358 Revealing contribution of pore size to high hydrogen storage
11. Lin RH, Xi XN, Wang PN, Wu BD, Tian SM (2019) Review on capacity. Int J Hydrog Energy 43(39):18077–18082
hydrogen fuel cell condition monitoring and prediction methods. 33. Gronich, S. (2000). DOE hydrogen program overview. Proceed-
Int J Hydrogen Energy 44(11):5488–5498 ings of the 2000 US DOE hydrogen review.
12. Merazga S, Cheriet A, M’hammedi K, Mefoued A, Gabouze N 34. Uhlir A Jr (1956) Electrolytic shaping of germanium and silicon.
(2019) Investigation of porous silicon thin films for electrochemi- Bell Syst Tech J 35(2):333–347
cal hydrogen storage. Int J Hydrogen Energy 44(20):9994–10002 35. Turner DR (1958) Electropolishing silicon in hydrofluoric acid
13. Barthélémy H, Weber M, Barbier F (2017) Hydrogen storage: solutions. J Electrochem Soc 105(7):402
Recent improvements and industrial perspectives. Int J Hydrogen 36. Memming R, Schwandt G (1966) Anodic dissolution of silicon in
Energy 42(11):7254–7262 hydrofluoric acid solutions. Surf Sci 4(2):109–124
14. Lan J, Cheng D, Cao D, Wang W (2008) Silicon nanotube as a 37. Carraro PM, Blanco AG, Soria FA, Lener G, Sapag K, Eimer
promising candidate for hydrogen storage: from the first princi- GA, Oliva MI (2016) Understanding the role of nickel on the
ple calculations to grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations. The hydrogen storage capacity of Ni/MCM-41 materials. Microporous
Journal of Physical Chemistry C 112(14):5598–5604 Mesoporous Mater 231:31–39
15. John GC, Singh VA (1995) Porous silicon: theoretical studies. 38. Wang Z, Wang F, Li M, Iqbal MZ, Lu Y, Xu M, Li Q (2014)
Phys Rep 263(2):93–151 Synthesis, characterization and hydrogen storage characteristics
16. Wang X, Maeda K, Thomas A, Takanabe K, Xin G, Carlsson of flower-like SnO2 porous microspheres. Mater Lett 119:36–38
JM, Antonietti M (2009) A metal-free polymeric photocatalyst 39. Manilov AI, Skryshevsky VA (2013) Hydrogen in porous sili-
for hydrogen production from water under visible light. Nat Mater con—a review. Mater Sci Eng, B 178(15):942–955
8(1):76–80 40. Honarpazhouh Y, Astaraei FR, Naderi HR, Tavakoli O (2016)
17. Das D, Veziroǧlu TN (2001) Hydrogen production by biologi- Electrochemical hydrogen storage in Pd-coated porous silicon/
cal processes: a survey of literature. Int J Hydrogen Energy graphene oxide. Int J Hydrogen Energy 41(28):12175–12182
26(1):13–28 41. Boaks M, Schubert PJ (2019) Kinetics of hydrogen storage on
18. Amirav L, Alivisatos AP (2010) Photocatalytic hydrogen pro- catalytically-modified porous silicon. J Catal 371:81–87
duction with tunable nanorod heterostructures. J Phys Chem Lett 42. Dürr M, Höfer U (2006) Dissociative adsorption of molecular
1(7):1051–1054 hydrogen on silicon surfaces. Surf Sci Rep 61(12):465–526
19. Zuo F, Wang L, Wu T, Zhang Z, Borchardt D, Feng P (2010) 43. Lysenko V, Bidault F, Alekseev S, Zaitsev V, Barbier D, Turpin
Self-doped Ti3+ enhanced photocatalyst for hydrogen production C, Garrone E (2005) Study of porous silicon nanostructures as
under visible light. J Am Chem Soc 132(34):11856–11857 hydrogen reservoirs. J Phys Chem B 109(42):19711–19718
20. KOŞAR, C. Hidrojen Depolama Yöntemleri. Open Journal of 44. Ryou J, Hong S, Kim G (2008) Hydrogen adsorption on hexagonal
Nano, 6(1), 1–10. silicon nanotubes. Solid State Commun 148(9–10):469–471
21. Atesin TA, Bashir S, Liu JL (2017) Nanostructured Materials for 45. Parkhutik V (1999) Porous silicon—mechanisms of growth and
Next-Generation Energy Storage and Conversion. Springer applications. Solid-State Electron 43(6):1121–1141
22. Lebrouhi, B. E., Djoupo, J. J., Lamrani, B., Benabdelaziz, K., & 46. John GC, Singh VA (1997) Self-organization in porous silicon
Kousksou, T. (2022). Global hydrogen development-A technologi- formation. Phys Rev B 56(8):4638
cal and geopolitical overview. International Journal of Hydrogen 47. Bratu P, Brenig W, Gro A, Hartmann M, Höfer U, Kratzer P, Russ
Energy. R (1996) Reaction dynamics of molecular hydrogen on silicon
23. Hames Y, Kaya K, Baltacioglu E, Turksoy A (2018) Analysis surfaces. Phys Rev B 54(8):5978
of the control strategies for fuel saving in the hydrogen fuel cell 48. Lysenko V, Vitiello J, Remaki B, Barbier D, Skryshevsky VJASS
vehicles. Int J Hydrogen Energy 43(23):10810–10821 (2004) Nanoscale morphology dependent hydrogen coverage of
24. Motalleb M, Đukić A, Firak M (2015) Solar hydrogen power meso-porous silicon. Appl Surf Sci 230(1–4):425–430
system for isolated passive house. Int J Hydrogen Energy 49. Rivolo P, Geobaldo F, Rocchia M, Amato G, Rossi AM, Garrone
40(46):16001–16009 E (2003) Joint FTIR and TPD study of hydrogen desorption from
25. Ozsaban M, Midilli A (2016) A parametric study on exergetic p+-type porous silicon. Physica status solidi (a) 197(1):217–221
sustainability aspects of high-pressure hydrogen gas compression. 50. Litvinenko S, Alekseev S, Lysenko V, Venturello A, Geobaldo
Int J Hydrogen Energy 41(11):5321–5334 F, Gulina L, Barbier D (2010) Hydrogen production from nano-
26. Ozcan H, Dincer I (2017) Energy and exergy analyses of a solar porous Si powder formed by stain etching. Int J Hydrog Energy
based hydrogen production and compression system. Int J Hydrog 35(13):6773–6778
Energy 42(33):21414–21428 51. Choi MH, Min YJ, Gwak GH, Paek SM, Oh JM (2014) A nano-
27. Bhouri M, Linder M, Bürger I (2018) Metal hydride reactor for structured Ni/graphene hybrid for enhanced electrochemical
dual use: Hydrogen storage and cold production. Int J Hydrogen hydrogen storage. J Alloy Compd 610:231–235
Energy 43(52):23357–23371 52. Chen CH, Chung TY, Shen CC, Yu MS, Tsao CS, Shi GN,
28. Zhang J, Yan S, Qu H, Yu XF, Peng P (2017) Alkali metal Lee WL (2013) Hydrogen storage performance in palladium-
silanides α-MSiH3: A family of complex hydrides for solid-state doped graphene/carbon composites. Int J Hydrog Energy
hydrogen storage. Int J Hydrogen Energy 42(17):12405–12413 38(9):3681–3688
29. Dincă M, Long JR (2008) Hydrogen storage in microporous 53. Guo GF, Huang H, Xue FH, Liu CJ, Yu HT, Quan X, Dong
metal–organic frameworks with exposed metal sites. Angew XL (2013) Electrochemical hydrogen storage of the graphene
Chem Int Ed 47(36):6766–6779 sheets prepared by DC arc-discharge method. Surf Coat Technol
30. Masika E, Mokaya R (2014) Exceptional gravimetric and volu- 228:S120–S125
metric hydrogen storage for densified zeolite templated carbons 54. Rajalakshmi N, Dhathathreyan KS, Govindaraj A, Satishku-
with high mechanical stability. Energy Environ Sci 7(1):427–434 mar BC (2000) Electrochemical investigation of single-walled
13
carbon nanotubes for hydrogen storage. Electrochim Acta 64. Sharma P, Sun X, Parish G, Keating A (2021) Optimising porous
45(27):4511–4515 silicon electrical properties for thermal sensing applications.
55. Dai GP, Liu M, Hou PX, Tong Y, Cheng HM (2002) Electrochem- Microporous Mesoporous Mater 312:110767
ical charge-discharge capacity of purified single-walled carbon 65. Davoodi E, Montazerian H, Haghniaz R, Rashidi A, Ahadian S,
nanotubes. Electrochem Solid-State Lett 5(4):E13 Sheikhi A, Toyserkani E (2020) 3D-printed ultra-robust surface-
56. Liu E, Wang J, Li J, Shi C, He C, Du X, Zhao N (2011) Enhanced doped porous silicone sensors for wearable biomonitoring. ACS
electrochemical hydrogen storage capacity of multi-walled Nano 14(2):1520–1532
carbon nanotubes by TiO2 decoration. Int J Hydrogen Energy 66. Khalaph KA, Shanan ZJ, Al-Attar FM, Abd AN, Jafar AM (2020)
36(11):6739–6743 Fabrication and investigation of hybrid Perovskite solar cells
57. Li S, Zhao HM, Jena P (2011) Ti-doped nano-porous graphene: A based on porous silicon. Mater Today Proc 20:605–610
material for hydrogen storage and sensor. Front Phys 6:204–208 67. Loni, A. (2014). Porous silicon formation by anodization. Hand-
58. Ismail N, Madian M, El-Shall MS (2015) Reduced graphene oxide book of Porous silicon, 1.
doped with Ni/Pd nanoparticles for hydrogen storage application. 68. Bakar NA, Ridzwan A, Tan WL, Bakar MA, Sabri NA (2019)
J Ind Eng Chem 30:328–335 Facile preparation of porous silicon from cost-wise silicon powder
59. He Z, Wang S, Wang X, Iqbal Z (2013) Hydrogen storage in hier- as effective catalyst for reduction of p-nitrophenol. Mater Chem
archical nanoporous silicon–carbon nanotube architectures. Int J Phys 232:387–392
Energy Res 37(7):754–760 69. Zhang X, Huang M, Yang C, Dai G, Huang J (2017) Fabrication
60. Dybtsev DN, Chun H, Yoon SH, Kim D, Kim K (2004) Micropo- of porous Si/nitrogen doped carbon composite and its enhanced
rous manganese formate: a simple metal− organic porous material lithium storage capability. Mater Chem Phys 201:302–310
with high framework stability and highly selective gas sorption 70. Sun J, Li J, Ban B, Shi J, Wang Q, Chen J (2020) A simple method
properties. J Am Chem Soc 126(1):32–33 to fabricate size and porosity tunable Si by Al–Si alloy as lithium
61. Im JS, Yun J, Kang SC, Lee SK, Lee YS (2012) Hydrogen adsorp- ion battery anode material. Electrochim Acta 345:136242
tion on activated carbon nanotubes with an atomic-sized vanadium
catalyst investigated by electrical resistance measurements. Appl Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
Surf Sci 258(7):2749–2756 jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
62. Gelloz B (2014) Photoluminescence of porous silicon. In: Can-
ham L (ed) Handbook of Porous Silicon. Springer International Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds
Publishing, Cham, pp 307–320 exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the
63. Lawrence B, Alagumanikumaran N, Prithivikumaran N, Jeya- author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted
kumaran N, Ramadas V, Natarajan B (2013) Effect of surface manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of
modification on the porous silicon infiltrated with biomolecules. such publishing agreement and applicable law.
Appl Surf Sci 264:767–771
13
1. use such content for the purpose of providing other users with access on a regular or large scale basis or as a means to circumvent access
control;
2. use such content where to do so would be considered a criminal or statutory offence in any jurisdiction, or gives rise to civil liability, or is
otherwise unlawful;
3. falsely or misleadingly imply or suggest endorsement, approval , sponsorship, or association unless explicitly agreed to by Springer Nature in
writing;
4. use bots or other automated methods to access the content or redirect messages
5. override any security feature or exclusionary protocol; or
6. share the content in order to create substitute for Springer Nature products or services or a systematic database of Springer Nature journal
content.
In line with the restriction against commercial use, Springer Nature does not permit the creation of a product or service that creates revenue,
royalties, rent or income from our content or its inclusion as part of a paid for service or for other commercial gain. Springer Nature journal
content cannot be used for inter-library loans and librarians may not upload Springer Nature journal content on a large scale into their, or any
other, institutional repository.
These terms of use are reviewed regularly and may be amended at any time. Springer Nature is not obligated to publish any information or
content on this website and may remove it or features or functionality at our sole discretion, at any time with or without notice. Springer Nature
may revoke this licence to you at any time and remove access to any copies of the Springer Nature journal content which have been saved.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, Springer Nature makes no warranties, representations or guarantees to Users, either express or implied
with respect to the Springer nature journal content and all parties disclaim and waive any implied warranties or warranties imposed by law,
including merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose.
Please note that these rights do not automatically extend to content, data or other material published by Springer Nature that may be licensed
from third parties.
If you would like to use or distribute our Springer Nature journal content to a wider audience or on a regular basis or in any other manner not
expressly permitted by these Terms, please contact Springer Nature at
onlineservice@springernature.com