Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SERVICES
IN THE CONTEXT OF HOME ECONOMICS INSTRUCTIONS
A Thesis
Presented to
The Graduate School
CEBU TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY
Main Campus, R Palma St., Cebu City
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
MASTERS OF ARTS IN VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
ETHYLE D. WEIGEL
November 2019
APPROVAL SHEET
This Thesis entitled “INDUSTRY’S COMPETENCE IN FOOD PREPARATION
AND SERVICES IN THE CONTEXT OF HOME ECONOMICS INSTRUCTIONS”
prepared and submitted by ETHYLE D. WEIGEL, in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN VOCATIONAL (MAVEd), has
been evaluated and is recommended for acceptance and approval for Oral
Examination.
PANEL OF EXAMINERS
ABSTRACT
Ethyle D. Weigel
ethyle.weigel2@gmail.com
Cebu Technological University- Main Campus
Home Making Arts and livelihood programs are both part of the important
life skills a person must learn while growing up. In the prior ages, Home Making
Arts’ focal point was more on teaching women how to fix food and sew but as
time develops, it became more diverse which is now relevant to both genders.
Food Industry in the Philippines is now increasing in size at its phenomenal rate
and becoming more varied. With this enormous amount of profit and food outlets
starting, the demand for more food industry workers is now escalating.
This research aims to determine the relevance of Home economics
instruction in regards to food preparation and service among food industry
workers of YELO, Coffee Bean Scent, Serenitea, Infuso and Med cafe which are
located in Cebu City, and Lapu-lapu City Philippines. This study utilized a
descriptive survey research method. The researcher entailed approximately 60
food workers as respondents, who were given questionnaires from the research
study by a group of researchers Noor-Azira Abdul-Mutalib, et al with the research
title “Knowledge, attitude and practices towards food hygiene and cleanliness of
food handlers in Kuala Pilah, Malaysia. After the respondents answered the
questions, the researcher described and analyzed the data gathered.
In conclusion, the study revealed that the respondents had a high
knowledge in food handling, positive attitude towards food handling and had a
proper practice method in food handling and service. With this high regards of
knowledge, attitude and food handling, it proved the effectiveness of Home
Economics Instructions, which is beneficial to the food workers’ service which
contributed to the food industry’s competence.
It is recommended that the areas of weakness in Home Economics should
be intensified and given importance to be taught in TLE Subject in order to
address the distinguished areas of concerns and differences; strengthen the
knowledge of the students in order to heighten their performance once these
students would start on working. While in strengths of Home Economics Subjects
should be pursued to be taught and reinforced in order for the students to benefit
from it in the future stages of their lives specifically upon employment.
My special thanks to my Brother and sisters, and friends for their support
and valuable prayers and for their keen interest shown to complete this thesis
successfully.
Ethyle D. Weigel
DEDICATION
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
TITLE PAGE I
APPROVAL SHEET
II
ABSTRACT III
ACKNOWLEDGMENT V
DEDICATION VI
LIST OF FIGURES IX
Chapter
INTRODUCTION
Theoretical background 3
THE PROBLEM
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Design
10
Data gathering 10
Environment 11
Respondents
14
Instrument
15
16
Treatment of data
20
Scoring procedure 20
Definition of terms
23
Educational attainment 26
Month of employment 27
47
Summary 47
Findings
48
Conclusions
49
Recommendations
50
4 THE OUTPUT
51
Rationale 51
Objectives 52
Target Clientele 53
Scheme Implementation 53
Strengthening guide 53
APPENDICES
A. Transmittal letter 57
B. Consent form 58
BIBLIOGRAPHY 59
CURRICULUM VITAE 61
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
food handling
9.0 Knowledge of food handling score 36
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure
Page
INTRODUCTION
key part of our lives, that is the basis as to why the way it is grown, processed
Content, 2010). With that, one fundamental right of an individual is the right to
raise awareness on the appropriate dietetic habits which taught the consumer to
decide healthier alternatives of food. The welfare of the citizens is the core
Republic Act No. 10533 in DepEd Order No. 43, S 2013 indicated that
Curriculum and inflating the number of years for Basic Education in which
Technology and Livelihood Education (TLE) is one of its important and correlated
curriculum. One of the rationale as to why the Philippine Educational System
skills are being initiated in Senior High and it requires further research to
stabilize the school programs and evolve the competencies of the learners that
are responsive to the qualities of the partner industries (DepEd, 2013). Home
ensure that the byproduct is safe and free from harmful levels of microorganism.
eating but also in preparing and producing food. The food establishment has
become one of the world's leading and superior industries in food preparation
and products. The birth of schools offering food preparation and production
course, open the doors to those who want to learn & enhance their cooking
prowess, improving their skills to serve the customer in a fast & safe way. Food
industry in the Philippines, which comprises all forms of food retail, is now
evolving at its phenomenal cost with added food outlets and food carts. In the
upcoming year, the food industry will pursue its rise and the involvement of more
individuals like students will confidently peak as well. In relation with this
demand, the study was focused on three proportions in Home Economic in which
service and determine the conveyance of cookery instruction food handling and
acquisition of skills during Senior High more especially in the Home economics
Theoretical Background
present have leveled up the amount of people buying and consuming food
emphasized life skills an individual must acquire while growing up. Furthermore,
the students grasp which nutrients are necessary for human health and
persistent growth of life and which food involves such nutrients, as well as the
place the efficiency and comprehension of nutrients and food into full practical
According to Laurel (2013), home economics discipline has paved the way
for people to the fields of education, nutrition, social service, and hospitality
management. In conjunction, hospitality focuses on preparation, production, and
this learning area that allows the Filipino apprentice the quality time to engage in
practical knowledge and life’s techniques that have been learned, most likely the
individual for entry into the commercialized industry. Thus, will be able to achieve
presented in the research study acclaims that it can be a salient drive for moving
et.al,2014).
product skills that produce them self reliance/self given employment describes
Vocational Home Economics. To equip the learners, the one who teaches the
subject should also be equipped with efficient and reliable strategies for effective
current society, Home economics is well positioned to instill reliable practices (all
order for them to live and do their potential in the global society of today and
tomorrow. For some time, home economists have seen that personal
commitments, values, and behavior matter, and that they can be among the most
THE PROBLEM
1. 1. Personal Information
1.1.1 age
1.1.2 gender
2.1.1 sanitation
3. What are the issues and concerns related to food preparation and food
be crafted?
The result of the study was very favorable to some people who were in a
way or any ways, involved in the food process and service, to frequently enhance
their values and view in regards to work. In these, lies the significance of this
study.
has benefited in this study through improving the curriculum of TLE of the Senior
High students. With this study, DepEd would be able to train TLE faculty with
through promoting the program and developing the skills in food preparation and
TLE subject that needs to be improved will be strengthened for effective and
the study will serve as a guide for the food industry in hiring workers that would
Food and other industry workers. Since home economics does not only
focus on food preparation and service alone, the results have benefited other
workers. Giving importance to the knowledge, skills and attitude they acquired in
Home Making Arts, they would be able to develop work values that would help in
Educators. Based on the output of the study, the Senior High Technology
and Livelihood Education subject educators were able to know the significant
contribution of the subject , teaching lifelong learnings to the students. With that,
the educators became efficient in their job since the learning will not only be
applicable during the student life but at the same time in the students’ future
career paths.
Education subject also benefit in this study since the educators were able to
focus on the key points on this subject. With that, the students were able to apply
their knowledge in Home Economics as they graduate and proceed with Tertiary
The Current Researcher. The study has helped uncover critical areas in
the educative process that many researchers are not able to explore. The
research study deals on the relevance of Home Economic Instruction with the
objective that skills delivered are acquired, developed by the students and
The Future Researchers. They are going to benefit from this study by
coinciding the data to the findings gathered. The relevance of Home Economics
not limiting only in the Efficiency of food industry workers but in other fields of
work as well.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Design
this study, food industry workers have answered questions which focuses on
and service through their knowledge, attitude and practice of food handling in
Education. Thus, educators were able to know and improve which aspects of
Environment
Infuso, Serenitea, MedCafe, YELO and Coffee Bean Scent which are all
located in Cebu, were the chosen Food Industries. These food retails are one of
the starting food industries located in Cebu City. They cater not just food alone
but at the same time serve coffees and milk teas. These food retails have just
started its branches in Cebu and are currently growing to be bigger retails. Infuso
Coffee Outlet is located in Mango Ave, opened last 2018, caters both Coffee and
Sweet Desserts. Serenitea is located in IT Park, opened last 2015, caters both
opened last 2018, serves Food that are served in solo and group orders. Coffee
Bean Scent is also located in Kamputhaw, opened last 2015, mainly serves
opened last 2018, serves food variants and some Milk tea. These are the chosen
food industries since they just recently opened and are still growing. With its
growing range, the researcher utilized its developing industry compared to the
established and bigger food retails. It would be fair to conduct the research study
in the food industry to have an idea on the food retail business that has just
started and is about to prosper into a larger business compared to the ones who
were already experienced and have established its working protocols and ethics.
The study was conducted in 5 different locations within Cebu City area
YELO
with an age range of 18 to 30 years old that are currently employed in S Infuso,
Serenitea, MedCafe, YELO and Coffee Bean Scent Cebu whose jobs include
cooking, preparation of food, serving the food prepared and after care of the
graduate or more, at least two (2) months in the food industry and literacy of an
questionnaires given. The exclusion criteria would be: respondents who were not
able to take a Technology and Livelihood Education subject, one (1) month or
less in the food industry and inability to read and write since it may contribute to
Table 1
Distributions of Respondents
Food Workers Male Female Total
Infuso 6 7 13
Serenitea 4 6 10
MedCafe 5 8 13
YELO 7 6 13
Total 27 30 60
Research Instrument
The two (2) types of measuring a food industry knowledge and efficiency
The adapted questionnaire that was used in this study was adapted from a
food handlers in Kuala Pilah, Malaysia. The main focus of the research was to
and their knowledge level. A self-administered questionnaire (Table 2.0, 2.1, 2.2)
was used in the research in which its validation was done with cross reference
and verification from the experts in the identified field. Reliability of the
questionnaires had also been tested with Cronbach’s alpha for each set of the
queries having a range of within acceptable limit (>.8). The knowledge section
(Table 2.0) involves eight (8) questions that need an answer of a scale from one
(1) to five (5). The attitude proportion (Table 2.1) involves 13 questions with an
answer of strongly agree, agree, uncertain, disagree and strongly disagree. For
the practice portion (Table 2.2), it involves 13 questions that need an answer of a
scale from one (1) to five (5). The study inferred that even though comprehension
towards food handling was satisfactory, some of the hygiene aspects should be
more often to the cookery service staff for it to decrease foodborne hazards
applicable. With the data that will be gathered at the end of the research study,
study. The questionnaires that were handed out to be answered are constructed
clearly in order for the workers to comprehend easily. The first part of the
Months of Employment and Previous Job (if applicable), respectively. With that,
the researchers were able to identify the competence of the respondents and the
On the second part of the Questionnaires, it was divided into three (3)
parts: Knowledge of Food Handling, Attitude towards Food Handling and Practice
before, during and after food preparation. Practice in Food Handling (Table 4)
primarily focuses on how they solely practice their knowledge and attitude as a
food industry worker. Questionnaires that were given were fully explained to the
properly. At the same time, the significance of the study was properly explained
described and analyzed the data gathered. The aid of a statistician is also
needed in order to comprehensively analyze the data that will be collected. The
Treatment of Data
instruments were tailed and tabulated and presented in tables for better and clear
significant relationship between Food Handling and Service and the Knowledge
gained in Home Economics Instructions during the respondent’s Secondary
Level of Education.
Scoring Procedure
be translated verbally. The succeeding tables illustrate the criteria for scoring the
Table 5 as seen in the Appendix D, it displays the scoring guide for data
DEFINITION OF TERMS
The terms in the key concept of this study are operationally defined in this
Meal Service. A service that simply refers to a meal being served to the
customer service, Food preparation and even cleaning duties in eating and
drinking establishments.
Chapter 2
connection with this study.The data pertain to the Industry’s competence in food
Information: Age, Gender, Educational Attainment and Attended TLE subject and
Part three (3) presents the issues and concerns related to food
Part four (4) discusses Integrative Home Economics instructions that can
Serenite, 14 workers from MedCafe, 13 workers from Coffee Bean Scent and 10
the age bracket of 21-23 years old which composed 58.33% of the total
population, 18 workers belong to the age bracket of 24-27 which composes the
30% of the population and 7 workers belong to the 27-30 years old age bracket
composing 11.67% of the population. This means that most of the food industry
workers are in the younger generation age bracket 21-23 years old indicating that
the food workers had studied the TLE subject approximately 4-6 years ago and
Table 6
Age of Respondents
n= 60
Age Respondents %
21-23 35 58.33
24-27 18 30
27-30 7 11.67
workers are female. Which means that most females are into jobs that involve
food and beverage but with a minimal difference with male ratio, approximately
4%.
Table 7
Gender of Respondents
n= 60
Gender Respondents %
Male 33 55
Female 37 61.67
Educational Attainment and TLE Subject Attended
attainment and if the respondents have attended TLE Subject. As shown in the
Table, Educational attainment was categorized into four (4) brackets, First
bracket was High School undergrad with zero (0) respondents; Second bracket
was High School graduate with twenty-one (21) composing 35% of the
population; Third bracket was College level with nineteen (19) respondents which
composes 31.67% of the population and fourth bracket was College graduate
with twenty (20) respondents composing 33.33% of the total respondents. This
indicates that all of the respondents were able to graduate High School and
attended the TLE subject but indicating that most of the workers were High
School Graduates.
Table 8
Educational Attainment
n=60
for 2-6 months, 40% of the population which is 24 respondents have been
employed for 7-11 months and 9 workers which is 15% of the population have
been employed for approximately 1-2 years already. Which means that most of
the workers have just started and experienced training just recently.
Table 9
Months of Employment
n=60
There were 60 respondents in this study all of which are working as a food
industry worker, most of the population are High School Graduates, mostly
females and have taken Technology and Livelihood Education specifically Home
Workers.
Table 10
Knowledge of Food Handling
n=60
Level of
Indicators Weighted Mean Effectiveness
Preparation of food in advance is more
likely to contribute to food poisoning. 1.87 Strongly Disagree
Reheating food is more likely to
contribute to food contamination. 1.85 Strongly Disagree
An incorrect application of cleaning
and sanitization procedures for
equipment (refrigerator, slicing
machine, mincer) increase the risk of
foodborne disease to consumers. 4.47 Strongly Agree
Washing hands before handling food
reduces the risk of contamination. 4.55 Strongly Agree
Wearing gloves while handling food
reduces the risk of transmitting
infection to consumers and staff. 4.67 Strongly Agree
The use of cap, masks, protective
gloves and adequate clothing can
reduce the risk of food contamination. 4.53 Strongly Agree
The importance of knowing the
temperature of the refrigerator/ freezer
to reduce the risk of food spoilage. 3.97 Agree
Improper storage of foods may cause
a health hazard to consumers. 4.45 Strongly Agree
Legend:
Range Level of Effectiveness
3.40-5.00 Strongly Agree
2.60-3.39 Uncertain
1.00-2.59 Strongly Disagree
weighted mean of 3.8; this means that the respondents agrees with the
respondent’s have learned during their Home Economics subject. The usage of
with the wearing of gloves and other hygienic practices to minimize the likelihood
The attitude towards Food Handling among the Food Industry Workers is
Table 11
Attitude Towards Food Handling
n= 60
Weighted Level of
Indicators Mean Effectiveness
Work area must be cleaned before start
working. 4.53 Strongly Agree
Hands should be washed before start
working. 4.82 Strongly Agree
As reflected in Table 11, the average weighted mean for the respondent’s
Agree; this means that the respondents mostly agrees with the statement
their Knowledge in Home Economics. The respondents Strongly Agrees with the
statement that Working with Dirty Hands should be avoided which is correct and
sanitation of hands (Green et al, 2016). The respondents are not in favor of
wearing jewelry such as watches while handling food. This further implies that
the respondent's attitude towards food handling can greatly affect their service as
a food industry worker in which these attitudes towards food handling were
Table 12
Practice in Food Handling
n=60
Weighted Level of
Indicators Mean Effectiveness
I clean the work area before I start work. 4.8 Always
I wash my hands before I start work. 4.92 Always
I use a tissue when I am coughing or
sneezing. 4.52 Always
I eat while working 2.0 Seldom
I use my apron as a towel to clean my
hand. 2.57 Often
I do not smoke while working. 1.05 Always
I rub my hands on my face, hair, etc.
while working. 4.53 Seldom
I use jewelry and a watch while working. 4.3 Seldom
I use the same towel to clean many
places. 1.63 Seldom
I do not separate raw food with cooked
food. 3.00 Often
I use separate kitchen utensils to prepare
raw and cooked food. 4.57 Always
I do not refreeze defrosted foods. 4.3 Seldom
I touch food that does not wrap up with a
wounded hand. 1.1 Always
Food Handling got an average weighted mean of 3.4 with a Verbal Interpretation
of Always which means that the respondents mostly affirms and does practices
the indicator statement. It implies that the respondents perform hand washing
prior to starting to work which is in accordance to the certainty that Proper hand
pathogens from hands to food and other materials (Green et al, 2016). This
further implies that the respondent’s knowledge and attitude towards food
handling, which were acquired during Home Economics subject, greatly affects
mostly affirms on the stated statement indicators. This implies that the knowledge
in food handling and attitude towards food handling, which were obtained and
This part of the Chapter further discusses the issues and concerns related
to food preparation and service in the industry in regards to the results gathered
through the questionnaire given to the respondents. With this, the researcher
would be able to know which issues and concerns should be directed in Food
Knowledge in Food Handling and Preparation, it implies that the respondents are
Furthermore, the respondent’s knowledge with the use of gloves in food handling
education and home economics teaching in regards to the use of gloves and
Attitude towards Food Handling and Preparation indicates that the respondents
had a great attitude towards food handling. In contrast, it also indicates further
fair amount education towards the Attitude in Food Handling which implies that
utensils in raw and prepared food. At the same time, a further education in
cooking raw and prepared food separately. This further implies that, Home
cooking of raw and prepared food. Overall, it implies that the respondent’s
attitude towards washing hands prior to working is a must and not smoking
during food preparation and service is prohibited. This further implies that the
Practice in Food Handling and Preparation implies that the respondents are
the respondents are greatly practicing food preparation and handling specifically
in the areas of washing hands prior to cooking, not using any jewelry during food
preparation and service, not smoking during working and not touching the food
with a wounded hand which in general implies that the respondents are
knowledge in regards to eating while working and use the apron in both cleaning
The overall results implies that the respondents are knowledgeable, have
a good perspective and practices correct and proper Food Handling methods;
which would also imply that their knowledge about Food Handling and Service
Instructions that are being crafted based on the findings. Some parts and aspects
preparation. In Attitude towards Food Handling, preparation for raw and prepared
food, proper usage of kitchen utensils and defrosting of food should be focused
Practice in Food Handling indicates proper usage for apron, refreezing and
defrosting of food and the importance of the prohibition of eating while cooking
should be focused and strengthened as it is being taught during the TLE Subject.
Overall, this chapter implies the specific topics and areas of Home Economics
Economics Instructions.
SUMMARY
Handling of the Food Industry Workers of the identified food industry of Infuso,
Serenitea, MedCafe, YELO and Coffee Bean Scent which are all located in Cebu
City as the basis for integrity of Home Economics Instructions. The profile of the
and performance of the food workers towards Food Handling and Service in
relation to the knowledge the respondents acquired during their High School
competencies, the efficiency of Food Handling and Service in relation to the Food
during the High School years and the effectiveness of the respondent’s Food
Service Handling at their present jobs and lastly, identify the areas of Home
Economics that are greatly discussed and should be continued to be taught and
the areas of Home Economics that should further enhanced and given
importance.
interview and observation were made to verify data and to determine the validity
FINDINGS
The findings of the study revealed that the respondents had a high
Knowledge in Food Handling, positive attitude towards Food Handling and had a
proper practice method in Food Handling and Service. With this, the researcher
was able to identify the areas of strengths of Home Economics and the areas
enhanced. With this high regard of knowledge, attitude and food handling,
CONCLUSION
return, an efficient food worker contributes to the greater competence of the Food
Industry.
RECOMMENDATIONS
students in order to enhance their performance once these students would start
on working. At the same time the areas of strengths in the Home Economics
Subjects should be continued to be taught and reinforced in order for the
working.
Chapter 4
THE OUTPUT
Rationale
One of the reasons the Philippine Educational System adopts the K-12
program is to prepare our Senior High graduate to find a job in the future in order
in Senior High and it needs further study to stabilize the school activities and
develop the competencies of the learners that are responsive to the standards of
the partner industries (DepEd, 2013). Home Economics is one of the areas in
Objectives
service and determine the delivery of cookery instruction food handling and
acquisition of skills during Senior High specifically in the Industry instructions and
service of the food workers becomes the basis for the effectiveness of Home
Curriculum.
Target Clientele
The target clientele of this inquest are the Technology and Livelihood
Scheme Implementation
be taught and reinforced in order for the students to benefit on it in the future
Areas of Objectives Strategie Persons Budget Source Time Expected Actual Remarks
concern involved of Frame Outcome Accompl
budget ishment
Knowledg
e, Attitude
and
Practice of
Food
Handling
by the
Food
Workers
APPENDIX A
Greetings in Peace!
Thank you!
Truly,
Ethyle Weigel
APPENDIX B
Thank you!
Truly,
Ethyle Weigel
APPENDIX C
Table 2
Knowledge of Food Handling
Indicators 1 2 3 4 5
Table 3
Attitude towards Food Handling
Indicators 1 2 3 4 5
We should not rub our hands on face, hair, etc. while working.
Table 4
Practice in Food Handling
Indicators 1 2 3
APPENDIX D
Table 5.0
2 2.60-3.39 Uncertain
1 1.00-2.59 Strongly Disagree
Table 5.1
3 3.40-5.00 Always
2 2.60-3.39 Often
1 1.00-2.59 Seldom
BIBLIOGRAPHY
CURRICULUM VITAE
ETHYLE DONGALLO WEIGEL
B.SUICO ST. BRGY. TINGUB, MANDAUE CITY
ethyle.weigel2@gmail.com(09177776225)
PERSONAL PROFILE
Date of Birth : March 29, 1971
Sex : Female
Civil status : Married
Religion : Roman Catholic
Parents : Tyrone A. Dongallo
Vicenta C. Dongallo
Spouse : Ernest D. Weigel
Children : Shari Nicole C. Dongallo
Ernest Luke D. Weigel
Ethan Luke D. Weigel
Euan Luke D. Weigel
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
TERTIARY
SECONDARY
Lourdes College High school
WORKING EXPERIENCE
ESL Teacher