Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Theory of Communication
Origin: The word “Communication” is derived from the Latin word ‘Communis’ which means to
make common, to share, to transmit or to impart.
Communication is a part and parcel of everyone’s life. All individuals need to communicate to
share their knowledge and information with others. However, the degree of its effectiveness depends
upon your personal communication skills. The better are your communication skills, the better a
person understands you. Effective communication skills enable a person to understand the mindset
of others and grasp the situation easily. It helps an individual get desired results even in an
unfamiliar situation. A good communicator is a highly motivated individual who always gives
importance to his goals and achieves them in the most efficient manner. He always understands his
role and knows how to convert his efforts integrated with skills into results. Not only
professionally, you also require effective communication skills in relationships to get the best out of
life. And, for the people who wish to achieve success in their life, communication skills work as the
Communication is a basic tool for motivation, which can improve morale (The state of the spirits of
a person or group as exhibited by confidence, cheerfulness, discipline, and willingness to perform
assigned tasks) of the employees in an organization. Inappropriate or faulty communication among
employees or between manager and his subordinates is the major cause of conflict and low morale
at work. Manager should clarify to employees about what is to be done, how well they are doing
and what can be done for better performance to improve their motivation. He can prepare a written
statement, clearly outlining the relationship between company objectives and personal objectives
and integrating the interest of the two.
#Postulates are the starting points/ foundations for reasoning, discussion or belief.
#Hallmarks are the stamps of authenticity in the particular field.
1. Open and honest communication: It leads more quickly to a mutual understanding and
respect for a difference in views, interests and needs. It gives the impression of authenticity
and integrity, essential foundations for true collaboration.
2. Empathy: Understanding other people's emotions is a key skill in the workplace. It can
enable us to resolve conflicts, to build more productive teams, and to improve our
relationships with co-workers, clients and customers.
3. Positivity: Positive communication has the power to convert even negative feelings
into positive ones and helps you create a positive impression for yourself. Positive
communication in the workplace enables both managers and employees to build teams of
cooperative and efficient workers. When each member of the team is able to communicate in
a positive fashion, they are able to trust each other, therefore increasing productivity and
lessening friction and tension.
1. Sender: The one who sends a message is called the sender. The message is the first component
which arises in the sender’s mind. It could be in the form of an idea, an opinion, a thought or a
feeling.
2. Encoding: The message has to be put in a certain form of expression. So it is put in a code which
could be an accepted language or non-verbal means of communication. By encoding the sender
gives his message a definite form and a certain meaning which he tries to convey.
4. The receiver: The one who receives the sender’s message is called the receiver.
5. Decoding: The message given by the sender is received by the receiver. After being received it
gets processed in the receiver’s brain. The brain filters the message through its own compartments
of the contents such as knowledge, emotions, prejudices (An adverse judgment or opinion formed
beforehand or without knowledge or examination of the facts) and gives it a unique meaning. It
analysis the meaning of the message, understands it and interprets it. Further, it also decides what
response is to be given and in what form it is to be given; either in the form of the spoken word or
written word or in non-verbal form suitable for the delivery of the response.
6. Feedback: This is an important component of the communication process which helps the
sender to see whether his message is being received by the receiver in the same light as he intended
it to deliver. It further gives him an idea, either he should continue in the same way or modify it.
The feedback is the response given by the receiver of the message. It could be positive when
expressed by positive words such as ‘yes’, ‘I agree with you’ or by giving a nod suggesting an
agreement with the message given by the sender. It could also be negative when expressed by
using negative words like ‘no’, ‘I don’t agree’, ‘I don’t understand how to respond’, or shaking
the head sideways suggesting disapproval, refusal etc. Some times if there is no reply to the
sender’s message, then it is called as absence of feedback.
Feedback
Communication is a dynamic process, ongoing and ever changing. It requires two parties; one is
the sender of the message and the other is the receiver of it. So it is a two way process. It involves
essential component: message, sender, encoding, channel or medium, receiver, decoding and
feedback.
First, an idea is born in the sender’s mind. Then the sender encodes it in a verbal or a non-verbal
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 3
form. He may choose an accepted language, a verbal form of expression as a code. The sender
transmits his messages in the chosen form of verbal or non-verbal expression. The receiver receives
it. After grasping the message, he tries to understand and interpret it according to his perception.
Thus, after decoding it he prepares his response. He puts it in a code and conveys it back to the
sender. This response by the receiver is called a feedback. After the feedback or the response is given
by the receiver of it who has to decode the response. He analyses it and decides for himself whether
the receiver received his message in the same light as he intended to convey. When this happens
there takes place an effective, mutually successful communication. In this way, one cycle of the
communication process is complete. A second cycle will start and complete in the same manner.
Thus, a series of cycles will continue till an obstacle or a barrier arises in the communication
between two parties.
Example: The Teacher (sender) discusses a subject (message) with the students (receiver) using
appropriate language (medium) in the classroom (channel) and the students respond (feedback).
Conclusion: Communication is a universal process. It is common to all people all over the world
irrespective of various castes, creed, race, nationalities and religions. The language of expression
may be different but the basic process of communication remains the same everywhere.
(Important Tips: Define communication/draw diagram and explain
it/example/conclusion)
Informal communications: The informal and unofficially transmission of information, tea time
gossip, casual gatherings, lunch time meetings or rumor from person to person. It grows out of the
social interactions among people who work together. These are not bound by any chart on the wall
but are bound by conventions, customs and culture. Such communication provides useful
information for events to come, in the form of grapevine.
Grapevine: The usual implication is that the information is passed from person to person by word
of mouth, perhaps in a confidential manner among friends or colleagues. It can also imply an
overheard conversation or anonymous sources of information. These channels may not be very
reliable as they may be company rumors or just gossip. Such channels are more active in
organizations that are not transparent. As employees want to know what is going on in their
organization, they seek out unofficial sources of information. The grapevine is not always negative
for an organization and can in fact be helpful as it helps in positive group building by acting as a
safety valve for pent-up emotions. It may help in building up organizational solidarity and
harmony. Managers can use the grapevine to get a feel for the morale of the organization,
understand the anxieties of the work force, evaluate formal communication efforts and see if they
are working.
Effective upward communication is possible only when organizations empower their employees
and allow them to participate freely in decision-making.
Downward communication depends on different types of print and oral media to disseminate
information. Handbooks, manuals, magazines, newspapers, bulletin boards, notices, posters,
reports and memos are different kinds of written media used by organizations. Direct orders or
instructions from top executives, speeches, meetings, public address systems, telephones and
closed-circuit television are examples of oral media used for downward communication.
Horizontal Communication
Horizontal communication is a communication that takes place within the same level, e.g. the
communication between the employees or between the board or director. In simple, the same level of
communication is called horizontal communication. The main objective of this type of
communication is developing teamwork and promoting group co-ordination within an
organization. Horizontal communication is less formal and structured than both downward and
upward communication. It may be carried out through informal discussions, management gossip,
telephone calls, memos, routine meetings etc. It functions as Co-ordination, problem solving,
sharing information, advice, support, for conference etc.
Advantages: Team spirit, elimination of misunderstanding, time saving. (Please elaborate the
points for big answer)
Methods of communication
Verbal Non-verbal
I. Verbal: Communication between two individuals or group with the help of words or
speeches is called verbal communication.
Oral Written
❖ Oral: Oral communication is very important for a business organization. It takes place
when a person conveys a message to the other person directly in the spoken form.
Oral communication:
Merits or advantages:
It is a direct medium. Good intonation (the rise and fall of voice in speaking) helps to express
the meaning correctly. Personal or individual issues may be sorted out. It enjoys the freedom
of expression. Immediate feedback or response is possible. Helps communicate effectively with
small groups of people. Body language can be effectively used. Ideal for access to illiterates.
Repetition can be used for emphasis.
Limitation or demerits or disadvantages: For a legal point of view, it has little value as there is
not permanent record. For long distance communication, it is difficult to use it without access to
telephone or other instruments. Revision and review are difficult. It is difficult to trace
responsibility.
Written Communication:
Merits or advantages
It provides a written record. It can serve as a legal document. There are less chances of missing any
point. There is more scope for analysis and evaluation. Highly technical topics can be presented
using words and diagrams. Written material provides a permanent record that can be referred to
from time to time or passed on to others. Written material can be duplicated in large quantities or
distributed on the Internet relatively inexpensively. It is easy to distribute written material to
People seldom take the time and effort to read technical materials. The preparation of written
documents is time-consuming. Once prepared in large quantities, printed documents are difficult
to change. Written material provides little feedback for the sender. Technical documents are often
too long and complex for the majority of readers. A portion of the population may not be able to
read written material. Too much reliance on written material as a communication method may
obscure (not know) the true needs of potential users.
Oral Written
It is free from all formalities.
It is formal in nature.
Oral communication cannot Being permanent in nature, it can
serve as an evidence because no be preserved to prove evidence.
record can be kept.
According to Neuro Linguistic Programming (NLP), (7 percent verbal (words) 38 percent vocal
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 8
(volume, pitch, rhythm, etc) 55 percent body movements (mostly facial expressions).
Or
“We cannot not communicate”
Paul Watzlawick, a renowned communication theorist stated that it is not possible not to
communicate. He considers all human behavior as communication.
Or
How would you justify the “Mehrabian Model” which says that in communication: 7%
of meaning is in the words that are spoken, 38% of the meaning is paralinguistic and 55%
of the meaning is conveyed through facial expression?
A positive body language includes smile, open posture, forward lean, eye contact,
gestures and nods.
❖ Silence: Silence can convey our feelings and thoughts. One can communicate better with
silence than with spoken words. A short silence or a pause between spoken words and
sentences is used to emphasize a certain important point of communication. A skillfully
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 11
placed pause during conversation has the power to make the listener more alert. Silence can
be a positive or negative influence in the communications process. It can provide a link
between messages. It can create tension and uneasiness or create a peaceful situation.
Silence can also be judgmental by indicating favor or disfavor - agreement or disagreement.
Silence can be very embarrassing if it is not possible to interpret it. It can be awkward in a
group, when no one knows how to break it. On the telephone, it can cause much discomfort,
as one cannot see the other and therefore has no clue from facial expressions as to the reason
for the other’s silence.
• Tactile
• Visual ( Graphs, Maps, Charts)
• Auditory
• Olfactory
• Gustatory
❖ Visual: Graphs, Maps, charts, Sign and Symbol are all substitute for written words to enhance
the meaning is called visual aids. It creates greater impact on the viewer. It clarifies the matter
instantly. It requires less space and has to be specific with reference to the matter it presents.
This type of communication is quite useful as a traffic control device, for conveying ideas
related to Geography, for scrutinizing and comparing, for conveying more information in a
very short span of time. And auditory symbols are useful for conveying messages to the people
at distant places.
Limitations for Visuals:
It cannot convey lengthy messages
It is not elaborate.
Visual communication is not a two-way process.
❖ Auditory signals: may be single tones, sounds (mixture of tones), or spoken messages. Tones
and sounds may be continuous, periodic, or unevenly timed. They usually come from horns,
bells, sirens, whistles, buzzers, or loudspeakers.
❖ Olfactics(Smell): Olfactics is the study of nonverbal communication through scent and smell.
Although this is a much neglected aspect of body language, it is nonetheless important because
people give a lot of psychological significance to the way they smell and get attracted to those
whose fragrance appeal to them. That is why, in developed countries, people spend billions of
dollars on scent. Many people daily use scent, deodorant and aftershave apart from a lot of
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 12
antiseptics and sanitizers to smell pleasant. Body odors, especially with bad smell, repel people.
Many consider bad smell from mouth or armpits as unsophisticated and uncivilized.
❖ Gustatory cues: Gustatory is related to sense of taste. Gustatory communication allocates
positive or negative feelings regarding a particular food item. We are happy to eat our favorite
dishes. But during illness, the same food seems to be tasteless. The feelings linked with taste
may change with age. The distinctive flavor of a dish in a restaurant might remind you of
home cooked food and make you nostalgic.
Communication is not always successful. Several things can prevent the message from reaching
the intended recipient or from having the desired effect on the recipient is called as Barriers.
Mechanical
• Transmission interruption
• No access to vital machines/devices
• Power failure
• Poor maintenance/defects in
machinery/Noisy machinery
Psychological
• Status barrier
Linguistic/ Semantic • Unjust assumptions
• Different languages • Prejudice
• Faulty translation • Closed mind
• Use of jargon • Resistance to change
• Multiple meanings • Halo and horns effect
• Connotative & Denotative meanings • Emotions
• Different accents • Self-image
• External noise
• Physical stress
• Environmental stress
• Time/Distance
• Intricate lines of communication/Structure of organization
i)External Noise: It becomes very difficult to pass on the message orally, when there is external
noise. Sometimes loud music or traffic creates a barrier in the communication process.
ii)Physical Stress: Due to sleeplessness, ill health, consumption orally, when there is external
noise.
iii) Environmental stress: Wrong choice of font colours in a power point presentation might
cause strain to the eyes of the viewer and the message might not be received properly. Similarly,
high temperature, humidity, bad ventilation etc. may hamper the sending and receiving of
messages.
iv) Time: The difference between the time zones of two countries often acts as a barrier to
communication. So if an organization has clients in different parts of the world, communication
will be difficult, if both parties are not able to find a common time to communicate.
Distance: Physical barriers erected at work places like cubicles, cabins, partitions, large furniture
etc. can create the physical barrier of distance even in a small organization.
v) Intricate lines of communication: In large organizations, the chains of communication are
long and intricate. Thus increases chances of distortion, thus disrupting communication.
Overcome the physical barrier: 1)Open office plan 2) minimize noise 3)Use of technology
4)mutual adjustment 5) Providing environmental comfort.
II)Mechanical Barrier: These arises when means of communication becomes faulty or develop a
technical snag.
• Transmission interruption
• No access to vital machines/devices
• Power failure
• Poor maintenance/defects in machinery/Noisy machinery
1)Language barriers: Language Barrier takes place when two persons do not understand the
language of communication. Perhaps they are from different native background so their language
is different. Sometimes the use of technical terms also brings about the language barrier.
2)Faulty translation: Most of the times, it is seen that when people translate a language, they
apply the grammatical rules of their mother tongue to that language. This results in literal
translation of words without understanding the deeper meaning.
3) Use of Jargon: The term Jargon refers to specialized vocabulary that people to the same
professional group might use. It should be used only when communication with people belonging
to same profession. When used with a lay person, it may cause confusion and misunderstanding.
4) Multiple meanings: Very often the same word might mean different things. Example: I
pushed the missive in the letterbox after seeing the main door ajar.(Here, the sender has used
vocabulary which is beyond comprehension of the receiver)
In simple terms, I pushed the letter in the letter box after seeing the main door slightly open.
The language of the sender and the receiver must be a common language.
Avoid using jargon or special terms belonging to a profession.
Be sure that you have an adequate knowledge of the language.
Learn to organize your thoughts, feelings to be expressed coherently.
Try to achieve clarity of them before finding words to express them.
Try to avoid repetition of your message unless it is required for emphasizing the message.
Use direct, simple, short and meaningful sentences.
Give sufficient time to the listener to respond.
Every culture has its own beliefs and values, attitudes and dreams. A person has to adapt himself
to the cultural environment of that society which comprises of a particular life style, a typical
language, typical habits, festivals, religious practices, manners and etiquettes. Cultural differences
have to be merged and similarities have to be encouraged. This will result in more effective human
activities.
1)Language: There are billions of people in the world who do not understand English or cannot
communicate in English properly. Not speaking properly can cause various misunderstandings
2)Dressing: Each country has its own dress code for different occasions. Example: Indian women
like wearing Sarees here but they might wear skirts or trousers abroad. Not following the dress
code might invite disapproving looks and would cause prejudice in people’s mind.
3)Body Language: Every culture has its own rules about proper behavior which affect verbal and
non verbal communication. Keeping eye contacts or not, keeping appropriate distance between each
other and many more rules of politeness differs from culture to culture.
4)Food: People from different cultures have their unique food habits and preferences. Those who
prefer vegetarian food might not be comfortable sitting next to a person having non-vegetarian
food. Not only food but also manner of eating food differs. In India, people are comfortable using
bare hands to eat while in westerns countries they feel comfortable using spoons, forks and knives.
5)Use of space and time: In some cultures, people stand close to each other during
communication. For example: Arabs stand too close to each other during communication and they
often touch the other person. While Britishers are known to keep a distance and would feel
uncomfortable if people stand too close to them. Time: Some cultures are conscious of time and
punctuality is appreciated. While in other cultures, time does not play a very crucial role and being
late is socially accepted. Example: Americans get offended if guests reach late than the scheduled
time for occasions/meetings. Whereas in India and Middle East, time is treated more casually.
6)Stereotyping: It is the process of creating a picture of a whole culture, over generalizing all
people belonging to the same culture as having similar characteristics and categorizing people
accordingly. It is a belief about a certain group and is mostly negative. Stereotyping can be done on
the basis of many things like nationality, gender, race, religion, ethnicity, age, etc.
7)Attitude or Ethnocentrism: It is the process of dividing cultures as “us” and “them”. The
people of someone's own culture are categorized as in-group and the other culture is out-group.
There is always greater preference to in-group. There is an illusion of out-group as evil and
inferior. This evaluation is mostly negative. If the culture is similar to us, then it is good and if is
dissimilar, it is bad. Other’s culture is evaluated and assessed with the standard being their own
culture. Ethnocentrism affects the understanding of message, and encourages hostility(ill feeling).
V) Psychological Barriers:
The human mind is very complex and unsteady. It keeps on changing its thoughts and emotions.
The psychological barriers arise mainly because of inadequacies in Human nature and various
psychological states that take place in the mind of a human being. No two thoughts in the mind are
exactly same. Therefore, many communication gaps take place due to these changes in the human
mind or the human nature.
1)Status Barrier: Status is the official or social position or condition. Sometimes it is the status
which does not allow a senior or commanding person to frankly communicate with a junior or
lower status person. On the other hand, the junior feels awkward or pressurized to communicate
freely with the senior or superior.
But in some other cases because of status insecurity open or free communication does not occur
particularly between employer and employees. The status of a person does create a barrier in
communication.
2) Unjust Assumptions: Assumptions are personal inferences made by the speaker and not
factual Statements. Our bias, prejudice and opinions prompt us to make unjust or unfair
assumptions about others. Some people, have the superiority complex and they assume others to be
inferior in all respects. Such a feeling can create barriers in communication.
3) Prejudice: Prejudice means the preoccupied mind about some person or event. If the mind is
preoccupied, the person is always viewed in the same manner. In case of prejudice, good thoughts
of an unlike person are also not positively appreciated. Because of prejudice negative thoughts come
about a certain person and that hampers communication.
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 19
4) Closed Mind:
A closed mind is the one which closes itself voluntarily to any new idea, thought or information. It
simply refuses to accept or receive other person’s opinions or any other new information. Such a
mind will depend only on it own pool of thoughts.
A person is required to have an open mind free of any prejudice or bias first to receive any
knowledge. After receiving, the mind processes it, and decides which one to be retained and which
one to be forgotten.
5) Resistance to change: Some people strongly resist new ideas which are against their
established opinions or traditions or social customs. They may avoid new ideas because they feel
insecure or afraid of changes in methods or situations. People bound by traditions have their own
emotions, attitudes, standards and convictions and do not accept anything that goes against their
cherished ideas.
6) Halo and Horn Effect: We like some people (Halo effect) and dislike (Horn effect) some. We
have our own reasons to like or dislike them. We generally believe readily in those whom we like.
We trust them without much doubt. We not only listen to them intently but also get influenced by
them. On the other hand, we have no faith in those whom we do not like. We do not believe them.
We do not pay attention to what they say. Even when we try to pay attention when they say
something we do not accept it, though it may be crucial or beneficial to us. Moreover, we have a
tendency to overrate a person good-This attitude of mind is called as Halo effect and a tendency to
oppose ideas of people whom we do not like- such kind of attitude of the mind is called the Horn
effect. It becomes barrier in our communication with others.
Example of Boss
7)Emotions: The human existence has little significance without various emotions. There are
positive as well as negative emotions. The human mind is like a melting pot of all these emotions
which are in a constant flux of change. Happiness, joy, wonder, love, affection, appreciation,
empathy is some of the positive emotions. On the other hand, jealousy, hatred, anger, fear; are some
of the negative emotions. Our conscious mind controls our emotions. When emotions overwhelm, a
person cannot think.
Example: When a person gets angry he cannot think rationally. He uses words which otherwise he
may have never used. The result may be an undesirable misunderstanding. The listener may get
hurt and may get disturbed by the emotional outburst of the sender. Thus, emotions act as a barrier
in communication.
8) Self Image: Self image can explain the person’s attitudes and behaviors towards himself, his
work and life in general. He decides himself his likes and dislikes, his opinions, his principles and
his own behavior. The constant use of ‘I’ in his conversation with others reveals most of his
personality traits. Thus, he creates a certain image of himself not only in his own mind but also in
the mind of the listener.
May2002
Read the following case study and answer the questions that follows: (5 Marks)
Vinod was a foreman in a large fiberglass product factory. As he was talking to his employees, he
often talked in a very loud voice because he was talking over factory noise. Vinod was a very active,
aggressive man and always in a hurry. Madhu and Shyam were called in to Vinod's office for an
explanation of a new procedure. Vinod talked to them in the same very loud voice he used in the
factory. The loudness of his voice made it hard to concentrate on the message. Vinod was in a
hurry as usual. He talked very fast, didn't pause for questions, and left in a hurry. His parting
words were,"Please go back to the line and explain to your co-workers how we are going to
implement this procedure". Madhu and Shyam left his office very confused, frustrated and not
very knowledgeable about the new procedure they were assigned to implement.
(i)Why was Vinod's message so hard to understand? What suggestions would you have
for Vinod ?
(ii) How should Madhu and Shyam prepare for their next conversation with Vinod ?
(i)Vinod's message was too hard to understand because he was speaking in very high pitched tone
and speedily. He was not taking pauses between his though shifts. The loudness of voice made it
difficult to understand the message. As he was speaking too fast, the message became complex and
difficult to understand.
Vinod should moderate his pitch and should speak with a considerate speed. He should pause for a
while before shifting to next idea or instruction. Also, Vinod should ask whether the listeners are
understanding his conversation and should try to give the listener an opportunity to suggest
something or ask a doubt. Even if Vinod is busy. He should value the importance of effective
communication.
(ii)Madhu and Shyam should try to become assertive when they plan their next interaction with
Vinod. Madhu and Shyam can take down notes when Vinod is speaking. Moreover, they should
plan to meet Vinod. Because confusion will lead to chaos failure of plan or procedure. Also they
should try to ask Vinod a written copy of new procedure to be implemented.
State whether the following statements are true or false. (Write down only answers) (5
Marks)
(1)The living nature of the English language causes semantic barriers.
(2) Stage-fright is a very rare phenomenon.
(3)Crossing one's arms across one's chest is a sign of defensiveness.
(4) The first component in the process of communication is encoding.
(5) One should write to impress, not express.
(6)Written communication has legal validity.
(7)It is easier to change an opinion than to change a belief.
(8)Television is an example of a medium of communication.
(9)Pacing up and down the stage while speaking in public makes a good impression.
(10) One cannot not communicate.
Dec.2002
Read the following case example and answer the following questions. (5 Marks)
Jayantibhai, a Mumbai businessman, was quite impressed when, during his visit to Italy, he found
factory hands working to the accompaniment of soft music which was piped through the public
address system. He was quite determined, to introduce this 'modern innovation' in his factory in
Thane and did so immediately on his return from his foreign tour. He however forgot that the
machines in his factory were old and noisy. Moreover, as the factory hands would like only film
music it was this that was blared through the loud speakers. The results of the 'modern innovation'
were instantaneous decrease in efficiency and fall in production. The foremen and supervisors
could hardly talk to the workers, nor could the workers communicate with one another.
(i) Identify the various barriers in communication taken place between Jayantibhai and
his workers.
(ii) What would you suggest to achieve effective communication in the above case
example? (Write the answer in about four sentences).
(iii) Explain: 'Factory hands working to the accompaniment of soft music'.
Answers:
(i)Jayantibhai failed to understand the mood and likes and dislikes of the workers. Moreover, he
couldn't evaluate whether the introduction of music in his factory is practical from the overall
perspective. Forman and supervisors cannot talk to workers and vice versa. Jayantibhai suffered
from 'stereo type' and 'false assumptions'. On the contrary, workers couldn't understand the
importance of introduction of music.
(ii)Jayantibhai should conduct a meeting of all the staff working in the factory and he should
address the workers about the purpose behind introducing music in the factory. Secondly, he
should ask the workplace. Workers should also report their problems to Jayantibhai and also find an
alternative.
Dec. 2003
Read the following case study and answer the questions that follow:(5 Marks)
A student took a summer job in rural Maharashtra which involved interviewing farmers about
water supply availability. The first few days he went to the field wearing a suit and tie. He also
used a lot of technical words in his questions. He got little co-operation from the farmers. He
decided to change his strategy-he began wearing Kurta and Pyjamas and started speaking to the
farmers in native Marathi. The farmers were much more co-operative.
(i) Why do you think the farmers were uncooperative? What barriers do you feel were
operating at this point?
(ii) Why were the farmer’s cooperative later? What does this tell you about effective
communication?
Answers:
(i)There was lack of common frame of reference between farmers and the student (employee). As
the student’s appearance, language, and strategy of communication was beyond comprehension
level of the farmer, the farmers couldn't share mutual bonding with him. On the part of the
student and the farmers, the linguistic and psychological barriers were exercising a strong
Reference notes by: Dr. Joseph Rodrigues (FrCRCE) 22
influence in their communication. The student's use of high technical jargon was not
understandable for the farmers. Farmer’s couldn't share mutual understanding with the student
because his appearance (tie, shoes, etc.) created a 'cognitive dissonance' in the farmer.
(ii)The farmers were co-operative lather because the student used common frame of reference in his
communication with them. Also, farmers were happy to see the student wearing costumes likes,
they wear and speaking the language they speak. There was bond of association between the
student and the farmers. In effective communication, Medium and channel plays very important
role. The absence of common frame of reference can create barriers to communication.
May 2005
Identify the barriers in the following situations. How can they be overcome? (6 Marks)
(1) Dharamdas was never known to have made a mistake in his account and was well known for his
clear head for mathematical work. His manager was, therefore puzzled when he was told that
Dharamdas just could not work with the new calculating machine with which he was required to
work.
(2)Manager Prabhu believed that managers can only communicate with their clerks by using a
"Memo" paper. The clerks were used to receiving 'memos' for coming late, for not doing their work
properly, for taking leave without permission. Typist Gonsalves received a "Memo" of
congratulations when his first son was born. There is a lot of resentment.
(3) Mr. Babu had been a successful manufacturer for twenty years. He used glass containers for his
products. When a salesman visited him to show a new plastic container which was more durable
and which cost less. Mr. Babu refused to listen to him and mockingly asked the salesman if he
Answers:
(1) Mechanical barrier: Dharmdas should learn the techniques of using the new calculating
machine.
(2) Manager is suffering 'status' or 'attitude' (psychological barrier) problem.
While communicating with subordinates. Manager should know when to use oral communication
and when to use written communication.
(3)Mr. Babu is suffering from psychological barrier because he is showing resistance to change.
Mr. Babu should listen to the salesman properly and should be receptive to new ideas. Mr. Babu
should not try to become old stick in the mud.
Dec. 2005
(a) Identify the barriers in the following conversations, and discuss how you could
eliminate or overcome them. (8 Marks)
(i) "I don't agree with you. I have studied and taught this subject for years and I can't be wrong".
(ii) "I am not going to attend that lecture. The seniors say that the teacher is no good".
Answers:
(1) Psychological Barrier
Solution: (1) Be receptive to new ideas
(2)Psychological barrier:
Solution:
(1) Student should attend the lecture first and then form an opinion.
(2)"Heard melodies are sweet and those unheard are more sweeter" the student should understand
the importance of this statement.
May 2006
Answers:
(1)Status barrier (2) Noise barrier(3)Psychological(4) Linguistic
Dec. 2006
Identify the barriers: (10 Marks)
(i) Student unable to understand clear instructions in Hindi. (Cross-cultural barrier, language
barrier, status barrier).
(ii) A Nigerian not able to converse with Indian (cross-cultural barrier, semantic
barrier, physical barrier).
(iii) A wedding hall/ auditorium near a college building (linguistic barrier, physical
barrier, psychological barrier.)
(iv) A student unable to answer question paper even though well prepared
(Psychological barrier, status barrier, cross-cultural barrier).
(v) Inability of school children to understand President's speech (Status barrier,physical barrier,
environmental barrier).
Answers:
1.Language barrier
2.Semantic, Cross-cultural
3.Physical barrier
4. Psychological barrier
5. Physical Barrier
Notes: