Professional Documents
Culture Documents
((
Chemie
Ingenieur Research Article 1
Technik
A significant amount of global carbon dioxide emissions is due to steel mill gases. One promising approach for the reduc-
tion of these emissions is their chemical conversion. In this regard, the conversion to urea is very advantageous, since com-
mon urea processes are already using carbon dioxide as a feedstock. In the present paper, urea capacities are determined
that can be realized using steel mill gases. The capacities are estimated based on new process concepts that are presented
in this paper. Exemplarily, the steel mill of thyssenkrupp Steel in Duisburg, Germany, is considered. It could be shown that
reasonable urea capacities can be reached. By this means, a great impact can be made on the reduction of steel mill carbon
dioxide emissions.
Keywords: Ammonia, Carbon dioxide, Hydrogen, Steel mill gases, Urea
Received: March 27, 2018; revised: May 03, 2018; accepted: June 12, 2018
1 Introduction amount and composition of the steel mill gases are given.
Sect. 4 is dealing with the urea production applying steel
The steel industry produces considerable amounts of steel mill gases. Here, the amount of urea is determined that can
mill gases, which are resulting in high carbon dioxide emis- be produced from the steel mill gases in Duisburg. In this
sions [1, 2]. Hence, steel mill gases have a great impact on context, it is also determined how much carbon dioxide can
global warming. For the reduction of carbon dioxide emis- be reduced and how much hydrogen is necessary. Further,
sions, several approaches exist [3 – 5]. One approach is the the resulting plant capacities are compared with common
use of carbon dioxide in chemical plants [6], which is also plant capacities.
attractive for the chemical industry.
The long-term aim of the Carbon2Chem project is cre-
ating the basis for the reduction of carbon dioxide emis- 2 Conventional Urea Production
sions of steel mills [7]. This project considers exemplarily
the steel mill of thyssenkrupp Steel in Duisburg, Germany. This section gives an overview on the basics of conventional
As possible products ammonia, urea, methanol, higher alco- urea plants. An example of a urea plant is shown in Fig. 1.
hols, polymers and oxymethylene oligomers are taken into This plant was built for Yara in Sluiskil, Netherlands, by
account. On the one hand, the project deals with the devel- thyssenkrupp Industrial Solutions AG in 2011. In Sect. 2.1,
opment of relevant gas treatment technologies. On the oth- the process is described that is generally applied for the urea
er hand, innovative synthesis paths are developed, especially production. The subsequent section deals with the product
for the chemical fixation of carbon dioxide. Both topics are features and the urea market. In Sect. 2.3, typical urea plant
investigated in the technical center that was built recently in capacities are listed.
Duisburg.
Chemical fixation of carbon dioxide in the urea molecule
is already applied in industrial scale. Here, carbon dioxide is 2.1 Process Description
reacting with ammonia to urea. In conventional urea plants
generally natural gas, water and air are used as feedstock. In The process for large-scale industrial urea production can
2016, about 171 million tons of urea have been produced be subdivided into three steps. In the first step, synthesis
[8], for which 125 million tons of carbon dioxide have been gas, mainly consisting of hydrogen and nitrogen is pro-
applied. duced. In the second step, the Haber-Bosch synthesis is
The present article deals with urea plants based on steel
mill gases. The suitability of the gases from the steel mill in
–
Dr. Ömer Yildirim, Dr. Klaus Nölker, Dr. Karsten Büker, Dr. Ralph
Duisburg is analyzed. In Sect. 2, an introduction to conven- Kleinschmidt
tional urea plants is given. In this context, relevant process- oemer.yildirim@thyssenkrupp.com
es and typical plant capacities are listed. In Sect. 3, an over- thyssenkrupp Industrial Solutions AG, Friedrich-Uhde-Straße 15,
view of the steel mill in Duisburg is provided. Thereby, the 44141 Dortmund, Germany.
Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8 ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cit-journal.com
’’ These are not the final page numbers!
Chemie
2 Research Article Ingenieur
Technik
www.cit-journal.com ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8
These are not the final page numbers! ((
Chemie
Ingenieur Research Article 3
Technik
2NH3 þ CO2 Ð CH6 N2 O2 Ð CH4 N2 O þ H2 O (2) nium nitrate and the urea/water solution leaving the urea
synthesis.
The major part of urea production is urea granules.
This reaction requires an operating condition of approx. Compared to prills, granules show a better stability, which
15 MPa and 180 °C. The challenge for the urea synthesis makes them more suitable for bulk handling, shipping
design is to keep the very corrosive carbamate inside the and storage.
system under the mentioned conditions. This is among Non-fertilizer applications of urea are mainly further
others accomplished by return of the unreacted compo- processing to melamine or use as reduction agent for NOx
nents into the reactor, so that only urea and the by-product removal from combustion exhaust gases. In the latter applica-
water can leave the synthesis section. After evaporation of tion, urea decomposes into ammonia and CO2, after getting
water, the liquid urea melt is directed to the finishing sec- in contact with hot exhaust gases. NOx is reduced by reacting
tion, which usually is either a fluidized bed granulation or a with ammonia. Urea solution marketed for this purpose is
prilling unit. Both can produce solid, almost spherical urea also known as AdBlue or diesel exhaust fluid [14].
particles (see Fig. 3).
Table 1. Selection of ammonia / urea plants built by thyssenkrupp Industrial Solutions AG.
Samsung for Ma’aden Phosphate Company 3300 / – Saudi Arabia engineering & procurement 2011
Misr Oil Processing Company 2 and 3 2 ·1200 / 2 ·2000 Egypt turnkey 2012
Samsung for Fertil 2 2000 / 3500 UAE engineering & procurement 2012/13
Daelim for Ma’aden Phosphate Company 3300 / – Saudi Arabia engineering & procurement 2016
CFI Port Neal 2200 / 3500 USA engineering & procurement 2016
Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8 ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cit-journal.com
’’ These are not the final page numbers!
Chemie
4 Research Article Ingenieur
Technik
a selection of urea plants built by thyssenkrupp Industrial 4 Urea Production Using Steel Mill Gases
Solutions AG in the recent years.
In the following, the suitability of steel mill gases for the
production of urea is analyzed. As seen in Tab. 2, 45 % of
3 Steel Mill Gases of thyssenkrupp Steel the steel mill gases were used internally in the steel mill.
in Duisburg The residual amount of the gases (55 %) was fed to the
power plant for production of electricity. This case is shown
The steel mill of thyssenkrupp Steel in Duisburg consists in Fig. 4 (see ‘‘Base case’’).
among others of three main units: blast furnace, coke oven In order to determine the impact of the available gases on
and converter. In each of these units, a gas stream is gener- the urea plant capacity, two additional cases are considered.
ated. Exemplary, the data from fiscal year 2015/16 are dis- In Case A, shown in Fig. 4 and explained in Sect. 4.1, gases
cussed in this work. The features of these three streams can are considered that are currently converted in the power
be found in Tab. 2. In column
two, three and four, the volume Table 2. Steel mill gases of thyssenkrupp Steel in Duisburg, Germany, and its features. Trace
flow of each stream and their components are not shown.
composition are listed. Minor
Blast furnace gas Converter gas Coke oven gas Total
components are not considered
3 –1
in this article. In the last column, Volumetric flow [Nm h ] 1 780 000 98 000 152 000 2 030 000
the total amount of steel mill CO [vol %] 25 64 7 26
gases and their average composi-
tion can be found. CO2 [vol %] 23 17 2 21
In the steel mill in Duisburg, N2 [vol %] 48 14 6 42
all gases are either used for the
H2 [vol %] 4 5 63 9
operation of internal processes or
for electricity production in the CH4 [vol %] 0 0 22 2
power plants. The percentage of Gases to power plant [%] 60 0 43 55
the gas streams, that were used in
2015/16 internally, is listed in the Gases for internal processes [%] 40 100 57 45
last row of Tab. 2. As can be seen,
all converter gas is used for inter-
nal processes, whereas 40 % of
blast furnace gas and 57 % of
coke oven gas were used internal-
ly. In total, 45 % of the steel mill
gases were applied internally,
whereas 55 % of the gases were
used in the power plants.
As listed in the table, the steel
mill gases consist of 21 % CO2.
The utilization of the steel mill
gases for heating or power gener-
ation results in producing more
carbon dioxide, since CO and
CH4 are converted to CO2. In
addition to 21 % CO2, also
26 % CO and 2 % CH4 have to be
considered. This results in a total
volume flow of about
994 700 Nm3h–1 CO2, which cor-
responds to a mass flow of
1950 t h–1.
Figure 4. Utilization of steel mill gases in existing plant (Base case) and for two cases investi-
gated in the Carbon2Chem project.
www.cit-journal.com ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8
These are not the final page numbers! ((
Chemie
Ingenieur Research Article 5
Technik
plant. Therefore in Case A it is assumed that 60 % of the 4.1.1.1 Treatment of the Coke Oven Gas
blast furnace gas and 43 % of the coke oven gas are available
for a chemical plant, whereas none of the converter gas can The coke oven gas, consisting mainly of H2 and CH4 is sub-
be used. In Case B shown in Fig. 4 and discussed in Sect. 4.2, jected to a pressure swing adsorption (PSA) to extract the
it is assumed that all gases are available. For the internal valuable amount of H2. The remaining CH4-rich stream
process, natural gas must then be imported as a substitute can be used as fuel elsewhere. The specification of the H2 is
for steel mill gases. 99.9 vol %. Since oxygen is a poison for the catalyst used in
For Case A and Case B a conceptual design is presented. the ammonia synthesis, all remaining oxygen-containing
In both cases, a synthesis gas with a molar ratio of H2 to N2 compounds are removed in the next step (cf. Sect. 4.1.1.3).
equal to 3 is required for ammonia synthesis. On this basis,
the amount of usable steel mill gases and the urea capacity 4.1.1.2 Treatment of the Blast Furnace Gas
are determined. In Sect. 4.3, all cases are discussed and the
The blast furnace gas, containing mostly of CO, CO2 and
CO2 emissions of Case A and Case B are compared with the
N2, needs a more complex treatment. First, the gas is
CO2 emissions of the base case. In Sect. 4.4, the impact of
cleaned by adsorption. In preparation of desulphurization,
external hydrogen sources on the urea plant capacity is
organic sulfur compounds are catalytically hydrogenated to
investigated.
form hydrogen sulfide (H2S). H2S is finally removed from
the gas stream by chemisorption on a sulfur guard material
(e.g., ZnO) in one or more adsorber vessels. This sulfur
4.1 Case A
removal step is comparable with the treatment of natural
gas at the inlet of conventional ammonia, hydrogen or
The process for the production of urea from the steel mill
methanol plants.
gases can be subdivided into the following steps:
Also proven in ammonia plants is the water-gas shift
1) synthesis gas generation,
(WGS) unit, in which the bulk of the CO in the gas is con-
2) ammonia synthesis,
verted to CO2 and H2. Due to constraints by kinetics and
3) urea synthesis and finishing.
equilibrium the exothermal WGS is designed to take place
The main process units are shown schematically in Fig. 5
in two subsequent vessels with cooling in between, first at
and described in the following.
high temperature and then at low temperature. For the high
temperature WGS, heating to approx. 350 °C is required.
4.1.1 Synthesis Gas Generation The heat can be recovered in a gas/gas heat exchanger
Blast furnace gas and coke oven gas from the steel mill are downstream of it in order to be used for preheating to the
separately treated due to their different composition and are required inlet temperature.
then mixed to form synthesis gas, consisting of H2 and N2 The gas, now consisting mostly of H2, N2 and CO2, is
in the ratio required by the stoichiometry of the ammonia cooled down to a temperature range between 50 and 70 °C,
synthesis. Both gas streams need to be compressed at first suitable for entering the CO2 removal unit. For its principle
in order to enable reasonably small equipment sizes and an of operation refer to Sect. 2.1.1. For the Carbon2Chem
optimum performance. project, the absorption by an amine-water solution is se-
lected as it is more energy-efficient and environmentally
friendly than other processes. This process is commercially
proven in large-scale ammonia produc-
tion. Most of the CO2 is released near
ambient pressure with a purity of ap-
prox. 99.9 % (mole dry), which is suitable
for the urea production.
Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8 ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cit-journal.com
’’ These are not the final page numbers!
Chemie
6 Research Article Ingenieur
Technik
4.1.2 Ammonia Synthesis furnace gas it is undergoing the same treatment as described
in Sect. 4.1.1.2. Compared to Case A, a higher amount of
This part of the process is almost identical to that of a natu- H2 can be produced.
ral gas based ammonia plant, where ammonia is formed as For determining the urea capacity, similar assumptions as
described in Sect. 2.1.2. The steam produced from its waste in Sect. 4.1.3 are used. For the converter gas, it is assumed
heat is used as process steam in the CO-shift reaction and that 90 % of the H2 and 90 % of the N2 can be recovered.
as driving steam for various turbines. Since some inert gases Regarding the coke oven gas and the blast furnace gas, the
are expected, a purge gas stream is foreseen similar to plants same assumptions as in in Sect. 4.1.3 are applied.
based on natural gas. The coke oven and the converter gas can be used com-
pletely. The correct H2/N2 ratio is adjusted by adding
4.1.3 Urea Synthesis and Finishing approx. 5 % of the available blast furnace gas. Limiting ele-
ment is the H2 content of the coke oven gas, again. The
The urea process, destined for application in the
analysis resulted in a urea capacity of 3500 t d–1.
Carbon2Chem project, is not different to any commercial
urea process, using ammonia and CO2 as feedstock. There-
fore, the urea synthesis corresponds to the process
4.3 Discussion
described in Sect. 2.1.3.
In order to estimate the urea capacity, it is assumed for
First of all, the urea capacities determined from Sect. 4.1
the blast furnace gas that 90 % of the H2 and 90 % of the N2
and 4.2 are compared with common capacities from Sect.
can be recovered and are available for ammonia production.
2.3. The capacity of Case A is a bit lower than common urea
Regarding the treatment of the coke oven gas in the PSA, it
capacities. In Case B it is possible to reach a urea capacity of
is assumed that H2 is recovered with a rate of 78 %. In addi-
3500 t d–1, which is comparable with common capacities
tion, it is assumed that the conversion to NH3 and Urea is
(cf. Tab. 1).
100 % each.
Regarding the evaluation of Case A and Case B, also the
The coke oven gas is rich in H2 and lean in N2. The full
CO2 balances must be considered. One major aim of the
quantity that was applied in the power plant can be used
Carbon2Chem project is to determine the potential of urea
(43 % as per Tab. 2). N2 is added by blast furnace gas. The
plants on the reduction of carbon dioxide emissions. For
calculations have shown that about 2 % of the blast furnace
this a life cycle assessment needs to be carried out [15, 16].
gas can be used in order to provide a synthesis gas with a
On the one hand the consideration of the conventional urea
ratio of H2 to N2 of 3. The limiting factor is the H2 content
production from natural gas, water and air is required. On
in the coke oven gas. The calculations resulted in a urea
the other hand, the base case from Fig. 4 needs to be taken
capacity of 850 t d–1.
into account. In the present work, only simplified balances
are considered to determine, which urea capacities are rea-
4.2 Case B sonable.
For the urea production of 850 t d–1 (35.4 t h–1) in Case A
The same process as described in Sect. 4.1 can be applied approx. 25.9 t h–1 carbon dioxide is used. This amount can
when the converter gas is added as a third gas source (see be related to the total carbon dioxide emissions determined
Fig. 6). This gas is rich in CO. After mixing with the blast in Sect. 3 (1950 t h–1). The ratio is about 1.3 %. This value
gives information about how much car-
bon dioxide reduction is in principle
possible with Case A. Hereby, the carbon
dioxide emission resulting from the ener-
gy consumption of the urea plant itself is
not considered. It is assumed, that the
consideration of this would not change
the general statement. As mentioned
above, a life cycle assessment must be
performed for proper analysis.
Regarding the carbon dioxide balances
of Case B, the amount of chemically
bounded carbon dioxide is about
106.7 t h–1. The ratio of this value to the
above mentioned total carbon dioxide
emission is 5.4 %. In Case B, the energy
Figure 6. Block diagram for the production of urea from blast furnace gas, converter use of the internal steel mill processes
gas and coke oven gas (Case B). must be compensated. For this, addition-
www.cit-journal.com ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8
These are not the final page numbers! ((
Chemie
Ingenieur Research Article 7
Technik
al natural gas needs to be used. By considering this, about This paper has shown that reasonable urea capacities can
3 % carbon dioxide reduction can be achieved. be reached using the steel mill gases from the steel mill in
As per reaction (1) for the production of ammonia stoi- Duisburg. Further, it could be shown that urea plants can
chiometrically three times more H2 is necessary than N2. make an impact on the reduction of steel mill carbon diox-
However, in steel mill gases, much more N2 is available (see ide emissions. In the current work simplified carbon diox-
last column in Tab. 2). For this reason, the urea capacity ide balances were used. In subsequent works the impact on
and the CO2-reduction potential are limited by H2 availabil- the carbon dioxide emissions will be analyzed by using life
ity. For high carbon dioxide conversion external hydrogen cycle assessment.
is necessary.
Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8 ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cit-journal.com
’’ These are not the final page numbers!
Chemie
8 Research Article Ingenieur
Technik
DOI: 10.1002/cite.201800019
Research Article: Considerable amount of carbon dioxide emissions are related with the
steel production. In steel mills different gases are produced, which are currently used in
power plants. The present work analyzes the potential of their use in urea plants. In this
context, different cases are considered, which are compared with respect to carbon dioxide
reduction and resulting urea plant capacity. ........................................................ XXX
www.cit-journal.com ª 2018 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018, 90, No. 10, 1–8