Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction
fig. 1
key social activi sts, Huh Chong-suk, Chu Se-chuk, and Park
Won-hui are particularly worthy of mention.
With her modem education and
scientific knowledge, the New Woman
carried on a new lifestyle in terms of
clothing, food and home. More than
anything, though, what identified a New
Woman from a trad iti ona l one was her
style of clothing. What she wore became
a key detenninant in fixi ng her identity.
A photo of Park Esther wearing a Gibson
Girl-style jacket and glasses reveals that
she is modem. Western and different
fig. 2
(fig.2). However, the typical 1920s attire
:Jflt":<: for a New Woman was not Western attire,
~ but a short or pleated skirt and a longer
version of the short Korean jacket, or
fj£. chogori , whieh was influenced by the
II Vi He-chang, 111.111 'guk sisa mal1ltwa jip (Korean Cartoons for current
affairs)," 1982, 136-1 37.
12 Kim Ki-rim, IJom ui JOllg'ryong (Messenger for Spring), v.S. 305.
13 Vom Sang-sop, Nohimm muot ul odonmmga (What have you
,jchieved), Nim'um-sa, 1974,214.
Being Modern: Representing the 'New Woman' 229
and 'Modern Girl' in Korean Art
to reproduce her image within defined, pri vate spheres only, such
as in domestic interiors or in enclosed gardens, that which
feminist art hi storian Griselda Pollock calls a space of
femininity. 14 Thi s indicates the difficulty artists had with
portraying the new image of a woman that departed radically from
that of the traditional woman. In the modem era, self-portraits and
fi gu res were genres newl y added to the traditional landscape and
still life . Most figure paintings of me n tended to be self-portraits
or portraits of artists' fri ends. Figure paintings of women,
however, consisted of anonymous generi c types and carried titles
such as " Woman Reading," "Woman Knitting," or even simply
"Woman." Despite thi s objectification of women, the number of
women figure paintings far outnumbered those of men, and
became a popular subj ect. There are a few different reason for this.
First, when Western painting was introduced in Korea in the
1910s, it mainly consisted of works by Impression ist artists who
loved to paint women in their daily li ves, whi ch then influenced
the Korean art scene. Second, Japanese Nihonga , especially
Bijinga (, Painting of Beauty ' ) began to infiltrate from the time of
colonization. Thirdly, using a live model was a new method of
painting, and modern artists were the ones privileged to take
advantage of this method.
14 Griselda Pollock, " Modernity and the Space of Femininit y," Visio n
and Dinerence, Routledge, Lond and New York, 1988, 50-90.
230 Young Na Kim
15 Chong Yo-sop, " lIje chiha-e itsoso hall" guk yosong-c dachan kyo'yuk
chongchek kwa ku johang-e kwan' han yon'gu (The stud y of educational
po licy and its resista nt movement in Japanese Coloni al period)," Asia
Yosong YOII 'gll , v.9. December, 1970,9.
Being Modern: Representing the 'New Woman ' 231
and 'Modern Girl' in Korean Art
of the fi gu res are very Westem. In addition , the man and the
woman show an equal relationship.
More tha n anything else, the New Woman 's trademark was he r
bobbed hair, which was tenned 'short-cut hair' for a time. Y i
Kwae-dae a nd Kil Jin-sop's Young Woman (fig.12l shows two
young ladies with their hair in a bob and
with Westem features. From its incepti on,
the bob faced serious opposition in society.
In 1895 Choi Ik-hyo n and othe r
Confuciani sts stood in front of the royal
gates and sent up a petition to Kin g
Kojong dcclaring. "Though yo u cut o ur
th roats, we w ill ne ve r c ut off our
topknots I " This demonstrates the degree to
t. which tradition and modernity were
fig. 12 divided by the symbo l of long or short hair.
It also suggests a breakdown o f gender bounda ries. The woman
who c ut her hair made ambig uous thc di stinction between her and
her male counterpart s, as well as betwee n the yo ung wo man with
her long braid a nd the ma rried woma n with he r bun .
Some say the first so-called " bobbed beauty" was the female
e ntertainer (ki saeng) Kang Myo ng-hwa, wh ile others say it was
Ka ng Ha ng- ran, also a ki saeng, w ho later became a soc ial acti vist.
Soon the reafter. educator Kim Hwa l- Ian . writer Kim Myong-sun.
dancer Choi Sung-hi and othcrs also c ut their hair in bobs. thus
mak ing it a symbol of the New Woman. The pros and cons of thi s
new hairsty le appeared in a variety of newspapers and magazines
and became the talk of the town. Kim Hwal-Ian desc ribed it as
hygienic, pretty, economi cal, li berating. and in line wi th world ly
16
trends.
In the 1930s as the number of arti sts increased, many pOl1raits
o f wo men in interiors wea ring Westem clothes were produced.
The leading artist of the time, Yi In-song, mostl y depicted wo men
in the countryside in traditional dress for the works he submi tted
From the end of the I 920s, the media 's interest turned to the
New Woman 's new manifestation, ' Modem Girl ' . The term
' modern ' had beco me a household wo rd by thi s time. 'Modem '
was a catchword used not only for Modem Girl and Modern Boy,
but al so for ' modern bread ', ' modem rea l estate ', ' modern
sc ience' , and so on, in anything that represent new culture. The
definiti on of a Modern Girl as found in a modern language
dictio nary of 1930 is as follows: "The definition of modern is ne w,
or contemporary, so Modem Girl means new woman , or
contemporary woman , and Modern Boy refers to the same except
it concerns the male .... usuall y Modern Girl or Modem Boy has a
negati ve, derisive connotation . Thus, the terms often refer to a
delinquent young girl or boy. Recently, the term modern has been
replaced by the word ' chic ' . It is super modern. Ultra modern."I '
This fresh kind of New Woman ineluded femal e stude nt s.
office workers, cafe girl s, tea room waitresses,
shop clerks, hair sty li sts, factory workers, bus
ticket sellers, telephone operators, and others who
for the most part had to support their fam ilies
(fig. 19). As worki ng women, however, they
gained economic power and enjoyed the life of
modern consumers who could freely think fo r
themselves. Modern G irl , unlike the original New
Woman, was not endowed with any association
with enlightenment or social consc iousness. But
she was potentially more th reatening to trad itiona l
ethics. The ne w urban working class that was the
fi g. 19
1930.
Being Modern: Representing the 'New Woman' 237
and 'Modern Girt' in Korean Art
basis of Modem Girl usually broke away from their controlling
familics and as working women often had much social contact
with men. Soon , the image of modcm girls constructed in the
media not only replaced the New Woman 's reformed traditional
dress with Western clothes, but also gave
them a new identity with the bob cut,
pointy shoes, heavy make-up, and as avid
j fo llowcrs of fashion with disorderly sex
lives. A good example of this is the cover
of the September 1929 issue of By ol
KOl1koll, where a healthy, attractive, and
bobbed Modem Girl and a Modem Boy
are pictured wa lking sprightly togethe r in
front of a big city backdrop (fig.20). Thc
woman's bu lg ing breasts, cinched waist,
fig. 20
and healthy thighs showing through her
flare sk irt exemplify the diffe rcnce between Standing Beauty
paintings of the past and modern renditions of the physical form
female in arousing male desire. This attractive yo ung woman
became a new paradigm for the Korean woman.
However, most people fclt that their li festyle was consumer
oriented and hypersensitive to trends and fads , so the often
frivolou s-seeming Modern Girl was viewed quite negatively . Thc
tenn Modern Girl was popular in Japan in the 1920s, and it secms
that perhaps the image was synonymous with that of the flapper in
the WesL I • The flapper in the 1920s United States was the kind of
woman who wore thin, short dresses and bobbed hair, who was
savvy and independent, and who practiced unrepressed cxpress ion
of her sexuality . From a 1927 Chason I1bo article (June 26), wc
see that at the time, Modern Girl and flapper had essentiall y the
same mcaning to the people. It reads, " Four or five years ago in
the United States, it was popular to call a young, beautiful woman
20 Kim Jin-song, Seoul e dance hallul "ohara (Permit the Dance Halls in
Seoul), Hyon'sil Munhwa Yon'gu, 1999,260.
" Ibid. , 210.
22 Kim 8yong-ik, "Chajol ui munhak kwa cafe girl (The Literature in
frustration and Cafe Girl)," Hall 'gllk Mlilldallsa (The History of Korean
Literary Circle), Ilji-sa, 1973, 154.
240 Young Na Kim
5. Conclusion
AI ztul~oJl 1.1 ~ oj A.J 9.1 >Hit!.g. ell ill' T- 7 ~"1 -lj'- °t5'- LJ--l'-oJ ~ T ~ t:~.
;;N t":- 'll'5- A1:&'!1- 0loJZ!- %oJ~2f 191O\iell oJl AI ~!t! A1°J~f2~ >f.g.
:il-8-\J I ~% %oIVlol:il, t:fe '*+t":- ~lt-9.I 1I"~fLJ- uJ-~f. cH'6-'lf"I9.1 If.
"I~f. 'iJ-:il, A~ ~~ '6-{)% "~ t":- cH '6-*H· '5- ~ "<l -'f-°lt:f. :il-8-ol ~9.I
"<l-'f-, 'll%ol~oJIA1 9.1 ojA.j 01\J1 "1 ~ oj "J 711 lll~"f'BA1 i:' cH:cj ojA.j 01
DI"I5'- 1t"H'Ai~t":-7fi!f ::: "doH It-'11'li717f -'t!t:f'B, ~lt-:&9.1 "~l..f 5'
'll%9.I.oJ~~:cj~5'-~4~~.~q *~. ~ ~~~>f.g.cH '6- ~~
9.1 "<l-'f-oJlt":- :J. 4;-A.j~ A~§j9.1 't!-% ~ ~AJ- % t:j "PJ~~5'- 't!-'l! ~ T
~t:ft":- 'lioJ1A1 :il-8-ol ~~t":- t:fe ~ 'B~ >lI AI ~t:j
-'f-cjLJ-,,!-oJIAj ~ojA.j0I\,! %oJ 7f ~1 g ::; "J- ~ -5l.g. 1 9!O\'!cH~'11 , 3'.1[!-
~~ .9l u lOl]Ai {!~"'Jol~ °P·JiiIll:tJ-.f?:-%~ =r~J-~ {!o:J"'J~~, {!~ jR~%
W :il ~1i~ . oJ~ ~ ,,!-£~oj~~~.~ t":- <>Icj£*olLJ-*~i % ~
{! O:1-"'J %%.£.-¥- .¥..~it!-t:l-. 3:. ~J-71 {!et1AJ~ 9-.£ .:r-~~oJ1Ai 191O\:!r.ij
"f"l 'lJ-!"-°ILJ- AjOJoJIA1 i:' cH"1 Jo!~-% W71LJ- "t419.1 21 "t{::! Jo!Af%ol 'II
~ .iC.-if7]:t}oJ1Al iC.4-% ~.g- ~T ~ ~Cl §. o:jAj% 7re\71Jl <U ~ tfr\1,
2O\i<l1 +';,]:'I'- EC1 §j "~"'I 'i:! 7J'0It:f. £q 7,:l.g. jO~J-719.1 'lll
%oJ t":- ' £q
cj 5."1~ ~ojA.j :i!~ t":- t:fg ~-li-9.I ~oV.j~ 5'- oj~'~, oj Af-'l'-!(!, 7f>l1 ~
°1LJ- ol-lFf -'8- 'M l..f§ 9.I "<l>ll il:j-l} 7f"l:il i:' cH 5::" I 'H[ ~ "Ur"f:il
"f%-'T9.I "i Af:il~ ~t":- "l'llojA.j% 9.lul~t:f. 1 930\icH ~ 'd+8Il A1 {joj
A.joJl cH~ "1 ~ 01 :il a:£1 ~t":-'11. °11.171::: 1920\icH9.I It-~f A,j5t17f ilLJ-
.Jl ~ tfr~~ ), l-~~.!f-1 717 } -c~ .li!.4-1l- ~o} 'cl-:q1% qL~i>} .Jl o}o] %%
~ tl-5!. t":- 11 01 °1~ ?4~ ojA.JAJ-ol"!-t":- ~£ oJ"'l9.1 °1'1I -&-5'- 717f ~.~!t!
1.1715'- {jojA.J°I"ft":- -§-oJ 5!.t:ft":- 5!.t:f 'F\';I "j~ -§- oJ~ ~cHojA.j°I"f t":
-§-oJ 7f cj ~ol Af%"'1 ~ t:f.
(Ilc: lrtf~ :fy1Y. "'~ ) '.p ~ "5IL lo-lz lv ~R j" jn ~It)~ lo -'H~ {Y
RolOn. %ltJ& t!r% '6'iYlv ~ I".j')d~ .w1"lo .wH) llofyltJi' l'Ofy l<>[v 'b
to I<> loH< ~ 10% IYIoILIi> .w li) llo j~iR k~~ 1'O{.l:[l,-ji 'ltJli .w it) llo-:}
"2Hy jolol• .wltJ llo~'" ~lloiYlv 1'0%10 ~Rjejn {-fvtoiY '.p l o~ {Y
-=eri-'L -3- I!"-{II 20!:Y:~~ Ikllo-~T6 ·1n Po ii['Llldo IOFL RtE ~:~ ~Yl:o IY
H~m- ~ 1~~Ha17IY ~2HY % Ir -t'k 'iIrU lot2tL '1~~ 1iTY i}lo~~)C-k R:
loj'£ ?r.g. 'i1I~ ~ ~lt.l5rr ~ UO % 1'L~- ~fo -:;: %lg {f~ ~-IR ",'Jfo ~
i9- j!"-l:J'jr;lo~.fO ~ tY- lrJlo Bd~FfiR ~yj;'d~:5-:2 K i!?-?Y~ {} -IT1~ 10-&'&
-wlt:l llofyp;,[v ·{LI~~HII %IiJ ~(.<?o ~ 1:1R~ld gi!" ~~ R 1~ -3-i11\l: 1~t!
["'%11< "5~jo .(11" ~ [}j1Fi~y j[5 If< l"ltJ~ ;:; j"lg;~", 'lin -i} l,yiloR>
~ ~ j" ji ~~ %~ i:o i1fo lloiHy Ir la lo lofvl<> iY 10~ln"2 IY loli)i'
'j:lil R' Ro IH 21<> Ii
lzt.o -a-to.f]t Ill!¢. i5" K: ·W%~ ~ ~~ * ~.: k % {}-:I\ lo lt~lY 'Hoi1 *{z 'it
I::t ~i fv .:;'d~ Iv 1~ i1 I0 ~ ~YS 1i! fy 1:0 iY !-Y [Io:f" -c I~ {y to IY 1~ ",:1 'tol 0 ~
lilil" 10fH;Hl- [ol" fo-& ~IIoIg jYi= ~ "5~ j o 'joVI~15ro% 1019,- jy 1o0i0
%~ltJ ~ Io~~~~.ltJ~~~"5.I R ~lO~ . [o.%%to~~~
III ~ 15.tojE "5l>:jo 10fYlf'f~ tofYl<> kilolti{.l: l'O joo-l< 't!rf', iW"2 lo 'j:l
~lofY/'l:S: -I< I'O-U. kIYfR.fHy I'O -~ Io ~l:1R I'O;:; [Otz~ lo ~ Hl llofy
l<>iY ~ li< oio Ro~ "§-l:1 lof,] frli IYlloli'<'Ho -~ I o If)fo r '.p~loi:oiJ, Ro:P;
~~ ~ lli -l~lloi¥ 1~1L lor)( ~ 10113 -2: ii!*D KH'I-~ ::l lloty% -~'- 1l}. -O ~ 'tv
l i~ 1i! {lc~ ~<~Io ~ 1210fYtoiY [.vlloMn ~Io ~l~ ~Z~ lo{; 10 l>dn 10
··!:1t¢; -6-Er ~l'bfo -9 ~ rr* -~ IY- tlllo lofY~B- l~dlo.g.R>.fnPo ·~to~~rY.
I>: 1~ lL ~1~lnlo l'Ofvtolv %i~* ilo il~Hn"'- I<) {'. Io ~P; lo 1"' -n 12{.'o 1:J
llo .s {d~ fv 111d~1n :>l:J7i-'t1d~ ';>' li,lfy ';>'{"' {~ ii" 'blol~ g,i" ~ 1~- f..
iY IJ iWii ~1" lalo'lo rY toiY ~I<>,~-'b [.vlIoM" .£ lll H~III llo ~ I" .,",~
·-l::t·'{b·fd bd·~-5 ~ ;; llo~R>. 0t19lr lofY ~.QIY ~:lP;fo [10Ft
.£ IOl~iR 1~-i'f 1ol:. {Y N"(K.6 l '-;!k -~ ~lHf *fvM~ lo~lo K@-~, -¥i-olo
-lollr, B- lofY~fY .:a-§-ld§ ?Yi"\ 2o !i: 7}li '-l1 0 ~-l!?- «~JoL IO % i~"3" -tf~~ HY
-f, fyt.o ;;t!i!-1~{} ita-a- 'fyt"o ';;'-{~ ~Y-5 '-b'!o e.' leL" 'd- fY~fY loHlf, ~Yllo
-to '~ lo -~ :5"10111 -l1Io·~fY~ lol!'Ft ro!i~[X 3" ~yf:j\lu-=t %fjl!u -li! rvl f ~'
IIr. Uo·~ [ o ;:H!i!-lyl{:i ·tt.i~ fy t.o '5"2[!Y 'IC1-'?-1~~ -"§..j}["2% li l·l: -;?r -b... ·~H L~· ln
' I:1Y~ iT ~l<>ri -:± l\J-j';: i~~- Io '6'R>lIy I'O FvtoiY f'd311 H~ lu~ dY l o l\J~
W ueaJO>I UI Y8 ~,
£V': pue ,UIllDM MaN, alI! ooljuasaJdatj :U~ 00188