No, Humans Didn't Evolve From

the Ancestors of Living Apes

The last ancestor that we shared with apes had
its own set of traits, and was different from both
us and modern apes.
Marcia Wendorf

The truth is that we don't know where we, homo sapiens, came from.
In his 1871 work, In The Descent of Man, Charles Darwin speculated
that humans originated in Africa, and that we evolved from an
ancestor who was different from any currently living species.

Now, a new study by an international group of paleoanthropologists,

with a wide range of specialties, have backed up Darwin by
concluding that it is likely that the last ancestor that we shared with
apes had its own distinct set of traits that are different from those of
both modern humans and modern apes.
Who was this ancient ancestor?

Chimpanzees, with whom we share 98 percent of our DNA, are in

genus Pan, while humans are in genus Homo. Humans diverged from
chimpanzees between 9.3 and 6.5 million years ago.

Historically, two major approaches have been used in analyzing

human ancestry:

Top-down - uses living apes, especially chimpanzees, to

reconstruct our origins
Bottom-up - uses the fossil record of both humans and apes; it
shows multiple possibilities both for what the LCA looked like,
and where he roamed.

In reviewing the studies surrounding these diverging approaches, the

authors of the paper argue that there are limitations to relying on just
one or the other of these opposing approaches. This is because the
top-down studies often assume that modern ape species share
habitat and features of earlier groups, while bottom-up studies tend
to give individual fossil apes a more important evolutionary role than
may be warranted.

In an attempt to reconcile these approaches to identifying our

ancient ancestor, the scientists looked at what the environment must
have been like for the Pan-Homo last common ancestor, or LCA. 

The Miocene epoch existed from around 23 to 5.3 million years ago,
and a number of fossil ape genera from that era have been found.
However, they show a combination of features common to both
"orthograde” (upright) and “pronograde" (walking on all fours) body
plan, which has led some scientists to exclude the Miocene apes
from the human lineage, and there is no scientific consensus on the
evolutionary role played by these fossil apes.
The journey from monkeys to us. Source: Almécija/AAAS

Some scientists espouse the theory that some Miocene apes

dispersed out of Africa and into Eurasia, approximately 16 to 14
million years ago, before the hominins diverged from apes. Some of
these apes gave rise to the line that produced orangutans, and the
European "Dryopith" apes, while others returned to Africa where
they evolved into modern African apes and hominins. Others
interpret dryopiths as broadly ancestral to hominids or as an
evolutionary dead end.

Most Popular

During the late Miocene period in Africa, increased habitat

fragmentation may have led to the evolution of African ape knuckle-
walking, and hominin bipedalism, or walking on two feet, from a
common orthograde ancestor who lived in the trees. Walking on two
feet might have allowed our human ancestors to adapt their diets
and locomotion, and escape the  “specialization trap” that kept other
apes in an arboreal environment.

The study concluded that future research efforts should focus on

looking for Miocene ape fossils in areas where they have yet to be
found. The scientists also concluded that data-driven modeling
should take precedence over trying to fit evolutionary scenarios to
every fossil find.

Hominin fossils have been found in eastern and central Africa, and
possibly also in Europe. Fossils of over 50 genera of ancient apes
have been found in Africa and Eurasia, however, as Dr. Sergio
Almécija, a researcher in the Division of Anthropology at the
American Museum of Natural History told Sci-News "... there is no
scientific consensus on the evolutionary role played by these fossil
apes."

Kelsey Pugh, one of the study co-authors, added that, "The unique
and sometimes unexpected features and combinations of features
observed among fossil apes, which often differ from those of living
apes, are necessary to untangle which features hominins inherited
from our ape ancestors and which are unique to our lineage."
Miocene ape fossil locations. Source: Source: Almécija/AAAS

Where do we go from here?

The new study seems to put us back to square one as to where we

came from. Every ancient religion has its own theory of how we came
to be. Giorgio A. Tsoukalos, better known as "the hair guy," who is a
producer of the show "Ancient Aliens" on which he often appears,
theorizes that humans arose due to visits made to Earth made by
ancient aliens. Tsoukalos shares those opinions with others including
Erich von Däniken, Zecharia Sitchin, and Robert K. G. Temple.

Like the lyrics in British band The Who's 1978 song "Who Are You?"
Well, who are you? (Who are you? Who, who, who, who?)
I really want to know (Who are you? Who, who, who, who?)
Tell me who are you? (Who are you? Who, who, who, who?)
Because I really want to know (Who are you? Who, who, who, who?)
we'd all like to know who our ancient ancestor was and how we came
to be.