Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and delaying
AOD uptake
by young
people.
Background paper
adf.org.au
Preventing and delaying AOD uptake by young people • 1
© Alcohol and Drug Foundation 2020
Disclaimer: The Alcohol and Drug Foundation has used its best endeavours to ensure that material contained in this publication was
correct at the time of printing. The Alcohol and Drug Foundation gives no warranty and accepts no responsibility for the accuracy
or completeness of information and reserves the right to make changes without notice at any time in its absolute discretion.
2
Contents
Preventing and delaying alcohol and other drug uptake by young people
Background 5
Conclusion 23
References 24
6
Addressing multiple
domains of influence
There are many interconnected factors, or domains, that
influence a young person’s health, wellbeing and development.
Peers, family, social activities, and school are all elements that
can influence behaviours.
Understanding the risk factors and the protective people’s leisure time, strengthening relationships
factors related to AOD harms within each of these between parents, and parents knowing where their
domains, and how they can be influenced, is young person is, are all factors that have been
crucial to ensure health and wellbeing in young demonstrated to have positive effects in reducing
people is optimised. alcohol and other drug use. 7
This includes understanding protective factors to Risk factors, or factors that may increase the
reduce the likelihood of - and at what age - they likelihood of a young person experimenting with
might begin using alcohol and other drugs. AOD use, have also been identified.
Many different elements influence the strength These include difficult family environments, low
of protective factors and, in any one community school engagement and negative peer influences.
multiple factors often combine to produce best
By identifying both the risk and protective factors,
case outcomes.
families and communities can work together to
Activities such as participating in organised sports, reduce AOD harm and delay uptake of alcohol and
increasing parental involvement in young other drugs among young people. (See Table 1)
8
Models of prevention of
AOD harm among young
people
Several international models that recognise the complexity of the
factors that influence AOD use among young people have been
developed. Two well-known models are the Plant Youth Icelandic
Prevention model and the Communities That Care model. Both
group the factors into a number of domains, influenced by the
broader environment.
10
Evidence for
interventions
Interventions that seek to prevent, or delay, AOD uptake among
young people focus on strengthening protective factors in each
of the domains as well as influencing the broader environment.
This section looks at the evidence for interventions in each
domain.
A systematic review and meta-analysis of peer-led
interventions to prevent tobacco, alcohol and/or
drug use among young people aged 11-21 years
Peer domain identified 17 eligible studies representing 13,706
young people from 220 schools.11 This review could
In adolescence, people typically become more not compare or assess the various types of peer
involved with peer friendship groups and activities interventions to identify the most or more effective
and have more unsupervised time, including time types, nor could it identify the most effective
outside the home. Peer influences are an important sites for action or the most effective duration
factor in this domain. of programs. Nor were all the studies positive or
neutral in outcome. In two studies the intervention
Peer support
group increased their use of substances over the
A peer support relationship is based in the equality control group.
of the participants. It centres around support
The authors concluded that peer interventions
and connection being provided by someone who
have a role to play in preventing alcohol and drug
is relatable and potentially more credible to the
use among adolescents, but they noted that their
young person as a member of their peer group.
findings were limited as they could not identify
Peer programs comprise activities led by peers of effects on socio-economic, gender and ethnic
the same age or older age in formal and informal subgroups.
settings such as schools, community centres, and
Analysis of six of the studies supported an
youth clubs.11 In education settings they are usually
association between peer-led interventions and
one component of a larger program, rather than a
lower odds of alcohol use and a meta-analysis
sole intervention.4
of three studies suggested peer-led interventions
Evidence supporting this approach reduced cannabis use. The authors noted, however,
that their findings were limited by poor quality
There is evidence for peer support approaches that evidence, recognising a need for more rigorous
is promising,5 however, program design should be studies with a longer follow up period.
mindful that some peer support initiatives may
lead to an increase in AOD use.4, 5 Research further suggests that, if implemented,
peer-led interventions should be part of a larger
program of prevention and not stand-alone
programs.
12
One such campaign, ‘Stop the Supply’, aimed to Evidence supporting this approach
increase knowledge of the laws around purchasing
There is some evidence about the effectiveness
alcohol for minors (secondary supply) and
of youth mentoring to prevent or reduce young
encourage parents to think again about doing just
people’s use of alcohol and other drugs, although
that. This program is yet to be formally evaluated;
some researchers have found that existing studies
however, a survey report found that 36% of
are at risk of producing biased results, and that
respondents were not previously aware of the
individual studies have had mixed findings.17, 18
secondary supply legislation. 15
Generally, the research record for mentoring has
Social marketing and community mobilisation
produced inconsistent results and insufficient
to reduce alcohol-related harms
robust research has been conducted to enable
Communities That Care, in partnership with a definitive conclusion about the effects and
Deakin University, is developing and trialling a the circumstances in which the effect is found.
social marketing campaign which seeks to educate Although there is a dearth of research into
parents and young people about the National Australian mentoring programs there is a body of
Health and Medical Research Council’s drinking resources that mentors can draw on to inform their
guidelines. The campaign objective is to convince work.19, 20
parents and young people to make an agreement
One research analysis of 46 studies published
that parents will not supply alcohol to people
between 1970 and 2011 reported some positive
under 18 years.16
benefits of mentoring on behavioural outcomes of
Mentoring young people, including AOD use.18 The authors
could not identify the type of program that was
Overview more effective than others.
Mentoring is a relationship between a person with Another study examined the results of four studies
less experience and a person with more experience, that were of sufficient quality for analysis. Two of
often a young person and someone who is slightly these found mentoring prevented alcohol use and
older. one found mentoring prevented drug use.17
The relationship is often focused on the older Other studies have variously found lower rates of
person (mentor) providing support and guidance alcohol and other drug initiation among mentees,
to the younger person (mentee) based on their reduced alcohol initiation (but not other drug
experience and skills. initiation), no effect on alcohol or cannabis use,
and no effect on ‘substance use’.17 The research
The mentor is not paid or expecting personal gain
suggested that a component which might make a
in exchange for this support.17
mentoring program effective include a focus on the
While mentors may be either formal or informal, mentor providing emotional support.5
formal mentoring arrangements are typically
the type that is subject to evaluation, therefore
Parenting programs
contributing to the evidence-base. The term ‘parenting program’, is often used
interchangeably with other terms such as ‘parent
Mentoring programs may be run in a number of
education’ or ‘parent training’.
settings, such as through an in-school program,
an after-school program, a weekly meeting in a Parenting programs aim to provide parents with
community setting, or online. Mentoring programs opportunities to enhance their knowledge, skills
may provide training and ongoing support for the and understanding in order to improve both
mentor. child and parent behavioural and psychological
outcomes. Parent programs typically focus on
14
Preventing and delaying AOD uptake by young people • 15
Leisure domain A study conducted in Norway suggests that
the impact of sport participation on alcohol
How young people spend their leisure time may consumption may differ depending on the type of
influence their use of alcohol and other drugs. sport; for example, team sports may be associated
with higher alcohol consumption than individual-
Having significant unsupervised and unstructured
based sports.30 However, more research is needed.
time, such as attending unsupervised parties,
increases the risk of alcohol or other drug use. An earlier research paper, that examined
participation in supervised activities (including
Being engaged in structured and supervised
sport as well as other activities like scouting,
activities or hobbies could potentially reduce the
rescue squads, etc.), found that participation in
risk of alcohol and other drug use.
such activities was associated with lower levels of
Supervised extracurricular activities alcohol consumption.31
The provision of supervised leisure options for This paper particularly emphasises the importance
children may prove protective against alcohol and of supervised activities, as unsupervised
drug use, theoretically because of the potential to adolescent activities are risk factors for alcohol use
increase the protective factors of: - this includes going to parties or hanging out in
the city on nights and weekends.
• participation in positive activities with adult
engagement
• positive role models, including around AOD
• sense of belonging/connectedness to
community.
An interesting aspect of the Icelandic Prevention School domain
Model is the provision of leisure activity cards
Schools can play a role in preventing and delaying
for use by young people aged 6-18 years.29
the use of alcohol and other drugs by young
These provide free access to a range of diverse
people.
activities, such as dance, sport, and music through
registered providers, regardless of the young Initiatives to do so may seek to increase protective
person’s socio-economic background. factors, such as enhancing a person’s sense of
belonging and connection to their school.
Evidence supporting this approach
Schools can also ensure they implement evidence-
Evidence on the impact of extracurricular activities
based drug education programs as part of their
on alcohol consumption by young people is mixed.
broader alcohol and other drug strategy.
Research often looks at sport specifically as a
protective factor, although supervised recreational Whole-of-school approach
activities are not limited to sport only.
Overview
A body of research, conducted primarily in
the USA, found that participation in sport A whole-of-school approach takes a holistic view of
was associated with an increase in alcohol the school environment, recognising that student
consumption, and in some studies earlier initiation health and wellbeing is the result of complex and
of alcohol use.30 overlapping factors.
This same body of research also indicates that This approach identifies the substantial social
participation in sport may be associated with lower learning which happens outside of the classroom
levels of other drug use. as a critical component of, and key outcome from,
a person’s school experience.
16
The culture of a school, and student’s day-to-day The selection of an evidence-based drug education
experience at the school, are important factors program is also important because some programs
that inform a child’s health and wellbeing. These have been found to increase drug use. 36, 37
may be leveraged to create a warm and supportive
Drug education programs are either delivered to
environment for young people.
all students, regardless of level of risk (universal) or
Evidence supporting this approach designed for adolescents and young people who
may be at greater risk of AOD harm (selective).
While the evidence specific to the impacts of a
whole-of-school approach on alcohol and other Universal programs, such as Climate Schools
drug use is somewhat mixed, some evidence has (outlined below), have the advantage of being able
shown small improvements in health measures, to reach large numbers of participants at relatively
ranging from increased physical activity to low cost; but this can lead to minimal impact.
reduced bullying.32
Selective programs, such as Preventure (outlined
In terms of protective factors, some studies have below) can be tailored to reach those that may be
suggested that school initiatives which specifically at greater risk; but this approach may be more
improve student participation in the school and expensive and lead to stigmatisation.
encourage a positive school culture are associated
Climate Schools
with reduced alcohol and other drug use.33
Alcohol and other drug education in schools It comprises 12 x 40 minute lessons which address
the use of alcohol and related problems. A
Current and effective school-based drug
psychostimulants and cannabis module - over six
education explores students’ values, attitudes,
lessons - for Year 9-10 is also available.
knowledge and skills with the aim of improving
their capacity to make healthier decisions about In each lesson, students view a cartoon-style story
using alcohol, tobacco and other drugs. of teenagers grappling with real life situations. The
cartoon is followed by classroom discussions and
Typically delivered as part of health education,
student interaction exploring the topic covered in
school-based alcohol, tobacco and other drug
the story.
education aims to increase students’ self-efficacy
to refuse alcohol, tobacco and other drugs and Evidence supporting this approach
equip them with knowledge and skills to reduce
harms.34, 35 Climate Schools has been shown to increase
students’ alcohol knowledge, decrease their
A note about drug education in schools positive expectancies about alcohol and reduce
alcohol consumption.
Evidence-based drug education can play a role
in preventing or delaying the use of alcohol and At 12 months follow up, there was a reduction in
other drugs by young people. Although the positive weekly alcohol consumption and the frequency of
impact of drug education on individual students’ excessive drinking.38
drug use is generally small, access to appropriate
and accurate information about alcohol and other A Climate Schools module that combines
drugs is still important. education on alcohol with cannabis was also found
to reduce alcohol consumption; reduce frequency
SHAHRP is a classroom-based program that aims The young people then participate in workshops
to reduce alcohol-related harm and prevent high tailored to their personality trait. The program may
risk drinking among students in Year 7-8, and Year be successfully delivered by trained school staff.
9-10 – a time that research suggests is a vulnerable
Developed in Canada, and adapted for the
period for alcohol experimentation.
Australian classroom, Preventure is a school-
The program takes a harm reduction approach, based, selective prevention program that aims to
with an emphasis on interactive skills building and reduce alcohol and other drug use among selected
individual and group decision making. students in Year 7-8 and Year 9-10.
SHAHRP is based on the social influence approach Students identified through a screening
which understands that young people begin to use questionnaire as at-risk are invited to participate
drugs due to psychological and social pressures in two x 90-minute groups, delivered by a trained
from peers, family and the media. facilitator and co-facilitator in a classroom
setting (training is now being offered in Australia).
The intervention comprises 17 interactive, skill- The workshops are designed to encourage an
based activities in year 8 with 12 follow-up understanding of how a student’s personality style
activities in year 9. Activities include problem- can influence their emotions and behaviour.
solving and rehearsal tasks in which students
develop and rehearse harm reduction, help- Four different workshops are available, each
seeking, making safety plans, decision-making focused on the development of coping skills
about situations involving drug use, as well as relevant to the four higher risk personality traits.
discussions based on scenarios suggested by
students.
Evidence supporting this approach
18
Local community and The campaigns did not appear to be effective in
reducing alcohol consumption; although they did
the broader environment
not claim to be designed to target consumption. 47
The broader environment, mass media campaigns
The Australian ‘Alcohol, Think Again’ campaign
and the local community can have a role to play in
demonstrates promise as an effective method to
preventing, or delaying, the uptake of alcohol and
increase awareness, decrease parental supply of
other drugs by young people.
alcohol and improve knowledge of guidelines and
Initiatives to do so may seek to address risk factors evidence. 48
in a community, such as the high availability of
Long term harm reduction mass media campaigns
alcohol, by increasing awareness of AOD-related
have shown some success in areas such as the
harms and reducing accessibility and promotion.
reduction of alcohol-impaired driving and the
Mass media campaigns aimed at young reduction of tobacco uptake among young people.
people These campaigns were accompanied by a range of
policy interventions, such as reducing accessibility
Public health efforts sometimes include mass to tobacco for minors.
media campaigns to share information and
encourage behaviour change.44 The successes of these campaigns demonstrate
that for mass media to be effective, a long-
Depending on the campaign and the target term investment is required, and they must be
audience, this may be done through channels accompanied by other policy measures. 46
ranging from television and social media to print
and outdoor advertising. Various campaigns Mass media campaigns should be undertaken
have been run in Australia by state and federal with caution, as there are concerns that some
governments to prevent illicit drug use. campaigns are ineffective and may inadvertently
produce a backfire effect.45, 49
Caveat about campaign approaches
Availability of alcohol
Some campaign approaches, such as those which
use alleged ‘before and after’ photos of so-called The availability of alcohol refers to how easy it is to
drug use-related transformations can stigmatise get alcohol in an area.
people who use drugs and reinforce negative
The availability of alcohol is affected by factors
stereotypes.
such as how many venues sell alcohol in an area
Evidence supporting this approach (outlet density), the opening hours of those venues,
and the age for legal purchase of alcohol.50
There is insufficient evidence on the effectiveness
of mass media campaigns in preventing the use of Outlet density
illicit drugs by young people to draw conclusions.45
Liquor outlet density refers to the number of licensed
This is due largely to ineffective or poorly designed
liquor vendors in a given area, including bars, pubs,
evaluation of campaigns. 46
clubs, etc., as well as packaged liquor outlets (i.e.
Research into alcohol-focussed media campaigns, bottle shops).
demonstrated high recall of the campaigns and
The evidence for the impact of liquor outlet density
a positive impact on knowledge, attitudes and
on underage drinking is mixed.51
beliefs about alcohol consumption – although
their impact on young people was not specifically Some international studies have found a significant
examined. relationship between outlet density and drinking
or heavy drinking among young people, whereas
other studies have found no relationship. 51
20
quasi-regulatory and self-regulatory regimes with competitions and discussions around appealing
limited or no involvement of government. cultural topics.
22
Conclusion
Adolescence is a complex time of growth, development, new
influences, expanding boundaries and personal discovery for
young people.
It is also a time of vulnerability and a time when By identifying risk and protective factors within
evidence-based interventions to prevent and each of these domains, AOD workers, families,
reduce the harms associated with alcohol and schools and communities can work to reduce
other drug use may have the greatest impact. AOD harm and early uptake among young
people.
The Alcohol and Drug Foundation strongly
supports the implementation of community The changing environment will also have an
and school-based initiatives to prevent and influence.
delay AOD uptake by young people – however,
Key factors such as the availability of alcohol
it cautions that these programs must be
within a community, ease of access, promotion
evidence-based and should consider the broad
of alcohol through advertising, sponsorships
range of interconnected factors – or domains –
and social media will continue to create new
that together influence a young person’s health,
challenges.
wellbeing and development.
New initiatives, resources and further research
The ADF has expanded upon on a range of
will be required to identify effective approaches
proven models to produce a Framework of
to counteract their negative influence in the
Risk and Protective Factors for 12-17 year-olds
future.
in Australia, anchored around the following
domains:
24
22. Carver H, Elliott L, Kennedy C, Hanley J. Parent– 33. Fletcher A, Bonell C, Hargreaves J. School effects
child connectedness and communication in relation on young people’s drug use: a systematic review of
to alcohol, tobacco and drug use in adolescence: An intervention and observational studies. Journal of
integrative review of the literature. Drugs: Education, Adolescent Health. 2008;42(3):209-20.
Prevention and Policy. 2017;24(2):119-33. 34. Teeson M, Newton NC, Barrett EL. Australian school-
23. Petrie J, Bunn F, Byrne G. Parenting programmes based prevention program for alcohol and other
for preventing tobacco, alcohol or drugs misuse drugs; A systematic review. 2012;31.
in children <18: a systematic review. Health 35. Foxcroft D, Tsertsvadze, A. Universal multi-
Education Research. 2006;22(2):177-91. component prevention programs for alcohol misuse
24. Patton G, Sawyer S, Santelli J, Ross D, Afifi R, in young people. . 2011(9).
Allen N, et al. Our future: a Lancet commission on 36. G H. The social impact of Life Education: Estimating
adolescent health and wellbeing. 2016;387. drug use prevalence among Victorian primary
25. Kumpfer KL, Pinyuchon M, de Melo AT, Whiteside school students and the state wide effect of the Life
HO. Cultural adaptation process for international Education program, . 1996;91.
dissemination of the Strengthening Families 37. G H, Garrard J, Dunt D. Does Life Education's drug
Program. Evaluation & the health professions. education programme have a public health benefit?
2008;31(2):226-39. 1995;90.
26. Molgaard V, Spoth R. Strengthening Family Program 38. Vogl L TM, Andrews G, Bird K, Steadman B, Dillon
for Young Adolescents: Overview and Outcomes. P:. A computerized harm minimization prevention
Residential Treatment for Adolescents and Youth. program for alcohol misuse and related harms:
2001;18(3):15-29. randomized controlled trial. . 2009;104(4).
27. Gorman DM. The decline effect in evaluations of 39. Champion K, Newton N, Teesson M. Prevention of
the impact of the Strengthening Families Program alcohol and other drug use and related harm in the
for Youth 10-14 (SFP 10-14) on adolescent substance digial age: what does the evidence tell us? Current
use. Children and Youth Services Review. 2017;81:29- Opinion in Psychiatry. 2016:242-9.
39.
40. Newton NC, Andrews, G., Teesson, M. and
28. Burn M, Lewis A, McDonald L, Toumbourou J. An Champion, K. Universal internet-based prevention
Australian Adaptation of the Strengthening Families for alcohol and cannabis use reduces truancy,
Program: Parent and Child Mental Health Outcomes psychological distress and moral disengagement: a
from a Pilot Study. Australian Psychologist. 2019. cluster randomised controlled trial. . 2014;65.
29. Reykjavik Co. The Leisure Card [Available from: 41. Midford R. MJ, Lester, L., Cahill, H. Foxcroft D.,
https://reykjavik.is/en/leisure-card. Ramsden, R., Venning, L., Pose M. Preventing
30. Kwan M, Bobko S, Faulkner G, Donnelly P, Cairney alcohol harm: Early results from a cluster
J. Sport participation and alcohol and illicit drug randomised, controlled trial in Victoria, Australia
use in adolescents and young adults: A systematic of comprehensive harm minimisation school drug
review of longitudinal studies. Addictive behaviors. education. 2014;25.
2013;39. 42. Newton NC, Conrod PJ, Slade T, Carragher N,
31. Thorlindsson T, Bjarnason T, Sigfusdottir ID. Champion KE, Barrett EL, et al. The long-term
Individual and community processes of social effectiveness of a selective, personality-targeted
closure: a study of adolescent academic prevention program in reducing alcohol use and
achievement and alcohol use. Acta sociologica. related harms: a cluster randomized controlled
2007;50(2):161-78. trial. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry.
32. Langford R, Bonell C, Jones H, Pouliou T, Murphy 2016;57(9):1056-65.
S, Waters E, et al. The World Health Organization’s
health promoting schools framework: a Cochrane
systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public
Health. 2015;15(1):130.
26
65. Jernigan D, Noel J, Landon J, Thornton N, Lobstein T.
Alcohol marketing and youth alcohol consumption:
a systematic review of longitudinal studies published
since 2008. Addiction. 2017;112:7-20.
66. Morgenstern M, Isensee B, Sargent JD, Hanewinkel
R. Attitudes as mediators of the longitudinal
association between alcohol advertising and
youth drinking. Archives of pediatrics & adolescent
medicine. 2011;165(7):610-6.
67. Fleming K, Thorson E, Atkin CK. Alcohol advertising
exposure and perceptions: links with alcohol
expectancies and intentions to drink or drinking
in underaged youth and young adults. Journal of
health communication. 2004;9(1):3-29.
68. Association AM. Alcohol marketing and young
people: time for a new policy agenda. ACT; 2012.
69. Anderson P, De Bruijn A, Angus K, Gordon R,
Hastings G. Impact of alcohol advertising and
media exposure on adolescent alcohol use: a
systematic review of longitudinal studies. Alcohol
and alcoholism. 2009;44(3):229-43.
70. Curtis BL, Lookatch SJ, Ramo DE, McKay JR, Feinn
RS, Kranzler HR. Meta‐analysis of the association
of alcohol‐related social media use with alcohol
consumption and alcohol‐related problems in
adolescents and young adults. Alcoholism: Clinical
and Experimental Research. 2018;42(6):978-86.
71. Kelly S. Sponsorship activation in Esports: a content
analysis of alcohol, energy drinks, junk food and
gambling category sponsorship. Canberra; 2019.
72. Jones SC. When does alcohol sponsorship of sport
become sports sponsorship of alcohol? A case study
of developments in sport in Australia. 2010.
73. Hurtz SQ, Henriksen L, Wang Y, Feighery EC,
Fortmann SP. The relationship between exposure
to alcohol advertising in stores, owning alcohol
promotional items, and adolescent alcohol use.
Alcohol and alcoholism. 2007;42(2):143-9.
74. Education FARE. Annual alcohol poll 2018. 2018.