Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Demartek Storage Networking Interface Comparision
Demartek Storage Networking Interface Comparision
Demartek
This version of the Demartek Storage Interface Comparison report is provided in ABOUT THIS REPORT
an active PDF format. With this format you are capable of viewing and interacting
with the information in ways not available with standard PDF readers. To get the Because of the number of storage interface types and related
most out of this guide we encourage you to upgrade to the latest version of the technologies that are used for storage devices, we have
Adobe Acrobat Reader.
compiled this summary document providing some basic
information for each of the interfaces. This document will be
updated periodically. This document may become larger over
time. Contact us if you’d like to see additional information in
LEGEND this document.
NEXT
Advances to the next page
LAST
Returns to the previous page
Demartek provides real-world, hands-on research and analysis by focusing on
industry analysis and lab validation testing of server, network, storage and
security technologies.
PRINT
Provides print options for the document
Demartek provides a few handy reference documents based on work
performed in the Demartek Lab. These documents are updated periodically.
CLOSE To get more information visit:
Closes the window containing this icon
Demartek
INTERFACE COMPARISON TABLE
Number Maximum Interface Transfer Rate Interface
Cable Type
of Devices Distance (m) Device (MB/sec) Attributes
10 (copper)
16M Copper 100, 200,
FC 10KM+ HBA 400, 800, Dual Port
(optical) Optical 1600, 3200
10 (copper) Copper CNA
FCoE 16M very long 1150, 4600 Dual Port
(optical) Optical 10GbE NIC
15 (copper) Copper 1000, 2000,
Infiniband HCA Full Duplex,
48M very long
Optical
4000, 7000,
Dual Port
(optical) 12,500
Ethernet Copper
iSCSI Many cable NIC, HBA 100, 1000, ///
distance Optical 4000
SAS
16K 10 Copper Onboard, 300, 600, Full Duplex,
(passive) HBA 1200 Dual Port
SAS Onboard, 300, 600, Full Duplex,
(active) 16K 20 Copper
HBA 1200 Dual Port
SAS
16K 100 Optical Onboard, 300, 600, Full Duplex,
(active) HBA 1200 Dual Port
Overhead Applications
8b/10b 20% 1GbE, FC (up to 8Gb), IB (SDR, DDR & QDR), PCIe (1.0 & 2.0) SAS, SATA, USB (up to 3.0)
64b/66b 3% 10GbE, 100GbE, FC (10Gb, 16Gb, 32Gb), FCoE, IB (FDR & EDR), Thunderbolt 2
*Throughput rates are single direction. For bi-directional (full duplex) rates, double the data rates.
Ethernet FC FCoE Infiniband iSCSI NVMe SAS SATA SMB/NFS Thunderbolt USB
12 12 123
*All interface speeds listed are single direction. Some of these interfaces can also operate bi-directional or full-duplex mode. For bi-diractional, double the rates.
Demartek
CONNECTOR COMPATIBILITY
Different connectors and connection technologies are used for the Two different connectors are now available with the Express Bay
various storage interfaces. Connector Backplane. The SFF-8680 connector is the traditional
connector for devices that use the existing SAS and SATA interfaces.
SAS and SATA connectors were designed to be as compatible with The U.2 (SFF-8639) connector is used for newer technologies such as
each other as possible. On devices, the SATA connector has a gap NVMe, etc., that connect to the PCIe bus and do not use the tradi-
between the data portion of the connector and the power portion of tional interfaces.
the connector, as shown in the illustration. The SAS device connec-
tor does not have a gap. This is because SAS devices need to carry The SATA Express Connector Mating Matrix indicates which type
more information regarding dual-port, wide-port, etc. A SAS back- of SATA, SATA Express and SAS cables and receptacles can be used
plane connector can accept SAS or SATA devices. together.
MULTI-MODE FIBER (MMF) Newer multi-mode OM2, OM3 and OM4 (50 µm) and single-mode
OS1 (9 µm) fiber optic cables have been introduced that can handle
Has an optical core of either 50 or 62.5 and supports
tight corners and turns. These are known as “bend optimized,”
distances up to 600 meters, depending on transmission
“bend insensitive,” or have “enhanced bend performance.” These
speeds and transceivers.
fiber optic cables can have a very small turn or bend radius with
minimal signal loss or “bending loss.” The term “bend optimized”
multi-mode fiber (BOMMF) is sometimes used.
Meter-for-meter, single-mode and multi-mode cables are similarly
priced. However, some of the other components used in single- OM5 fiber-optic cable, known as wideband multi-mode fiber
mode links are more expensive than their multi-mode equivalents. (WBMMF), transmits four wavelengths (colors) simultaneously
using short wavelength division multiplexing (SWDM) to achieve
When planning datacenter cabling requirements, be sure to consid- 100Gbps (4 x 25Gbps) transmission on a single-lane connection.
er that a service life of 15 to 20 years can be expected for fiber optic OM5 carries at least four times more capacity than OM4 over the
cabling, so the choices made today need to support legacy, current same distance. When configured in four parallel lanes (four sets of
and emerging data rates. Also note that deploying large amounts of fiber), transmission speed can reach 400Gbps.
new cable in a datacenter can be labor-intensive, especially in exist-
ing environments. OS1 and OS2 single-mode fiber optics are used for long distances,
up to 10,000m (6.2 miles) with the standard transceivers and have
been known to work at much longer distances with special trans-
ceivers and switching infrastructure.
Demartek
CABLES: FIBER OPTIC & COPPER (cont.)
Update: 24 April 2012:
Addendum 1 for data center fabrics
The Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) Engineer-
ing Committee TR-42 Telecommunications Cabling Systems has 16- and 32-fiber MPO-style connectors
approved the publication of TIA-942-A, the revised Telecommu-
Category 8 twisted pair cable, expected to support
nications Infrastructure Standard for Data Centers. A number of 25GBASE-T and 40GBASE-T applications.
changes were made to update the specification with respect to
higher transmission speeds, energy efficiency and harmonizing A new OM5 fiber-optic cable type (wideband multimode fiber
with international standards. For backbone and horizontal cabling or WBMMF) that supports short-wave wavelength division
and connectors, the following are some of the important updates: multiplexing (see TIA-492-AAAE)
10GBASE-LR
These are the “long reach” fiber optic cables that support
Update: June 2017: single-mode fiber optic cables and connectors.
The TIA approved for publication the TIA-942-B data center cabling
standard at its June 2017 meeting. This standard includes several
updates from Revision-A including: Indoor vs. Outdoor Cabling
OM1 OM2 OM3 OM4 1 OM1 cable is not recommended for 16GFC, but
is expected to operate up to 15m
1 Gbps 300m 500m 860m ///
2 Gbps 150m 300m 500m ///
Distances supported in actual configurations
4 Gbps 70m 150m 380m 400m are generally less than the distance supported
by the raw fiber optic cable. The distances
8 Gbps 21m 50m 150m 190m shown here are for 850 nm wavelength multi-
mode cables. The 1300 nm wavelength multi-
10 Gbps 33m 82m Up to 300m Up to 400m
mode cables can support longer distances.
16 Gbps 15m 35m 100m 125m OM5 distances will be added to the table later
1
this year.
25 Gbps /// 20m 70m 100m
32 Gbps /// 20m 70m 100m
Demartek
CABLES: FIBER OPTIC & COPPER (cont.)
Copper Cables: Active Copper vs. Passive Copper Copper: 10GBASE-T and 1000BASE-T
Copper cables are available in passive and active designs. Passive 1000BASE-T cabling is commonly used for 1Gb Ethernet traffic in
copper cables consume no power and have shorter reach. Active general, and 1Gb iSCSI for storage connections. This is the familiar
copper cables include components that boost the signal, reduce four pair copper cable with the RJ45 connectors. Cables used for
the noise and work with smaller-gauge cables, improving signal 1000BASE-T are known as Cat5e (Category 5 enhanced) or Cat6
distance, cable flexibility and airflow. These active copper cables (Category 6) cables.
consume some power and are more expensive than passive cop-
per cables. From a distance perspective, active copper cables reach 10BASE-T cabling supports 10Gb Ethernet traffic, including 10Gb
longer than passive copper but shorter than fiber-optic cables. The iSCSI storage traffic. The cables and connectors are similar to,
copper cables, both passive and active, typically include a connector but not the same as the cables used for 1000BASE-T. 10GBASE-T
or transceiver mounted directly on the cable. cables are Cat6a (Category 6 augmented), also known as Class EA
cables. These support the higher frequencies required for 10Gb
Passive copper cables are very common in datacenters and are fre- transmission up to 100 meters (330 feet). Cables must be certified
quently used in configurations with top-of-rack (“TOR”) switches for 10GBASE-T compliance, and is typically deployed in Europe.
because even at the higher speeds, passive copper cables can usu- Cat6 cables may work in 10GBASE-T deployments up to 55m, but
ally reach the full height of a rack. Many newer datacenters are de- should be tested first. 10GBASE-T cabling is not expected to be de-
signed in such a way to keep cable lengths short to take advantage ployed for FCoE applications in the near future. Some newer 10GbE
of lower-cost passive copper cables rather than use more expensive switches support 10GBASE-T (RJ45) connectors.
active copper cables.
10GBASE-CR - Currently, the most common type of copper 10GbE
The newer speeds of some interfaces are expected to increase the cable is the 10GBASE-CR cable that uses an attached SFP+ connec-
use of active copper cables over time. tor, also known as a Direct Attach Copper (DAC). This fits into the
same for factor connector and housing as the fiber-optic cables with
Copper Cables: Distances SFP+ connectors. Many 10GbE switches accept cables with SFP+
connectors, which support both copper and fiber-optic cables. These
Passive copper cables, depending on the rated speed, typically are cables are available in 1m, 3m, 5m, 7m, 8.5m, and longer distances.
in the single-digit meters in terms of distance. Active copper cables The most commonly deployed distances are 3m and 5m.
can typically reach into the low double-digits of meters. As the data
rates increase, the distance decreases. With single-lane data rates of 10GBASE-CX4 - These cables are older and not very common. This
25 Gbps and 32 Gbps, copper cables have a relatively short reach. type of cable and connector is similar to cables used for InfiniBand
technology.
Research is being conducted to determine the feasibility of cop-
per cables at 100 Gbps per lane. One example of this was shown at
DesignCon 2016. An incubation startup company demonstrated a Continue reading for information on connector types.
100 Gbps serial data communication over a 1.5 meter twinaxial cop-
per cable.
Demartek
CONNECTOR TYPES
Several types of connectors are available with cables used for stor- With the announcement of 25 Gbps Ethernet, some in the industry
age interfaces. This is not an exhaustive list but is intended to show believe that single-lane 25 Gbps Ethernet infrastructure (cables,
the more common types. Each of the connector types includes the connectors and adapters) will gain faster market acceptance than
number of lanes (or channels) and the rated speed. multi-lane 40 Gbps Ethernet infrastructure.
As of early 2011, the fastest generally available connector speeds Two of the popular fiber-optic cable connectors are the SFP-style
supported were 10Gbps per lane. Significantly higher speeds and the QSFP-style (see diagrams below). SFP stands for “small
are currently achieved by bundling multiple lanes in parallel, such form-factor pluggable” and QSFP is “quad small form-factor plug-
as 4x10 (40Gbps), 10x10 (100Gbps), 12x10 (120Gbps), etc. Most of gable.” As the data rates for various interfaces have increased, the
the current implementations of 40GbE and 100GbE use multiple internal technology in these connectors has changed, and the names
lanes of 10GbE and are considered “channel bonded” solutions. have changed slightly. The table below indicates the name of the
technology and the interfaces that use it. See the Roadmaps section
14Gbps per lane connectors appeared in the last half of 2011. These for additional details on particular interfaces.
connectors support 16Gb Fibre Channel (single-lane) and 56Gb
(FDR) InfiniBand (multi-lane). QSFP-DD: The Quad Small Form Factor Double Density specifi-
cation was released in March 2017. This specification is for a new
25Gbps per lane cconnectors began to appear in volume in 2016. module and cage/connector system similar to, and backward com-
The underlying technology (“25G/28G”) used for 25 Gbps con- patible with, the existing QSFP (and QSFP28), but with an addition-
nectors for Ethernet is essentially the same as the technology used al row of contacts for an eight-lane electrical interface. A number of
for 32Gb Fibre Channel. The Ethernet implementation provides major industry companies are promoters and contributors to this
25 Gbps per lane and the Fibre Channel implementation provides specification. There is a Frequently Asked Questions section on the
32 Gbps per lane. This same technology is bundled into four-lane main page of the QSFP-DD website.
(“quad”) configurations to achieve 100GbE and 128GFC. Other vari-
ations of bundling multiple lanes of 25 Gbps may be possible, such Development of on-board optical connections is underway via the
as 10x25 (250 Gbps), 12x25 (300 Gbps) or 16x25 (400 Gbps). Consortium for On-Board Optics (COBO).
In the second half of 2010, a new variant of the SFP/SFP+ connector The Mini SAS connector is the familiar 4-lane connector available
was introduced to accommodate the Fibre Channel backbone with on most SAS cables today. The Mini SAS HD connector provides
64-port blades and the planned increased density Ethernet core twice the density as the Mini SAS connector, and is available in
switches. This new connector, known as mSFP, mini-SFP or mini- 4-lane and 8-lane configurations. The Mini SAS HD connector is the
LC SFP, narrows the optical centerline of a conventional SFP/SFP+ same connector for passive copper, active copper and optical SAS
connector from 6.25 mm to 5.25 mm. Although this connector looks cables. The diagrams below compare these two types of SAS
very much like a standard SFP style connector, it is narrower and is connectors.
required for the higher-density devices. The photo provided here
shows the difference between mini-SFP and the standard size.
MR-IOV
Enables multiple non-coherent Root Complexes (RCs) to
enhance resource utilization of PCI hardware and is primarily
the overlaying of multiple Virtual Hierarchies (VHs) over a
shared physical set of multi-root aware (MRA) and non-MRA
components.