Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Carla Binotto & Alice Payne (2017) The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary
Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness, Fashion Practice, 9:1, 5-29
Download by: [Cornell University Library] Date: 28 June 2017, At: 06:42
Fashion Practice, 2017, Volume 9, Issue 1, pp. 5–29
DOI: 10.1080/17569370.2016.1226604
© 2016 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
The Poetics
of Waste:
Contemporary
Fashion Practice
in the Context of
Carla Binotto and
Alice Payne Wastefulness
Carla Binotto is an Abstract
independent scholar and
fashion designer. Her This article traces several interwoven traditions of considering waste
postgraduate fashion
and its materiality within fashion practice. Waste in fashion is com-
research was undertaken
at Queensland University monly considered a problem to be solved, whether through reduced
of Technology, Brisbane, consumption, improved production processes, or recycling and upcy-
Australia. Carla’s research cling practices. While the pragmatic and effective “waste management”
interests include the social life approaches are key to developing a sustainable fashion industry they
and life cycle of clothing and
can also distance and obscure the materiality of waste, and in doing so
objects, and reuse, recycling
and repurposing in fashion overlook the potency and poignancy that waste can have. As a coun-
design practice. ter-approach to the problems of waste, this article explores a poetic
binottoc@gmail.com element that relates to an aesthetic of the worn and wasted, and a fash-
ion practice that elevates rather than disguises waste. This is discussed
6 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
through a case study of experimental fashion label Maison Briz Vegas, Dr. Alice Payne is a lecturer
in Fashion at Queensland
reflecting on time, place and waste.
University of Technology,
Brisbane, Australia. Her research
KEYWORDS: fashion, waste, refashioning, upcycling, poetics interests include the fashion
design process, the Australian
mass-market fashion industry,
and the problem of design for
sustainability within the fashion
Introduction context. Alice is also an award-
Waste in fashion is commonly seen as a problem to be solved, wheth- winning designer, investigating
er through reduced consumption, improved production processes, or design for sustainability in fashion
via practice-led research.
recycling and upcycling practices. However, waste can also play a role a1.payne@qut.edu.au
as part of a poetic language of fashion. This article traces several inter-
woven traditions of considering waste within fashion practice. The first
is waste as a problem (i.e. environmentally polluting, or morally wrong
in its associations with excess and lavishness) and therefore something
to be reduced or eliminated. The second considers waste as a feedstock
for new designs in which textile waste is masked and revalorized, with
the designer acting as a conjurer to make new goods from old. The
third approach relates to a poetic element within fashion practice, an
aesthetic of the worn and wasted in which waste is elevated rather
than disguised. This last approach we examine through a case study of
experimental fashion label Maison Briz Vegas. Maison Briz Vegas uses
discarded t-shirts and generic consumer waste—symbols of mass-pro-
duction and the everyday—to create artisanal designer fashion. Work-
ing from both within and without the fashion center of Paris, Maison
Briz Vegas works within a tradition of displacement and elevation of
waste. Aside from the environmental activism such a practice may im-
ply, this article discusses a poetics of waste: how the potency and poign-
ancy of rubbish can be harnessed to reflect on universal ideas of grief,
loss and renewal.
become associated with pollution, guilt, loss and damage. In The Ethics
of Waste, Hawkins (2006) argues that since the mid-twentieth century,
waste has been problematized as an environmental threat, and attitudes
towards waste and its meaning have changed. Waste management sys-
tems and education campaigns that promote “doing the right thing”
for the environment by recycling and conserving natural resources, for
example, “have implicated waste in the formation of new circuits of
guilt and conscience and practices of self-regulation” (Hawkins 2006,
ix). In this notion of waste, waste is a burden to be managed, reduced
and eliminated.
Critically, “waste” is connected to notions of value, which are
ever shifting. It is a state that things can move in and out of. Items,
goods and leftovers formerly deemed waste can be re-categorized and
reclaimed with fresh value ascribed to them. As Gregson and Crewe
(2003, 143) explain, “life can be infinite, value can lie dormant, [and]
meaning can be hidden from view, awaiting rediscovery.” Thus, engage-
ment with the material world of “waste” can be intimate, sensorial and
profound; according to Edensor (2005, 316), it is possible to search for
the “congealed life in discarded things, seeking out their allegorical po-
tentialities, and a multitude of other semiotic, sensual, practical, social
and aesthetic potential that reside in objects.” Furthermore, as Assmann
(2002, 78) describes, the ephemeral nature of rubbish makes it a pow-
erful metaphor for life itself, a “life in thrall to the fury of extinction.”
It is this capacity for waste to provoke thought and reflection that this
paper explores as a poetics of waste. We argue that waste, in its material
form, is expressive. Its presence can disrupt and provoke, particularly
when it appears out of place. Thus, the poetic and aesthetic disposition
of trash has the potential for meaningful engagement with the world.
Furthermore, if waste is hidden or disguised, it is denied the opportunity
to communicate and any engagement will be forgone.
Slavoj Žižek, in Examined Life (2009, 163), proposes we embrace
the aesthetic dimension of and “discover trash as an aesthetic object.”
Rejecting the sacralization of nature as a true motivation for ecological
change, Žižek (2009, 163) argues, “The true spiritual challenge is to
develop … a kind of emotional attachment to, or to find meaning in,
useless objects.” In a similar vein to Žižek, Hawkins suggests that what
needs to be considered is that “it might actually be waste, rather than
“nature” or “the environment,” that triggers new actions, that inspires
us” (Hawkins 2006, 11). The proposal of waste as unlikely inspiration
has parallels with Bennett’s (2001) notion of “enchantment.” Accord-
ing to Bennett, despite the dominant notions of disenchantment and
alienation associated with the modern world, moments of enchantment
nevertheless exist—with nature and commodities—and these experi-
ences can have a powerful affective force, promote reflections on the
ethical and have the potential to motivate ethical responses. Similarly
to Hawkins, it is Bennett’s view that the affective, more so than the
8 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Tackling Waste
A number of responses have been developed to reduce or eliminate the
various forms of waste within fashion. Following the waste hierarchy
(DEFRA 2011), prevention of waste is the crucial first stage in man-
aging waste, followed by reuse of products, recycling and recovery.
Disposal is the last resort (see Figure 1). Complex, trans-global sup-
ply chains facilitate the resale and reuse of second-hand apparel, and
much of the apparel unsuitable for resale is absorbed into recycling
networks (see Hawley 2011). Within the design context, responses to
the problem of waste include reducing or eliminating the fabric waste
incurred by traditional pattern-cutting methods through minimum or
zero-waste patternmaking, enabling ease of recycling through design
for disassembly or design with monomaterials, and design of modular
garments that enable sections to be replaced instead of disposing of the
entire garment if a section is damaged beyond repair. Chief of these
approaches to waste management are upcycling practices, also referred
to as “reclamation” (Fletcher and Grose 2012) and “refashioning”
(Brown 2013; Farrer 2011), in which reclaimed waste is used to pro-
duce new garments.
Reuse, recycling and upcycling practices enable a revaluing of pre-
and post-consumer textile waste. Pre-consumer textile waste, or off-
cuts from the cutting process, can be shredded and re-spun into new
yarn, or post-consumer polyethylene terephthalate (PET) bottles can
be converted into polyester fabric. These processes have a twin positive
effect in redirecting pre- and post-consumer waste away from landfill
but also reducing the demand for virgin fiber needed to produce new
textiles (Farrer 2011). McDonough and Braungart’s (2002) cradle to
cradle model of industrial ecology—in which all waste becomes food
for new product life cycles—has inspired action from large companies
such as Patagonia to develop garments that can be close-loop recycled
10 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Figure 1
most prevention
favoured The waste hierarchy. Illustration by
option Drsteuy (2008).
minimisation
reuse
recycling
least
energy recovery
favoured
option disposal
into new garments with no loss of quality. As Black (2012) notes, these
kinds of upcycling practices are moving from being niche practices to
mainstream. For example, fast fashion chain Topshop’s capsule Reclaim
to Wear collections, in partnership with upcycling pioneer Orsola de
Castro and Filippo Ricci, launched in 2012, introduced upcycling to a
broad consumer audience.
Masking Waste
The use of recycled yarns and the upcycling, reclamation or refashion-
ing of existing textile waste are effective ways of revalorizing waste that
would otherwise go to landfill.
In mass-production, G-Star Raw and BIONIC yarns harvest plastic
waste from the oceans to use as a feedstock for new yarn for designer
denim. In artisanal fashion practice, many designers work with reclaimed
fabrics to create garments that do not betray their humble origins. For
example, British designer Christopher Raeburn, who launched his
label in 2008, has used decommissioned military stock, parachute silk,
Swedish army snowsuits as well as various uniforms in his collections
of menswear and womenswear (Brown 2013; Sibley 2009). American
artist and designer Greg Lauren uses old army tents, blankets and
duffle bags to create his collections, which have a worn and weathered
aesthetic. The label From Somewhere, established by Orsola de Castro
in 1997, utilizes pre-consumer textile waste in upcycled collections,
working with unevenly shaped pieces to create visual interest through
paneling. From Somewhere has also transformed reclaimed Speedo
wetsuits into chic body con dresses (Vogue UK 2012). Other labels
working with reclaimed textiles include Goodone, TraidRemade and
Frau Wagner (Brown 2013).
These approaches—the recycling and upcycling of pre- and post-con-
sumer waste—make use of material potentiality and the “embodied
energy” (Fletcher and Grose 2012, 63) that exists within the already
made—a practice that doesn’t draw from, or “waste,” more finite nat-
ural resources. To return to the notions of waste discussed earlier, this
is a view of waste as undesirable, polluting, and something to be elim-
inated. These approaches aim to eliminate, reduce or convert material
The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness 11
waste and excess matter, yet often this really means that the waste is no
longer visible; the garments absorb or conceal it. The designer becomes
a conjurer, essentially making waste “disappear.” However, waste nev-
er really disappears; it just goes somewhere else. As Marilyn Strathern
(as cited in Hetherington 2004, 162) contends, “one cannot dispose of
waste, only convert it into something else within its own life.” The waste
is therefore still present in its material form, but it has been revalorized
and masked as “food” (following McDonough and Braungart 2002) for
new processes.
Moreover, this masking of waste is characteristic of a fashion sys-
tem that privileges newness and first-cycle consumption. Fabric rem-
nants from the cutting stage are upcycled into garments that look new.
Zero-waste patternmaking works to eliminate offcuts, but excess fabric
may hide in tucks and folds. Fabric made from recycled PET bottles
passes as virgin fiber and is used to create new garments. The backstory
of the garments and their utilization of waste may be communicated
through marketing material or swing tags, but garments themselves
skillfully appear “new.” Although these are important approaches to
limiting the environmental impact of fashion, these practices may serve
to mask waste while satisfying the desire for newness. The designers’
need to mask or conjure away waste is fundamentally linked to society’s
acceptance, or often rejection, of items that appear damaged, old or
worn. In part, this masking of waste relates to a notion of newness that
has developed with modern consumerism (Campbell 1992). “New” is
equated with “clean,” unworn or unused by an anonymous other. In
the case of upcycling post-consumer textiles—“used” clothes—the idea
of wearing something that has been worn by others is not appealing to
many people as it relates to the idea of something being “dirty.” Thus
used clothing may disgust and repel. Second-hand clothing exhibits
traces of use through signs of wear that are directly linked to the body
and practices of wearing. Odors, stains, tears, fading, stretching, the
thinning of fabric in certain areas are all signs of bodily presence (Greg-
son and Crewe 2003, 156). According to Gregson and Crewe, the con-
sumption of second-hand clothing “requires individuals to confront too
both the constructions and taboos of personal bodily dirt and death,
and their own thresholds in relation to these” (2003, 156). Gregson
and Crewe discuss the ways in which an “unknown other, [and] his
or her body and practices of wearing” (2003, 156) are negotiated by
consumers of second-hand clothing through “divestment rituals,” such
as cleaning and personalization. Designers using post-consumer textiles
must also negotiate degrees of bodily presence and within their practice
incorporate methods that cleanse and renew so as consumers might
accept their products.
This shifting, hiding, concealing and converting of waste are the ways
in which excess matter no longer wanted, needed or valued is dealt
with in modern society. Moreover, according to Žižek (2009, 162),
12 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Elevating Waste
Parallel to practices that disguise reclaimed waste are practic-
es that elevate it. Since the 1990s, the work of labels such as Mai-
son M artin Margiela and XULY.Bët demonstrate an approach to
utilizing waste in which the waste is highly visible and becomes an
integral part of the design aesthetic. As Rovine (2005) notes in the
work of XULY.Bët’s designer Lamine Kouyaté, the physical recy-
cling of garments equates with the restless change of fashion that
returns to the past for inspiration, and XULY.Bët designs literally
return to old clothing as a source for new fashion, often retaining
the stains and marks of their previous owners. As a Malian designer
based in France, Lamine Kouyaté’s work is not framed as an eco-ac-
tivist approach to making waste visible, but rather his work lies at
a complex intersection of culture, fashion and materiality. Kouyaté,
quoted in Rovine (2005, 224) says, “It’s an African—and any Third
World nation’s—philosophy to use things up. You don’t waste any-
thing, but create new from old.” Kouyaté continues to examine this,
most recently in his 2015 public and unscheduled appearance dur-
ing New York Fashion Week which took place “guerrilla-style, on
the sidewalk outside the Skylight at Moynihan Studio in Midtown,
right after Anna Sui’s always popular and heavily attended show”
(Trebay 2015). Kouyaté’s show was intentionally disruptive to high
fashion norms, as were his designs and presentations in the 1990s.
Another approach to the elevation of waste in fashion is seen in the
work of Martin Margiela and the team at Maison Martin Margiela, in
which second-hand garments are deconstructed and reassembled. Evans
(1998) discusses Margiela’s work as a process of effecting creative trans-
formations and reversals through material. Although the end products
The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness 13
exist in the field of high fashion, the raw materials Margiela starts with
are “abject materials” and “fashion detritus” such as “second-hand or
army surplus clothing ... the commodity form with the lowest value
in the fashion system” (Evans 1998, 85). However Margiela’s practice
cannot be viewed as simply a desire to elevate poor materials as part
of a pragmatic environmental agenda. Rather, as Vinken (2005, 143)
argues, Margiela’s use of waste is “not a moral, but an entirely aesthetic
maneuver.” Instead, his work captures the poetic and affective capacity
of discarded items revalorized.
Used items of clothing are potent artifacts that can hold rich sym-
bolic meaning. As Wilson articulates, “clothes are amongst the most
fraught objects in the material world of things, since they are so closely
involved with the human body and the human life-cycle” (2003, vii).
Through its materiality and close relationship to the body, clothing
develops history and biography and continues to have a “life” even after
having been discarded (Gregson and Crewe 2003; Miller 2005). This
idea activates second-hand clothing to appear alive and full of potential
for designers. Tseelon (2012) proposes that Margiela sees the potential
value in the material qualities of old clothing as a “creative ingredient.”
Thus keeping visible the origins of the old clothes, with their stains and
signs of wear from other bodies, can feed into the metaphorical beauty
of elevating waste to make new garments.
A number of designers working in upcycling do so as a way to lim-
it the environmental impact of fashion production and consumption,
and the visibility of waste within their work becomes a bold state-
ment associated with sustainable fashion. One example is the designs
of London-based label Junky Styling that retain visible imprints of
the garments’ origins, with elements such as shirt cuffs and plackets
still recognizable but repositioned in new ways. Visually this approach
references the deconstruction aesthetic led by designers such as Rei
Kawakubo and Martin Margiela in the 1980s and 1990s (Gill 1998).
However the revalorizing of old clothing waste can also be seen as an
activist response to fast fashion and over-consumption. Junky Styling
designers Sanders and Seager (2009, 159) say of their work that it
“demonstrates that even within the disposable, fickle world of fashion,
it is still possible to exercise ecological awareness.” Similarly, the Ital-
ian designer Pietra Pistoletto develops artisanal ranges of second-hand
garments from waste in which the humble origins of the materials re-
main visible yet altered. Pistoletto refers to the waste she collects and
painstakingly transforms as “anti-jewels” (Ricchetti and Frisa 2012,
206), upturning the luxury associated with high fashion. When cloth-
ing waste is visibly reused and revitalized, it becomes a potent state-
ment of renewal.
In the case of Margiela and XULY.Bët, the connection to environ-
mental activism is not as clear as with that of Junky Styling. Mar-
giela’s work is not about proposing eco fashion (Gill 1998). Rather
14 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Figure 2
Origin and outcome, The Wasteland. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2012.
Figure 3
Process and product, The Wasteland. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2012.
Figure 4
The Wasteland. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2012.
are shaped by the locations where they are developed and created, as
the designers source the second-hand t-shirts and discarded materi-
als locally. Thus materials used to create the collections are subject to
what is available at a particular geographic location and according to
climate. Trips to the flea markets in Paris would yield an abundance
of t-shirts during the summer months but very few during the winter,
when woolen jumpers and old fur coats replace them. The Glam and
The Gloom, a winter collection, used second-hand jumpers as the base
fabric for new garments or quilted them between printed t-shirt fabric
(see Figure 5). In comparison to the clearly defined seasons of Paris, the
subtropical climate of Brisbane means that thrift shops have a constant
glut of t-shirts but very few warm winter items.
In Paris, sourcing the second-hand clothing involved physically trav-
eling beyond the peripherique, the boundary that encircles Paris, and
symbolically moving from the center of luxury and style to the mar-
gins. Place is also referenced symbolically through the collections. The
Wasteland title alludes to a place, wild and desolate. The second col-
lection, The Glam and The Gloom, a reference to Irish mythology, was
about magic and hope versus darkness and depression. The collection
also references the geography of waste by contrasting the glamour and
wealth of Paris’ illustrious center with the disparate poverty visible at
the periphery of the city where second-hand garments were gathered to
create the collection.
This contrast is represented within the garments with features such
as buttons made from the bottle caps of premium French champagne
collected from an exclusive restaurant in the heart of Paris combined
with second-hand clothing waste from the flea markets at the city’s
outskirts.
Figure 5
The Glam and the Gloom. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2012.
The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness 19
Figure 6
The Glam and The Gloom showroom presentation. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2012.
20 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Figure 7
Trashtopia destination t-shirts. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2014.
Figure 8
Trashtopia postcard. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2014.
The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness 21
has deeper significance. The seemingly playful prints designed for this
collection also present a darker narrative: turtles swim amongst rings
from plastic bottles, a school of fish-shaped plastic soy sauce containers
swims through seaweed, and a happy holidaymaker dives into contam-
inated water. The playful yet uneasy nature of the prints was intended
to depict the gloom of waste in a humorous manner, telling a story of
waste that can be read as an environmental commentary.
The Trashtopia collection was presented as a beach installation cre-
ated in a gallery space in Brisbane (see Figure 9). A floor resembled
sand, silhouettes of seagulls dotted the walls, and props including an old
beach chair, umbrella and inflatable toys were arranged in the setting,
which was accompanied by a laid-back tropical soundscape. However,
punctuations of litter unsettled the scene: a chip packet, a beer bottle,
plastic gelato spoons and empty pearlescent soy sauce fish containers.
The displacement of this waste invited people to notice rubbish, to look
for more of it, and to see it in a new way.
An aesthetic of waste and decay are also communicated through
Maison Briz Vegas’ promotional images and the places where garments
are photographed. In Paris such sites include a public telephone cov-
ered with graffiti (as shown in Figure 4), abandoned and littered urban
spaces, a cracked and peeling concrete wall, amongst the stalls of used
clothes at flea markets. In Brisbane it included the setting of a typi-
cal backyard suburban swimming pool area, though a neglected one.
Figure 9
Installation view of Trashtopia. Photo: Erika Fish, QUT Marketing, 2014.
22 Carla Binotto and Alice Payne
Figure 10
Hem detail, Trashtopia. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2014.
Figure 11
Feather detail, Trashtopia. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas, 2014.
Figure 12
Hand-carved block printed label, hand finished edges and bottle cap detail, The Glam and The Gloom. Photo: Maison Briz Vegas,
2012.
in the design and making process, and then the presentation of these
garments and objects that are at once new but bearing the signs of
their past lives. Bennett’s enchantment relates to the Maison Briz Vegas
design process and the designers’ experience in working with mundane
discarded items, as well as the end product and presentation—which it
is hoped will elicit a mood of enchantment in others. Therefore, it is as
much about process—gleaning the objects, caring for them, reinvigorat-
ing them—as it is about outcome.
Given that a practice which privileges actual, visible waste is con-
trary to fashion’s modus operandi, other issues emerge regarding the
use of second-hand garments. For example, when logos from the gar-
ments’ previous lives remain visible in their new life, this may raise
dilemmas regarding appropriation and copyright. In several Maison
Briz Vegas garments, old logos on t-shirts are intentionally visible and
carefully selected in order to strengthen the concept of each collection,
in a tongue-in-cheek and subversive manner (see Figure 7). This kind of
appropriation of another brand’s logo connects with culture jamming
and the political comment of Adbusters, or in the playfully anti-con-
sumerist Logo Removal Service (LRS 2015), a service to remove brand
logos from second-hand t-shirts. Although separate from the notion of
waste, issues around copyright highlight the problems and political na-
ture of these practices on the margins, and suggest why designers may
be loath to reveal the origins of waste materials.
Conclusion
This article has explored several views of waste and wastefulness. In
one view, waste is associated with guilt and damage, and is something
to be eliminated through improved practices and processes. In another,
waste is examined as holding the potential for beauty and symbolism.
When observed in this light, wasted and abandoned things hold the
power to provoke a feeling in the viewer of not necessarily guilt but
rather tenderness, as these unwanted objects become a metaphor for
life’s transience. Both perceptions of waste may resonate and intertwine
within fashion practice. Many designers valorize waste and keep it
visible and vital in their work. For some designers this practice is con-
nected to environmental activism and a problem-solving approach to
tackling fashion’s endemic waste. Yet at the same time the aesthetic of
the worn and the wasted has become another strand of fashion’s visual
language in which the visibility of old clothing or rubbish gleaned and
treasured can be associated with the pragmatics of recycling as well as a
poetics of renewal. In the discussion of Maison Briz Vegas’ approach to
elevation of waste, the work stems from a lineage of practice that may be
used as part of sustainable fashion narratives, but can also be distinct from
it. Instead waste is used to tell social, cultural and material n
arratives—
encounters between the human and material world. The rational
The Poetics of Waste: Contemporary Fashion Practice in the Context of Wastefulness 27
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Carla van Lunn for her reflections
on practice as well as frank and thoughtful feedback throughout the
writing process. As founder of Maison Briz Vegas, Carla’s philosophy
and sensitive approach to materiality permeates this paper. The authors
would also like to thank Kathleen Horton for her initial feedback on
early drafts, and invaluable mentoring role as Carla Binotto’s PhD
supervisor.
Disclosure Statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
References