HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault | E&T Magazine https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/06/hse-refuses-to-act-over...

Welcome
IET sites
Your IET account

Search the IET Search

Exclusive
HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault
By Conor McGlone

Published Tuesday, June 13, 2023

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has broken its

silence over an increasingly common dangerous fault on
the electricity network, after a member of the House of
Lords intervened following an E&T article in February.
Responding on behalf of the government to a question from Labour Lord Rooker, Viscount Younger of Leckie said HSE
officials had been advised that “neutral current diversions (NCD) are a known phenomenon and can occur for a number
of reasons”.

Younger added that the HSE had “monitored developments carefully and continues to do so”. However, he said officials
“were of the view that no additional action is required by the regulator to manage this risk of neutral current diversion at
the present time.”

Experts have said the response is disappointing and have called for more transparency.

In February, several electrical experts told E&T that there was a real risk of deadly gas explosions and fires in the UK
due to NCD. They argued that the HSE needed to acknowledge the risks of NCD so that a programme of testing can be
implemented - and lifesaving upgrades made to the grid.

An NCD can occur on the network when the combined protective earthing and neutral (PEN) conductor fails. The
current is then diverted by making a circuit via exposed metalwork on buildings including gas, water and oil pipes. This
can lead to a significant build-up of heat, leading to fires and gas explosions.

PEN conductors are particularly susceptible to damage, corrosion and general wear and tear across an ageing PME
(protective multiple earthing) network – and given the huge projected load growth on the network, incidents are
expected to continue to rise.

Last year, E&T revealed that the reports of broken PEN conductors had increased by more than eight times over the
last 18 years in the UK from 57 in 2003 to 474 reports in 2021. One broken PEN incident may affect in the region of 50
properties, meaning tens of thousands of properties could be affected each year in the UK.

Former SP Energy Networks (SPEN) employee Gordon Mackenzie, who is trying to raise awareness about the dangers

1 of 5 6/15/2023, 11:02 AM
HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault | E&T Magazine https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/06/hse-refuses-to-act-over...

of NCD, said it was “a really good thing for public and operative safety that the risks associated with NCD have been
highlighted and raised at the highest levels”. But he said the answers given “fall short on technical detail and leave me
questioning the data and information used by the HSE to get to the declared position”.

“I hope that there will be a continuing industry-wide collection of electrical testing data and knowledge sharing, to allow
the HSE and others to fully appreciate the associated risks, and to carry out a future review as soon as possible,” he
added.

Paul Meenan, senior asset manager for rail firm C2C and chairman of a subgroup of the Electrical Safety Roundtable,
an industry forum dedicated to enhancing the standards of electrical safety across the UK, said he remained
“disappointed by the HSE stance”. He called “at the very least for transparency” and said that data should be made
available “so industry can assess and better manage risk locally”.

Industry sources say many reported appliance failures, which have led to fires, were in fact a result of NCD. The fault
can cause gas explosions, according to Mackenzie. While the cause of the majority of gas explosions are recorded as
gas leaks, he noted that NCDs are so prevalent on gas pipes that the gas industry attaches jump leads between gas
pipes before changing them, because they generate sparks.

In its written response, the government added that the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations require additional
electrical bonding when cutting conducting gas pipes to minimise the risk to workers.

However, Mackenzie said these measures were not adequate and would not mitigate the risks associated with the
heightened levels of current that can flow through gas pipes where NCD exists. He also pointed out that any metallic
piping could carry the current, including water and oil pipes, which are not covered under these regulations.

The HSE has been approached for comment.

Sign up to the E&T News e-mail to get great stories like this delivered to your inbox every day.

Contact us

Our O�ces

UK, Head o�ce

T: +44 (0)1438 313 311
E: postmaster@theiet.org

China

2 of 5 6/15/2023, 11:02 AM
HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault | E&T Magazine https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/06/hse-refuses-to-act-over...

T: +86 10 6566 4687

E: china@theiet.org

India
T: +91 80 4089 2222
E: india@theiet.in

Hong Kong
T: +852 2521 2140
E: adminap@theiet.org

USA
T: +1 (732) 321 5575
E: ietusa@theiet.org

Our Venues

IET London: Savoy Place

T: +44 (0)20 7344 8460
E: faradaycentre@ietvenues.co.uk

IET Birmingham: Austin Court

T: +44 (0)121 600 7500
E: austincourt@ietvenues.co.uk

About the IET

Our history
Vision and Strategy
Governance
AGMs
Royal Charter and Bye-laws
Our o�ces
Our venues
Working for the IET
Advertising and sponsorship

3 of 5 6/15/2023, 11:02 AM
HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault | E&T Magazine https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/06/hse-refuses-to-act-over...

Membership & Registration

Join the IET
Bene�ts of membership
Manage your membership
Member News
Communities
Professionalism and ethics
IET Library and Archives
E&T magazine

Career & Learning

Professional registration
Professional development
Career Manager
Accreditation
Courses and training
IET Academy
Support for employers
Routes to engineering
STEM education
Career support
Engineering jobs

Intelligence & Research

Publishing with IET Journals
Publishing with IET Books
Inspec
Subscribe to our content
Bookshop
Wiring Regulations
Codes and guidance
IET.tv - video content and production
IET Library and Archives

Events
Events
Search all events

Get Involved
Volunteering for the IET

4 of 5 6/15/2023, 11:02 AM
HSE refuses to act over dangerous electrical fault | E&T Magazine https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/06/hse-refuses-to-act-over...

Young Professionals
Partnerships
Collaboration
Support future generations
Online community

Impact & Society

Sectors
Government policy and submissions
Thought leadership
Our impact in Scotland
Our impact in Northern Ireland
Fact�les
Awards and scholarships

Media Hub
Campaigns
Press releases
Media support for members
IET social media

Help

Cookies

Privacy Statement

Accessibility

Modern Slavery Act Statement

Legal notices

© 2023 The Institution of Engineering and Technology. The Institution of Engineering and Technology is registered as a Charity in
England & Wales (no 211014) and Scotland (no SC038698).

5 of 5 6/15/2023, 11:02 AM