301237755

Project 1 – Assembly
Description Grade Comment
1 Assy Drg – 3 views, + Exploded 4
2 Production part clearly shown 4
3 Sandwich jig submitted 4
4 Clearance above part 4
5 Clearance under part 4
6 Jig plate clamped 4
7 Jig plate located 4
8 Part clamped 4
9 Part located – Long ref. Side 4
Fixed locator on wrong side – See Content/Extras/Tolerance
10 Part located – Short ref, side 0
and Location.
Production part is loaded upside down. Therefore cannot be
11 Part error proofed 0
error proofed using 3/8” Dia. Blind hole.
12 Modular construction 4
1. See rules for drill bushings and for purchased parts. Drill
bushings are not normally “stock” parts
13 Drill Bushings correctly defined 1
2. See unit on drill bushings. Fixed renewable bushings require
screws. Type H would be best choice here.
14 B.O.M. Exists 4
15 B.O.M. All parts Ballooned 3 5?
1. 17Cr3 is a foreign (European) standard special steel. CRS
would be fine here. I doubt if you could purchase European
special steels easily in North America. If you must specify the
steel for this project AISI 1018 or 1020 would be a much better
16 B.O.M. All Manuf. parts I.D. & Mat'l 2
choice.
2. Many years ago I specified EN31 (a British high strength
alloy steel) and found out no one locally had any idea what it
was.
17 B.O.M. All Purch parts I.D. 4 Except for drill bushings
18 B.O.M. All Quantities shown 4
19 B.O.M. Format correct/notes 4
20 General formatting – title block 3 See rules

Project 1 – Parts
Description Grade Comment
1 Misc. Manuf parts drawn if reqd 4
2 Purchased parts NOT drawn 4
3 All parts Det#,Qty,Mat'l on dwg 4 Support Block
Clearance hole for screws not dimensioned. Should be #9 or
#7 drill thru’.
4 Manuf misc parts dimns 3 In my opinion, the 10-24 thread is too week to be practical and
should be avoided. All the other UNC threads are OK. FYI –
Unfortunately shoulder screws all use UNC threads.
5 Manuf misc parts tolerances 0 See rules re tolerance block
6 Top plate Det#,Qty,Matl on dwg 4
7 Top plate dimns from ref. 0 See Content/Extras/Tolerances and Location and 50% rule.
Distance between drilled holes is 1.625” in both planes. None
8 Top plate other dimns 1
of your dimensions reflect this.
9 Top plate ref tols 0
10 Top plate other tols 0 See rules re tolerance block
11 Base plate Det#,Qty,Matl on dwg 4
12 Extrusions NOT used 4
13 Base plate dimn from ref. 0 See Content/Extras/Tolerances and Location and 50% rule.
14 Base plate other dimns. 4 No need to specify tap drill sizes to toolmakers.
15 Base plate ref tols 0
16 Base plate other tols 0 See rules re tolerance block

0, 10, 20 ,30, 40 or 50 Penalty %

Grading scheme Grade

Non-compliant 0
25% compliance 1
50% compliance 2
75% compliance 3
100% compliance 4

Page 1