You are on page 1of 4

(I=@?C9E=?>?<?CC1<1D1>1<IC9C1>4$5DG?

B;9>7$

%F5BF95G?6+9BDE1<9J1D9?>9><?E4?=@ED9>7
$1>3I 19> (1;C898?E481BI
>CD9DED5?6>79>55B9>7)538>?<?7I >CD9DED5?6>79>55B9>7)538>?<?7I
5F989<I1+9C8G1F94I1<1I1>4?B5 #& 5F989<I1+9C8G1F94I1<1I1>4?B5 #&
>4?B5>491 >4?B5>491
>1>3I:19> 
7=19<3?= 25DE38?E481BIC37=19<3?=

()'))858?DD5CD1B51?6B5C51B389>D85C541IC9C  )'+')*".)%$
3<?E4 3?=@ED9>7 G8938 7?5C 9> @1B1<<5< G9D8 ?>5 =?B5 >45@5>45>3I ?6 ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= 1>4
9=@?BD1>D 3?>35@D 9> D85 45F5<?@=5>D ?6 81B4G1B5 1>4 1@@<931D9?>C 6B?= D85E>45B<I9>7 81B4G1B5
C?6DG1B5F9BDE1<9J1D9?>D538>?<?7I >D89CB5C51B38@1@5B +9BDE1< =1389>5C 31> 25 51C9<I @B?F9454 D? 1>I
G5 G9<< 49C3ECC 12?ED F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 256?B5 1>4 16D5B CICD5=
F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9DC B?<5 9> 3<?E4 3?=@ED9>7 2B956 F95G %( 1>41@@<931D9?>31>25 51C9<I =1>17541C?>5
12?ED 8I@5BF9C?B CD?B175 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> C5BF5B 3?=@<5D55>D9DI 2I GB1@@9>7E@ D85=9>D?F9BDE1<
F9BDE1<9J1D9?>25>569DC?6F9BDE1<9J1D9?> =1389>5C

!-,%'( +9BDE1<9J1D9?> <?E4 ?=@ED9>7


I@5BF9C?B(D?B175F9BDE1<9J1D9?>(5BF5BF9BDE1<9J1D9?>

 $)'%*)%$
<?E43?=@ED9>731>25 C1941C1D538>?<?7ID81D1<<?GC
EC5BC D? 1335CC <1B75 1=?E>D ?6 41D1 9>6?B=1D9?> 1>4
F1B9?EC ?D85B 3?=@ED9>7 B5C?EB35C 9> 1 =1>>5B 9> G8938
D85 3ECD?=5B EC5C D85C5 B5C?EB35C 1>4 @1IC 6?B 9D
133?B49>7  6 G5 D1<; 12?ED F9BDE1<9J1D9?> F9BDE1<
=1389>5 9D 9C 1 =1389>5 D81D 85<@C D? 9=@B?F5 D85
5669395>3I ?6 3<?E4 3?=@ED9>7 ,9D8 D85 85<@ ?6
F9BDE1<9J1D9?>9D9C@?CC92<5D?G?B;?>=E<D9@<5?@5B1D9>7
CICD5=C 1>4 1@@<931D9?>C C9=E<D1>5?EC<I ?F5B D85 C1=5
C5BF5B 85>35 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9>3B51C5C D85 ED9<9DI 1>4
6<5H929<9DI?681B4G1B5

 ,) (+')*".)%$


+9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9> D85 C9=@<5CD 1>4 51C95CD G?B4C 9C D85
12CDB13D9?> ?6 3?=@ED5B B5C?EB35C +9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9C 1
3?=@?>5>D G9D89> 3<?E4 3?=@ED9>7 G8938 1<<?GC
C5@1B1D9?> ?6 ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= 6B?= D85 81B4G1B5 ?> +9BDE1<9J1D9?>>6B1CDBE3DEB5
G8938 9D 9C G?B;9>7 +9BDE1<9J1D9?> 81C 129<9DI D? 1<<?G
C9>7<5@8IC931<B5C?EB35C5BF5 1C=E<D9@<5F9BDE1<B5C?EB35C
1>431>5F5>=1;5 =E<D9@<5@8IC931<B5C?EB35C6E>3D9?>1C
1C9>7<5F9BDE1<B5C?EB35 +9BDE1<9J1D9?>81C2B?E78D17B51D  '%"%+')*".)%$$"%*
381>759>D85G?B;9>7?6)?B71>9J1D9?>C 9> 1<<G1IC %#&*)$
+9BDE1<9J1D9?> 1>4 =E<D9D1C;9>7 ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5=C 81F5
C9=9<1BG?B;9>731@129<9D95C D1<<?GC1>E=25B?6F9BDE1<
 %'+')*".)%$ C5BF5BCD?25 35>DB1<9J549>D?1C9>7<5@8IC931<=1389>56
%>5%(9=175?>?>5 =1389>5 1> ?B71>9J1D9?> >554 D? BE> DG? ?B =?B5 C5BF5BC 6?B 1
(?6DG1B51>481B4G1B5D978D<I3?E@<54 @1BD93E<1B D1C; 9> 31C5 ?>5 619<C 5F5> D8?E78 >59D85B 9C
DD5=@DD?BE>=?B5D81>?>51@@<931D9?> ?> C1=5 3<?C5D?6E<<B5C?EB35EC175 +9BDE1<9J1D9?>31>85<@85B5
=1389>5?6D5>3B51D5C3?>6<93D 2531EC5 B5<1D9F5<I 9D9C51CID?=97B1D56B?=?>5@8IC931<
$?DC? 6<5H92<51>4 5F5> 3?CD<I9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 3?=@ED5B D? 1>?D85B (? 1>?D85B 297 14F1>D175 9C










   
   

Authorized licensed use limited to: Middlesex University. Downloaded on August 03,2020 at 14:53:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

(I=@?C9E=?>?<?CC1<1D1>1<IC9C1>4$5DG?B;9>7$

=97B1D9?> +9BDE1<9J1D9?> 31> 85<@ 9> 5>5B7I C1F9>7


453B51C9>7 D85 3?CD 1>4 C5BF5B 81B4G1B5 6??D@B9>D 1>4
85>3585<@D853?=@1>95C=1H9=9J5D859B@B?69D

> 3?=@ED5 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 1 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> <1I5B B5C945C


25DG55> D85 81B4G1B5 1>4 F9BDE1< =1389>5 ?> G8938 1>
?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= 9C BE>>9>7 )85 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> <1I5B 9C
1<C?;>?G>1C8I@5BF9C?B
)858I@5BF9C?B@B?F945CCD1>41B49J5481B4G1B5B5C?EB35C
6?B5H1=@<5&*#5=?BI$5DG?B;5D3 D?D85F9BDE1<
=1389>5C

I@5BF9C?BC 1B5 31D57?B9J54 9>D? DG? DI@5C 8?CD54


8I@5BF9C?B1>421B5=5D1<8I@5BF9C?B

)I@5  1B5=5D1< 8I@5BF9C?B > D89C DI@5 D85


8I@5BF9C?B9C49B53D<I9>CD1<<54?>D85H21C5481B4G1B5
6D5B 9>CD1<<9>7 D85 8I@5BF9C?B 45C9B12<5 9>CD1>35 ?6
?@5B1D9>7CICD5=9C9>CD1<<54?F5BD81D8I@5BF9C?B 5>35
9D 9C =?B5 5669395>D D81> 1 8?CD54 8I@5BF9C?B  5C;D?@
3?=@ED5BCEC5CE38DI@5?68I@5BF9C?B

+ ()%'+')*".)%$
D @B5C5>D C35>1B9? D85 =?CD C5F5B5 @B?2<5= 9C D85
=1>175=5>D 1>4 CD?B175 ?6 <1B75 1=?E>D ?6 41D1 6
C?=58?GG5<?C5 1335CCD? D81D9>6?B=1D9?>5F5>6?B65G
41IC 3?=@1>95CG?B;9>7?>297@B?:53DCC81<<259>7B51D
<?CC )89C 3?=@<5H C9DE1D9?> 81C 253?=5 1> ?2CD13<5 9>
13895F9>7 9=@?BD1>D 2EC9>5CC 7?1<C )89C @B?2<5= ?6
1335CC9>7 D85 41D1 31> 25 9=@B?F54 2I F9BDE1<9J9>7 D85
CD?B175CICD5=>C9=@<5G?B4CG531>C1ID81D9D9C51CI
D? =1>175 F9BDE1< B5C?EB35C D81> D? =1>175 @8IC931<
B5C?EB35C

)85B51B5=19><I69F5 DI@5C?6CD?B175F9BDE1<9J1D9?>49C;
D1@569<5CICD5=69<51>42<?3;F9BDE1<9J1D9?>

 9C; +9BDE1<9J1D9?> )89C 9C D85 ?<45CD 6?B= ?6 1<< 1>4
81C 255>9=@<5=5>D54C9>35 453145C9>F1B9?EC49C;4B9F5
69B=G1B5C
=17>5D9349C;3?=@B9C5C?63I<9>45BC8514C1>4C53D?BC
)I@5  ?CD54 8I@5BF9C?B > D89C DI@5 1> ?@5B1D9>7 (1>4D8531@139DI?649C;45@5>4?>>E=25B?6D85C5
CICD5= 9C 9>CD1<<54 ?> D85 81B4G1B5 1>4 D85> D85 3I<9>45BC
8I@5BF9C?B9C9>CD1<<54 ?>D81D?@5B1D9>7CICD5=%F5BD89C )85 ( 144B5CC 9C DB1>C6?B=54 9>D? 3?>C53ED9F5<I
8I@5BF9C?B1>9>CD1>35?6?@5B1D9>7CICD5=9C9>CD1<<54 >E=25B54 <?7931< 2<?3;C G8938 1B5 EC54 2I ?@5B1D9>7
(9>359DBE>C?>1>?@5B1D9>7CICD5=9DCE@@?BDCD858E75 CICD5=C1>48?CD1@@<931D9?>C
B1>75?681B4G1B53?>697EB1D9?>C )89C9C;>?G>1C<?7931<2<?3;144B5CC9>7")89C81C
B5F?<ED9?>9J54 D85 =1>>5B 9> G8938 D85 8?CD 3?=@ED5BC
451<DG9D849C;C
$?GD85C9J5?649C;9C45D5B=9>542ID85>E=25B?6 D85C5
<?7931<2<?3;C

)1@5+9BDE1<9J1D9?> )89CDI@5?6F9BDE1<9J1D9?>9CEC54
9>D1@5<92B1BI3?=@?>5>DC1>43?=5CE>45B 21C931B51C

Authorized licensed use limited to: Middlesex University. Downloaded on August 03,2020 at 14:53:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

(I=@?C9E=?>?<?CC1<1D1>1<IC9C1>4$5DG?B;9>7$

F9BDE1<9J1D9?> ?6D1@5=54911>4F9BDE1<9J1D9?>?6D85D1@5
4B9F5C  (5BF5B F9BDE1<9J1D9?> EC5 C5BF5BC D? 9DC 6E<<
1 )1@5 #5491 +9BDE1<9J1D9?> )89C =1;5C EC5 ?6 ?><9>5 @B?35CC9>731@129<9D95C
49C; CD?B175 G8938 13DC 1C 1 2E665B 1>4 85>35 1<<?GC
B5149>7 1>4 GB9D9>7 ?6 41D1 D? 1>4 6B?= @8IC931< D1@5  +9BDE1< C5BF5BC @B?F945 1> 9>45@5>45>D @<1D6?B=
=5491 )89C G1I 9=@B?F5C D85 213;E@ @5B6?B=1>35 1C 6?B D5CD9>7 >5G 1@@<931D9?>C ?B ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5=C
G5<< 1C 5>81>35C 9DC C5BF935 <965 #?B5?F5B 9D 9=@B?F5C D?@B?7B1==5BC
B5CD?B5 @5B6?B=1>35 1>4 =51> D9=5 D? D1@5 41D1 2I
1F?949>7 D85 D9=53?>CE=9>7 =?E>D9>7 1>4 E>=?E>D9>7  '53?F5BI?641D19C51CI
?6D1@5C
2 )1@5 B9F5B +9BDE1<9J1D9?> )85 29775CD @B?2<5= ?6
?@5> CICD5=C EC5BC 9C 1> 1DD5=@D D? C81B5 @8IC931< D1@5 (5BF5BF9BDE1<9J1D9?>9CCE249F94549>D?D8B55DI@5C
4B9F5C9>D1@5<92B1B95C 1=?>7 1C =1>I 8?CDC 1C@?CC92<5
)1@5 4B9F5 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9> D89C 3?>D5HD 5CD12<9C85C D1@5 E<<+9BDE1<9J1D9?>
4B9F5@??<C7E1B1>D559>7D859>D57B9DI?6 >6E<<F9BDE1<9J1D9?>8I@5BF9C?B49B53D<IEC5C3?=@?>5>DC
41D1 1>4 5>CEB5C 3?>DB?<<54 1335CC D? D85C5 4B9F5C 1>4 ?6@8IC931<C5BF5B)858I@5BF9C?B8945C1<<F9BDE1<C5BF5BC
@B5F5>DC3?>6<93DC25DG55>1@@<931D9?>C1>4C5BF5BC1C41D1 6B?=?>51>?D85B?@5B1D9>7?>D85C1=5@8IC931<=1389>5
9CGB9DD5>D??B B5146B?=D1@5 =5491 ,85> 1@@<931D9?>C BE> ?> F9BDE1< C5BF5BC D85 8I@5BF9C?B
81CD?45@5>4?>@8IC931<C5BF5B6?BD85B5C?EB35CG8938
 9<5 (ICD5= +9BDE1<9J1D9?> > D89C 6?B= C?=5 69<5 1B5D?25@B?F9454D?D85B5AE5CD9>7F9BDE1<C5BF5B1C5138
C5BF5BC =1>175 C81B54 >5DG?B; 1335CC D? 69<5C 9> D85 69<5
CICD5=)81D69<5 CICD5=9C1335CC542I=1>IEC5BC?>D85 DEB> =1;5C D85 @8IC931< C5BF5B D? @B5C5BF5 C?=5
>5DG?B;B571B4<5CC?6D85?@5B1D9>7CICD5=CD85IBE>?> @B?35CC9>7 @?G5B 6?B 8I@5BF9C?B C? D81D 9D 31> BE>
1@@<931D9?>)89CC<?GCD85?F5B1<<@5B6?B=1>35?6C5BF5B
 9<5 +9BDE1<9J1D9?> )89C 1ED?=1D5C D85 =97B1D9?> ?6
B1B5<IEC5441D1D?<5CC5H@5>C9F5C53?>41BICD?B175=5491 &1B1F9BDE1<9J1D9?>
<9;5?@D931<49C;CD1@54B9F5C5D3)89C=97B1D9?>9CF9C92<5 >@1B1F9BDE1<9J1D9?>1<<D85F9BDE1<C5BF5BC1B51G1B5?6
D?2?D8EC5BC1>41@@<931D9?>C 5138 ?D85B 1>4 D8EC  ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= ?6 5138 F9BDE1<
C5BF5B G?B;9>7 ?> @8IC931< C5BF5B 9C 1G1B5 ?6 >554C ?6
 <?3; +9BDE1<9J1D9?> )89C 3B51D5C F9BDE1< CD?B175 ?D85B ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= D81D 1B5 259>7 B5AE5CD54 2I D85
45F935C 6B?= @8IC931< 49C;C G8938 1B5 1C <1B75 61CD 1>4 @8IC931< C5BF5B 5B5 8I@5BF9C?B >554C <5CC @B?35CC9>7
1F19<12<5 1C CD?B175 3?>CE=5BC B5AE9B5 << D85C5 613D?BC @?G5B 6?B BE>>9>7 1@@<931D9?>C )8EC ?F5B1<< C5BF5B
1B5 =5D 2I 3?=29>9>7 =E<D9@<5 >E=25BC ?6 49665B5>D @5B6?B=1>359C9=@B?F54
31@129<9D95C ?6 2<?3; F9BDE1<9J1D9?> (E@@?C5 1 EC5B 9C 9>
>554 ?6 1449D9?>1< 49C; 31@139DI D85> 1449D9?>1< F?<E=5C %(<5F5<F9BDE1<9J1D9?>
1B575>5B1D54?B5><1B754D?D8?C5G89381<B514I5H9CD > D89C DI@5 ?6 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> D85B5 9C >? >554 ?6
8I@5BF9C?B 5B5 D85 @8IC931< ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= G9D8
F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 31@139DI @<1IC D85 B?<5 ?6 8I@5BF9C?B )85
+ ('+'+')*".)%$ =1:?B 4B1G213; ?6 D89C F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9C D81D ?@5B1D9>7
)85 =19> 3?>35B> ?6 ) ?B71>9J1D9?>C 9C =9>9=E= CICD5= ?6 5138 F9BDE1< C5BF5B C8?E<4 25 C1=5 1>4 5138
9>F5CD=5>D ?> B5C?EB35C 1>4 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 C? 1C D? 75D 1 F9BDE1<C5BF5BB5=19>C9>45@5>45>D6B?=1<<D85?D85BC
=1H9=E=?ED@ED
)85 25CD =5D8?4 D? 13895F5 D89C 9C D8B?E78 C5BF5B
F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 1C931<<I C5BF5B F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 5>12<5C EC5 + $)(%+')*".)%$
?6=E<D9@<5F9BDE1<C5BF5BCF9BDE1<=1389>5?>1@8IC931< (5BF5B3?>C?<941D9?> C49C3ECC5412?F5G9D8D8585<@
C5BF5B 2I EC9>7F9BDE1<9J1D9?> C?6DG1B5 5B5 5138 F9BDE1< ?6 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9D 9C @?CC92<5 D? BE> =E<D9@<5 F9BDE1<
C5BF5B 2581F5C 1C 1 @8IC931< 45F935 BE>>9>7 9DC ?G> =1389>5C ?> 1 @8IC931< C5BF5B )89C B54E35C D85
?@5B1D9>7 CICD5=C )85 =?CD @?@E<1B C?6DG1B5 9C 45F9C54 B5AE9B5=5>D6?B@8IC931<C5BF5BC
2I+#G1B5#93B?C?6D1>49DB9H  C?<1D9?> C F9BDE1< =1389>5C 31> 1335CC 1<< DI@5C ?6
@8IC931<B5C?EB35C?61@8IC931<=1389>52IC81B9>7D85I
1B5 3?=@<5D5<I 9>45@5>45>D ?6 5138 ?D85B (E@@?C5 D85B5
4F1>D175C?6EC5?6C5BF5BF9BDE1<9J1D9?> 1B5 6?EB F9BDE1< =1389>5C G?B;9>7 ?> 1 C9>7<5 @8IC931<
81B4G1B5 1>4 ?>5 ?6 D85 F9BDE1< =1389>5C 75DC 41=1754
 +9BDE1<9J1D9?> ?6 41D1 35>D5BC 81F5 <54 D? 4E5 D? C?=5 B51C?> D85> 9D G9<< =1;5 >? 381>75 ?> D85
=9>9=E= EC5 ?6 C5BF5BC G8938 9> DEB> 81F5 G?B;9>7?6D85B5=19>9>7F9BDE1<=1389>5C
B54E354 3?CD ?6 @?G5B 3?>CE=@D9?> 3??<9>7 1>4
=19>D5>1>35  >31@CE<1D9?> +9BDE1< =1389>5 31> 25 C194 1C 1
3?=@<5D5 @13;175 3?>D19>9>7 =1>I F9BDE1< B5C?EB35C
 '54E3D9?> ?6 >E=25B ?6 C5BF5BC 81C <54 D? <5CC 9>3<E49>7 F1B9?EC 1@@<931D9?>C ?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= 1>4 D85
41D135>D5BC@1351B51B5AE9B5=5>D

Authorized licensed use limited to: Middlesex University. Downloaded on August 03,2020 at 14:53:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

(I=@?C9E=?>?<?CC1<1D1>1<IC9C1>4$5DG?B;9>7$

81B4G1B5 ?> G8938 9D 9C 9>CD1<<54 D =1;5C F9BDE1< *C5 +#C D? 5>12<5 49665B5>D C5BF935C D? BE> 9> C5@1B1D5
=1389>5C51CID?=1>1751>4@?BD12<5 +#C?>D85C1=5@8IC931<=1389>5
?B9>CD1>351F9BDE1<=1389>531>25=?F541>43?@954
6B?=?>5CICD5=D?1>?D85B:ECD<9;5169<5?B1 @93DEB5?B1 +9BDE1<9J1D9?> 9C 6?E>41D9?>1< 5<5=5>D ?6 3<?E4
4?3E=5>D 3?=@ED9>7 1>4 85<@C 45<9F5B ?> D85 F1<E5 ?6 3<?E4
3?=@ED9>7 C194 2I D85 49B53D?B ?6 @B?4E3D =1B;5D9>7
 1B4G1B5 9>45@5>45>35  F9BDE1< =1389>5 9C +#G1B5#9;541=C / 0
3?>697EB54 G9D8 F9BDE1< 3?=@?>5>DC CE38 1C &*
=5=?BI>5DG?B;31B4 D81D1B53?=@<5D5<I9>45@5>45>D?6 ''$(
D85E>45B<I9>7@8IC931<81B4G1B5)89C79F5CD856B554?= / 0 8DD@ GGG2EC9>5CC>5GC419<I3?=  
D?=?F51F9BDE1<=1389>56B?=?>5 F9BDE1<9J1D9?>FC3<?E43?=@ED9>78D=<
H=1389>5D?1>?D85BG9D8?ED=1;9>71>I381>75D?D85
45F9354B9F5BC?@5B1D9>7CICD5=?B1@@<931D9?>C

 '54E354 3?CD  ?=@ED5 F9BDE1<9J1D9?> B54E35C D85


6?<<?G9>749B53D3?CDC C@1356?B@8IC931<=1389>5C@?G5B
1>43??<9>781B4G1B51>41>>E1<=19>D5>1>35

%$"*(%$
%>5 ?6 D85 9=@?BD1>D 3?CD 1>4 5>5B7I C1F9>7 1>4
81B4G1B5=9>9=9J9>7 D538>9AE5C EC54 2I 3<?E4 @B?F945BC
9C F9BDE1<9J1D9?>
,9D8 %( F9BDE1<9J1D9?> 5138 +# 31> EC5 1 49665B5>D
?@5B1D9>7 CICD5= %( 1>4 5138 %( 9C 9C?<1D54 6B?= D85
?D85BC

Authorized licensed use limited to: Middlesex University. Downloaded on August 03,2020 at 14:53:51 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like