Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/275971299
CITATION READS
1 9,294
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Elyse Mireille Charrois on 08 May 2015.
James Prochaska’s interest in learning about how people change began when his
attempts to help his father, who suffered from depression and alcoholism, failed and ended with
his death. While alive, James Prochaska’s father did not envision himself as having difficulties
with depression or alcoholism and did not believe in psychotherapy. In an attempt to understand
why his father could not change, Prochaska began reviewing individual methods of
psychotherapy to understand how they encourage change. Prochaska and his colleagues,
John Norcross and Carlo DiClemente, found that there were an overwhelming amount (400 +)
of methods of psychotherapy available. Many therapies had a very restricted approach but none
were clearly better than the others.
The Transtheoretical model came out of Prochaska’s efforts to find familiar elements
within important therapies including psychoanalysis, behaviourism, cognitive therapies,
existential analysis and humanism. He tried to segregate the main beliefs and methods of
change that each psychotherapeutic approach had to offer. What he discovered was that while
each psychotherapeutic approach disagreed on what problems clients have and what they need
to change, there was more agreement about how change is effected (Prochaska et al., 1994, p.
25). Prochaska was able to summarize a very large amount of psychotherapeutic theories by a
few crucial principles he called the “processes of change”, which he defined as any activity that
an individual initiates to help modify thinking, feeling, or behaviour. This prompted Prochaska to
write his first book titled “Systems of Psychotherapy” in 1979.
Prochaska determined that all psychotherapies promote change by applying at least two
processes of change as seen in Table 1. Each theory of psychotherapy has its own sphere of
excellence. For example, psychoanalysis is the preferred approach for raising awareness of
both conscious and unconscious motivations, also referred to as consciousness-raising; while
behaviourism is the most effective approach for modifying discrete problem behaviours. The
Transtheoretical model integrates the best of each approach into a coherent whole.
Prochaska and DiClemente’s most surprising discovery was that successful self -
changers used certain tools only at specific times and that these specific times were constant
from person to person (Prochaska et al., 1994). This phenomenon has now come to be called
stages of change. Prochaska and DiClemente also found that there were fewer differences
between individuals who use therapy to assist them with change (therapy – changers) and self -
changers than once believed, that successful change was precipitated by individuals identifying
the stage they were in for a particular predicament and matching their challenges to their stage,
that individuals progress through the same stages of change regardless of the problem they are
addressing, that the same processes of change can apply to any problem and to a combination
of problems, that each stage entails a series of tasks that need to be completed before
progressing to the next stage, and that undesirable predicaments seem to occur simultaneously
(eg. smoking and drinking). There is some evidence that it may be more efficient to apply the
processes of change to more than one problem at a time rather than try to change problem
behaviours one by one and that people are more likely to be successful in their change attempts
when they are given two or more choices of how to pursue change rather than one (Prochaska
et al.). Hence, the five stages of change include pre-contemplation, contemplation, preparation,
action, and maintenance. The diagram below illustrates the Transtheoretical model as a spiral
model of change that includes progress and relapses that is inherent in the individual’s journey
toward recovery.
Emily: Hey Isabella, I notice that you have been smoking more often lately.
Isabella: Yeah, I have been under a lot of stress, plus I have been very busy writing. But
enough talk about me, what about you’re atrocious eating habits of late?
In this example, the response does not address the smoking, but instead displaces the
blame on writing and stress; in addition the focus quickly shifts from one person to the other.
Precontemplators actively resist consciousness-raising by utilizing well-placed defense
mechanisms. Social liberation involves any element in the external environment that supports
the change effort being made by the individual which in tandem can increase self-esteem. This
process may involve creating more alternatives and choices for individuals, providing more
information about problem behaviours, and offering public support for individuals who want to
change (Prochaska et al., 1994). Social liberation may be actualized by no smoking signs,
• Establish contact
• Actively listen
• Affirm
Contemplation
The next stage of change is the contemplative stage. In this stage many contemplators
have indefinite plans to take action in the next 6 months or so, but may also be far from making
a commitment to action (Prochaska et al., 1994). Sometimes individuals move quickly into the
next stage of change and other times individuals remain in the contemplative stage for a very
long time, even years. Though individuals may know their goal and how to achieve it, the time
spent in contemplation may be a result of a fear of failure and individuals may conduct a search
with no end for the latest information on their predicament but never engage in the change
process. Individuals who eternally substitute thinking for action can be called chronic
contemplators (Prochaska et al.).
In this example, Isabella seems to have been emotionally affected by the movie that she
watched enough to consider making a change to her habit of smoking.
Preparation
While an individual is continuing to work through the processes of social liberation,
emotional arousal and self-re-evaluation, they may begin to transition to the stage of preparation
which begins with the process of commitment. During the transition, the individual’s thinking will
begin to focus on the solution to the predicament rather than the predicament itself, and it also
directs attention to the future rather than the past. Commitment is taking the responsibility to
change. It includes not only a willingness to act, but also a belief in the individual’s ability to
change, which in turn reinforces a person’s will (Prochaska et al., 1994). Techniques that might
help consolidate commitment include taking small steps toward the change, setting a date for
which the change may begin, telling others outside of the self about the intended change,
spending the energy that the change will take, and creating a plan of action (Prochaska et al.).
Any lingering ambivalence that undermines the individual’s determination must be resolved for
the preparation stage to transition to the action stage of change. It is important to allow enough
dwelling time in the preparation stage to mitigate the risk of failure. For example, if an individual
makes a private promise to themselves one day that they wish to stop smoking immediately and
spends little time planning how they are going to proceed with making the change, there is a
higher chance that they will not succeed in implementing their change, or that the change will
not last very long.
Emily: Isabella, when did you say you were going to quit smoking?
Isabella: A month ago, I just feel like I don’t know how to go about quitting.
In this example, Isabella is recognizing that she needs to create a plan to assist her in
making the change of quitting her smoking habit.
The motivational strategies that health care professionals may utilize with individuals
who are in the preparation stage of change include exploring the client’s concern about mental
health and substance use, and identifying discrepancies between the client’s goals and their
current behaviors.
Box 3: Motivational Strategies for the Preparation Stage
Rewards modify the consequences that follow desirable behavior and reinforce it
(Prochaska et al.). Rewards include treating oneself in the event of beneficial behaviors.
Effective reward techniques that individuals have used successfully include covert management
(when resistance to temptation occurs and a private kudos is offered to oneself), contracting
(devising a rewards plan for each step taken towards one’s goal), and shaping behavior (this
happens gradually). Self-praise, buying a gift, or investing the money saved as a result of
beneficial actions describe rewarding oneself. For example, in the event of quitting smoking the
individual may find that they have extra money from not buying cigarettes, and decide to treat
themselves and their family to a day at the water park.
Helping relationships can mean recruiting outside help, which may be friend, family,
spouse, partner or other, to provide support, caring, understanding and acceptance (Prochaska
et al.). Engaging with another individual who has the same goals works well, as does receiving
praise from designated family members or friends.
In this example Isabella outlines the elements of her plan that help her to resist
temptation and continue taking action in relation to her goal of not smoking.
The motivational strategies that health care professionals may utilize with individuals
who are in the action stage of change include starting the action plan, eliciting change talk,
rewarding progress, using relapses as learning opportunities, involving, nurturing and sustaining
social supports, developing specific action steps to work on target behaviors, encouraging self-
efficacy and identify examples of same, reviewing and reinforcing actions that are producing
behavior change, reviewing and identifying new goals as client continues to change, and
emphasizing healthy alternatives.
Maintenance
The maintenance stage is as essential as the action stage, but it is much more difficult to
attain. It is during the maintenance stage, which may last from six months to as long as a
lifetime, that an individual must work to consolidate the gains achieved during the action and
other stages, and struggle to prevent lapses and relapses which is most likely to occur in the
first month or two (Prochaska et al.).
The factors that are significant to successful maintenance include sustained, long-term
effort and a revised lifestyle (Prochaska et al.). To succeed in maintaining a change that was
made, one must be able to identify the danger signs that could lead to a relapse. The most
common threats to maintenance are social pressures, internal challenges, and special situations
(Prochaska et al.). Social pressures are evident when self-changers spend time with those who
engage in the undesirable behavior, and those don’t understand its impact, internal challenges
usually result from overconfidence, temptation, and self blame, and special situations arise
when confronted by an unusual, intense temptation (Prochaska et al.).
During the maintenance stage of change, the individual must keep up their commitment
to the change and avoid people, places, and things that could compromise the change, work to
create alternative behaviors, and be aware of their attitudes toward the change. Secretly
coveting a relapse is an example of a practice that will inevitably lead to engaging in unhealthy
behaviors once again. Patience and persistence is key. Helping relationships, environmental
In this example, Isabella indicates that she has maintained her goal of not smoking for
three months. She also mentions that although she has been successful to date, without the
extrinsic support of her friends and family she would not have been able to accomplish what she
has. This statement reveals that she knows her own limits in regards to smoking and uses
family and friends to guard against those limits.
The motivational strategies that health care professionals may utilize with individuals
who are in the maintenance stage of change include keeping focus on the client’s goals,
reinforcing links between change behavior and accomplishment of client’s goals, identifying
continuing high risk situations, developing relapse prevention plans, reinforcing self-efficacy,
focusing attention on client’s gains, reviewing for new areas of risk, supporting continued social
engagement for mutual aid, leisure, spirituality, learning & volunteering.
Recycle
Although relapse is undesirable, it does show that movement toward change can be non-
linear, even circular and is usually the rule rather than the exception. Once an individual
relapses, they might slide back to the contemplation stage of change most commonly and begin
making plans to institute the change again, working their way forward. Prochaska et al. (1994)
outline ten lessons of relapse as follows:
• Few changers remain in the maintenance stage of change – only about 20 percent of the
population permanently conquers long-standing problems on the first try.
• Trial and error is inefficient – using relapse as a guide to effective learning can help
benefit from experiences.
• Change costs more than budgeted – what is needed is a commitment over time to an
action plan that exploits all that the processes have to offer.
• Using the wrong processes at the wrong time – by becoming misinformed, misusing
willpower, and substituting one bad behavior for another.
Table 3: Overlap between the Stages of Change and the Stages of Treatment
Stages of Change Stages of Substance Definition Goal
Abuse Treatment
Scale -Revised
Precontemplation Engagement Client does not have To establish a working
contact with clinician alliance with the client
Contemplation Persuasion Client has regular To develop the client’s
Preparation contact with clinician, awareness that
and may want to work substance use is a
on reducing problem, and increase
substance use motivation to change
Action Active Treatment Client is motivated to To help the client
reduce substance further reduce
use, as indicated by substance use and, if
reduction for at least 1 possible, attain
month but less than 6 abstinence
months
Conclusion
The journey through the Transtheoretical model is not usually linear but instead can be
spiral. Individuals can move forward, backward, and recycle through the stages of change
(DiClemente). The stages of change inherent in the Transtheoretical model coincide with the
Stages of Substance Abuse Treatment model showing the same goals for the client and
motivational strategies for the health care professional. The dynamic framework of the
Transtheoretical model makes it imperative that behavior change specialists be aware of the
critical tasks and stages, know where clients are in this process of change, and focus efforts on
helping them accomplish the parts of the process where they are having difficulty (DiClemente).
DiClemente, C. C. (2007). The transtheoretical model of intentional behavior change. Drugs and
Alcohol Today, 7(1), 29-33.
McHugo, G. J., Drake, R. E., Burton, H. L., & Ackerson, T. H. (1995). A scale for assessing the
stage of substance abuse treatment in persons with severe mental illness. Journal of
Nervous and Mental Disease, 183, 762-767.
Mueser, K. T., Bennett, M., & Kushner, M. G. (1995). Epidemiology of substance abuse among
persons with chronic mental disorders. In A. F. Lehman & L. Dixon (Eds.), Double
Jeopardy: Chronic Mental Illness and Substance Abuse. (pp. 9-25). New York, NY:
Harwood Academic.
Mueser, K. T., Noordsy, D. L., Drake, R. E., & Fox, L. (2003). Integrated treatment for dual
disorders: A guide to effective practice. New York, NY: The Guildford Press.
Prochaska, J. O., Norcross, J. C., & DiClemente, C. C. (1994). Changing for good: A
revolutionary six-stage program for overcoming bad habits and moving your life
positively forward. New York, NY: Avon Books.