Foto

',)&$' )#$&#-)*#+0' #$#&*
'$' ,%%) !*

" +*' ") '%()"&*#- '))+#-/)#*

)'+''$*'&+" '))+#'&' $/#$$+''+#&'0+,&+*
.#+"-).#!"+
[ Downloaded from jarums.arums.ac.ir on 2023-03-28 ]
'EKI7L? H78CEC;D?
;F7HJC;DJ E< -FEHJ #D@KH?;I 7D: EHH;9J?L; N;H9?I;I -9>EEB E< *>OI?97B :K97J?ED -FEHJI -9?;D9;I
#I<7>7D%>EH7I=7DH7D9>#IB7C?9P7:/D?L;HI?JO#I<7>7D#H7D
;F7HJC;DJE<-FEHJI-9?;D9;I-9>EEBE<"KC7D-9?;D9;I%>EC;?D?I>7>HH7D9>#IB7C?9P7:/D?L;HI?JO
%>EC;?D?I>7>H
#I<7>7D#H7D
.;B 7N C7?B7H78CEC;D??7KA>I> 79 ?H
,;9;?L;:FH 99;FJ;:'7O

B7J<EEJ?IED;E<J>;CEIJ9ECCEDF>OI?97B7D:CEJEH:?IEH:;HI
7CED=IJK:;DJI .>;7?CE< J>?IIJK:OM7IJE ?DL;IJ?=7J;J>; ;<<;9JIE<J>H;;9ECFH;>;DI?L;
9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I; FHEJE9EBI ED J>; 9EHH;9J?ED E< <B;N?8B; <B7J <EEJ ?D 8EO IJK:;DJI M?J>
EL;HM;?=>J
#DJ>?IGK7I?;NF;H?C;DJ7BIJK:OM>?9>M7IF;H<EHC;:7I7FH;J;IJFEIJJ;IJ M?J>
7 9EDJHEB =HEKF 7 JEJ7B E< EL;HM;?=>J IJK:;DJI M?J> <B;N?8B; <B7J <EEJ M;H; I;B;9J;:
FKHFEI;<KBBO 7D: :?L?:;: ?DJE <EKH ;GK7B =HEKFI D H7D:ECBO .>;H787D: ;N;H9?I;
(-' M7J;H H;I?IJ7D9; JH7?D?D= 7D: 7 9EDJHEB =HEKF .>; ;NF;H?C;DJ7B =HEKFI F;H<EHC;:
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
9EHH;9J?ED ;N;H9?I;I <EH M;;AI I;II?EDI M?J> C?DKJ;I F;H M;;A 07H?78B;I M;H;
C;7IKH;:7JJ>;87I;B?D;7D:7<J;HM;;AIE<9EHH;9J?ED7BFHE=H7C 7J7M;H;7D7BOP;:KI?D=
7D7BOI?I E<9EL7H?7D9; 8O-*-- IE<JM7H;7JJ>;I?=D?<?97D9;B;L;BE<
.>;H;IKBJIE<J>;IJK:OI>EM;:J>7JJ>;J>H;;FHEJE9EBI.>;H787D:;N;H9?I;(-'
7D:M7J;HH;I?IJ7D9;JH7?D?D=>7:7I?=D?<?97DJ;<<;9JEDJ>;?CFHEL;C;DJE<<B;N?8B;<B7J<;;J
?D EL;HM;?=>J C7B; IJK:;DJI M?J> 9E;<<?9?;DJI E< 7D: H;IF;9J?L;BO Z
KHJ>;HCEH; ?J M7I E8I;HL;: 7 I?=D?<?97DJ :?<<;H;D9; 8;JM;;D E< J>;I; J>H;; 9EHH;9J?L;
FHEJE9EBIED<B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ
.>;I; <?D:?D=I ?D:?97J;: J>7J J>; J>H;; 9EHH;9J?ED ;N;H9?I;I >7L; 7 I?=D?<?97DJ
;<<;9J ED J>; ?CFHEL;C;DJ E< <B;N?8B; <B7J <;;J .>;H;<EH; ?J ?I H;9ECC;D:;: JH7?D;HI E<
H;>78?B?J7J?ED9;DJ;HI7D:9EHH;9J?L;CEL;C;DJIKI;J>;I;JH7?D?D=C;J>E:I
EHH;9J?L;N;H9?I;.>;H787D:N;H9?I;(-'17J;H,;I?IJ7D9;.H7?D?D= B7J
EEJ
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
1 / 14

/IOaKIN.1 0 Ic~>D1MaEK0 1 {EK C>c^6.}q0IAd}U

MHKXT+E+ M#YF+J\E<-'7\E+X(<U0Q$0< Y?<)3*0

YN+F<@ [T AW

/]D/IwfC`!0IAd/IA` Y/Iwf[W1Cc! 1.}q1C[KMEK]N0[>dCWfI=]W1Cc! 1CÌc JE`01]@
/]D/IwfC`!0IAd]cCEY[W1CIa.}q0[>dCc! 1.}q01]@
7H78CEC;D??7KA>I> 79 ?H<E1]O>|Ma6

_=Iv

w}N-Ha0[aD
:)$!
*[M`*If2I6u= 2 IUIC==/ 1 CO=]W1CIaT2I2 IUID]NpDIc!C>D :ZYX)T
2 ]a6/!b ulr*If2I6u=h Iqf]KCWfID]N{>N1]6`]EQINC` ]Kb1;6D
K/!1vIh
2I6u=h IqIK! b -]O=01]@1/!_6 /!bE6]kIKCdDI!Eb1;6D +#
CvI)gN )f)K1I)ZO2 I)/qK[v[2]E@#1 IK/!1vIh2 1ulr*If
C)dDI!2I)01]@[[cDÂDIT-]O=1 CO1IzD]N(-'ID]N[IK]ND]N0]w 01]@
1/)!bE)6C)D]N)I]K2I)O1[)OK [).I)U CWfID]N2 zEy a}T Ow]1Ow
^)v.])))!0IwO))Ì)K_I)D 1={)E}XN/)!!I 0{E}XN1DÛNMT[c.IU01]@ /! _6
[D]@0IwO` 2 IrVl` -*--
CO1I)zD])N1 (-'[)IK]NI)KD])NCW)fI)D]N{>N1]6`=/Idr|IlSDIO +ZY1N+(
]EQI)N/^)EEK01qKZ [ *If2I6u=LK]K2 Ir]EQFN
1 JD]h IKJEN]NK
[c0[Id2 Ir1IwNulr*If 2I6u=f]KCWf{>N1]6`D
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
]EQI)Nu)lr*I)f2I)6 u)=)f1)LK])KCW)fD])N{)>N1]6)`[ C/IdIOvIDD <)%Y6)1W

0IwO)`C)D]N2I#1 D!CN!IK^=]1CWfI=]W/IEK]c CIdE61 D! 2oW{KIy
[=
*If2I6u= CO1IzD]N(-'[IK]NIKD]NCWfID]N:)S#+Z

<(;

/N+(
M)Ì)6K&K]2I h Iq/Ia I 2 IUI YT:PT

I6u=CvIf2 IUI(1I6u=EWI 1eYIcIqh!C>D/[K IOYI`2I2 IUI

[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]

D]))NpDI))c!1]))))= ))T1 ))@2I))61 E) )KM)`C)O=]W.}q r|Il ~
[)cIKC/I== $gYKI6K&K]>d !C)cI% )q1])Q{)}q(E)c/Ê]kIY
[rOIr|Il CIaT2I2 IUI!1]K

B7J EEJ

H9> EEJ
)DD])N ~!C>D5
6M` Ov]@ ]yr|Il
2 / 14

/ I>1 2`"ILq CWfID]N{>N1]6`]EQFN
1O)v 0 j})aN.[)qI)!]K IdvCAOaY *I)f2I)6u)=I)6C)}YC|k"y(IwN bI=

cC{ELyD!]AD2ICOW I [W!bEK
dE1]6IKM`>1c C0[EI
)f1)TNME10[c/IEKJ|IlKTNIK )K)h IqD [cIKjLN] C6IyMXN{gw
.!/!1vIh2 ]v IfgY 2 IUID CI)IAE|C}c[IC}q12 :EIurhM}q
x)Ey )k)KI6u="y
2ICOE vM` /ZO))`))T1 C) HM))c bY]))9C}>))c[))K
]EYF))N))=]))9))cCDI))Ìc/!))b)) {))612! I)) 2))q"|I))NC))q]v21I))
C)>EE}=~)GqI)UDJL`= DheEZdN )TK{)q)D!C)LE=]NI)D -I)` INCZO`

IE)aKCI) I[)y)c C)C|I)a@ ^KE` u)lr*I)f2I)6u)=)= Dh[DC
CI@1]=[YJ}kÊ 2]NCTIN 2I)M)IAE|[)W!bEKC@[Ed=!CcI[N C
!)K[)Y]D\)6I I)OTC)W]T-I)q[D[c [)cIK
C)ZE 21I12cI6 C6Iy21I C6Iy
bI)=1)fM)T]Q)CDI 0EcOvID1 D I))K/I))== *I))f2I))6u))=(E))c/^))E

0 ) /I)KjLN]% q1I6u=2I 2 IUI -)D v12 I):D)=2 kKM`0[c# ^@

CW)fI)D]NM)` 0KEzzX2I s[s! 1[)f |I` I9IN`/I== /(Ec
$))gY))D [)) I=1[))EwC))c1 /))q))K # ^)@[)f |I)`M)dI)NS)6/I==
CW)fI)D]NM)`0)K)TN )0 /(E)c^)E / I)>1
])wEv
[]=

CNI))!CO))` , ))K))=M))`C))c1
[)]=/IEK[f |I`bcIN `/I==

1VEX)f2])T2])K
<)EI>EK1
24|DÊ= ()*I)f2I6u=(Ec/Ê~/ I>1CI
C@[))!1D]))NE))W I))=]WM))EwE=))LK !]E)c])cCD[)OK/!b ]D\6*Ilr
)K<)=2])KI)D]N)D[= C<=0]!1
[]= 1]K[f
)ÊI/LK1I2 IUIC}fM}qEErN /IO)dA21 Ov 0 1ID!bd=!CcI% q
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
CW)f2I#1 !C>D
]E@C ]y0IwO` )DIQ>)dPqIKJ}sI6u=CvIf/]LT 2]K

[IK]NIKD]NOv]@ ]yTN 0!1]= I)6{>c]EEtNOv 0 .IAKCOW I1 [I
2I6u=% q21 ]K/2 \@]QPXK=M` 1C)d>9M)dAI)6~Y!cI6EWI [D[c
M)`C)d=Ik[IK]NM`]lulr*If [))c[))` C)])o))K
))cC)])=
1I)#! 1/CI)ad=MEfgY!0IwOÌK= ]O)dEK/!1vI)h2 ]v 0[c/IEK>d
.I)U/IK/NC2[`1u}OZID]N P)qIKI)I6]K]OdEK IdvIKIK/!1[cIK/]AD!
CWfID]NCqC@!INKD]K01q

Cc! 1C>c^6C}CI=CWfID]N/qIK

{I))c))=[))0[))cC))v]r
(-'I))>D] *HED7J?ED

-K8J7B7H $E?DJ
12)cI&I)z]QbI= o K I}W]
&?=7C;DJ&7N?JO

.?8?7

(7L?9KB7H-;9KD:KC
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]

0;HJ?97B.7BKI

;<EHC?JO .7HI7B E7B?J?ED

D7JECO .7BKI D7L?9KB7H &?=7C;DJ

%?D;I?EBE=O .7BKI 97B97D;KI &?=7C;DJ

?EC;9>7D?9I (7L?9KB7H 9KD;?<EHC &?=7C;DJ

.>;H787D: 9>7HH? EHH?EB

(7J?ED7B97:;COE<-FEHJI';:?9?D; O<;H
3 / 14


2I)2 I)UICWf1CI 2I I]KG = bD^v I=YCLgq~OaE`/ ]y]EQFNMXN

2]D\))6]Q!C))T1C=))=/ 1 I))6u))= 2!I)`-I)rvCIad=ME}KIybD^v o K-k
()hDC` ]KMEM` Y]K2]OK .IU)a1 I= ~=2IMvIKME|IrvbD^v o K
)=)D)K)TNI)KE)9~)[)DIC)/[91 C)O=]W~OaE`2]>}qMEv]nbD^v o K
])QC)` ]K)K0!)W)D Oc\@2I b1;6 )M)ErITM)}qKI{>N1]6D
[cIKC
C)}CI=ID]N[IK]NIKD]NCWf#1 0[)c.I)U2Ib1;6[Ov]@ ]y2ID!TN
]))K CO1I))zD]))N1I))>D]#! 1J))k f (-'2I<E>N=M`/!C=IWÊ

I)KI)/2 \)@]Q)aDIz1*I)f2I)6u=f 2I)D])NKMLa2]OK]EQFNI 2 IUICY]K
*I>)c[)` C)])o)K[))OY]6]O=]AD[>D ~)CW)fD])N0Ec
[ CO`CWf
[!IE= T1/I9~0!WD Cd1;6 KI)dOL|=M`
CO1IzID]N]AD
IK]hIWb1;61 D!M`2]OdEK 2Ib1;6 I))D]N ))cC)).I))U^))EC>))dY /
CW)fI)D]N{)>N1]6)`]EQI)NC)` ]K*[ 1/N [y]>}qbD^vJL` CO1Iz
D]N1I>D]#! 1JkID]N[IK]ND]N )D E)dE6I)r|Il
[cC}iq{XN
u)lr*I)f2I6u=f]K CO1Iz )k)K[)=C[EDFN C` ]K jK1 0!W
M`0[c.IU/!1vIh2 ]a6/!b C)` ]K)KC)d1;6 / I>1[Ec >v-IR
2I)6u)=)LK])K2 Ow CWfI]K<D]Q
+# )=[)OvID 1)OY]6/]a62IOaD-IrN1*If
/)!bE)6])kI)KC)K]UN )E]hIWb1;6 1IwNCdDI!01]@/! _61/! bE6/IE
-])O=01])@<D1CdDI!01]@ÌK/! _6 ))T1))h Iq))LKM))T 2 I))r
)E}={I)cb1;)62 I)rIT
-1[TK CvIfMD]D[*[IK2 |Iz / I>1 /11
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
2I)6u)=I)K-1l)Òp)lz]a6/! b [[E` UEODK/I== ]D\6*Ilr2I6u=

I)h]c/IO)`]c/!1 vI)h2 1ulr*If /I) J)TJ)ÌCW)f#1 !0IwO`=
bDI))6]))k2I))0!0IwO))Ì))K))=[))K 1 /]D[I9E)`D])K01)qcCh Iq
))# 1]))61#!))CO}>))`2I))2 I))UI I)D]N)=[)OvID Cd1;6
/ I>
#1 !0IwO)Ì)K[)cI)ZOI)EK !2 I ])QI)I62!])O1*I)f2I6u=LK [IK]N
)=])w ~)UW)K2)[v[2]E@ ^))E / I))> 1 <))ENM))Ò))c2 I))r
[))Kb1;))6))K1 12]))K.!jD]))c[))T1 ])Q[)IK]NCO1I)zID]N!0IwO`=[OvID
01])@ CvI)gN )f)K1[[)cIZO ulr*If2I6u=LK]K2 Ir
-])O=01])@<)D1C)dDI!01]@`{Ic0]w I)6 IOYI)`CNIEW0IADIT1bzKTNIKD]KIK
Vl)`"I)`])K)~)UW)D[[)cDÂDIT MYI)cI)K)=M)`2 1]h/IaCO=]W0]EU!
I))ZO[f /! /N1[f /IEk 1))fM))T *I))f2I))6u))=2 I))UI{))I=
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
![)K I)Lqb1;)6)K1 12I IEr[)c CDIT/!c.[yI2 IUID% qbI=

]a6!bIL}k1M=]cMDIh .]v{E>N
17J;H,;I?IJ7D9;.H7?D?D=
/!1vI))))h2 !))))b))))-1l))))Ò
%MED

-?L79>7D:?H7D
M=])cu)lr*I)f2I)6u)=2 ! b
J?A
4 / 14

]))K[)Y!=[c0/IEkIK1 -k ]ADCI IDCD]NI]K8E /]>

[c IYb1;6![ZK=/I! JE))`zKI))`{I))c1]))Y2I)) IEr1D]))N
eYI)c/!1[)y2]E@0![[OK]k2]T2]K C)aTM)E|}rCI)OXN.[CW]TID1CAOa>c
2I) ^Kx)D]k!u)lr*I)f2I)6u=1'# C)O=]W)2[)6N {>)dIDC>c^6MEq
C))dDI!2I))01]))@_7))`[))c.I))Ub1;))6 1!bE)KM)LEs1CI)OXN.[){fIwCrELk]Es
-])O=01])@[)]=]T CWf2I {>N1]6 I)KCAI)!_)6)KC)D]NI)a}T a}T
CWfID]N[Oc[CD]NI]K[D 2)))a}TC)))k)))kK]E|H)))a1" [)))

)a}T])1)a}T)`2)Ow)Ow a}T 3I)=x)EzXN])kE! D[|11/! b
_)6MDI 1 -1[T[ ]TKzEy {))E>N ))r|Il MDI))h .]))v1[[))c))ETN
2I)) ^K/I))x))D]k!I))0 1))D.I))N! b1;)6C)yY-)fM)DIq )o )K[
[c]T/!_62]E@0![ [)cOcAI]XI C!2]vIgZd
AZ" <G'S#+UW:5
/!_6 {zOa]EtO /!bE6 IC! 01]@
. 2 . /!1vIh2 *If2I6u=h IqIK/!b [IK]NIKD]N
. 2 . /!1vIh2 *If2I6u=h IqIK/!b (-'ID]N
. 2 . /!1vIh2 *If2I6u=h IqIK/!b CO1IzID]N
. . /!1vIh2 *If2I6u=h IqIK/!b -]O=
)OwM)d2 [)IK]NI)KD])N)OwMd2I]EtO 1]K1/!_6}W] CKID! . I]EtO 1]K1/!bE6}W] CKID! .
CO1IzID]NOwMd 2(-'ID]N
])O)K[)y.1/)N])K~EazN.]@}E=K/!1 -CE:;B S`[y![y2]E@0![2]K

I)Er/)qK IN EK '#[D]@0IwO` [))c0IwO))`]))OC))}E M))yI))K !;HC7DO
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
[cOv]@]o /!1vIh ))KMd6]K2I6IKC!= f D[K

!u))lr*I))f2I))6u))=]))EtObU))`M))T ])y2 kK0[c0[ILa9 DK=CU`[y

{>)c [)c0IwO)` C}IOèYIc2]E@0![ I)6121 21Ia k Kb[K/!131=[Ov]@
)EWIE)K&I)LN C}IO)`CDI)6u)="yeYIc ])yIO)` <)D I)I61N1]`3IEIQc~EazN
)f)K1[)=CIUD I6bzCw}Y12^=] [=_| D]v]`1ÌKII6Md61]E@
D])N C)}Y]K"IjY<Dc CLÌX]D! C)!])`21 )=b)= jY!0IwOÌK_7`
)lzcC0[Ed= I" INIO]`1I6cI6EWI J)aW])K])v[y.!IKM|IW [c C0 ]y
)D!cCLÌXC}YC|k XDCIE 2])KE)9~)[D]@MLQ12]E@0![]OCOI`
0[E)d=2 )kC|)k X]KqjY<Dlz %* #. -I)OEUD21!])N!/!12])E@0![
<)D{>)cE)K[= LqI6bz!=c C I)KI)C![c0IwO` CE:;B"#(
"I)C}YC|k X=2lz2]K]ADjY 2 kC>c^621!]N21 bw=/1[K1<L`"IL|
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
_7)`)cC)0[E)d=M)`)Ov]@ ]ycI6]K )c~EazNI61]21 /Ic /!1=[Ov]@ ]y

K cI6EWI1 I6bz2^=]EWI%]q [)cM)LQ.]@}E=
MyIK]v/[K/!1_7`
'#A=
C -))]v!~)) '#L))ÌX2]))K

-J7>;B?#D:;N
5 / 14


CN )f.1)Ow CN )f-1Ow CDI6u="yeYIcc C2]E@ 0![]O C}E

CU I). I9Ow1 CU I.Òw M)`)K [)z]K [z/]=~EazNIK*#
!~))dc))Ow !~U))6))Ow[))f *#
[DC
^)]y~O)dOw1 ^]y~OwOw
*B7DJ7HH9>#D:;N

M)dCI)N-1)Ow {)>N1]6D

?) 1 ])>N
I)K [)IK]NI)K])o D]N
1]) ])>N<)DbD^vIK10]=!IsCN f
/I)DI6 )Ow]) [)IK]N IdvbD^v1Ow
[E)` /I)DI6)K^]y? 1 ]>N
IK~OdOw
C)D]N2I){)>N1]6CIN =M`]=K.!
K/]=.]@CD]NI]K<D[OK I C! 'SZ+1?D9+BY.?+8T Q$B
)K/])=]Ì]K<DIO 1zEy
[
!u)lr*I)f2I6u=eEZdNMTD]K01q
-1[T[.IU zEy [
21I)/ZO)`M)v/!!MZ`*If2I6u=
,G'ST'T+# '7\E+X(<U0Q$0<
E)|12])K21I)Mv/![c0IwO`
(.
+$(<T
M)T2}E)`1/)q)K
21]Kj`N IK
)}W] ID]N!2 0]EU!{Ic{>N1]6D
])c/I@[)1 I)6/E)Ì1]6 [z2!I` C=
2!I)` )9 I7>D12!I)` -Irv2!I` {Dk2!I` I
[)OK21IMv/Ê/]=eZdMT[c0
])1)a}T )Ow]))Ow [K.IUa
(I)wN <)9=b)=j)Y<)D!0IwOÌK]@ /!
2!I)` I}W] [c]TzEy 1[Wa}T
C)RYMEr)h1 E)!Vl)Ì)N21I)/ZO`
bI=IDbN2!IÌ oK2 I2I<E>N!
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
21I)OD!1]KNbZKD]NOaT]KKTNIK"|IN
-IE))cIv1 I1 2I))M))vIK0![))!bE))KM))E|Irv
MEr)h1 I)=)D_7)`[)=C)2]E@0![
I=D[c 0IwO`/[K 2]N1 Ciq CLgq
]K/[K/!1! -IqIK-I]1_>}D 0IOaD
)=-IE)cIvDI)2!I)Ì 2I)<)E>N!0IwOÌK
DCk21I(IwN *OY[ C.IUI6]21
])T/I)O}s.)v{R[cC.IU]vYj`N
/I)d)=[)I C) 21I)Mv/Ê MErh11
C)dd=2I)<)E>N!2!I)` {)Dk)}W] [c
C|)k")y/[c*IfIDI6dE1]6 [z0[
))1-))kCI))ad=M))E}KIybD^))v ))o)K
M`/!1{XNID/IOaD-k I6C}Y
/[)K -IEcIvDI1 2I MvIK ,)'CO=]W
'X(<U0+ZQ$0<
IOaDbd=2]E@ I>KxD]k!}W]D[c 0IwO`
:W+-<0+-V(<U0Q$0< MR
2!I)`-Irv}W][c .IUCiq CLgqbd=1
)K[)IK]NI)KC)D]NI]K-1CdDI!01]@
2I))<))E>N1^))UCOD))zNI))D]N!0IwO))Ì))K
1[)Wa}T]1a}TÒw]1Ow [
bD^)vI)D2!!I)K o KCOErh1<D]O1^D
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
M))1Iz[))c]))T0[))D^v ))f))K))zEy
I)ODI1[)c])T I)=~)=2I)M)vIK2!I`-Irv
])=C)])EEtN])D! fKOw] I[IK]N
))o))K.IU))a2I))<))E>N!.IU))a))}W]

(7L?9KB7HHEF.;IJ
,7D=;E< 'EJ?ED
HE:O
6 / 14

J)}Tx)q0 I)K VE)hN1]ZO`jEX !)iq.I)NCrT

CD^v ~]>}q2!!IK
/]=.]@ I/IKC]xD]k!]vIOq }E))`1))K))=0[1]))dE62]))>}qI))=]Wx))D]k
2I 1Ic1[IK]N!0IwOÌKCO1IzID]N [[))cC)).I))UI))D6~U))aI))=]W2]E@ I))>K
DI6 I9!0IwOÌKC|IrNI=]W 0]Es1I68 -1[T[c0IwO`
])`2])KC)dd=I)=]W I)c)OZN1-1 '1T+PTV(<U0Q$0<
x)q ~)=M)ay )I]K)D -1[)T/]= ]))Ow [)K CO1IzD]NI]K
1[WINI6u=!(IwN ]R=[W1[c]T]ZO` [)c])T)zEy 1[Wa}T ]1a}T Ow

KIC!*I I)K2 I@!I)`
)K])D!}W]S6{IcID]N

-OD;H=?IJ?9
:W+-<0+-'X(<U0Q$0< :5
IO61C` 1 d>}vC` 1 d>}v IO6 d>}v IO6 /4 1 /4 D IO6 C` 1 I=]W
8d>}v /4 D /4 1 /4 D d>}v d>}v IOw

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! -1
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! .1
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! .`
EIQMW]O`
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! . I9
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~U6
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~dc
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~Ow
EIQMW]O`

]>NME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~Od
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
EIQMW]O`
7 / 14


+X(<U0Q$0< :5
IXEhN [c ]>N[ 1 M=]W {W]
CT IYbZK Oa EIQ
C}r}y1
I
CT IYbZK Oa EIQ
C ]`1
-IEcIvDI2!IÌ
CT IYbZK Oa EIQ
-ILENE}D
I6Md6C}YbY]9 Oa EIQ
}y1bd=
I6Md6C}YbY]9 Oa EIQ
C}rbd= -kbD^v
I6Md6C}YbY]9 Oa EIQ
!IK+IkM|IW C ]`1bd= IOaDbd=
I6Md6CT IYbY]9 Oa EIQ

0IOaDM|IW .IE60[d=bd=
C[yCyI`

M1Iz{KIz 8d>}vC` 1
C}Y}y1

I6<D+I`/]=[}K
2!I`-Irv
bY]9IK0]M1Iz{KIz !/]=~Y
C}Y?D]Oa

<D]O1^DCODzND]N
/ C}Y
Cw}YCyI`

M1Iz{KIz /4 D1d>}v IO6
!I6JÌ"ymwW
/IOdA{KIz ~EzOa Oa

Vl`[9 I6<D21 ]K-IrNKCKIEO` CdZK.IUa
.`1.1
'1T+PT'X(<U0Q$0< :5
CIoOv 0 K!D]N C|IrNI=]W 1M=]W Ov 0 Ov 0 I=]W
I>`M=]W Cw=!0IwO`
*If! E` DI6 I9IK Ch]vz}W }TK JzqK IOw
]>N
]O ]O ]>N
]>N 1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! -1
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N

]>N 1 ]O
]O ME|Irv/Ê
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
zEy/I! .1
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N

zEy/I! .`
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N

zEy/I! . I9
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N
]>N
1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~U6
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N
]>N
1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/Ê
zEy/I! ~dc
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O
]O
]>N
]>N
1 ]O ]O
ME|Irv/Ê
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
zEy/I! ~Ow
EIQMW]O`
]>N
]O ]O ]>N
]>N
1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/Ê

zEy/I! ~Od
EIQMW]O`
8 / 14

+ZY1N+( +J\GQ)S80 Y(=60

1/!1[y`{IcI C!2]v2I C@;D1 2I)1I)wN 2 I)r /! MTb1;6D
{>c C` ]K 01]@ I92]K '#eYIc #1 ! /!_6 1 /!bE6I01]@EAIE
M`0[cG I)K2])EtO[)9 _I)D = {)E}XN 1 )DÛN 2 I
1bDI)!01]@` = [C/Id -1[TSDIO 2 I)rVl)` -*-- ^)v .])!0IwO`
b1;)6 )2I)]EtO!C)>D {y[)W-]O= [c0IwO`
I)K/)!_)6B)}W] u)lr*I)f2I6u= ))Ìc ))K +))Y [))= 2 ]))hIW ))r|Il

[ 2 Ir1IwN]AD[>D [cIKC #, #/ %"-" ,

!
+Z'W[T I-<T<1T<-<%[S)# <%[S)#<1T'1W+? :O+? V?V)&W+)TQ$B
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
AZ" +Z<%+Z<UW V)&W+)T <- <)L1T:X! >W+([# Q)S80 QE+7 4(+1W :5
2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![ [z /! 01]@

2E6]Q

^}>D12[L

?E}O]Q [IK]NIKD]N

21 dD D]N5 ^K

2E6]Q

^}>D12[L

(-'

?E}O]Q

21 dD D]N5 ^K

2E6]Q

^}>D12[L

CO1IzD]N

?E}O]Q

21 dD D]N5 ^K
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]

2E6]Q

^}>D12[L

?E}O]Q -]O=

21 dD D]N5 ^K
Z Vl` I01]@/!_61/!bE62I0]EK2 Ir1IwN
9 / 14


+E+ M# +Z<UW V)&W+)T <- [$W+T V1T [$W Q)S80 QE+7 4(+1W
:5
2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![ 1\UEAIE 1\U(U 01]@ ]EtO

[IK]NIKD]N

(-'
ulr*If2I6u=

CO1IzD]N

-]O=
Z Vl` 01]@] /!_61/!bE62I0]EK2 Ir1IwN
1 <))EN/ I))>1 /]D[I9E))`/ I))> 1I)wN = cC 0[Id -1[TSDIOKTNIK

1C)E:}@2I))OvIDI)KI) CY ~/ I> 2I6u= ]EtO 'IX| ! /!_6 1 /!bE6 EK
1/ I)))>12]))wrT])))q / I))> 01]))@[))IK]NI))KD]))N01]))@ u))lr*I))f

[CY~ / I>1 CD}9I9 Vl)` CO1I)zD])N01])@1 (-'
I)D]N ]EQF)N aDIzK Cd1;6 / I>1 . ])Q 0![) JD]h01qKM` Ir Z
-IrN]K*If 2I6u= CWf ID]NIK <D]OD6 01])@1 (-'01])@[)IK]NI)KD]N2I 01]@
+I)9
IN /I== 2]>}q,]XN1I6 MErh1 [)f

1 JEN]NK CO1IzD]N
)D SDI)O[)OY]6 ]D\)6*I)lr*I)f 2I6u=IK D])N[OK2 \@]QMD|1JEN]N KD]KIKK
]EQF))N C))D]N))I]K1]))/I))d))r|Il 1 [)IK]ND]N[rK (-'CWf
[) *I)f 2I)6u)= 2 I)UIf]K 2 Ir [Oc ]y
CO1IzD]NIO
))KC))d1;6 ~))/ I))>1[E))c >v
u=LK]K2Ow CWfI]K<D]Q C` ]K 28-
r|IlD[OY]6/]a62IOaD-IrN1*If2I6 2[)rO>d[NC*If2I6u=2 IUI
01])@/)!_)61/)!bE6/IE=/Id !I))` ))c 0]))!1 C@[))!10]))=I))UD
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
)h Iq)LKM)T 2 I)r1I)wNCdDI! !bE)60;)D1Kh IqDf1CDIÌcD]KIK

01])@1/)! _)6/I)E1I)wN1O)cT1 !)K[)Y2 1])h1 ~) IE)aKC|I)` 5 ^K
1 I)LTM)`0)K Ir~[Ic1CdDI! )`]EQF)NC)` ]K*[)I)K])hIWb1;)61 D
I>D]#! 1JkID]N=[OvID ~/ I> CW)fI)D]N[)IK]NI)KD])NCWf{>N1]6
2I)6u)=LK]K2 Ir]EQFNCO1IzID]N1 )h Iq)f])K CO1IzD]N1 (-'
1 /]D[I9E)`1 / I>1C=D
[ *If 2 ])a6/!) b) ulr*If2I6u=
1 <)EN[)]=[)EDFN +)vSDI)OÊ/ I> )`)=/Idb1;6SDIO[c.IU/!1 vIh
!0IwO)`]EQF)NC` ]KKCd1;6 ~ / I> )f])K2 I)r]EQF)NCW)fID]N{>N1]6
u)lr*I)f2I)6u=LK CWfI ]K<D ])a6/!)b ulr*If2I6u=h Iq
I)KCO1IzID]N!0IwO`=[OvID 1OY]6 Z [Oc/!1vIh2
u)lr*I)f2I6u=LK]K2 Ir]Q[IK]N / I))>1
.2I))))OvIDI))KI))))OvID))D
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
1 C=))D / I))>1 I))LT/ I))>1[E))c >v

-?L79>7D:?H7D

J?A
BB7C
9>79>BEK;?
/A?
10 / 14

12 1I))KYIUDJTI))D]N ]O))`1/I! /11 / I>1

-IKID]K01q
eZc 2LK1CNI)))"I)))aW/[cOa>c SDI)O^)E / I)>1 I)^D1 / I>1
[C0!IT[IK]NIKD]NE9 ~
cC []=# ^@ CKId
"]O)`{KIy1]N(O2]K I=CO=]W2IA|IN 2I)#1 !]hIWr|Il[I0[c]=Ir|Il
CE|I)Ku)}OZjD])c 1u}OZE`]v2]K u)=h IqKOL]vLK2]KCw}OZCD]N
I)KvI)hI)KD])N2I,]X1[cIK"]O` Cq))K^)E.[=]1[ 0]=0IwO`*If2I6
cCiqMDzNK]U[IK]NM1Iz!CcI )T1)DI)K [)0)# ^)@ 2]Q)SDI)O

M))}q))K^))E CO1I))zI))D]N

I)K CN1I)wOSDI)O)= T1ÊCDI b1;6
[I[NC M=]W.IA0 12I Idv -IR kK[0]=# ^@Ib1;6D2IOvID
! /!121])E!C)cI I)dv)KIT[h{E]N ID]N/Id/ I>1CD}9I9b1;6SDIO
)).I))N D]))N1O))Ì=CI))OXN.[))21 [) [*I)f2I6u=LK]K2 Ir]QCWf
!I` ]aE Idv"IaW1 D]O=IK CO=]W ))=[))OvID ^))E/ I))>12]))wrT]))q
C)aW2I) I=1!I`<D]XNbD^v]AD*]k! +)D1!1O)v 0 )LK])KC)LE=]NID]N
CO1I)z}E)`10]KCKjEX /[K2]>E6 [)2 I)r]EQF)N/)T/!) b
)LK]K-1[O{>cK[0IN= [IK]N[I I))D]N))=[))]=/I))EK~)) / I))>1C))E:}@
]EQFN*If2I6u= . [`KOL]vLK]K [D[T]>D1 IKCWf
/^)E)=/Id]hIWr|IlSDIOD]K01q ))D [))2 I))r]EQF))N))dE1]6*]))X
D]N(-'CWfD]N{>N1]6`2 \@]Q !0IwO))`!C))cI[))NC))I))))OvID 1I))wN
J))EN]N))K CO1I))zD]))N1[))IK]N ()C)D]N0 1[)u}OZCWf2I #1
]))ADCN I)Lq)KM))`0)K[)f
1 2I))#1 1I))C))!jD]))cCW))fI))=]W
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
C)D]N#1 D]N \@]Q (-'CWfID]N [cIK1IwOCd1;6

[)]=# ^@/ I>1Z>EE!D [K ur)hu)lr*If2I6u=IUD~{q!
I)D]N2 \)@]Q/^)E 2 I)r1I)wN= NIE6)`M|I)iq$gY K <Ea]Oa=M|Iiq
))D ))T1*I))f2I))6u))=))LK u))}OZ 1I6 <Ea]ODiq1 Cw}Y /IN I7= N D
CO1I)))zI)))D]N[)))]=# ^)))@E)))zzX 0;)D1)KCWfID]N
MÌD6ILQbI=
12X[ 0KCD]N#1 D]N \@]Q M))DzN ))iq(-'CW)fD]))N)I]K
CWfD]NI]K]EQFNaDIzh~ / I> CO}>` 1f JÌICDIOaD2I MErh1
/]a6 *If2I6u=2 IUI]KCrh1pIT IKUEO =2]EQF)N[)C)bI)= Ciq
E)K2 I)r1I)wN=[]= /q-I`
IN
1C)O=]W2I I2]E@ID C)iq [yOv
#! 1J)k pI)TI)D]N1CrhID]N]EQFN Mc\@I))K[DCT1KCI))aTCDI))N))LK
)T1*If2I6u=2 IUIf I>D]

7DM;B
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
1CI))w}DM))`]O))dEKpI))TI))D]N]EQF))N1
P;C7

CWfID]N#1 1]EQFNaDIzIKÊ / I> NJH?DI?9 'KI9B;I

-KF?D7JEH 'KI9B;

#! 1J)kC)}CI)=CW)fI)D]N1SD #DL;HJEH 'KI9B;

*EIJ;H?EH ECF7HJC;DJ
M)aE|ILNv/I)TI62 IUI]EEtN]KI>D]
#DJH?DI?9 'KI9B;I
11 / 14


M))DIq )) &I))EOW1

[))D1="1]))D1 I)#1 )D2 \@]Q/Ê 2 Ir1IwN
0 1E))9~)))0 I)cCO))c[K2I){)>N1]6 "I)`])K [)]=0[Id*If2I6u=LK
2I)0 13I)OW)K)Ow )r|Il)DCD]N ]N \)@]QI>D]JkCWfID]Nb1;6D
)=)D)h[)cIK]N]Q)])N [[}KCD]N )T1)DI)K)K[)IK]N[ICO`2I #1 !
p))lz]))a6/!b21 3Iv]))f]hIWb1;6 ]EQF)NEK2 Ir1IwN 0![Y 1COUWC}Y1
c.IU-1lÒ I))D]N1I))>D]#! 1J))kCW))fI))D]N
[)]> 0[I)dOv 0 >d]KCO1Iz

<)%Y6)1W /^))E 2 I))r1I))wN~)) / I))>1 I))LT
I))D]N{)>N1]6)`)=/I)db1;)6SDI)O I)D]N1I)>D]#! 1J)kI)D]N2 \@]Q
D])N1 (-'ID]N[IK]NIKD]NCWf [)]>0[I)d*I)f2I6u=LK2]KCO1Iz
u=h Iqf]K2 Ir]EQFN CO1Iz

2 ]))a6/!))b)) u))lr*I))f2I))6 ~UaCD]N0]EU!<D (-' CWfID]N
JD])h01)q )KZ [)O)c/!1vIh I)9 C) 1[)EwSDI)O[)N C)=M`
01])@[)IK]NI)KD])N2I)01])@ ])Q 0![) .IU)a12!I)`-Irv2!I`{Dk2!I` I}W]
J)EN]N)K CO1I)zD]N01]@1 (-' [)OKCWfI]KD
[cIKOc0]K
M)D|1J)EN]N)KD]KIKK[f
1 )=C>EI)>2I0[]E@.1[1Oa Idv-Iq
[)rK (-' CW)fD]N[OK2 \@]Q I)=Y12^)=]CL)gq2I ~OaE`K Iqk
CO1I)zD])NI)O 1 [IK]ND]N 2I)M)vIK_7)`[)=C)<)D]XN[)=C-I`
SDI)))OC}= )))k)))K[O)))c ])))y
b)d=M)XN0[c0IN=ID-Irv bEK-IEcIvDI1
)LK CW)f#1 `D{EaIO60[ /Id -I)rv~)=-IE)cIvDIMvIK 1[]E@ C ]y
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
!M)`/!)b) *I)f2I6u= 2 IUI .IU))a2I))<))E>NI))K 3I) ODI1))cC))<))D]XN

# 1]61#!E|Hac CIdE61 D <)DKMd@!IK2]K/IaM=]W~OaE`2!!IK
D!#! 1E}r1/IEK]CdZLN/IÌc I= 2]E@ I)>K
cC]T2]>}qCO=]W2A|
*I)f2I)6u=h IqfMTCD]N2I #1 }iqI@[9CDICD^v~1{gwI@[9-Iq
(-'I)))D]N#1 1[)))DI0IwO)))` 0])=<=Ciq CLgq-]O=CKID!IKK[N C
[ ]yCWfID]NMD|1 )iq/I)E ?)IM=]WJEN]ND[K1
ID]N#1 DD]KIK [dZKLK]E@
'W:O<$C0 2I)6u)=LK]K CK}l]Q[N CCWf
/!)b!$gYK1/ I>!}E`1D[K [cIKOc]v *If
2 I))>))r|Il))D.I))U ))=0[))=M=]))c ))K/))NC))]))hIWb1;))62I))MD1[))X!
]@CC [y1]>dNMDI[ C[)))I60 1 b1;)))62I)))02 1p)))T
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
12 / 14


8:EB7>P7:'7D;I>C7D:?" .>;;<<;9JE<7DM;;A(-'9EHH;9J?L;;N;H9?I;FHE=H7CED
KFF;H9HEII;:IOD:HEC; $-FEHJ?EC;9> KJKCD 5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
7O7JJEHA ' -ASB: ' -KD:IJHKF D:;HI;D && N;H9?I; ?DJ;HL;DJ?EDI JE ?CFHEL; FEIJKH7B
C7B7B?=DC;DJI ?D >;7: D;9A 7D: JHKDA 7CED= 7:EB;I9;DJI 7:KBJI 7D: EB:;H F;EFB; IOIJ;C7J?9
H;L?;ME<H7D:EC?P;:9EDJHEBB;:JH?7BI $N;H9,;>78?B ;8
BIK>7OC? ' BCE>7CC7:? B>7H8? ) B7M<? " )B<7J '' B>7PC? ) ;J 7B
B7J<EEJ 7CED= I9>EEB7=; 9>?B:H;D ?D BC7:?D7> BCKD7MM7H7> *H;L7B;D9; 7D: H?IA <79JEHI $
'KI9KBEIA;B;J-KH=,;I $7D
7DM;BB " *7H?I ' '79A?DJEI> - 1?BB?7CI ' *;:?7JH?9 <B;N?8B; <B7J <EEJ >EM 7H; M;
C;7IKH?D=?J7D:7H;M;=;JJ?D= ?JH?=>JIOIJ;C7J?9H;L?;M $ EEJDAB;,;I '7O

7AEEH ,7I>?: " 7D;I>C7D:? " .>; ;<<;9JI E< 7 M;;AI 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I; FHE=H7C ED
?CFHEL?D=<B7J<EEJ7D:IJ7J?987B7D9;?D8EOI $ *H79J-JK?EI-FEHJ 1?DJ;H 5 KBB
J;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
/;A?3-7AKC717:7# *7J>EBE=O7D:C7D7=;C;DJE< <B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ?D9>?B:H;D $7D

!>7:;H?O7D ' !>7I;C? ! ECF7H?IED J>; H7J; E< CEL;C;DJ <EEJ 9;DJ;H E< FH;IIKH; ED 8EO
IJK:;DJIO;7HIEB:M?J>DEHC7BFB7DKI7D:97LKI<EEJJOF;I $,;I-FEHJ,;>78?B -FH?D=
5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
;DKCKB7F7BB?%KBA7HD?''!7D:EJH7, *H;L7B;D9;E<<B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ?D7:KBJI79HEII
I;9J?ED7BIJK:O $B?D?7=D,;I $KD
)P7D EU7H !;DQ;H % %EOKD9K W 07J7DI;L;H KO=KBK ;J 7B -OCFJEC7J?9 <B;N?8B;
<B7J<EEJ?D7:KBJIIK8J7B7H7HJ>HE;H;?I?I .>;HB?D,?IA'7D7= )9JX
9>7HH?$$ EHH?EB .>;:;L;BEFC;DJ?D<EEJFH?DJCEHF>EBE=O?DED=EB;I;9>?B:H;D<HEC
KH87D7D:HKH7B7H;7I7D:J>;H;B7J?EDI>?F8;JM;;DJ>?I7D:M;7H?D=I>E;I $*;:?7JH)HJ>EF
'7H
O<;H $$ HE7J9> $, .H;M?D $ "7DIED H=KI % !7HD>7C * ;J 7B EB: M7J;H
?CC;HI?ED7JJ;DK7J;I7D78EB?9 I?=D7B?D=7D:IA;B;J7BCKI9B;<?8;H>OF;HJHEF>O8KJDEJIJH;D=J>=7?D
<EBBEM?D=M>EB;8E:OH;I?IJ7D9;JH7?D?D= $FFB*>OI (EL
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
C7C? ' C7C? - 'E>7CC7: "EII;?D? ' *H;L7B;D9; E< <B7J <;;J <B;N?8B; JOF; ?D C7B;
9>?B:H;D $';:? ,;I -KCC;H 5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
'EI970- B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ?D9>?B:H;D7D:7:EB;I9;DJI $>?B:)HJ>EF FH
7FE:7=B?E*!E88?'EDDE& KC7=7BB?KH7JJE!7BB?';J7B <<;9JE<E8;I?JOED
AD;;7D:7DAB;8?EC;9>7D?9I:KH?D=M7BA?D= -;DIEHI7I;B )9J
B7HA ' &K9;JJ - (-' ;II;DJ?7BI E< 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I; JH7?D?D= IJ ;: /- C7PED

%7B7D? ( ->7>H87D?7D - ,?7>? 4 <<;9JI E< H;I?IJ7D9; JH7?D?D= M?J> J>;H787D: ED F7?D 7D:
GK7B?JOE<B?<;?DF7J?;DJIM?J>AD;;EIJ;E7HJ>H?J?I $7I,;I';:-9 $KB
%M7A$%?C3&&;;-' <<;9JIE<;B7IJ?987D:H;I?IJ7D9;;N;H9?I;ED87B7D9;CE8?B?JO7D:
=7?J<KD9J?ED<B;N?8?B?JO7D:<7BB;<<?979O?D;B:;HBOF;EFB; $*>OI.>;H-9? (EL

$7887H%!7D:EC? .>;;<<;9JIE<D7J?ED7B797:;COE<IFEHJIC;:?9?D;7D:I7>HC7DDJH7?D?D=
ED<EEJFH;IIKH;:?IJH?8KJ?ED?D<B;N;:FEIJKH;IJK:;DJI #H7,;>78?B$ '7H
BC7IEE:?'# '7>:7L?D;@7:,!>7I;C?! .>;;<<;9JE<M;;AID7J?ED7B797:;COE<IFEHJI
C;:?9?D; ;N;H9?I;I JH7?D?D= ED FEIJKH; I>EKB:;H F7?D 7D: <KD9J?ED7B :?I78?B?JO ?D C7B; M?J> KFF;H
9HEIIIOD:HEC; *IO9>E:K$ ;8
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
7J7B>7(?7I-'7H?D>E*7HH797$ .>;;<<;9J?L;D;IIE<B7D:7D:M7J;H87I;:H;I?IJ7D9;
JH7?D?D=EDI>EKB:;HHEJ7JEH9K<<IJH;D=J>7D:87B7D9;E<OEKJ>IM?CC;HI $"KC%?D;J $KD

'EKI7L? ' !>7P7B?7D <<;9J E< ;?=>J M;;AI M7J;H H;I?IJ7D9; JH7?D?D= M?J> :7HA 9>E9EB7J;
IKFFB;C;DJ7J?ED ED J>; 87B7D9; E< J>; ;B:;HBO $ ->7>?: -7:EK=>? /D? ';: -9? KJKCD
5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
13 / 14


%MED$3'O;HIED'- '7D7=;C;DJE<J>;<B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ?DJ>;9>?B:7<E9KIEDJ>;KI;E<
EIJ;EJEC?;I<EH9EHH;9J?ED EEJDAB;B?D $KD
-?L79>7D:?H7D - %KC7H ! <<;9J E< 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I;I FHE=H7CC; 7CED= 7J>B;J;I M?J> <B7J
<;;JED<EEJ7B?=DC;DJ<79JEHI #DJ$*>OI:K9-FEHJI";7BJ> (EL
J?A)POKH;A- B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ (EHJ>B?D#IJ7D8KB K=
(?;C?HE !' ,;M7D; B=EJ7H ' N;H9?I; 7D: <?JD;II ;<<;9J ED E8;I?JO $KD #D
-J7J*;7HBI5#DJ;HD;J6 .H;7IKH;#IB7D: &-J7J*;7HBI*K8B?I>?D= $7DX *'#
BB7C "" 'K>I;D B17B7> ' BEJ7?8? ( BEJ7?8? -- BI7OO7: &% <<;9JI E<
FBOEC;JH?9 ;N;H9?I;IL;HIKI <B7J<EEJ 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I;IED FEIJKH7B 9EDJHEB7D: <EEJ FEIJKH;?D E8;I;
9>?B:H;DM?J>7 <B;N?8B; <B7J<EEJ FFB?ED?9I?EC;9> )9J

!EB9>?D? ,7>D7C7(&EJ<? EHEKI>7D?' <<;9JE<9EHH;9J?L;;N;H9?I;IM?J>7D;M7FFHE79>
EDJ>;?IEC;JH?9IJH;D=J>?DF;EFB; M?J>FHED7J?ED:?IJEHJ?EDIOD:HEC; $*7H7C;-9?;D,;>78?
1?DJ;H 5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
H78@7<7H? 4 7J7>? " ->7CI;>AE>7D * .>; ;<<;9J E< M;;AI 9EC8?D;: ;N;H9?I;I EH;
IJ78?B?JO7D:.>;H787D:ED:?IJ7D9;E<AD;;C;:?7B9ED:OB;I+7D=B;7D:;D:KH7D9;E<9EH;CKI9B;I
?D7:EB;I9;DJIJK:;DJIM?J>=;DKL7HKC $,;I-FEHJ,;>78?B -KCC;H 5 KBBJ;NJ
?D*;HI?7D6
9>79>BEK;? 887IP7:;=7D ' =>87BCE=>7DBEK .>; ;<<;9JI E< 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I;
FHE=H7CED<B7J<EEJ:;<EHC?JOE<C7B;7D:<;C7B;IJK:;DJI DD?EBE,;I ;8
P;C7 # 87H7E=K /) )A7<EH !) B7J <EEJ 7D: 7IIE9?7J;: <79JEHI 7CED= FH?C7HO I9>EEB
9>?B:H;D9HEIII;9J?ED7BIJK:O "ED=%ED=*>OI?EJ>;H$ $KD
,KIK&'7H?D'#!;7C8;I7'',KIK', 'ED?JEH?D=J>;HEB;E<F>OI?97B79J?L?JO?D9>?B:H;D
M?J> <B7J <;;J 8O 7II;II?D= IK8J7B7H <B;N?8?B?JO 7D: FB7DJ7H 7H9> ?D:;N >?B:H;D 7I;B '7H

(?AA>EK7C?H? AEE9>7A?7D ' ->?HP7: H7=>? "EI;?D (;@7: - <<;9J E< I?N M;;AI E<
9ECFH;>;DI?L;9EHH;9J?L;;N;H9?I;IED87B7D9;7D:<EEJFH;IIKH;F7JJ;HD?D<;C7B;7:EB;I9;DJIM?J>
<B;N?8B;<B7J<EEJ $,;>78';: KJKCD 5 KBBJ;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
37B<7D?D87H?7D'D?AEE,D87H?7D' ,;B7J?EDI>?F8;JM;;DFEIJKH7B9EDJHEBM?J>-M7O
879A'7B7B?=DC;DJ?DJ>;DED7J>B;J;C7B;I $#B7C/D?';:-9? KJKCD 5 KBB
J;NJ?D*;HI?7D6
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.22287280.1400.21.2.6.6 ]
)A>B? " "E@@7J? " A>EKD:P7:;> ! ECF7H?D= J>; ;<<;9J E< J>; 9EHH;9J?L; ;N;H9?I;I E<
C;H?97YID7J?ED7B797:;COE<IFEHJIC;:?9?D;7D:*?B7J;IEDJ>;9EHH;9J?EDE<BEH:EI?I7CED=<;C7B;
>?=>I9>EEBIJK:;DJI?D=EB;IJ7DFHEL?D9;?D #DJ$-9>EEB";7BJ> )9J
[ DOI: 10.52547/jarums.21.2.157 ]
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
14 / 14

Foto

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Foto

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

',)&$' )#$&#-)*#+0' #$#&*

'$' ,%%) !* 

" +*' ") '%()"&*#- '))+#-/)#*

,;9;?L;:FH  99;FJ;:'7O 

MHKXT+E+ M#YF+J\E<-'7\E+X(<U0Q$0< Y?<)3*0

/]D/IwfC`!0IAd/IA` Y/Iwf[W1Cc! 1.}q1C[KMEK]N0[>dCWfI=]W1Cc! 1C`Ic JE`01]@

[ Downloaded from jarums.arums.ac.ir on 2023-03-28 ]

]EQI)Nu)lr*I)f2I)6 u)=)f1)LK])KCW)fD])N{)>N1]6)`[  C/IdI OvIDD <)%Y6)1W

M)`I)6K&K]2I h Iq/Ia I 2 IU I YT:PT

I6u=CvIf2 IU I(1I6u=EWI    1eYIcIqh!C>D/[K IOYI`2I 2 IU I

1O)v 0 j})aN.[)qI) !]K IdvCAOaY *I)f2I)6u)=I)6C)}YC|k"y(IwN b I=

C)>EE}=~)GqI)UDJL`= DheEZdN )TK{)q)D!C)LE=]NI)D -I)` INCZO`

0 ) /I)KjLN]% q1I6u=2I 2 IU I -)D v12 I):D)=2 kKM`0[c# ^@

[)]=/IEK[f  |I`bcIN `/I==

2I) 2 I)U ICWf1CI 2I I]KG = bD^v I=YCLgq~OaE`/ ]y]EQFNMXN

]))K CO1I))zD]))N1I))>D]#! 1J))k f  (-'2I <E>N=M`/!C=IW^E

2I)6u)=I)K-1l)`Op)lz]a6/! b [[E` UEODK/I== ]D\6*Ilr2I6u=

![)K I)Lqb 1;)6)K1 12I IEr[)c CDIT/!c.[yI 2 IU ID% qb I=

]) )K[) Y!=[c0/IEkIK1 -k ]ADCI IDCD]NI]K8E /]>

CWfID]N[Oc[CD]NI]K[D 2)))a}TC)))k)))kK]E|H)))a1" [)))

])O)K[)y.1/)N])K~EazN.]@}E=K/!1 -CE:;B S`[y![y2]E@0![2]K

 [cOv]@]o /!1vIh ))KMd6 ]K2I6IKC!= f D[K

_7)`)cC)0[E)d=M)`)Ov]@ ]ycI6]K )c~EazNI61] 21 /Ic /!1=[Ov]@ ]y

J)}Tx)q0 I)K VE)hN1]ZO`jEX !)iq.I)NCrT

1[WINI6u=!(IwN ]R=[W1[c]T]ZO` [)c])T)zEy 1[Wa}T ] 1a}T Ow

I6Md6CT IYbY]9 Oa  EIQ

]O  ]O  ]>N

]>N  1  ]O ]O  ME|Irv/^E

]>N  1  ]O ]O  ME|Irv/^E

1  ]O  ]O ME|Irv/^E

+ZY1N+( +J\GQ)S80 Y(=60

I)K/)!_)6B)}W] u)lr*I)f2I6u= ))`Ic ))K +))Y [))= 2  ]))hIW ))r|Il

2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![ [z /! 01]@

2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![  1\UEAIE  1\U(U 01]@ ]EtO

1 <))EN / I))> 1 /]D[I9E))`/ I))> 1I)wN = cC 0[ Id -1[TSDIOKTNIK

IN /I== 2]>}q,]XN1I6 MErh1 [)f 

)h Iq)LKM)T 2 I)r1I)wNCdDI! !bE)60;)D1Kh IqDf1CDI`IcD]KIK

1 C=))D / I))> 1 I))LT/ I))> 1[E))c >v

12 1I))KYIUDJTI))D]N ]O))`1/I! /11 / I> 1

cCiqMDzNK]U[IK]NM1Iz!CcI )T1)DI)K [)0)# ^)@ 2]Q)SDI)O

C)D]N#1 D]N \@]Q (-'CWfID]N [cIK1IwOCd 1;6

M))DIq  )) &I))EOW1

 [)]> 0[ I)dOv 0 >d]KCO1Iz

!M)`/!)b) *I)f2I6u= 2 IU I .IU))a2I)) <))E>NI))K 3I) ODI1))cC))<))D]XN

9>?B:H;DM?J>7 <B;N?8B; <B7J<EEJ FFB?ED?9I?EC;9> )9J  

Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)

You might also like

',)&$' )#$&#-)#+0' #$#&

'$' ,%%) !*

" +' ") '%()"&#- '))+#-/)#*

,;9;?L;:FH 99;FJ;:'7O

MHKXT+E+ M#YF+J\E<-'7\E+X(<U0Q$0< Y?<)3*0

/]D/IwfC`!0IAd/IA` Y/Iwf[W1Cc! 1.}q1C[KMEK]N0[>dCWfI=]W1Cc! 1C`Ic JE`01]@

]EQI)Nu)lr*I)f2I)6 u)=)f1)LK])KCW)fD])N{)>N1]6)`[ C/IdIOvIDD <)%Y6)1W

M)`I)6K&K]2I h Iq/Ia I 2 IUI YT:PT

I6u=CvIf2 IUI(1I6u=EWI 1eYIcIqh!C>D/[K IOYI`2I2 IUI

1O)v 0 j})aN.[)qI)!]K IdvCAOaY *I)f2I)6u)=I)6C)}YC|k"y(IwN bI=

C)>EE}=~)GqI)UDJL`= DheEZdN )TK{)q)D!C)LE=]NI)D -I)` INCZO`

0 ) /I)KjLN]% q1I6u=2I 2 IUI -)D v12 I):D)=2 kKM`0[c# ^@

[)]=/IEK[f |I`bcIN `/I==

2I)2 I)UICWf1CI 2I I]KG = bD^v I=YCLgq~OaE`/ ]y]EQFNMXN

]))K CO1I))zD]))N1I))>D]#! 1J))k f (-'2I<E>N=M`/!C=IW^E

2I)6u)=I)K-1l)`Op)lz]a6/! b [[E` UEODK/I== ]D\6*Ilr2I6u=

![)K I)Lqb1;)6)K1 12I IEr[)c CDIT/!c.[yI2 IUID% qbI=

]))K[)Y!=[c0/IEkIK1 -k ]ADCI IDCD]NI]K8E /]>

CWfID]N[Oc[CD]NI]K[D 2)))a}TC)))k)))kK]E|H)))a1" [)))

])O)K[)y.1/)N])K~EazN.]@}E=K/!1 -CE:;B S`[y![y2]E@0![2]K

[cOv]@]o /!1vIh ))KMd6]K2I6IKC!= f D[K

_7)`)cC)0[E)d=M)`)Ov]@ ]ycI6]K )c~EazNI61]21 /Ic /!1=[Ov]@ ]y

J)}Tx)q0 I)K VE)hN1]ZO`jEX !)iq.I)NCrT

1[WINI6u=!(IwN ]R=[W1[c]T]ZO` [)c])T)zEy 1[Wa}T ]1a}T Ow

I6Md6CT IYbY]9 Oa EIQ

]O ]O ]>N

]>N 1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/^E

]>N 1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/^E

1 ]O ]O ME|Irv/^E

+ZY1N+( +J\GQ)S80 Y(=60

I)K/)!_)6B)}W] u)lr*I)f2I6u= ))`Ic ))K +))Y [))= 2 ]))hIW ))r|Il

2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![ [z /! 01]@

2 IrVl` 2 I/N ]Q0![ 1\UEAIE 1\U(U 01]@ ]EtO

1 <))EN/ I))>1 /]D[I9E))`/ I))> 1I)wN = cC 0[Id -1[TSDIOKTNIK

IN /I== 2]>}q,]XN1I6 MErh1 [)f

)h Iq)LKM)T 2 I)r1I)wNCdDI! !bE)60;)D1Kh IqDf1CDI`IcD]KIK

1 C=))D / I))>1 I))LT/ I))>1[E))c >v

12 1I))KYIUDJTI))D]N ]O))`1/I! /11 / I>1

cCiqMDzNK]U[IK]NM1Iz!CcI )T1)DI)K [)0)# ^)@ 2]Q)SDI)O

C)D]N#1 D]N \@]Q (-'CWfID]N [cIK1IwOCd1;6

M))DIq )) &I))EOW1

[)]> 0[I)dOv 0 >d]KCO1Iz

!M)`/!)b) *I)f2I6u= 2 IUI .IU))a2I))<))E>NI))K 3I) ODI1))cC))<))D]XN

9>?B:H;DM?J>7 <B;N?8B; <B7J<EEJ FFB?ED?9I?EC;9> )9J