Professional Documents
Culture Documents
!"
"12#$! % !& ' ()*+ ,-$ ./ 0'
-1-
C Q < " 'zy M$K A% 1 15& 17:
b Z M( 5 C(f9 .7( '\ 5JK L(<* C(* p: a1(d
h5 p: E rF J ( T" ] 5JK L(<* ^Z f ;
7: 'E0w : ] A ,K MD*: } 'V$2 A ; H B< H " ,
'7$ M7 U8f\: (2 CTV J: {$2 !, 9 ;] 5
] '_: 5JK L(<* M08 J (d e ,T :U: H0 ME c
E +, 5JK L(<* M08 J -v&: 5JK L(<* A$ *: 17 $1<T
.
R;: 'FV C(* 'T \( '; i*$V b Z '1J: :
E, [(\: "@& 4@|"| !dI: '] 'DU AE GD PG ^ ": .^y E,
.^y E, C(* $ [$f|&| D.; ju !, M] '<-( rPG A <&: .^1y
'; &: .',$T 8 Q: 5JK L(<* ' Q E] '; rPG ! U , B ":
(J< 8\:: G Z 'T0: 8E,: ^y] }"$ H1 h15 1`"
.)z_ Z:
MG ! ',$9 'G aG ("' q" ] a" E9 E5) 5JK L(<* ' Q
JQ 2 "" +, LH ": .a,E D: OU_ 7D
v2J 7: . " 5JK L(<* @"@& !: a,E D: OU1_ 7D C1
()
L(<= & *: b "PT & Q bjkl A1, C: t,E 1 b1
: .(d* H ! q &G }v & $<&: . $ @0$ 'JH: 5JK
8F " ':U m aH 5JK L(<* ' Q '"(`, `& b$1\ i17(
. a,E D: OU_ 7D
()
-2-
;] '9:$ ',$T 8 G b $F 8 "(d& R<, b' q Mv2J:
' q" ;] a" E9 8 2) 8 "n: 5JK L(<* @"@ ',$T ' 1q
C: 8F & FZ ! }v & / b',$T ' q M 1;: .("'1,$T
<&: ' q Sv& M; ] A< 8 ] ! Mz_ Z ' b' q `,
.Mz(
S / ! $ T } ]; ' ; "( ; ' q E s:
} bf5e/ ]; '-#- ',$T ' q E s: ."$]/15J
.',$T ' q: ' q 'J 8Tz(] 5JK L(< '5 '\(T E&: .`"
+, ' q M@0 bG 8, h: aT9 . 5 $ +, ' q E, X& <
L(< a #,K :$2 M ,: .5JK L(<= '< 'T " \:
H: ';5: 'J L(<] * B " !"P : !1" 8: 15JK
a5h$ O Fz b<] ¡S ]: .'9<H: ',E D: '"U_ 7D L(<]
E , jklu A, : .5JK L(<* M08 JD O _ (G ' q A1
$ O S¢D 'f; '" ' q i5" tJ +, " $7 a,E D: OU_ 7D
. "5JK L(<= B & 4(d O rs
()
. ()
U w ] C(* ', '27 $ '] $7K
-3-
aT9 .jkum A, D 4$Z '* O 'Q ' q !5 " t1J 1e
\ t( ] ( 5e: C$ Q jku A, a t] A7 OP #<JD 1<,
'* '; __ #, <"$9 jkum A, ' q Mv2J bO 1 1h$
B"$T w FZ: ~Z $< * jkuk A, : .a 5JK L(<*
B"$T ' q Mv2J bjk§¨ A, : .a T ~ _ x1 F
. © O$5< T ZD MD* '; bT ZD MD= ª
M" O _ ^ M 2J 'JE 'U i««7 b ¡1S P 1:
(© +, M rPG A%J BFf& " ] ¥: . © ¬ 5JK L(1<*
. "@ M08 JD Cd R; & x= 8Td&: d ] $H0
MD* ';U 'E8 G: ,5 5JK L(<* ^® ' q 15&:
'* ¯ G iJ0 ^y D.G E, '_* iJ°(° 0 b 5 $ +,: . U 1w
+, 5JK L(<* ±UF BFf& " / R; (G: D t1 " 1
4( 5 +, ',(\(: 5 M27 ; PG vG: .17( ²
* ! H0 M(d5 +, :^ !"P b" ` [&: .p: a(d
! rS¢ aXF " C(* M(d ( ;; d E0 b8 Ez !, ($³
.'"E @"@ ';(E ] &
p(* A <": .^y E, 5JK L(<* ' q '"( 5 : ´7 1&:
µ] A 7: . ¯("(J g ' 'EQ `" G$"<& ^y x-
. g ] ! c M( b'¶ e (_] b^y
! " #$ % &'( ) *+, -./
$ +,: 8h2J P b5JK L(<= ' @8 M 81
U , z: b¨¨¨ ^E9(J/H !"$2& aT9 .·( d2] 87fJ 5& b 5
l ] 5JK L(<* Cc ^0 5 : C$ ! (E" !1
-4-
'< h5 ! ( ';: 'ThV afX& '"D: 8 M ;: . FZ: FZ
L(<* ' Q iJ0: .',E D: ';5: '"U_ 7D: '9<H: 'J L(<1]
b' 'EQ ) ; *: '"D: H ;] bM"D( M ; / aG 5JK
.' 5 M,N CTV ¯$] '< '"D( aG
'] ª ^y B"$9 jku A, i2J P b' q i; 7:
b$\ i7( : . U w '"$f7 MD* ';U ; <& b<"$9 (
'"$f< M"D( rPG Ed 5|&|: . ^Z 5 4$Z '"$f7 '"D: jl ¯ 1G
( )
L(< ! ';: 'Thf] B & ,(\( afX& ' \( 1¢ M1"D(]
'"D: A 7 9 br$0S BF; E0: .',E D: '9<H: '"U_ 7D: ';5: 'J
b¡S ]: .O$5< T ZD MD= i<&: jk§¨ A, M 1; /1 a1G
b$7 i7: : .';5: 'J L(<] 'fF&$ h5 +, D: ' q M@0
% 7(: .'9<H: ',E D: '"U_ 7D L(< +, AE 1GD R1_J
',E D: '"U_ 7D L(< Cc iJ0 jkkm A, P 15 M1"D(
.'9<H:
RF5]: MD µ] b!d: . *: FZ '"D( 5|&| U1,:
! ' '7$9 }v &: .#, ^Z B"$9 ' q 2 & b$% 7 'v5 '1FV
] Ey 'E7K M,(E ! ',(Ec 0 !, U$9 O bU$9 '15¸
.']$X ]::: '7$2 ]::: bº"d: ' &# d"$: b; : ,<"$9 a1G:
MD= ª B"$T ^y '7$9 ! <"$9 E" b$1\ i17( :
.aT5 ?q *D] ª B"$T: O$5< T ZD
Cc E @0$& F µ] C:* b Z M( 5 4 +1,:
'E B Fz b¡S +, ]: .'E ] 'fF&$ h5 +, 5JK L(<*
¡& ! '* 0 aT9 .\ AE G \( ad£ }d ] 'fF1&$ h15:
-5-
p:U , B"$9 !: < 5 FZ ! }v & F MS '1 1(& MD1
e ME% : F7$: C: EQ '*( T ' '7$9 rPG '"(`,: .a(d*
.'(d
&'( 2 1 0
L(<* Cc ?F M_2 ! G FZ l GU , »F ^y
bh`< :.5 F0 ^y ] !: . a* ¬ (E ": 15JK
(<];: (* `,: ("U_ 7 ^Z: (w: (IU0: b<]5:
(E " G: . T¼( F0 + 7: b'(d* e ME% 1
: .MFZ ZD U(8Q ! "@ CP] b Z M( 5 : .BV 1 1
.MFZ j¨ ¯ G $\ i7(
;< 9 b4$Z '"D: ! } ³ @0$ \( ! e$ +,:
M Z <& +, (_"$* 4( 5 (9 U$9 ½ (G ^y ] ¯$ 12
( ": (J< @0$ T ] ( E " G: .]< :U
t: +, U°° ½ 88 {# Z ! e$ +,: .aE% d£ TJ 1V
b 8 TJ * Re (<Ff" ½9 8 ;U (f ' 1<9: '17
.a" ` ; EF5*
-6-
'd2 +, : M08 J !, $"<& U , +, M"D( rPG @0$& !dE9
$H0 : z_ Z ! "@ +, : ' < ,5 <& '5 +, : b'
.Mz_ ZD rPG !
&'( 8 59 :; 1
. Fy ; ! U À OP (G '"D( 2 a(d p: $<
e$ +,: .' q aH: zy !"$< U ³ OP (G ' q 1h$9
U(" $< 9 b' q R d h$ :2 " v] a`<" O5 {$ !
X ": .T; 'F&$ ! a;(]U U, (G ' q h: .h$ '"8
.' q R d 'H aG: 'E7K M,(E ] : ] h$ R_
^y µ]: A aH ³ OP (G g A :
.5JK L(< a5 ²(T ! 'z(& +, ] b< 5
aXF " b¡P: .'"D( '7 _ 'F5 ] '¶* 'v5 F1y 1 Z:
#" $<& 7: .5JK L(<= '<E, '"U t: 4( 5 9 _ Fy (1d"
' T 8" O U$T '_2: ' 8 MT_ b^y Z , bAE GD
. "@ A ,: '#< ;D: 'GN: '"D( Cc ^y:
( )
-7-
$E 5" !dE ! 0 jkkk A, ¬*: .t "D: ! FZ O h$ +1T,
.'"; '"D( M$E ; V f<J #] t E8 Fy
O '"D( 4(_< (d& ' q M$7 bjkkk "$]/5J :
'F5 ] i7. ] 0 '9\ M( ; Á#- +, $< J: .M( ; i; aG FZ
`" ' q M$7: .i5 M( 5 `<J +, 8 "D: i9$ !"P ^
¡S B< " +," b`" ' '7$9 ^y ' Z : & ¯ G (1d"
. "'< J M( ; Á#- $ 9 4 +, ' M(f®
( )
: b' q H b': '(d M£ $"<& ^y 1 A 1<":
µ] M"D: a` <&: .)z(&: ) ; v2] b g ' '1EQ
:$Z F " E ] '"$% M; $ +, ;; 8E G :@0$" ^1y
.'E a*( +, @0$& G
-8-
((<": bAE G# H h5 ';U: x= (<E " ^y %:
L(<* M08 J " \ ! 4:d ! tJ(< " (1; ": '"$1f7 M"@1]
bMD µ] : ." ` D.G !, '] ] M(d 4 (Z ": b5JK
.ª< : ^] `" ^y az("
()
a;; $_ , (G 5JK L(<* M08 J " \ !, '] ] Z
, Â ¯8 JD +, 'DU Ov9 .5JK L(<* Cc E $1z , !1
'* {:$¼ B< ] A7 U$c : 8E G -: 1 1
.M?:q * \( * µ] 90 J(d" !dI b'
L(< ¯8 J Á: = ' M,U: M( ^y 1% +< 1":
08 J ] S '(d ', M J (8(" bMD µ] : .5JK
: ] 'h (© (8(" ^y µ]: .Á À ¡: +, 5JK L(< E5
O F (<Ff" ¡P] G: .h;$ rP U, ' q (XF" G: .' ; 10 1J
M( U_ '":5 ~$9 '1*& ^1y C:1À: .L15&D: '9T12
'< M08 JD ! 'T (J +, MD µ] O(f &: .' M(d :
.GU(8 B5 & +, ^y °q ° 2|"| bF< PG ! MD* : .^Z , M"D(]
()
: .ª F "? '"$f< '"D( ::S ^y 8,$" / M"(: !
8 b4$Z ] "@] ((<" Ph ,: õ9$] "@ RV Ä]Ä<" * µ]
. '_ O:S ,T $h;: # M#]< $K bª F : F
.' 5 &$ : $ ' F ^y :@" v] 'J@ E15&:
.M"@ ! "@ A< 'J@ !, 'Z MF&$& * µ] `" &:
-9-
Mz_ Z 8E2& / F "? \( ( ^y $<" 17:
d U, 'J@ E5&: .M( ! tJ(< " ; +, b8 "D:
F "? '"$f< M"D( ::S ^y +5": . "$f7 &"? $] FZ
! : 85TJ ^y ! UF "@ RV Åv": . BV 1 1
. U w $7 5JK L(<* ' Q RJ
( )
-10-
!" # (¾)
Cc 8<Ff 'q* MS ": ,(7 \: ^y µ] +15"
ZU !"U$2 ~] ª A g ~y HE E, <9 .81E,
'< 'J(J< ,(< ! ',(Ec : U ,K : J(J< ^y ! B"$9
±UF U ,K ;v0 ,(< rPG ~y HE A 1; È b1ZU "$12 ]
iV* bjkk§ "$]/5J : .ZU !"U$2 ~ '"n v2] '8(&
R* OP MD0( ] '0$ 2 'Eh ' q $<]: ±UF rP E, ' 1q
85c '02 8<Ff& +, ' q `, MD0( q: ±UF1 rP1
Mf5 : C: (H $ 5" E0 ±UF rPG i\|:| 7: .'"P1T
'(d e ME% : '(d ': ME% : U$9: M,(E: 4$1Z
.ZU "$2 ] 'fF&$ h5 'Q ,
'5¸ ! °(° d baT5 ?q *D] ª B"$T \: bH1]:
bjkkk ^E5"U/C: (J0 m 'Z. m 7 t : aT9 .E V b^Z
a5E aT5 ?q *D MD* 'Q " B"$T \: bCH F1; +1,
:.2 '5 '\(T B5 ] ¥ OP bE PG 0: .(q
.'(d e ME% : C: ! U , RJ ! R*$& \( b#
!" (U)
F_": .)z(&: ) ; v2] M(d M(* ^y <"
O _ '?# UK 8" +, M(d A <& , 1T (1
'(d* bCH F; +, b¡S ! .^y 8 , $, / B< t: '1" É
'V$2] D:.5 b F t&"? - bR"P 'v5 ª ~y $<E i °, 0
- ~y $< C:.5 PG B9: ,~y $< B5 9 4( 5 +1,
b¯8 J !, 'sJ \: _ '"(9 ME& z] MF; , A7: t H]
-11-
?q * @q w !, ¾$9K : !"@q ¦ µF ' 'Ff '",$1 H1
.'] M$ ! CT $K P , ~y $< $7: .T5&
.^y Mz(&: M ;D '9d '] +, A% '9 E 1&:
/ Mz( ] 'Eh7 ª" R_ ] ª ~y $< , bCH F1; +19
<& 8 FV M(d '":U 'T_] Mz( rPG À (G: .r$"$<& 8 E`&
b" ] (: bPT & E0 GS¢ A@ & : )P¢ /1 ] 1 1]: )<1&
( 6E`" G: .'- R; (<Ff" :$Z ^Z PZ: .8 2 M1z(
.M(d RJ ! 9 U:U ! (< " G$"<&
$%&'( )* + ( G)
a` <& " , M"D: ¡S .G *: C: +, ^y & $_ <" D
b¨¨¨: jkk a, ] ET9 .'(d* e MJ0 8 5|&| !
M08 JD !, $"<& C(_ 5JK L(<* '= ' '< 5 Fy i 7
M$K `" i: &: . F ¡S M2 U7: $ E,? 8Fd& /
. C(_ '"@0$ '(d* e ¼ MD10: 1)P¢ /1
': M(< v] 'h< M,U# jkk§ A G$"$<& ! F0 @ i__Z:
.C(_ GU(: - M08 J iFd&
. ': M5;. M"D( ! "@ U , C: " b$\ i17( :
b' y (" : ad£ }d : 'E ] 8 B " 'zZ: bM"D( µF9
p: ¡ F M5;. H b' M5;. M;; -v1& '1;U { 1)
'f<J ½ aG M"D( rPG 'E7: .5JK L(<* +, bp: < 1 L: 1z:
.h5 rPG C(* Ç< L#fJ
-12-
%&'( )* #," -. (:)
A% #hG E,U ' V(: 'E7K: ': '(d e ME% A 1<&
@0$ 5JK L(<= 'E 8 '(d e ME% i *: .'1zy M$1K
!, ';; M(: M# A <& aG: . U w M"D: 2J] U _
A(<": . U ¦ \( ! Hd] B " E9: " , ] 5JK L(<* '*
M(d * ! H0 ½(À: M( rPG !1 B< 1] ^1y
'¦ G$h:U (8EQ }"$ ] '(d e ME% A(<&: .18h E 1D
PG @"@ '(d e ME% t <& OP Fd A8;K +%À: .^y 1E]
^ ": . : ^y: M(d RJ ! Lf ;( $" < ] A% 1
E2" D 9$ , ¨¨¨ A, 5JK L(<* !, 9 v12] '1"D: 12J
`" E2" ] R5 9 '(d e ME% RJ ! 8 , e D / '15
}"( : ¾,?Ê (\$ " 5JK L(<* !, 9 ! !"H10 '<1<*
9(& :$`] {$ , tJ E0 b5JK L(<* Cc 81E] 817 RF15]
.£ '"E
. £ 'F5 ] 5JK L(<* ¯8 J] M,UD U(&: ;D] " ` U $"<
E, 0 !: ." ` !, '] ] ^y ! " Z " b' 5 1 +1,:
4@|&| P !E9 bX 85& '9U (7 b* ! H0 b^ " ^1y
}7( & H0 ( ¯ 89 . *: , 5JK L(<* Cc ';(E h 1
-13-
M08 JD rs p: E : ] E : M(d 9 U:U +1,
.)z(&: ^y M ; rs:
D p: E " ` F" z( d2] ' '* ';U e
L(<* (d8 " bPdG: .8% !, F 'z$T 8f": b8 w Gq 1"
89 5JK L(<* q; 9 ' Mf5 &: .'F7$ i ½ 5JK
µ] b¡S OU.": .'J5JK: 'hÂK: ';5 MF ,D +, -v& t (d;
.`9 (© X : '5 5 b*
+, b¡S ! .$dF PJ ']H ^y $"<& (d& b* 1% :
A ,K: `< LfJ ¾Z A ,K MD= ª ~y $< bCH1 F1;
',EQ U]K ME, D J F7 J:$ "@] A7 T5& : @( M$1]
T U p: E F" : .fZ a7$, } , ! Á À E, $"$<& A 7: b89
.A£ $dF PJK PG ? R;
" q ": .^y 8<<À / ';(E h +, " , 'H ¯ G:
(J0 aT9 ." ` {_J +, ,5 b'"$f< M"@1 1- b8 1
5JK L(<* '= ª ~y $< Ë bCH F; +, bjkk $" "/H
A ,K '](<, " F ] Ì RË h$ ! a;h $17 1_ ; 15JX9
., ¨ !q5] '](<, _ jjl (© +, '\:$T
JKL5 2 M ) N OPC &'( Q
Uz U w M$7 ' \( U w A8 #f\D ^y ! R1f|"|
88 (f`" : 8 "D: U: = (@ " 8 7( |": . 1 !1,
+%À C#< ;D PG: . a(d* e : a(d* -v& O !, ] A1& C#< 1;]
o$ (G: .'(d e ME% : M(d: " ` RJ ! »] $" < ]
( )
-14-
A b g A !, '] ] b7 EF5*: .'"D( U [q t ]D
L(<* Cc '"D( z UU$ A C#< ;D D(" ': C 1 '1Edw
5JK L(< ': " M08 J !, ¿#]K (zy :$<: 5JK
. " " :
( )
-15-
U:@": . #f\D -: MHF] #f\D F7 /5(: a,(\( 1,
.)"? $< F v2] t" '* < L:: r$"< ] `" MHF J^
&'T U RS!
Cc g M"D(] (f`" !"P ^ (J< } _
M? '7T& U(_< ] "A8 (Eh7 ^Z" ½ (G 15JK L(1<*
8 "D(] 8,#f\ $ 9 C(V ^y E ": .jkl A MJ_*:
U b( ' !E\ b " ] ' F: 8 T¼(] 'J$ < MJ_: M? D]
:a" E2& aG: .'7T&D ! $T ! ';U5
8 U_ !: _ G?q *: 8T7(& ! 'J1_ (1)"
Ã'_2
MJF] B " E9 'J(J< M$K (J ! 'J_ (3)
V ((<" / C9]: 8 , U_ '"$"$ 1 : '"(T12
Fy M Z 8 J ] ¬* 'J_ rPG $E 5&: .8 E8 8 1"Uv&
à g f\ / 'E8
ÃBh-(: L: EÉ 5 A , (4)
] )D_& ²$e ?($ ( 5" 8<* (.)
: ';(] 'F< * B"$V !, M#;$ : L: A# ; :
Ã'( Rh<*
'E : º < +, U(<] '< M#815 1TJ ( 5)
Ã' 7. '¶ MH] !" 9( 'F M(d aHE '*( E:
'*( E: '_2 8 v] '< M#85 : MJ_ TJ (-)
.";(] -(FE
-16-
O2 ; O (\( )J_*: ' q ^Z M? iJ0 b$Z.:
8" 'Ed¦ M z bjkkk "$]/5J k aT9 .': C 'Edw !, z
`< C#< ; 'v5 ª ~y $< ba(;(0 A1] (1&U '1`7
Rf µ"( q* »] b"@ 82& 4:,U , r \ i9|| OP b¦:
.ad"$ D:U jj¨¨¨ B $` !, t]
'7T& ! $T ! ';U5 U ': C 1 '1Edw M:
a(;(0 5 '`7 +, "BFf 'F:" )J_*:
( )
M?
Cd ! d1 O 1\ 'J1_] 1E t B11À" t1J M1:
$2|J|: t i"$ ']< - t , U_ F] B " E9 "'J(J< M$1K
International " ',(Ff !jkkm $11FE9(J/H !11"$2& U 11, 8_J
RF5 " a(;(0 5"v] 'Ed¦ i`7: ."Commercial Litigation
'zZ 'T_]: b'"@ 0¦ t, 8 \$9 / ' }1d v12] $1\ O
O$ ¿#]] 'Ä@Ä '"@ "'(d 'Ed¦ M: ."'F"$` '\y }d
B&, +, '7( ': M@ D STJK ¡S: '"@ 0 E1 O12 ;D
. "a(;(0 5 E " / 'J_ A$ *D: b"@
( )
-17-
M E , b¡P 'q J: .^y E , \$ ; ' 1q M$1 b¨¨¨
iÏ: .^y E, T0 5 '$ M$< ! U , ¨¨¨ "$]/5J
M"D( z 'F5 ] 8 K B]5 ' @ 8 " E ] 1
.G Z , 5h d2" ^y C#< ; +, 0v $d&:
'27 g ' 'EQ V O$s b¡1S '91\K]:
! bA8 !" 9( ^y +, 8<Ff& A@ |"| ¯(5 ,(<] 'J: :$2
r ] OP a5h$ e2: . 5JK L(<* Cc
( )
^Z 89
(,9 ½ '<<* R; ( +, a,$" D tJ (G 'J: :$2 rs ^1y
(< " p ]: $ (\< " !"2 5 (5: b$1 (1\< " D: (< 15
5 '"D( Mz_ ZD <9: (9$_ " 8 a` <& 8 E8 ¡S .ME&
.5JK L(<* (J7: h7( ; +,: bG$hE\ 8, t> : 8
bjkk A, P : .8E ÅP % ! 7 `" ^1y 1I:
(H F" bM,E D ¡& : .)"D(] 'fF&$ h5 C(* ´7 "( ; (E
²(T M27 `" :$: .8E, Bh$V H b¯$ 2 AE GD MS Ð_
1 MG ;Î: 5JK L(<* ' Q R d: 5JK L(< a5
';; M G R( v2 : b5JK L(<= ' '1" G
M,E D rPG ): .'(d e ME% : b 5JK L(<* Cc i5
( )
&'T 5 @8 9
¿$T ; +, }h¼: (X2" ( 8 1G ^1y $% 1]
&J ',(J 9 bi7( ! @ ; +, )1 Z (1 <":
'5 '\(T ! tJ(< " OP , ',(J +, bF0 * b E 1& 81E,
b$\ i7( : .E P£ (T¼( 8;$d" / $ T +,: 5JK L(1<
-18-
*: '"D(] #f\D +, ,5E *: }¼( M Z <& '\(T f 5&
.¿$T ; +, ' 5 E, (8 '-#- CU& $ T
^0 R] A% E A , '* 'Ñ C: '1Fe ¯ 1&:
M"D: 2J :$\ J* ²$T& 5JK L(<* MD* e .tWEW f 15"
'* U( U"? 8F0(& D / b 5 M"D( U , U"? OU.&: . "
.5JK L(< '5 '\(T B&, +, '9\ F, < b,
- ,5 b';U U , !"FZ ! '\(T iFV bjkkk A1, :
S¢] '; iz:: .8 F& 'T0: ' Ò ^y M * v2] bT¼( !
'9 5: Ã' M '9 U"@ ] & :A% @"@ 1 1] & '15¸
_¢ C#Z ! , U"?: Ã'] Bh$V 5: ñ(f MD ']q ;D
U( U"? ] rPG PT & a` <": . MJF ,7 2J: 9\ T¼(
( )
-19-
'9<H: 'J b5JK L(<* '"n: @"@& E2&: Lf '1;: a15
(& b( PG +,: . © b',E D: ';5: '"U1_ 7D:
": . 'zy M$K M : a5 ²(T '"D: ] Z & U(1: '1Jd
.B5 B"$V !, Z PG OUT&
- :@_ 4S, `![
)v2J '; : x F] 'TÓÓd ^Z ',(Ec !, F, aG ',$T ' q
] ! 0 ba\ : .' ° $G(¼ BE dT C#Z ! G ,5 ' q
$% ": ,(< "2 U , ',$T ' q if\ / '5h$ A8
.": ,(< ¡& ! U , ' 'EQ M E ,: .' q 89
' ; 0 (E G: .#< 5 FZ ! ',$T ' q }v 1&:
p ": .5JK L(<* "`7 v2] C: } f5e/ ]; '1-#-
(d& / b',$T ' q A MJF] '(d 1e ME% 1: C: 1 (H1
\(] Mz(& ' q ',$T ' q 9$&: .(8Eq U, '*( T ),E
. 89 $% Rf & /
( )
-20-
C(V ^y E ' ,: '`T 5 '27 O$s: .Bh< a_< MHF] (1TÔÔd"
! ';U \( (\( 0 (d": .]; '-#- L$X 5& / ',$T ' q :U
Ã',$T ' q ] zy !"$< ! $H0 : *: ~1Z $1< R1J
'; ] }ÓÓd Fy A <" bU : .7 +, M( ; Á#- '; L$X 5&:
.a y $"$< È *$ $"$<& È : $"$<& È E, '7:
: IU0 ! ',$T ' q ^Z Z " b1* R1e :
U 8 7( |" tJ e .)(d* aH ! b* µ] b: `< : ¦
.a(d* e : a(d* -v& O !, 4v ',$T ' q 8E,
'J RJ ! {$ O b< 5 ^Z 8Tz(] b^y 1`³ D:
L(< '5 '\(T £ 8 <& / ,5 ! e$ +,: . 1 1
U( '"U: w $% ]: .'J !, < 5 d2] 8-(= :$ ½9 b5JK
GU( +, ^y E " H0 bt K i<F; EF5* b'1Jg '* 1
.8-(= , '&P
+, bB< " E0 "(* :U ] 5JK L(<* ^Z OU.1"
.MÆ9d : ( '" (\< " D G: .?( : {(y ! $ ba 4( 5
8Tz(] b5JK L(<* STJ F; E !, \$] (2 a1G )v19d:
.5JK L(< a #,K EF5* b"$2F t f " +¶"
.t&Jd B<À ad aTd" Hd] 7 A% '* U( C@& D:
a A$ *D { G B< ! t dE A% @"@& '$ U(8Q CP] $E 5":
: B"$V !, ·( (© +, t 9 U"? !dE !: .5JK L(<* EQ
e f<: MG: M(d 'zZ 'T_]: b,T ¬1 1]
.a(d
-21-
. ()
!"# $ %& ' ( )* +, !-. ' / 01 2 3$ ()
F (==E C 1 D, ) @ ;$ AB :> == 9:;#</ ( )8 7& 3 /&45 ' 3+"
) )I F( ==) ) < F (== ) & JI F ( == ) ) H3@I F (== ) 3-G&
F (== ) 9:NO$ F (== ) ( J # F (== ) $ M:I F (==E ) KL & < F (== )
F(==E) U# F(==E) -$# F(==) K) &# F (==E ) RST# F (== ) 2 PQO$
!RX$ !:&Y. F (==E ) !HT$ !#;"$ !:U> . F( ==E ) ;VW. F (==E ) -T: Q
P)R$ !:&YZ F(==) :&J !:&YZ F(==E) !:&$ !#;"$ !:&Y. F( == )
HN F(==) ) & F (==E ) _HG F ( ==E ) +:;]< ^-G F ( ==E ) ![;+\$
F (==E) B QL F (== ) `$ F (== ) -T:N@ F (==E ) 2 P-$ F ( == )
( U R$ F(==) ;Mc F ( ==E ) C ) b] F ( ==E ) a: W3-3] F (== ) 3);]
F (==) H$J F (==E ) R:& @J F ( ==E ) #J F ( ==E ) -3J F ( ==E )
eR F ( ==) ;+3XL F ( ==E ) :W3$ F (== ) :UH3$ F (== ) 3dQB
-$;:5 fg"$ ) M:O$ !RT F ( ==E ) !: "$ !#;"$ !3RT F ( == )
:US) F( ==) ;S-$ F ( == ) h: ;-$ F ( == ) 7X:& F ( ==E ) !$ 3X$
.(== ) ( # $ F(== ) !R:; j :B$ F( ==E ) -i F (== )
!-. &;+ (opm) (n 8 ) mn 1 GB K `cB kTl &;c (E)
.opm ;: -:/ r $ () J ' +" q %& ' & `$ ( )* +,
. ;+d$ Fopm F E/259 !+s$ F( E ) &;+$ (p)
K `cB kTl 1 F( )* +, !-. t3TM$ !# S3@ (n)
1 uXRQ v$ jB !@&# (4< Kw$ om C "$ ( p8 ) E &;+$ 1 GB
( p8 ) n=E |&;c tG} FkTl z{ .( )* +, j J Y) ; x3y
; xy 1 uXRQ v$ ~ RX$ !: ;# T"Q j/;GI Fom= C 1 ' 3"
. ( )* + !. j J Y)B
!:B$ j<#) !T !-MTd$ {& :> !:;M+$ j :B$ |w3> ()
K) &# F ( op) (!a@* 8 ! :&YZ ) (;:I F ( op ) ( ) P]< F(ooE C 31 '
F ( ooE) ( $ F (oom ) ) & F ( oop ) ![;+\$ P)R$ !3:&YZ F ( oon )
& y F(ooE) : HJ F(ooE) !V@B -L F( oo ) ;"$ F( ooE ) 2 `$
.(oo ) !+# $ ]a@L: F(oon ) v: > F ( oo )
-22-
( z# Q )
:> $ , aM{B K& . !-" z{} !+T"3 j 3:B$ (m)
d"Q < WG j/;G# < / 0+$ & C1* jB , (o= ) K;+$ / dB
2 d[ z# ( om) !cWQ; ( o ) :$ t`"$ (on ) t3:w"$ (o )
( ;X (oo) d"$ N S,B ( oo= ) !"T ' / PH$ ' iaP3@
UH"$ K<;$ !:;, (ooE) t) G |;J !:;`-"T$ ; " 2 R (oo ) T
0+$ 2a+@ (ooE ) !T j 31$ ' 2 3d[ ;3I (ooE )
(oo ) zc ;+ d$(oon) !$ j : d-$ (oop ) <; { u-3"$ (oop )
' (ooo ) :;G Y +, ( oo ) T"$ ' ( oo ) !-$ ' 3
( )* +, 1 (3"] (=== ) /w3P$ ' 3 ( === ) 3Va$ R3$
' :B$ # z. ) !3G& (3:$ T3Ri u3R$ j 3@ @ ( === )
.(=== C 1
# 9 "$ :;d$ ;:;+Q m ;+d$ F2 9H3@ fT31 F;3g)< ()
.(E/CN.4/2000/112) ( )* +, j $5 !$ "] W:W"# " j& $
01 F!) $ !-$ ' :01 Fq !-$ ' :01 2H@ : (o)
F E/CN.4/2000/112 ) !$ +)B ;d$ / -s< !33:&;@B : F!$ $ !-3$ '
.(= ;+d$
!T "$ !c;] / @& /O / T / :&;+ 9$ (= )
!+s$) !:& X@B j h );# ( )* +, !-. ' ! j/;G* C g) (X#
.(ooo O: / 2 () J ' !& E/CN.4/2000/5
;:& +Q z{} (-" /O Cc F{ -$ ~ fT1 ( )
[ - zZ ' FT: ] > < ;Q F!$ EE 1 9+: B qI % "# 1 !-3ST$ qI
F-L < F ) )I F ) < F ) H$< F( ) P]< : % :B# !T j4 ! : 0c (X# F "$
F!RX$ !:&Y. F!c;X$ &Q Fk)Q F J;Q F U# F RST# F( 3J # F-3$;:5
F( $ F R)B K;@ F ) & F +:;]< ^-G F!+# $ !]a@L$ ) + !3:&YZ
F :W$ F -J F H$J F #J F( U R$ FC ) b] FS] Fa: ] FB QL FT3
F-$> F :& P-> Fv: > F!$ X$ -$;:5 fg"$ ) M:O$ !3RT Fe3R
. , UH ;J< %& :W# C c (TH$ |w> "# . $
-23-
( z# Q )
C1* jB " &;+ (< F2 9H@ fT1 Fe3$4 3 ( )
/ -$ 9c !$ !$ $ -G fT1 & < c d"Q < WG j/;G# < / 0+$ &
$ ! "$ !". j1 F === O]) /r $ :;XQ ' .;X$ 1 ]$ @ #
{ !T:[ +"$ F^ +1 ( Ft3RQ;Q bT v$ !\;. |w> !) # i &;c 2 <
!d j;X) F=== O]) /r $ :;XQ n ' . "$ / < :"$ ' / -$ B5
"(H:;Q $U> 2 ) );)" !d j 1< { 2, !, ] !$ + " W\ Q &:) "
"$ ;5 < ( R ' !-@ 9J / -$ B5 2 PQ": Y] / G v$ F!$ + |w3> ;3X)
e$4 ' } F!TV "$ ; k ¡< fT1 Y$I ;g-: 2 "]< fT1 # +1 %I < YV #5 K:#
!{ c$ < t:;L ¢£ z -T1 &Yg$ < F W$ # :$$ ;< ( `1 < F )W$
2H+# BI ¤A B ¡< ( +": £ :"$ 2W: B !\;G > 8 ^ `LB
;:& +Q Y-1 YT T# 1 $ ! !++ bPT#< FC "$ w> . !0$
# & < @5 ^-G x@ ;X$ ' ;X$ 1 ]$ @ # jB L c# 3dQ
." +:;]< !-Qa$ R:;<
# 9 "$ :;d$ ;:;+Q = ;+d$ F2 9H@ fT31 F;3g)< ( E )
.(E/CN.4/2000/112) ( )* +, !-. j $5 !$ "] W:W"# " j& $
nn ;+d$ (p )
%& '() *+ ,-. (X# K& X@B K<;$ ' ! " # $
./0 1 2 34 # 5'4 67% 8+ !9. #:
!9. #: %& '() *+ ,-. (X# K& X@B K<;$ (n )
o ' & `$ </0 1 2 34 # 5'4 67 % 8+
.ooo 9:;#< / ( )
!-. j $5 !$ "] :W# " j& $ # 9 "$ :;d$ ;:;+Q ;g)< ( )
.(E/CN.4/2000/112) ( )* +,
!) d a¥ $ WJ; g-$ ¦;+ @ @ C g-$ ( m )
.(A/54/695) !@ @ % HG Yc+, !Y} V +$ /O ! "$
-24-
( z# Q )
!) + # § $ Y"$ :> !$ $ j> 3" |w3> ( )
!c dQB F!] +$ !1 GB !: `cB + # § $ 3Y"$ F!3@ $
zZ fT1 / 0+T$ !$ $ !c dQB FK;`-"$ W$ 2 R< zZ fT1 / 30+T$ !3$ $
!#+"$ < !T " ^ ;{ |UL t:w"$ !0> - !c dQ F <; { W$ 2 R3<
. 9dM$ +, !c dQ F!-Y < !) )Ia$ < !@ +$
"Capacity building to strengthen the special : ;3
3g) ( o )
procedures system of the United Nations human rights programme",
Thomas Hammersberg and Mona Rishmawi, 30 June 1999
-$ !"@ !dV [ !1;d$ !-ST$ K;3¨ ;3{ b3c$ ' (= )
UL +, :!$ $ z{ # (-" ( ( &;+ C+: j @& > . j @&$
( )* + 9 R$ z$ fT1 >UsQ ! "$ © ª* 9"$ !@& CYd -[
Yca1 !T ^"X$ !TdM$ <; ! ' ;sQ v$ !:T+$ j @& fT1 / 0+$
(X# 91 j c& 1# e$wJ !1;d$ !-ST$ C+Q ( )* +, ^ >&* «& #
R`$ D YT1 ¢-Q v$ U#$ F1 GB 9 < 9"$ 7 @< fT1 V +$ W$
t$ @< fT1 !HQ; & s¬ F >[Q ![;+\$ W:W"Q 2 ' ( )* + !3$ $
T": ] !-[$ O1 j J;X$ 2 $ !$ F YMX)< !-[$ O1 j J;X$ 91
+, U: " wd-# j J;X$ C c !dR# ! j/;G* F( )* +, zZ Y) #
F!V -@B !V 0+$ j `B !:;R"$ J 2a 2"$ !3 cI F( 3)*
/ 0+$ C g) ' W$ F!$ "] `) 9H@ U]# j W$B wd-$ !T"$ !T U#$
C 1 ' !-ST$ qI !1;d$ !-ST$ bHT[ Fe$4 qI !] {* # .(S$ !`£` FV -3.
# !ca"$ ;SP$ !: ® ( )* +, 9J X : > Fj @& z#&< fT1 !+] ===
^;X$ | ' 2 1I W:W"Q # !] +$ !1 GB !: `cB + # z3 $
.( )* +, j> " fT1 j gd$ ¯Q $ ( )* +,
-25-
:
( )
( )
!"#$% &#'
( )
(!)* +,- &
./* 0 1 !/* +,- 23 *4 51* 67
( ) 8 9 :; < . =>?% &%
5@$7 A' &=B
( ) C 41
D 4AE -
5>9
0B &=BF7 < 8>* G &%
./* 0 1 H4 =I J
K 2
A* L-M<
O * P4 : $
( ) , 3 1B% !Q/R% J
(!)* IS J
& 4RE
!T 0!0* U &$V
WBC
-26-
($ Y-$ X
P4 R>% :< Z 0 1
L>UE = +A [V \ "I ! 4 &$"1
Y!B] L1*
. =C? &%
8>* ^P %7 _* 5* X!>
+ ab DA' Y!" c7 ] U "-! d%V$ *`$
-27-
e@R f+A
89&+:9 . !" #$%&' ( )*+, - .+/0 123 4!56
%;< 9< =>2 "? @AB C 123 4!56 DE )+F G!HI
.JK
!NO )G ! e@R f+A ML9
- PQR: 0 $ Q+9 %""- 123 4!56 STU 6 @G V"9<
8HGU @G )GH 6+, %9 %W?9 #N+ X9 Q: D'< )*+,
.6 9 [Q \]< D ( ^_!:9 %2I e@R f+A .4!5Y Z:
`G a>? %b )*+, - cd ef gK< cd hU !5& Ji?
123 4!5Y )*+, - =Ki? J3 N' `%9 #c !+j e%d:
.L k PRJ!? P%U )T, 9G9 Z?
-28-