Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E
1
Contents
Lean robotics overview 2
Introduction 4
2
Robotiq’s library of eBooks covers each phase of robotic cell deployment, giving you access to advice
from robotics experts each step of the way.
Learn more about lean robotics at l eanrobotics.org.
3
This eBook covers preparation for lean robotics
This eBook is about preparing for your robotic integration. Preparation comes before the three phases of
lean robotics—design, integrate, and operate—and should be completed b efore starting the Design
phase.
This preparation consists of defining the scope of your project, getting your team on board, and
presenting the project to management and the workforce.
In a way, you’ve been preparing ever since you first had the idea of using collaborative robots. By the
end of your preparation, you’ll have an idea of what to automate, the support of your company, and an
enthusiastic team who will lead the robotic cell deployment.
4
Introduction
At businesses everywhere, people are asking:
However, even though it’s generally accepted that robots are part of the manufacturing industry’s
future—and the benefits of automation are widely recognized—smaller companies with limited
resources can find it hard to know where to begin.
When you approach cobot cell deployment the right way, you can start production very quickly. As a
result, the return on investment (ROI) comes much sooner than with other automation methods.
However, you need to be smart about how you plan and implement the deployment. That’s why we
developed the lean robotics framework to help you get your robots off the ground as soon as possible.
5
Each step builds on the last, so we suggest completing them in order. Let’s go!
6
Although cobots are a relatively new technology, this doesn’t mean they’re hard to use. In fact, cobots
are designed to be easier to operate than traditional industrial robots.
Until fairly recently, if you wanted to automate a process with robots, the only option was industrial
robots. These are what most people think of when they imagine robots: big, heavy, dangerous, and
expensive.
Industrial robots evolved to satisfy the needs of high-volume production, like that found in the
automotive, aerospace, and consumer goods industries. Cobots, by contrast, were created for the sort
of high-mix manufacturing found in most small-to-medium sized enterprises (SMEs).
Industrial robots and cobots have many similarities. However, cobots have some unique benefits that
make them a great fit for many businesses—not just SMEs. Just consider the table below.
ⓘ Note
Cobots allow you to perform the same tasks as industrial robots, but with a smaller
investment and much greater flexibility in terms of setup and footprint.
7
Follow a path/trajectory ✓ ✓
Are expensive ✓
Cobot applications
Cobots can be used for a huge variety of tasks. We’re constantly amazed by the new applications
companies come up with (like the ones featured in our ever-growing case study library).
8
However, a few applications crop up time and again (and we’ll cover them in detail later in this eBook).
The top five most common cobot applications are:
2. Pick-and-place. The robot moves a part from the output of one process to the input of
another. For example, it could grab parts from a bin and arrange them in order on a tray.
3. Assembly. The robot performs simple part-assembly tasks that require low dexterity. (On
the other hand, assembly tasks that require high dexterity are a perfect fit for human-robot
collaboration: the robot can perform the simplest assembly tasks, then move parts into an
area where the human operator can finish the assembly process.)
You’ll notice most of these applications involve non-value-added tasks (i.e., tasks that do not add
something to a product that the customer would be willing to pay for). That’s because non-value-added
tasks are easy for cobots to perform, and they liberate humans from tedious, repetitive work.
By this point, you might be feeling eager to buy your robot and get started with one of these
applications. But first, you must get a clear idea of which applications and processes within your
company are the best candidates for automation—which brings us to the next section.
9
Before you move forward in your robotic cell deployment, you should decide which manual (i.e.,
human-operated) process you want to automate first.
⚠ Important
Before you read on, write a list of all the manual processes to which you'd like to add a robot.
Don't worry about the feasibility of these applications yet. Just get all your ideas out of your
head.
Maybe you have only one application in mind, in which case just write the one. However, if
you can come up with some more ideas, that’s even better.
This list will give you a good starting point. It indicates the processes you think are inefficient
and that have room for improvement.
10
Task feasibility
Look again at your list of potential tasks to automate and try to identify the applications that would be
easiest for you and your team to automate.
ⓘ Note
Although a particular task might seem like a good candidate for automation (perhaps because
it’s boring and repetitive), it might not be the best fit for cobots.
That’s because cobots and humans have very different “skill sets”: what’s easy for a human is
not always easy for a cobot.
For your first cobot application, it's best to start small and keep it simple. You can build up to more
complex applications after you’ve gained more experience with cobots.
1. Highly predictable. The task is the same every time, with few deviations.
2. Repeatable. The task will be performed over and over again.
Many tasks have one of these properties but not the other. For example, making a pizza is highly
repeatable—your local pizza shop makes many pizzas every day—but it’s not very predictable, because
the dough, sauce, and toppings vary between pizzas.
On the other hand, building a toy house out of Lego bricks for your child is highly predictable—the
bricks are all the same size and shape, and the task has a defined sequence—but it’s not repeatable
because you only need to build one toy house. (That is, unless you're planning to become the
neighborhood’s designated Lego assembler.)
Make sure you choose a task that is both highly predictable and repeatable.
Task predictability
Tasks are highly predictable when the objects to be manipulated are always the same and they always
arrive at the same location.
11
● Ordered objects. A series of objects that is always handled in the same order. Your cobot
can repeat this order again and again.
● Similar objects. Objects with the same or very similar dimensions, weight range, physical
form, etc. This allows for quick changeovers between products without the need to change
tools.
● Regular objects. Objects with little variation from one to another. (By contrast, potatoes
are an example of objects that are all similar but not regular.) Your cobot can handle some
irregularity with the right choice of gripper, but regular objects are much easier to work
with.
● Regular part presentation. Objects are arranged in a deliberate, consistent order. Matrices
and trays are often used for part presentation: processes involving fixed matrices are the
easiest to automate, whereas with trays you can program your cobot to remove the empty
tray and bring a new tray to the same spot for parts to be picked again.
Task repeatability
Tasks are repeatable when the steps of the task are the same every time and are repeated over and
over again.
● Consistent operation. T he task does not vary between objects in a batch and does not
vary (much) between different batches.
● Long-term operation. The operation will be performed many times. (You wouldn't go to
the trouble of automating a unique, one-time-only operation.)
● High-demand operation. The best cobot applications tackle high-demand operations (i.e.,
those which are needed constantly). You can use robots for low-demand operations, but
they’re not usually the best option.
ⓘ Tip
A picture (or video) is worth a thousand trips to the shop floor.
We highly recommend taking pictures and videos of the cell you want to automate. This will
help you define each step of the application.
Plus, you’ll be able to examine the application from your desk—instead of waiting for
someone to perform it every time you need to take a closer look at something.
12
1. Machine tending
By far the most popular application is machine tending. It's also one of the easiest, because it involves
minimal programming, no extra sensors, and (if you don't overcomplicate it) no need to communicate
with other equipment.
If this all sounds good to you, check out our Machine Tending Guide.
Also see our L owercase case study for a real-life example of a machine-tending application.
Pick and place can be even easier to implement than machine tending, if the objects are well-ordered
and of similar shapes and sizes, and no extra sensors are needed.
See our B
eyerdynamic case study for a real-life example of a pick-and-place application.
ⓘ Tip
Universal Robots (UR) offers wizards to help you automate these simple picking applications.
UR's wizards are embedded in the robot controller and can be engaged very quickly.
13
3. Dispensing
Dispensing tasks, such as gluing, are a great first task for robots. You simply move the robot's end
effector around the desired path and it repeats the task the same way every time.
Force sensors are also useful for this task because finishing requires the robot to follow complex paths.
See our Saint-Gobain case study for a real-life example of how the team used force sensor path
recording for a finishing application.
Traditionally, force assembly actions have been difficult to program. However, Robotiq Skills allow you
to add these capabilities without the need for complex programming.
See our S
piral Search Skill for a real-life example of what is possible with Robotiq Skills.
Traditionally, it was challenging to add vision to robots. However, the Robotiq Vision Sensor—with its
intuitive t emplate learning tool—has made it a lot easier.
14
See our A
ssa Abloy case study for a real-life example of a vision-guided pick-and-place application.
We recommend avoiding applications that include them because they’ll require you to spend more
time, energy, and money deploying your robot. Although these factors may seem simple at first, they
quickly turn into headaches. The best strategy is to start small and work your way up to more complex
projects over time.
15
Robots, on the other hand, need much more predictability. For instance, you could probably program a
pick-and-place application for apples and oranges (which are of similar shape and size). But, there’d be
trouble if you spontaneously passed your robot a banana.
16
3. Conveyors
Conveyor belts are common in factory automation—which leads people to assume they’re the best way
to present objects to cobots.
In reality, conveyors present a big integration challenge. You often have to add a vision system or part
detection sensors in order to detect the moving objects, and you need advanced programming to get
the robot to move to the right position and grasp the moving objects.
Our case study of WALT Machine, Inc. is a perfect example. The company’s president, Tommy Caughey,
was initially considering a conveyor solution. However, he found that the Robotiq Camera was a much
simpler solution. With it, he was able to increase daily production by 100%.
4. Complex sensing
If you find yourself asking "Is it possible to detect this with a sensor?", the answer is probably "Yes… but
it's not the best idea." Some sensors are easy to integrate with cobots, but more advanced sensors are a
challenge.
For example, with the new fixed laser-light camera systems—which build 3D models of objects and the
robot’s environment—it’s possible to both detect an object in 3D and calculate the best grasping
configuration.
However, this task is complicated enough to form the basis of an entire research study. In real-world
situations, it's better to use simpler sensors, or (if possible) none at all.
17
For example, you could get the robot to physically push the start button on the CNC machine. This takes
minutes to program rather than hours. If digital communication is vital, it's easier to attach a wire to the
digital inputs and outputs of each machine than to use communication protocols.
6. Logic
Humans are natural problem-solvers. If we see an object turned upside-down in the part presentation
tray then we’ll flip it over. If we’re handed a baseball bat then we grasp it one way; if we’re handed a
kitten then we grasp it another way. This type of logic comes easily to us.
For robots, every decision to be made adds a layer of programming complexity. You can spot logical
decisions by looking out for phrases with "If… then." Try to eliminate these wherever possible.
18
19
In summary:
● Cobots are great at pick and place, material handling, and material dispensing.
● Applications that require extra sensing—e.g. finishing, assembly, and vision-guided pick and
place—are not ideal for a first robot project. (Although with Robotiq sensors, these
applications aren’t as challenging as they used to be.)
● Other poor choices are those that require complex sensing, unstructured and divergent
objects, moving objects, force control, logic, and integration with other machines.
In our experience, people get the most out of cobots by starting simple and gradually building up their
expertise over time.
20
There are a lot of misperceptions about robots. Some people believe that as soon as a robot enters a
plant, the ”robot takeover” isn't far behind. People start to fear for their jobs.
ⓘ Note
The goal of cobots is not to eliminate jobs by replacing human labor. The goal is to
eliminate monotonous and repetitive tasks so humans can focus on more value-added
tasks. This boosts productivity, prosperity, and worker morale.
But how do you convince your workforce to embrace cobots, not fear them?
The best way is to start with a small team of "mobilizers"—key people who will champion the effort to
bring cobots to the business.
1. Robotics
2. Project management
3. Your manufacturing process
21
22
Clearly, it's important to get the right people on your team! Download the Team Roles and
Responsibilities spreadsheet for an outline of each role’s objectives, key responsibilities, and metrics.
Addressing these concerns now will make it easier for your team to convince the rest of the workforce
later.
To get the conversation started, here are what we see as the top three benefits of cobots:
At every plant where we’ve seen cobots introduced, management did not cut jobs. Instead, workers
were transferred to other processes that require more dexterity and human intelligence.
We've even seen cobots lead to more jobs being created. Cobots create a shift in labor on your
production floor, allowing you to move workers to more value-added tasks—which increases your
production. As a result, you will likely need to hire more people down the line to handle the increase.
We’ve also seen businesses use cobots to “onshore” manufacturing operations (i.e., move them back to
the country of origin). One example is Lowercase, which moved eyewear production from China back to
the US. This trend contributes to even greater job security.
Your team will appreciate it if you guarantee them that staff numbers will not be reduced when you
introduce collaborative robots.
23
Tending a CNC machine, for example, is neither fun nor stimulating. Such tasks can ruin an otherwise
great day at work. By contrast, setups, quality inspections, and robot programming are much more
stimulating tasks for your employees.
Nobody likes to do dull tasks. However, every business has some boring but necessary jobs which
someone has to do. Every time you get a collaborative robot to perform a boring task, it means you can
move an employee to a more interesting task that uses their skills more effectively.
Stimulating tasks result in a workforce that is happier and more motivated. Your team will appreciate
the benefits of cobots when you highlight how their jobs will become more interesting.
In most cases, any fear of robots that existed before the first application is quickly forgotten after the
first robot is installed. People quickly realize how much the robot can help them in their work.
Sometimes they even give the robots nicknames! For example, at Scott Fetzer Electrical in the USA,
workers dubbed a pair of collaborating robots ”Thelma and Louise.”
● Why. Why cobots and why now? Make sure you’re 100% clear on why cobots are a good
idea. After this is decided, the “how” becomes much easier.
● Scope. Clarify which manual cell you’re going to automate. Define the start and end points
of the robotic process.
24
● Schedule. Decide on a realistic time frame for the project and set a date by which the
cobot cell should be up and running.
● Roles. Make sure everyone’s clear about his or her roles and responsibilities. Take the
opportunity to double check that all ten roles have been filled.
Once your team has agreed on roles and responsibilities, and been made aware of the benefits of
cobots, you’re ready to move forward with the project.
25
But before you announce your cobot project, it’s important to present a solid case for cobots.
You and your team are already convinced of the benefits. This step simply involves clarifying those
benefits in a way that management and the workforce will understand.
They let you go from this: "We want to introduce a machine tending cobot because it will boost
productivity”…
To this: "We want to introduce a machine tending cobot to the milling CNC machine. This will increase
the machine's throughput by 20% over four months and improve quality consistency, with a payback
period of one year."
Here are five metrics to choose from, along with questions you and your team should answer:
1. Quality
People assume the main benefit of robots is speed (performing tasks faster). That’s a misunderstanding.
The main benefit of robots—and cobots—is that they perform tasks the same way every time, leading to
better quality and consistency of output.
26
Consider:
2. Throughput
Cobots have the potential to increase a cell’s throughput. Sometimes this is because the robot works
faster than a human could, but it’s more often because it can work 24/7 without breaks.
Consider:
3. ROI potential
Cobots usually have a quick payback period compared to traditional industrial robots. For example, 3D
printing company Voodoo Manufacturing earned a ROI in just six months (see the c ase study for details).
Consider:
4. Time
Cobots can increase your employees’ productive time. By moving a worker to a greater value-added
task, you increase that worker's productivity. Plus, cobots reduce downtime because they work without
slowing down or taking breaks.
Consider:
● How often, and for how long, does downtime occur now?
● Which value-added tasks elsewhere in the process are currently understaffed?
5. Value
In business, value refers to anything the customer is willing to pay for. That doesn’t mean all
non-value-added operations are unnecessary. Some, like packaging, must be done. By assigning these
tasks to cobots, you and your employees are free to focus on operations that create value.
27
In the lean robotics methodology, we also consider value at another level: within the robotic cell itself.
Here, the customer is defined as the next cell in the process, so value-added operations are anything
that create value for the next cell.
Consider:
● How would the cobot affect the value created for the end customer?
● How would the cobot affect the value created for the next cell along in the process?
Some of these metrics are straightforward to quantify (like ROI and throughput). Others are more
qualitative, and may require some lateral thinking (like quality and value).
The key is to describe the specific benefits (backed up by your metrics) using "management language."
This doesn't mean business buzzwords, sales slang, or junior-executive jargon: it means finding out
what’s most important to management and framing the benefits of cobots in terms they’ll appreciate.
Download our workbook, How to Convince Your Boss to Go With Cobots, for help completing this
process.
28
Robots aren’t just another piece of equipment. Employees won’t care when there’s a new printer at
work, for instance, but they often have doubts and fears about robots. Most people have never heard of
collaborative robots. They aren’t aware of the difference between cobots and full automation.
When people aren’t told what’s going on, they tend to assume the worst. Rumors move fast. Once
misconceptions spread, they’re hard to get rid of. It’s much easier to simply provide the right
information in the first place.
While it’s important to explain the value of cobots, you also need to listen to people’s opinions and
address their concerns.
One of the best ways to do so is to hold a "kick-off session" to announce the project.
Before it happens, gather your team of mobilizers and prepare the following:
● A list of questions workers are likely to ask, along with answers that genuinely address the
concerns behind these questions.
● Videos and images of collaborative robots working in similar facilities to yours, so people
see how well they work alongside humans. Check out our case study library for examples!
● Documents with more information about the project, which should be made available to
members of the workforce.
Make sure to leave lots of time for questions at the end of the kick-off session.
It’s also a good idea to arrange one-on-one meetings with team members to address any lingering
concerns or questions.
29
The design phase is the first major phase of the l ean robotics framework.
In the design phase, you will build on this work. You and your team will:
To learn about the Design phase, download the Lean Robotics book and jump to the section "Phase 1:
Design."
Use our online Blueprints tool to describe the manual task you want to automate, and one of our
coaches will get in touch for a free consultation.
30
Now what?
You’ve got your copy of Lean Robotics, so you know how to start the Design phase.
You’ve created a Blueprints account, scheduled a free coaching session, and can’t wait to learn more!
But you’ve begun to wonder: isn’t something missing… like the actual robot?!
Yep, it’s time to go shopping for your first cobot. Go on to the next eBook in our Getting Started with
Collaborative Robots series—Shopping for a Collaborative Robot—and learn how to find the perfect
cobot for your project.
31
About Robotiq
Robotiq’s lean robotics methodology and products enable manufacturers to deploy productive robotic
cells across their factory.
Manufacturers leverage the lean robotics methodology for faster time to production and increased
productivity from their robots. Production engineers standardize on Robotiq’s Plug + Play Components
for their ease of programming, built-in integration, and adaptability to many processes. They rely on
Flow’s software suite to accelerate robot projects and optimize robot performance once in production.
Robotiq is the humans behind the robots: an employee-owned business with a passionate team and an
international partner network.
32
Workfloor: Robotiq’s
Twitter
Blog
Linkedin Facebook
Youtube Google+
Robotiq’s community where industrial a utomation Pros
share their k
now-how and get answers
robotiq.com | leanrobotics.org