Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal 2 Pneumomediastinum With COVID-19 A Natural Process
Jurnal 2 Pneumomediastinum With COVID-19 A Natural Process
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2349-2902.isj20204712
Review Article
*Correspondence:
Dr. Elmutaz Kanani,
E-mail: mutazkanani313@hotmail.com
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
COVID-19 pneumonia is a serious respiratory viral infection that recently spread all over the world. It carries a
significant mortality risk. Little is known about the pathophysiology of the disease, being a newly mutated virus.
Knowledge of the clinical disease manifestations kept evolving as unfamiliar findings and presentations are constantly
reported. Pneumomediastinum had been frequently reported since the start of the pandemic, and its significance was
questioned. The aim of this review is to analyze the reported cases of pneumomediastinum with coronavirus infection
to look for its pathophysiology, prognostic value, and best treatment. A systematic literature search was conducted using
free text search for pneumomediastinum with COVID-19 case reports and case series. PubMed and Google scholar data
bases were searched. Twenty three articles were retrieved. All are case reports and case series, 39 cases of the reported
cohort qualified for inclusion into analysis. Chronic respiratory conditions were found in 23% of the patients. There
was about four folds risk of developing the condition with oxygen therapy (both through invasive and non-invasive
means). The best diagnostic modality was chest computed tomography scan (74.4%). Management was conservative
in 69%, while pleural drainage was necessary in 23% of the patients. Both treatment strategies were successful with no
statistical difference (p value=0.327). It is not yet clear if pneumomediastinum is a pathological disease process or an
interventional complication. Interventional and conservative treatment had similar outcomes depending on individual
case merits. No prognostic value could be demonstrated.
INTRODUCTION the COVID-19 pandemic. The world had shared the same
interests and fears. Comparable preventive measures were
Coronavirus disease (COVID 19) is a serious life- rehearsed in all edges of the world. This can't be professed
threatening disease with global spread. As per the World to be the case in the medical and scientific community.
Health Organization (WHO); more than 18 million cases There is as yet an ongoing debate about the best treatment
had been reported by the first week of August 2020. strategy. There is no consensus to date about the range of
Fatalities were reported to exceed seven hundred thousand the disease manifestations and newly recognized
for the same period. symptoms are being reported every now and then.
Healthcare systems were overwhelmed by the influx of Pneumomediastinum is one of these emerging findings. It
huge numbers of patients requiring medical care with high is not a common condition, and it is said to be present when
demand for critical care and mechanical ventilation. The free air is present within the mediastinum. This can be
disease had negatively impacted the economies and public caused by numerous intra and extra-thoracic pathologies
activity. Nothing had united the whole world recently like that lead to air leak into the mediastinum.1
Although the pneumomediastinum was first described by Microsoft Office Excel (2007) was used for the statistical
Laenek in 1827, the explanation of its pathophysiology analysis. P value <0.05 was considered significant.
was provided later in 1944 by Macklin and Macklin.2 They
concluded that alveolar rupture results from increased RESULTS
intra-alveolar pressure. The resultant leaked air migrates
through the peribronchial and perivascular sheaths into the A total of twenty three articles were deemed relative to the
mediastinum.2 The leaked air may dissect through the topic of interest and subjected to analysis. All are case
loose areolar tissue into the neck and subcutaneous space, reports and case series. Inclusion criteria were met by 39
and into the peritoneal cavity resulting in subcutaneous cases, and they were subjected to the analysis. Table 1
emphysema and pneumoperitoneum, respectively. It may summarizes all the reported coronavirus infections with
also result in pneumothorax.2 pneumomediastinum cases.
Time of
PTX/PM Air
Mode
diagnosi Diagnost -
Patie Age Co- of O2 Manag- Outc-
Sex Co-morbidities s related -ic way
-nt (years) ugh therap ement ome
to modality inju
-y
intuba- -ry
tion
Hypertension,
hypercholesterolemia, Non- Chest CT
Not
13 84 F heart failure, prosthetic Yes invasiv (PM, - N/A Died
intubated
valve replacement, renal -e PTX)
failure
Non- CXR
Not
23 67 M Nil No invasiv (PM, - ICD Died
intubated
-e PTX)
Basal cell epithelioma, Non-
Not Chest CT Conser-
33 73 M obstructive sleep apnoea, No invasiv - Died
intubated (PM) vative
obesity, depression -e
Non-
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
44 38 M Nil Yes invasiv -
intubated (PM, SE) vative -ved
-e
Chest CT
Non-
5 Not (PM, Conser- Resol
5 62 M Nil Yes invasiv -
intubated PTX, vative -ved
-e
SE)
Continued.
Time of
PTX/PM Air
Mode
diagnosi Diagnost -
Patie Age Co- of O2 Manag- Outc-
Sex Co-morbidities s related -ic way
-nt (years) ugh therap ement ome
to modality inju
-y
intuba- -ry
tion
Coronary artery bypass,
chronic pulmonary
CXR
diseases including After
6 Invasiv (PM,
6 67 M obsolete pulmonary No Intuba- No ICD Died
-e PTX,
tuberculosis, chronic tion
SE)
bronchitis, and
emphysema
Non-
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
77 49 M Hypertension, NIDDM Yes invasiv No
intubated (PM, SE) vative -ved
-e
After
Invasiv Chest CT
88 57 M Nil Yes intuba- No N/A N/A
-e (PM, SE)
tion
Non-
Lung disease: Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
99 - - No invasiv -
emphysema, smoker intubated (PM, SE) vative -ved
-e
Non- Before
Chest CT Conser- Persis
109 - - - Yes invasiv intuba- -
(PM, SE) vative -ted
-e tion
Non- Before
Chest CT Conser- Resol
119 - - Asthma Yes invasiv intuba- No
(PM, SE) vative -ved
-e tion
Non- Chest CT
Not Resol
129 - - Nil Yes invasiv (PM, - ICD
intubated -ved
e PTX)
Non-
Not Chest CT Conser- Persis
139 - - Asthma Yes invasiv -
intubated (PM, SE) vative -ted
-e
During Chest CT
Invasiv Surgi-cal
1410 59 F Morbid obesity No intuba- (SE, PM, Yes N/A
-e repair
tion PTX)
After Chest CT
Invasiv Conser-
1510 67 M Morbid obesity No intuba- (PM, Yes N/A
-e vative
tion PTX)
Non- Before
CXR Conser- Resol
1611 36 M IDDM Yes invasiv intuba- No
(PM, SE) vative ved
-e tion
After
Invasiv CXR Conser- Resol
1711 47 M Drug and alcohol abuse No intuba- No
-e (PM, SE) vative ved
tion
After
Hypertension, Invasiv CXR Conser-
1811 78 M No intuba- No Died
hyperlipidemia -e (PM, SE) vative
tion
After
Invasiv Chest CT Conser-
1912 77 M Nil No intuba- No N/A
-e (PM, SE) vative
tion
Non-
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
2013 44 M Nil Yes invasiv No
intubated (PM) vative -ved
-e
Non-
NIDDM, obstructive Not Chest CT Conser-
2114 64 M N/A invasiv No N/A
sleep apnoea intubated (PM) vative
-e
Continued.
International Surgery Journal | November 2020 | Vol 7 | Issue 11 Page 3870
Kanani E. Int Surg J. 2020 Nov;7(11):3868-3875
Time of
PTX/PM Air
Mode
diagnosi Diagnost -
Patie Age Co- of O2 Manag- Outc-
Sex Co-morbidities s related -ic way
-nt (years) ugh therap ement ome
to modality inju
-y
intuba- -ry
tion
Non- Chest CT
Not Conser- Resol
2215 38 M Nil Yes invasiv (PM, No
intubated vative -ved
-e PTX)
Non-
Not Chest CT Conser-
2316 36 F Nil Yes invasiv No Died
intubated (PM) vative
-e
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
2417 23 F Nil No No No
intubated (PM) vative Continued.
-ved
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
2518 78 F DM, hypertension Yes No No
intubated (PM) vative -ved
Chest CT
Not (PM, Resol
2618 41 M Nil No No No ICD
intubated PTX, -ved
SE)
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
2719 30 M N/A No No No
intubated (PM, SE) vative -ved
Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
2819 65 M N/A No No No
intubated (PM, SE) vative -ved
Non- Chest CT
Hypertension, asthma, Not Conser-
2920 55 F Yes invasiv (PM, No Died
morbid obesity intubated vative
-e PTX)
Non-
Chronic gastritis, Not Chest CT Conser- Resol
3020 31 M Yes invasiv No
hypercholesterolemia intubated (PM) vative -ved
-e
Bilateral
ICDs,
After
Invasiv Chest CT bilateral Resol
3121 70 M Hypothyroidism, smoker Yes intuba- No
-e (PM, SE) subcutan -ved
tion
-eous
drains
Bilateral
ICDs,
After
Invasiv Chest CT bilateral Resol
3221 60 M IDDM, pancreatitis No intuba- Yes
-e (PM, SE) subcutan -ved
tion
-eous
drains
After
Invasiv CXR Bilateral
3321 38 M Nil Yes intuba- N/A Died
-e (PM, SE) ICDs
tion
After CXR
Invasiv
3421 51 M Asthma Yes intuba- (PM, N/A Left ICD Died
-e
tion PTX)
After
Invasiv CXR Conserva Resol
3521 60 M Early prostate cancer No intuba- No
-e (PM, SE) -tive -ved
tion
Before
Chest CT Conserva Resol
3622 52 M Nil Yes No intuba- No
(PM) -tive -ved
tion
Non- After
CXR Conserva Resol
3723 52 M DM, asthma Yes invasiv intuba- No
(PM) -tive -ved
-e tion
Continued.
Time of
PTX/PM Air
Mode
diagnosi Diagnost -
Patie Age Co- of O2 Manag- Outc-
Sex Co-morbidities s related -ic way
-nt (years) ugh therap ement ome
to modality inju
-y
intuba- -ry
tion
Chest CT
After
Hypertension, Invasiv (PM, Resol
3823 68 M Yes intuba- No ICD
hypercholesterolemia -e PTX, -ved
tion
SE)
Before
Hypertension, obesity, CXR Conserva Resol
3923 66 M No No intuba- No
chronic kidney disease (PM) -tive -ved
tion
CXR: chest X ray, chest CT: chest computed tomography scan, PM: pneumomediastinum, SE: subcutaneous emphysema, PTX:
pneumothorax, ICD: intercostal intrapleural drainage, IDDM: insulin dependent diabetes mellitus, NIDDM: non-insulin dependent
diabetes mellitus, DM: diabetes mellitus, N/A: information not available
There were 28 male and 6 female patients (male to female difference was observed in the outcome between the
ratio 14:3). The mean age is 55 years (range 23-84 years). groups who developed the condition with or without endo-
tracheal intubation (p value=0.646).
Nine patients reported to have pre-existing chronic
respiratory diseases (23%); 5 asthmatic, 2 other chronic
lung diseases, and two cases of obstructive sleep apnoea.
Two patients were smokers.
Figure 4: Management outcome. There was no statistical difference between the two
management strategies in terms of outcome, and the
majority of patients responded favorably to management
18 whether conservative or interventional (pleural drainage,
surgical repair of airway injury). Death incidence was
16
evenly distributed between the two groups. Lack of
14 autopsy-derived information makes merely attributing
12 these fatalities, in the context of coronavirus infection, to
10 Conservative pneumomediastinum a kind of conjecture.
8 Pleural Drainage
Macklin and Macklin in their excellent work published in
6
1944 considered pneumomediastinum in the context of
4 serious lung inflammatory process and existence of cough
2 indicators of severity; what they called “malignant
0 pneumomediastinum”.25 A detailed description of the
Resolved Persisted Died N/A disease process, pathophysiology and autopsy findings of
a cohort of patients during the influenza epidemic 1918 by
Torrey and Grosh led them to the believe that presence of
Figure 5: Outcomes related to management strategy. free air around blood vessels compressing them and
reducing blood movement to and from the chest thus
DISCUSSION interfering with the cardiac function, together with the
effect of the air in the connective tissue preventing the
Pneumomediastinum is not a known classical finding in lungs from collapse during expiration, are the grounds of
the course of coronavirus infection. Although it may be the pneumomediastinum deleterious consequences.26
precipitated by barotrauma; especially in a chronically
diseased lung, its development without such a cause in Although Chu et al reported that pneumomediastinum is a
many coronavirus infected patients had recently attracted frequent complication of severe acute respiratory
attention. syndrome which carries poor prognostic indication during
the SARS epidemic, this cannot be considered true for the 10. Abou-Arab O, Huette P, Berna P, Mahjoub Y.
coronavirus infection; both being of viral origin; based on Tracheal trauma after difficult airway management in
currently available data.27 morbidly obese patients with COVID-19. Br J
Anaesth. 2020;125(1):168-70.
CONCLUSION 11. Al-Azzawi M, Douedi S, Alshami A, Al-Saoudi G,
Mikhail J. Spontaneous Subcutaneous Emphysema
There is no enough evidence to suggest that and Pneumomediastinum in COVID-19 Patients: An
pneumomediastinum is a natural disease process in Indicator of Poor Prognosis? The American Journal
coronavirus infection, or it is just a complication of of Case Reports. 2020 Jul; 21:e925557. DOI:
treatment interventions. A poor prognostic value of 10.12659/ajcr.925557.
pneumomediastinum is not supported by the currently 12. Collercandy N, Guillon A. Pneumomediastinum in
available data. Both conservative and interventional critically ill adult with COVID-19. Med Intensiva.
management are successful depending on the clinical 2020.
scenario and the treating doctor preference. It is worth to 13. Wegner U, Jeffery G, Abrajan O, Sampablo I, Singh
mention that most of these case series did not report the C. Spontaneous Pneumomediastinum Associated
total number of the patient cohorts treated in their With SARS-CoV-2: Infrequent Complication of the
institutions in order to generate valuable statistical Novel Disease. Cureus. 2020;12(7):9189.
assumptions. Moreover, the number of un-diagnosed and 14. Goldman N, Ketheeswaran B, Wilson H. COVID-19-
un-reported cases may be quite significant to make a associated pneumomediastinum. Clin Med.
difference. Further well-designed observational studies of 2020;20(4):91-2.
enough sample size may shed more light on the topic. 15. Sun R, Liu H, Wang X. Mediastinal Emphysema,
Giant Bulla, and Pneumothorax Developed during
Funding: No funding sources the Course of COVID-19 Pneumonia. Korean J
Conflict of interest: None declared Radiol. 2020;21(5):541-4.
Ethical approval: Not required 16. Wang J, Su X, Zhang T, Zheng C. Spontaneous
Pneumomediastinum: A Probable Unusual
REFERENCES Complication of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-
19) Pneumonia. Korean J Radiol. 2020;21(5):627-8.
1. Zylak CM, Standen JR, Barnes GR, Zylak CJ. 17. Kolani S, Nawfal H, Haloua M, Alaoui Lamrani Y,
Pneumomediastinum Revisited, Radiographics. Boubbou M, Serraj M, et al. Spontaneous
2000;20(4):1043-57. pneumomediastinum occurring in the SARS-COV-2
2. Kouritas VK, Papagiannopoulos K, Lazaridis G, infection. ID Cases. 2020;11(21):e00806.
Baka S, Mpoukovinas I, Karavasili V, et al. 18. Brogna B, Bignardi E, Salvatore P, Alberigo M,
Pneumomediastinum. J Thorac Dis. 2015;7(1):44-9. Brogna C, Megliola A, et al. Unusual presentations
3. Vega JML, Gordo MLP, Tascón AD, Vélez SO. of COVID-19 pneumonia on CT scans with
Pneumomediastinum and spontaneous spontaneous pneumomediastinum and loculated
pneumothorax as an extrapulmonary complication of pneumothorax: A report of two cases and a review of
COVID-19 disease. Emerg Radiol. 2020;1-4. the literature. Heart Lung. 2020.
4. Zhou C, Gao C, Xie Y, Xu M. COVID-19 with 19. Romano N, Fischetti A, Melani EF.
spontaneous pneumomediastinum. Lancet Infect Dis. Pneumomediastinum related to COVID-19
2020;20:510. pneumonia. Am J Med Sci. 2020.
5. Wang W, Gao R, Zheng Y, Jiang L. COVID-19 with 20. Quincho-Lopez A, Quincho-Lopez DL, Hurtado-
spontaneous pneumothorax, pneumomediastinum Medina FD. Case Report: Pneumothorax and
and subcutaneous emphysema. J Travel Med. Pneumomediastinum as Uncommon Complications
2020;27(5):taaa062. of COVID-19 Pneumonia—Literature Review. Am J
6. Xiang C, Wu G. SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia with Trop Med Hygiene. 2020;103(3):1170-6.
subcutaneous emphysema, mediastinal emphysema, 21. Wali A, Rizzo V, Bille A, Routledge T, Chambers A.
and pneumothorax. Medicine. 2020;99(20):e20208. Pneumomediastinum following intubation in
7. Mohan V, Tauseen RA. Spontaneous COVID‐19 patients: a case series. Anaesthesia.
pneumomediastinum in COVID-19. BMJ Case Rep. 2020;75:1076-81.
2020;13:e236519. 22. Janseen J, Kamps MJA, Joosten TMB, Barten DG.
8. Lacroix M, Graiess F, Monnier Cholley L, Arrivé L. Spontaneous Pneumomediastinum in a male adult
SARS-CoV-2 pulmonary infection revealed by with COVID-19 pneumonia. Am J Emerg Med.
subcutaneous emphysema and pneumomediastinum, 2020.
Intensive Care Med. 2020;46:1620-1. 23. Volpi S, Ali JM, Suleman A, Ahmed RN.
9. Eperjesiova B, Hart E, Shokr M, Sinha P, Ferguson Pneumomediastinum in COVID-19 patients: a case
GT. Spontaneous Pneumomediastinum/Pneumo - series of a rare complication. Eur J Cardio-Thoracic
thorax in Patients With COVID-19. Cureus. Surg. 2020;58(3):646-7.
2020;12(7):e8996. 24. Caceres M, Ali SZ, Braud R, Weiman D, Garrett HE.
Spontaneus pneumomediastinum: a comparative
study and review of the literature. Ann Thoracic 27. Chu CM, Leung YY, Hui JYH, Hung IF, Chan VL,
Surg. 2008;86(3):962-6. Leung WS, et al. Spontaneous pneumomediastinum
25. Macklin MT, Macklin C. Malignant interstitial in patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome.
emphysema of the lungs and mediastinum as an Eur Respir J. 2004;23(6):802-4.
important occult complication in many respiratory
diseases and other conditions: an interpretation of the
clinical literature in the light of laboratory
experiment. Medicine. 1944;23(4):281-358.
Cite this article as: Kanani E. Pneumomediastinum
26. Torrey, Robert G, Lawrence C. Acute pulmonary
with COVID-19: a natural process or complication?
emphysema observed during the epidemic of
A literature review. Int Surg J 2020;7:3868-3875.
influenzal pneumonia at Camp Hancock, Georgia.
Am J Med Sci. Philadelphia. 1919;157(2):170.