SMART COLLEGE

63-3, 65-3, 67-3, JALAN KAMPUNG PANDAN,

TAMAN MALURI, 55100 KUALA LUMPUR
______________________________________________________________
DIPLOMA IN CRIME & INVESTIGATION

SUBJECT CODE : LAW 1101

SUBJECT TITLE : INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
BATCH :DCI 21A

SMART COLLEGE
 63-3, 65-3, 67-3, JALAN KAMPUNG PANDAN,
TAMAN MALURI, 55100 KUALA LUMPUR
______________________________________________________________
FACULTY OF LAW AND ENFORCEMENT
ASSIGNMENT

STUDENT INFORMATION :

NAME SYAFIQAH INILYAH

SUBJECT INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

SUBJECT CODE LAW 1101

PROGRAMME DIPLOMA IN CRIME & INVESTIGATION

BATCH DCI 21 A

MODE INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT

DATE OF 21ST AUGUST 2023

SUBMISSION

LECTURER’S NAME MS ASHMITA KAUR

FOR LECTURER USE ONLY :

SUBJECT INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

SUBJECT CODE LAW 1101

TOTAL MARKS

DATE OF 21ST AUGUST 2023

SUBMISSION

LECTURER’S REMARK

SMART COLLEGE
63-3, 65-3, 67-3, JALAN KAMPUNG PANDAN,
 TAMAN MALURI, 55100 KUALA LUMPUR
____________________________________________________________________

ASSIGNMENT
INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM (LAW 1101)
DIPLOMA IN CRIME & INVESTIGATION 21A

Name SYAFIQAH INILYAH

ID Number 230008

Batch DCI 21A

Date 21ST AUGUST 2023

Lecturer MS ASHMITA KAUR

INSTRUCTION TO STUDENTS :

1. This Assignment booklet consists of 8 questions

 2. This is an individual assignment

3. Please answer the questions in the following format :

a. Essay Form
b. Font : Arial
c. Size : 12
d. Spacing : 1.15
e. Alignment : Justified

4. Submission of this Assignment is on 21st August 2023, MONDAY during

class hour

5. Each students are required to create a poster for the Assignment

6. Presentation will be held on 21st August 2023, MONDAY

7. Total carry marks for the assignment will be 15%

8. Marks will be deducted for late submission of assignment. Each week of late
submission, 1.5% will be deducted from the 15% full carry mark.

9. Students will be barred from taking midterm if this Assignment is not

submitted.

ABD MALEK HUSSIN v BORHAN HJ DAUD & ORS

The plaintiff was arrested without a warrant by a group of Special Branch officers led by
the first defendant on 25 September 1998, at about 10pm. The arrest occurred in front
of his house just after he had been dropped off by a friend. The plaintiff was only
vaguely told that he was being arrested under the Internal Security Act 1960. He was
then handcuffed and slapped thrice by the first defendant when he was unable to show
the first defendant the location of his car.

Thereafter, the first defendant and his men entered the plaintiff's house without a search
warrant and seized several documents and items. He was then blindfolded and taken to
the IPK Kuala Lumpur. During the journey to the IPK, apart from wearing the blindfold,
the plaintiff's head was forcibly covered with a T-shirt and the plaintiff was forced to
bend forward and down between his legs in the car. At the IPK, Kuala Lumpur he was
taken to an air-conditioned room on the first floor where he was stripped, drenched with
water and made to stand in front of the air-conditioner. The plaintiff further testified that
he was verbally abused and physically assaulted by the first defendant, the then
Inspector-General of Police ('IGP') Tan Sri Rahim Noor, and several other police
personnel. He was hit, punched and kicked repeatedly all over his body. His penis was
hit and an object pushed against his anus. He lost his balance and fell down several
times during the assault. At one instance when his blindfold slipped, he recognised one
of the assailants as the second defendant,Tan Sri Rahim Noor, the then IGP. The
plaintiff recounted that after the assault, his mouth was forced open and some foul
urine-smelling liquid was poured into his mouth. This harrowing ordeal lasted until 4am
on 26 September 1998.

He was denied medical treatment for several days and was only taken to see Dr
Vasantha on 29 September 1998. The plaintiff testified that he was taken to Bukit Aman
on 26 September 1998 and interrogated for 19 days. The plaintiff averred that the
interrogation was only focused on inter alia, his relationship with Datuk Seri Anwar
Ibrahim, the 'reformasi' movement and opposition politics. All in all, the plaintiff spent 57
days in police custody and under solitary confinement. During this 57-day period he only
saw his family twice and was denied access to counsel. The plaintiff sued the
defendants for damages for the tort of false imprisonment as well as for the tort of
assault and battery.

QUESTIONS :

1. Identify the parties involved in this case. (2 marks)

 2. Describe the facts of the above case (2 marks)

3. State the issues in the above case. (4 marks)

4. By applying Section 27B of the Police Act 1967, determine whether there was
use of force by the Defendants towards the Plaintiff.
(10 marks)

5. Analyse whether there was compliance in regard to the form issued by the first
defendant with Article 5(3) of the Federal Constitution.
(6 marks)

6. Evaluate whether the Plaintiff was given a right to access a lawyer. (8 marks)

7. Determine whether the Plaintiff was granted the right of medical treatment.

(2 marks)

8. Predict the outcome of the Judge in this case. (3 marks)

NAME : SYAFIQAH INILYAH

DATE : 21ST AUGUST 2023
MATRIX NUMBER : 230008
BATCH : DCI 21 A
 PART A : FORMAT

CRITERIA / GRADE A (4) B (3) C (2) D/F (1/0) MARKS

Organization of Well-planned Good overall Organization, No sense of

Content and well-thought organization tools are used organization
out weakly or
missing

References Well quoted and Cited with Support some Poorly cited and
cited. Conform occasional citations and a does not
to APA Style errors in few errors in conform to APA
conformity to APA Style style.
APA Style

Style : Clear Clear Generally clear Unclear

Sentences and sentences, sentences, sentence, little sentence and no
example specific some use of use of example use of
examples and example and and description. description.
description. description.

Grammar Excellent A few errors in Shows a Continuous

grammar, grammar, pattern of errors error
spelling and spelling and in spelling,
punctuation. punctuation. grammar and
punctuation.

Plagiarism Very little Some form of Half of the Many areas are
plagiarism plagiarism. paragraph is plagiarized
Used own plagiarized. (>75%)
words.

TOTAL (20 marks)

TOTAL PART A (10%)

PART B: VIRTUAL BOARD

CRITERIA/GRADE A (4) B (3) C (2) D/F (1/0) MARKS

Poster/Infographic Organized & Relevant Partial Poor information
Content informative information. Not information and and
posters. Relevant well organized. unorganized. unorganized.
information.

Work quality/effort Work exceeds Good work Average work No quality and
expectations, quality and effort quality and effort.
visible amount of effort
effort

TOTAL (8 marks)

TOTAL PART B
(10%)

PART C: CLO MARKING

NO CLO 1 CLO 2 CLO 3 CLO 4 CLO 5 TOTAL MARKS

QUESTION 1,2 6,7 5 3,4 8 40

MARKS ALLOCATED 4 13 6 14 3 40

MARKS GIVEN

TOTAL

TOTAL PART C (80%)

TOTAL PART A /10

TOTAL PART B /10

TOTAL PART C /80

TOTAL PART /100

A+B+C

TOTAL (15%)

Deduction for late -1.5 %

submission
(One week late):

Deduction for late -1.5 %

submission
(Two week late):

TOTAL (15%)

COMMENT :

LECTURER NAME :

SIGNATURE :

DATE :