Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Justito Adiprasetio & Annissa Winda Larasati (2023): Deconstructing
Pocong, the Indonesian Sacred Ghost: A Diachronic Analysis of Mumun (2022),
Indonesian Contemporary Horror Film, Quarterly Review of Film and Video, DOI:
10.1080/10509208.2023.2230116
Introduction
A body wrapped in a white cloth with tightly bound shroud strings,
smeared with soil, packed with maggots, jumping and flying aggressively,
strangling, spewing bodily fluids through the mouth, emitting green light
from the eyes, seeking revenge and killing, becomes elements of the repre-
sentation of the pocong in Mumun (2022). Mumun (2022) manifests how
the lurking pocong within the universe of Indonesian society’s fears is pre-
sented on the contemporary Indonesian cinema screen. The pocong in
Mumun (2022) becomes an iconography of a ghost, which, although resur-
rected from an Indonesian soap opera from mid-2002 to 2003, possesses
both generic and unique characteristics. Generic because it is presented in
similarity to the patterns of many Indonesian horror films post-reforma-
tion, after the fall of the authoritarian New Order regime. Unique because,
even though its representation is closely related to Islamic religious rituals,
the pocong as a ghost does not (ever) dominantly occupy the cinema
screens of other major Islamic countries such as Malaysia, Brunei, or even
Middle Eastern countries. Prior to the reformation, one would also not
find the pocong dominating Indonesian cinema screened three decades ago.
At that time, no flying pocong or pocong could spew and vomit disgusting
bodily fluids or emit green light from their eyes. Mumun (2022) stands as
evidence of how ghosts in Indonesian films are representations of various
discursive intersections, influenced by discursive practices, and even hybri-
dized with other ghost representations.
Pocong refers to a spectral entity in South East Asia folklore. It is
believed to be the spirit of a deceased individual ensnared within their bur-
ial shroud. Referred to as “kain kafan” in Indonesian, this shroud is a
Justito Adiprasetio is an Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Communication Science, Universitas Padjadjaran.
He and his wife wrote Memaksa Ibu jadi Hantu (Mother Who Forced to Haunt). He also wrote Komunikasi dan
Kuasa (Communication and Power), which discusses the history of communication science in Indonesia.
Annissa Winda Larasati currently works as an adjunct lecturer in Television & Film Studies, Universitas
Padjadjaran. Along with her husband, she wrote her first ever book which discussed maternal horror in
Indonesian films was published under the title of Memaksa Ibu Menjadi Hantu (Mother Who Forced to Haunt)
on 2022.
ß 2023 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2 J. ADIPRASETIO AND A. WINDA LARASATI
the main ghost: Setan Kuburan (1975). The emergence and significant
increase in quantity indicate a change and elevation in the position of the
pocong within the realm of fear in Indonesian society after the reformation.
Looking back, Setan Kuburan (1975) utilizes a slightly different formula
compared to Mumun (2022) as it does not involve romance but still
emphasizes unresolved matters. Setan Kuburan (1975) tells the story of a
moneylender in a village who dies after being crushed by a tree. In Setan
Kuburan (1975), the pocong is represented as being jumped over by a black
cat, which later causes it to wander and demand payment from those who
have not yet repaid their debts.
Although some films represented pocong as a ghost, such as in Malam
Satu Suro (1988), pocong never became the main ghost in films over a long
period. Pocong only served as a representation of the ghostly manifestation
element that later transformed into other ghosts, such as sundel bolong in
Malam Satu Suro (1988), or as an addition to add a sense of terror in the
final part of the film, as seen in Pengabdi Setan (1980).
The time gap of over three decades between Setan Kuburan (1975) and
the Pocong 2 (2006), which emerged in the mid-2000s, raises the question:
What laid the foundation for the resurgence of pocong in the Indonesian
horror film repertoire?
The emergence of Pocong 2 (2006), followed by a series of other pocong
films, including Mumun (2022), indicates a shift in the discourse of fear in
Indonesian society. Larasati dan Adiprasetio (2022) captures the significant
increase in Indonesian horror films, particularly in the spiritual horror
genre that relies on religious nuances, in the post-reform era. Pocong as a
ghost is resurrected amidst the bustling atmosphere of post-reform carnival
haunted house.
The representation of pocong becomes a symptom of the increasingly
close relationship of Indonesians with supernatural and religious discourse.
It becomes part of the Indonesian people’s fantasy to explain the uncertain
things on the border of reality and the vague: the reality of the afterlife and
the relationship between the living and the dead (Hutchings, 2014). In
order to bind and delve into the pocong, we can turn to Freud’s explan-
ation that ghosts and perceptions of ghosts stem from something repressed
and hidden in the deepest recesses of the subconscious. The influence of
religion and beliefs in the supernatural awaken the realm of the uncanny—
a Freudian term difficult to translate—and make many people feel as
though they have experiences with the dead, corpses, and their return.
Indonesians’ fear of pocong arises from the “an uncanny effect often arises
when the boundary between fantasy and reality is blurred, when we are
faced with the reality of something that we have until now considered
imaginary, when a symbol takes on the full function and significance of
what it symbolizes (Freud, 2003).”
6 J. ADIPRASETIO AND A. WINDA LARASATI
mysticism in readers’ minds, starting from the early period of 2001. The
early editions of Hidayah itself were taken and adapted from the best mate-
rials of the Malaysian edition of Hidayah. The explosive rise in Hidayah’s
circulation in 2004, reaching 320,000 copies per edition, surpassed not only
the circulation of the magazine in its home country but also outperformed
all other publications that had emerged earlier and had a long track record
in the competitive media landscape in Indonesia, such as Gadis, Kartini,
Tempo, and Intisari (Irawanto, 2011). This indicates that Hidayah became
one of the most influential media outlets at that time. The massive circula-
tion of Hidayah exemplifies how pocong could be quickly revived within
the realms of horror in Indonesian society in a relatively short period.4
Hidayah magazine was first published in October 1998 in Malaysia under
the Varia Group in a digest format.5 During that period, 30 mystery maga-
zines were published monthly in Malaysia in the same format. Although it
had a large audience, Hidayah was not Malaysia’s most prominent Islamic
or mystical media at that time (Supriansyah, 2007). The emergence of
pocong in visual representations post-reformation owes its debt to a trans-
national exchange involving aspects of dakwah (Islamic propagation)
between Indonesia and Malaysia. Malaysian horror films in the 2000s that
exploited the pocong (known as “hantu bungkus” in Malaysian terminology)
were released after pocong had become one of the dominant visual objects
in Indonesian cinema, as seen in Hantu Pocong Ikat Tepi (2015).
Unlike magazines such as Suara Quran, Kasyaf, and Cahaya Sufi, where
the dominant discourse revolves around the spiritual and esoteric aspects
of Islam and its dissemination in Indonesia, or media outlets like Sabili,
Suara Hidayatullah, and Media Dakwah, which have heavily politicized
content, particularly in their criticism of modern democracy, Hidayah tends
to focus on mystical stories packaged with religious teachings: what should
be done, what should not be done, and the rewards for each action
(Irawanto, 2011). Although it contains inspiring stories about how good
deeds are rewarded in a religious context, the most dominant stories in
Hidayah are about punishments, curses, and supernatural occurrences in
the afterlife or the realm of the grave due to not following religious com-
mands, breaking prohibitions, or harming others. The stories revolve
around bizarre, grotesque, and even astonishing events.6
Exposure to post-death conditions and the realm of the grave results in
stories and visual representations packaged within the magazine covers and
illustrations that are heavily dominated by the figure of a corpse, specific-
ally the pocong. Hidayah repeatedly features the pocong on its covers in ter-
rifying conditions: covered in blood, chained, entangled, submerged, and
restrained. Hidayah presents religious horror even before readers have a
chance to open the pages of the magazine. Hidayah became the first and
QUARTERLY REVIEW OF FILM AND VIDEO 9
most consistent media platform after the reform era, associating the pocong
with horror and promoting it to the Indonesian public.
This can be understood when the pocong and the horror that had
emerged in print media later infiltrated television through the soap opera
Jadi Pocong (2002–2003). Although at the time, the director of Jadi Pocong
(2002–2003) claimed that it was based on Betawi folklore that had existed
for years, the fact that it appeared after Hidayah magazine had filled the
racks of newspapers and magazines throughout Jakarta and even Indonesia,
indicates that it ultimately benefited from the mainstreaming of the pocong
that had been established earlier.
Hidayah was later adapted into a soap opera format from 2005 to 2007.
Each episode of the soap opera Hidayah (2005–2007) stands independently,
without continuity between one episode and another. Similar to what was
presented in the magazine format, the moral messages in each story are
displayed explicitly. “Azab” (divine punishment) is the most dominant
theme in the soap opera Hidayah (2005–2007). Although the representation
of pocong is not as explicit as in the magazine format, the depiction of
pocong being subjected to curses can still be seen in many episodes.
The continuous and tense bombardment of visuality in print media and
television played a crucial role in constructing the audience’s imaginative
universe regarding pocong in the early 2000s. This discourse formation gave
rise to films like Pocong 2 (2006), other pocong-themed films, and even
Mumun (2022). These media outlets employed what Jenkins (2010) called
transmedia storytelling. Transmedia storytelling is a technique of storytell-
ing and sharing experiences that transcends platforms and media formats,
involving multiple storytellers and relying on signification that can some-
times be arbitrary but remains bound to the context (Jenkins, 2010).
The significant context of transmedia storytelling within the realm of
Indonesian religious horror narratives, particularly regarding pocong, is
influenced by the resurgence of Islam due to populism and the main-
streaming of Islam in the media, as eloquently described by Hadiz (2016)
and Rakhmani (2017). Hidayah, the soap opera Jadi Pocong (2002–2003),
and the film Pocong 2 (2006) are part of the religious discourse framework
that encourages the audience to differentiate between the physical world
and the realm of the supernatural, a dimension that presents a diverse
array of creatures, ghosts, monsters with various characters and forms.
Most spiritual horror films are derived from or become contemporary
versions of folklore and mythology intertwined with religious aspects
(Balmain, 2008; Koven, 2023). Folklore and mythology blur the boundaries
between reality and fiction: the origins of their stories are often claimed to
be based on true events. It is common for each edition of Hidayah to be
claimed as derived from a “true” story that offers moral lessons, as well as
10 J. ADIPRASETIO AND A. WINDA LARASATI
the stories of Jadi Pocong (2002–2003) and Mumun (2023), which are
labeled as retellings of actual events.
Many ghost stories from the past have been reincarnated multiple times,
then retold with ornaments and modifications in the following generations,
allowing Western ghost and monster figures such as lady in white, bell
witch, bloody mary, Frankenstein, Dracula, and vampires to endure for
hundreds of years and be resurrected multiple times in films. The same
goes for adaptations of events considered real and existing, such as The
Exorcist (1973), The Conjuring series (2013, 2016, 2021), and Annabelle
(2019). The possibility of reviving various forms of ghosts as symbols of
terror involve more than one media product. The nature and narrative
structure of the horror genre are almost always transmedia to successfully
enter the realm of fear (Carrol, 1990). The collective efforts of the media
lead us to resurrect the once faint presence of the pocong, popularize it,
and force Indonesian audiences to become familiar with Mumun (2022).
Transmedia storytelling serves as a mechanism that enables the resurrec-
tion of the pocong within the semiosphere of Indonesian horror films in
the 2000s. Various media outlets then creatively tell stories about the ori-
gins of the pocong, its experiences, and how it becomes a body that never
truly dies. Transmedia storytelling also builds familiarity among the public,
associating the pocong closely with curses, horror, and terror (Harvey,
2019). Within the realm of the pocong in Indonesia, its stories spread
through digital forums such as Facebook, Kaskus, and Twitter. The Twitter
account @poconggg, created in 2009, narrates pocong and horror stories,
rapidly gaining millions of followers.
Transmedia storytelling can be seen as a particular case of the creation
of trans fictionality—the transposition of fiction across multiple media. It is
a method for transferring highly familiar elements into new discourses,
enabling expansion, modification, and transformation in terms of storytell-
ing (Ryan, 2013). This allows the ghosts in horror films from various coun-
tries to appear in creative and innovative narratives in every aspect of their
reproduction.
However, no matter how creative the forms of reproduction may be in
horror films, there is always a thread of discourse that connects these
ghosts to their original folklore or mythology. For example, the appearance
of Dracula is a blood-sucking creature vulnerable to sunlight. The Bell
Witch is an entity or spirit that manifests as a fortune teller with non-
material powers and the ability to move across time boundaries. Zombies
reanimated human bodies in the past due to magic or voodoo, and now,
due to viral infections and fungi. In the context of Indonesia, transmedia
storytelling also allows the audience to be very familiar with ghosts like the
sundel bolong” and kuntilanak while also creating innovative versions such
QUARTERLY REVIEW OF FILM AND VIDEO 11
In the discourse of early 20th-century Malay culture, the pocong was rep-
resented as a rolling ghost and did not leap like in many Indonesian horror
films, such as in Setan Kuburan (1975), nor did it fly like in Mumun
(2022). The pocong was not imagined to extend its hands; instead, it only
rolled. Although this knowledge about the pocong may be derived from
colonial accounts, it is evident that the representation of the pocong has not
remained fixed over the past century, and the emergence of horror in the
past was conveyed through very simple gestures.
This is also reflected in British Orientalist, Richard Olaf Winstedt when he
was documenting mysticism in the Malay region (1925). Winstedt mentioned:
QUARTERLY REVIEW OF FILM AND VIDEO 15
Besides these two classes of malicious birth spirits and familiars, created from the
corpses of man, there are graveyard spooks of the sheeted dead. In Patani one of the
most noted of these (hantu bungkus) is thought to appear as a white cat or to lie like
a bundle of white rags near a burial ground. “Should a person pass it who is afraid,
it unrolls, twines itself round his feet, enters his person by means of his big toe and
feasts within on his soul, so that he becomes distraught and dies in convulsions,
unless a competent medicine man can exorcise it in time to save his life and
reason.” A bold person anxious to see ghosts has only to use as a collyrium the tears
of the wide eyed slow loris!
(Winstedt, 1925)
What Makes Mumun (2022) and Pocong Fail to Haunt the Audience
As mentioned earlier, Mumun (2022) is a tedious film. It presents atmos-
pheric horror, reminiscent of Indonesian horror from 4 to 5 decades ago,
but fails to deliver cohesive terror. The repetitive appearances of the
pocong, without a strong storyline, make the horror portrayed in the film
lack a climax. Mumun seems to be presented with the assumption that the
mere presence of the pocong will always be terrifying. This is due to the
immense intention to capture a nostalgic atmosphere for viewers who have
watched the soap opera Jadi Pocong (2002–2003), those who are in a state
of fear of the pocong due to the influx of post-2000 pocong films, as well as
16 J. ADIPRASETIO AND A. WINDA LARASATI
Conclusion
This article shows that the representation of pocong in Mumun (2022) is part
of the resonance of Indonesian people’s fears with the dominant religious
QUARTERLY REVIEW OF FILM AND VIDEO 17
Notes
1. In Indonesian folklore, there exists a supernatural entity known as the sundel bolong. This
mythical ghost is depicted as a woman with stunning, flowing black hair and dressed in a
long, white gown. The term “sundel” refers to a “prostitute” or “whore,” while “bolong” in
Javanese translates to “hole.” Scholars of contemporary folklore suggest that this myth
originated within Javanese culture as a means to discourage the proliferation of
prostitution during the period of Dutch East Indies colonization (Pangastuti, 2019).
2. The kuntilanak, known as pontianak in Malaysia, is a legendary being that exists in
Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. It shares similarities with the Langsuir found in
other Southeast Asian regions. The pontianak is commonly portrayed as a pregnant
woman who is unable to deliver her child. Alternatively, it is often depicted as a
vengeful, vampire-like female spirit. Another variation of the pontianak refers to the
ghost or white lady found in the folklore of Southeast Asia.
3. The suster ngesot originated from the story of a nurse who was raped and mutilated by
a doctor. Due to her severed legs, she haunts by crawling. Some scholars believe that
the suster ngesot is a transfiguration of the Lady in White in Indonesia, known as the
kuntilanak (Larasati & Adiprasetio, 2022).
4. Unfortunately, studies on Hidayah tend to be very limited, unsystematic, and only
mentioned in media scholarship analyses without being deeply explicitly explored. The
study that should have been conducted on the most successful magazine in the history
of media in Indonesia is submerged in the decadence of research on Indonesian
communication and media scholarship (Adiprasetio, 2022).
5. The same group later published Hidayah in Indonesia (Supriansyah, 2007).
6. During the 1980s and 1990s, various printed products exposing the concept of
“terrifying religion,” such as Komik Neraka (Comic Hell), were distributed in
Indonesia. Although the representations depicted the torment of human bodies in the
afterlife, the presence of pocong in Komik Neraka (Comic Hell) was relatively minimal
or even nonexistent.
7. The hantu Terowongan Casablanca originated from the victims of forced abortions
who were subsequently buried alive. Unlike the general story of the kuntilanak, the
hantu Terowongan Casablanca haunts a specific location and causes accidents.
ORCID
Justito Adiprasetio http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5698-2013
Work Cited
Adiprasetio, J. 2022. “The Development of Communication Research in Indonesia in 2001–
2020.” Jurnal Kajian Komunikasi 10 (1): 105–120. doi:10.24198/jkk.v10i1.35954
QUARTERLY REVIEW OF FILM AND VIDEO 19
Madani International Film Festival 2022. “MIFF 2022 Book Discussion x Binus University -
Pocong Movie & Muslim World þ Video Essay.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=
LASNp9Zr0Qs
Ndalianis, A. 2012. The Horror Sensorium: Media and the Senses. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Pangastuti, A. 2019. Female Sexploitation in Indonesian Horror Films: Sundel Bolong (a
Perforated Prostitute Ghost, 1981), Gairah Malam III (Night Passion III, 1996), and Air
Terjun Pengantin (Lost Paradise-Playmates in Hell, 2009) [Master’s Thesis, Auckland
University of Technology]. https://openrepository.aut.ac.nz/items/3512ac43-2e3d-4b84-
b7d0-9582b6e0d3b4
Phillips, K. R. 2005. Projected Fears: Horror Films and American Culture: Horror Films and
American Culture. Westport: Praeger Publishers.
Rakhmani, I. 2014. “The Commercialization of da’wah: Understanding Indonesian Sinetron
and Their Portrayal of Islam.” International Communication Gazette 76 (4–5): 340–359.
doi:10.1177/1748048514523528
Rakhmani, I. 2017. Mainstreaming Islam in Indonesia. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Ridenour, A. 2016. The Krampus and the Old, Dark Christmas: roots and Rebirth of the
Folkloric Devil. Washington: Feral House.
Ryan, M.-L. 2013. “Transmedial Storytelling and Transfictionality.” Poetics Today 34 (3):
361–388. doi:10.1215/03335372-2325250
Sasono, E. 2011. Menjegal Film Indonesia: pemetaan ekonomi politik industri film Indonesia.
Jakarta: Rumah Film & Tifa Foundation.
Supriansyah, 2007. Kisah-Kisah di Majalah Hidayah (Analisis Strukturalisme Claude Levi-
Strauss). Banjarmasin: Antasari Press.
Sutandio, A. 2012. “The Return of the Repressed: Pemuda and the Historical Trauma in
Rizal Mantovani and Jose Purnomo’s Jelangkung.” Plaride: Journal of Communication,
Media, and Society 12 (2): 1–22.
Sutandio, A. 2014. Historical Trauma and the Discourse of Indonesian-Ness in
Contemporary Indonesian Horror Films. Athens, OH: Ohio University.
Thompson, R. 2019. “Bodies at a Quick Standstill.” New Writing 16 (4): 449–452. doi:10.
1080/14790726.2019.1574307
Triwahyupriadi, D., and Y. Ayuningtyas. 2020. “Indonesian Horror Film: Deconstruction of
Repetitive Elements of Indonesian Urban Legend for Cultural Revitalization, Creativity,
and Critical Thinking.” In Proceedings of International Conference on Art, Design,
Education and Cultural Studies, KnE Social Sciences, 115–125. doi:10.18502/kss.v4i12.
7589
Wilkinson, R. J. 1906. Malay Beliefs (Vol. 1). London: Luzac & Company.
Winstedt, R. O. 1925. Shaman, Saiva, and Sufi: A Study of the Evolution of Malay Magic.
London: Constable Limited.