You are on page 1of 10

30 Tattoo Removal with Lasers

WILLIAM KIRBY, DO, FAOCD  •  FRANCISCA KARTONO, DO  • 


REBECCA SMALL, MD

T he growing trend of tattooing has led to increased LASER PRINCIPLES


numbers of patients seeking tattoo removal. Studies
note that 40% of Americans between the age of 26 and Tattoo ink serves as a cutaneous chromophore for lasers.
40 currently have tattoos and 17% of these people are Certain wavelengths of light are selectively absorbed by
seeking removal.1,2 With more than 20,000 tattoo different ink colors.4 In this way, colored inks can be
studios in the United States placing tattoos, the demand targeted and removed by laser light with minimal
for removal is likely to continue to increase in the damage to surrounding tissues. The chromophore
coming years.3 absorption spectrum of the tissue chromophores,
Multiple techniques can be used for tattoo removal. melanin and oxyhemoglobin, as well as wavelengths
Early removal methods used mechanical destruction used for tattoo removal, are shown in Figure 30-3.
such as dermabrasion, chemical peels, and continuous- Wavelength selection for different tattoo colors is shown
wave lasers. These methods left patients with unsatis- in Figure 30-4 and is as follows:
factory results and were associated with suboptimal
removal and scarring (Figure 30-1). The current stan- • Black and dark blue inks are best treated with a
dard of using Q-switched lasers has revolutionized 1064 nm wavelength.
tattoo removal and offers patients a safe and effective • Red ink (and variations of red such as orange and
means for removing tattoo ink. yellow) is best treated with a 532 nm wavelength.
In this chapter, we describe the physiology of a • Green ink is best treated with 650, 694, or 755 nm
tattoo, the latest tattoo removal technology, and the wavelengths.
current standard practice recommendations for tattoo • Sky blue is best treated with a 585 nm wavelength.
removal with Q-switched lasers. • Purple is a combination color and can be treated with
585 and 532 nm wavelengths.

TATTOO ANATOMY Laser parameters including wavelength, pulse dura-


tion, and fluence can be tailored to maximize tattoo ink
During the tattooing process, tattoo ink is injected intra- destruction and minimize thermal damage to surround-
dermally. The epidermis and upper papillary dermis are ing tissue. Short pulsed, Q-switched lasers further
homogenized and ink particles (ranging in size from 2 employ photoacoustic vibration to fragment tattoo ink
to 400 nm) are deposited intracellularly and extracel- into smaller particles. These smaller ink particles are
lularly. After 2 to 3 months, the skin layers are reestab- eliminated through epidermal extrusion, lymphatic
lished and ink is concentrated in the dermis within drainage, and macrophage phagocytosis. In addition,
fibroblasts, beneath a layer of fibrotic scar tissue (Figure laser-treated ink particles have altered optical properties
30-2). that render the ink remaining in the skin less visible to
Numerous chemicals and inks are used in the tattoo the eye.5
industry and the component ink compounds in a given
tattoo are usually unknown by the patient at the time Laser Parameters and
of presenting for tattoo removal. The Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) does not regulate tattoo inks and,
Tattoo Treatments
therefore, tattoo inks are not evaluated for safety. In • Pulse width, or pulse duration (measured in nanosec-
general, amateur tattoos are often carbon based such as onds) is the length of time that laser light is in contact
burnt wood or pen ink, and there is a lower density of with the skin. Q-switched lasers have fixed nanosec-
pigment particles. Professional tattoos are typically com- ond pulse widths and this parameter cannot be
posed of organic dyes mixed with metallic elements that adjusted for treatments.
give the color: red is often made from mercury; yellow • The thermal relaxation time (measured in seconds) is
from cadmium; green from chromium; blue from cobalt; defined as the time required for the absorbed energy
white from titanium dioxide; and flesh color from iron within the target chromophore to cool to one-half its
oxide. Tattoo inks are usually combinations of colors, original value immediately after irradiation. To spe-
so a green, red, or light blue tattoo may also contain cifically target the chromophore ink and reduce
darker colors such as black ink. unwanted thermal damage to surrounding tissues,
367
30 SECTION THREE  •  Cosmetic Procedures

Ink particles
Epidermis
Tattoo needle
puncture site
Dermis

Subcutaneous layer
A

FIGURE 30-1  Dermabrasion results for tattoo removal showing


scarring, hypopigmentation, and residual ink. (Copyright Rebecca
Small, MD.)

very short pulse widths (shorter than the target


thermal relaxation time) are used to heat and ablate
the ink faster than heat is conducted to the sur-
Fibrotic layer
rounding tissue.
• Spot size (measured in millimeters) is the diameter of Ink particles
the laser beam on the skin surface. Use of a larger
spot size results in less scatter of the photons and
deeper laser beam penetration. This maximizes the C
distribution of laser light to the dermal ink and FIGURE 30-2  Tattoo placement and dermal incorporation of ink
reduces epidermal injury. Larger spot sizes should be (A) immediately after tattooing, (B) 1 month, and (C) 2 to 3 months
after.
used as long as sufficient fluence can be obtained to
achieve the desired clinical endpoint. A smaller spot
size (e.g., 2 to 3 mm) has greater scattering of
photons, delivers energy less efficiently, and causes

Oxyhemoglobin
650
532 Melanin
694
585
Absorption coefficient (cm–1)

1000
755
1064
100

10

0
400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400
Wavelength (nm)

UV Visible light Infrared light

FIGURE 30-3  Chromophore absorption spectra and tattoo removal lasers.

368
30  •  Tattoo Removal with Lasers 30

Fitzpatrick skin type VI patients have the greatest risk


of complications with any aesthetic procedure, and pro-
viders should consider treatment of this skin type an
advanced laser application.
Almost any tattoo is indicated for laser tattoo removal.
1064 nm
Multiple treatments are needed to achieve satisfactory
Black results. Due to great variation in tattoo ink depth,
density, composition, and techniques used for place-
ment, the number of treatments needed for removal
585 nm can be difficult to estimate accurately. In general, pro-
Sky blue fessionally placed tattoos have a high ink density and
require 9 to 14 treatments, whereas amateur tattoos
typically require 4 to 8 treatments. Several other factors
can affect the number of treatments necessary for
removal: faded, older tattoos on paler skin types in
more proximal locations tend to resolve with fewer
532 nm
treatments than intense, multicolored tattoos on darker
Red skin types in distal locations.6 Patients should be ques-
tioned about other tattoo removal methods used previ-
ously. Methods that create scar tissue, such as burning
or abrasion, can make tattoo removal with lasers less
successful.
Certain types of tattoos are considered advanced, and
650 nm, 694 nm, treatment should not be undertaken until the provider
755 nm
Green
is fully confident in his or her skill with artistic tattoo
removal. Advanced tattoos include cosmetic tattoos,
such as those used for permanent eyeliner or lip liner,
flesh-colored inks, and traumatic tattoos.
FIGURE 30-4  Laser wavelengths used for different tattoo colors.
(Copyright Rebecca Small, MD.)

INDICATIONS
more epidermal injury than larger spot sizes (e.g., 6 Laser tattoo removal is indicated for the treatment of
to 8 mm). ectopic skin pigment. This pigment is usually from pur-
• Wavelength (measured in nanometers) is chosen posefully placed ink in tattoos (both professional and
based on the tattoo ink color. In general, as the wave- amateur artistic tattoos) as well as tattoos associated
length increases, so does the depth of penetration. with medical procedures (e.g., radiation therapy
• The energy output is known as fluence (measured in tattoos). In rare cases ectopic pigment may be the result
joules per square centimeter). More specifically, of trauma (traumatic tattoos) where materials such as
fluence is defined as the amount of energy delivered asphalt are trapped in the dermis.
per unit area. Fluence should be sufficient to produce
immediate whitening with tattoo treatment without
bleeding or blistering. The fluence emitted with a ALTERNATIVE THERAPIES
given spot size is dependent on the device used.
Adequately powered tattoo laser devices can main- The following alternatives to Q-switched laser tattoo
tain high fluences (e.g., more than 4.5 J/cm2) with removal methods are not recommended:
large spot sizes (e.g., 6 mm).
• Dermabrasion (not to be confused with
microdermabrasion)
PATIENT AND TATTOO SELECTION • Salabrasion
• Cryotherapy (liquid nitrogen)
Lasers may be used for tattoo removal in patients of all • Continuous-wave lasers
skin types (Fitzpatrick types I through VI). However, • Chemical acids
patients with darker skin types (IV through VI) are at • Thermal injury (electrocautery).
greater risk for side effects, specifically hypopigmenta-
tion and hyperpigmentation. Topical hydroquinone The results of using these alternative modalities are
(2% to 8%) can be used preprocedure, and resumed often unsatisfactory to both patients and health care
once the skin is healed postprocedure, to reduce professionals. These techniques significantly increase
the risk of postinflammatory hyperpigmentation in the risk of adverse effects including scarring, hypo­
patients with darker skin types. Additionally, patients pigmentation, hyperpigmentation, depigmentation,
of Asian or African descent have a greater predisposi- incomplete resolution of ink, pain, prolonged healing
tion to hypertrophic and keloidal scarring. In general, time, infection, textural changes, and unpredictable
369
30 SECTION THREE  •  Cosmetic Procedures

outcomes. The advantage of these techniques is that • Provides the best cosmetic result when compared to
they are relatively inexpensive and may offer faster ink other forms of tattoo removal.
resolution when compared to laser tattoo removal
treatments. Some providers use surgical excision as a
method of tattoo removal. DISADVANTAGES OF LASER
TATTOO REMOVAL
• Expensive.
PRODUCTS CURRENTLY AVAILABLE • Painful.
• Multiple treatments are required.
Q-switched lasers are now widely regarded as the gold • The procedure has risks of hyperpigmentation,
standard for laser tattoo removal. Current Q-switched hypopigmentation, depigmentation, and textural
lasers available include: changes.

• Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm)


• Frequency doubled (532 nm) EQUIPMENT
• Dye modules (650 nm and 585 nm)
• Q-switched alexandrite laser (755 nm) • Q-Switched laser device
• Q-switched ruby laser (694 nm). • Topical anesthetic
• Tongue depressors to apply anesthetic
The Q-switched Nd:YAG (neodymium-doped yttrium • Gauze pads to remove anesthetic
aluminum garnet) produces a 1064 nm wavelength of • Sterile wipes or alcohol wipes to cleanse the treat-
light that is ideal for treating black ink. A primary dis- ment area
advantage is its limited efficacy in removing yellow and • Protective eyewear for patient and laser operator and
green inks. With some devices, through a process called any other personnel in the room
frequency doubling, an Nd:YAG laser can also produce • Appropriate door sign indicating laser usage
light with a wavelength of 532 nm to treat red, orange, • Ice packs
and yellow inks.20 The Nd:YAG laser has an advantage • Nonsterile gloves
of treating darker skinned patients with less risk of • Face shield for laser operator (optional)
hypopigmentation, hyperpigmentation, and textural • Masks for laser operator (optional).
changes.7 This can be attributed to the increased dermal
penetration of this longer wavelength and the lower Although relatively reliable, Q-switched lasers, like
melanin absorption. The wavelength of the light emitted any laser device, are made of sensitive components.
by the Q-switched alexandrite laser is 755 nm. This Q-switched lasers should not be transported from loca-
wavelength has excellent absorption by black, good tion to location and all measures should be taken to
absorption by green and blue, but poor absorption by move the device as little as possible. To ensure that
red ink. The ruby laser was one of the first Q-switched calibration and mirror alignment within the laser arm
lasers, and it emits a 694 nm wavelength. It works well are adequate, one can aim the laser on a wooden
for darker colors (black, blue-black, and some green), tongue depressor and observe the formation of concen-
but poorly on yellow and red ink. Although more effec- tric circles with a laser pulse. If this pattern does not
tive for green ink than the Nd:YAG, the ruby laser com- appear, the equipment is due for a calibration. When
monly causes hypopigmentation and hyperpigmen­tation not in use, the foot pedal should be properly stored and
and, although usually transient, may be permanent.5 the key removed. Always take care to not damage the
Recently, a number of lower cost, Q-switched devices laser arm.
have become available. Although considerably less Q-switched lasers can rupture blood vessels and
expensive, these units have little to no long-term track aerosolize tissue, so a laser operator may choose to use
records and are of unknown quality. Choosing a device a plastic shield or a cone device on the laser tip to
with a more established company is recommended. protect from tissue and blood contact as well as a face
shield and mask.

CONTRAINDICATIONS8
PROCEDURE PREPARATION
• Ink allergy.
Also see Chapter 26, Hair Reduction with Lasers, for addi- 1. Review the patient’s medical history to ensure there
tional laser contraindications. are no contraindications to treatment (see Contrain-
dication section). If there is a history of herpes simplex
in or near the treatment area, prophylactic antiviral
ADVANTAGES OF LASER medication is used 2 days prior and 3 days after the
TATTOO REMOVAL treatment. If the risk of herpes is low, antivirals may
instead be started on the day of treatment.
• Considered the “gold standard” for tattoo removal. 2. Review the tattoo history: amateur/professional/
• Individual treatments are relatively quick. cosmetic/traumatic, years present, flesh-colored or
370
30  •  Tattoo Removal with Lasers 30

specific colored areas with the wavelength appro-


priate for the color. For example, the fifth treat-
ment for a green tattoo with red and sky blue
ink would be as follows: 1064 nm to the whole
tattoo, followed by 650 nm to the whole tattoo,
532 nm to the red areas, and 585 nm to the sky
blue areas.
2. Start with larger spot sizes (e.g., 6 to 8 mm) for
initial treatments and progress to smaller spot sizes
(e.g., 4 mm) over the treatment series. Larger spots
penetrate deeper and are less aggressive with fewer
side effects.
3. The laser tip is moved smoothly in a painting motion
over the tattoo and is not in direct contact with the
skin.
4. Universal precautions should be used during and
FIGURE 30-5  Red tattoo ink dermatitis, prior to laser treatment. after the treatment due to possible tissue splatter and
(Courtesy of W. Kirby, MD.) bleeding.

Planning and Designing


white ink, “cover-up” tattoo, previous methods used Treatment of thinner skinned areas such as the neck,
for removal and scarring at the tattoo site. breast, and below the knees can result in adverse reac-
3. Determine the patient’s Fitzpatrick skin type (see tions, so conservative settings with lower fluences and
Chapter 19, Aesthetic Principles and Consultation). larger spot sizes are advised.
4. Perform a brief and focused physical examination For large tattoos covering an entire extremity, con-
to rule out ink allergy. Ink allergy presents with signs sider performing the dorsal area in one session and
of an allergic contact dermatitis (erythema, edema, volar area in a subsequent session to avoid circumfer-
induration, and discomfort in previously tattooed ential edema and a possible tourniqueting effect.
areas). A severe red ink dermatitis is shown in “Cover-up” tattoos, in which a second tattoo has
Figure 30-5. Examine the tattoo carefully for areas been placed on top of the initial tattoo, have a greater
of scarring; document if present and inform the density of ink and should be treated with very low flu-
patient. ences initially to reduce the risk of overtreatment.
5. Photograph the tattoo.
Anesthesia
Tattoo treatments are painful but can be performed
LASER TATTOO REMOVAL: STEPS relatively quickly. Some patients may forgo anesthesia
AND PRINCIPLES altogether, but many patients require some form of
local anesthesia. A topical anesthetic cream such as
The following guidelines are based on treatment of benzocaine:lidocaine:tetracaine (see the Resources list at
artistic tattoos using a Q-switched laser (HOYA ConBio the end of the chapter) may be used under occlusion
RevLite), which is indicated for all Fitzpatrick skin types with plastic wrap for 30 minutes in the office prior to
(I through VI). Manufacturer guidelines specific to the laser treatment. If complete anesthesia is desired,
the device used should be followed at the time of injections of 1% or 2% lidocaine with epinephrine sub-
treatment. dermally may be used. Local injection is discouraged by
the authors because clinical experience has shown
increased bleeding and edema at the time of treatment,
General Treatment Technique rendering treatments less effective.
1. The appropriate wavelength is selected for the tattoo
ink color to be treated. Colored inks are often a Performing the Procedure
mixture of different colors and it is safest to use a
1064 nm wavelength for initial treatments of multi- 1. Remove any reflective jewelry that may scatter
colored tattoos. laser light.
• Treatment 1: Use a 1064 nm wavelength regardless 2. Apply topical anesthetic (such as benzocaine:lidoca­
of the color of the tattoo. ine:tetracaine) in the office and remove after 30
• Treatments 2 through 4: Use a 1064 nm wavelength minutes of contact time.
for multicolored tattoos in the dark areas (black, TIP: Patients will experience discomfort in spite of
blue, purple, green), and a 532 nm wavelength analgesic measures used, and reminding patients
for red-colored ink areas. to breathe during treatments will assist with pain
• Treatments 5 and greater: Treat the whole tattoo management. Squeezing the treated area is also
with a 1064 nm wavelength first and then treat a useful distraction technique.
371
30 SECTION THREE  •  Cosmetic Procedures

3. Position the patient on the treatment table in a 15. The initial treatment session may be performed
comfortable position allowing for exposure of the with conservative settings and minimal endpoints
tattoo. to determine how a patient will respond, particu-
4. Cleanse the treatment area with a sterile wipe or larly with darker skin types and very dark tattoos.
alcohol and allow to dry. 16. At subsequent visits the tattoo ink will lighten and
5. Provide wavelength-specific protective eyewear to the fluence should be increased or spot size reduced
all people in the room. If working on the face, for more aggressive treatments to achieve desired
provide the patient with lead extraocular goggles. endpoints. Typically, the fluence is increased first,
6. The laser operator should be positioned comfort- based on the manufacturer’s recommended treat-
ably, often sitting, as opposed to leaning over the ment parameters. After maximizing the fluence
patient. This will allow for comfortable manipula- over several visits, the spot size is then decreased
tion of the headpiece while depressing the foot with an associated reduction in fluence.
pedal that is used with most laser systems. TIP: A test spot should be performed at each visit
7. The wheels on the device should be placed in the prior to initiating treatment to determine the
locked position to ensure that the unit does not roll appropriate settings.
during treatment. CAUTION: Watch for vasovagal signs of light-
8. Select the appropriate wavelength for the tattoo headedness, perspiration, and fatigue and discon-
color (see the General Treatment Technique section tinue treatment if these occur.
earlier in this chapter).
9. Select the appropriate spot size based on the
patient’s Fitzpatrick skin type using the manufac- RESULTS
turer’s guidelines. In general, for initial treatments,
larger spot sizes (e.g., 8 mm) should be selected Immediately after a Q-switched laser treatment, the
for darker Fitzpatrick skin types (V and VI) and tattoo will have a white discoloration. Figure 30-6
smaller spot sizes (6 mm) for lighter skin types (I shows a blue-black tattoo during treatment with imme-
through III). diate whitening. This white color change is thought
10. Confirm again that everyone in the room is wearing to be the result of rapid, heat-formed steam, causing
appropriate eyewear at all times and all doors are dermal and epidermal vacuolization. Patients may per-
fully closed. ceive this as reduction of ink, but this positive change
11. Hold the handpiece at a 90-degree angle to the is only temporary and typically lasts for 20 minutes or
skin. less. Ink color will gradually fade during the month fol-
12. Instruct the patient not to move if he or she experi- lowing each treatment. Results from laser treatments
ences discomfort and, to inform you if a short rest for removal of tattoo ink are cumulative and results
is needed during the treatment. from some treatments will be more noticeable than
13. Perform a test spot on the darkest area of the tattoo others.
using the 1064 nm wavelength (regardless of the Figure 30-7 shows a blue-black professional tattoo
tattoo ink color) and observe for clinical endpoints. (A) before and (B) after five treatments with a
The amount of ink present is highly variable and Q-switched laser using 1064 nm wavelength (HOYA
settings will be determined by the tissue response ConBio Medlite) demonstrating typical tattoo clear-
to the test spot performed. Desirable clinical end- ance. Figure 30-8 shows a multicolor professional tattoo
points include: (A) before, (B) midway through treatment with light-
• Whitening of the tattoo ink. Figure 30-6 shows ening of the black ink and hypopigmentation, and (C)
whitening of a black ink tattoo using a 1064 nm after completion of treatment with a Q-switched laser
Q-switched laser (HOYA ConBio RevLite).
• Audible and palpable snapping felt during laser
pulses due to photoacoustic vibration.
• Edema.
• Petechiae are desirable endpoints and indicate
aggressive settings. This is more commonly seen
with shorter wavelengths, such as 532 nm.
TIP: If the tattoo ink appears yellowish or brown
immediately after the laser pulse, increase the
fluence to obtain a white spot.
TIP: Dark tattoos with high concentrations of ink
will require lower starting fluences and larger
spot sizes than lighter faded tattoos.
14. Pinpoint bleeding results from vascular injury and
represents an overly aggressive treatment. The
fluence should be reduced if this occurs. Some of
the newer tattoo laser technologies available have FIGURE 30-6  Laser tattoo removal treatment showing immediate
modified beam profiles, which have reduced the clinical endpoint of whitening. (Copyright Rebecca Small, MD, using
occurrence of pinpoint bleeding. HOYA ConBio RevLite™.)

372
30  •  Tattoo Removal with Lasers 30

A B
FIGURE 30-7  A blue-black professional tattoo (A) prior to and (B) after completion of five treatments with a Q-switched laser using a 1064 nm
wavelength. (Courtesy of W. Kirby, MD, using HOYA ConBio Medlite™.)

using 1064, 532, and 585 nm wavelengths for black/ and for 15 minutes every 1 to 2 hours on the day of
blue, red/yellow, and sky blue inks, respectively (HOYA treatment to reduce the risk of blistering.
ConBio Medlite). If the treated skin is fully intact and in an area that
Occasionally colored inks may darken with treat- will not be abraded, a broad-spectrum sunscreen (con-
ment due to darker constituent inks. Figure 30-9A taining zinc or titanium) with an SPF of 30 or greater
shows a red ink tattoo prior to treatment. This tattoo can be applied without a dressing. If the skin is not
was initially treated with a Q-switched laser using a intact, an occlusive ointment, like Aquaphor, should be
1064 nm wavelength (Medlite, Hoya ConBio) and the applied and loosely covered with a nonadherent dress-
tattoo ink darkened and became black in color (Figure ing and tape that is changed once daily, for moist wound
30-9B). Subsequent treatments were performed using healing. Care should be taken not to macerate the
a 1064 nm wavelength for black and a 532 nm wave- treated area with excessive occlusion. Once the skin is
length for red ink areas. intact, a daily broad-spectrum sunscreen should be
applied for the duration of the tattoo removal
treatments.
AFTERCARE A crust may appear over the treated area that sloughs
off at approximately 14 days post-treatment. The treated
Laser tattoo removal treatment normally results in tem- skin appears slightly shiny until the area has fully
porary swelling, redness, and tenderness of the treated healed. Crusts or blisters should not be removed and
area, which may take a few hours to resolve. Ice is patients cautioned against picking, which increases the
applied immediately after treatment for patient comfort risk of scarring. Mild pruritus is part of the healing

A B C
FIGURE 30-8  A multicolor professional tattoo (A) before, (B) midway through treatment with lightening of the black ink and mild hypopigmen-
tation, and (C) after completion of treatment showing resolution of hypopigmentation with a Q-switched laser using 1064, 532, and 585 nm
wavelengths for black/blue, red/yellow, and sky blue inks, respectively. (Courtesy of R. Anderson, MD, and S. Kilmer, MD, using HOYA ConBio
Medlite™.)

373
30 SECTION THREE  •  Cosmetic Procedures

A B
FIGURE 30-9  Red tattoo ink (A) prior to and (B) after treatment with a Q-switched laser using a 1064 nm wavelength demonstrating paradoxical
darkening. (Courtesy of W. Kirby, MD, using HOYA ConBio Medlite™.)

process and is common during the first few weeks fol- changes in the normal skin pigmentation (hyperpigmen-
lowing treatment. tation or hypopigmentation).5,9 These changes usually
Strenuous exercise and exposure to water should be resolve in 6 to 12 months but rarely may be perma-
avoided until the skin is intact. Elevation of treated nent.7,10 The risk of hyperpigmentation and hypopig-
extremities can reduce edema. mentation is greatest with skin types IV, V, and VI,
regardless of the wavelength used. Areas that blister
and bleed are more likely to have pigmentary and
FOLLOW-UP textural changes.11 Twice daily treatment with hydro-
quinone and broad-spectrum sunscreens on fully healed
A 6 to 8 week interval between treatments is necessary skin usually resolve hyperpigmentation within a few
to allow the skin to heal completely. This interval may months, although in some patients resolution can be
be extended without any reduction in efficacy and, in prolonged. Shorter wavelengths, such as 532 nm, are
fact, treated tattoo ink may continue to fade slightly more commonly associated with blistering and hypopig-
over time. The tattoo is appropriate for retreatment mentation than longer wavelengths.
once the skin is fully intact, without a crust and the Transient textural changes are common and typically
shiny appearance to the skin has resolved. Patients resolve within a few months; however, permanent tex-
often request more frequent treatment sessions as they tural changes and scarring can occur.10 If a patient is
are usually highly motivated to remove their tattoos. prone to pigmentary or textural changes, longer treat-
However, treating too frequently, such as every 4 weeks, ment intervals are recommended. Additionally, patients
may increase the chances of textural changes, scarring, with a history of hypertrophic scarring need to be
and hypopigmentation. warned of their increased risk of scarring.
Local allergic responses to tattoo pigments have been
reported at the time of tattoo placement, and allergic
COMPLICATIONS reactions to tattoo pigment can also occur after
Q-switched laser treatment.13–18 For example, photoal-
• Hyperpigmentation lergic reactions have been reported to yellow cadmium
• Hypopigmentation/depigmentation sulfide, a pigment commonly added to tattoos to bright­
• Blistering ­en red or yellow inks. This reaction is also reported with
• Bleeding red ink, which may contain cinnabar (mercuric sulfide),
• Textural changes green (chromium), and blue (cobalt).21,22 Erythema,
• Scarring (including hypertrophic and keloids) pruritus, and even inflamed nodules, verrucose papules,
• Prolonged healing or granulomas may occur. The reaction is confined to
• Infection (e.g., herpes simplex, varicella zoster) the site of the red/yellow ink. Treatment consists of
• Paradoxical tattoo darkening (flesh-colored ink or strict sunlight avoidance, use of sunscreen, intralesional
permanent makeup) steroid injections, or in some cases, surgical removal.22
• Allergic reactions with local dermatitis/nodules or Q-switched lasers mobilize the ink through the lym-
systemic allergic response (rare). phatic system and systemic allergic responses are
extremely rare complications. Oral antihistamines and
A fine line exists between expected side effects and anti-inflammatory steroids may also be used to treat
true complications from laser tattoo removal treat- allergic reactions to tattoo ink.23
ments. For example, discomfort, swelling, blistering,
and itching are commonly associated with the treat-
ment8 but extreme pain, limb edema, bulla, and in­­ TREATING SPECIFIC LESIONS
tractable pruritus are rare and indicate treatment
complications. Caution should be used with cosmetic ink appearing
About half of the patients treated with Q-switched pink, flesh colored, or peach because these may
lasers for tattoo removal will show some transient contain iron oxide or titanium oxide pigments.25 These
374
30  •  Tattoo Removal with Lasers 30

pigments, when treated with a Q-switched laser, may equal to 9 in.2 may be $200; 10 to 25 in.2, $350; and
turn brown or black in a phenomenon known as para- 26 to 49 in.2, $500; with an additional $100 added for
doxical darkening.9 Although this brown or black color tattoos containing red, sky blue, or green.
usually responds well to continued treatment, it can be
disconcerting to patients as the effect of early treatment
will often leave the tattoo looking darker than it did CONCLUSION
prior to treatment. If tattoo darkening does occur, after
8 weeks, the newly darkened tattoo can be treated as Tattoo removal has advanced greatly in the past decade
if it were black pigment with 1064 nm. with the advent of highly selective Q-switched laser
One of the newest forms of tattoo ink is an iridescent technologies compared to early, nonspecific tattoo
pigment that is only observable under a black light. removal modalities that relied on thermal and mechani-
Patients refer to these tattoos as “glow-in-the-dark.” cal destruction. Through the process of selective photo-
These patients should not be treated because their ink thermolysis and photoacoustic vibration, Q-switched
contains no chromophore for selective absorption. lasers can specifically target inks of all different colors
Occasionally patients will present with tattoos that while minimizing damage to the surrounding tissues
are slightly raised. Prior to laser treatment, if a tattoo is and are now considered the gold standard for patients
palpable, it will still be palpable when the treatment seeking tattoo removal.
series is completed. It is important to remember that
Q-switched lasers only treat ectopic pigment and are
not intended to improve the texture of the skin. Resources
Traumatic tattoos resulting from asphalt or “road Tattoo Removal Lasers
rash” can be effectively treated with laser tattoo removal Alma Lasers
methods.24 Obtaining a proper history is imperative Phone: 866-414-2562
when treating any traumatic tattoo because case reports www.almalasers.com
of laser ignition from flammable debris have been
reported.12,26 Asclepion Laser Technologies
www.asclepion.com

LEARNING THE TECHNIQUES Cynosure


Phone: 800-866-2966
Practice by drawing an image on a large grapefruit or www.cynosure.com
orange using a black permanent marker. This will serve
as an excellent model for practitioners new to Q- HOYA ConBio
switched laser techniques. As comfort level increases, Phone: 800-532-1064
practitioners can experiment with other colors until www.conbio.com
they feel their skill level warrants treatment on a
patient. Light Age
Phone: 723-563-0600
www.light-age.com
CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS
Lumenis
A recent development is the advent of a specific type of Phone: 408-764-3000
tattoo ink called Infinitink™. The pigment in this ink is www.aesthetic.lumenis.com
stored in transparent, biocompatible capsules, which
according to the company that produces it (Freedom Syneron (formerly Candela)
2™), require fewer treatments with Q-switched lasers Phone: 800-821-2013
for removal. No studies confirming this claim are avail- www.candelalaser.com
able. Furthermore, because tattoos are meant to be
permanent, it is questionable whether or not the tattoo Topical Anesthetics
artist community will embrace the use of this ink. American Health Solutions Pharmacy
(benzocaine:lidocaine:tetracaine (20 : 6 : 4)
ointment)
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS Phone: 310-838-7422
www.AHSRx.com
Although tattooing of skin may be considered medically
necessary when performed as part of a therapeutic
intervention (e.g., radiation therapy, or with breast References
reconstruction), tattoo removal is considered cosmetic 1. Farmer S, Laumann A, Baranwal M. Epidemiology of tattooing
and is not reimbursed by insurance providers. Most and body piercing: National Data Set. J Am Acad Dermatol.
2005;52:104.
providers base their fee for tattoo removal on the size 2. Harris RB. Harris Poll. 2003;58.
of the tattoo and the presence or absence of multiple 3. Mariwalla K, Dover JS. The use of lasers for decorative tattoo
colors. For example, fees for black tattoos less than or removal. Skin Ther Lett. 2006;11:8–11.

375
30 SECTION THREE  •  Cosmetic Procedures

4. Kirby W, Desai A, Kartono F. Tattoo removal techniques: effective 15. Bagnato G, De Pasquale R, Glacobbe O, et al. Urticaria in a tat-
tattoo removal treatments—Part I. Skin and Aging. 2005; tooed patient. Allergol et Immunopathol. 1992;71:70–73.
9:50–54. 16. Winkelmann RK, Harris RB. Lichenoid delayed hypersensitivity
5. Kilmer SL, Lee MS, Grevelink JM, et al. The Q-switched Nd:YAG reactions in tattoos. J Cutan Pathol. 1979;6(1):59–65.
laser effectively treats tattoos. A controlled, dose-response study. 17. Bendsoe N, Hansson C, Sterner O. Inflammatory reactions from
Arch Dermatol. 1993;129(8):971–978. organic pigments in red tattoos. Acta Dermatol Venereol. 1991;
6. Kirby W, Desai A, Desai T, et al. The Kirby-Desai scale: A proposed 71(1):70–73.
scale to assess tattoo removal treatments. J Clin Aesthetic Dermatol. 18. Blumental G, Okun MR, Ponitch JA. Pseudolymphomatous reac-
2009;2(3):32–37. tion to tattoos. Report of three cases. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1982;6
7. Grevelink JM, Duke D, van Leeuwen RL, et al. Laser treatment (4 Pt 1):485–488.
of tattoos in darkly pigmented patients: efficacy and side effects. 19. Tazelaar DJ. Hypersensitivity to chromium in a light-blue tattoo.
J Am Acad Dermatol. 1996;34(4):653–656. Dermatologica. 1970;141(4):282–287.
8. Crawford K. Laser devices: tattoo removal. In: Pfenninger JL, 20. Kilmer SL, Anderson RR. Clinical use of the Q-switched ruby and
Fowler GC, eds. Pfenninger and Fowler’s Procedures for Primary Care. the Q-switched Nd:YAG (1064 nm and 532 nm) lasers for treat-
3rd ed. Philadelphia: Mosby/Elsevier; 2011. ment of tattoos. J Dermatol Surg Oncol. 1993;19(4):330–338.
9. Anderson RR, Geronemus RG, Kilmer SL, et al. Cosmetic tattoo 21. Bjornberg A. Allergic reactions to chrome in green tattoo mark-
ink darkening. A complication of Q-switched and pulsed-laser ings. Acta Dermatol Venereol. 1959;39(1):23–29.
treatment. Arch Dermatol. 1993;129:1010–1014. 22. Bjornberg A. Allergic reaction to cobalt in light-blue tattoo mark-
10. Ho WS, Ying SP, Chan PC, Chan HH. Use of onion extract, ings. Acta Dermatol Venereol. 1961;41:259.
heparin, allantoin gel in prevention of scarring in Chinese 23. Ashinoff R, Levine VJ, Soter NA. Allergic reactions to tattoo
patients having laser removal of tattoos: a prospective random- pigment after laser treatment. Dermatol Surg. 1995;21:291–
ized controlled trial. Dermatol Surg. 2006;32(7):891–896. 294.
11. Wenzel SM. Current concepts in laser tattoo removal. Skin 24. Agneta M. Effective treatment of traumatic tattoos with a
Therapy Lett. 2010:15(3):3-5. q-switched Nd:YAG laser. Lasers Surg Med. 1998;22:103–108.
12. Fusade T, Toubel G, Grognard C, et al. Treatment of gunpowder 25. Lee CN, Bae EY, Park JG, et al. Permanent makeup removal
traumatic tattoo by Q-switched Nd:YAG laser: an unusual adverse using Q-swiltched Nd:YAG laser. Clin Exp Dermatol. 2009;34(8):
effect. Dermatol Surg. 2000;26(11):1057–1059. e594–e596.
13. England R. Immediate cutaneous hypersensitivity after treatment 26. Taylor CR. Laser ignition of traumatically embedded firework
of tattoo with Nd:YAG laser: a case report and review of the lit- debris. Lasers Surg Med. 1998;22(3):157–158.
erature. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2002;89:215–217.
14. McFadden N, Lyberg T, Hensten-Pettersen A. Aluminum-induced Additional Reading
granulomas in a tattoo 31. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1989;20(5 Pt Small R. Tattoo removal. In: Small R, ed. A Practical Guide to Cosmetic
2):903–908. Lasers. Philadelphia: Lippincott; 2012.

376

You might also like