Professional Documents
Culture Documents
15
atrist per million population, and in a few countries there number of other countries, is largely run by nurses, this
is just one psychiatrist per 5 or 6 million. By comparison, results in the systematic availability of mental health
in the UK there is one adult psychiatrist per 50,000, and in expertise in primary care.
much of the former Soviet Union there is one psychiatrist What continuing training is available in primary care?
per 10-20,000. It is important that mental health policy pays appropriate
Taking severe disorders first, including the psychoses, attention to the continuing professional development of
in richer countries, people with severe mental illness may primary care nurses (33,34). In Zanzibar, the education
be cared for by specialist services, with some collaboration coordinators organise and deliver continuing training for
with primary care for long-term support. In poorer coun- all staff in primary health care units, which is regular (on
tries, on the other hand, there may often only be capacity several weekends a year), is accompanied by transport
for a small number of people with psychosis to be cared allowances and incentive payments, and affords an oppor-
for in specialist care, and most will need to be assessed, tunity for mental health to be included in the programme.
diagnosed and treated in primary care, with support from In low-income countries, it is important to give mental
specialist services where available. Thus in poor countries, health education to midwives and traditional birth atten-
where there is often much less than one psychiatrist per dants who have the opportunity to detect and refer post-
million population, most people with psychosis will need natal psychosis and severe depression. The physical, cog-
to be cared for much of the time in primary care. nitive and emotional development of children is influ-
Considering the common mental disorders second, we enced by parental mental health, and so ensuring prompt
know from epidemiological studies that there is a high treatment of maternal depression is one of the most
prevalence of mental disorders in the general population important preventive activities we can do.
and in primary care (3). Contrary to popular view, the In low-income countries where there are few medical
common disorders seen in the general population and in practitioners in primary or even in secondary care, nurses
primary care are not only frequent, but may also be severe, are likely to be given responsibility for prescribing and
disabling and of high duration (25-30). This high preva- managing medicines, and it is important that their basic
lence in all countries of the world means that not even training and continuing education programme support
rich countries can afford sufficient specialists to look after them in this role.
everyone with a mental disorder. What quality monitoring exists in primary care? In Iran,
Because of their high socio-economic costs, it is not health psychologists perform a quality monitoring role for
tenable to argue that the burden of common mental disor- the village health workers, and visit every month to sup-
ders should be ignored. These costs arise from the repeat- port, supervise and check on the quality of the work. Who
ed primary care consultations if they remain untreated, is in the front line? Are the primary care doctor and nurse
sickness absence, labour turnover, reduced productivity, in the front line for initial assessment or are there other
impact on families and children, and the difficult to quan- tiers? For example, health workers with a few months
tify but nonetheless important concept of the emotional training in Iran are responsible for 2000 population, and
well-being of a country and nation. Primary care, there- primary care doctors are in the second tier responsible for
fore, needs to play a central role in overall mental health 10,000 population. In Tanzania, first aid workers are
care in rich countries as well as in poor countries. responsible for 50 people, dispensaries for 2000 and pri-
Besides these logistical reasons why primary care is cru- mary health care units (nurses and medical assistants) for
cial, it also has particular advantages in that it allows 10,000 or more.
attention to physical health care needs and accompanying Systems for information collection in primary care are
social needs, it allows continuity of care, it is often pre- needed for adequate planning. This can be effective with-
ferred by consumers, it is often more accessible than spe- out involving expensive technology. For example, in Iran,
cialist care, and studies have shown that it is able to health workers routinely collect and display annual data
achieve good clinical and social outcomes. on prevalence and outcome of priority disorders: infec-
The importance of primary care for mental health has a tious diseases, epilepsy, schizophrenia, depression and
number of implications for the training of the primary care anxiety.
team. In developing policy on training, it is helpful to Policy should address how proactive primary care
understand the current situation in relation to the basic should be. Should it mostly concentrate on active consul-
training for each tier of primary care and for each of the ters or should it take a more population perspective and
professional cadres. How much mental health, if any, is seek to find and treat common disabling conditions?
included? For example, in Iran and Pakistan, the village Primary care capacity for outreach is important. Trans-
health workers receive a few months training in selected port is necessary for outreach from secondary care to pri-
priority topics so that they can screen, assess, diagnose mary care, and from primary care to the community. It
and treat (31,32). In Zanzibar, there is a four-year basic may need to be subsidised, be appropriate to the terrain
training for all nurses and the fourth year is devoted to and preferably not shared with other specialties with dif-
mental health. Since primary care in Zanzibar, as in a ferent working patterns.
17
tious diseases. Sometimes the sheer volume of refugees and needed. It is important to monitor research funding (43).
their movements make practical arrangements very diffi- Access to the Internet, the Cochrane Collaboration, and
cult. For example, in Macedonia during the Kosovo crisis, international journals are all essential if countries are to
there were over 250,000 refugees and large transfers at avail themselves of the international evidence base. There
short notice between camps as new refugees arrived, mak- is a pressing need for cost-effectiveness studies in low-
ing psychosocial work very difficult during the initial phase income countries (44).
(40). In Georgia, with a population of around 5 million,
and an economic crisis which has reduced government
POLITICAL WILL
health expenditure per capita from 200 USD to 7 USD per
year, there are more than a quarter of a million internally We need political will at national level, to support men-
displaced people with largely unmet needs for psychologi- tal health in public policy (including a high profile for
cal support, and a further 7,000 refugees from Chechenya mental health within the Ministry of Health, liaison with
for whom the government does not accept responsibility, other ministries and a cabinet committee for mental
so they have no access to medical care other than that sup- health as in Iran); political will at international level
plied by the Red Cross (41). The central importance of (including mental health on the agenda of key interna-
involving primary care teams in the management of the tional political meetings, e.g., the European Union Presi-
medium- and long-term psychological consequences of a dencies), debate in the international media and interna-
disaster has long been argued (42). tional cooperation (6).
19