You are on page 1of 14

t

os
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

rP
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
Introduction

yo
Five years after buying his first sewing machine, Scott Hunter was telling friends about his
conversation with Yvon Chouinard, the legendary rock climber and environmental advocate who
founded the global apparel and equipment brand Patagonia. Years before—while a student in the
MBA program at Babson College—he had sought to interview Chouinard for a paper he had to
write, but was unable to connect. After graduation, Hunter began work on designs for backpacks
to be sold under his newly launched brand, Vedavoo. He worked with outside designers, and
struggled to identify an offshore factory to manufacture his bags. One of these in China looked
promising, but it ultimately rejected his project after Nike bought all unused capacity. In another
op
case, he shipped a prototype bag that had cost him thousands to another potential partner in
Vietnam, only to have the design stolen and the intermediaries he was expecting to do business
with disappear. After months of effort, Hunter found himself down to his last $700 with little to
show for the time and capital invested to that point.

By fate or divine guidance, Hunter received a very unexpected call:


tC

Mr. Chouinard’s assistant called me and said, “Yvon’s got 20 minutes this
afternoon. If you’ve got time, he would be happy to speak with you.” So I
jumped on it, and the conversation lasted about an hour. We swapped
stories about hiking and climbing in Wyoming before he asked, “Okay, tell
me about your business.” I told him what I was working on, and the
challenges I’d faced. He said, “If you can’t build something with your own
No

hands, you have no business being in business. You’ve got to learn what’s
involved in making it, how it goes together and why things are the way they
are so that you can figure out ways to build it better, easier, and more cost
effective. How can you expect others to make something for you if you don’t
even know what your designs will force them to do? Go buy a sewing
machine and learn to sew!”

Inspired by Chouinard’s advice, Hunter went straight to Craigslist and used $300 of his remaining
funds to purchase a used sail-making machine. He drove from his home west of Boston down to
Do

Providence, Rhode Island, to pick it up. He returned home, and following the time-honored,

This case was originally written by Martha Lanning, under the direction of Dr. Caroline Daniels at Babson
College in 2014. Dr. Daniels made substantive changes in 2019. It was developed as a basis for class
discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. It
is not intended to serve as an endorsement, source of primary data or illustration of effective or ineffective
management.

Copyright © 2018 Babson College and licensed for publication to Harvard Business Publishing. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication can be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by any means without prior
written permission of Babson College.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
classic American entrepreneur tradition, set up the machine in his garage. Filled with
determination, he used another $300 to purchase enough materials to make a few backpacks,
prepaid his website for the year to come, and began teaching himself to sew with a $12 safety net.
He explained his plans for the company, which he named “Vedavoo,” after an area in the Medicine
Bow Routt National Forest in Wyoming.1 Hunter noted, “I decided it’s going to be made in
America, and we’re going to use American-sourced goods. We’re going to build on-demand. We’re

rP
going to follow this path whether it’s custom goods or our core products” (see Exhibit 1).

Company Background
Scott Hunter grew up in Wyoming, spent much time outdoors hunting and fishing, and graduated
from the University of Wyoming in 2005. During his senior year, he was a finalist in a business
plan competition with his concept for Changing Leaf Designs,2 a startup that would make large

yo
modular backpacks for backpacking. Though he did not win the competition, the effort
established an entrepreneurial passion in his heart to be pursued in time.

Upon graduation, Hunter took a job in Wyoming as an Internet salesperson, ultimately moving
up within the company to a Project and Account Management position developing wireless
telecommunications systems for the oil business. Finding little personal value in this work,
Hunter left the business and returned to his initial plan to make backpacks. He applied to Babson
op
College, hoping to enroll and learn skills he would need as an entrepreneur launching a startup.
To his surprise, he gained acceptance to the one-year program and promptly moved to
Massachusetts.

In 2009, Hunter launched his backpack company while finishing his program at Babson. His plan
was still to make large, modular trekking packs. After facing many challenges, including bad
advice from respected experts and losing money in deals with unscrupulous offshore agents,
tC

Hunter reframed his business plan to focus on building smaller, simpler designs that would be
designed internally for domestic production. By 2014, Hunter had established and begun to grow
a successful enterprise fabricating fly fishing packs from his home base in Lancaster,
Massachusetts. He noted, “We just try to keep evolving and let the market dictate.”3

Sales revenue had not yet reached one million dollars, but product orders were growing and the
company had high expectations. Hunter summed it up, saying, “Coming back to my passions and
No

to the things I love has been incredible. Knowing we’re creating new jobs and new opportunities
in the state is unbelievably fulfilling for me.”
Do

1Vedauwoo was an area of distinctive rock outcrops in southeastern Wyoming, popular for rock climbing. Hunter
changed this word slightly for the name of his company.

2 Pingora Peak was a prominent granite tower in the Cirque of the Towers in the Wind River Range in Wyoming.
Hunter chose the name of this peak for his company.
3 Scott won the Babson BETA contest ($20,000) in 2014. One of the judges described one of the reasons Vedavoo

won; they knew he would stretch every penny as far as it would go. Scott’s answers to the Competition Judge’s
questions illustrated that Scott was one of the most resourceful entrepreneurs he had ever seen.
2

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
The Entrepreneurial Process
Generating the Idea: Outdoor Life Shapes the Entrepreneurial Vision

rP
During his early years in Wyoming, Scott Hunter hiked, fished, and camped in the mountains and
rivers of his home state. He was active in Boy Scouts of America and in their service branch, the
Order of the Arrow,4 building trails and portages and other conservation projects. He was elected
state president, then five-state regional president, then the National Vice-Chief in 2001. He taught
leadership skill development and advocated conservation-minded outdoor programs from this
platform.

yo
Heading off to the University of Wyoming, Hunter planned to study aeronautical engineering. He
commented, “Frankly, after one semester, I realized it was completely wrong for me. I’m a people
person. I couldn’t sit behind a desk with a calculator all day and just crunch numbers. I needed to
get out and talk to folks and be me.” He enrolled in the College of Business, and studied Business
Administration.

In his senior year, Hunter pursued and was granted special clearance to substitute the traditional
op
capstone thesis with a business plan to be entered in the Wyoming $10K entrepreneurship
competition during the academic year 2004–2005. Previously during a summer internship in
Washington, D.C., he had worked for Senator Mike Enzi from Wyoming. While in Washington,
Hunter frequently heard people talk about the decline of American manufacturing and
outsourcing. His concern grew, and he resolved not to outsource.

I knew I needed to write a business plan, so I tried to pick something I had


tC

a lot of passion for, something I loved. I decided that starting a bag and
pack business with everything made in the USA could be the way to go. At
the time, a lot of things were going overseas. I saw manufacturing jobs
leaving, and you couldn’t buy a Made in the USA backpack anymore. That
really bothered me! I was selected a finalist with the first iteration of what
would become Vedavoo. I got to pitch to local angel investors, but was
graciously told I was far from ready. So I went back to finish my
No

undergraduate study and to look for a real job to gain some experience
before I took it forward again.

Transition from Desk Job to Entrepreneur


Hunter turned down a marketing job in Washington, D.C. and took a job near Lander, Wyoming,
as an Internet salesperson. He said, “It wasn’t the most glamorous opportunity, but I wanted to
be close to the outdoors, to stay close to what I loved.” He moved up the ranks quickly and was
transferred to a sister company in wireless telecommunications system consulting and design for
Do

oil fields. As director of business development, he met with clients and worked on big-ticket
contracts, but knew he was not fulfilled, noting, “It was a big jump in a short time, and it was very
good work. But at the end of the day, I was killing myself for very little personal value.”

4The Order of the Arrow (OA) was the honor society of Boy Scouts of America. Among other goals, OA promoted
responsible use of the outdoors, environmental stewardship, and service.
3

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
He decided to chase his dreams as an entrepreneur. His plan was to reframe his early idea to build
large trekking packs that could be converted to other uses such as a tent or a sleeping bag: “My
concern as a backpacker was that I would hike in with this huge pack that weighed a lot, but once
I got to camp it had no useful purpose.” Hunter arrived at Babson College, bringing with him his
concept for the backpack company, now named Pingora Pack Company.

rP
Outsourcing vs. Personal Values
Hunter used his time to prepare his company for launch while at Babson. Soon, he was forced to
change the name of the venture again after learning that another pack company had rights to the
name “Pingora.” He drew inspiration for a new name from another of his favorite areas in his
home state of Wyoming, the area known as Vedauwoo in the Medicine Bow Routt National Forest.
Hunter opted for an easier to pronounce and spell variation of the park’s name, choosing

yo
“Vedavoo” for the brand under which he would focus on building modular backpacking
equipment. Prospective financiers for his venture and advisers alike strongly encouraged him to
go overseas for manufacturing. Through a contact at Babson, Hunter identified a design studio in
California with the capability to convert his ideas into prototypes, and to further coordinate
material selection, sourcing, and fabrication in China. Hunter explained as follows:

They were a one-stop-shop. They could help me select materials for my bag.
They could do all the coordination and sourcing themselves, and then take
op
it to a factory in China. I wasn’t thrilled to give up on keeping production
domestic, but at that point it seemed more important to win the battle first,
then come back to the US with production later when we had the brand and
the resources to support the move.

Although it meant sacrificing his personal values at least temporarily, Hunter decided to proceed
tC

with the California design firm:

So I went to the designer with a patent pending technology for a modular


backpack, and spent hours trying to make it real. Everything was looking
up for the brand, and people were getting excited about our first products,
but the pack proved too complicated for him to build a sample or to attract
interest from capable factories overseas. There were too many things that
No

had to work together just right. There was a huge fear the pieces wouldn’t
operate the right way and that we would have a high waste ratio because of
the number of pieces that had to fit together perfectly. So factories pushed
us away, the designer was pushing us away, and we went back to the
drawing board. Looking back, this was a blessing in disguise. Even if it had
been produced, it would have retailed around $700 in a niche that really
only accounted for about 5% of the global pack market at that point.

Reframing the Strategy


Do

Looking for simple alternatives to bring to market after the abandonment of the modular trekking
pack, Hunter worked with the designer on three other options. The first was a bear bag he had
developed with a team of fellow students in Babson’s Product Design and Development class. This
bag was designed to be suspended from a tree, thus holding food and other “smellable” cooking
and camping items at a height above the reach of bears. The second was a shoulder sling with
removable storage pouch based on a concept he had envisioned while fly fishing. The third was a
4

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
new hiking backpack design with modular padding that gave users the ability to customize their
pack to better fit their bodies and comfort preferences. He pursued a provisional patent on this,
and worked again with the California designer to generate final designs and prototypes for each
of the products.

The California designer also worked in parallel for other notable brands such as Marmot,

rP
CamelBak, REI, and Eastern Mountain Sports and was therefore unable to complete work quickly
for Hunter. Turnaround for prototypes of the designs took several months to receive and cost
thousands of dollars. The single backpack prototype alone cost Hunter $5800 (see Exhibit 2).
Though each of the new options were much simpler in design, the California designer still
struggled to locate suitable manufacturing overseas. Potential factories viewed the projects as too
complex and the company too small to offer adequate return. After several months without
progress, Hunter and the design firm found the challenges too great and ended their relationship.
He noted,

yo
If I wanted to be a success, I had to reduce my dependence on outside
sources, and be able to do more myself. I needed to have the ability to work
directly with potential factories so that I could work through potential
hang-ups. I needed to be able to do my own sourcing. I went back to the
Outdoor Retailer show on a mission to find myself a factory.
op
Another New Beginning
In January 2010, now approaching a year into the business without serious revenue, without
sellable packs, without a factory, and without a designer, Hunter attended the Outdoor Retailer
Winter Market Show in Salt Lake City, Utah. Carrying the prototypes of the modular padding
backpack and bear bag, he spoke with several potential partners before coming to an agreement
tC

with a group from South Korea that managed a pack factory in Vietnam. This factory was known
for work they did for Mont-Bell, another notable, premium brand. Through a translator, they
agreed Hunter would send the only existing sample of his modular padding backpack, and using
this, they would develop a line of three sizes of backpacks built to use the same customizable
padding technology that was in the prototype. Hunter shipped the pack and never heard from the
company again. He related the saga:
No

I tried to fight it for a little while, but it became clear that the South Korean
company was just an intermediary. They had sold themselves as the owner
of the factory when in reality they were just a contractor using the factory’s
resources. At some level, the design got stolen. So picture this: I had put in
a year, spent an exorbitant amount of money, and had nothing to show for
it! I didn’t even have the backpack anymore to be able to try and figure out
how to rebuild it!

In March 2010, having spent so much of his capital in the efforts to that point, Hunter reached a
Do

point when he had only $700 left in the company account. After the struggles to that point, he was
faced with giving up on his dream, or finding a way to keep it alive. He remembered his early
conversations with others who had followed similar paths, like Wayne Gregory (the founder of
Gregory Packs), and drew heavily on his conversation with Yvon Chouinard. Each in their own
way had encouraged him to follow a similar path: “Learn to sew!” He also returned to his early
goal of producing all of his products in the US. Taking the advice and his values to heart, he bought
a used industrial sewing machine off Craigslist for $300, bought $300 worth of materials, and

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
prepaid his website for another year. With a $12 safety net and limited revenue from the sale of
Vedavoo t-shirts, Hunter went to his garage and taught himself how to sew.

Using old daypacks and duffel bags from Goodwill and garage sales, Hunter studied how packs
and bags were made. He cut them apart, made patterns out of brown paper grocery bags, and tried
to recreate them using his own fabrics. He learned to understand how curves worked to create

rP
depth. He learned how square cutouts could be used to make corners. He learned the importance
of sewing consistently strait lines, and just how difficult it was to make them.

Though Hunter struggled with reproducing existing products, he had to be able to do much more
than copy other products for Vedavoo to succeed. He wanted to learn how to design products
himself so that he could use the machine to turn his ideas into realities without outside help.
Joining several pieces of two-dimensional fabric into a single three-dimensional shape was a
significant challenge that outweighed the sewing itself. When weeks of practice gave him a

yo
reasonable grasp on this, he then taught himself how to refine those shapes so that they would
each fit together perfectly. He reflected:

Those days were so hard. I had no money. I had no experience building


gear. All I had was my dream, my passion, and a commitment to keep the
company alive. Having never sewn before, my early products were as could
be expected—but they laid a foundation that I use still today.
op
His greatest challenge at this stage, however, was finding a niche with genuine opportunity for an
American Made bag company to succeed, and developing products that would deliver real value
for customers there. He reflected:
tC

After we struggled to find traction in backpacking, I wasn’t sure where to


turn next. I knew I still wanted to keep the venture in the outdoor industry,
but it was tough to narrow down to a niche I could work in. Vedauwoo—the
inspiration for the company’s name—is known for many types of outdoor
adventure, but more than anything, it’s known for rock climbing. So I was
getting all kinds of interest from rock climbers through social media. I
decided to follow the energy there and to focus my efforts on building rope
bags, duffels, chalk bags, and simple backpacks for climbers to carry their
No

gear in. I knew little about the sport, but they gave me great ideas and the
energy they brought in support of our new brand convinced me.

Through this process, Hunter learned the ins and outs of how to build gear: how to pattern, how
to build, how to prototype, and how to put things together, saying, “I learned how to do all that,
and instead of paying $5,800 for a single pack, now I had my own patterns, the ability to make
my own prototypes, and for the first time, I had products that were truly my own designs.”
Do

Serendipity Strikes
Armed with a line of packs and bags for rock climbers, Hunter raised new capital and in the
summer of 2011 went a second time to the Outdoor Retailer Trade Show. This time he had his own
booth. However, a few problems became apparent:

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
They put me on the back wall in a corner from hell because I was a first-
timer. There was no light above the booth. I got my stuff set up, and the few
people who actually made it back that far started saying, “If I can buy a
similar pack made in China for $40, why would I pay $80 for yours?”
American Made wasn’t enough to justify the difference for a sport where
the bulk of the money is spent on things that keep climbers from falling. To

rP
put it mildly, I was feeling like a complete failure. As I neared the end of the
show, I had no sales, no serious interest, and was ready to give up and move
on. But late on the last day, a gentleman came by the booth with a
wheelchair. He had his video camera mounted to it so it worked like a
rolling tripod. Though he was definitely soliciting me to pay him for other
videos later, he offered to do the first video for free, and I said, “Sure.” At
that point, I had nothing left to lose. Much to my surprise, he scanned the
packs on display and kept walking. He pointed at the back of the booth,

yo
where a sling pack I had built for myself to use fly fishing after the show
was hanging. He said, “I want to do the video on that!” I didn’t even have it
named until he asked me what it was called while filming.

Another Surprise Phone Call


A week after the show, Hunter received a phone call from a person who ran the International Fly
op
Tackle Dealer (IFTD) Show.5 He told Hunter, “We have the show next week in New Orleans, and
I want you to be there. I saw this video online, and I’m really impressed. I think you’d be perfect
for this market. We need new guys and new blood in the industry, and I think you’d be fantastic!”
Hunter had spent nearly all his money on his Outdoor Retailer booth and said he could not afford
to attend. The Fly Tackle Show manager offered Hunter a booth for free, adding, “Just don’t tell
anybody.”
tC

Hunter grabbed one of his climbing designs, altered it slightly to work as a fly fishing daypack,
developed a simple lanyard, grabbed his personal sling pack, and went to New Orleans. He
thought, “We’ll see what happens.” To his immense surprise, the gear was a hit. “People loved
what we were doing. They loved the ideas and the new brand. Our designs were different. Plus,
we found that fly fishermen had a lot more money to spend than climbers did!”
No

Hunter learned that this market, unlike rock climbing, was not composed of college students with
no money. Instead it was 35- to 40-year olds and up with discretionary income to spend. Hunter
thought back to his conversation with Yvon Chouinard and how he had mentioned among other
plans that he considered building packs for fly fishing. Chouinard had told him not to touch it,
that fly fishing was a “dying market.” The show clearly proved otherwise. In fact, Hunter saw that
fly fishing was changing. It was no longer solely for men older than 35. A new market segment
was emerging that was younger, passionate, and interested in having gear that was different and
designed better and more durably than the gear their fathers and grandfathers used. Stores and
media professionals quickly took note, and Hunter got his first legitimate orders.
Do

Hunter identified a factory in Pennsylvania and placed preliminary orders with them to build the
fly fishing products that had enjoyed success at the trade show: the sling pack, the chest pack, and
the day pack. Two days before the order was scheduled to ship, Hunter telephoned the factory to

5 The International Fly Tackle Dealer Show was the largest gathering in the world for fly fishing manufacturers,
retailers, sales reps, media, and industry organizations. The yearly shows featured people, products, emerging trends,
innovations, leading brands, seminars, and more for the fly fishing industry.
7

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
confirm billing details and learned they had not yet begun production. Hunter exclaimed, “So here
I am again: I’ve had my first real glimmer of success, then the factory I was counting on so
desperately completely dropped the ball! I fired my factory, called all of my first customers, told
them what was happening, and told them my plans to bring everything back in-house.” Hunter
reflected:

rP
It was so tough in 2012 because every pack shipped I had built myself. But
it was truly a blessing in disguise. I was a one-man show, so I built only
what actually sold because I didn’t have time to build up an inventory. It
took me probably five times what it should have, but I made sure that I built
it right so that it would last. And at least I was building it myself! I didn’t
have that cost, and I wasn’t depending on an outside source. I was able to
build on demand and keep moving forward. This established the baseline
for the business model we have now, giving us the opportunity to build on

yo
demand with only minimal inventory. We get paid up front for sales, build
to order, and stay nimble and cash efficient with everything we do!

Strategy Decisions
In early 2016 as Hunter looked back on the five years since he had bought his sewing machine, he
op
reviewed how Vedavoo had progressed and recognized two things: he was building packs, which
had been his initial dream; and he was sourcing everything he could in the United States, in line
with his personal values. There had been many challenges along the way, well more than many
would deem worth fighting through, but also a few lucky breaks that no one could have planned.

Key strategy decisions had sometimes evolved organically without deliberate planning. They had
allowed the business to stay true to its original focus, and also to scrape through when the going
tC

got tough:

1. Product focus: Abandoned backpacking and rock climbing in favor of a central focus on
fly fishing. Re-launched in 2012 with two products that sold immediately: a chest pack and
a sling pack. Followed with a Daypack, and several simple storage solutions that also saw
quick success. Continues to keep line simple, but innovates regularly to keep the line fresh
while developing new solutions for greater market share (see Exhibit 4 and Exhibit 5).
No

2. Pricing: Looked at other packs on the market and set Vedavoo prices only slightly higher,
typically around $10 more, to suggest greater value but not so far removed from
competitors that higher numbers seemed unreasonable. “The pricing worked, and we’ve
been able to increase our price more on some things. People continued to buy, and sales
actually went up when we increased the price. It’s a shame that I underpriced a bit upfront,
but without knowing clearly what my costs were, I just did my best. As we’ve grown, we’ve
learned new tricks that help us be more efficient with our most expensive input—labor
hours—and we’ve found ways to make new products easy to build and standing products
Do

easier to build so we can be more profitable.”

3. Quality control: Built everything “to perfection” to assure no returns and to protect brand
reputation.

4. Customization: Decided early on to offer customization. Customers asking for specific


features gave Hunter new ideas for product improvement and development, noting, “We
8

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
were able to make continuous iterations, compared to a company with a lot of inventory
made overseas that they are stuck with for a year.”

5. American sourcing: “If I was going to hang the flag, it had to represent the entire picture.”
Initially all packs were built in Massachusetts. Later, Hunter added other work-from-
home sewers from around New England and as far South as Maryland. Further, he used

rP
American-made inputs wherever possible. Heavy duty, 1,000 denier military grade
Cordura nylon that was “more than double the thickness and density of the best pack cloth
on the market” improved durability, and 500 denier cordura was used for linings. Buckles,
zippers, Velcro, webbing, and even the sewing thread used to make the products came
from US manufacturers. Non-fabric products were also US-made, for example bottles
from the Pacific Northwest, and apparel produced in Southern California.

yo
Future Growth
Hunter discussed how Vedavoo was positioned to grow:

We have grown no less than 83% per year since 2012, at least doubling in
every other year. More business comes with added costs and greater need
for a strong team. Could we grow faster if we went out and got a big angel?
op
Probably. Do we want to grow faster? Not really. Organic growth has been
excellent, and is letting our team develop and grow in a positive way
together as we take on more work.

My expectation was to come to Babson for the one-year program, graduate,


and move back. I expected to launch the business out west, use Wyoming-
based manufacturing, and work with folks I already had contact with from
tC

the local business council. But we made the decision to stay in


Massachusetts and have built a community around ourselves. It was
definitely not the ideal location for a new outdoor brand, but it’s been
perfect for American craft manufacturing, and I’ve found other people here
that have helped make the dream a reality.

New England has this strong manufacturing mindset, and people and
No

facilities here were part of that culture. It has been a good place to develop
our business. Things may have gone downhill when all the factories closed,
but the people who sewed here remain. We’ve been fortunate enough to
gain staff from factories long since outsourced, and they already know the
craft when they sit down to sew their first sling. We have stay-at-home
mom’s and grandmothers, single ladies, and college kids. It’s been
awesome. The best example is a stay-at-home mother of three that lives in
the same town I do, and we met at a local festival. Her husband came
through and said, “Hey, I want that pack!” and she followed with “I can sew
Do

that.” So I asked her on the spot if she wanted an interview. She’s become
my right-hand in the business and works as our production team manager
now.

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
Cash remained a challenge, however, and Vedavoo was covering bills with incoming revenue.
Capacity to build for large orders had begun to loom as a growth concern:

Every day we are challenged by new orders and less time to build them. As
strong as our team is, it wasn’t built overnight. Finding skilled and talented
professionals is difficult and takes time. Our greatest risk is growing too

rP
fast, but we’ve been slowly planning for the storm since 2014.

Hunter began a program to develop and grow as the business grows. His “workshop team” handles
day-to-day manufacturing on an at-will basis. Historically, this team did it all. With significant
growth and the increase in partner and retail orders, it became clear that a quick spike in ordering
could quickly overwhelm this team. He linked with a manufacturing facility in western
Massachusetts late in 2014, and has continued to work with the factory on large-scale projects
since that time. The factory had run successfully for many years but was forced to close when the

yo
outsourcing movement began. Hunter appreciated New England’s rich manufacturing history
that extended from the 19th through the 20th century.

Vedavoo now focused on fly fishing products. Seasonality and geographic region were important
to this market. Hunter noted that certain times of year were busier than others:

Our biggest season starts at Thanksgiving and goes through Easter. That’s
op
by far our heart and soul. Christmas buying season is followed immediately
by consumer show season. In 2014, we did ten of these events, and they
were a huge success. That year we surpassed 2013 net before we got to the
end of the first quarter. Our slowdown happens thereafter through mid-
summer. We have used this time to build for cobranded projects, new
orders for retailers, and some inventory for the holiday to come. Every
tC

minute sewing is a minute making money—and we try to keep everyone


running smooth and even all year, buffering the seasonality. By the time we
hit fall, people start ramping up again leading into Thanksgiving.

Customer interest in Vedavoo had begun in New England and the Northern Rocky Mountains
where fresh water fishing was practiced; then strong sales developed in the Southeast. Hunter
said about 75% to 80% of customers were male, parallel to industry participation: “People going
No

out for saltwater fishing have also picked up our stuff. They’ve been very happy with it, so a lot of
new potential, and recently expansion into international markets as well.” Discussing
competition, Hunter named standby industry leaders like Orvis6 and Fishpond,7 but he tries to
focus on his work so that he always competes with himself. Hunter often invited potential
customers at trade shows to try on a competitor’s pack, then come back and try on a Vedavoo
pack. At the beginning, Hunter thought Made in the USA would be the primary driver of sales,
but he learned gear functionality was the real key to winning a customer:
Do

6 The Orvis Company, worldwide leader in fly fishing, was founded in Vermont in 1856. Orvis was America’s oldest
mail order outfitter and longest-operating fly fishing business. In 2014, Orvis was a multi-national company with
1,700 employees and $350 million in sales (2012).
7 Fishpond was a small enterprise based in Colorado and focused on the fishing industry.

10

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
In our case, the weight stays put on your back better because of the way our
pack is shaped. You can lean over and the pack still stays put, whereas with
the others, the pack flips to the front and gets in your way, or slides down
your back. We also designed the pack to keep your front clean and free, with
the pack riding flush on your back until you need it.

rP
On the future of the industry, Hunter believed Vedavoo held a good place:

Fly Fishing was probably considered “a dying industry” because the active
angler was getting older, and products homogenized. When we entered the
industry, you could look at two sling packs from different companies; they
look very similar, all built by Asian factories. They were feature rich but
overso. These companies lost sight of the critical piece, which was how it
felt, carried, and functioned once the user was there. Conditions were ripe

yo
for new entrants—and this coupled with a huge emergence of fly fishing as
a “cool” active sport in the 18–35 demographic. Seeking “different” than
their fathers and grandfathers, and driving demand for Made in America
product. We started as that wave started and we’ve been fortunate as a
result. Getting more younger people and kids into the sport is the centerpin
of our longevity.
op
tC
No
Do

11

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
Exhibit 1
Scott Hunter Sewing in Basement Workshop

rP
Source: Scott Hunter. Used with permission.
yo
op
Exhibit 2
Vedavoo Exhibit at the IFTD Show in 2014
Scott Hunter Wearing Red Sling Pack
tC
No
Do

Source: Scott Hunter. Used with permission.

12

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
Exhibit 3
Vedavoo Top Sellers

rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do

13

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860
Entrepreneurial Challenge: Vedavoo
BAB444 / NOVEMBER 2018

t
os
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do

Source: Scott Hunter and www.vedavoo.com. Used with permission.


Accessed September 2014.

14

This document is authorized for educator review use only by Fraser Pogue, University of British Columbia until Oct 2020. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860

You might also like