Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The manuscript was received on 7 January 2006 and was accepted after revision for publication on 23 August 2006.
DOI: 10.1243/03093247JSA202
Abstract: The mechanical properties of AISI 4140 steel were studied at different strain rates
(0.167, 0.833, and 1.667 min−1) for various microstructures. To investigate the influence of
microstructure, spheroidizing, normalizing, and quench tempering (single tempered and
double tempered) were used to obtain a range of microstructures and strength levels. To study
the dependences of the mechanical characteristics of AISI 4140 steel on both the strain rate
and the microstructure, tensile tests and microscopic evaluation were performed.
The results showed that not only do the yield and the ultimate strength depend on both
the microstructure and the strain rate but also so does the appearance of the yielding
phenomenon. Also the results showed that an increase in strain rate causes the strain-hardening
exponent n and the strength coefficient K to decrease in both quench-tempered and normalized
structures but has a negative effect on the spheroidized structure. In fact, the sensitivity of the
spheroidized structure to the strain rate is higher than those of the other structures. Microscopic
evaluation proved that the Lüders strain width of the spheroidized microstructure is much
lower, because of its soft ferrite matrix.
strain rates [14–18]. The presented models give the rate on the mechanical characteristics of AISI 4140
flow stress of carbon steels as a function of the strain, steel. Also attempts were made to clarify the yielding
strain rate, temperature, and carbon content. The phenomenon mechanism.
fifth approach considered the relationship between
the residual stresses due to heat treatment and the
tensile properties of AISI 4140 [19–23]. The results
2 EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
show that the yield stress and ultimate stress can be
affected by the residual stress. Also it has been proved
2.1 Materials
that the magnitude of the residual stress depends
strongly on the kind of heat treatment. For example AISI 4140 steel was obtained from Yazd Alloying Steel
the effect of normalizing is greater than the effect of Complex (Iran-Yazd). The chemical composition of
quench tempering [19]. the used material is summarized in Table 1.
From the literature review performed by the present
authors, it was found that many researchers [1–26]
2.2 Heat treatment
have studied the effect of normalizing, annealing, and
quench-tempering heat treatments on the mechanical Different heat treatment cycles were applied to 12
properties such as the hardness, yield stress, and AISI 4140 steel billets of 20 mm diameter and 100 mm
tensile stress but there is no evidence of the investi- length. To eliminate the history of the alloys, all
gation of the effects of both heat treatment and samples were annealed at 815 °C for 20 min. Then
strain rate on mechanichal characteristics such as the specimens were cooled to room temperature
the strain-hardening exponent n, strength coefficient in glass wool to achieve a cooling rate of about
K, and strain rate sensitivity m. Also the roles of 1–2 °C/min [3]. Details of the heat treatment cycles
both the heat treatment and the strain rate in the applied to the specimens are summarized in Table 2.
yielding phenomenon has not attracted attention. The spheroidizing heat treatment was applied
Therefore, the main goal of the current study is to to the first three specimens (specimens 1, 2, and 3).
elucidate the effect of normalizing, spheroidizing, The specimens were heated to 750 °C and held in
and quench-tempering heat treatments and strain the furnace for 7 h. Specimens 4, 5, and 6 were
Element C Mn Si Cr Mo S P
Second
Austenitizing First tempering tempering Second
temperature Austenitizing Quench temperature First tempering temperature tempering
Specimen (°C) time (min) medium (°C) time (min) (°C) time (min)
normalized for 30 min at 870 °C and cooled in still air. i.e. 0.167, 0.833, and 1.667 min−1. Table 3 indicates
A quench-tempered heat treatment was performed the different strain rates applied to the heat-treated
on specimens 7, 8, and 9. The samples were heated samples.
to 855 °C for 30 min and then quenched in agitated
oil; afterwards they were tempered at 620 °C for 2 h. 2.4 Microscopic evaluation
Heat treatment of sample 10 is similar to those of
An Olympus B202 optical microscope and a LEO
quench-tempered specimens but its tempering con-
1450VP scanning electron microscope were employed
dition is different. It is worth noting that specimens
to examine the microstructures of some heat-treated
11 and 12 experienced double-tempering cycles.
samples. The scanning electron micrographs were
The true reason for choosing this kind of tempering
obtained using the secondary-electron method.
was to avoid acceleration of exponential diffusion
phenomena [27]. In fact, for this treatment, after the
first tempering cycle, the specimens were cooled to
room temperature and then the second tempering 3 RESULTS
cycle was applied. To compare the results of low and
high tempering temperatures, specimen 7 was con- The engineering stress–strain curves of spheroidized,
sidered in this stage. Table 2 shows the different normalized, and quench-tempered specimens (speci-
quench-tempering cycles applied to the specimens. mens 1 to 9) are shown in Fig. 2. The dependence
of the tensile behaviour of AISI 4140 steel on both
2.3 Tensile tests the strain rate and the microstructure obtained
by different heat treatment cycles can be observed
Tensile tests were performed on the heat-treated clearly. The mechanical properties such as the yield
specimens according to ASTM Standard E8M-6. stress and the tensile stress in different heat treat-
Figure 1 shows the dimensions of the tensile samples. ment and strain rate conditions obtained from the
The tensile tests were performed using a Zwick stress–strain curves are summarized in Table 4.
250 kN machine. As can be seen from Fig. 2 and Table 4, an increase
To investigate the influence of the strain rate on in strain rate for all specimens in each heat-treated
the stress–strain curve and its parameters, tensile group causes the magnitudes of the yield stress and
tests were carried out at three different strain rates, ultimate tensile stress to increase. The effects of
increasing the strain rate are not the same for all
samples. In fact, when the strain rate was changed
from 0.167 to 1.667 min−1, the yield stresses of
specimens 7, 8, and 9 increase by about 76.56 MPa.
Unlike the above-mentioned samples, the strain
rate does not have a significant effect on the yield
stress of spheroidized samples, i.e. specimens 1, 2,
and 3. Increasing the strain rate from 0.167 to
1.667 min−1 causes an increase of only about
14.07 MPa in the yield stresses of the specimens.
Fig. 1 Dimensions of the ASTM E8M-6 tension test It is interesting that an inverse behaviour occurs
specimen used. All dimensions are in millimetres for the ultimate tensile stress. In other words,
1 Spheroidizing – 0.167
2 Spheroidizing – 0.833
3 Spheroidizing – 1.667
4 Normalizing – 0.167
5 Normalizing – 0.833
6 Normalizing – 1.667
7 Quench tempering Single tempered 0.167
8 Quench tempering Single tempered 0.833
9 Quench tempering Single tempered 1.667
10 Quench tempering Single tempered 0.167
11 Quench tempering Double tempered 0.167
12 Quench tempering Double tempered 0.167
regard to Fig. 5 it can be concluded that the work- m value than high-yield-strength materials such as
hardening exponent n depends on the microstructure. the quench-tempered steels.
In fact, the higher value of n in the spheroidized Figure 7 compares the engineering stress–
microstructure can be attributed to coarse carbide engineering strain curves of specimens 10 to 12
particles which are surrounded by a soft ferrite with specimen 7. All samples have been tested at
matrix. the same strain rate condition, i.e. 0.167 min−1. The
The flow stress in the homogenous deformation mechanical properties of the specimens, which are
part of the stress–strain curves can also be estimated obtained from the engineering stress–engineering
by another equation which relates the flow stress to strain curves, are summarized in Table 5. Figure 8
the strain rate [33] according to shows the true stress–true strain curves of quench-
tempered specimens. To investigate the influence of
s=C(ė)m (5)
quench-tempering condition on stress–strain curve
where parameters, i.e. n, K, and m, the homogenous
deformation parts of the true stress–true strain curves
G H G H
q[log(s)] D[log(s)]
m= # were drawn on a log–log scale (Fig. 9). The summary
q[log(ė)] D[log(ė)] of calculated parameters is shown in Table 6.
e,T e,T
log(s )−log(s )
= 2 1 (6)
log(ė )−log(ė )
2 1
where m is the strain rate sensitivity parameter and C
is a constant value. The results of the variation in m at
different true strains in the homogenous deformation
part of the stress–strain curves are shown in Fig. 6.
This figure shows that there is considerable difference
between the values of m for the spheroidized, the
quench-tempered, and the normalized specimens. It
can be seen that there is a direct relation between
the strain rate and m for the normalized and the
spheroidized specimens and an inverse relation
for the quench-tempered specimens. The reason
is attributed to the different microstructures and
mechanical properties of the spheroidized and the
normalized specimens from those of the quench-
tempered specimens. It should be noticed that
generally m increases as the yield strength decreases.
Materials with low yield strengths, such as the
spheroidized and normalized steels, possess a higher
the specimens. Carbide growth can be observed as 7 Fedyukin, V. Thermal cycling treatment of steels
both the time and the temperature of the tempering and cast irons (in Russian), 1984 (Leningrad State
treatment increase. The present authors believe that University, Leningrad).
8 Konopleva, E. Thermal cycling treatment of low-
the true reason for the appearance of the yielding
carbon steel with hardening from intercritical
phenomenon can be attributed to the carbide size and temperature range. Metal Sci. Heat Treatment
its distribution inside the matrix. Since the carbon Metals, 1989, 8, 617–621.
content in the ferrite matrix in the speheroidized 9 Smoljan, B. Contribution to investigation of the
microstructure is much lower than in the other thermal cycling treatment of steel. In Proceedings
microstructures, thus the Lüders strain can be small of the Ninth International Congress on Heat treat-
[31, 32]. ment and surface engineering, Nice, France, 1994,
pp. 49–58 (PYC Edition).
10 Gaponov, Y., Marchenko, V. G., Shtein, Y. A., and
D’yachenko, S. S. Influence of thermal cycling treat-
4 CONCLUSION ment to the critical points of steel. Metal Sci. Heat
Treatment Metals, 1988, 7, 493–501.
In this paper the dependence of the mechanical 11 Radovic, M., Lara-Curzio, E., and Riester, L.
characteristics of AISI 4140 steel on both the strain Comparison of different experimental techniques
rate and the microstructure is investigated. The for determination of elastic properties of solids.
Mater. Sci. Engng: A, 2004, 368, 56–70.
conclusions are summarized as follows.
12 Davis, J. R. (Ed.) Metals handbook, 1990 (ASM
1. The quench-tempered microstructure has lower International, Materials Park, Ohio).
n and K than both the spheroidized and the 13 Armstrong, P. E. and Bunshan, R. F. (Eds) Measure-
ment of mechanical properties, techniques of metals
normalized structures and the responses of the
research, Vol. V, Part 2, 1971, pp. 103–107 (John
quench-tempered and the normalized structures Wiley, New York).
are the same as the strain rate increases. 14 Lenard, J. G., Pietrzyk, M., and Cser, L. Math-
2. The strain rate sensitivity of the spheroidized ematical and physical simulation of the properties
structure is about three times higher those of the of hot rolled products, 1999, pp. 73–75 (Elsevier,
other structures. Amsterdam).
3. At the same strain rate, AISI 4140 steel has different 15 Misaka, Y. and Yoshimoto, T. Formulation of mean
resistance of deformation of plain carbon steel at
yield point phenomenon behaviours.
elevated temperature. J. Jap. Soc. Technol. Plast.,
4. The appearance of the yield point phenomenon 1967–1968, 8, 414–422.
can be attributed to the growth of carbides and 16 Siciliano, F. and Jonas, J. J. Mathematical modeling
the ferrite matrix content. of hot strip rolling of microalloyed Nb, multiply-
5. The Lüders strain width depends on the micro- alloyed Cr–Mo, and plain C–Mn steels. Metall. Mater.
structure. For instance the Lüders strain can be Trans. A, 2000, 31, 511–530.
eliminated in the quench-tempered structure by 17 Shida, S. Empirical formula of flow stress of carbon
decreasing the tempering temperature. steels resistance to deformation of carbon steels at
elevated temperature. 2nd Report (in Japanese).
J. Jap. Soc. Technol. Plast., 1969, 10, 610–617.
18 Sarıoǧlu, F. The effect of tempering on susceptibility
REFERENCES to stress corrosion cracking of AISI 4140 steel in 33%
sodium hydroxide at 80 °C. Mater. Sci. Engng: A,
1 Grange, R. Strengthening by austenite grain refine- 2001, 315, 98–102.
ment. Trans. Am. Soc. Metals, 1966, 59, 26–29. 19 Holzapfel, H., Schulze, V., Vöhringer, O., and
2 Mahajan, S., Venkataraman, G., and Mallik, A. K. Macherauch, E. Residual stress relaxation in an AISI
Grain refinement of steel cyclic rapid heating. 4140 steel due to quasistatic and cyclic loading
Metallography, 1973, 6, 337–345. at higher temperatures. Mater. Sci. Engng: A, 1998,
3 Krauss, G. Steels, heat treatment and processing 248, 9–18.
principles, 1990 (ASM International, Materials Park, 20 Holzapfel, H. Das Abbauverhalten kugelstrahl-
Ohio). bedingter Eigenspannungen bei 42CrMo4 in Ver-
4 Petch, N. J. The cleavage strength of polycrystals. schiedenen Wärmebehandlungszuständen. Dr-Ing.
J. Iron Steel Inst., London, 1953, 174, 25–28. Dissertation, Universität Karlsruhe (Technische
5 Low, J. R. Relation of properties to microstructure, Hochschule), 1994.
1954, pp. 163–168 (ASM International, Materials Park, 21 Holzapfel, H., Schulze, V., Vöhringer, O., and
Ohio). Macherauch, E. Relaxation behaviour of shot peen-
6 Smoljan, B. An analysis of combined cyclic heat ing induced residual stresses in AISI 4140 due to
treatment performance. J. Mater. Processing Technol., quasistatic uniaxial loading at elevated temper-
2004, 155–156, 1704–1707. atures. In Proceedings of the Sixth Conference on
Shot peening (Ed. J. Champaigne), San Francisco, 27 Jost, W. Diffusion in solids, liquids and gases, 1952
California, USA, 1996, pp. 385–396 (International (Academic Press, New York).
Scientific Committee for Shot Peening, Tokyo). 28 Datsko, J. Material properties and manufacturing
22 Ebenau, A. Das Verhalten von kugelgestrahltem 42 processes, 1966, pp. 18–20 (John Wiley, New York).
CrMo 4 im normalisierten und vergüteten Zustand 29 Ludwigson, D. C. Modified stress–strain relation
unter einachsig homogener und inhomogener Wechsel- for FCC metals and alloys. Metall. Trans., 1971, 2,
beanspruchung. Dr-Ing. Dissertation, Universität 2825–2828.
Karlsruhe (Technische Hochschule), 1989. 30 Morrison, W. B. The effect of microstructure on
23 Eifler, D. Inhomogene Deformationserscheinungen mechanical properties of low carbon steel. Trans.
bei Schwingbeanspruchung eines unterschiedlich Am. Soc. Metals, 1966, 59, 824–829.
wärmebehandelten Stahles des Typs 42CrMo4, Dr- 31 Sowerby, R. and Duncan, D. L. Failure in sheet
Ing. Dissertation, Universität Karlsruhe (Technische metal in biaxial tension. Int. J. Mech. Sci., 13,
Hochschule), 1981. 217–229.
24 Hall, A. M. Introduction to today’s ultrahigh-strength 32 Hall, E. O. Yield point phenomena in metals and
structural steels, ASTM STP 498, 1971 (ASTM alloys, 1970 (Plenum, New York).
International, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania). 33 Dhar, A., Clapham, L., and Atherton, D. L. Influence
25 Unterweiser, P. M. Heat treater’s guide, 1995, of Lüders bands on magnetic Bauhauser noise and
pp. 120–180 (American Society for Metals). magnetic flux leakage signals. J. Mater. Sci., 2002, 37,
26 Thelning, K. E. Steel and its heat treatment, 1975, 2441–2446.
pp. 584–590 (Butterworth, London).