Professional Documents
Culture Documents
rull$
MR Peas (AAUW) report (Wellesley College Center for Research
on Women, 1992) concluded that "all differences in math
performance between girls and boys at ages 11 and 15
could be accounted for by differences among those scor-
ing in the top 10-20%" (p. 25). This means that many of
our brightest female mathematics students are not keep-
by
ing up with their male counterparts. It is clear from this
N1 KSub * CI-1f and other research studies discussed in this article that
many mathematically talented females perform at levels
that are not commensurate with their abilities (Reis,
1987; Reis & Callahan, 1989).
Stereotyping
About Females
and Mathematics
Before we can alleviate the
problems experienced by girls
like Jennifer, it is important to
try to understand the factors
behind those problems. One
of the main reasons that girls
do not succeed in mathemat-
ics may not be due to any
lack of ability or effort-
rather it may attributed to
the fact that they are not
expected to excel in this area
by some of their parents,
teachers, or peers.
Stereotypes influence per-
ceptions and performance
in school and in life, and are
often cited as contributing to
girls' problems in math and
related fields such as technol-
However, the situa-
tion can be improved, for teachers and the time she needs to
ogy. Both stereotyping and prej- h
parents can implement specific strate- udice affect girls in mathematics
really think about concepts and to for- classes. Unfortunately, mathematics is
gies to help talented girls succeed in mulate her own foundations of mathe- often thought of as a "male" field, and
math. matical thinking. She also needs to
Jennifer, for example, is at a criti- our society holds traditional male
know that everyone, even mathemati-
cal point in her mathematical develop- images of scientists, engineers, com-
cians, experience similar states of dis-
ment. While she wants to please her puter scientists, and mathematicians.
comfort when they encounter
parents and teachers by excelling in Society's influence is also demonstrated
challenging content. In fact, mathe-
algebra, she is becoming increasingly in the development of software for stu-
matical insights and future discoveries
anxious about mathematics and is often emerge from confusion. If dent use. Software continues to be
afraid she may no longer make the Jennifer is to be successful and remain geared toward male interests, with males
honor roll because of her score in in this class, her teacher should pro- being the heroes in 63% of the software
math. She spends more time on home- vide a classroom environment that will examined in one study (Nelson &
work, yet she receives fewer As than help Jennifer develop her mathemati- Watson, 1991). Not only is there a need
before. Therefore, she needs encour- cal abilities and regain her confidence for software in which girls will have an
agement from her parents to assure her regarding her ability to do advanced interest, but also girls' interests need to
that B grades are acceptable in acceler- work. This environment should nur- be expanded so that gender-based
ated courses. She needs support from ture creative thinking and encourage stereotypes are not reinforced (Sanders,
her teachers to encourage her to use risk taking, as well as use alternative 1994).
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
GIFTED CHILD TODAY 33
Talented Girls in Mlathematics
Evidence also exists that girls are 1996 SAT were higher than females', the fields, such as computer science and
regarded as less capable in mathematics by females who took the test had a higher engineering as courses of study. Using
some of their teachers and parents, and mean high school grade point average: data from the National Education
these perceptions may influence girls' 3.27 overall, versus 3.11 for males Longitudinal Study of 1988
opinions of their own abilities. For exam- (Educational Testing Service, 1996). How (NELS:88), a 10-year data collection
ple, Kissane (1986) found that teachers does this affect gifted females in particu- project sponsored by the U.S.
were less accurate in nominating girls who lar? Rosser (1989) reported that the higher Government, Gavin (1997) examined a
are likely to do well on the quantitative the grades, the greater the gender gap. cohort of approximately 1,400 high
subtest of the SAT than they were in nam- "Girls with an A+ grade point average mathematics ability students. As seniors
ing boys who were likely to score high. averaged 23 points lower on the SAT- in 1992, these students were surveyed to
Recent research by Siegle and Reis (1994) Verbal section (9 points lower than the determine their intended fields of study
found that adolescent female gifted stu- overall verbal M/F gap) and 60 points in college. Although all students had
dents indicated that they had higher abil- lower on the SAT-Mathematics section been identified as having high mathe-
ities than males in language arts only, than boys with the same GPA" (p. iv). matics ability, only 27% expressed
while male gifted students indicated they Also, we cannot discount the influence of interest in a mathematics or science
had higher abilities than females in math- societal expectations and the media dis- major with only 1.8% intending to
ematics, science, and social studies. It is cussion of SAT scores on the confidence major in mathematics. The numbers for
important to examine beliefs and pay level of females as they enter the classroom females were quite revealing: only 9
attention to them since beliefs influence to take the SAT exam. Do they have a (0.7%) selected computer science, 46
actions. For example, current data indi- mindset that they will not do well on (3.3%) engineering, 19 (1.4%) mathe-
cate that of the 11,793 students who took these tests? If so, how much does this matics, and 27 (2%) physical science.
the AP Computer Science A exam, only affect their performance? This is worthy Examining data on intended majors for
1,959 or 17% were female. On the more of further examination. females who took the SAT in 1996, of
extensive or more difficult AP Computer Kimball (1989) made a fascinating those intending to major in engineer-
Science AB exam taken by 6,450 students, point about the ways that we currently ing, only 19% were female, in computer
only 611 or 9% were female. Men com- measure mathematics achievement, stat- or information sciences, just 25%
prised the vast majority of test takers, as ing: 'Although there is ample evidence of (Educational Testing Service, 1996).
91 % of those taking either test were male. young women's superior math achieve- These remarkably low percentages of
Looking at the implications of this at the ment when grades are used to measure career interest in mathematics and sci-
local level, Henry and Manning (1998) achievement, they have not been consid- ence occur despite data cited earlier sug-
reported that only one girl enrolled in the ered seriously in the literature on mathe- gesting that females receive consistently
math class entitled "Introduction to matics achievement. I am proposing that higher grades in elementary school, sec-
Computer" at a particular high school it is important to begin to take them seri- ondary school, and in college-related
during the 1998 academic year, and no ously' (p. 203). Kimball suggested that subjects.
girls were enrolled in "Advanced classroom grades reflect what is learned Although much attention has been
Computer." during a particular class and should not given to research studies that have
influenced by other experiences outside reported equal numbers of males and
Mathematics Grades of, or prior to, the classroom experience. females declaring mathematics as their
Also, the information that girls are not at
in School a disadvantage and, in fact, have a grade
major field of study, it is important to
study those who actually graduate with
advantage in many courses may be useful a mathematics major and pursue a
In her review of literature on women's
in increasing girls' confidence in their
mathematics achievement, Kimball mathematics career. While equal num-
mathematics ability. bers of males and females start with the
(1989) found that while standardized test
scores still favor boys, grade differences mathematics major, females comprise
favor girls. The pattern of performance on Postsecondary and 43% of those completing the under-
standardized aptitude assessment mea- Career Choices graduate major and only 20% of those
sures is also very different from the pattern completing the doctoral degree (Linn
of grades. While males' mean scores on Many gifted females continue to & Kessel, 1995). With respect to
both the verbal and math sections of the reject mathematics and directly related females who are minorities, the num-
help, may be detrimental to females' * frequent activities oriented toward that teachers provide it, peer observa-
sense of self-confidence. Rather, teach- broadening views of mathematics tions can be established with colleagues.
ers should encourage students to persist and physical sciences, Using this technique, a teacher observes
in seeking their own solutions. For * presenting mathematics as a tool in a peer's class and tallies the number of
example, they should answer questions solving problems, and times girls and boys are called upon.
with a question, giving hints but not * frequent use of strategies to ensure One way that some teachers address the
solutions. They must have high expecta- full class participation. issue of classroom equality is simply to
tions for girls, let them know it, and It is important to point out the similar- alternate between calling on males and
praise them for being able to solve chal- ity of these curricular and instructional females in class.
lenging problems. practices to those recommended by the Some current research indicates
Teachers must also be aware that National Council of Teachers of that girls tend to thrive in small group
females who are talented in mathematics Mathematics (2000) in their Principles work, especially all female groups. In
are often talented in other academic and Standardsfor SchoolMathematics. In coed groups boys may dominate,
areas as well. Without encouragement to fact, these are the kinds of practices becoming the leaders and monopoliz-
pursue their talent in these areas, they touted by the leaders in mathematics ing the discussion, while girls become
often choose other more female-oriented education as essential for all students. the recorder of the discussion. This is
fields. Teachers must make parents We translate these research findings especially true in computer work. Boys
aware of the need to support their into practical ideas for the classroom have been found to monopolize com-
daughters' talents in mathematics. In with the following suggestions. All girls, puters even in preschool (Nelson &
school, older girls taking Advanced especially adolescents, need classrooms Watson, 1991). When boys and girls
Placement courses can be asked to come in which they will be heard and under- are paired together at the computer,
and talk to younger students to encour- stood, and where they can discuss ideas research has found that a girl will defer
age increased participation in these before coming to conclusions. The to her partner's wishes (Martin &
courses. At every stage, all opportunities teacher should provide a setting where Murchie, 1992; Volman, 1997).
should remain available to talented students are not permitted to call out Current research indicates that by the
female students. They should be encour- answers randomly and where there is 3rd or 4th grade, girls are less techno-
aged to enroll in and complete advanced plenty of think time-period of uncon- logically oriented (Nelson & Watson,
mathematics and computer classes. tested silence that may encourage stu- 1991). Boys are at least three times
3. Create a safe, caring, and sup- dents to become more willing to share more likely than girls to be involved
portive learning environment. Eccles their thinking with others. Teachers with computers during secondary and
(1987) drew several conclusions from should not rush to provide closure to a post-secondary years (Kramer &
the existing literature about mathemat- lesson, for a mulling period is often Lehman, 1990). So it is important that
ics and science teachers who have been essential for talented girls studying girls be assured the opportunity to
successful in reversing stereotypes and advanced topics. A very effective strategy work individually on computers or,
keeping females interested in mathemat- is the think-pair-share technique in when working in pairs, be given a deci-
ics. She noted a pattern of conditions in which, after time for private thought, sion-making role and time for hands-
these classrooms, including: students share their answers with a on computer use.
* frequent use of cooperative learning neighbor and then with the entire class. Opportunities for students to
opportunities, The paired discussion lends credibility reflect in writing about their ideas and
* frequent individualized learning to their thinking, fosters mathematical fears about mathematics can also be
opportunities, communication, and develops a sense of provided in a safe and supportive class.
* use of practical problems in assign- confidence. A comment box enables students to
ments, Teachers should also become per- drop a note about their feelings or their
* frequent use of hands-on opportu- sonally aware of the additional attention understanding of the content of the
nities, they sometimes give to boys. It is hard to daily mathematics lesson, including
* active career and educational guid- deny a waving hand or someone calling questions they have and related topics
ance, out, but increased attention, even nega- they would like to pursue. E-mail also
* infrequent use of competitive moti- tive attention, can reinforce behaviors. provides the opportunity for students
vational strategies, Girls need equal attention and to ensure to contact the teacher with questions or
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
36 WINTER 2003 * VOL. 26, NO. 1
concerns. Feelings can also be addressed math classes are being experimented experts on single sex concluded that a
in creative journal assignments, includ- with throughout the United States. single-sex classroom with a sexist teacher
ing mathematics metaphors as sug- Although some districts have been con- is just as detrimental as a coed classroom
gested by Buerk and Gibson (1994). A cerned with legal ramifications, other with the same type of teacher (The
sample assignment might be the follow- districts have found that if all boys' Wellesley College, Center for Research
ing: If mathematics were a food (color, classes are also offered or if boys are on Women, 1998).
animal, etc.), it would be ... and why? given the opportunity to take the classes 5. Appeal to the strengths offemales
The results can quickly foster commu- designed for girls (few want this as motivators. During middle school
nication and provide information option), then this does not present a and usually continuing through their
about personal feelings. Journals can problem. In fact, Gavin and Shmurak adolescent years, mathematically tal-
also be used to encourage communica- (1999) found that in an urban middle ented females exhibit great attention to
tion about mathematical concepts and school setting the boys in single sex detail in their work, strong organiza-
offer talented students a way to bring classes benefited the most by making tional skills, and for some, a sophisti-
deeper understanding and new insight significant gains on state mathematics cated level of maturity. These skills can
to areas they wish to pursue. Girls may mastery test scores when compared with be used to motivate girls' interest in
often enjoy the intimate student- their counterparts in coed classes. mathematics. One way to do this is by
teacher dialogue created by the journal- Math clubs for girls, computer encouraging them to organize a Family
writing process. An outgrowth of this camps for girls, summer math programs Math Night (from EQUALS) at the
experience could be the creation of dis- for girls, such as SummerMath at Mount elementary school for parents and chil-
cussion groups at lunch or after-school Holyoke College, are all empowering dren to engage in fun mathematics
clubs in which girls can discuss their ways for females to explore mathematics activities. The girls choose activities for
feelings and explore interesting mathe- in nonthreatening environments. Some the evening, issue invitations, set up
matics topics. females, especially at the upper elemen- and actually run the entire event (under
4. Provide some single-sex learning tary and middle school levels, feel intim- the auspices of a teacher-mentor).
opportunities in mathematics. With the idated by the male dominance in Tutoring younger children and organiz-
discussion of gender bias in the class- competitive math leagues such as Math ing mathematics clubs or Saturday
room prompted by several AAUW 1992 Olympiad and Math Counts; yet, these enrichment programs also encourages
reports, there has been a renewed inter- leagues provide talented students with and empowers talented adolescent
est in single sex schools and classes for challenging mathematical problems and females.
girls. The research results on the effects a forum for teachers and peers to recog- Some research evidence indicates
of the single-sex environment have been nize mathematical talent. Some teachers that classes emphasizing competition
quite contradictory leaving one with have created all female Math Olympiad result in higher achievement for males
what Gill (1996) refers to as "a now- and Math Counts teams that have and classrooms that encourage coopera-
you-see-it-now-you-don't effect that is worked well (Volpe, 1999). Establishing tion result in higher achievement for
both tantalizing and frustrating." clubs for girls as after-school or activity- females (Peterson & Fennema, 1985).
However, researchers agree that there period alternatives also gives girls the However, these results may not always
seems to be a qualitative difference in freedom to confront math anxiety, if it apply to some females who are mathe-
the single-sex class environment that exists, and to delve into complex prob- matically talented. In a qualitative study
makes many girls prefer it to a coed lems in a friendly environment (Karp & of female mathematics majors enrolled
classroom. In her studies of middle Niemi, 2000). Female role models in in a highly selective women's college,
school girls, Janice Streitmatter (1997) various math-related professions can be Gavin (1996) found that these young
found that girls were more likely to ask guest speakers at the club meetings, and women had actually enjoyed competi-
and answer questions in the math sin- field trips taken to explore career options tion in their high school classrooms,
gle-sex classroom and that the girls-only may inspire a budding mathematician. especially when it involved males.
setting enhanced their ability to learn A word of caution is necessary. It is Hernandez (1997), in a recent study,
and was overwhelmingly preferred. The important to remember that it is the found similar results. Investigating
single-sex setting seems especially useful nurturing environment provided by the gifted females' and males' achievement
in mathematics where females' self- teacher that makes these single-sex set- and attitudes about advanced math, she
esteem traditionally is lower. All girls' tings work. The AAUW roundtable of found talented girls liked fast-paced
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
competitive classes and disliked cooper- female role model is an episode from ties when studying mathematics.
ative learning situations that held them the Jasper Woodbury Series (Learning Moving students beyond the familiar
back. The implications of these research Technology Center, 1996) entitled.The with ideas that stretch the mind should
results indicate that teachers need to Right Angle. In this episode, a young be a major goal of a program for all tal-
recognize that all females are not alike Native American female searches for a ented students, including females. From
and have different learning styles. They treasure left to her by her grandfather. elementary school exposure, to such top-
need to observe the females in their class Students work cooperatively using ics as different numeration .systems, the
and be especially aware of the needs of maps and compasses to locate the trea- Fibonacci Numbers, LEGO-Logo and
the talented females, some of whom sure. nonroutine problem solving to sec-
may break the mold. They should pro- 6. Use language, problems, and ondary school study of non-Euclidean
vide some competitive, some coopera- activities that are relevant to girls. geometry, fractals, chaos theory, and
tive, and some individual learning Suzanne Damarin (1990) examined combinatorics, students need to struggle
situations and allow choice whenever traditional mathematics vocabulary with a change of mindset and relish this
possible so as to maximize student inter- and found that it reflects a strong male struggle, for it fosters a deep, intimate,
est and learning. influence. The language contains goals and broadened understanding of mathe-
Other research indicates that boys of mastery and mathematical power. matics.
like to experiment and tinker, while We teach students to attack problems In designing curriculum for tal-
girls are more goal-oriented in school and our instructional strategies ented females, teachers should include
and feel tinkering may be a waste of include drill and competitions. She a variety of alternative assessments. As
time (Martin & Murchie, 1992). believes that instead of talking about some talented females may not do their
Because some girls have been socialized working toward mastery, teachers best thinking during timed tests, other
to play more often with dolls rather should talk about internalization of options will enable them to demon-
than blocks and to read books rather concepts. Instead of attacking prob- strate their knowledge and competen-
than tinker with fixing their bicycles, lems, students should be encouraged cies. Independent and small group
they may need more time to work with to interact with them, sharing prob- projects provide an ideal medium to
manipulatives. They may also need in- lems, and working cooperatively toward showcase talent. These projects should
class time to build models, to see how solutions. go beyond a typical term paper and
things work, and to develop their sense Rather than focusing mainly on should focus on investigative activities
of spatial relationships. The activity activities relating to football yardage, in which students assume the role of
Cooperative Geometry (EQUALS) is baseball statistics, and housing con- first-hand inquirers-thinking, feeling,
another excellent example of group struction, teachers should also con- and acting like a practicing profes-
work with manipulatives that develops sciously incorporate problems and sional. In Renzulli's Enrichment Triad
spatial thinking as well as encourages a activities that girls enjoy. Problems deal- Model (1977), student products are
true cooperative problem solving ing with endangered species, recycling, used as the vehicle to help to develop
spirit. The extensions are especially the spread of disease, population research skills and provide an opportu-
challenging for talented elementary growth, and quilting have proven to be nity to use authentic methodology.
and middle school students. Equally excellent suggestions. Activities involv- This is an excellent opportunity to
good for upper elementary and middle ing patterns including tangrams, paper entice girls to use technology as an
school students is the unit Ruins of folding, and tessellations, and those effective tool for advanced research
Montarek (1998) from the new NSF- involving art such as making mobiles, especially in gathering and analyzing
funded mathematics series, Connected origami, computer graphics, and scale data. The AAUW report, "Tech Savvy:
Mathematics Program (Lappan, Fey, drawings may appeal to many girls. Educating Girls in the New Computer
Fitzgerald, Friel, & Phillips, 1998). In Some favorite teacher resource materials Age" (2000) makes it clear that the rea-
this unit, Emily Hawkins, a famous with activities to encourage girls in son girls are not represented well in
explorer and adventurer, investigates mathematics are listed at the end of this computer classes is that they are critical
the ancient ruins of the lost city of article. of the computer culture rather than the
Montarek making models of buildings 7. Create a challenging curriculum. mistaken belief that they are computer
from the clues found at the ruins. Teachers must encourage talented phobic. Using technology to support
Another investigation that features a females -to seek challenging opportuni- interesting, independent projects is
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................
38 WINTER 2003 * VOL. 26, NO. 1
one way for females to realize the use- Using this knowledge, they may decide come back to life in the twenty-first
fulness of computers. These projects to create a play space for children at a century can also be effective. This pro-
are most effective when they are pri- local preschool or redesign a veterinari- vides a creative twist to the historical
marily directed toward bringing about anIs office space for more efficient use. perspective that appeals to some tal-
a desired impact on an audience, Again, the teacher acts as a guide and the ented females. Role models need not all
whether it be fellow students, adminis- students are empowered to discover the be historical; examples of women cur-
trators, town officials, mathematicians, mathematics and see the relevance of rently working in mathematics and
or senior citizens. The teacher func- mathematics in the real world. They related fields-Ph.D. mathematicians,
tions as a facilitator, pointing the stu- learn to value mathematics and, hope- computer scientists, astronauts, engi-
dent in the direction of resource fully, become inspired to continue study neers, physicists, astronomers, and so
persons and materials as needed or pro- and pursue a mathematically related on can be presented as well. The
viding direction in learning methodol- career. Internet is an exciting new medium for
ogy to conduct the investigation. Some 8. Providefemale role models and students that will allow them to enter
examples of these projects might mentors. Many teachers understand that into dialogue with these professionals.
include contacting local community some girls have unique ways of con- Some excellent resources on the lives of
officials for needed surveying or design necting to people. Teachers should cap- female mathematicians, with interest-
projects, such as a population survey or italize on this and include an historical ing anecdotal family and personal sto-
a statistical analysis on the use of cur- perspective in their mathematics cur- ries are included at the end of the
rent library facilities, or an energy riculum to help students become aware article.
audit of town hall using mathematical of both the people and the creative A rewarding experience for teach-
analysis with recommendations to the processes behind mathematics. The ers, as well as girls, is organizing and
town council for improved efficiency. lives of mathematicians, their interests participating in a career day in mathe-
The NCTM addenda series book, in the subject, and how they created matics, science, and technology. At
Data Analysis and Statistics Across the their mathematical discoveries will help these conferences, which are generally
Curriculum, Grades 9-12 (1992), is young female students to appreciate the held for girls in middle or high school,
also an excellent resource for long and creative process as well as the difficul- female professionals conduct hands-on
short-term projects with time lines and ties faced in getting new theories workshop sessions with girls, interact-
evaluation criteria. accepted. It is interesting to discover ing with them and exposing them to
With the increased use of block that concepts as basic as the notion of actual on-the-job activities that spark
scheduling at the middle and high zero, irrational numbers and negative career interest in girls. It is exciting and
school level, another means for offering numbers were quite controversial when rewarding to visit these sessions and
challenging and interesting mathematics first presented and were adopted only observe girls listening to a dog's heart-
to students is the use of enrichment clus- with great difficulty. beat with a veterinarian, performing a
ters. Enrichment clusters are groups of The names of the following female chemical test on local river water with
students who share common interests mathematicians are usually not recog- an environmental engineer, or trying to
and who come together during desig- nized by boys or girls: Hypatia, Marie determine car insurance rates for
nated time blocks to pursue these inter- Agnesi, Sophie Germain, Evelyn Boyd teenage girls with an actuary. An associ-
ests (Renzulli, 1994). Single-sex Granville, Sonya Kovalevskaya, Mary ation that can assist teachers in plan-
enrichment groups can provide an Somerville. These female mathemati- ning these days is Expanding Your
increased sense of confidence for cians made distinguishing contribu- Horizons, Math-Science Network
females. During these extended time tions and teachers can make these located at 2727 College Ave., Berkeley,
periods, students can pursue mutual women come alive by celebrating their CA 94705. We have conducted several
mathematical interests together. For birthdays, hanging their portraits in of these career days at the University of
example, they might study fractals using bulletin board displays, and encourag- Connecticut and found that in addition
computer models and decide to create ing females to perform autobiographi- to the hands-on workshops, panels of
programs that generate original fractal cal skits dressed in their period professional women are also effective,
pieces. Or, they might gather to start a costumes. Videotaped interviews con- and allow a greater variety of careers to
Young Architects' Guild focusing on ducted between student reporters and a be represented. To enliven these panels
learning about architectural design. remarkable woman who has suddenly and encourage interaction between the
women and the often shy female stu- number of talented persons we need Caucasian children. Paper presented
dents, we highly recommend using the into careers in mathematical areas in at the annual meeting of the
"Tool Clues" activity designed by the future. What should be clear to all American Educational Research
EQUALS with the address listed in the of us is that too few talented females Association, Chicago.
appendix. In this activity, female pro- regard a career involving mathematics 'Campbell, P. B. (1992). Nothing can stop
fessionals provide bags of "tools" used as an attainable goal, and it is vitally us now: Designing effective programs
in their careers, and students, working important to encourage and support for girls in math, science, and engi-
in groups, try to guess their profession more females to pursue mathematics in neering. Newton, MA: Women's
using a 20-question format. the future. (T Educational Equity Act.
One of the greatest benefits from Chipman, S. F., Brush, L. R., & Wilson,
these interactions with professional References D. M. (Eds.)(1985).Women and
women is the opportunity for establish- mathematics: Balancingthe equation.
ing mentorship and internship pro- American College Testing Program. New York: Erlbaum Associates.
grams. Participating in these programs (1989). State andnationaltrend data Cooley, D., Chauvin, J. C., & Karnes, E
gives mathematically talented females for students who take the ACT A. (1984). Gifted females: A com-
the opportunity to work directly with a Assessment. Iowa City: American parison of attitudes by male and
female role model in a high-level mathe- College Testing Program. female teachers. Roeper Review, 6,
matics-related career position. Becker, D. E, & Forsyth, R. A. (1990). 164-167.
Gender differences in grades3 through Damarin, S. K. (1990). Teaching math-
Conclusion 12: A longitudinal analysis. Paper ematics: A feminist perspective. In
presented at the meeting of the T. J. Cooney and C. R. Hirsch
Far fewer females than males major American Educational Research (Eds.), Teaching and learningmathe-
in mathematics and pursue careers in Association, Boston. matics in the 1990s. (pp. 144-158).
mathematics and related fields. It is our Becker, J. R. (1994, April). Research on Reston, VA: National Council of
responsibility to try to make high-tech, gender and mathematics perspectives Teachers of Mathematics.
high paying professional careers equally and new directions. Paper presented Dickens, M. N. (1990). Parentalinflu-
available to all students. As pointed out at the meeting of the American ences on the mathematics self-concept
in this chapter, few talented students of Educational Research Association, of high achieving adolescent girls.
either sex indicate an interest in major- New Orleans, LA. Unpublished doctoral dissertation.
ing in mathematics. The majority of Brandon, P. R., Newton, B. J., & University of Virginia,
the strategies we have suggested above Hammond, 0. W. (1987). Children's Charlottesville, VA.
are of the type recommended not only mathematics achievement in Hawaii: Dreyden, J. I., & Gallagher, S. A.
for girls but also for all students by the Sex differences favoring girls. (1989). The effects of time and
National Council of Teachers of American Educational Research direction changes on the SAT per-
Mathematics in their Principles and Journal 24, 437-461. formance of academically talented
Standards for School Mathematics Buerk, D., & Gibson, H. (1994). adolescents. Journal for the
(2000). These strategies and activities Students' metaphors for mathemat- Education of the Gifted, 12,
focus on constructivist, discovery-ori- ics: Gathering, interpreting, impli- 187-204.
ented learning as the key to building cations. WME Newsletter, 16(2), Eccles, J. S. (1987). Gender roles and
mathematical confidence and under- 2-8. women's achievement-related deci-
standing in all students. So, in reality, Campbell, G. (1996). NationalAction sions. Psychology of Women
promoting equality in the classroom is Council for Minorities in Quarterly, 11, 135-171.
also promoting good teaching tech- Engineering, Inc. research letter. New Educational Testing Service. (1996).
niques, developing student problem York: National Action Council for 1996 College-Bound Seniors: A
solving abilities, and instilling a gen- Minorities in Engineering. Profile of SAT Program Test Takers.
uine appreciation for mathematics. Campbell, J. R., Connolly, C., Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing
Only the wider use of these strategies Lacattiva, C., & Pizzo, J. (1985). Service.
will provide answers to questions about Math/sciencegender gap: Influence of EQUALS. (1986). Cooperative
how we can continue to recruit the parents on gifted Asian and Geometry. Berkeley, CA: Lawrence
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
GIFTED CHILD TODAY 41
Talented Girls in Mathematics
National Science Foundation. (1992). Rosser, P E (1989). Sex bias in college Teaching in the Middle School, 4(5),
Women andminorities in science and admissions tests: Why women lose out. 290-293.
engineering:An update. Washington, Cambridge, MA: National Center Webb, N. M. (1984). Sex differences in
DC: Author. for Fair and Open Testing. interaction and achievement and
National Science Foundation. (1996, Sadker, D. M., & Sadker, M. (1994). classroom participation: An experi-
September). Women, minorities, and Failing at fairness: How Americas ment involving Advanced Placement
persons with disabilities in science schools cheat girls. New York: calculus classes. Journal of
and engineering. Arlington, VA: Macmillan. EducationalPsychology, 76, 33-40.
National Science Foundation. Sanders, J. S. (1986). The neuter com- Webb, N. M., & Kenduski, C. M.
Nelson, C. S., & Watson, J. A. (1991). puter: Computers for girls and boys. (1985). Mathematics small group
The computer gender gap: Children's New York: Neal-Schuman. interactions among high ability
attitudes, performance, and socializa- Sanders, J. S. (1994). Bibliography on learners. Gender differences in small
tion. JournalofEducation Technology gender equity in mathematics, science, group interaction and achievement
Systems, 19, 343-353. and technology: Resources for class- in high- and low-achieving classes.
Parsons, J. E., Adler, T F., & Kaczala, C. room teachers. New York: Gender In L. C. Wilkinson & C. B. Marrett
M. (1982). Socialization of achieve- Equity Program, Center for (Eds.), Gender -influences in class-
ment attitudes and beliefs: Parental Advanced Study in Education, room interaction (pp. 209-236).
influences. Child Development, 53, CUNY Graduate Center. New York: Academic Press.
310-321. Siegle, D., & Reis, S. M. (1994). Wellesley College Center for Research
Peterson, P. L., & Fennema, E. (1985). Gender differences in teacher and on Women. (1992). The AAUW
Effective teaching, student engage- student perceptions of student abil- report: How schools shortchangegirls.
ment in classroom activities, and ity and effort. Journal of Secondary Washington, DC: American
sex-related differences in learning Gifted Education, 6, 86-92. Association of University Women.
mathematics. American Educational Sheffield, L. J. (1994). The development Wellesley College Center for Research
ResearchJournal, 22, 309-335. of gifted and talented mathematics on Women. (1998). Gender gaps:
Phillips, D. A. (1987). Socialization of students andthe National Councilof Where schools still fail our children.
perceived academic competence Teachers of Mathematics standards. Washington, DC: American
among highly competent children. Storrs: The National Research Association of University Women.
ChildDevelopment, 58, 1308-1320. Center on the Gifted and Talented, Wellesley College Center for Research on
Reis, S. M. (1987). We can't changewhat University of Connecticut. Women. (1998). Separated by sex: A
we don't recognize: Understanding Stevenson, H. W., & Newman, R. S. critical look at single-sex educationfor
the special needs of gifted females. (1986). Long-term prediction of girls. Washington, DC: American
Gifted Child Quarterly, 31, 83-88. achievement in mathematics and Association of University Women.
Reis, S. M., & Callahan, C. M. (1989). reading. Child Development, 57, Wellesley College Center for Research
Gifted females: They've come a long 646-659. on Women (2000). Tech-Savvy:
way-or have they? Journalfor the Streitmatter, Janice. (1997). An Educatinggirls in the new computer
Education of the Gifted, 12, 99-117. Exploratory study of risk-taking and age. Washington, DC: American
Renzulli, J. S. (1977). The enrichment attitudes in a girls-only middle Association of University Women.
triad model. Mansfield Center, CT: school math class. Elementary School
Creative Learning Press. Journal, 98, 15-26. Author iNote
Renzulli, J. S. (1994). Schools for talent U.S. Bureau of Census. (1999). Current
development: A practical plan for population reports. Washington, DC: Portions of this article have been
total school improvement. Mansfield, S. Bureau of the Census. excerpted or paraphrased from Work
CT: Creative Learning Press. Volman, M. (1997). Gender-related Left Undone: Choices & Compromises of
Rogers, P. (1990). Thoughts on power effects of computer and information Talented Females, by S. M. Reis, 1998,
and pedagogy. In Leone Burton literacy education. Journal of Mansfield Center, CT: Creative
(Ed.), Gender and mathematics: An Curriculum Studies, 315-328. Learning Press. Copyright © 1998 by
international perspective (pp. Volpe, B. J. (1999). A girls' Math Creative Learning Press. Used with per-
38-46). London: Cassell. Olympiad team. Mathematics mission.
Mathematics Contests and concepts. Using a series of mathe- lem-solving skills and logical reasoning,
and Comnpetitions matical clues, teams work together to build familiarity with mechanical tools,
predict numerical information on his- strengthen spatial visualization skills,
American Mathematics Competitions, torical or geographical topics. The final and teach the importance of mathemat-
DL Walter E. Mientka, AMC Executive clues guarantee success-a really positive ics for opening occupational doors.
Director, Department of Mathematics cooperative learning experience for the
and Statistics, University of Nebraska, entire class in grades 4-8. Research and Planning Center,
Lincoln, NE 68588-0658. University of Nevada. Add-Ventures
Downie, D., Slesnick, T., & Stenmark, for girls: Building math confidence.
MathCounts, National Society of J. K. (1981}). Mathforgirlsand other Newton, MA: WEEA Publishing
Professional Engineers Information problem solvers. Berkeley, CA: Center.
Center, 1420 King St., Alexandria, VA Equals, Lawrence Hall of Science.
22314. Available from the Women's
This book presents a variety of Educational Equity Act Publishing
Mathematical Olympiad for Elementary activities that make mathematics fun Center, 55 Chapel St., Newton, MA
Schools, 125 Merle Ave., Oceanside, NY and challenging. Topics explored 02160. This book combines teacher
11572 (Division E: grades 4-6; Division include logic strategies and patterns, cre- development with strategies that work in
M: grade 7), (516) 781-2400. ative thinking, estimation, observation, teaching mathematics to girls. It
spatial visualization, and careers. includes a chapter on computer equity
Mathematically Precocious Youth issues that gives a list of questions for
Program, Duke University Talent Erickson, T. (1989). Get it together. Palo schools and/or teachers to assess the
Identification Program, Box 40077, Alto, CA: Dale Seymour. computer-learning climate for girls.
Duke University, Durham, NC 27706- Erickson, T. (1996). United we solve. Strategies for making computer educa-
1742. Oakland, CA: eeps media. tion more accessible and appealing to
girls are also discussed.
Johns Hopkins University, Dr. Luciano These books specifically outline
Corazza, 2701 North Charles St., activities for groups using manipulatives Skolnick, J., Langbort, C., & Day, L.
Baltimore, MD 21218. ranging from pattern blocks to M&M's (1982). How to encourage girls in
and toothpicks. Problems have a wide math & science. Palo Alto, CA: Dale
Mathematics Pentathlon, P.O. Box range of topics and difficulty, but all Seymour.
20590, Indianapolis, IN 46220. have the same format: six clue cards that
together provide the information needed This book focuses on ways to help
National Mathematics League, P.O. Box to solve the problem. Everyone in a girls acquire the skills and confidence
9459, Coral Springs, FL 33075. group must work together because each they need to pursue a full range of inter-
member has different information ests in mathematics and science. It
Young Scholars Program, National needed for the solution. (The four includes strategies and activities for
Science Foundation, 1800 G St., NW, resources listed above are available from developing spatial visualization, working
Washington, DC 20550. Dale Seymour, P.O. Box 10888, Palo with numbers, logical reasoning, and
Alto, CA 94303-0879). scientific investigation.
Annotated List of Teaching Resources:
Fraser, S. (1982). Spaces: Solving prob- Other Teaching Resources:
Cook. M. (1990). Team estimation and lems of access to careers in engineering
analysis. Balboa Island, CA: Marcy and science. Palo Alto, CA: Dale Gruver, N., & Kelly, J. (Eds.). New
Cook. (312 Diamond, Balboa Seymour. moon: The magazine for girls and
Island, CA 92662) their dreams. Duluth, MN: New
The activities in Spaces were Moon.
This workbook is a series of group designed to stimulate students' curiosity
estimation activities integrating social and interest in doing mathematics. The Karp, K., Brown, E. T., Allen, L., &
studies and mathematical computation classroom-tested lessons develop prob- continued on page 64
continuedfrom page 44 Resources on Notable Women: their chosen fields. It also includes
Allen, C.. (1998). Feisty females: enjoyable activities based on each wom-
Inspiring girls to think mathemati- Cooney, M. (1996). Celebrating women an's contributions to mathematics.
cally. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. in mathematics and science . Reston,
VA: National Council of Teachers of Organizations
Lappan, G., Fey, J. T., Fitzgerald, W. M., Mathematics.
Friel, S. N., & Phillips, E. D. Association for Women in Mathematics
(1998). Ruins of Montarek: Spatial This book features 22 biographies of University of Maryland
visualization. White Plains, NY: notable female mathematicians and sci- College Park, MD
Dale Seymour. entists and shows how their determina-
tion, creativity, and intellectual passion
Center for Gender Equity in Technology,
Learning Technology Center. (1996). helped them excel in their fields.
The adventures of Jasper Woodbury. Appropriate for use at the middle and Science, and Math Education
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. high school levels, the text supplies University of Washington
many references that can be used for his- Seattle, WA
National Council of Teachers of tory of mathematics courses and is filled
Mathematics (2000). Principlesand with excellent illustrations similar to EQUALS
standards for school mathematics. woodcuts. It is available from the Lawrence Hall of Science
Reston, VA: Author. National Council of Teachers of University of California
Mathematics. Berke'ey, CA 94720
National Council of Teachers of
Mathematics (1992). Data analysis Edeen, S., Edeen, J., & Slachman, V. Math/Science Network
and statistics across the curriculum. Portraits for classroom bulletin 2727 College Ave.
Reston, VA: NCTM. boards: Women mathematicians. Palo Berkeley, CA 94705
Alto, CA: Dale Seymour.
Perl, T (1978). Math equals. Menlo National Women's History Project
Park, CA: Addison-Wesley. This kit is a set of black-line drawings 7738 Bell Road
(8" x 11") of 15 pioneering mathemati- Windsor, CA 95492-8518
Sanders, J. S. (1994). Lifting the barriers: cians with accompanying one-page (707) 838-6000
600 strategies that really work to biographies for quick bulletin boards or .,
increase girls participationin science, student handouts. It is also available SummerMath
mathematics, and computers. Port with hypercard program for student Mount Holyoke College
Washington, NY: Jo Sanders. exploration or classroom presentation.
South Hadley, MA 01075
(These two resources are available from
(413) 538-2608
Sanders, J., Koch, J., & Urso, J. (1997). the National Women's History Project,
Gender equity right from the start: 7738 Bell Road, Windsor, CA 95492-
Women and Mathematics
Instructionalactivitiesfor teacheredu- 8518).
cators in mathematics, science, and Department of Mathematics
technology. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. Perl, T. (1993). Women and numbers: and Computer Science
lives of women mathematicians plus Meredith College
Sanders, J., Koch, J., & Urso, J. (1997). discovery activities. San Carlos, CA: Raleigh, NC 27607
Gender equity sources and resources World Wide Publishing/Tetra.
for education students. Mahwah, NJ: Women and Math Education
Erlbaum. This multicultural book relates the Women's Educational Equity Act
biographies of 13 outstanding mathe- Publishing Center
Stenmark, J. K., Thompson, V H., & maticians from the 19th and 20th cen- Educational Development Center, Inc.
Cossey, R. (1986). Family math. turies, examining where and how these 55 Chapel St., Ste. 200
Berkeley, CA: Lawrence Hall of women's interests in mathematics origi- Newton, MA 02160
Science, University of California. nated and their accomplishments in (800) 225-3088