Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ORG
1McKetta Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA
2Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, University of Calgary, Calgary, T2N 1N4 Canada
3Department of Petroleum Engineering, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA
Abstract:
A challenge for underground CO2 storage is the leakage of the buoyant supercritical gas through microcracks in wellbores that
cannot be sealed with current oilfield cements that are too viscous and cannot penetrate the cracks. Polymer gels consisting
of pH-sensitive hydrogel particles suspended in an aqueous solution offer a potential alternative. The rheology of aqueous
solutions of Carbopol 934 as a model pH-sensitive gel is measured to find the compositions and pHs for both ease of injection
and to seal cracks against the flow of bulk CO2 and CO2 dissolved in brine. The polymer gels have low viscosity at low pH and
can easily flow into the microcracks. In the elevated pH of the microcracks, the particles swell creating a significant yield stress
sufficient to seal leakage pathways. The yield stress reaches a maximum at pH 5 and it increases with increasing concentration.
The flow curves of stress versus shear rate for all pHs and concentrations are well-described by the Herschel-Bulkley model
with an exponent of about 0.34 except for highly acidic conditions when the gelant solutions show a much lower yield stresses
and higher exponents. The flow curves can be collapsed onto a single universal flow curve rescaled with the yield stress, the
low frequency shear modulus and the suspending fluid viscosity. The presence of salts, especially high valence salts, reduce
the yield stress of the gels considerably. It is shown that the addition of chelating agents mitigates this effect and can restore
more than 30 % of the yield stress of the gelant.
Key words:
CO2 , Carbopol, yield stress, Herschel-Bulkley, pH-sensitive gelant
1 INTRODUCTION The seals on these old wells are often imperfect [5 – 7].
Small channels can be created during the initial curing
Geologic carbon storage GCS is a path on the transition of the cement [8, 9]. Chemical attack from formation
to renewable energy by capturing carbon dioxide CO2 fluids and mechanical stressing, drilling, and hydraulic
and injecting it deep underground via wells into geo- fracturing can create cracks in the cement that then
logical reservoirs [1]. GCS involves capture of CO2 from leaks [10, 11]. The challenge is to ensure the integrity of
power plants, transport to geological formations, and the cement to prevent any potential leakage of CO2
finally compression of the gas and injection into a for- from the formation.
mation, where its movement is monitored and the Current technology for sealing damaged wells is
quantity stored is regularly verified [1, 2]. A major con- so-called cement squeeze in which slurry cement is
cern for GCS is the ability of the formation to hold CO2 forced into cavities behind the casing and near leakage
over the long term. pathways to restore the integrity of existing wells. This
Many reservoirs that meet the required specifica- technique is often unsuccessful as the fractures are too
tions for CO2 storage are located in areas with aban- narrow to be filled and repaired with highly viscous oil-
doned preexisting wells and no owner or operator [3, field cement. Here we explore and develop the formu-
4]. These wells are constructed with cement between lation of a polymer gelant based on a model pH-sensi-
the steel casing and the rock formation layers to form tive microgels to seal small channels and microcracks
a seal to prevent uncontrolled flow of liquid and gas. from which CO2 could leak from the formations [12, 13].
2.3 RHEOMETRY
of 200 µm was glued to both the plates. Samples were elasticity of the polymer network. The maximum thick-
pre-sheared for two minutes to erase any shear history ening is achieved when the sodium hydroxide deproto-
during sample preparation and loading. Samples were nates approximately all the carboxylic acid groups along
then allowed to rest for two minutes before the mea- the polymer backbone. The yield stress sy was deter-
surements. Strain sweep tests were conducted for mined by fitting the flow curves to the Herschel-Bulkley
strains ranging from 0.002 to 18000 % with a fixed fre- model
quency of 0.1 Hz that ensure the measurements were
within the linear viscoelastic region. We determined
flow curves by applying varying shear stresses and mea- (1)
suring the resulting shear rates. For points close enough
to yield stress, the gel was sheared about 104 seconds Where sy, k and n represent yield stress, consistency in-
in order to reach equilibrium. At stresses above the yield dex, and power law index. The flow curves in Figure 1
stress, the plot of shear rate versus time shows a are well described by the Herschel-Bulkley model,
plateau, which is a representative of steady state [15]. which is in accordance to previous studies done on oth-
Creep test, stress ramp and strain sweep were also con- er polyacrylic acid microgels [12, 13, 15, 20, 21]. The values
ducted to measure and verify the yield stress of the gels. of the Herschel-Bulkley parameters from the flow
With the help of creep test, we could measure shear curves are listed in Table 1.
rates as low as 10-5 s-1 which was impossible to achieve
with other methods. 3.2 EFFECT OF POLYMER CONCENTRATION ON FLOW
BEHAVIOR
The shear stress s versus shear rate g ̇for 1.0 wt.% Car-
conducted to obtain flow curves. A plot of shear stress
as a function of shear rate for range of concentrations
bopol 934 for varying pH is shown in Figure 1. For all pHs, of polymer at pH = 4.5 is shown in Figure 2. As the con-
the material exhibits a Herschel-Bulkley behavior with centration of polymer increases, the yield stress and the
a plateau or yield stress sy at low shear rates. The yield viscosity of polymer gelant increase. For polymer con-
stress increases by almost two orders of magnitude as centrations greater than 3.0 wt.%, the dispersion and
pH varies from 3.3 to 5.9. Increasing the pH from 5.0 to injection of polymer gelant becomes impractical. The
9.0 does not affect the yield stress values but the further values of sy, k, and n for several concentrations of the
increase of pH values lowers the yield stresses to some polymer neutralized to 4.5 is given in Table 1.
extent. The highest yield stress is achieved at pH = 5.9
(see Figure 1), consistent with studies on other Carbopol 3.3 EFFECT OF PH AND CONCENTRATION ON YIELD
gels [19 – 21]. This increase in stress is known very well STRESS
and could be attributed to the swelling of the cross-
linked polyacrylic acid when the carboxylic acid groups Yield stress was obtained via three different methods.
are deprotonated [14, 21, 22]. The polymer particles swell The stress ramp method was the primary technique
due to the osmotic pressure ultimately balanced by the used, but creep tests and strain sweep tests were also
(2)
Figure 9: (a) The untreated gel after precipitation and (b) treated gel in brine-filled environment.
In another experiment, a cube of cement was Pa threshold value, which confirms our claim that the
placed inside a treated gel. In order to prevent the gel treated polymer could maintain the yield strength for
from drying out, the gel was maintained inside a cov- more than a year when exposed to saline-filled media.
ered beaker in the lab’s environment for about 20 Since long-term storage is required, aging could
months. It was found the treated gel did not undergo adversely affect the sealing purpose to some extent.
precipitation and maintained the yield stress of 140.8 However, 3 wt.% Carbopol (97 wt.% water) is very cheap
Pa. Figure 9a shows the precipitation of the untreated to prepare and it could be maintained in reservoir con-
polymer gel in contact with cement core. Figure 9b de- dition at least for one year. In order to assure long-term
picts how a treated gel could withstand against brine- containment, the polymer could be injected in regular
filled environment. Furthermore, the graphs of shear intervals (for example annually) until the CO2 is trapped
stress against shear rate for untreated and treated poly- in any of known trapping mechanisms.
mer gels are plotted in Figure 10. Note that the untreat-
ed sample was not exposed to saline media while the 3.8 COMPARISON OF YIELD STRESS-LOW FREQUENCY
treated one was in contact with brine-filled environ- SHEAR MODULUS WITH HYDROGELS
ment. The flow curves show that the salinity could af-
fect the gel’s strength to some extent. From Figure 10, The plot of yield stress versus low frequency shear mod-
the yield stress values of untreated and treated 2.0 wt.% ulus for different hydrogels has been plotted in Fig-
Carbopol 934 at pH = 7.1 were determined 223.3 and ure 11. Ultrez 10, ETD 2050 and MAA/EA show lower val-
140.8 Pa, respectively. The 140.8 Pa is still above the 100 ues of yield stress when compared to Carbopol 934 and
940 [21, 26]. It has been shown below some concentra- been reported for relatively monodisperse microgels, it
tions called CG (entropic glass transition) samples be- is remarkable that it also works for polydisperse mate-
have like dilute colloidal suspensions. For concentra- rials. In part, the collapse occurs because the power-law
tions CG < C < CJ, where CJ is jamming transition, the exponent of the Herschel-Bulkley fit is approximately
long-range displacement of particles is restricted [26]. the same for all pHs and polymer concentrations. The
Above CJ, the steric hindrance results in flat contacts fitted values of these power law exponents are quite
which is responsible for repulsive forces and hence the sensitive to the values of the yield stresses. It was thus
onset of elastic [14]. The elastic modulus, which is a critical in this study to use roughened surfaces and mul-
function of elastic contact forces increases rapidly as tiple and sometimes time-consuming methods to en-
concentration increases which could be attributed to sure accurate, cross-checked values of the yield stress.
the increase in number of particles per contact and It is possible that the universal flow curve has not been
compression of particles [14, 27]. The low frequency observed for other Carbopol or polydisperse polyacrylic
shear modulus of MAA/EA changes slowly up to CJ = acid hydrogels because of the challenge of measuring
0.016 wt%. However, above this point the low frequen- the yield stress at low shear rates needed to accurately
cy shear modulus increases rapidly compared to yield fit the power law exponents.
stress which could be the reason for unusual behaviors The presence of sodium and calcium ions leaching
of polymers like MAA/EA, Ultrez 10 and ETD 2050 [26]. from the cement of the wellbore can cause the polymer
The same behavior could be seen for low and high con- to precipitate and prevent the formation of a solid-like
centrations of Carbopol 941. gel to seal the microcracks. Chelating agents included
in the hydrogel formulation can bind these ions and al-
low the hydrogel to form a solid with 30 % of the orig-
4 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS inal yield stress restored, sufficient to seal the microc-
rack for formulations identified here. The yield strength
The shear rheology of Carbopol 934 as a model hydrogel of the material is maintained for at least one year in
for sealing microcracks in wellbores and stopping leaks brine-filled environment of the microcrack. Thus, hy-
in CO2 storage formations has been studied. These ma- drogels are viable materials for sealing microcracks in
terials exhibit superior rheological properties compared formations for CO2 storage.
to the current oil-field cements for sealing in that they
can be injected at low pH with low viscosity to penetrate
and fill the microcracks and then become solid in the ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
higher pH environment of the cement. The strength or
yield stress of the hydrogel is more than sufficient to The authors thank the Department of Energy for fund-
seal the cracks against the flow of CO2 and prevent leaks. ing this work through Award No.: DE-FE0009299 at the
The flow curve of the shear stress versus shear rate Center for Petroleum Engineering at The University of
of the hydrogel is well described by the Herschel-Bulk- Texas at Austin. The help of undergraduate students
ley equation. All the data can be collapsed onto a single Deepali Patel, Valeriy Shakenov, Joulia Nikolaevna Po-
master flow curve for a range of pHs and polymer con- liaeva and Paulami Das with performing some of the
centrations allowing one to predict the properties of experiments is greatly appreciated. We are grateful to
other potential formulations and provide a convenient Dr. Michel Cloitre for his advice on measuring the yield
formula for flow simulations. While such a collapse has stress and other discussions.