Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7.0IJRARE-Vol.6 No.2 AGT
7.0IJRARE-Vol.6 No.2 AGT
net/publication/373361308
Numerical Analysis of the Effect of Train Speed and Axle Load on Rail Fastening
System Components for Heavy Haul Track
CITATIONS READS
0 20
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Abrham Gebre Tarekegn on 24 August 2023.
ISSN: 2423-3838
International Journal of
Railway Research
Numerical Analysis of the Effect of Train Speed and Axle Load on Rail Fastening System
Components for Heavy Haul Track
Downloaded from ijrare.iust.ac.ir at 15:47 IRDT on Monday May 25th 2020
Article history: With the ever-increasing demand for heavy haul and high speed trains the
track, especially fastening system, suffers a lot and is experiencing
Received: 11.05.2019
unexplainable failures which reduce the life of the entire track. Although
Accepted: 19.07.2019 the numerous researches have been conducted on fastening system for
Published: 24.12.2019 different reasons (many concentrated on one component), few researches
have been conducted on effect of train speed and axle load on all
components of the fastening systems. In this research an ANSYS Software
Keywords:
is used to numerically analyze the effect of speed and axle load for heavy
Deformation haul on fastening system components. Different speeds and axle loads are
Fastening system considered. It is shown that by increasing the ratio of the lateral to vertical
Speed load (L/V ratio) the deformation increases at high rate compared with the
increments in the speed. The results show that when this ration increases
Axle load
from 0.1 to 0.5, by considering the speed of 100 km/h for 25t axle load,
ANSYS the rail deformation increases 299.5%, railpad 115.5%, abrasion plate
Mechanical design 69.1%, rail clip 162.1%, bolt 117.4 %, shoulder 223.8% and top of the
sleeper 55.1 %. It is also shown that by increasing the speed from 80km/h
to 160km/h the deformations, in all fastening system components, increase
to an average of 32%. Increase of axle load from 25t to 40t causes the
deformations to increase up to 13% compared to the increase of speed. It
means that the increase of axle load is more effective compared with the
increasing speed. The results are expected to add on more understanding
of the mechanical behavior of fastening systems when subjected to
different loading scenarios.
*
Corresponding author, Professor
Email: elias.kassa@ntnu.no
Numerical Analysis of the Effect of Train Speed and Axle Load on Rail Fastening System …
Researches have been focusing on investigating how much axle load can cause the failure of the
the performance of different fastening systems clip based on mechanical properties of the clip.
under laboratory and field loading environments,
Although the numerous researches have been
but the behavior of concrete sleeper fastening
conducted on fastening system for different
systems under different loading conditions is not
reasons (many concentrated on one component),
fully understood.
very few research have carried out to look onto
Numerous researches have been conducted the effect of train speed and axle load on all
on fastening systems for different reason and it component of the fastening systems.
has been shown that the defects on rail and Considering that there is an increase of axle load
Downloaded from ijrare.iust.ac.ir at 15:47 IRDT on Monday May 25th 2020
sleeper-fastening systems are the main causes of and speed which comes with unexplainable
derailment [7]. Other research has been done in failures of fastening system component, so a
order to further understand the mechanical study is needed to look at the influence of speed
behavior of fastening system. Holder et al [8] not only on one component but in all
conducted a laboratory research to investigate components of fastening systems as a whole.
the lateral performance of Skl-style fastening
One type of research that needs to be
system. The purpose was to characterize the
conducted is to investigate the mechanical
lateral load path in fastening system by using the
behavior of the fastening system due to increase
Lateral Load Evaluation (LLED) technology.
of axle load and speed. It is known that the speed
Williams et al [9] conducted a research to
increase causes high increase of dynamic forces
quantify the demands on the insulator through
which will ultimately cause the failure of the
analysis of the transfer of lateral wheel loads into
track. One of the affected components will be the
the fastening system by measuring the
fastening components. The aim of this research
magnitude of lateral forces entering the shoulder,
is to analyze the effect of axle load and speed for
but no conclusion drawn as the threshold of the
heavy haul on fastening system components to
forces resisted by the shoulder or other
further understand the mechanical behavior of
components as a results of the vertical load and
fastening system components. The outcome will
lateral loads increase. Orguei et al [10] used the
lead to design the track components based on the
dynamical mechanical analysis method to
concepts of the mechanical design.
measure the dynamic behavior of rail pad under
a wide range frequency but there is still need to
know the influence of speed on the displacement
2. Methodology
of railpad. On the other Van Dyk et al [11]
studied the mechanical design of concrete This numerical analysis was conducted on
sleepers and elastic fastening systems under widely used fastening system (Vossloh system)
current loading in order to improve the as shown in Figure 1. All components are
understanding of mechanical behavior of the modelled as solids, mainly for simplifying.
concrete sleeper-fastening system, later provide Some components are considered as spring-
the basis of mechanical design process. Wen et damper in model by ignoring the longitudinal
al [12] reported on the contact-impact stress and lateral dimensions of the components and
analysis of rail joint region using the dynamic considering only the vertical direction. This may
finite element method. Furthermore, Williams et have an impact on reproduction of vertical track
al [9] conducted an experimental field dynamics [14]. Another advantage of modelling
investigation on quantifying the distribution of the components by using solid elements is to
lateral forces by use of the Lateral Load have the same degrees of freedom as suggested
Evaluation Device (LLED). Additionally, by Prakoso [15]. In this analysis, the effect of
Sadeghi et al [13] conducted a research aiming axle load increase was investigated and speed as
to investigate the impact of loading conditions well as the axle load were varied in order to have
(including train speed and train axle load) on more insight on the influence of both speed and
clips fatigue. After conducting various tests they axle load. This will help to capture the
concluded that axle loads are more effective in relationship of this variation and the effect it has
causing considerable deformations on rail clip on deteriorating the fastening components.
than the train speed. From the above
In this research the ANSYS software version
investigation they considered few factors that
16 is used to numerically analyze the model in
can cause clip deformation and they didn’t show
question.
Parameters Unit
Concrete grade C 50/60
Sleeper length (L) 2600 mm
Sleeper width (W) 272 mm
Sleeper height (H) 252 mm
Downloaded from ijrare.iust.ac.ir at 15:47 IRDT on Monday May 25th 2020
7.85 ton / m3
Where P is the design load in kN stiffness for ballast and bub-ballast, stiffness foe
ballast and stiffness for sub-ballast, respectively.
Where V is speed (km/h)
In order to simulate the component
is the dynamic factor interaction and friction between them, the
D is wheel diameter (mm) =864mm coefficients of friction are defined. The COFs
are defined from literature [24-26]. They are
qr is rail seat load summarized in the Table.5.
DF is a distribution factor, expressed as a In railways there is an ever increasing
percentage of the wheel load and for concrete demand for higher axle loads. In order to capture
sleepers is obtained as 51% the effect of axle load increment, the axle loads
Le and Lb are the effective support lengths of half of 25, 30, 35, and 40t are chosen. They are
sleeper, and the sleeper width, respectively. chosen based on most used worldwide and future
Also, h1, h2 are the thickness of the ballast and considerations, especially the 40t axle load. In
sub-ballast layers, respectively. E1 and E2 are the the analysis a combination of lateral and vertical
elastic moduli for the ballast and sub-ballast load was used with ratio of 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5
layers, respectively. K, K1 and K2 combined (lateral load to vertical load) by keeping the
vertical load constant.
Table 5. COFs defined in the FE model [22] The model consists of rail, rail pad, abrasion
plate, rail clip, bolt, shoulder and sleeper which
Component Frictional COF values are modeled as solid to account for the real
Name Interaction situation on ground. Their dimensions are
summarized in Table 2. A space of 5mm was left
Pad-Rail 0.3 between shoulder and rail. This was done to let
Pad the shoulder move laterally freely so that it
Pad-Abrasion 0.3 cannot touch the rail during the lateral
plate
displacement. Since the focus is on
Downloaded from ijrare.iust.ac.ir at 15:47 IRDT on Monday May 25th 2020
The other ratio can be interpolated. The ratio 3. Results and Discussions
is limited to 0.5 because it is believed that it’s the
worst case that may happen. The wheel load and During the numerical analysis the
lateral load are applied in the middle of rail on displacements on different fastening system and
single sleeper (Figures 2&3) and on two sleepers at the top of the sleeper are captured. In the
(Figure 4). The bolt torque moment is analysis a combination of vertical and lateral
represented by bolt preload taken as 10kN per load, by keeping vertical load constant and
bolt as per Chinese standards [27]. varying the lateral load for different L/V ratios
of 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5 are considered. Other ratios
maybe interpolated. Figures 5 to 7 present the
deformations of fastening system components
subjected to different axle loads.
In the analysis, the vertical load is kept
constant, only the lateral load is varied to the
ratio of 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5. The ratios are chosen
randomly, by expecting that in the worse cases it
can reach the half of the vertical load. The other
Figure 3. The model of a single sleeper
ratios will be interpolated. From the above charts
(Figures 5-7) it is seen that as the speed
increases, the deformation also increases to
higher values.
As it is expected, the rail has high
deformation compared to other components. The
railpad is the one that has a high rate of increase
among the fastening components, this may be
due to its softness. Among the others, the rail clip
also has high deformation; this is due to the clip
force that is applied on it. The imparted load
from lateral and vertical loads together with
torque load contributed to that increase.
By increasing the L/V ratio, the deformation
also increases, this shows that the lateral force
Figure 4. Equivalent Von Mises stresses with a plays an important role in deteriorating the
speed of 100 km/h, rail resting on two sleepers fastening systems, because the vertical load was
kept constant. From the results, it is also seen the tangent track, because it is where the lateral
that the fastening systems that is on the opposite load is higher
side where the lateral force is applied, suffers a
Increasing the speed from 80 km/h to 160
lot more than the other side. This means that one
km/h on the ratio of 0.5 for 25 t of axle load; the
side of the fastening system deforms on a higher
deformation on rail increases 32.49 %, railpad
rate than the other depending where the lateral
increases 31.89 %, abrasion plate increases
force is applied. The fastening component on the
32.23%, the rail clip increases 32.33%, the bolt
curve has to be designed differently with that of
10
Deformation in mm
Deformatio in mm
0.2
0.1
0.02 0.01
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0 0.2 0.4 0.6
Load ratio (L/V) Load ratio (L/V)
10
Deformation in mm
Deformation in mm
2
1
0.1 0.2
0.01
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.02
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Load ratio L/V Load ratio (L/V)
Figure 5(a-d). Deformations of fastening component for 25t axle load with different speed
a) Deformation of railpad
d) Deformation of rail clip
80 km/h 100 km/h
45 80 km/h 100 km/h
45
40
40
Axle load [t]
25 25
20 20
0.3 0.5 0.7 0.9 1.1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Deformation [mm] Deformation [mm]
40 40
35 35
30 30
25 25
20 20
0.3 0.5 0.7 0.9 1.1 0.15 0.25 0.35 0.45
Deformation [mm] Deformation [mm]
Champaign, (2014).
- Increasing the lateral to vertical load ratio by
keeping vertical load constant from 0.1 to 0.5, [2] J. Sadeghi, Ballasted Railway Tracks:
the deformation increases up to 40% compared Fundamentals of Analysis and Design, IUST
to the increase of speed from 80 to 160 km/h. Publication Service, Tehran, Iran, (2010).
- Increase of axle load from 25t to 40t causes the [3] Xiao Hong, Guo Xiao, Wang Haoyu, Ling
deformations to increase up to 13% compared to Xing, Wu Sixing, Fatigue damage analysis and
the increase of speed. It means that the increase life prediction of e-clip in railway fasteners
of axle load is more effective than increasing the based on ABAQUS and FE-SAFE, Advances in
speed. Mechanical Engineering, Vol. 10(3), (2018), pp.
1–12.
- One side of the fastening system deforms on a
higher rate than the other depending where the [4] Mohammad Fesharaki, Amin Khajehdezfuly,
lateral force is applied. Influences of train speed and axle loads on life
cycle of rail fastening clips, Transactions of the
- In order to gain more understanding of the
Canadian Society for Mechanical Engineering,
mechanical behavior of the fastening
Vol. 39, No. 1, (2015).
components, it is recommended to carry out a
parametric study and determine the robust model [5] Brent A. Williams, Donovan Holder, Marcus
under different axle load and speeds. Dersch, Riley Edwards, Christopher Barkan,
Quantification of lateral forces in concrete
- It is also recommended to provide the fastening
crosstie fastening systems, Transportation
systems in curves that are more resistive
Research Board 94th Annual Meeting, Jan.
compared with the ones in tangent tracks.
(2015).
Simply because in a curve there is a high demand
of lateral load. Measures, like, using friction [6] Thiago B. do Carmo, J. Riley Edwards, Ryan
sleeper, widening the curve, use of under G. Kernes, Bassem Andrawes, Chris P.L.
sleeper-pads, smaller sleeper spacing and Barkan, Laboratory and field investigation on
constraining the sleepers have to be taken to the railpad assembly mechanistic behavior, Joint
increase the track lateral stability. rail Conference 2014, Colorado, USA.
[7] J. Sadeghi, Investigation on the fatigue
phenomena in the railway track fastening
Acknowledgement systems and design of fatigue testing machine,
The authors would like to acknowledge the Research Program Report 348F15, Iranian
contribution made by Dr. Celestin Nkundineza Railway Research Center, (2007).
for his help in understanding the software [8] B.G.J. Holder, Y. Qian, M.S. Dersch, J.R.
program. Edwards, Lateral load performance of concrete
sleeper fastening systems under non-ideal
conditions, Proceedings of the 11th International
Declaration of Conflicting Interests Heavy Haul Association Conference (IHHA
The authors declare no potential conflicts of 2017), Cape Town, South Africa.
interest with respect to the research, authorship [9] B.W. Williams, J.R. Edwards, M.S.
and publication of this article. Dersch, C.P.L. Barkan, R.G. Kernes,
Experimental field investigation of the effects of
lateral load distribution on concrete crosstie
Funding track, AREMA, Annual Conference 2014.
[10] M. Oregui, A. de Man, M.F. Woldekidan, [21] D. Kurhan, Determination of load for quasi-
Z. Li , R. Dollevoet, Obtaining railpad properties static calculations of railway track stress-strain
via dynamic mechanical analysis, Journal of State, Acta Technica Jaurinensis, Vol. 9, No. 1,
Sound and Vibration, 363, (2016), pp. 460–472. (2016), pp. 83-96.
[11] B.J. Van Dyk, J.R. Edwards, C.J. Ruppert [22] Zhe Chen, Mechanistic analysis of concrete
Jr., C.P.L. Barkan, Considerations for crosstie and fastening system using field-
mechanistic design of concrete sleepers and validated Finite Element Model, M.Sc. Thesis,
elastic fastening systems in North America, Rail University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign,
Transportation & Engineering Center (2015).
Downloaded from ijrare.iust.ac.ir at 15:47 IRDT on Monday May 25th 2020