Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development*
Linda M. Veltri, PhD, RN; Halina Barber, PhD, MS, RN
Table 5-1
New Models of Patient Care Delivery
APRN, Advanced practice registered nurse.
Data from: American Nurses Association. (2012, June 29). The Supreme Court decision
matters for registered nurses, their families and patients. Retrieved September 20, 2014, from
http://www.emergingrnleader.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/SupremeCourtDecision-
Analysis.pdf
Institute of Medicine. (2010). The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health.
Washington, DC: National Academics Press and Sherman, R. (2012). 5 ways the Affordable
Care Act could change nursing. Retrieved September 20, 2014, from
http://www.emergingrnleader.com/5-ways-the-affordable-care-act-could-change-nursing/
Technological Explosion
America’s transition from a resource-based, industrial economy
characterized by semiskilled factory workers and raw materials to a
knowledge-based, information-age economy has been reshaping
society for decades. Today technology continues to transform nursing
practice and education. Most recently, nationwide adoption and use
of electronic health record (EHR) systems has required nurses,
educators, and students to “use, navigate, and accurately document in
the EHR” (Winstanley, 2014, p. 62). The American Recovery and
Reinvestment Act of 2009 helped to accelerate the development of
standardized EHRs as a means to capture clinical information that
could be used to improve health outcomes and lower health care
costs. To ensure meaningful use of this new technology and to
function in the increasingly complex health care environments, all
nurses are expected to “have basic computer competencies, be
information literate, and have information management skills”
(Tellez, 2012, p. 230).
High-tech, digitalized nursing practice requires educators to
incorporate concepts related to information technology into the
curriculum and develop teaching strategies requiring students to
access, document, collect, and retrieve health care data and other
information from electronic sources such as the EHR. Inclusion of
informatics education within schools of nursing will assist students to
understand data, combine data and knowledge, and make decisions,
often through the use of technology (Tellez, 2012). As technology
becomes embedded into nursing curricula and health care systems
become increasingly automated and digitalized, nurse educators and
practitioners must remain mindful of the need to balance the essence
of caring and nursing presence at the bedside (Winstanley, 2014).
Technological advancements have also greatly affected nursing
education by offering “new opportunities to enhance and broaden
learning experiences” (Flynn & Vredevoogd, 2010, p. 7), and by
preparing students who are working within complex care
environments to be decision makers (Institute of Medicine, IOM,
2010). As technology evolves, increased numbers of nursing programs
have found that e-learning, simulation, and mobile devices offer much
potential for nursing education (Institute of Medicine, IOM, 2010).
Web-enhanced or online learning in particular provides opportunity
for practicing nurses to pursue educational programs at times
convenient for learners (Institute of Medicine, IOM, 2010; Murray,
McCallum, & Petrosino, 2014). As a result, technology allows for
educational mobility, provides 24/7 access to education and
knowledge, enhances opportunities for teaching and learning or
career advancement, and contributes to the availability of a qualified
nursing workforce (Institute of Medicine, IOM, 2010).
Technology is also responsible, in part, for how educators have
changed their approach to learning in the face-to-face classroom.
Educators increasingly are using the “flipped” classroom approach to
move select content to an online format. Doing so provides students
access to online resources such as voice-over lectures, videos, or links
to additional relevant information as a way to learn foundational or
knowledge-based content prior to attending a face-to-face class
meeting. This instructional strategy allows nurse educators to use
class time for applying content learned to new situations, guiding
students as they engage in problem solving, as well as engaging
students in higher-level thinking (Murray, et al., 2014). Along with the
incorporation of the “flipped” classroom, nursing curriculum should
take into account how students and educators will engage with and
use other available technologies to deliver course content, access
information during class and clinical rotations, complete assignments,
and communicate with each other.
Simulation is another instructional strategy widely incorporated
into nursing curriculum that has come a long way thanks to
technological advances (Hayden, 2010; Sanford, 2010). The advent and
use of medium- or high-fidelity manikins as well as digital recording
capabilities has turned simulation centers into learning environments
demanding high levels of technical expertise and the ability to
authentically simulate real-work nursing practice; they allow students
to learn and practice in a safe environment. Simulation, along with the
use of mobile devices such as smart phones or tablets, teaches
students real-life skills and prepares them for nursing practice in
authentic settings (Institute of Medicine, IOM, 2010; Wolters Kluwer
Health, 2014).
Environmental Challenges
Just as currency more readily crosses borders, so can environmental
and epidemiologic hazards. Besides health issues across the globe,
there are concerns regarding sustainable development, energy
availability, pollution-free water, and climate change, to name a few.
Environmental health involves understanding how the environment
influences human health and disease. It involves an awareness of the
effect that environmental conditions have on the health of individuals
and populations and of interventions that can improve the effect
nurses and others have on the environment and the effect the
environment has on the health of the people (National Institute of
Environmental Health Sciences, 2005; Shaner-McRae, McRae, & Jas,
2007).
Increasingly, Americans are becoming aware that the threats to
public health and life are found in the frailty of our earth and our
delicate interdependence. Therefore it is important for nurses to be
aware that the environment affects our health and that actions in our
professional and personal lives can and do make a difference. Nursing
curricula should address the content and competencies related to
environmental health as well as environmentally responsible clinical
practice. Additionally, curricula should encourage and prepare nurses
to factor environmental issues into the web of disease causation and to
intervene to improve environmental health. The implications of global
warming provide an excellent platform for students to discuss the
ethics of protecting the environment as well as ways to conserve
resources and make educated choices among products that are
environmentally friendly. Excellent environmental health resources
are available on the American Nurses Association website
(http://nursingworld.org/rnnoharm/) and the Alliance of Nurses for
Healthy Environments website (http://www.envirn.org/).
Issues in Higher Education
Institutions of higher education sit at an interesting juncture of at least
two global themes: the technological explosion and globalization. As
learning, knowledge, and skills become the primary resources of a
country, the public and private financing of quality higher education
becomes more challenging. Colleges and universities, faced with
shrinking resources, technological advances, increased enrollments,
and the call for globalization of curricula must strive to find a balance
between innovation and tradition if they are to remain relevant and
current in an ever-changing and evolving world (Flynn &
Vredevoogd, 2010; Hornberger, Eramaa, Helembai, McCartan, &
Turtiainen, 2014). Therefore affordability, access, accountability, and
internationalization continue to be key issues facing higher education.
Each issue affects the other, as affordability determines access and, as
public concerns related to these issues mount, there are increasing
calls for accountability. These challenges must be met in the face of
shrinking public higher education budgets.
Affordability
The concern for affordability, noted as early as 1947, persists today as
economic and societal factors promote an increased value of a college
degree. Current evidence supports that investment in higher
education exceeds the cost of that education in the long run. For
example, for most people, higher education is associated with a secure
lifestyle, significantly increased likelihood of employment, and stable
careers, as well as positive financial earnings. It is also associated with
a healthier, more satisfying life as well as active participation in civic
activities (Baum, Ma, & Payea, 2013). Today, higher education faces
many challenges caused by the current economic situation, increasing
student enrollment, and rising expectations for quality and equity
(Flynn & Vredevoogd, 2010; Heyneman, 2006). Cuts in federal and
state funding have affected publicly funded institutions while
fluctuations in the stock market have contributed to the declining
value of endowments. In short, higher education “will be asked to do
more with less” (Flynn & Vredevoogd, 2010, p. 6).
Because of societal concern for a living wage, the financing of
higher education becomes a crucial public policy debate. Within that
debate, the academy should prepare persuasive arguments for the
merits of education beyond salary, society’s obligation to invest in
human infrastructure, and the importance of public commitment to
higher education. The specific charge for schools of nursing is to
articulate the cost-effective contribution that nursing makes to the
improvement of the health of the nation.
Access
Another issue with historical roots that persists today is access to
higher education. The issue of access is important considering
society’s transformation from an industrial economy to an
information-based, global economy because college graduates have
“substantially better prospects in the labor market than peers who
stop their formal education after high school” (Brock, 2010, p. 110).
While access to higher education has increased substantially for
women, Hispanics, Asians, and Pacific Islanders, other racial and
ethnic groups, such as American Indians and Alaskan Natives, remain
underrepresented (Brock, 2010).
The ability of all Americans to take advantage of the multiple
benefits and opportunities that higher education affords requires
public policies and political will that support access, as well as higher
education institutions that make real those opportunities. As
administrators of nursing schools pursue robust enrollments of
diverse and talented students, affordability and access are crucial
considerations for the profession.
Accountability
Worldwide, governments and the taxpaying public are questioning
the allocation of scarce public resources. The concept of high-quality,
affordable public education is threatened by the competition for
funding of other public needs. This, along with rising fear about the
deterioration of the U.S. higher education system, low completion
rates, and poor preparation of a workforce ready and able to compete
in a global marketplace, led to the formation of the Spelling
Commission. The purpose of this commission was to recommend a
national strategy for postsecondary education reform, with an
emphasis on “how well colleges and universities are preparing
students for the 21st century workforce” (Floyd & Vredevoogd, 2010,
p. 19).
Several forces prompt this increased accountability for higher
education. In times of cost cutting and corporate downsizing, business
and private sector management looks to education, and its products,
for competitive strategies. Also, drastic state budget cuts have caused
policy makers and taxpayers to require justification for higher
education funding. Legislatures have tended to disallow tuition hikes
and request internal moves toward efficiency. Additionally, “publicly
funded institutions must be accountable to their principal stakeholder
—the public” (Floyd & Vredevoogd, 2010, p. 10). Each of these forces
promotes increased public scrutiny and higher expectations.
Accountability therefore becomes a multidirectional force.
Institutions of higher education depend on the government for
funding and are therefore highly accountable to the public for
academic productivity and fiscal prudence. Governments, in response
to their perceived accountability to the public, act to regulate and
reform higher education. Schools of nursing are accountable to state
legislatures, Congress, and the public regarding the preparation of
adequate numbers of competent nurses. This accountability includes
incorporation of and adherence to regulations set forth by state boards
of nursing, accrediting bodies, and others who set standards for
prelicensure and graduate nursing education. Clearly accountability
will continue as a significant theme in higher education.
Internationalization
In higher education internationalization has served to intensify the
“mobility of ideas and of people” in large part because of the
technology explosion that continually shrinks time and space (Egron-
Polak, 2012, p. 1). It is anticipated over the course of the next 10 years
that educational institutes providing English language–based
postsecondary education will experience strong demand from
international students who have the desire to study outside of their
home countries (Ruby, 2013). In turn, institutes of higher education
are increasingly open to attracting more international students as well
as able to offer faculty opportunities to engage in international
research. As a result, new funding sources become available at a time
when academic institutions are struggling financially for reasons
explicated in the preceding discussion on affordability (Egron-Polak,
2012).
Issues Specific to the Nursing Profession
This chapter began by looking through the lens of the broad
socioeconomic and sociopolitical issues that shape the world and
influence contemporary life. This section focuses the lens more
specifically on the nursing profession and highlights issues of
particular consideration within the profession. Included are the
context of nursing care delivery, new and reemerging degrees, and
competencies for the twenty-first century.
Rising Costs
The second trend involves the continued surge in health costs and the
need for hospitals and providers to manage care more efficiently
within finite budgets. Hospital budgets will be challenged by
declining charitable donations and investment income; increasing
numbers of Medicare, Medicaid, and self-pay clients; labor shortages;
and increased pharmaceutical and supply costs (O’Dell, et al., 2011).
Research that documents nursing’s contribution to efficient, quality
care is needed to advocate in budget negotiations and hospital
changes.
Health Policy
Health policy, the third trend, becomes an increasingly significant
strategy to shape, finance, and regulate the health care system. With
the cost of national health expenditures anticipated to rise from 16% to
20% of the gross domestic product (GDP) by 2017, state and federal
policies seek to regulate costs, shift care to less expensive settings, and
use market forces to control costs when possible (Henry J. Kaiser
Family Foundation, 2009; O’Dell, et al., 2011). Ensuring that everyone
in the United States has health insurance is one strategy that would
help reduce health care expenditure to only 18.5% of the GDP (O’Dell,
et al., 2011). The PPACA represents great progress toward making
health care available to and affordable for all Americans. Since its
inception, the number of insured Americans has continued to rise. The
U.S. Census Bureau (2013) reported that in 2012 both the percentage
and number of Americans with health insurance increased to 84.6%
and 263.2 million, up from 84.3% and 260.2 million in 2011.
The number of people covered by private health insurance
continues to drop while increasing numbers receive coverage by
government health insurance. Another feature of the PPACA is the
mandate to revitalize primary and public health care infrastructures
(U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2014). The focus of
health care is shifting away from acute and chronic hospital-based
care toward community-based care. Nursing will continue to be called
on to coordinate collaborative interdisciplinary community-based care
and to act as primary care providers, practicing to the full extent of
their education and training. The expansion of nursing roles under the
PPACA will create a shift in nursing employment statistics and create
additional career opportunities for new graduates (Institute of
Medicine, IOM, 2010).
The predicted shift from hospital-based to community-based
employment has already begun. In 2008, 62.2% of all employed
registered nurses (RNs) worked in hospitals. Currently, more than
50% of nurses work outside the hospital setting (Benner, Sutphen,
Leonard, & Day, 2010). In 2010 the HRSA estimated a 109% increase in
the need for community-based RNs compared with a 36% increased
need for hospital-based RNs by 2020.
In response to this shift in where care is delivered, governing
agencies are recommending that schools of nursing restructure their
curriculums and move away from the traditional primary focus on
acute and chronic hospital-based instruction to one that includes more
team-focused, community-based practice emphasizing policy
technology and leadership development programs (Institute of
Medicine, IOM, 2010; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
2014). Innovative nurse educators are responding to these
recommendations by building collaborative relationships with
patient-centered medical homes and nurse-managed health clinics to
provide nursing students with clinical experiences that demonstrate
the principles of community care, leadership, and client care in
community settings (American Association of Colleges of Nursing,
AACN, 2013).
Emerging Degrees
Two graduate degrees, the clinical nurse leader (CNL) and the doctor
of nursing practice (DNP), have been created and implemented within
the profession in the last decade. These two emerging degrees provide
one example of efforts within the profession to create roles and
curricula to meet changing societal needs for health care.
In 2000, considering declining nursing enrollment among other
professional issues, the AACN determined that changes must be
made in education, practice, licensure, and credentialing. The AACN
recommended a new educational model for a master’s entry, the CNL,
to improve patient care and maximize patient safety (American
Association of Colleges of Nursing, AACN, 2007). To this end, the
CNL is intended to be a leader within all health care settings who
assumes accountability for patient-care outcomes and provides and
manages care to individuals and patient cohorts (American
Association of Colleges of Nursing, AACN, 2013). Other fundamental
aspects of CNL practices are outlined in Box 5-1. Programs to educate
CNLs require ongoing partnerships between practice and education
so that both arenas shape the learning and graduates enter practice
environments designed to use their skill set.
Box 5-1
Fundamental Aspects of CNL Practice
Clinical leadership for patient care practices and delivery, including
the design, coordination, and evaluation of care for individuals,
families, groups, and populations
Participation in identification and collection of care outcomes.
Accountability for evaluation and improvement of point-of-care
outcomes, including the synthesis of data and other evidence to
evaluate and achieve optimal outcomes.
Risk anticipation for individuals and cohorts of patients.
Lateral integration of care for individuals and cohorts of patients.
Design and implementation of evidence-based practices.
Team leadership, management, and collaboration with other health
professional team members.
Information management or the use of information systems and
technologies to improve health care outcomes.
Stewardship and leveraging of human, environmental, and material
resources.
Advocacy for patients, communities, and the health profession.
CNL, Clinical nurse leader.
Source: AACN. (2013). Competencies and curricular expectations for clinical nurse leader
education and practice. Retrieved September 22, 2014, from
http://www.aacn.nche.edu/cnl/CNL-Competencies-October-2013.pdf
Box 5-2
AONE Nurse Leader Competencies
1. Communication and relationship-building competencies
a. Effective communication
b. Relationship management
c. Influencing behaviors
d. Diversity
e. Shared decision-making
f. Community involvement
g. Medical, staff relationships
h. Academic relationships
2. Knowledge of the health care environment
a. Clinical practice knowledge
b. Delivery models, work design
c. Health care economics
d. Health care policy
e. Governance
f. Evidence-based practice, outcome measurement
g. Patient safety
h. Utilization, case management
i. Quality improvement, metrics
j. Risk management
3. Leadership
a. Foundational thinking skills
b. Personal journey disciplines
c. Systems thinking
d. Succession planning
e. Change management
4. Professionalism
a. Personal and professional accountability
b. Career planning
c. Ethics
d. Evidence-based clinical management practice
e. Advocacy
f. Active membership in professional organizations
5. Business skills
a. Financial management
b. Human resource management
c. Strategic management
d. Marketing
e. Information management and technology
AONE, American Organization of Nurse Executives.
Adapted from Nurse Executive Competencies, copyright 2011, by the American Organization
of Nurse Executives (AONE). All rights reserved.
More than a decade ago, Bellack and O’Neil (2000) discussed the
recommendations from the Pew Health Professions Commission’s
fourth and final report, which represented a continuing effort to
support the health professions’ education reform and align
educational programs more fully with the health needs of the
population. They presented five recommendations for all health
professions schools, including nursing: (1) update professional
training to meet new health care demands, (2) ensure diversity in the
health professions workforce, (3) require interdisciplinary
competence, (4) continue to move health care education into the
ambulatory care setting, and (5) encourage health care students to
engage in public service. Despite being issued more than 10 years ago,
these recommendations continue to provide excellent guideposts for
nurse educators as they pursue the preferred future via the current
reality.
In many respects, nursing education is still grappling with
developing educational models that successfully address the Pew
Commission’s recommendations from 2000. Most recently, the IOM’s
(2010) report offers a new set of recommendations that call for
significant changes in how nurses are educated and prepared for
practice in an era of health care reform. The four key messages
delivered in the Future of Nursing report are that nurses should: (1) be
able to practice to the full scope of their educational preparation; (2)
seek higher levels of educational preparation, and be able to do so in
seamless academic progression systems; (3) function as full partners in
interdisciplinary teams to redesign health care delivery; and (4)
benefit from improved data collection and information
infrastructures. The IOM report promises to be influential in focusing
attention on solutions to the barriers that have kept nurses from being
as influential as they can be in leading and advocating for changes in
health care.
Strategies to Identify Influential Forces and
Issues
The forces and issues that influence the nursing profession and
curriculum originate in the external, higher education, and internal
environments. This section presents strategies that may be useful to
nurse leaders in identifying these influences.
Environmental Scanning
“Strategic planning is critical to the survival of health care
organizations in today’s turbulent environment” (Layman &
Bamberg, 2005, p. 200). Environmental scanning, a component of
strategic planning, involves various activities that monitor and
evaluate information from the external environment (Layman &
Bamberg, 2005). The goal of environmental scanning is for leaders and
managers to become aware of general trends and events affecting
health care and higher education generally and nursing specifically.
Information from the environment can be acquired in various ways,
including careful review of scientific and professional journals as well
as lay literature and newspapers and attendance and networking at
professional meetings. Information gathered from these activities
becomes “the basis of future initiatives” (Layman & Bamberg, 2005, p.
200).
Environmental scanning continues to be successfully used by
colleges and universities to determine the context of the forces
affecting curriculum development. For example, use of strategic
environmental scanning led one southeastern university to develop a
non–nurse practitioner program designed to prepare nurses for other
types of advanced practice roles. Following review of program
evaluations and assessment of graduates and other nursing leaders in
the community, the Master of Science in Nursing in Advanced Care
Management and Leadership program was developed with the goal
of preparing nurse leaders who are “equipped to manage and
improve client care outcomes” (Aduddell & Dorman, 2010, p. 171).
In curriculum development, environmental scanning allows faculty
to be simultaneously reactive and proactive. Through awareness and
acknowledgment of significant trends (reactive), faculty can more
actively choose a future direction for nursing education and
curriculum (proactive). The use of environmental scanning as a
strategy to obtain a broad scope of information and evaluate its
relevance to nursing is the foundation of the other strategies that
follow.
Strategic Planning
Often educators, leaders, and managers are so preoccupied with the
“tyranny of the urgent” that they lose sight of their ultimate goals and
objectives. Strategic planning is one strategy educators and
organizations can use for quality checks, assessments, planning, or
analysis. A strategic plan serves as a framework for decisions,
provides a foundation for detailed planning, is used to explain “the
business” to others, assists with benchmarking and performance
monitoring, and stimulates change (PlanWare, 2014).
The process of strategic planning may include the use of the
Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats (SWOT) analysis.
Educators charged with curriculum development or redesign can use
SWOT to guide development and analysis of curricular objectives and
key strategies to meet them. SWOT can also be used as an
instructional strategy to assist students with job searching and career
planning (Weiss & Tappen, 2015).
Epidemiology
Epidemiology is the study of the distribution and determinants of
states of health and illness in human populations. Epidemiology
provides nursing faculty with systematic ways to understand patterns
of disease, characteristics of people at high risk for disease,
environmental factors, and shifts in demographic characteristics of the
population. Using epidemiologic data with groups or populations,
nurses understand and document the need for programs and policies
to reduce risk and promote health. Epidemiology can therefore be
seen as a method for planned change.
In the same way, nursing faculty responsible for the development of
curriculum can use epidemiological data and methods to understand
factors affecting the health of populations and trends occurring in
health and illness states. Epidemiologic analysis provides faculty with
methods for understanding that part of the context that involves the
broad determinants of health and patterns of disease and disability in
the population.