Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Denhardt,
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
1. Understanding the value of a merit system in government employment
2. Learning about the activities of the human resources function
3. Understanding the importance of collective bargaining and labor-management relations
4. Learning about issues that affect human resources, such as diversity and discrimination
5. Understanding the relationship between the political and career administrators
SUMMARY OVERVIEW
The concept of a merit-based civil service personnel system serves as a principal organizing
feature of this chapter. The authors address the importance of managing the people who work in
government organizations and examine the reasons behind the rules, regulations, and “red tape”
that often appear as roadblocks to effective personnel management. The chapter covers the rise of
the spoils system in the United States and the move to reform the civil service based on merit
rather than political favoritism, including the creation of the Pendleton Act, the Civil Service
Reform Act, and more recent efforts at “reinvention.” The discussion also addresses the ways in
which these reforms have been adopted at the state and local levels.
Chapter 6 also examines the main components of the personnel function, including classification
systems, recruiting, and pay systems. Conditions of employment also are addressed in this
section, as those who hire and manage government employees must be concerned with issues of
drug use, sexual harassment in the workplace, the rights of individuals with HIV/AIDS, violence
in the workplace, and processes for removing employees.
A key component of this chapter is a detailed discussion about the changes in the relationship
between labor and management in the public sector and the rise and decline of public-sector
unions. The authors trace the history of public-sector unions, outlining the conditions that led to
their development and affecting their growth. Labor-management relations at the federal level
also are contrasted with those at the state and local levels. This section offers a detailed
description of the steps in the bargaining process and discusses the implications of the decision on
the part of employees to strike. This section closes with a look at recent efforts to limit collective
bargaining rights for public employees at the federal, state and local levels.
The chapter then moves to an examination of fundamental issues of discrimination in public
employment, which includes a review of the development and purpose of equal employment
opportunity and affirmative action programs and the Americans with Disabilities Act. The
authors detail the varying approaches to enforcing compliance among employers as defined by
federal guidelines and key court decisions and discuss recent developments in attempts to correct
past patterns of discrimination against women and minorities through affirmative action. This
section also includes an examination of the problems of extending diversity throughout public
organizations and the gaps that still are being experienced by women and minorities in terms of
pay, job status, and overall employment opportunity.
The final section of the chapter deals with the difficult relations between political appointees and
career executives. The authors argue that the tension between political responsiveness and
managerial effectiveness that characterizes public administration is illustrated particularly well in
the relationship between political appointees and career public executives. As appointees become
“bosses” of career civil servants, tensions may arise because the political appointee wishes to
move in new policy directions but often has little experience in government operations while the
career executive has both knowledge and expertise but, aware of potential problems, may appear
reluctant to change. The attempt to reconcile the two positions, the authors note, brings the focus
back to the question of politics and administration.
CHAPTER OUTLINE
I. MERIT SYSTEMS IN PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT
A. Spoils versus Merit
Public Administration in History: THE SPOILS SYSTEM
Exploring Concepts: PRINCIPLES OF CIVIL SERVICE
B. The Civil Service Reform Act and Its Aftermath
C. Reinvention and the National Performance Review
D. State and Local Personnel Systems
II. HIRING, FIRING, AND THINGS IN BETWEEN
A. Classification Systems
B. The Recruitment Process
C. Pay Systems
D. Conditions of Employment and Related Matters
E. Sexual Harassment
F. AIDS Policy
G. Workplace Violence
H. Removing Employees
I. Personnel Reform Efforts
Public Administration Reform: URGENT BUSINESS FOR AMERICA
III. THE CHANGING CHARACTER OF LABOR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS
A. Steps in the Bargaining Process
B. To Strike or Not to Strike
C. Unions Redefined
IV. CORRECTING PATTERNS OF DISCRIMINATION IN PUBLIC
EMPLOYMENT
A. Americans with Disabilities Act
B. Questions of Compliance
C. Affirmative Action and Reverse Discrimination
Take Action: ADVANTAGES OF DIVERSITY
D. The Glass Ceiling
E. Relations between Political Appointees and Career Executives
V. SUMMARY AND ACTION IMPLICATIONS
LECTURE LAUNCHERS
1. Discuss the problems associated with the spoils system in the United States using notable
examples such as the election of Andrew Jackson, the rise of Tammany Hall, and the
administration of Chicago Mayor Richard J. Daley (related information is widely
available on the Internet). In these examples, what advantages did the spoils system
provide? What problems did it create? Why was the move to reform the civic service
system necessary?
2. Recent actions in Wisconsin, Ohio, and New Jersey represent increasing efforts to limit
collective bargaining rights. Discuss these recent events, including the factors that gave
rise to them, and explore the implications for public employees.
3. What is the difference between “equal employment opportunity” and “affirmative
action?” Define each, discuss the purpose of each, and explore what factors gave rise to
these programs.
IN-CLASS ACTIVITIES
1. Using the links in the Web Links section below along with sources for state and local
personnel offices, have students either individually or in teams explore what kinds of
government jobs are available in your area. Students should address: (1) types of
positions that are typically available; (2) salary levels to expect for entry at the bachelor’s
or master’s level; (3) benefits associated with these positions; and (4) hiring processes for
applicants.
2. Divide the class into groups of 3 to 4 students; give each student a copy of your school’s
policy on sexual harassment with regard to administrators, faculty, staff, and students.
Have each group analyze the policy addressing the following:
(a) Is sexual harassment defined in a way that is understandable?
(b) Does the policy specify the kinds of actions that are considered harassment?
(c) Are procedures clearly defined through which sexual harassment charges can be
brought and heard?
(d) Are penalties clearly defined for each action?
(e) Does the policy act as a deterrent to sexual harassment.
(f) What can be done to strengthen, clarify, and more easily enforce the policy?
KEY TERMS
Adverse or disparate impact Criterion for showing that employment practices affect one group
more harshly than another.
Affirmative action Use of positive, results-oriented practices to ensure that women, minorities,
individuals with disabilities, and other protected classes of people will be equitably
represented in an organization.
Bargaining unit The organization that will represent employees in conferring and negotiating
various issues.
Comparable worth Notion that men and women in jobs that are not identical but require similar
levels of skill and training should be paid equally.
Equal employment opportunity Refers to efforts to eliminate employment discrimination on
the basis of race, ethnic background, sex, age, or physical handicap; ensures that all
persons have an equal chance to compete for employment and promotions based on job
qualifications.
Final-offer arbitration Technique in which both parties must present their best offer with the
understanding that an arbitrator will choose one or the other without modification.
Job description A thorough analysis of the work to be done and the capabilities for a job;
typically contains these elements: job title, duties required, responsibilities, and job
qualifications.
Lateral entry Entry into government positions at any level.
Merit pay Increases in salary and wages that are tied to actual quality of work performed.
Merit principle Concept that selection and treatment of government employees should be based
on merit or competence rather than personal or political favoritism.
Position classification Analyzing and organizing jobs on the basis of duties, responsibilities, and
knowledge and skills required to perform them.
Rule of three Provision of most merit systems that requires at least the names of the top three
applicants be forwarded to the hiring official to allow some flexibility in selection.
Sexual harassment Any unwarranted and nonreciprocal verbal or physical sexual advances or
derogatory remarks that the recipient finds offensive or that interfere with his/her job
performance.
Spoils system The ability to give government jobs to the party faithful; “to the victor belong the
spoils.”
Structured interviews Those in which a previously developed set of questions is used with each
applicant.
Unit determination Decision to include or exclude certain groups in a bargaining unit.
Whipsaw tactics Argument that pay or benefits negotiated by one group should be applied to
others.
WEB LINKS
The following are links to information on general personnel issues, human resources,
and jobs:
Office of Personnel Management: (www.opm.gov).
U.S. Equal Opportunity Employment Commission: (www.eeoc.gov).
United States Department of Labor: (www.dol.gov).
HR.Com: (www.hr.com) and (www.hr-guide.com).
LaborNet: (www.labornet.org).
American Federation of Government Employees: (www.afge.org/).
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees: (www.afscme.org/).
International Personnel Management Association: (www.ipma-hr.org).
International Public Management Association for Human Resources: (http://www.ipma-hr.org/).
Society for Human Resource Management: (www.shrm.org).
Public Service Careers: (www.publicservicecareers.org/).
Go Public Service: (www.gopublicservice.org/Careers.aspx).
FedWorld.Gov: (www.fedworld.gov/).
Careers in Government: (www.careersingovernment.com/index.cfm).
GovtJob.Net: (www.govtjob.net/).
USA Jobs: (www.usajobs.opm.gov/infocenter/howjobsgetfilled.asp).
The Chronicle of Philanthropy: (http://philanthropy.com/section/Jobs/224/).
Opportunity Knocks: (www.opportunityknocks.org/).
INSTRUCTOR RESOURCES
Bowman, J. S., J. P. West, and M. A. Beck. Achieving Competencies in Public Service: The
Professional Edge. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 2009.
Capozzoli, Thomas, and R. Steven McVey. Managing Violence in the Workplace. Delray Beach,
FL: St. Lucie Press, 1996.
Rice, Mitchell F., ed. Diversity and Public Administration: Theory, Issues, and Perspectives.
Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 2010.
Risher, Howard, Charles H. Fay, et al. New Strategies for Public Pay. San Francisco: Jossey-
Bass, 1997.
Robinson, Dana Gaines, and James C. Robinson. Performance Consulting. San Francisco: Berrett
Koehler Publishers, 1995.
Selden, Sally Coleman. The Promise of Representative Bureaucracy. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe,
1997.
Shafritz, Jay M., Albert C. Hyde, and David H. Rosenbloom. Personnel Management in
Government: Politics and Process. 4th ed. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1991.
Sloane, Arthur A., and Fred Witney. Labor Relations. 8th ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-
Hall, 1994.
Stivers, Camilla. Gender Images in Public Administration: Legitimacy and the Administrative
State. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 2002.
Sylvia, Ronald D., and C. Kenneth Meyer. Public Personnel Administration. Fort Worth, TX:
Harcourt College Publishers, 2002.
4. Among the goals of the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 were
a. to increase the technical nature of personnel administration.
b. to reduce flexibility in hiring and firing to agencies.
c. to create a more rigid classification system for senior executives.
d. to restore the merit principle which had gotten too bureaucratic.
ANS: a
6. In recent years state and local merit systems in the personnel function
a. have contracted as a result of due process requirements based on court decisions.
b. have become weaker as a result of pressure from the federal government.
c. have been strengthened as a result of expanding public employees’ due process protection
provided by courts.
d. have been dominated by political party machines.
ANS: c
7. The arrangement of jobs on the basis of their duties, responsibilities, and skills is prepared in
a. position classifications.
b. job descriptions.
c. equal employment opportunity programs.
d. an assessment center.
ANS: a
8. A document containing job title, duties, responsibilities, and qualifications for employment is
called
a. a position classification.
b. a job description.
c. an equal employment opportunity form.
d. an assessment form.
ANS: b
11. Drug testing of public employees frequently has been challenged in court because
a. public employees are less likely to use drugs.
b. public employees are more clearly protected against illegal search and seizure.
c. public employees are being tested more often.
d. public employees can’t be held responsible for their actions.
ANS: c
12. Which of the following is not an example of behavior and remarks that may be defined as sexual
harassment in the workplace?
a. “Say, honey, would you get the coffee”?
b. A suggestive remark directed to a subordinate by a supervisor
c. Deliberate brushing or touching of another person.
d. Reciprocal verbal sexual advances between co-workers
ANS: d
13. Which of the following may contribute to the likelihood of workplace violence in public
organizations?
a. Reducing operating hours, hiring security guards, and increasing lighting
b. Pay disparities, personal problems, and bad management
c. Political environment, deterioration in public perception of government workers, and
increased worker stress
d. Changes in physical environment, lack of recognition from political superiors, and limits
on collective bargaining
ANS: c
17. Recent actions in Wisconsin, Ohio, and New Jersey involved efforts to
a. curb benefits and collective bargaining rights for public employees.
b. give public employees greater access to public-sector unions.
c. lower employees’ contributions for health care and pensions.
d. reduce salary levels for public employees.
ANS: a
18. The effort to see to it that women, minorities, and others will be employed in fair numbers or
proportions in an organization is called
a. equal employment opportunity.
b. reverse discrimination.
c. discrimination.
d. affirmative action.
ANS: d
19. The basic federal legislation governing employment practices with respect to equity and related
issues is the
a. Civil Rights Act of 1964.
b. Employment Discrimination Act of 1960.
c. Affirmative Action Act of 1970.
d. American Disabilities Act of 1990.
ANS: a
22. The tension between political responsiveness and managerial effectiveness is illustrated by
a. the relationship between managers and staff employees.
b. the relationship between personnel officers and mangers.
c. the relationship between political appointees and career executives.
d. the relationship between union leaders and agency managers.
ANS: c
23. Which of the following is not one of the reasons put forth for involving career public
administrators in developing policy?
a. They have the background and expertise to make substantial contributions.
b. They have the capacity to override political decisions on policy changes.
c. They will implement a policy more effectively if they understand the need for the change.
d. They will do a better job of implementation if they feel some “ownership” of the process.
ANS: b
24. The traditional emphasis of the personnel officer of a public sector agency has been
a. to induce compliance.
b. to support managers in a consulting role.
c. to help increase productivity.
d. to persuade managers to become more effective.
ANS: a
25. Which of the following is likely not a new role for the personnel specialist in a public
organization?
a. The elimination of hiring, retention, promotion, and compensation procedures
b. Participation in development of affirmative action programs
c. Assistance in developing a productivity improvement program in the organization
d. Advise on legal issues
ANS: a
CHAPTER 6—TRUE-FALSE
1. Important features of the spoils system are merit selection, tenure protection, and responsiveness
to political leaders.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
2. The Civil Service Reform Act created the Office of Personnel Management and the Merit
Systems Review Board.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
3. The states and localities of the United States have generally been in advance of the federal
government in establishing a merit-based civil service system.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
4. An important reason for using position classification systems, beyond that of connecting tasks to
the skills required to perform them, is to help ensure equity across similar jobs.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
5. While a “step” is a set of roughly comparable jobs, “grades” are a set of pay increments.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
6. Drug testing programs have steadily increased in the last two decades.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
7. Sexual harassment is defined as “any unwanted and nonreciprocal verbal or physical advances or
derogatory remarks that are found offensive by the recipient or that interfere with one’s job
performance.”
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
10. Labor-management relations at the state and local level are fairly standard and uniform in nature.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
11. In recent years, there has been greater support for public-sector unions at the federal level
although support at the state and local level has declined.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
12. “Affirmative action” refers to the obligation of an organization to take positive steps to hire,
retain, and promote minorities, women, and others.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
13. Support for equal opportunity programs has grown over the past two decades.
a. True
b. False
ANS: b
14. Recent actions by the courts have had the effect of narrowing what can be considered as
discrimination.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
15. The term “glass ceiling” refers to barriers that exist to the advancement of women and minorities
in the workplace.
a. True
b. False
ANS: a
CHAPTER 6—ESSAYS/DISCUSSION
1. Describe and evaluate the “merit principle” in the civil service system. What does it mean? Why
was it established?
2. Two significant pieces of legislation—the Pendleton Act and the Civil Service Reform Act—have
been instrumental in shaping the federal civil service. Discuss the importance of each. Why was
each necessary?
3. Even after the federal government created its civil service system, states and localities were slow
to adopt the same reforms. Discuss the reasons for this. What contributed to the reluctance of
states and localities to follow suit?
4. What are the main steps in the recruitment process in the federal civil service? Describe each
briefly.
5. In what ways may sexual harassment and ethics in the workplace be related? Does an ethical
workplace demand absolute gender blindness? Explain.
6. Describe the history of the development of unions in federal employment.
7. Compare the reasons for prohibiting public employee strikes with reasons given in support of the
right to strike. What conclusions can be reached? Explain.
8. Identify the principal components of an affirmative action program for an organization.
9. Evaluate “comparable worth,” summarizing the arguments pro and con. What position do you
take? Pay special attention to the equity issues involved.
10. The authors argue that the tension between political responsiveness and managerial effectiveness
that characterizes public management is particularly well illustrated in the relationship between
political appointees and career executives. Explain this. What do they mean by this? Give
examples.