Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashapuri
Resurrecting a
Medieval Temple Site
Adam Hardy
Ashapuri
Resurrecting a
Medieval Temple Site
335
thousands of the fragm ents, revealing the Whether or not the new form was invented
bases of som e twenty-six tem ples. This site is here, the site exhibits the kind of thinking
known nowadays as the Bhutanatha (usually underlying that invention, with its
Bhootnath, i.e. Lord of Ghosts) group of experim en tation in com posite tem ple design s
tem ples, after the nam e given locally to the and its awareness of different regional
largest of them , num bered Tem ple 21. tr ad ition s.
Whether their destruction is due to With O.P. Mishra’s encouragem ent, I had
natural or hum an causes is still uncertain: recently begun to take a m ore sustained
earthquake or warfare? An ythin g beyon d the in terest in Ashapuri, when the opportun ity
eleven th cen tury is con spicuously absen t arose to work on the site as part of a larger
from the Bhutanatha group, and from Bilota. project funded by World Monum ents Fund
So, did the sam e calam ity that halted work at (WMF) in partnership with DAAM, set up to
Bhojpur spell the end of Ashapuri at the sam e develop con servation strategies for im portan t
tim e? architectural sites un der the protection of the
The full historical and architectural Governm ent of Madhya Pradesh.2 For m any of
significance of Ashapuri and Bhojpur can only the sites, the task is to preserve and
be understood if the two sites are considered sen sitively en han ce the often crum blin g fabric
together. Stylistic peculiarities at Bhojpur of relatively intact structures. In the case of
point to Ashapuri as the m ain source for Ashapuri, any m eaningful plan depends on
m asons. Used to carving exquisite detail for first attem pting, on paper initially, to
sm all, intim ately related shrines, the shift to reconstruct the designs of the m onum ents that
the cyclopean scale of Bhojpur m ust have were there, and to ascertain which of them
been as bewildering as it had been for their could potentially be there once again if
Chola counterparts a few years earlier, enough pieces of the jigsaw puzzle rem ain.
accustom ed to alpav im an as an d called to The larger puzzle, in the Bhutanatha
build the Brihadishvara at Thanjavur. The group alon e, con sists of twen ty-six sm aller
Bhojpur tem ple as it stands is not obviously a puzzles, som ewhat jum bled together an d on ly
Bhum ija tem ple, although I have argued provision ally sorted, with m an y pieces
elsewhere that it was intended to be; but, m issing. To search across the site for a given
regardless of this, its detailing and am ple other piece is often m ade difficult by vegetation,
evidence at the site show it to be the creation especially during and after the m onsoon.
of craftsm en specialising in this new form of Som e pieces are at the site m useum , or the
tem ple that the Param aras m ade their State Archaeology Museum or the Birla
preferred on e, exem plified m ost gloriously in Museum in Bhopal. Ideally, it m ight be m ost
the Udayeshvara tem ple at Udayapur fruitful to work on the whole site at once and
(dedicated in 10 8 0 CE ).
Unlike other tem ple reveal all the tem ple designs in one go, but
form s, the Bhum ija appears as if it has been realities dem and that the work should proceed
in ven ted rather than havin g evolved sequentially. For each tem ple, in turn, we are
gradually. Beyond its legacy to Bhojpur of a m aking a photographic database of the
new tem ple m ode and—in term s of the fragm ents, with key dim ensions. As each
characteristics and hallm arks of the school of n um bered batch in evitably con tain s pieces
m asons—a new style, Ashapuri holds am ong from several of the m onum ents, a sense of the
its scattered fragm ents the rem ains of what character of all the different tem ples is
m ust be the earliest known Bhum ija tem ples. em er gin g.
Art, Icon and
Architecture
in South Asia
336
337
338
339
Fig. 24.4. Ganesha from west bhadra of Temple 17, now of an upward growth of the bhadra elem ent
at Ashapuri site museum. into the base of the shikhara (cf. Fig. 24.10 ).
The shikhara has four bhum is (levels). Five
tem ple. In the bhadras we do not find Surya, would be m ore usual for a pancharatha plan:
as gen erally seen , un problem atically, in com parable tem ple designs at Terahi (Shiva
central Indian Surya tem ples of the ninth tem ple) and Um ri (Surya tem ple) have
century, such as those at Mandkheda and respectively five an d seven bhum is. Yet the
Um ri. We have Karttikeya, Ganesha (Fig. profile is elegant and not at all stunted. The
24.4), and Kubera, no doubt in the south, west pratilatas, like the karnas, are articulated with
and north, respectively. The south kapili n iche am alaka-topped kutas, giving a ‘double
contained an im age of Parvati in penance, the venukosha’ (Fig. 24.5). Construction is in eight
north kapili niche Durga Mahishasuram ardini. courses of even height throughout, each
Each karna face displays a niche containing a com prising two m ouldings. While m any of the
Dikpala (guardian of the direction). karnas are m ade from two blocks, with a
Over the jangha, the v arandika (cornice vertical joint, the latas and pratilatas are
zone), typically, consists of a pair of kapotali carved together from single large blocks. The
m ouldings with a tulasangraha (joist-end ghanta at the sum m it of the shikhara would
m oulding) in between. In the bhadras and the have consisted of the usual griva (neck),
kapili, the top gavaksha of the udgam a am alaka, padm ashirshaka (in verted lotus
penetrates the lower kapotali – the beginnings m oulding) and kalasha (pot-finial).
Art, Icon and
Architecture
in South Asia
340
Fig. 24.5. Temple 17, course from lata/pratilatas. m ulaprasada (shrine proper) can be worked
out with a fair degree of certainty; and
TEMPLE 5 sections of the tem ple could be put together to
Tem ple 5, belonging to around the end of the m ake sense for the visitor. The carving retains
ninth century or the beginning of the tenth, is m uch of the sensuousness of the three-
am ong the m ost lavish of the Pratihara cen turies old m ain stream cen tral In dian
tem ples at Ashapuri. Only around twenty Nagara tradition that created it, while arriving
percent of the stone fragm ents from this at an unprecedented degree of proliferation in
tem ple have so far been located. Others m ay its saptaratha (seven -projection ) plan ,
com e to light in different parts of the site, but deducible from the elaborate pitha, which has
reassem bly does not seem at present to be a survived reason ably in tact (Fig. 24.6). This
viable option. However, the design of the west-facin g tem ple would have com prised the
341
342
343
344
Fig. 24.10. Temple 5, miniature shikhara over the bhadra lower Deccan, and links with the south are
penetrating the base of the lata. evident in m any aspects of Bhum ija
m onum ents, including the pillar type used
the Chandellas and Kachchhapaghatas to the ubiquitously, the v edi m ouldin g form in g the
north of Malwa, and of the western Indian skandha platform at the top of the shikhara,
schools that coalesced in western India into the form of the m ahanasi at the base of the
the widespread Maru-Gurjara style. lata spine (Fig. 24.12), and indeed the whole
The next shift is different. While the bhadra elem ent of which this is the crown,
Nagara schools go on developing the new term ed the shala in the
‘Bhum ija tradition’, as it m ay be called, though Sam aranganasutradhara. That text – like
not isolated from those strands, shows a
distinct character that gives the im pression of
havin g arisen through deliberate choice an d
through con tacts with m ore southerly,
Deccani practices. The already known Bhum ija
tem ples of central India are m anifestly the
creations of guilds or workshops specialising
in that m ode. Moulding shapes are precise,
m an y with pron oun ced double flexion s, an d
with a certain hardness counterbalanced by a
linear, graphic quality bound up with the
process of drawing on the stone before cutting
and carving it. This general character also Fig. 24.11. Udgama from a tenth-century temple
takes hold during the eleventh century in the at Ashapuri.
Ashapuri:
Resurrecting a
Medieval
Temple Site
345
Fig. 24.12. Part of one of the mahanasis over a bhadra m y earlier sense that there we can see
from the Bhutanatha temple, Ashapuri. som ething of a transition. The style as well as
the form of the Bhum ija m onum ents is
Bhojpur, another of Bhoja’s m onum ental different from the start, though it is difficult to
enterprises – also specifies for given Bhum ija unravel whether this was through a local effort
tem ple types that particular elem en ts should to transform the way things were done,
be either Nagara or Dravida.4 The Dravida (or assim ilating foreign influences and perhaps
dravidakarm a) kuta is widespread in Bhum ija with an influx of artists from elsewhere, or
tem ples, often visible as a constituent elem ent
of the kutas (m iniature shikharas) crowning
the kutastam bhas. Whereas the kutastam bhas
of the early Bhum ija tem ple at Bilota are
crowned by m iniature Latina shikharas, those
of the Bhutanatha (Fig. 24.13) already have
com posite kutas, with lesser, dim in utive kutas
on the corn ers that m ay have been con ceived
as Dravida.
At Ashapuri, the Bhum ija wave arrived
som etim e around the last years of the tenth
century. Regardless of whether this was where
that wave was set in m otion, a fascinating
aspect of the site is that it rolls out am ong the
plentiful currents of the continuing Nagara Fig. 24.13. Fragment of kutastambhas from a Bhumija
tradition. However, I am beginning to doubt shikhara at Ashapuri, probably the Bhutanatha.
Art, Icon and
Architecture
in South Asia
346
Fig. 24.14. Part of a lata from a Bhumija shikhara, orthogon al, n o doubt created before the
probably from the Bhutanatha. stellate possibilities of the Bhum ija m ode were
developed, although star shapes begin to
whether the Bhum ija works could som ehow be appear in the ceilings of the Bhutanatha. The
the products of an entirely new school. But earliest of the Bhum ija m onum ents seem s to
where would they have com e from ? H owever, be the exquisite little Bilota tem ple. Of the
it m ay have happened, the sensuous, Bhutanatha, the pitha rem ains (Fig. 24.15),
vivacious sculpture, an d a delight in lin earity with som e pieces of the khura (hoof) and of the
(Fig. 24.14) an d crisp, curvaceous m ouldin gs, lower part of the separate kum bha. The plan of
give the creations of Ashapuri at the turn of the Bhutanatha, visible in the pitha, is of an
the eleventh century a freshness and life that east-facing tem ple with the m ain shrine to the
subsequent Bhum ija m onum ents rarely live up west, and with two half-shrines projecting
to. Bhojpur, in its sheer scale, is inevitably from the sides of the m andapa to the north
drier in quality. and south. This alm ost trikuta arrangem ent is
The Bhum ija works so far discovered one of the aspects redolent of Deccani
am ong the tem ple bases and fragm ents at connections. Of these southern links, the m ost
Ashapuri and neighbouring Bilota are the rem arkable m anifestation is found in
sm all one at the latter site, the large fragm ents, probably from the Bhutanatha, of
Bhutanatha and two adjacent shrines, and Dravida kutas (Fig. 24.16). Though not what a
an other sm all tem ple presen tly outside the south Indian sthapati would recognise as
gate of the Bhutanatha com pound. All are Dravida, these are far from the ultra-stylised
Ashapuri:
Resurrecting a
Medieval
Temple Site
347
Fig. 24.15. Pitha of the Bhutanatha, west side. examples to draw upon, it could lay out the
possibilities inherent in the system . Surviving
dravida karm akutas found in m ost Bhum ija Bhum ija tem ples are relatively close to the
tem ples, which hardly an yon e recogn ises as prescriptions of the Sam aranganasutradhara,
Dravida. Over the kapota, as seen in the m ost no doubt because the theory and practice
intact of these fragm ents found so far, instead developed side by side. But the Bhumija works
of the usual curly leaf passing for the prati/ at Ashapuri were alm ost certainly built before
v y alam ala m ouldin g—what the the text was written, and would have loomed
Sam aranganasutradhara calls the m akera— large in the minds of those who were working
we see a clutch of m agnificent, fully-fledged out the theory.
m akaras frothing out over a jewelled prati or While hundreds of fragm ents from the
floor-plan k m ouldin g. 5 Bhutanatha tem ple have been laid out at the
Only after such a moment could the site, m any m ore rem ain strewn down the ghat
Sam aranganasutradhara have been and into the tank, accessible only when the
conceived, with its awareness of the range of tank is dry. A good season of salvage
architectural form s and regional varieties, of archaeology is required before the jigsaw
the hitherto predom inant Nagara traditions, puzzle can be solved for this jewel in the crown
and of the Dravida too, and with the desire both of the con servation project. To un derstan d the
to incorporate and to surpass these in a newly significance of each puzzled out tem ple, it is
created form, the Bhumija. Chapter 65, on necessary to reflect not only on the site as a
Bhumija temples, stands out for its coherence whole, but on the m uch larger picture that is
and its complexity. With an invented form, the the architectural history of cen tral In dia, an d
text did not need to incorporate passages from of In dian tem ple architecture m ore broadly.
venerated earlier texts. Without m any built In turn, each newly revealed tem ple design
Art, Icon and
Architecture
in South Asia
348