Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ACADEMY
(A Project of Al-Bahria CSS Institute)
DAWN Editorials: 15 October 2023, Sunday
Repugnant racism
The ongoing conflict in Palestine has brought out the worst amongst many self-professed democrats
in the West, as they have cheered on Israel`s excesses, and participated in the dehumanisation of the
Palestinians. Particularly galling are efforts by the US administration to block a ceasefire and give
Gaza`s besieged population a breather. When asked recently about calls for a ceasefire, the White
House press secretary termed these calls `repugnant ... and disgraceful`. Moreover, as reported in the
American media, a State Department memo has advised US diplomats against using phrases such as
`restoring calm, end to violence/bloodshed` and `de-escalation/ceasefire`. From the looks of it,
Washington has given Israel the green light to carry on its butchery of the Palestinian people, while
drowning out calls for ending the violence. Other members of the Western fraternity are no better.
France has banned pro-Palestine rallies to preserve `public order`. Ironically, in the land of liberté,
egalité and fraternité, these vaunted ideals are out of bounds for Palestinians or those who
sympathise with them. In the UK, the ultra-hawkish home secretary has asked police to consider
banning Palestinian flags and chants. While the Western states never tire of touting the sanctity of
free speech, apparently this right is again only reserved for those critical of Palestine, and supportive
of Israel. Back in the US, there have been reports that students and activists who have participated in
pro-Palestine events have been harassed, or visited by FBI agents.
These developments seem to indicate that to the Western elite, Israel represents `us`, to be mourned
and avenged, while the Palestinians are symbolic of `them`, to be damned and preferably eliminated.
While anti-Semitism reviling Jewish people is unacceptable, anti-Zionism the critique of Israel`s
founding philosophy is kosher, as is criticism of Israel`s violent history of Palestinian repression.
Israel is a colonial settler state that was established with the blessings of empire, by ethnically
cleansing the native Arab population. Over the past seven decades, it has fine-tuned violence against
the Palestinian people, and what occurred last Saturday was the result of 75 years of repression,
humiliation and murder. At its core, the Palestinian struggle is one of liberation and dignity. Perhaps
that is why people across the Muslim world, as well as the Global South, and conscientious citizens in
the West, stand in solidarity with Palestine. What is repugnant is not the call to end violence in Gaza,
but Western hypocrisy and racism towards the Palestinians. Quite obviously, many Western
governments and segments of the Western media have shown that they stand with the oppressor, and
refuse to consider Palestinians as human beings. Next time the great and the good in the West lecture
others about human rights, their stand on Palestine`s civilian population will render their rhetoric
hollow.
Victories against the Netherlands by 81 runs and Sri Lanka.-. where Babar`s men had
chased down a World Cup record score of 344 had, in a way, masked those frailties. India,
though, capitalised on those weaknesses. There was a welcome return to form for Babar,
who struck 50, but once Pakistan`s batting mainstay departed, no one really stood up and
took responsibility. The in-form Mohammad Rizwan who shared an 82-run stand with
Babar for the third wicket made just two runs after his captain`s dismissal before being
sent back for 49. There seemed to be no plan in place to limit the damage, and worse still,
Pakistan were sent packing in the 43rd over. Babar appeared to be at a loss for words to
explain the collapse and admitted his side didn`t have the cutting edge with the new ball
after seeing India race to victory. The euphoria has come crashing down and a deep
inquest is needed, the underperforming ones need to stand up and be counted if Pakistan
are to revive their campaign.