Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ACADEMY
(A Project of Al-Bahria CSS Institute)
DAWN Editorials: 09 October 2023, Monday
Turned away
ON Saturday, as UN agencies pressed Islamabad to consider the risks of forcefully repatriating
Afghan refugees, a major earthquake in western Afghanistan resulted in over 2,000 deaths,
according to the Taliban government, with thousands left injured and homeless. Reports of the
devastation caused by the disaster served as a grim backdrop to the concerns raised by
humanitarian agencies about the difficulties. Pakistani authorities may condemn hundreds of
thousands of Afghans to as they go ahead with a controversial plan to evict all `illegal aliens` by the
end of this month. The drive, which has been criticised for seeking to forcibly push those who had
fled violence, persecution and impoverishment in Afghanistan back into that troubled country, has
been pursued with unseemly eagerness by the caretaker government, with one ministry even
running a countdown on X (formerly Twitter) to remind undocumented migrants about the
number of days they have remaining in this country. Meanwhile, reports abound of refugee
settlements being shuttered, landlords being told to evict Afghan tenants, and Afghans both
documented and undocumented, men, women and children being rounded up by police across the
country. The reaction from rights organisations and more hospitable Pakistanis to Islamabad
suddenly turning its back on Afghan refugees has, understandably, been one of dismay and
concern. While the Pakistani authorities are well within their rights to demand that migrants and
refugee seekers, especially those who are undocumented, return, is this really the right way to go
about doing so?
Uprooting hundreds of thousands of human beings who have scraped together a life in Pakistan
and sending them back to an uncertain future defined by terror and turmoil seems unnecessarily
cold, made all the more so by the short deadline given to them to pack up and leave. The UNHCR
and the International Organisation for Migration have both come forward to advocate for the rights
of Afghan refugees; they must work proactively with the Pakistani government to find a quick
solution to this issue. It appears from reports that the authorities here are unprepared for the task
they have taken on. At the bare minimum, the ongoing effort to deport all foreigners not holding a
valid visa and passport requires international oversight to ensure that those being returned are not
deprived of what little they possess in the process. There have been complaints of unscrupulous
individuals exploiting vulnerable Afghans by demanding bribes to ensure their safety; the Pakistani
authorities have a responsibility to put an immediate end to such reprehensible practices. Ideally,
the entire exercise needs to be reconsidered, but even if the decision is non-negotiable, the
returning Afghans need to be treated with compassion. They are owed that.
Why has Pakistan seemingly abandoned its mothers and children? An unfortunate cocktail of
reasons is to blame. Year after year, health expenditure remains inadequate, sidelined in favour of
more `immediate` concerns. While public health initiatives exist, they lack the reach, consistency
and monitoring necessary to make a lasting impact. The situation is exacerbated by the rural-urban
divide, with remote regions deprived of even basic healthcare. Environmental challenges, such as
flooding and locust attacks, have compounded the problem. Sixty-nine districts reported nearly
48pc stunting in children under five. Such figures should sound warning bells at the highest
echelons of power. A Rs8.5bn plan to combat stunting and malnutrition in some 31 districts was
recently unveiled, offering some hope.
Socioeconomic factors must also be considered. There is limited awareness about maternal
nutrition, poor antenatal care, deep-rooted beliefs that prevent the consumption of a varied diet by
expecting mothers, early marriages, and the practice of feeding boys more than girls. All these
contribute to both preterm births and stunting. Ignorance, sadly, isn`t always bliss. Pakistan needs
a multipronged approach. A sizable increase in health expenditure is non-negotiable. Awareness
campaigns must be ramped up, as well as collaboration with global health agencies. The health of
our children is the health of our nation. It is high time we invest in our future by prioritising the
well-being of our youngest citizens. If not now, then when?
Unsurprisingly, the reasons are often worldly: property, revenge and control. This culture of
impunity also seems to suit a shameless power elite that confines itself to customary
condemnations. We have long maintained that hate speeches from microphones aimed at stirring
up perverse zeal towards weaker sections, cannot be condoned. In the age of social media, it takes
minutes for news and accusations to spread, making a disturbed situation more tenuous. Hence,
the state and clerics have little choice but to uphold their responsibility to counter social apartheid
by ensuring that a community is not demonised from the pulpit.
The power of spiritual podiums should not be taken lightly; with the right ulema in place, these can
be vital voices of harmony and acceptance. That said, separating ideas on faith from political
rhetoric is the path to reversing the tide of prejudice. Unfortunately, the last two decades have been
far from promising, so such a shift is a pipe dream. Meanwhile, authorities can use the power of
Friday sermons to erase majoritarian canard and oppressive traditions, or else the plague of
militancy and bigotry will annihilate our own.