Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ACADEMY
(A Project of Al-Bahria CSS Institute)
DAWN Editorials: 22 September 2023, Friday
Delayed elections
Brushing aside criticism that it is about to commit yet another violation of the Constitution, the
ECP on Thursday announced that general elections will be held `in the last week of January` nearly
three months after the constitutional deadline to hold polls expires. After this announcement, it has
become clear that President Arif Alvi`s letter, wherein he recommended to the ECP that the
question of when elections ought to be held should be taken up with the superior judiciary, was
consigned to the dustbin shortly after it was received. With the Supreme Court withdrawing behind
its new chief justice`s apparently strict interpretation of Article 184(3), the legal community
divided, the PPP confused about what it wants, and the PTI in disarray, not much seems to be
standing in the way of those who plotted this delay in the electoral exercise.
One can only hope that this `neutralisation` of the Constitution acquiesced to by most stakeholders
under the ostensible patronage of the establishment will prove temporary. A timeline has been
given, but, as the proverb goes, there`s many a slip between the cup and the lip. Will the ECP really
deliver on this occasion, considering the number of U-turns it has already taken this year? It may
be recalled that the Commission had issued an election schedule for Punjab in March before
withdrawing it later for flimsy reasons. At the heart of this uncertainty is the ECP`s questionable
posture that it is some kind of supra-constitutional authority which can delay elections for however
long it feels necessary. This stance has been validated so far by the state`s refusal or failure to hold
the Commission to account for delaying the Punjab and KP elections. Given that the precedent is
there, there seems to be no good reason to write off further delays.
The proof of the pudding is in the eating. If the ECP wishes to affirm that it is serious, it should
start moving on all pending matters so that the possibility of any further delay is minimised. It has
already sent a draft election code of conduct to political parties, seeking their feedback. From what
has been reported about this code, one important `rule` seems missing: building on the increase in
the number of registered women voters, the ECP should seek formal guarantees from political
parties that they will not seek to block women from participating in the electoral process anywhere
in the country and, instead, will encourage them to vote with all possible means at their disposal.
The ECP also needs to take up without delay the complaints regarding the absence of a level playing
field made by two major parties. The country cannot afford another election to be tainted by
accusations of pre-poll rigging.
Interestingly, there are rumours that the latest trip is linked to Nawaz Sharif`s remarks about
holding retired generals and judges accountable. These statements must have come as nasty shock
to Shehbaz Sharif as he generally refrains from criticising the military establishment, despite his
older brother`s different take on the subject. However, even the senior Sharif, apart from criticising
the security establishment from the PDM platform on occasion, has been largely silent on issues
related to the military leadership. For his part, while in the opposition, Shehbaz Sharif endorsed
Gen Bajwa`s extension and, later, was head of a government that endorsed the military trials of
civilians. When he returns to Pakistan next month, will Nawaz Sharif`s critical views of the military
leadership be intact? Or will his opinions be limited to only those he believes had a hand in his
ouster? With the current military leadership`s ire focused on his political rivals, it is convenient for
Mr Sharif to restrict his criticism to the previous army leadership. But it is still not known how the
institution will respond to his talk of accountability. If Mr Sharif indeed returns next month, the
brothers will need to decide what the party`s narrative will be, given how vastly different their
views are on the establishment`s role in politics. The PML-N leadership must realise that it cannot
continue to play games with the public, especially as people are drowning in economic misery.
According to the CPLC, over the past nine months, some 60,000 incidents of street crime
have taken place in Karachi. The figure for all of 2022 was 85,000. Police say between 50
to 60 gangs are active in this deadly business, while mobile-snatching and motorbike-
lifting top the list of crimes. Various factors are fuelling high street crime rates,
including inflation, joblessness, and the lure of easy money. People often resist parting
with their hard-earned cash or valuables, with the result that they end up paying with
their lives. However, addressing the underlying factors behind crime is a long-term
project; the immediate need is to quell the deadly wave of killings. Here, the Sindh
government has failed miserably. The PPP, which has been ruling the province since
2008, has much to answer for where law and order goes. The caretaker government can
only do so much, and it is hoped that the next elected government that takes power in
Sindh has solid proposals to beat crime. Otherwise, precious lives will continue to be
snuffed out by trigger-happy criminals.