Professional Documents
Culture Documents
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
62
due to excessive occlusal load and/ agnosis and treatment plan.” They
or a pathological neuromuscular pat- also state that when reviewing the
tern, represents, together with the literature, there are incongruities in
loss of posterior occlusal support, Amsterdam’s definition of PBC given
the most prominent clinical sign of to disparaging clinical situations that
the total posterior bite collapse.” The present with loss of OVD.
most common cause of PBC is the According to Tonetti et al,1 the
Fig 1 Normal/ideal, periodontally healthy loss of molars and their nonreplace- difference between Stage III and
occlusion without TL.
ment. Conditions such as excessive Stage IV periodontitis is case com-
occlusal wear due to parafunction, plexity. Primary factors such as tooth
faulty dental restorations, malocclu- mobility and PBC with drifting and
common include the presence of sions, inadequate orthodontic treat- flaring of teeth can add complexity
periodontitis, AF, and loss of OVD. ment, or dental caries might also be to a case. The purpose of this article
Since its first publication, mul- considered predisposing or initiat- is to elucidate the original definition
tiple articles have obfuscated rath- ing factors that potentially result in: of PBC and its multiple clinical mani-
er than clarified the meaning and drifting of the mandibular premolars festations, as well as to propose a
clinical course of PBC. The goal of and molars into the now-edentulous grading framework for PBC.
this article is to reexamine its origi- area; extrusion and rotation of the
nal definition, elucidate its multiple maxillary molar into the edentulous
clinical manifestations, and propose area; and temporomandibular dys- PBC, Defined
a grading system for PBC. function (TMD). Furthermore, oc-
clusal discrepancies could result in PBC is a means to describe a clini-
infrabony defects, causing areas for cal syndrome with multiple, often
Methodology food impaction and plaque accumu- pathognomonic factors that deviate
lation,6 leading to the progression of from a normal or “ideal” occlusion
A search of the term “posterior bite periodontitis with increasing tooth (Fig 1) in which the posterior occlu-
collapse” using the database of the mobility and, ultimately, AF and sub- sion is compromised and may ulti-
Temple University Kornberg School sequent loss of OVD. Similar findings mately result in the destruction of
of Dentistry was performed, and a were published by Rosenberg7 and the functional protective capacity of
finite series of articles published Rosenberg and Lever,8 adding that the entire dentition. Secondary clini-
from 1970 to 2018 was found. These PBC may be found in the absence of cal sequelae may include, singularly
articles were secondary reviews and tooth loss and periodontitis. Dersot or in combination: the accelerated
provide cursory analyses of Amster- and Giovannoli9 stated that PBC is a progression of periodontitis, TMD,
dam and Abrams’ publications and sequelae of advanced breakdown, increasing mobility/fremitus, addi-
theses. influenced by periodontal inflamma- tional TL, AF, and loss of OVD. Etio-
tion and attachment loss (AL), which logic factors may include (but are
can lead to tooth migration as a re- not limited to), singularly or in com-
Historical Background sult of occlusal forces. Mesial drifting bination: TL without replacement
of teeth with AF may be aggravated (Fig 2), orthodontic malocclusions
Since PBC’s first publication, multiple by the nonreplacement of missing and dental-skeletal disharmonies
articles have been published attempt- teeth, malocclusion, or neuromuscu- (Fig 3), periodontitis (Fig 4), acceler-
ing to elucidate PBC but have only lar disorders.9 Shifman et al10 stated ated retrograde occlusal/interproxi-
brought greater confusion. Brayer “although there are different defini- mal wear (Figs 5 and 6), severe car-
and Stern4,5 maintained that “the tions of PBC, only the definition by ies, or iatrogenic and conformitive
flaring of the anterior teeth, whether Amsterdam provides a definite di- dentistry3–5,7,8,11 (Fig 7).
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
63
a b c
Fig 2 (a) Buccal and (b and c) lateral views of orthodontic malocclusion Class I (CLI) presenting with bite collapse, bilaterally missing man-
dibular first molars, and a reduced yet healthy periodontium. Tipping and extrusion of posterior teeth were noted, along with increasing
anterior diastema, an increased intercuspal/centric relation (IC/CR) relationship, and mild loss of OVD.
a b
c d
e f
Fig 3 Periodontally stable malocclusions presenting with PBC without TL. OVD loss may be seen if the rate of occlusal wear exceeds the
rate of compensatory eruption. (a and b) Class II division 1 (CLIId1) and (c and d) division 2 (CLIId2) malocclusions. (e and f) Class III (CLIII)
malocclusion.
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
64
b
Fig 6 (a) Buccal and (b and c) lateral oc-
Fig 5 CLI malocclusion in PBC with clusal views of a CLIId1 malocclusion in
a
primary OT and accelerated retrograde PBC with periodontitis and no TL. Broad
wear. The dentition is periodontally stable, interproximal contact was seen in the
with TL, loss of OVD, and no AF. Due to posterior dentition, indicative of acceler-
the unstable IC position, the mandible is ated interproximal wear and drifting.
postured anteriorly to a pseudo-dental Increasing mobility/fremitus, extrusion of
CLIII malocclusion with an increased IC/CR the mandibular anterior teeth, AF, loss of
relationship. OVD, and an increased IC/CR relationship
were noted. Photos courtesy of Dr Morton
c
Amsterdam.
Bite Collapse, AF, and OVD obtain a stable intercuspal (IC) po-
sition, resulting in AF and the even-
AF and loss of OVD have always tual loss of OVD.3,11 Marks12 states
been a point of contention in the di- that the nonreplacement of miss-
agnosis of PBC. The literature is re- ing posterior teeth can cause the
plete with the assumption that OVD adjacent teeth to tip into the open
loss and AF are requisites for PBC. space, thereby shifting those por-
Fig 7 Periodontally stable dentition that
has been restored in PBC with missing The most common progression of tions of the teeth that support the
posterior teeth and loss of OVD. AF is not PBC is due to the premature loss of posterior occlusion, resulting in the
evident due to the fixed partial denture the 6-year molar, resulting in the ac- loss of OVD. Based on these state-
masking the flaring. Because of the AF,
occlusion is established such that the man- celerated mesiodistal drift of teeth ments, it is easy to conclude that
dible is positioned anteriorly to a pseudo- and loss of the stabilizing support PBC is synonymous with TL, AF, and
dental CLIII malocclusion with an increased
IC/CR relationship. of the posterior teeth. The loss of loss of OVD.
the natural protective capacity that However, Chasens13 states that
the posterior teeth provide results the remaining dentition may be
in an extension of excessive occlu- stable enough to maintain a physi-
sal loads to the anterior teeth as the ologic OVD (Fig 8). Furthermore, is
mandible is positioned anteriorly. it possible to have PBC without loss
This positioning is to avoid prema- of OVD, TL, or AF? PBC can occur
ture posterior interferences and to in the periodontally stable patient
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
65
a b
Fig 8 (a) Clinical and (b) radiographic view of a periodontally stable CLI malocclusion presenting with PBC, a missing mandibular right first
molar without AF, and no significant loss of OVD.
a b
Fig 9 (a) Buccal and (b) mandibular occlusal views of a periodontally stable CLIId2 malocclusion presenting with PBC. Maxillary AF is not
noted. However there is an increase in the anterior overbite relationship as OVD is lost due to accelerated retrograde wear of the denti-
tion.
a b c
Fig 10 (a) Buccal and (b and c) lateral views of a CLIId1 malocclusion presenting with PBC. The dentition presents with periodontitis, TL,
displacement of teeth, maxillary AF, and loss of OVD, contributing to an unstable IC position. The mandible is postured anteriorly to a
pseudo-dental CLIII malocclusion with an increased IC/CR relationship.
with primary OT, in which the den- indicators of probable loss in OVD Bite Collapse in the Presence
tition becomes mutilated when the include increasing mobility/fremitus, of Dental/Skeletal Malocclusion
rate of retrograde wear exceeds displacement of teeth, increased
the rate of compensatory eruption, AF, accelerated retrograde occlusal In 1900, Edward Angle published
resulting in a net loss of OVD with- wear, and an increase in IC/centric the first classification of orthodon-
out AF14 (Figs 5 and 9). Ultimately, relation (CR) relationship (Fig 10). tic malocclusions, known today as
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
66
normal occlusion and malocclusion OT may be seen.21,22 These patients Angle’s CLIId2 Collapse
Class I (CLI), Class II (divisions 1 and may present with a dental pseudo-
2; CLIId1 and CLIId2, respectively), CLIII malocclusion, as opposed to In the CLIId2 malocclusion, the an-
and Class III (CLIII). Although re- a true orthodontic pseudo-CLIII, as terior teeth receive greater occlusal
ferred to as a “malocclusion,” these the IC and CR discrepancy increases forces and there typically is little AF
occlusal patterns, which deviate and the mandible is positioned an- (Figs 3c, 3d, and 9). This is not only
from the ideal, may be physiologic, teriorly in order to obtain occlusal due to the skeletal relationship, but
and are more susceptible to peri- stability.14 also due to occlusal forces directed
odontal breakdown, are classified as closer to the transverse axis of rota-
PBC (Fig 3). Although most maloc- tion, thus negating the potential for
clusions will follow the clinical pat- Angle’s CLIId1 Collapse off-axis forces and flaring.14 These
tern of PBC originally published by patients tend to be “locked in” and
Amsterdam and others, they vary Similar to the CLI malocclusion, in- are unable to easily perform excur-
depending upon Angle’s malocclu- creasing mobility/fremitus may be sive movements. As OVD is lost, in-
sion. Classification of malocclusion noted with greater AF with the pro- creased wear and/or chipping in the
at the time of clinical presentation gressive loss of OVD (Figs 3a, 3b, teeth, increased fremitus/mobility,
may prove to be difficult in cases of 6, and 10). Loss of OVD in the pres- or TMD may be seen.
restored dentition where PBC had ence of AF, extrusion, and drifting
been present at the time of prior of unopposed posterior teeth could
treatment but was unaddressed likewise cause posterior cusps to Angle’s CLIII Collapse
(“restored in PBC”; Fig 7). function effectively steeper, which
may be exacerbated by shallower The clinical appearance of the CLIII
articular eminence inclinations. Sec- malocclusion in PBC tends to be an
Angle’s CLI Collapse ondary OT may also be noted in the extension of its appearance without
presence of PAL. Mandibular pre- PBC (Figs 3e and 3f). As this maloc-
In the presence of periodontitis with molars tend to either maintain their clusion collapses, the edge-to-edge
AL, this malocclusion may present position or tip mesially. This could or reverse anterior overbite relation
with increasing mobility/fremitus be attributed to their relative posi- becomes exacerbated. As OVD is
and AF resulting in a loss of OVD3– tion against the maxillary arch and lost, mandibular prognathism in-
8,11,15,16
(Figs 2, 4, 5, and 8). If mandib- the way in which forces are transmit- creases with no AF. It should be de-
ular molars are missing, the premo- ted along their long axis. termined whether the malocclusion
lars would tip distolingually into the In cases where there is an in- is a true orthodontic CLIII or a den-
edentulous space; if present, the creased anterior overjet relation, sig- tal pseudo-CLIII due to loss of OVD
second molar tips mesiolingually, nificant AF may not be seen in PBC. and anterior positioning of the man-
and excursion of the opposing mo- As OVD is lost, the overbite would dible at an increased IC/CR relation-
lar may be seen.3–8,11,13,17–20 The loss increase with a decrease in overjet ship (Fig 5).
of OVD with AF and malpositioned due to the mandible’s anterior po-
posterior teeth could cause the pos- sitioning to obtain a stable anterior
terior cusps to function effectively contact (Fig 3). These patients may Framework for Grading
steeper, creating frequent interfer- present with a dental pseudo-CLIII Bite Collapse
ences between the opposing cusps, malocclusion with an increased IC/
which may be exacerbated by shal- CR relationship. Since PBC encompasses a wide
lower articular eminence inclina- range of clinical manifestations and
tions. In the presence of periodontal can be diagnosed with or without
attachment loss (PAL), secondary periodontitis, TL, AF, or loss of OVD,
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
67
a grading system was devised. This AF or loss of OVD, and dentition titis with or without AF or concomi-
system is based upon the two most in which the remaining teeth are tant loss of OVD (Figs 4 and 10). This
common etiologic factors that can able to maintain a physiologic OVD grade may best coincide with Stage
contribute to PBC: the presence fall in this group.13 However, in the IV periodontitis. In the majority of
or absence of TL and the health of presence occlusal wear, a net loss in cases, this dentition presents with
the periodontium with potential OVD may be seen.14 G2 PBC also in- compromised periodontal support,
sequelae of AF and/or loss of OVD cludes dentition that present with a which may lead to additional TL,
(Table 1). healthy but reduced periodontium. thereby translating to progressive
Additionally, physiologic therapeu- loss of masticatory function, increas-
tic dentition that have been restored ing mobility/fremitus, and AF. In the
Grade 1 in PBC are included. presence of AF in conjunction with
increasing mobility, there is invari-
Grade 1 (G1) PBC malocclusions are ably loss in OVD.
periodontally stable without TL (Figs Grade 3
3 and 9). There is typically a lack of
AF but may show signs of increasing Grade 3 (G3) PBC malocclusion Conclusions
mobility/fremitus, which may indicate presents without TL in the presence
a loss in OVD. The presence of ac- of active periodontitis (Fig 6). This PBC is a clinical syndrome consist-
celerated retrograde wear may also malocclusion may or may not pres- ing of various alterations in the
indicate loss in OVD. Dentition that ent with AF or concomitant loss of dentition that deviate from an ideal
present with a healthy but reduced OVD. However, OVD loss should be occlusion.3,7,8,11,14 The dental-occlu-
periodontium23 are included, as well suspected in the presence of ret- sal alterations, as well as dental-
as physiologic therapeutic dentition rograde wear, increasing mobility/ skeletal discrepancies in the poste-
that have been restored in PBC. fremitus, and AF. Physiologic thera- rior dentition in PBC, establish an
peutic dentition that have been re- environment that is potentially more
stored in PBC are also included. susceptible to periodontal disease
Grade 2 and caries.6 In the presence of peri-
odontitis, the attachment apparatus
Grade 2 (G2) PBC malocclusions are Grade 4 becomes severely compromised
periodontally stable with unrestored and results in the instability of the
missing teeth (Figs 2, 5, 7, and 8). Grade 4 (G4) PBC malocclusions remaining dentition, which could
These may present with or without present with both TL and periodon- subsequently become easily affect-
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
68
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
69
17. Brunsvold MA. Pathologic tooth migra- 20. Craddock HL. Occlusal changes follow- 23. Chapple ILC, Mealey BL, Van Dyke TE,
tion. J Periodontology 2005;76:859–866. ing posterior tooth loss in adults. Part 3. et al. Periodontal health and gingival
18. Craddock HL, Youngson CC, Manogue A study of clinical parameters associat- diseases and conditions on an intact
M, Blance A. Occlusal changes follow- ed with the presence of Occlusal inter- and a reduced periodontium: Consen-
ing posterior tooth loss in adults. Part ferences following posterior tooth loss. sus report of workgroup 1 of the 2017
1: A study of clinical parameters associ- J Prosthodontics 2007;17:25–30. World Workshop on the Classification
ated with the extent and type of supra- 21. Branschofsky M, Beikler T, Schäfer R, of Periodontal and Peri-implant Dis-
eruption in unopposed posterior teeth. Flemmig TF, Lang H. Secondary trauma eases and Conditions. J Periodontol
J Prosthodontics 2007;16:485–494. from occlusion and periodontitis. Quin- 2018;89(suppl 1):s74–s84.
19. Craddock HL, Youngson CC, Manogue tessence Int 2011;42:515–522. 24. Glickman I, Smulow J. Effect of exces-
M, Blance A. Occlusal changes follow- 22. Fan J, Caton J. Occlusal trauma and sive occlusal forces upon the pathway of
ing posterior tooth loss in adults. Part excessive occlusal forces: Narrative gingival inflammation in humans. J Peri-
2. Clinical parameters associated with review, case definitions, and diagnos- odontol 1965;36:141–147.
movement of teeth adjacent to the site tic considerations. J Periodontology 25. Granger ER (ed). Biomechanics. In: Prac-
of posterior tooth loss. J Prosthodontics 2018;89(suppl 1):s214–s222. tical Procedures in Oral Rehabilitation.
2007;16:495–501. Lippincott: Philadelphia, 1962:16–18.
© 2021 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
Copyright of International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry is the property of
Quintessence Publishing Company Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.