Professional Documents
Culture Documents
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
351
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
352
the longer that natural metabolism lems and should be avoided when synthesis of a treatment plan, the
can maintain it. possible. Harper9 states that when present authors previously pub-
The present authors previously treating OVD, the condyles must be lished a grading system for diagnos-
showed that PBC encompasses a in CR, and that it must be tested us- ing PBC based on two fundamental
wide range of clinical presentations ing reversible treatment modalities. etiologic factors: periodontal health
that do not necessarily involve the Most importantly, restoration must and TL (Table 1).4 Sequelae such as
presence of periodontitis, TL, AF or be within the neuromuscular adap- increasing mobility/fremitus, OVD
loss of OVD.4 Despite its multiple tation for each patient. The inherent loss, and AF are to be diagnosed
definitions since its first introduc- problem is that there remains no clin- and annotated secondarily.
tion, only the definition by Amster- ical practice guidelines on occlusion, Periodontal diagnosis should
dam provides a definite diagnosis and many clinicians adhere to one be based upon the staging sys-
and treatment plan.5 According to of any number of occlusal philoso- tem developed by the 2017 World
the definition by Amsterdam and phies for treatment. Regarding oc- Workshop on the Classification of
Abrams,1 any malocclusion that de- clusion, it is generally accepted that Periodontal and Peri-implant Dis-
viates from the normal or ideal is di- there are multiple philosophies that eases and Conditions10 and those
agnosed with PBC. may work, but while one philosophy published by Tonetti et al.11 Occlu-
Historically, the most common of occlusion may be successful with sal diagnosis should be based upon
erroneous assumption has been one patient, the same approach will Angle’s classification of malocclu-
that PBC is synonymous with loss not work for every case. The basis in sion, with the understanding that
of OVD. Chasens6 and the present developing a therapeutic physiologic the functional physiologic therapeu-
authors have shown that in the pres- occlusion to restore PBC should con- tic occlusion and the conformative
ence of PBC, the remaining dentition form to the physiologic form and dentition restored in PBC may be
may have enough periodontal sta- functional demands of individual pa- masking an underlying occlusal pat-
bility to maintain a functional physi- tient needs. Therefore, the purpose tern, especially in cases where there
ologic OVD. However, Rosenberg of this article is to provide general is anterior posturing of the mandible
et al7 showed that in a periodontally treatment guidelines for PBC based that gives the appearance of a Class
stable malocclusion in the presence on form and function. I (CLI) or dental pseudo–CLIII maloc-
of primary occlusal trauma (OT), if Using the database of Temple clusion in either the presence or ab-
the rate of occlusal wear exceeds University, Kornberg School of Den- sence of AF. It is also recommended
the rate of compensatory passive tistry, a search of the literature per- that any IC/CR discrepancies be
eruption, there may be a net de- taining to posterior bite collapse, evaluated.
crease in OVD. This would result in occlusion, and multidisciplinary
the anterior posturing of the man- treatment was performed, ranging
dible and an increase in the inter- between 1964 and May 2020. Treatment Guidelines
cuspal (IC)–centric relation (CR), pre-
senting as a dental pseudo–Class Irrespective of PBC grade, the ini-
III (CLIII) malocclusion. In PBC cases Diagnosing the Problem tial therapy should always consist of
with OVD loss, clinicians may face treatment and maintenance of peri-
the challenge of inadequate inter- The foundation in formulating a odontal health; ie, establishing and
arch space for restorative materials. treatment plan lies in proper diag- maintaining correct soft tissue and
According to Turner and nosis; there may be many ways to osseous architecture. Additionally,
Missirlian,8 it is critical to verify loss treat a case, but there can only be treatment of any active disease pro-
prior to restoration at an increased one correct diagnosis. Because of cesses, such as caries control, peri-
OVD, as rehabilitation at an increased variations in PBS clinical presenta- radicular pathology, and extraction
OVD may cause postoperative prob- tion and in an effort to aid in the of diseased, nonrestorable teeth.
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
353
For dentitions presenting with initial therapy is completed. In the with a reduced yet healthy peri-
Grade 1 (G1) PBC (free of primary presence of drifting and/or supra- odontium10 with a previous history
OT or OVD loss), no other treat- eruption of teeth, orthodontic cor- of Grade 4 (G4) PBC and tooth loss/
ment may be necessary beyond ini- rection may be necessary to ob- replacement are included in G2 and
tial therapy and caries control. For a tain adequate space for restorative G1 PBC, respectively.
more severe G1 PBC case (present- materials and to restore occlusal A dentition without TL present-
ing with primary OT, severe retro- planes. As with G1 PBC, G2 PBC cas- ing with stage I or stage II periodon-
grade wear, increasing mobility/ es presenting with primary OT with titis and Grade 3 (G3) PBC would
fremitus, and OVD loss), appliance severe retrograde wear, increasing likely require more extensive peri-
therapy, restoration of surfaces mu- mobility/fremitus, and/or OVD loss odontal treatment (and possibly
tilated by OT, and OVD restoration may require adjunctive occlusal ap- extraction of nonrestorable teeth),
may be necessary. pliance therapy along with restora- as well as stabilizing and restoring
When unrestored TL is present tion of surfaces mutilated by OT in occlusal disharmonies. Once peri-
in the periodontally stable denti- order to restore the OVD. Occlusal odontal and occlusal stability have
tion, as in the Grade 2 (G2) PBC appliance therapy could be used as been achieved, replacing nonrestor-
case, the missing teeth may need both a reversible means to assess able teeth with either fixed or re-
to be restored with either a fixed or OVD and IC/CR discrepancies and movable prosthetics may be neces-
removable prosthesis (Fig 1) once as a treatment modality. Dentitions sary. Adjunctive occlusal appliance
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
354
a b
Fig 2 (a) Illustration of a CLI or CLIId2 malocclusion in G4 PBC. There is TL, drifting of teeth, AF, and loss in OVD. (b) Restoration of such a
case would involve periodontal therapy and maintenance; leveling and aligning the mandibular anterior teeth; occlusal appliance therapy
to determine a therapeutic physiologic OVD; determining the centric relation position; correction of posterior occlusion at restored OVD;
and retraction of the maxillary anterior teeth into a functional OB/OJ relation. Platforming the lingual aspect of the maxillary anterior teeth
with fixed prosthodontics may be necessary (A). Therapeutic physiologic malocclusion is such that IC is equal to CR in long centric.
therapy may also be considered in required; each case presents col- sion presents a greater challenge.
the presence of increasing mobility lapse differently, especially with re- These PBC cases often present
and fremitus. Careful consideration spect to mandibular position. In the with a deep OB anterior relation
should be taken when retrograde presence of OVD loss with CLI, Class with no AF, increased occlusal
wear is present in conjunction with II division 2 (CLIId2), and CLIII maloc- retrograde wear, and increased
increasing mobility/fremitus, as this clusions, the mandible may be po- mobility/fremitus. As OVD is re-
indicates possible secondary OT sitioned more anteriorly, resulting in stored, the mandible retrudes
with underlying primary OT, as well an increased IC/CR discrepancy. Re- into CR. Although this may de-
as OVD loss. storing the OVD of the CLI or CLIId2 crease and possibly improve the
Stage III and IV periodontitis malocclusions in the presence of AF OB relation, the OJ could poten-
presenting with G4 PBC could re- would likely result in retrusion of the tially significantly increase, thus
quire more complex, multidisci- mandible into CR, and it would re- worsening the anterior functional
plinary treatment.1,12–15 These cases quire retraction of the anterior teeth relationship. Often, the anterior
would require extensive periodontal in order to restore a functional over- teeth may require a lingual plat-
treatment, additional TL, stabiliza- bite (OB) and overjet (OJ) relation- form in the final prosthesis in or-
tion and restoration of occlusal dis- ship. As OVD is restored, the man- der to establish adequate anterior
harmonies, replacement of missing dible will retrude into CR, resulting function (Fig 3).
teeth with fixed or removable pros- in a decrease in OB and increase Periodontally stable dentitions
thetics, and OVD restoration. in OJ (Fig 2). Restoring the OVD in with PBC with OVD loss due to se-
CLIII and orthodontic pseudo–CLIII vere retrograde wear, primary OT,
malocclusions could result in the or missing/displaced teeth may
Restoring Vertical Dimension anterior teeth remaining in an edge- present with mandibular protrusion
in PBC to-edge or reverse edge-to-edge appearing as a CLIII malocclusion
relationship due to the skeletal dis- (dental pseudo–CLIII). Restoring
When the decision is made to re- crepancy.7 the OVD of such cases may result
store OVD in PBC, evaluation and an Restoring OVD in the Class in a CLI, CLIId2, or true CLIII maloc-
Angle’s malocclusion diagnosis are II division 1 (CLIId1) malocclu- clusion, as the mandible retrudes
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
355
a b
Fig 3 (a) Illustration of a CLIId1 malocclusion in G4 PBC. There is TL, drifting of teeth, no AF, and loss in OVD. (b) Restoration of such a
case would involve periodontal therapy and maintenance; leveling and aligning the mandibular anterior teeth; occlusal appliance therapy
to determine the therapeutic physiologic OVD; determination of CR position; and correction of posterior occlusion at the restored physi-
ologic OVD. Due to the dentoskeletal malocclusion, a significant increase in OJ may be seen as OB decreases. Platforming the lingual
aspect of the maxillary anterior teeth with fixed prosthodontics will be necessary (A). Therapeutic physiologic occlusion is such that IC is
equal to CR in long centric.
a b
Fig 4 (a) Illustration of a potential CLI, CLIId2, or CLIII malocclusion in G1 PBC with primary OT, severe retrograde wear, and con-
comitant loss in OVD. As a result of OVD loss, mandibular protrusion could be noted, presenting as a dental pseudo–CLIII malocclusion.
(b) Treatment would involve periodontal therapy and maintenance; occlusal appliance therapy to determine therapeutic physiologic OVD,
determining the CR position, and rehabilitation of the dentition at the restored physiologic OVD.
into CR (Fig 4). Regardless of mal- rehabilitation with fixed prostho- bilaterally missing mandibular first
occlusion, a functional therapeutic dontics.1,12–15 molars without replacement, and
physiologic occlusion may often a chief complaint (CC) of miss-
result with IC equal to CR in long ing teeth and anterior diastema
centric.16,17 Once OVD is restored, Cases that had been increasing over
the remaining posterior dentition time. As a result, the surround-
should be restored and periodon- Case 1: G2 PBC + CLI ing teeth drifted into the space.
tally stable enough to maintain the The increasing anterior diastema
restored therapeutic OVD. In most A 45-year-old man presented indicated OVD loss. Treatment
cases, restoration of PBC maloc- with a CLI malocclusion with a re- involved restoring the OVD, oc-
clusions may require full-mouth duced, stable periodontium and clusal therapy with IC equal to CR,
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
356
a b c
d e
Fig 5 CLI malocclusion with G2 PBC. (a to c) Reduced yet stable periodontium, bilaterally missing 6-year molars, drifting of teeth into
edentulous spaces, and increasing anterior diastema noted. (d and e) Following periodontal therapy, an anterior Hawley bite plane (BP)
appliance was inserted and posterior occlusion was stabilized with orthodontics and occlusal adjustment, establishing IC equal to CR. The
anterior diastema was closed using the labial bow of the BP appliance.
correction of the posterior occlu- Case 3: G4 PBC + CLI prosthodontics may be necessary
sal planes, and closing the diaste- to maintain a functional physiologic
ma (Fig 5). A 47-year-old woman presented therapeutic occlusion.
with stage III periodontitis and a
CLI malocclusion in PBC, with a
Case 2: G3 PBC + CLI CC of periodontal issues. Her man- Case 4: G4 PBC + CLIId2
dibular left first molar was missing,
A 51-year-old man presented with causing the surrounding teeth to A 56-year-old man presented with
stage II periodontitis and a CLI drift into the space. Additionally, stage IV periodontitis and a CLIId2
malocclusion in PBC, and a CC of the remaining posterior dentition malocclusion in PBC, with a CC of
generalized increasing mobility show accelerated mesial drifting in esthetic concerns. He had multiple
and fremitus with bleeding gums. the presence of increasing mobility missing teeth, a deep OB, OVD loss,
Although there was no TL, AF, or and fremitus with no AF. Treatment and conformative treatment in col-
significant OVD loss, there was ac- involved extracting nonrestorable lapse. Treatment involved extracting
tive periodontitis, a reduced peri- teeth, restoring and maintaining nonrestorable teeth, restoring and
odontal attachment apparatus, and periodontal health, and correcting maintaining periodontal health, cor-
secondary OT. Treatment involved occlusal planes with IC equal to CR. recting occlusal planes with IC equal
restoring and maintaining periodon- Interproximal stripping of the den- to CR, restoring OVD, and replacing
tal health, extracting nonrestorable tition was necessary to reestablish missing teeth (Fig 8). The patient re-
teeth with their restorative replace- interarch occlusal relationships and fused any orthognathic corrective
ments, addressing osseous defects, the OB-OJ relationship with the surgery. Due to the deep CLIId2
and periodic, 3-month periodontal mandible in CR (Fig 7). Full-mouth malocclusion, altering the OVD
maintenance (Fig 6). restoration with fixed or removable would retrude the mandible into CR,
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
357
Fig 6 (a) Clinical and (b) radiographic views of a CLI malocclusion with G3
PBC and stage II periodontitis. Although TL was not noted, there is general-
ized moderate to severe attachment loss, increased mobility/fremitus, no
AF, and no significant loss in OVD.
which may improve the OB but of- progression of periodontitis and • Is the patient free of active
ten detrimentally increases the OJ. may allow for the preservation of a dental caries?
Restoration of such cases could ne- stable, functional, physiologic mal- • Is the patient free of subjective
cessitate full-mouth restoration with occlusion. First and foremost, the and objective TMD symptoms?
fixed or removable prosthodontics. foundation of all treatment must • Is there a negative occlusal
be the health of the periodontal at- sense present?
tachment, free of inflammation. The • Does the patient have a
Conclusions decision to intervene with treatment parafunctional habit pattern
should be based on the following (bruxism)?
PBC is a clinical syndrome with parameters:
multiple, often pathologic etiologic When treatment is needed,
factors. In developing a multidisci- • Can the patient chew the availability of restorative space
plinary treatment plan to treat PBC, adequately? should be evaluated, and the de-
the adequate diagnosis and analy- • Is the patient esthetically cision to restore OVD should be
sis of each individual patient is re- satisfied? tested using reversible treatment
quired. Although not all PBC cases • Does the patient have a modalities. Additionally, assess-
require treatment, early intervention phonetic pattern? ing the occlusal pattern, amount
and careful maintenance of these • Is the patient in good of centric slip, and AF presence
patients can prevent the onset and periodontal health? should be done before engaging in
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
358
a b c
d e f
Fig 7 CLI malocclusion with G4 PBC and stage III periodontitis. (a to c) The patient presented with TL, secondary OT, and mesial tipping
in posterior dentition without AF or significant loss in OVD. (d to f) Following periodontal therapy and extraction of nonrestorable teeth,
orthodontic appliances were used to correct dental/occlusal discrepancies. Interproximal stripping was necessary to retract teeth and rees-
tablish functional arch form. Treatment and photos provided by Dr Jonathan Korostoff (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA).
a b
c d e
Fig 8 CLIId2 malocclusion with G4 PBC and stage IV periodontitis. (a and b) The patient presented with conformative occlusion with TL,
secondary OT, no AF, and loss in OVD. (c) Following periodontal therapy, an anterior Hawley BP appliance was inserted to evaluate OVD
and CR position. Due to the skeletal discrepancy, OB decreased and the OJ increased significantly. (d and e) Restoring a stable therapeu-
tic physiologic occlusion required full fixed prosthodontics with an anterior lingual platform and IC equal to CR in long centric.
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
359
Periodontitis stage
I II III IV
PBC grade 1 2 3 4
Angle class I IId1 IId2 III
AF Y N
Increased mobility/fremitus Y N
OT 1 degree 2 degrees 1–2 degrees
OVD loss Y N
PBC = posterior bite collapse; AF = anterior flaring; OT = occlusal trauma; OVD = occlusal vertical dimension; Y = yes; N = no.
treatment. Table 2 demonstrates tics and restorative dentistry, which were the 9. Harper RP. Clinical indications for al-
base inspiration for this article. tering vertical dimension of occlusion.
an example of a means to record Functional and biologic consideration
clinical findings. The therapeutic The authors declare no conflicts of interest. for reconstruction of the dental occlu-
goal for intervention should be such sion. Quintessence Int 2000;31:280–
282.
that the dentition is able to function 10. Chapple ILC, Mealey BL, Van Dyke TE,
within the masticatory form and the References et al. Periodontal health and gingival
diseases and conditions on an intact
functional demands for each pa- and a reduced periodontium: Consen-
1. Amsterdam M, Abrams L: Periodontal
tient; in everyday practice, clinicians prosthesis. In: Goldman H, Cohen DW sus report of workgroup 1 of the 2017
deal with a statistically insignificant (eds). Periodontal Therapy, ed 3. St Lou- World Workshop on the Classification
is: Mosby, 1964:762–813. of Periodontal and Peri-implant Dis-
number—one—and never know eases and Conditions. J Periodontol
2. Rosenberg ES. Posterior bite collapse,
where this one patient may fall with- part 1: Pathologic occlusion. Compen- 2018;89(suppl 1):s74–s84.
dium 1988;9:207–218. 11. Tonetti MS, Greenwell H, Korrnman KS.
in the average. Above all, multidisci- Staging and grading of periodontitis:
3. Granger ER (ed). Biomechanics. In: Prac-
plinary care in treating PBC should tical Procedures in Oral Rehabilitation. Framework and proposal of a new clas-
be accepted by the patient with the Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1952:16–18. sification and case definition. J Clinical
4. Nakamura SS, Donatelli D, Rosenberg Periodontol 2018;89(suppl 1):s159–s172.
understanding that a functional, 12. Amsterdam M. Periodontal prosthesis:
ES. Posterior bite collapse and diag-
physiologic, therapeutic occlusion nostic grading for periodontitis. Int Twenty-five years in retrospect. Alpha
J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2021; Omegan 1974;67:8–52.
may not be achieved without com- 13. Rosenberg ES, Lever B. Posterior bite
41:61–69.
prehensive integration of treatment 5. Shifman A, Laufer BZ, Chweidan H. Pos- collapse, part II: Occlusal therapy. Com-
and extensive fixed prosthodontics. terior bite collapse–revisited. J Oral Re- pendium 1988;9:258–278.
habilitation 1998;25:376–385. 14. Kastenbaum F. Case report: Treatment
6. Chasens AI. Controversies in occlusion. of posterior bite collapse with second-
Dent Clin North Am 1990;34:111–123. ary occlusal traumatism. Penn Dent J
(Phila) 1977;79:39–42.
Acknowledgments 7. Rosenberg ES, Simons J, Gualini F. Clini-
15. Jensen-Doray PG. Case report: Com-
cal aspects and treatment of posterior
bite collapse due to accelerated wear. prehensive treatment of a patient with
The authors wish to acknowledge Dr Morton Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent posterior bite collapse. Compend Con-
1987;1:67–82. tin Educ Dent 1984;5:826–838.
Amsterdam for his dedication to the educa-
8. Turner KA, Missirlian DM. Restoration 16. Celenza F. The centric position: Re-
tion of countless dental professionals and placement and character. J Prosthetic
of the extremely worn dentition. J Pros-
advancements in the practice of periodon- thetic Dent 1984;52:467–474. Dent 1973;30(4 Pt. 2):591–598.
17. Schulyer CH. Freedom in centric. Dent
Clin North Am 1969;13:681–686.
© 2022 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
Copyright of International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry is the property of
Quintessence Publishing Company Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.