You are on page 1of 11

The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

THE EFFECT OF PERCEIVED USEFULNESS,


PERCEIVED EASE OF USE, AND SOCIAL
INFLUENCE TOWARD INTENTION TO USE
MEDIATED BY TRUST
JAM
20, 1 Ilham Agung Kurniawan
Received, December ‘20 Master of Management, Faculty of Economics and Business,
Revised, September ‘21
Accepted, September ‘21
Universitas Brawijaya, Indonesia
Mugiono
Risna Wijayanti
Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Brawijaya, Indonesia

Abstract: This research analyses the effect between perceived usefulness, perceived ease
of use, social influence, trust, and intention to use on a digital zakat application at Malang
City. The object of this research utilizes people who are 23 years of age and over. Besides,
they are required to have income, know about a digital zakat application, and are required to
pay zakat using the application. This research used a nonprobability sampling method with
a purposive sampling technique of 104 respondents. It also utilized smartPLS 3.0 as data
analysis. The research instruments involve the inner model test, outer model, conversion
path diagram, and hypothesis testing. The result of the analysis reveals perceived useful-
ness, perceived ease of use, social influence, and trust explicitly affect intention to use the
digital zakat application. Trust can mediate the influence of perceived usefulness, per-
ceived ease of use, and social influence toward intention to use. Social Influence and Trust
have a dominant influence on intention to use. In this case, service facility providers can
promote digital zakat applications through any media to reach potential consumers. It can
help them give some recommendations about the use of zakat applications. Moreover, it will
Journal of Applied help create trust in consumers about using digital zakat applications.
Management (JAM)
Volume 20 Number 1,
March 2022 Keywords: Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, Social Influence, Trust, Intention
Indexed in DOAJ - to Use, Digital Zakat Application
Directory of Open Access
Journals, ACI - ASEAN
Citation Index, SINTA -
Cite this article as: Kurniawan, I. A., Mugiono, and R. Wijayanti. 2022. The Effect of
Science and Technology Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to Use
Index, and Google Mediated by Trust. Jurnal Aplikasi Manajemen, Volume 20, Number 1, Pages 117–127.
Scholar. Malang: Universitas Brawijaya. http://dx.doi.org/10.21776/ub.jam.2022.020.01.12.

Digital technology was de- etc. Along with the increasing use of smartphones
veloping very rapidly and and the acceptance of electronic learning (e-learn-
Corresponding Author: helped a lot in people’s daily ing), people’s lifestyles are starting to change. Mo-
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mas- life. It can make people get bile devices such as smartphones become an inher-
ter of Management, Faculty of
Economics and Business,Uni- information more accessible ent part of people’s activities and change the socio-
versitas Brawijaya, Indonesia, through digital devices such cultural structure in all aspects (Pimmer, 2016).
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.
21776/ub.jam.2022.020.01.12 as smartphones, computers,

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 117
117
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mugiono, Risna Wijayanti

Digital technology can develop businesses and NU Care Lazismu, BAZNAZ corner, Tokopedia
expand networks, even in profit or nonprofit busi- zakat, and are still being added by the Amil Zakat
nesses. In general, people know the technology only institution and Islamic boarding schools. That pro-
for commercial services and transactions related to vided zakat services regularly digital and the menu
an occupational matter. Meanwhile, it recently of payment features issued by several marketplaces,
started to penetrate the spiritual aspect. Therefore, such as Go-Jek, Shopee, Bukalapak, and several
technology is used in the business field and can be other applications that also include a digital zakat
used in social and religious matters. payment feature, increasingly dominating several
The use of digital information technology in the zakat payment service applications.
social sector started to be done frequently. It is indi- However, in the implementation, there is a prob-
cated by the existence of a digital platform that pro- lem related to the lack of interest in adopting the
vides zakat, Infaq, and alms payment services. The services offered by digital zakat service providers.
application’s existence, it can make the public will Therefore, it creates a different response from so-
be facilitated in making payments and calculating ciety. Digital zakat application offers easy and fast
zakat. transactions for consumers. In contrast, it also makes
Indonesia’s Muslim population reached 87.21% some people unsure about using the application for
in 2017. And as a country with the largest Muslim zakat. Venkatesh (1999) said that individual expec-
population, Indonesia has great potential for national tations regarding a product or system are not al-
zakat, around IDR 217 trillion. However, zakat man- ways limited to performance aspects, even though
aged by BAZNAS is only IDR 8 trillion or around the expected performance of a system has been
1%. Apart from BAZNAS, other zakat institutions found. Therefore, it is not always the strongest pre-
also help to manage the potential of zakat funds from dictor to influence technology acceptance in the user
society to make the available potential can be man- population. It has shown that the user expectations
aged more optimally (Zaenal, 2020). regarding a system can focus on many aspects, es-
Technology is increasingly demanding the zakat pecially in the payment of social assistance such as
fund collection and distribution institution adapt to zakat. Previous studies that examined the variables
the times. Zakat is collected through the institution regarding the effect of interest in use are shown in
of Amil Zakat and can be conducted digitally to save the following Table 1.
time and cost. The existence of several applications The results of previous studies displayed dif-
regarding zakat payment, such as Dana, Aksi Cepat ferent variables. Therefore, it can be a gap for the
Tanggap (ACT), Dompet Dhuafa, Kitabisa, Amalin,

Table 1. Previous Studies

No Connection Research Results Researchers Information


1. Perceived usefulness to positive effect Singh and Sinha (2019)
intention to use positive effect Akbari et al. (2020)
No effect Septiani et al. (2017)
2. Perceived ease of use to positive effect Akbari et al. (2020) Inconsistency of
intention to use positive effect Septiani et al. (2017) Results
No effect Lu (2014)
3. Social influence on intention positive effect Baabdullah (2018)
to use positive effect Hsu et al. (2017)
No effect Afshan and Sharif (2016)
Source: References:2020

118 JOURNAL OF APPLIED MANAGEMENT VOLUME 20 NUMBER 1 MARCH 2022


The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

researcher to deepen the research on technology cluded in an investigation to explain the usability of
acceptance. The current research utilizes a digital technology and convenience for users.
zakat application as the object. It intends to analyze The additional variable is needed to provide a
the determinants of interest in using digital transac- strong model. Even it has a high adoption rate (Legris
tion applications in the social sector. Trust variable et al., 2003). However, Venkatesh and Davis (2000)
is included as a variable mediation test to analyze vanished a provision toward the appropriate tech-
the inconsistency of research results from each nology because of weak predictions regarding us-
variable. Akbari et al. (2020) stated that trust medi- ing the system. Subsequently, the new model is in-
ated the relationship between perceived usefulness troduced as the external variable based on social
and perceived ease of use on the intention to use. influence. In the next section, we review the com-
Besides, Khawaja (2017) also displayed that trust prehensive literature on perceived usefulness, per-
mediated the relationship between social influence ceived ease of use, social influence and trust on
and intention to use. intention to use, and previous research to develop
and support the research hypothesis. Furthermore,
LITERATURE REVIEW the following is the display of the conceptual frame-
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) work (Figure 1).
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is a
Intention to Use
theory of the use of information technology systems
that are considered influential and often explain the Intention to use is users interested in using the
individual acceptance of the use of technology sys- system assuming that they have access to informa-
tems. In the acceptance of the use of technology, tion (Venkatesh et al., 2003). Users will use new
TAM is defined into two variables; perceived ease information technology because they believe tech-
of use and perceived usefulness. Davis (1986) stated nology can improve their performance, easy to use,
that the main aim of TAM is to build a basis for and get the attention of the surrounding environ-
exploring the influence of external factors on the ment. Suki et al. (2011) stated that plans and inter-
attitude and purpose of a person. Further, Davis est are a factor in using digital payment applica-
(1989) said that the external variable should be in- tions.

Perceived
Usefulness (X1)
5
1

Perceived Ease 2 4 Intention


Trust (Z)
of Use (X2) to Use (Y)

3
7
Social Influence
(X3)

Figure 1. Conceptual Model of Research

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 119
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mugiono, Risna Wijayanti

HYPOTHESIS DEVELOPMENT ety, computer playfulness, and perceptions of ex-


Perceived Usefulness ternal control (facilitating conditions) are appropri-
ate with perceived ease of use because those are
Davis (1989) defined Perceived usefulness as
stronger and experience to the system. Akbari et
describing people’s beliefs about how an appropri-
al. (2020) showed that perceived ease of use posi-
ate system can improve performance. Further,
tively affected trust and intention to use. So, the
Adams et al. (1992) also defined Perceived useful-
next hypothesis is obtained from the empirical stud-
ness as the level of a person who believes that us-
ies. Results in this research are as follows:
ing a particular subject will improve work perfor-
H2. Perceived ease of use significantly affected trust.
mance. The perceived usefulness of the technol-
H6. Perceived ease of use significantly affected
ogy acceptance model (TAM) is similar to the per-
intention to use.
formance expectancy of the unified theory of ac-
ceptance and use of technology (UTAUT).
Social Influence
Individual constructs perceived usefulness
based on the instrumental cognition process. It con- Social influence affects people’s behavior if the
structs an observation about the advantage needed emotion is affected by the suggestion of other
in doing a job. TAM2 theory explained mental indi- people. Social influence is an individual belief in
viduals based on the match between work goals and people’s suggestion to use the new system or not
the consequences of job assignments. Besides, it (Venkatesh et al., 2003). Social influence as a de-
used a system as a basis for forming perceptions terminant of intention that is represented of a sub-
about the system’s usefulness (Venkatesh and Davis, jective norm in Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA),
2000). Research that the previous researcher has Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), Theory of
done found proof that perceived usefulness influ- Planned Behavior (TPB) / DTPB, Combined TAM
ences trust and intention to use. Akbari et al. (2020) and TPB (C-TAM-TPB), social influence di Model
showed that perceived usefulness positively affected of PC Utilization (MPCU), and Innovation Diffu-
trust and intention to use. Hypothesis obtained from sion Theory (IDT). Rashotte (2007) stated that an
the empirical studies results in this research are as individual changes his feelings and behavior when
follows: faced with social pressure. The previous research
H1. Perceived usefulness significantly affected trust. found that social influence affects trust and inten-
H5. Perceived usefulness significantly affected in- tion to use. Kaabachi et al. (2019) showed that so-
tention to use. cial influence had a good effect for influencing trust
French Consumers in use. Hsu et al. (2017) revealed
Perceived Ease of Use that social influence positively affects the intention
to use. The next hypothesis is obtained from the
Perceived Ease of Use is defined as people’s
empirical studies. Results in this research are as
belief that using an appropriate system can make it
follows:
easier to be understood (Davis, 1989). It refers to a
H3. Social Influence significantly affected trust.
system that is easy to use (Venkatesh and Davis,
H7. Social influence significantly affected intention
2000). Perceived ease of use in the technology ac-
to use.
ceptance model (TAM) is similar to effort expect-
ancy in the unified theory of acceptance and use of
Trust
technology (UTAUT).
Venkatesh (2000) stated that a person builds a Trust is a behavior displayed by a human who
perception of perceived ease of use system based believes it can be relied on as truthful. Gefen et al.
on guidelines. It is related to individual general be- (2003) defined trust as the individual’s willingness
liefs about technology and the user. Venkatesh to depend on a belief in abilities, virtue, and integ-
(2000) said computer self efûcacy, computer anxi- rity. Trust is the main feature to start using digital

120 JOURNAL OF APPLIED MANAGEMENT VOLUME 20 NUMBER 1 MARCH 2022


The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

transactions. It is related to social and economic Q² = 1 – (1 – R1²) (1 – R2²).....(1 - Rn²)


transactions (Pavlou, 2003). Q2 = 1 – [( 1 – 0.815) ( 1 – 0.771)] = 0.958
The cumulative experience significantly influ-
ences customer confidence in the vendor’s compe- The R-square of the trust variable is 0.815 or
tence, predictability, and goodwill (Siau and Shen, 81.5%. It indicates the diversity of trust variables
2003). Trust plays an important role in technology can be explained by perceived usefulness, ease of
acceptance, system reliability, and availability when use, and social influence as 81.5%. On the other
users need services. It is an important factor af- hand, the contribution of perceived usefulness, per-
fecting the adoption of these services. Research ceived ease of use, and social influence on trust is
results that previous researchers had done found 81.5%. Meanwhile, the rest of 18.5% is the contri-
that trust could influence intention to use and be- bution of the other variables which are not discussed
come variable mediation for intention to use. For in this research.
instance, research that had been done by Akbari et Furthermore, the R-square variable intention to
al. (2020) showed that trust has a positive effect on use is valued at 0.771 or 77.1%. It indicates the
the intention to use and can mediate perceived use- diversity of intention to use variables can be ex-
fulness and perceived ease of use on intention to plained by perceived usefulness, perceived ease of
use. Moreover, Gong et al. (2019) showed that trust use, social influence, and trust as 77.1%. Besides,
could mediate social influence on intention to use. the contribution of perceived usefulness, perceived
Therefore, the next hypothesis is as follows: ease of use, social influence, and trust on the inten-
H4. The trust significantly affected intention to use. tion to use is 77.1%. Meanwhile, the remaining
H8. The trust mediated the relationship of perceived 22.9% is not discussed in the contribution of the
usefulness toward intention to use. other variables. Q-Square predictive relevance (Q2)
H9. The trust mediated the relationship perceived is 0.958 or 95.8%. It indicates the overall model of
ease of use toward intention to use. 95.8% can explain the diversity of intention to use
H10. The trust mediated the relationship of social variables. In addition, the contribution of perceived
influence toward intention to use. usefulness, perceived ease of use, social influence,
and trust on the overall intention to use is 95.8%.
Determination Coefficient Test (R²) Meanwhile, the rest amounting to 4.2%, is the con-
Predictive Relevance Test Q2 and GoF (Good- tribution of other variables that are not discussed.
ness of fit)
METHOD
This research uses quantitative methods and
Table 2. The Goodness of fit Model
an explanatory research dissertation. The popula-
tion and sample are consumers in Malang City who
Endogen R2 are familiar with the digital zakat application, whether
Trust 0.815 they have used the application or not. The sampling
Intention to use 0.771 method used in this study is non-probability sam-
Q2 = 1 – [( 1 – R12) ( 1 – R22 )] pling with purposive sampling. The correspondents
Q2 = 1 – [( 1 – 0.815) ( 1 – 0.771)] are 104 persons with the criteria; Muslim, 23 years
= 0.958 and over, have income, know the digital zakat appli-
Source: Primary Data Processed (2020) cation, whether they have used the application or
not. The research instrument is a questionnaire given
online according to the respondents’ preferences.
The inner model is tested by using the Predic- Besides, it used a Likert scale to measure each item
tive - Relevance (Q2) value, and the formula as of questions asked to respondents. The devices used
follows: to analyze the data are Partial Least Square (PLS)

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 121
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mugiono, Risna Wijayanti

and the SmartPLS3.0 application. The research cational background, most of them were dominated
analysis used the path to test the outer model, inner by S1/S2/S3 level as many as 98 people (94.2%)
model, hypothesis testing, and research mediation. and for professional background teacher/lecturer
were dominating 27 people (26%). Respondents who
RESULTS have monthly income IDR 3.000.000-5.000.000 got
Based on the results of data collection answers the most numbers as many as 35 people (33.7%)
from 104 respondents, 52 people (50%) from total from total respondents. Last, 14 people (13.5%)
female respondents and the rest of 52 (50%) male have ever used the digital zakat application and the
respondents. The age range of the majority of re- rest of 90 people (86.5%) have not ever used the
spondents was between 23 to 30 years old, that is app.
53 people (51%). For respondents classified by edu-

Tabel 3. Hypothesis Test Results of Direct Effect

Hypoth- Path Coeffi- Error t-


esis Relationship Between Variables Result
cient Standard statistic
H1 Perceived usefulness – trust 0.297 0.107 2.765 Significant Accepted
H2 Perceived ease of use – trust 0.472 0.101 4.695 Significant Accepted
H3 Social influence – trust 0.239 0.068 3.486 Significant Accepted
H4 Trust – intention to use 0.526 0.132 3.994 Significant Accepted
H5 Perceived usefulness –intention to use 0.309 0.120 2.574 Significant Accepted
H6 Perceived ease of use – intention to use -0.305 0.109 2.801 Significant Accepted
H7 Social influence –intention to use 0.400 0.099 4.035 Significant Accepted
Source: Primary Data Processed (2020)

Based on the Table above, it is known that the Therefore, hypothesis (H5) is accepted, which
H1 path coefficient value is 0.297, the standard er- means perceived usefulness directly affects the in-
ror is 0.107, and the t-statistic is 2.765. Therefore, tention to use. The coefficient value of the H6 path
(H1) is accepted, which means perceived useful- is 0.305, the standard error is 0.109, and the t-sta-
ness directly affects trust. The H2 path coefficient tistic is 2.801. Therefore, the hypothesis of H6 is
value is 0.472, the standard error is 0.101, and the t- accepted, which means perceived ease of use has
statistic is 4,695. Therefore, the hypothesis (H2) is a direct effect on the intention to use. The coeffi-
accepted, which means perceived ease of use di- cient value of the H7 path is 0.400, the standard
rectly affects trust. error is 0.099, and the t-statistic is 4.035. There-
The coefficient value of the H3 pathway is fore, the hypothesis of H7 is accepted, which means
0.239, the standard error is 0.068, and the t-statistic social influence has a direct effect on the intention
is 3.486. Then, H3 is accepted, which means social to use.
influence directly affects trust. The coefficient value The coefficient value of the H8 path is 0.156,
of the H4 line is 0.526, the standard error is 0.132, the standard error is 0.069, and the t-statistic is 2.273.
and the t-statistic is 3.994. It reveals that the hy- Therefore, the hypothesis of H8 is accepted, which
pothesis (H4) is accepted, which means trust di- means that trust can mediate the perceived useful-
rectly affects the intention to use. At H5, the path ness to intention to use. The coefficient value of the
coefficient value is obtained as 0.309, the standard H9 pathway is 0.248, the standard error is 0.082,
error is 0.120, and the t-statistic is 2.574. and the t-statistic is 3.042. Therefore, the hypoth-

122 JOURNAL OF APPLIED MANAGEMENT VOLUME 20 NUMBER 1 MARCH 2022


The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

Table 4. Hypothesis Test Results of Indirect Effect

Hypoth- Path Coeffi- Error t-


esis Relationship Between Variables cient Standard statistic Result

H8 Perceived usefulness – trust – 0.156 0.069 2.273 Significant Accepted


intention to use (partial mediation)
H9 Perceived ease of use – trust – 0.248 0.082 3.042 Significant Accepted
intention to use (partial mediation)
H10 Social influence – trust – intention 0.126 0.048 2.626 Significant Accepted
to use (partial mediation)
Source: Primary Data Processed (2020)

esis of H9 is accepted, which means trust can me- there is a positive relationship significantly between
diate perceived ease of use to intention to use. perceived usefulness on trust, and Akbari et al.
The coefficient value of the H10 pathway is (2020) showed that perceived usefulness has a good
0.126, the standard error is 0.048, and the t-statistic effect on trust.
is 2.626. Therefore, the hypothesis of H10 is ac-
cepted, which means trust can mediate the social The Effect of Perceived Ease of Use on Trust
influence on intention to use. This research reveals that perceived ease of
use has a significant positive effect on trust. It means
DISCUSSION that increasing perceived ease of use can directly
The Effect of Perceived Usefulness on Trust increase trust. The impact of perceived ease of use
The results of the analysis reveal that perceived on trust makes consumers familiar with the use of
usefulness affected trust. According to Davis (1989), digital applications that various vendors provide.
the perceived usefulness of technology depends on According to Davis (1989), perceived ease of use
a person’s perception. It refers to people’s belief in related to the extent to people’s belief in using a
a certain system that can improve their performance. certain system is easy to be understood. It is re-
If the technology adopted follows people’s needs in lated to avoiding difficulties and errors when using
working, then one’s trust in the technology directly the system.
increases in proportion. Technology is symbolically considered to pro-
This research reveals the various benefits is vide comfort to give confidence in carrying out a
offered by the digital zakat application to fulfill the task. The perceived effect of ease of use on trust is
benefits of paying zakat practically. It can construct that consumers can recognize the use of digital ap-
consumers’ trust and consumers start to believe that plication technology provided by various vendors.
the digital zakat application can complete their needs. Then, consumers are easy understand the use the
The descriptive analysis displayed the digital zakat digital zakat payment applications. Besides, consum-
application as the main indicator of perceived use- ers believe the digital zakat application is a trust-
fulness. It indicates that the availability of the digi- worthy and easy electronic transaction. This re-
tal zakat application provides the benefit of making search result supports the study by Sarkar et al.
it easier for consumers to pay zakat quickly and (2020), which significantly showed a positive rela-
accurately. Therefore, consumers’ trust arises re- tionship between perceived ease of use and trust.
garding the efficiency in paying zakat. This Akbari et al. (2020) showed that perceived ease of
research’s result supports the previous research that use positively affects trust.
has been done by Sarkar et al. (2020) is shows that

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 123
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mugiono, Risna Wijayanti

The Effect of Social Influence on Trust tomer funds in digital wallets and misuse of data
This research reveals that trust is affected by customers for criminal acts will be a consideration
social influence. It means that better social influ- for trusts from consumers to use digital zakat appli-
ence can increase trust. Rashotte (2007) stated that cations. The result is supported by Venkatesh
individuals would change their feelings and behav- (1999). He stated that individual expectations about
ior when faced with social pressure and interact a product or system are not always limited. Besides,
with others. on the performance aspect, even though the ex-
The use of social media is considered an ef- pected performance of a system has been found.
fective way to interact with consumers. It refers to The security aspect needs to be improved in the
giving on the Google Play Store application and pro- digital zakat application. This research result sup-
viding feedback on promotional ads on the YouTube ported the previous research that has been done by
channel. It has been proven that the use of social Lafraxo et al. (2018), which shows trust influences
networking applications (SNS such as Facebook, intention to use, and research result by Sharma et
YouTube, Twitter, and company blogs) is recom- al. (2018) trust has a good influence on intention to
mended to signify trust in consumers who were pre- use.
viously unfamiliar with the products offered
(Brengman and Karimov, 2012). This research re- The Effect of Perceived Usefulness to Inten-
sult supports the research done by Kaabachi et al. tion to Use
(2019), which shows social influence is bringing good This research reveals that the intention to use
effect in influencing French consumer’s trust. is affected by perceived usefulness. It means the
Khawaja (2017) showed that social influence posi- increasing perceived usefulness influences consum-
tively affects trust. ers’ intention to use digital zakat applications.
Venkatesh and Davis (2000) stated that an
The Effect of Trust on Intention to Use individual’s perceived usefulness pattern is based
Trust significantly influences the intention to on cognitive instrumental processes. It refers to an
use. It means the higher the trust can increase the individual’s pattern of judgments about perceived
intention to use. Perceived trust is the main compo- benefits. Cognitively, it compares the system of
nent of technology adoption. Besides, it helps ser- people’s needs in working matter. Therefore, the
vice providers to build strong relationships. Perceived perceived usefulness benefits consumers in distrib-
trust in technology is an emotional state that en- uting zakat more effectively through the digital zakat
courages a person to trust based on previous expe- application. The next effect is the emergence of
riences. This descriptive analysis reveals that the the intention to use the digital zakat application.
digital zakat application item providing reliable ser- Consumers can adjust the types of zakat transac-
vice has the most important value in variable trust. tions they want to pay and routinely use the digital
Consumers believe the digital zakat application of- zakat application according to their regularly avail-
fered by service provider vendors has good perfor- able needs. These results support the research con-
mance. It makes consumers are confident with more ducted by Singh and Sinha (2019), showing that
specific payment applications such as digital zakat perceived usefulness has a significant effect on the
and intention to use for consumers. Then, the re- intention to use. The results of Akbari et al. (2020)
sults of the analysis also display that the digital zakat showed that perceived usefulness has a significant
application provides safe financial services and has positive impact on intention to use.
the lowest value even though they have a good in-
terpretation. This cannot be separated from prob- The Effect of Perceived Ease of Use to Inten-
lems that often occur due to weaknesses in pay- tion to Use
ment transaction applications in general, breaking Perceived ease of use negatively affected the
of customer accounts which result in loss of cus- intention to use. It means the increasing perceived

124 JOURNAL OF APPLIED MANAGEMENT VOLUME 20 NUMBER 1 MARCH 2022


The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

ease of use reduces consumers’ intention to use digi- one to adopt the technology because many people
tal zakat applications. Consumers are accus- have proven the benefits. Baabdullah (2018) stated
tomed to using paid applications. Therefore, con- that social influence positively affected customers’
sumers expect innovation in an application. In the intention to use. Then, Hsu et al. (2017) revealed
absence of direct consumer experience regarding that social influence positively affects the intention
digital zakat applications related to perceived ease to use.
of use, consumers use the general experience in
assessing digital zakat applications. Therefore, it The Effect of Trust Mediated Perceived Use-
displays the first stages of the user experience. fulness to Intention to Use
There is a general determinant for perceived ease The coefficient of indirect effect perceived
of use of an application system (Venkatesh and usefulness on the intention to use through trust is
Davis, 1996). Therefore, the trust factor of con- 0.156. It indicates that perceived usefulness signifi-
sumers also plays a role in generating the intention cantly positively affects the intention to use through
to use the wishes offered by service providers of trust. It means that the better-perceived usefulness
digital zakat applications. causes the high of trust. Besides, it tends to increase
Several applications provide convenience to the intention to use. The analysis results reveal that
transfer funds in a certain amount without provid- perceived usefulness has an important impact on
ing proof of transactions, limit, and payment history. intention to use through trust. However, the impact
It makes consumers feel doubt about the credibility of trust mediation is known as partial mediation.
of the zakat application. This research is different Therefore, it can be interpreted that trust can con-
from Akbari et al. (2020) that displayed the results nect the influence of perceived usefulness on the
of perceived ease of use have a positive influence intention to use. However, perceived usefulness in
on the intention to use. and this research has a dif- digital zakat applications can increase the intention
ferent view from Septiani et al. (2017) in that she to use without trust. This research supports the study
revealed the perceived ease of use positively af- by Singh and Sinha (2019), which stated that trust
fects the intention to use. mediates the effect of perceived usefulness on the
intention to use. Then, Akbari et al. (2020) displayed
The Effect of Social Influence on Intention to that the results of trust mediate the relationship be-
Use tween perceived usefulness and intention to use.
Social influence influences the intention to use.
The increasing social influence reduces the inten- The Effect of Trust Mediated Perceived Ease
tion to use digital zakat applications. The analysis of Use to Intention to Use
results display that media suggest people pay zakat The indirect effect of perceived ease of use on
through a digital application. It is the main determi- the intention to use through trust is 0.248. It indi-
nant in influencing consumers to create the inten- cates that perceived ease of use significantly posi-
tion to use for consumers to use the digital zakat tively affects the intention to use through trust. It
application. It also refers to web-based social net- explains that the better-perceived ease of use causes
works providing different methods, such as chat high trust. It tends to increase the intention to use.
rooms and discussion forums for individuals to in- This research shows that perceived ease of use has
teract, exchange opinions, and compare experiences an important impact on intention to use through trust.
with others (Kim and Srivastava, 2007). According However, the impact of trust mediation is known to
to Venkatesh et al. (2003), social influence is de- be partial mediation. The results of this study sup-
fined as the degree to which an individual assumes port the findings of several previous studies that
that other people convince him that he must use a show trust can mediate perceived ease of use to-
new system or not. The other suggestions a person wards intention to use. This research supports the
receives for using technology will influence some- study results by Akbari et al. (2020), which stated

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 125
Ilham Agung Kurniawan, Mugiono, Risna Wijayanti

that showing the results of trust mediates the rela- can be concluded that perceived usefulness, per-
tionship between perceived ease of use and inten- ceived ease of use, and social influence have an
tion to use. important impact on the intention to use.

The Effect of Trust Mediated Social Influence RECOMMENDATIONS


on Intention to Use Social influence and trust are variables that have
The coefficient of indirect social influence on the most dominant influence on intention to use.
intention to use through trust is 0.126. It indicates Service providers can benefit from this opportunity
that social influence significantly positively affects to promote digital zakat applications through any
the intention to use through trust. It means that the media to reach potential consumers. So, they can
high of trust is caused by better social influence and help recommend using the digital zakat app through
tends to increase the intention to use. The result the circle of consumers. Then, it will help create a
revealed that perceived ease of use has an impor- trust to increase consumers’ interest in using digital
tant impact on intention to use through trust. How- zakat applications.
ever, the impact of trust mediation is known to be In this research, the researcher only uses per-
partial mediation. This research supports Gong et ceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, social in-
al. (2019). He said trust in service providers plays a fluence, and trust to be known about the influence
mediating role between subjective norms and inten- on intention to use. For further research, the re-
tion to use. Furthermore, as Khawaja’s (2017) state- searcher expects this research to be expanded and
ment, trust mediates the relationship between so- integrated with more complex theories and other
cial influence on intention to use. factors that can influence intention to use.

CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES
Based on hypothesis testing, discussion results, Adams, D. A., Nelson, R. R., and Todd, P. .1992. Per-
and research findings reveal the conclusions as fol- ceived Usefulness, Ease of Use, and Usage of Infor-
lows: mation Technology: A Replication. MIS Quarterly,
Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, 16(2), pp. 227–247.
Afshan, S. and Sharif, A. 2016. Acceptance of Mobile
and social influence have a significant positive ef-
Banking Framework in Pakistan. Telematics and
fect on trust. Therefore, it can be concluded that Informatics, 33(2), pp. 370–387.
the increase in perceived usefulness, perceived ease Akbari, M., Rezvani, A., Shahriari, E., Zúñiga, M. A.,
of use, and social influence can increase consumer Pouladian, H. 2020. Acceptance of 5G Technology:
trust in the digital zakat application. Perceived use- Mediation Role of Trust and Concentration. Jour-
fulness, social influence, and trust have a signifi- nal of Engineering and Technology Management -
cant positive effect on the intention to use. There- JET-M, 57(July 2019), p. 101585.
fore, it can be concluded that increased perceived Baabdullah, A. M. 2018. Consumer adoption of Mobile
usefulness, social influence, and trust can increase Social Network Games (M-SNGs) in Saudi Arabia:
consumers’ intention to use digital zakat applications. The role of social influence, hedonic motivation,
and trust. Technology in society, 53, pp. 91–102.
However, different results are found on perceived
Brengman, M. and Karimov, F. 2012. The Effect of Web
ease of use which had a significant negative effect Communities on Consumers Initial Trust in B2C E-
on the intention to use. Therefore, it can be con- Commerce Websites. Management Research Review,
cluded that the increasing perceived ease of use 35(9), pp. 791–817.
reduces consumers’ intention to use in using digital Davis, F. D. 1986. A Technology Acceptance Model for
zakat applications. Trust can mediate the effect of Empirically Testing New End User Information
perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and Systems: Theory and Results. Computer Science,
social influence on intention to use. Therefore, it (1986), pp. 233–250.

126 JOURNAL OF APPLIED MANAGEMENT VOLUME 20 NUMBER 1 MARCH 2022


The Effect of Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, And Social Influence toward Intention to ...

Davis, F. D. 1989. Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease hanced Learning/ ?. Interactive Learning Environ-
of Use, and User Acceptance of Information Tech- ments ISSN: 4820(March).
nology. MIS Quarterly, 13(5), pp. 319–339. Rashotte, L. 2007. Social Influence. The Blackwell Ency-
Gefen, Karahanna, and Straub. 2003. Trust and Tam in clopedia of Sociology: 443/sociology/docs/
Online Shopping: an Integrated Model. MIS Quar- BEOS_S1413, pp. 1–3.
terly, 27(1), pp. 51–90. Sarkar, S., Chauhan, S. and Khare, A. 2020. A Meta Analy-
Gong, Z., Han, Z., Li, X., Yu, C., and Reinhardt, J. D. 2019. sis of Antecedents and Consequences of Trust in
Factors Influencing the Adoption of Online Health Mobile Commerce. International Journal of Infor-
Consultation Services: The Role of Subjective mation Management, 50(March 2019), pp. 286–301.
Norm, Trust, Perceived Benefit, and Offline Habit. Septiani, R., Handayani, P. W., and Azzahro, F. 2017. Fac-
Frontiers in Public Health, 7(October), pp. 1–9. tors that Affecting Behavioral Intention in Online
Hsu, C., Lin, Y. and Chen, M. 2017. Investigating The Transportation Service: Case study of GO-JEK.
Determinants of E-Book Adoption. Program: elec- Procedia Computer Science, 124, pp. 504–512.
tronic library and information systems, 51(1), pp. 2– Sharma, S. K., Al Badi, A., Rana, N. P., & Al-Azizi, L. 2018.
16. Mobile Applications in Government Services (mG-
Kaabachi, S., Ben Mrad, S. and O’Leary, B. 2019. App) from User’s Perspectives: A Predictive Mod-
Consumer’s Initial Trust Formation in IOB’s Ac- elling Approach. Government Information Quar-
ceptance: The Role of Social Influence and Per- terly, 35(4), pp. 557–568.
ceived Compatibility. International Journal of Bank Siau, B. K. and Shen, Z. 2003. Building Customer Trust
Marketing, 37(2), pp. 507–530. in Mobile Commerce. Communications of the ACM,
Khawaja, K. F. 2017. Why Should I Trust ICT/ ? An Em- 46(4), pp. 91–94.
pirical Study Examining Teachers and Students Singh, N. and Sinha, N. 2019. How Perceived Trust Me-
Usage of ICT for Knowledge Sharing and Seeking. diates Merchant’s Intention to Use a Mobile Wal-
International Conference on Advances in Business let Technology. Journal of Retailing and Consumer
and Law (ICABL), 2017, pp. 419–439. Services, 52(July 2019), p. 101894.
Kim, Y. A. and Srivastava, J. 2007. Impact of Social Influ- Suki, N. M., Ramayah, T., and Ly, K. K. 2011. Empirical
ence in E-Commerce Decision Making. Proceed- Investigation on Factors Influencing the Behav-
ings of the Ninth International Conference on Elec- ioral Intention to Use Facebook. Universal Access
tronic Commerce - ICEC 07, pp. 293–301. in the Information Society, 11(2), pp. 223–231.
Lafraxo, Y. Hadri., Amhal, H., and Rossafi. 2018. The Ef- Venkatesh and Davis. 2000. A Theoretical Extension of
fect of Trust, Perceived Risk, and Security on The the Technology Acceptance Model: Four Longitu-
Adoption of Mobile Banking in Morocco. ICEIS dinal Field Studies. Management Science, 46(2),
2018 - Proceedings of the 20th International Confer- pp. 186–204.
ence on Enterprise Information Systems, 2 (Iceis), Venkatesh, V. 1999. Creation of Favorable User Percep-
pp. 497–502. tions: Exploring The Role of Intrinsic Motivation.
Legris, P., Ingham, J. and Collerette, P. 2003. Why do MIS Quarterly, 23(2), pp. 239–260.
People Use Information Technology? A Critical Venkatesh, V. 2000. Determinants of Perceived Ease of
Review of The Technology Acceptance Model. In- Use/ : Integrating Control, Intrinsic Motivation,
formation & Management, 40, pp. 191–204. Acceptance Model. Inorganic Chemistry Communi-
Lu, J. 2014. Are Personal Innovativeness and social In- cations, 11(3), pp. 319–340.
fluence Critical to Continue With Mobile Com- Venkatesh, Morris, Davis, and Davis. 2003. User Accep-
merce/ ?. Internet Research, 24(2), pp. 134–159. tance of Information Technology: Toward A Uni-
Pavlou, P. A. 2003. Consumer Acceptance of Electronic fied View. MIS Quarterly, 27(3), pp. 425–478.
Commerce: Integrating Trust and Risk with the Venkatesh, V. and Davis, F. D. 1996. A Model of The An-
Technology Acceptance Model. International Jour- tecedents of Perceived Ease of Use: Development
nal of Electronic Commerce, 7(3), pp. 37–41. and Test. Decision Sciences, 27(3), pp. 451–481.
Pimmer, C. 2016. Mobile Learning As Boundary Cross- Zaenal, M. H. 2020. Indikator Pemetaan Potensi Zakat
ing/ : An Alternative Route to Technology En- (IPPZ). Books - Puskas Baznas, [S.l.], v. 4.

ACCREDITED by Ministry of Research and Technology Republic of Indonesia, No 200/M/KPT/2020 ISSN: 1693-5241 127

You might also like