ASME Y14.

5-2018 - APPENDIX E
4.1 FUNDAMENTAL RULES
(The following dimensioning rules appear on page 4 of the Y14.5 Dimensioning and Tolerancing
Standard. The Times Roman font is what appears in the Standard. The italics font are comments
about the rules.)
Dimensioning and tolerancing shall clearly define engineering intent and shall conform to the
following:
(a) Each feature shall be toleranced. Tolerances may be applied directly to size dimensions.
Tolerances shall be applied using feature control frames when feature definition is basic.
Tolerances may also be indicated by a note or located in a supplementary block of the drawing
format. See ASME Y14.1 and ASME Y14.1M. Those dimensions specifically identified as
reference, maximum, minimum, or stock (commercial stock size) do not require the application
of a tolerance.
The Y14.5 standard has move away from applying plus/minus tolerances to location dimensions.
The Y14.5-2018 chairman stated in the Forward, “This 2018 revision emphasizes the use of
profile for location tolerances applied to surfaces; the use of plus and minus tolerances has been
moved to an Appendix that is likely to be removed in the next revision.”
(b) Dimensioning and tolerancing shall be complete so there is full understanding of the
characteristics of each feature. Values may be expressed in an engineering drawing or in a CAD
product definition data set. See ASME Y14.41. Neither scaling (measuring directly from an
engineering drawing graphics sheet) nor assumption of a distance or size is permitted, except in
undimensioned drawings, such as loft, printed wiring, templates, and master layouts prepared on
stable material, provided the necessary control dimensions are specified. Model data shall be
queried when dimensions are not displayed on the model.
This rule sets a goal. Drawings may be perfect, but produced parts are not. Companies may have
different ideas as to what the word “complete” actually means. Maybe “complete” means that
all the part features can be related back to the datum reference frame(s).
(c) Each necessary dimension of an end product shall be shown or defined by model data. No
more dimensions than those necessary for complete definition shall be given. The use of
reference dimensions on a drawing should be minimized.
The concept of an end part is meant to be the part as it is in a final assembly. The cast, forged, or
molded part is an end product to the person who makes them. To the person doing the
machining, the end product is the machined part not the casting or forging. The reason for
limiting reference dimensions is the possibility of producing or inspecting parts with reference
dimensions.
(d) Dimensions shall be selected and arranged to suit the function and mating relationship of a
part and shall not be subject to more than one interpretation.
While function and relationship may be on the top of the list, there are other reasons to apply
dimensions. This rule may allow all the drawings for a multiple part assembly to be considered
one package. The individual drawings can be considered chapters in a book. As with any good
non-mystery book, one logical chapter (detail drawing) should lead to the next logical chapter
and ultimately to the final chapter (assembly drawing).
(e) The drawing should define a part without specifying manufacturing methods. Thus, only the
diameter of a hole is given without indicating whether it is to be drilled, reamed, punched, or
made by another operation. However, in those instances where manufacturing, processing,
quality assurance, or environmental information is essential to the definition of engineering
requirements, the information shall be specified on the drawing or in a document referenced on
the drawing.
The main reason for this rule is that manufacturing methods m improving. It is a disservice to
manufacturing personnel to restrict their ability to make the highest quality products in the least
amount of time. Hopefully all specified manufacturing methods noted on the drawing were
created with the assistance of the manufacturing personnel. An instance where a designer will
want to specify a manufacturing method is with heat-treating materials. Different heat treat
methods can yield vastly different results.
(f) Nonmandatory processing dimensions shall be identified by an appropriate note, such as
NONMANDATORY (MFG DATA). Examples of nonmandatory data are processing
dimensions that provide for finish allowance, shrink allowance, and other requirements, provided
the final dimensions are given on the drawing.
As an example of when this rule may come into play is where a company applies a rough turn
diameter, finish turn diameter, grind diameter and an after plating diameter on the same
diameter of a shaft. The last diameter is the only one that really matters to the designer. As
nonmandatory information, the other diameters are suggestions. Another example is when a
cylindrical part is allowed to have holes drilled in the ends to accept lathe centers. Rather than
specify a manufacturing function by defining the sizes, the common note is, CENTERS
PERMISSABLE.
(g) Dimensions should be arranged to provide required information for optimum readability.
This is not so much a rule as good dimensioning practice. This rule can be a challenge when
applying model-based dimensions. The dimensions may appear arranged well in one orientation
but the dimensions may appear to collide when the model is oriented differently.
(h) Dimensions in orthographic views should be shown in true profile views and refer to visible
outlines. When dimensions are shown in models, the dimensions shall be applied in a manner
that shows the true value.
One example is to place the size of a hole in the same view as its location dimensions. Another is
to place dimensions that apply to two adjacent views between those views. If a feature is hidden
from view, a section view will be required so visible outlines may used for dimensioning.
(i) Wires, cables, sheets, rods, and other materials manufactured to gage or code numbers shall
be specified by linear dimensions indicating the diameter or thickness. Gage or code numbers
may be shown in parentheses following the dimension.
This rule is an extension of the “commercial stock size” part of rule (a). It is common to include
the dimension and gage or some other code if it exists. Different users of the drawing may know
the material by the dimension only or by the code only.
(j) An implied 90° angle shall apply where center lines and lines depicting features are shown on
orthographic views at right angles and no angle is specified. For information on applicable
tolerances for implied 90° angles, see para. 5.1.1.3.
This is a very significant rule. Lines that appear to be at 90° angles to each other are at 90°
angles. To adhere to rule A, a default angular tolerance must be stated on the drawing or in an
external specification. If the angular tolerance is ±1°, the tolerance zone is a 2D “V” shape with
an angle between 89° – 91°.
(k) An implied 90° basic angle shall apply where center lines of features or surfaces shown at
right angles on an orthographic view are located or defined by basic dimensions and no angle is
specified. For information on applicable tolerances for implied 90° basic angles, see para.
5.1.1.4.
This rule is the basis for the geometric controls of perpendicularity, profile and position and
effectively replaces Rule (j). It applies between two perpendicular features where one is the
datum feature and the other is geometrically controlled to the datum feature. The 90° angle
between them is considered perfect. This allows the tolerance zone, which is oriented at a basic
90° angle to be considered perfect.
(l) A zero basic dimension shall apply where axes, center planes, or surfaces are shown
coincident on orthographic views and geometric tolerances establish the relationship between the
features. On CAD models, the distance is basic when queried model distances are zero and
geometric tolerances establish the relationship between the features. For information on
applicable tolerances for zero basic dimensions, see para. 5.1.1.4.
This rule is the basis for the geometric control of coaxial position. It applies between two coaxial
features where one is the datum feature and the other is geometrically controlled to the datum
feature. The 0° angle between the feature axes is considered perfect. This allows the tolerance
zone, which is based the 0° basic angle to be considered perfect.
(m) UOS, all dimensions and tolerances are applicable at 20°C (68°F) in accordance with ASME
B89.6.2. Compensation may be made for measurements made at other temperatures.
This rule reduces arguments between suppliers and customers by setting an environmental
standard that all should be agree to. Some machine tools and inspection equipment may include
temperature compensation. There is no humidity requirement stated in the Y14.5 standard.
(n) UOS, all dimensions and tolerances apply in a free state condition. For exceptions to this
rule, see subsection 7.20.
A “free state” refers to measuring parts without additional forces applied. If parts are restrained
in their application, any measurements should be made in that same restrained condition. The
drawing should note the restraint amount and location.
(o) UOS, all tolerances and datum features apply for full depth, length, and width of the feature.
If this rule is not required, a partial datum, chain line, datum target area can be used to show the
limited area that is the datum feature.
(p) Dimensions and tolerances apply only at the drawing level where they are specified. A
dimension specified for a giv
en feature on one level of drawing (e.g., a detail drawing) is not mandatory for that feature at any
other level (e.g., an assembly drawing).
One reason for this rule is heat. The heat from welding processes can distort the welded parts.
Some critical dimensions may need to be rechecked after heat induced processes. Other
processes also may alter part geometry.
(q) UOS by a drawing/model note or reference to a separate document, the as-designed
dimension value does not establish a functional or manufacturing target.
The “dimension value” is a number. It conveys no meaning.
(r) Where a coordinate system is shown on the orthographic views or in the model, it shall be
right-handed UOS. Each axis shall be labeled and the positive direction shown.
NOTE: Where a model coordinate system is shown on the drawing, it shall be in compliance
with ASME Y14.41.
This is a rule that most everyone assumed, but did not appear in the Y14.5 standard. It was
created to coordinate with the ASME Y14.41 standard which states in Paragraph 5.1.3,
“Coordinate systems shall be right-handed unless otherwise specified.”
(s) UOS, elements of a surface include surface texture and flaws (e.g., burrs and scratches). All
elements of a surface shall be within the applicable specified tolerance zone boundaries.
This rule is similar to rule (o) except that it specifically mentions surface texture and flaws. Some
companies consider these features (especially burrs and scratches) to be independent from size
and geometric tolerances. Those companies may elect to create their own standards that define
the parameters of features outside the size and geometric tolerances.