You are on page 1of 27

Cretaceous-Paleogene rifting on the NW margin of the Australian

continent, SE Banda Arc region


Tim Charlton
1Saint Omer Ridge, Guildford, Surrey GU1 2DD, U.K.
timrcharlton@gmail.com

ABSTRACT

The Banda Terrane successions of Timor Island and correlative units in Sumba are widely
considered allochthonous with respect to the Australian continental margin successions that
form the main part of the Banda arc-continent collision complex. A new interpretation is
proposed for the Banda Terrane, which suggests that these units originated on the outermost
(northern) edge of the Australian continent. Volcanic successions in the Banda Terrane, which
date to the Cretaceous and Paleogene (Aptian/Albian to Eocene), are interpreted as
originating in a backarc/marginal basin setting behind a northward-facing arc that rifted
away from the NW margin of Australia through this period. The Banda terrane successions
are interpreted as representing the southern, continent-attached portion of the marginal basin,
and occupied a position on the distal edge of Australia up to the onset of Banda arc-continent
collision in the Miocene.
Supporting evidence for an Australian margin origin of the Banda Terrane includes very
similar age ranges for zircons dated to the Cretaceous in Sumba and Timor (Banda Terrane)
and in sandstones of the Ungar Formation in Tanimbar, the latter forming an element of the
Australian margin succession. In Timor there is also previously reported evidence for
continental margin rifting during the Late Cretaceous, while contemporaneous Late
Cretaceous-Paleogene volcanism is also recognised in the Bird’s Head-Misool region of
eastern Indonesia, which forms part of the Australian continental margin. In addition, a
number of stratigraphic links between the Banda Terrane and the Australian continental
margin successions in Timor are summarised in this study.
The effects of the Cretaceous-Paleogene rifting event are also apparent in subsidence curves
derived from petroleum exploration wells drilled on the northern ‘passive’ continental margin
of Australia from SW of Timor to the Bird’s Head-Misool region of eastern Indonesia. Inferred
rift-related subsidence commenced in the Aptian-Albian on the Australian palaeo-margin
immediately east of Timor and developed sporadically but in regionally consistent groupings
throughout the Late Cretaceous and Paleogene.
Keywords: Banda Terrane, Timor Island, NW Australia, Cretaceous-Paleogene rifting

Copyright ©2023 by Author, published by FOSI. Author doesn’t retain all rights. This
is an open access article distributed under Creative Commons License (CC-BY-SA 4.0).

Manuscript received: 11 Jan 2023, revised manuscript received: 27 Apr 2023, final
acceptance: 26 May 2023. DOI: 10.51835/bsed.2023.49.2.437

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 1


to which there is an ‘allochthonous’, non-
INTRODUCTION Australian component in the present-day
In a previous paper published in this Banda arc-continent collision complex. At
journal (Charlton, 2012), the present present, probably the majority opinion
writer reviewed the paleogeographic amongst geologists actively investigating
evolution of the SE Banda Arc region that this area is that there is a substantial body
extends from Timor Island in the west to of allochthonous material in the Banda
the Tanimbar and Kei islands in the east forearc, and particularly in Timor island
(Figure 1). The present paper seeks to where stratigraphic elements such as the
continue the evolutionary development of Mutis metamorphic complex (in
this region through the Cretaceous and Indonesian West Timor, and its direct
Paleogene. Remarkably, although much equivalent the Lolotoi Complex in Timor-
closer to the present-day in time, the Leste) and their cover sequences including
paleogeographic evolution through the the Cretaceous-Paleogene Palelo Group,
Cretaceous and Tertiary is rather less-well the Eocene Dartollu Limestone Formation
constrained than for the earlier period and Paleogene Metan and Barique
covered by the preceding paper. The volcanic successions are considered to
difficulty centres primarily around the derive from a pre-collisional Banda forearc
ongoing controversy regarding the degree that developed on the southern margin of

Figure1: Location and tectonic setting of the SE Banda Arc region. The Banda-Sunda volcanic
arc is shown in pink; the forearc ridge (Sumba, Timor, Tanimbar, western Kei islands, Seram
and Buru) in brown. The offshore NW Australian continental shelf (including the offshore areas
of the Bird’s Head structural block) is shown in yellow; the offshore shelf of the Sundaland
continental block in green. Structural highs on the outer Australian margin south of Timor are
indicated by the cross symbol (SP: Sahul Platform).

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 2


‘Asian’ Sundaland. In contrast, the onto the Australian margin during
present writer is of the opinion that there collision as the so-called Timor allochthon
is no such substantial allochthon in the (or Banda Terrane).
Banda collision complex, and that the
Mutis/Lolotoi Complex and its cover The Banda Arc extends from the islands of
successions (hereafter referred to as the Sumba and Flores in the west to the Kei
Banda Terrane, following Harris, 1991, Island group in the east (Figure 1). The
2006) also originated on the distal north- inner volcanic arc is a direct lateral
western margin of the Australian continuation of the Sunda volcanic arc to
continent. Critical to this interpretation is the west, while Sumba forms the
a suggestion that the various volcanic westernmost island of the Banda forearc
successions associated with the Banda ridge that also includes Timor, a series of
Terrane did not originate in arc smaller islands further east including
environments as is widely interpreted in Kisar, Leti and Babar, and then the larger
the allochthonous model, but rather in Tanimbar island group, before the forearc
oceanic rifting within a marginal basin ridge turns northward to the Kei islands
that developed off the northwest margin of and then further northward and then
the Australian continent during the westward again through the islands of
Cretaceous and Paleogene. Seram and Buru. The islands of the Banda
forearc ridge are, for the most part (except
for Buru and Sumba islands at either
REGIONAL TECTONIC SETTING extremity of the arc), considered to form
The area under consideration in this study foreland fold and thrust belts composed
comprises the zone of collision between primarily of distal Australian margin
the north-western continental margin of successions stacked beneath the pre-
Australia and island arc systems forming collisional forearc during arc-continent
the south-eastern borders of the Asian collision. The extent to which there is any
continent, and particularly the Sundaland remaining pre-collisional forearc in the
structural domain that forms the primary present-day collision complex is a matter
sub-element of the Asian continent in of significant debate in Timor (the Timor
western Indonesia (Figure 1). Arc- allochthon problem) but appears to be
continent collision in this region has been minor in other forearc islands to the east
ongoing since the Late Miocene, with Keep and northeast of Timor. In Seram island,
and Haig (2010) dating the for instance, a substantial allochthon was
commencement of collision to between also formerly interpreted by Audley-
9.8–5.5Ma in Timor. Prior to this, it is Charles et al. (1979), but a more recent
widely interpreted that the present Banda detailed structural study (Pownall et al.,
Arc formed a direct eastward continuation 2013) does not recognise any significant
of the Sunda oceanic subduction system allochthon in that island.
in, and to the south of, present-day Java
Island. In the allochthon model the forearc The island of Sumba is perhaps a special
of this pre-collisional subduction zone case in that it has been widely interpreted
would have included a microcontinental as composed entirely of non-Australian
fragment previously rifted from the tectonostratigraphic elements, and could,
Sundaland margin that was obducted therefore, be considered entirely
allochthonous with respect to the

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 3


Australian margin. It will be argued in the successions under the outer slopes to the
present study, however, that this south and east of the Timor-Tanimbar
exceptionalism for Sumba may not be Trough. Further south and east is an
correct, and that this island also consists extensive area of marine continental shelf
largely of Australian margin material, bordering onto the Australian continent in
although of an atypical character. the south (the Timor Sea), and the marine
shelf separating northern Australia from
To the south of the Banda forearc ridge is New Guinea island (the Arafura Shelf). The
the Timor Trough and its north-eastern Timor Sea, the western New Guinea
continuation the Tanimbar Trough, with a margin, and to a lesser extent the Arafura
further extension to the north and west as Shelf are areas that have received
the Seram Trough (Figure 1). The Timor considerable interest for petroleum
Trough is morphologically the direct exploration, and the second half of this
eastward continuation of the Java Trench study considers the drilling records for
which is the subduction trench of the several wells from this area (see Figure 7).
Sunda Arc, and the Timor-Tanimbar-
Seram Trough system similarly marks the To the southwest of Timor and Sumba is
deformation front of the arc-continent the NE corner of the Indian Ocean, the
collision complex, with thrusted and oldest portion of which is the Argo Basin
folded successions of the collision complex (Figure 2). The NE Indian Ocean began to
under the inner slopes of the troughs, but develop through oceanic rifting on the
little-deformed Australian margin Australian continental margin during the

Figure 2: Simplified spreading map of the northeast Indian Ocean. Oceanic spreading
decreases in age from southeast to northwest: dark blue = Argo spreading ~158-130.5Ma
(~Oxfordian-Hauterivian); light blue = Gascoyne spreading 130.5-100Ma (~Hauterivian-Albian);
purple, green and orange = Wharton spreading subdivided into age bands: purple = 100-83Ma
(~Cenomanian-Santonian, Cretaceous magnetic quiet zone); green = 83-66Ma (~Campanian-
Maastrichtian); orange = 66-43Ma (Paleocene-mid Eocene). Crustal ages in the Wharton Basin
follow Jacob et al. (2014, Figure 2).

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 4


Late Jurassic (Fullerton et al., 1989; Heine carbonate compensation depth (CCD).
and Muller, 2005; Gibbons et al., 2012), These rocks are assigned to the Nakfunu
and this rifting is clearly connected with Formation in West Timor (Rosidi et al.,
Jurassic volcanism on the western margin 1981), and to the Wai Bua Formation in
of Australia to the south of Timor. Latest Timor-Leste (Audley-Charles, 1968; and
Jurassic-earliest Cretaceous volcanism revised stratigraphic nomenclature of
was also intercepted in the Banli-1 Charlton et al., 2020, unpublished). These
petroleum exploration well in southern formations are Early Cretaceous in age,
West Timor (Sani et al., 1995). The Indian certainly ranging from the late
Ocean continued to develop through the Valanginian to the Aptian (Carter, 1972a,
Cretaceous and Paleogene as oceanic 1972b; Carter, 1973; Clowes, 1997;
spreading propagated to the south and Munasri, 2019, in Charlton et al., 2020),
west (Figure 2). The relationship between and may locally range as old as Berriasian
oceanic spreading in the Indian Ocean and in West Timor (Munasri & Sashida, 2018).
oceanic rifting events interpreted in the It seems very likely that the dramatic
present study during the Cretaceous to deepening in sedimentary environments
Paleogene will be considered in a separate represented by the change from neritic
paper (Charlton, 2023). conditions in Timor during the Late
Jurassic (cf. Charlton, 2012) to abyssal
environments during deposition of the Wai
CRETACEOUS – PALEOGENE SUCCESSION Bua/Nakfunu successions is an
IN TIMOR. indication that ocean margin rifting
Two essentially parallel probably continued in the Timor region
tectonostratigraphic successions are from the Late Jurassic into the Early
recognised in the Cretaceous and Cretaceous.
Paleogene of Timor that can, for brevity, be
referred to as the Kolbano and Palelo The predominantly non-carbonate
Associations (Figure 3). The Kolbano successions of the Wai Bua and Nakfunu
Association (also described as the Kolbano Formations pass upwards with apparent
Group or Kolbano Megasequence) gradational transition (in East Timor:
represents the main stratigraphic Charlton et al., 2020) or perhaps
succession that accumulated on the distal unconformably (in West Timor: Clowes,
edge of the northern Australian 1997) into deepwater limestones of the
continental margin. The Kolbano Borolalo Formation in Timor-Leste
Association consists largely of fine-grained (Audley-Charles, 1968; Charlton et al.,
sediments (shales, limestones and 2020), and the Latan, Menu and Ofu
radiolarites) deposited in very deep marine Formations in West Timor (Sawyer et al.,
environments, primarily outer neritic or 1993; Clowes, 1997). These deepwater
deeper, and commonly bathyal and even limestones, ranging in age from
abyssal. The lowermost part of the Aptian/Albian (latest Early Cretaceous) to
Kolbano Association consists of at least the Eocene, have been interpreted
radiolarian shales and cherty radiolarites, as a distal Australian continental margin
commonly reddish in colour, and succession, perhaps deposited on
apparently deposited in ultra-deepwater marginal plateaus directly analogous to
environments close to or below the the Scott and Exmouth Plateaus on the
present-day western continental margin of

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 5


Australia (Charlton, 1989; Haig, 2012). Cretaceous and younger lithostratigraphic
Deposition in similar deep marine domain in Timor which, together with the
carbonate environments continued into Mutis-Lolotoi metamorphic complexes,
the Miocene, represented by the Aliambata comprises the Banda Terrane succession.
Formation in Timor-Leste (Audley- The Palelo Group is divided into two
Charles, 1968; Charlton et al., 2020) and formations, with the Noni Formation
an equivalent succession in West Timor, succeeded by the Haulasi Formation
provisionally described by Charlton & Wall (Figure 3). The Noni Formation is
(2004) as the Siu Formation, although this composed of radiolarian cherts
name may be redundant as it now seems interbedded with volcanic breccias (van
clear that the Miocene successions in West West, 1941; Rosidi et al., 1981; Earle,
and East Timor are sufficiently similar in 1983). As described by van West (1941)
lithology and age to be described under from the Miomafo massif in northern West
the single name Aliambata Formation. Timor, the lower Palelo (Noni Formation)
consists of a basal unit of radiolarian
The Palelo Association (Palelo Group and cherts, usually well stratified and dark red
stratigraphically related younger units) brown to dark violet colour, succeeded by
forms an essentially distinct but parallel more thinly stratified radiolarian cherts,

Figure 3: Cretaceous-Paleogene stratigraphy of the Australian Northwest Shelf (Sahul Platform


area) and the Kolbano and Palelo associations of Timor.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 6


with bedding planes frequently covered by composition. The upper Palelo series
manganese mineralisation. Interbedded (Haulasi Formation) was estimated to be
volcanic breccias include fragments of 350m thick in this area.
slightly schistose albite diabase,
establishing a stratigraphic relationship At unspecified locations in Timor, Carter
with the crystalline basement. The et al. (1976) also recorded clasts of
radiolarian cherts of the lower Palelo are Permian fossiliferous limestones in
practically devoid of detrital material and conglomerates of the Haulasi Formation,
were probably deposited in bathyal or and Earle (1979) vesicular basalt clasts
abyssal environments. A stratigraphic resembling Permian Maubisse Formation
thickness of 40m was estimated. In West alkaline lavas.
Timor the Noni Formation is dated to the
Aptian-Turonian (Audley-Charles et al., In the Molo massif, Tappenbeck (1940)
1974; Haile et al., 1979; Munasri & recorded a planktonic microfauna
Harsolumakso, 2020). recovered from marly claystones and
greywackes in the upper part of the Palelo
The succeeding Haulasi Formation series (Haulasi Formation), including
consists of conglomeratic greywacke, Globotruncana cf. canaliculata,
sandstone, tuffaceous shale, and well- Globigerina aequilateralis, Guembelina
bedded grey to greenish marl, with sp., and Oligostegina laevigata.
volcanic material common (Rosidi et al., Concavatotruncana canaliculata, probably
1981). The upper Palelo series (Haulasi the equivalent of Tappenbeck’s
Formation) in the Miomafo massif was Globotruncana canaliculata, ranges in age
described by van West (1941) as from latest Cenomanian-Coniacian
consisting of monotonously grey-green (Boudagher-Fadel, 2013), while
greywacke, tuff, marl, and conglomerate. Oligostegina laevigata, which is now
All sedimentary rocks contain volcanic considered a calcisphere of uncertain
material, and contemporaneous taxonomic affiliation (Elbrächter et al.,
volcanism was interpreted. The 2008), occurs in the Turonian of
sedimentary succession is intruded by Switzerland (Elbrächter et al., 2008) and
occasional dykes of quartz-augite albitites SE Turkey (A. ten Dam, undated
similar to igneous rocks intruding the manuscript online). No definitive faunas
underlying crystalline schists. pre-dating the Upper Cretaceous were
Conglomerates are locally dominant, recognised.
primarily composed of schist fragments,
most commonly graphitic mica-schists, The Palelo Group also outcrops
and quartz schists. Less abundant but extensively in south-central East Timor,
still frequent are epidote-chlorite schist on the southern slopes of the Bubususo
and amphibolite fragments, all closely massif east and west of Samé town (Carter
comparable in composition to the et al., 1976; Standley and Harris, 2009;
underlying Miomafo crystalline schists. Charlton et al., 2018). Standley and Harris
The conglomerates also contain a few (2009) reported cherts and tuffs of the
fragments of limestone and chert, and Noni Formation in the Sui River north of
many fragments of igneous rocks (mainly Samé, but the present writer failed to
augite-andesites) and much more volcanic relocate this unit. In the Caraulun river,
material, mainly andesitic and dacitic in 4km west of the Sui River, the Haulasi

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 7


Formation unconformably overlies the needs confirmation by further detailed
Lolotoi Complex. It consists of hard, fieldwork, that the essentially non-
greenish, brown-weathering medium volcanic Dartollu Formation may be
grained sandstones and siltstones/fine broadly contemporaneous with volcanic
sandstones bedded on a decimetre scale, successions of the Metan Formation in
interbedded with coarse conglomerates West Timor, particularly in its type area in
containing angular to subrounded clasts the Metan river where Audley-Charles and
up to large cobble size (but mostly pebble Carter (1972) described the Wiluba facies
grade) consisting of schist, greenstone, (see also earlier mapping of this area by
acicular and occasionally vesicular basalt van Voorthuysen, 1940), and similarly in
fragments, and quartz and calcite pebbles. East Timor, in the type area of Audley-
The sandstone-dominated successions Charles’s Barique Volcanics, as
grade upward into finer grained and more documented by Haig et al. (2019).
thinly bedded clastic successions, Although direct dating of both the Metan
eventually becoming predominantly black (West Timor) and Barique (East Timor)
shales with interbedded thin sandstones. volcanic successions is limited, Costa et
The section is estimated to be about 150m al. (2020) have reported a youngest zircon
thick. Similar successions are exposed in age of 34Ma (late Eocene) from a
the Sui and Marak rivers further east, and volcaniclastic sediment attributed to the
in many other streams in the Samé area. Barique Formation collected to the north
Samples from the Caraulun section of Samé in Timor-Leste. In addition, a
yielded Late Cretaceous palaeontological body of gabbro intruding the Lolotoi
ages based on dinoflagellates (MGPalaeo, metamorphic complex near Fohorem in
unpublished report to Timor Resources, SW Timor-Leste is also likely to be
reported in Charlton et al., 2018), and late genetically related to the Metan/Barique
Albian-late Cenomanian (or younger) and volcanic successions, with a zircon date of
late Coniacian-Maastrichtian ages based 55Ma (Early Eocene) interpreted as the
on nannofossils (P.T. Rafflesia Baru, 2020, age of intrusion (KOICA, 2013).
in Charlton et al., 2020).
Further shallow marine limestones
The Haulasi Formation (upper Palelo accumulated during the Oligocene-Early
Group) is succeeded by the Dartollu Miocene in the Banda Terrane successions
Formation, which consists typically of of Timor, described as the Noil Toko
shallow marine limestones rich in larger Formation in West Timor (Rosidi et al.,
benthic foraminifera of Eocene age 1981) and as the Booi Group (or Booi
(Audley-Charles, 1968; Haig et al., 2019). Formation in the Timor GAP stratigraphic
Although originally defined and most nomenclature: Charlton et al., 2020) in
widely recognised in East Timor, the East Timor (Haig et al., 2012). The Booi
Dartollu Formation also occurs widely if Formation is named after the Booi (or Boi)
sporadically in West Timor, as described massif in West Timor where Tappenbeck
by Audley-Charles and Carter (1972) (1940) described rocks that Haig and
under the name Wiluba facies, and as colleagues identified as equivalent to the
observed by the present writer in joint Oligo-Miocene limestones in East Timor.
fieldwork with Adept Titu Eki (Nusa There are some indications that volcanism
Cendana University, Kupang) in October- continued contemporaneously with
November 2022. It appears, although this deposition of the Noil Toko Formation in

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 8


West Timor (Kadar, 1978), and the same Note that the lack of Maastrichtian (latest
may be true for East Timor although this Cretaceous) zircon ages for the Timor
has not been established with any samples in Figure 4 is probably because
certainty. the sample database was derived primarily
from sampling specifically of Cretaceous
aged sediments (primarily by
CRETACEOUS - PALEOGENE VOLCANISM IN Zimmermann and Hall, 2019), and the
THE BANDA FOREARC AND BIRD’S HEAD samples analysed were presumably older
Igneous activity is recorded regionally than Maastrichtian.
across SE Indonesia and Timor-Leste
during the Late Cretaceous and Paleogene. As already discussed in the previous
section, in addition to Cretaceous igneous
rocks, Paleogene volcanics are also
Timor recognised in the Banda Terrane
successions of Timor, under the names of
As summarised in the previous section, the Metan Formation in West Timor and
sandstones in the Late Cretaceous- the Barique Formation in Timor-Leste.
Paleogene Haulasi Formation are
primarily volcaniclastic in origin, and the This Cretaceous-Paleogene volcanism,
formation in the West Timor area were with its broadly calc-alkaline
intruded by younger but undated basic geochemistry (Harris, 2006; Standley and
intrusive (shown to the present writer by Harris, 2009; Benincasa, 2015), has been
Adept Titu-Eki). Although only limited widely interpreted as arc volcanism,
igneous rocks have yet been dated leading to an interpretation that the
radiometrically to the Cretaceous and Banda Terrane successions occupied a
Paleogene in Timor, several processed position in a subduction arc on the
samples of Haulasi sandstone have southern margin of Sundaland during this
yielded zircons with radiometric ages that time period – the Great Indonesian Arc of
fall within this period (see Table 1). These Harris (2006). A geochemical investigation
zircons are presumed, for the most part, to of these Timor volcanic successions by
derive from erosion of contemporaneous Standley (2007) aimed at establishing
volcanic successions. For Cretaceous- their igneous provenance by reference to
aged samples from Timor (Figure 4), the various discriminant diagrams based on
majority of zircons date to the Santonian- whole rock and trace element proportions.
Campanian, with a substantial tail of ages Standley (2007) concluded: “In summary,
back to the Aptian, no zircons dating to discriminant analysis results indicate
the late Valanginian, Hauterivian or provenance that is transitional between
Barremian (gap between 136.7-124.0Ma), MORB [mid-ocean ridge basalt] and VAB
and 3 zircon grains dating to the [volcanic arc basalt],
Berriasian-early Valanginian interval – the
one grain dated to the Berriasian deriving
from the Kolbano Association (sample SZ
37: Zimmermann and Hall, 2019),
whereas all the others can be attributed to
the Palelo Association.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 9


Table 1. Samples from the southern Banda Arc (Timor, Sumba, Tanimbar, Babar, Kisar and Leti)
yielding zircons of Cretaceous-Paleogene age, as reported in previous publications.

Author Sample Location Peak/mean age Age range Stage equivalent Notes
number
Harris (2006) 70 Caraulun river N of Same 83±1.4Ma 90.9Ma to 80.0Ma Range Coniacian- Andesite cobble collected from a weakly metamorphosed
town, south-central (Harris); or 89.2-80.0Ma Campanian; mean age conglomerate overlying Lolotoi Complex metamorphic rocks. Of
Timor-Leste on 206Pb/238U dating Santonian 23 zircons dated radiometrically, 21 yielded Cretaceous ages (the
(21 zircons) other two were Early Jurassic).
Standley & Harris (2009) 839 Laclubar (Bebe Susu) Main peak 113.8-81.8Ma on Main peak Coniacian; Metabasic amphibolite.
massif, north-central 87.0±2.7Ma; 206Pb/238U dating (14 secondary peak Aptian-
Timor-Leste secondary peak zircons) Albian. Youngest grain
113.9±8.3Ma Campanian
KOICA (2013) FP6 Fohorem area of SW Youngest zircon age Early Eocene Gabbro intruding Lolotoi Complex. Interpreted age of intrusion.
Timor-Leste 55Ma
Zimmermann (2015), ET 17 N coast of Timor-Leste 139.4-97.3Ma (10 Valanginian (2 zircons); Youngest zircon age is supported by a late Albian-early
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) east of Baucau zircons) Aptian-Cenomanian (8 Cenomanian planktonic foraminiferal age determination (M.
zircons) BouDagher-Fadel, personal communication to the authors).
Zimmermann (2015), SZ 47 Noil Meto river S of Soe 116.9-75.5Ma (16 Aptian-Campanian See Charlton & Titu Eki (2022, submitted) for further discussion
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) town, south-central West zircons) of this sample.
Timor
Zimmermann (2015), SZ 37 Margin of Pasi Inlier, 138.7 (1 zircon) Valanginian Sample contains Eocene foraminifera (M.
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) Kolbano area, S West BouDagher-Fadel, personal communication to the authors).
Timor Kolbano (Australian margin) succession.
Kadarusman et al. (2020) A160 S of Wini, north-central Single zircon grain dated Turonian Quartzite
West Timor at 93Ma
Kadarusman et al. (2020) A10 Near Atapupu, NE West Primary peak 117-63Ma Range Aptian-early Pelitic schist
Timor 71.8±0.83Ma, Paleocene. Primary peak
smaller peaks at Campanian, smaller
91.0±1.3Ma and peaks Turonian and
112.5±4.9Ma Aptian-Albian
Kadarusman et al. (2020) A397 Kunif river, Mutis massif, 91.1±0.66Ma Youngest grain 68Ma Turonian peak age; Pelitic schist
north-central West Timor youngest Maastrichtian

Kadarusman et al. (2020) A445 Kisan river, Mutis massif, 80Ma peak Campanian peak Granulite. Limited analytical data presented.
north-central West Timor

Kadarusman (2012) A449 Kisan river, Mutis massif, 60Ma Paleocene Felsic granulite schist. Limited analytical data presented.
north-central West Timor

Kadarusman et al. (2020) TM 36 Aileu Complex, near the N 2 zircons, 73Ma Campanian, ~Turonian Quartzite. Other zircons recovered are considerably older
coast midway between and ~93Ma (>200Ma).
Dili and Manatuto, Timor-
Leste
Costa et al. (2020) 180503-04 Coinaça tributary of the Main peak 37Ma, with Main peak late Eocene; Non-metamorphosed medium grained volcaniclastic rock. The
Caraulun river 4km N of 80% of 22 concordant also Coniacian- authors assigned this rock to the Barique Formation, but the
Same, south-central age determinations in Campanian present writer’s regional mapping placed this outcrop within the
Timor-Leste the range 34-41Ma, and Haulasi Formation
9% in the range 78-
90Ma.

Zimmermann (2015), SUM 01 Central Sumba 90.8-81.5Ma (4 zircons) Siltstone/semi-pelite


Zimmermann & Hall (2019)
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 06 East Sumba 116.7-72.0Ma (60 Calcareous sandstone (lithic arenite). Contains Globotruncana
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) zircons) sp. planktonic foraminifera. Shallow inner neritic environment.
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 10 Central Sumba 115.2-84.7Ma (4 zircons) Siltstone (lithic arenite)
Zimmermann & Hall (2019)
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 21 West Sumba 100.8-77.80Ma (10 Sandstone (lithic arenite)
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) zircons)
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 22 West Sumba 92.0-82.8Ma (13 zircons) Red sandstone (sublithic arenite)
Zimmermann & Hall (2019)
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 24 West Sumba 108.1-80.7 (or 64.1?)Ma Siltstone (lithic arenite)
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) (7 zircons)
Zimmermann (2015), SUM 30 South-central Sumba 114.0-79.1Ma (15 Sandstone (lithic arenite)
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) zircons)

Zimmermann (2015), TAN 11 Wotar island, Tanimbar 124.4-84.6Ma (13 latest Barremian- Siltstone (sublithic arenite). Ungar Formation - part of the
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) group zircons) Santonian Australian margin succession.
Zimmermann (2015), TAN 28 Teneman island, 96.8-83.7Ma (3 zircons) Cenomanian-Santonian Sandstone. Ungar Formation - part of the Australian margin
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) Tanimbar group succession.
Zimmermann (2015), TAN 31 Vatvurat island, Tanimbar 140.4Ma (1 zircon) and Berriasian and Aptian- Sandstone (subfeldspathic arenite). Ungar Formation - part of the
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) group 120.5-89.5Ma (13 Turonian/Coniacian Australian margin succession.
zircons)
Zimmermann (2015), TAN 45 Laibobar island, Tanimbar 124.6-104.1Ma (13 Aptian-Albian Sandstone (subfeldspathic arenite). Ungar Formation - part of the
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) group zircons) Australian margin succession.
Kadarusman (2020) TLA 62 Laibobar island, Tanimbar ~70Ma Youngest age 59Ma Main peak Pelitic schist.
group ~Maastrichtian;
youngest late Paleocene

Zimmermann (2015), BAB 25 Babar island, central ridge 125.7Ma & 104.7Ma (2 latest Barremian and Siltstone (grey siltstone/metapelite).
Zimmermann & Hall (2019) zircons) Albian
Kadarusman et al. (2020) KS44 Kisar island ~95Ma (2 zircons) & ~Cenomanian and Amphibolite. Only limited information presented.
66Ma (1 zircon) Maastrichtian
Kadarusman et al. (2020) LK29 Leti island Zircons ranging from Coniacian and older Mica schist. Only limited information presented.
88Ma back to 1985Ma
Kadarusman et al. (2020) LK45 Leti island 85Ma & 37.5Ma (2 Santonian and late Pelitic schist. Only limited information presented.
zircons) Eocene
Kadarusman et al. (2020) LK96 Leti island 75-20Ma (29 zircons) Campanian and younger Calc silicate rock. Only limited information presented.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 10


which is found most commonly in (e.g., Boger et al., 2017), and the complex
marginal and back arc basins” – although therefore represents part of the pre-
subsequently Standley and Harris (2009) collisional Australian continental margin.
modified their interpretation to “mixed According to Berry and McDougall (1986),
MORB and volcanic arc affinities for the 40Ar/39Ar hornblende release patterns for

igneous units”. If the former interpretation radiogenic metamorphic minerals


remains valid, then the Banda Terrane (hornblende and mica) are consistent with
Cretaceous-Paleogene volcanism may an initial closure to argon loss at ~70Ma
have originated not in a volcanic arc, but (latest Cretaceous). Harris and Long
in a backarc basin. This is a significantly (2000) interpreted this event as related to
different tectonic environment from a rifting on the passive continental margin
volcanic arc, particularly considering that of Australia.
the backarc basin must have been located
behind, but to the south of, the associated
arc in order for the Banda Terrane to have Sumba
been obducted southward onto Timor.
Sumba island to the west of Timor also
However, a marginal basin has two
yields a record of Late Cretaceous and
margins: that attached to the associated
Paleogene volcanism similar in age to that
arc, and that on the continental margin
in Timor. According to Abdullah et al.
from which the arc detaches. It is the
(2000), there were three main phases of
contention of the present study that the
igneous activity in Sumba, dated at 86-
Banda Terrane tectonostratigraphic
77Ma (~Santonian-Campanian), 71-56Ma
succession represents the trailing
(~Maastrichtian-Paleocene) and 42-31Ma
continental edge of the marginal basin
(~mid-late Eocene), based on whole rock
where a subduction arc migrated
and mineral 40K/40Ar radiometric dating.
northward away from Australia during the
Zimmermann (2015) collected 7
Late Cretaceous-Paleogene. The Banda
sandstone/siltstone samples from the
Terrane volcanic successions were thus
Lasipu Formation in Sumba that yielded
located on the outermost northern edge of
Cretaceous zircons ranging in age between
the Australian continental margin prior to
117-72Ma (~Aptian-Campanian), with an
arc-continent collision, rather than in a
apparent peak of zircon ages during the
Sunda-Banda (Asian) forearc complex.
Santonian-Campanian, as in Timor
(Figure 4).
Supporting evidence for this interpretation
comes from radiometric dating of the Aileu
Abdullah et al. (2000) described Sumba
Complex. This metamorphic complex,
volcanics as displaying the characteristics
located in NW Timor-Leste, developed
of a predominantly calc-alkaline and a
primarily during the Neogene arc-
minor potassic calc-alkaline series,
continent collision with a peak of
characterised by variable K2O contents,
metamorphism at about 5Ma (Berry et al.,
relatively high Al2O3 and low TiO2
2016), although earlier phases of
contents, suggesting a typical island arc
metamorphism extend back to the late
environment. Standley’s 13 analysed
Mesozoic (Berry and Grady, 1981). It
samples from Timor, interpreted as
seems now generally agreed that the bulk
marginal basin volcanics, when compared
of the Aileu Complex protolith consists of
with Abdullah et al.’s 20 analysed samples
Australian continental margin elements

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 11


from Sumba, show substantial overlap in east of Timor. In the Tanimbar Island
these parameters, with significant group Zimmermann (2015) and
variability in K2O (Timor 0.02-1.49%; Zimmermann & Hall (2019) dated samples
Sumba 0.55-3.65%), relatively high Al2O3 from the islands of Wotar (sample TAN 11),
(Timor 11.20-21.71% mean 14.85%, Teneman (TAN 28), Vatvurat (TAN 31) and
Sumba 14.80-19.00% mean 17.60%) and Laibobar (TAN 45), all derived from
low TiO2 (Timor 0.11-2.65% mean 1.30%, sandstone successions of the Ungar
Sumba 0.47-1.05%, mean 0.79%). Formation (Charlton et al., 1991). Forty
three Cretaceous zircons were separated
from these four samples, the majority
Banda forearc islands east of Timor ranging in age between 124.6-83.7Ma
(~Aptian to Santonian or earliest
Zimmermann (2015) and Kadarusman et
Campanian), similar to the Timor and
al. (2020) have also recorded zircons of
Sumba Cretaceous zircon ages, although
Late Cretaceous to Paleogene age in
with an earlier, Albian-Cenomanian peak
several islands of the Banda forearc to the
in the age distribution, in comparison to a

Figure 4: Cretaceous zircon age distributions from islands of the southern Banda Arc (Sumba,
Timor, Babar and the Tanimbar islands). The Sumba graph is cumulative zircon ages from
individual grains in Zimmermann and Hall’s (2019, Supplementary Data file 4) samples SUM 01,
06, 10, 21, 22, 24 & 30, while the Tanimbar-Babar graph is cumulative for samples TAN 11, 28,
31 & 45, and BAB 25. The Timor graph sums grains from Zimmermann’s (2015) samples SZ 37,
SZ 47 & ET 17, together with Harris’s (2006) sample 70 and Standley and Harris’s (2009) sample
8-3-9. For the latter two samples 206Pb/238U radiometric ages are plotted, which is Zimmermann’s
‘preferred’ age determinant for Cretaceous samples.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 12


Santonian-Campanian peak in Timor and Bird’s Head-Misool
Sumba (Figure 4). The small difference in
peak zircon ages may reflect an absence of Very similar aged volcanism to that
latest Cretaceous sandstones in Tanimbar documented in the Cretaceous-Paleogene
below an Early Miocene unconformity (cf. of Timor and Sumba is also found locally
Charlton et al., 1991). Kadarusman et al. in the Australian continental terranes of
(2020) also recorded zircons with a peak eastern Indonesia, including the Bird’s
age of ~70Ma (~Maastrichtian) and a Head structural block of western New
youngest age of 59Ma (~late Paleocene) Guinea island and offshore regions to the
from a pelitic schist in Laibobar island west including the island of Misool (Figure
(Tanimbar group). In Babar Island to the 1). In the Bird’s Head, Fraser et al. (1993)
west of Tanimbar, Zimmermann (2015) reported that Late Cretaceous sediments
sampled a siltstone/metapelite (BAB 25) of the Jass Polysequence commence with
that yielded 2 zircons dated at 125.7Ma a pronounced volcanic event. Ages
(latest Barremian) and 104.7Ma (Albian) reported for volcanic intervals in various
(Zimmermann and Hall, 2019). petroleum exploration wells include
Zimmermann (2015) noted similarity Coniacian-Santonian in the Tarof-2 and
between the lithology of BAB 25 and the Ayot-2 wells, upper Coniacian-Santonian
Lasipu Formation on Sumba Island. On in Agung-1, upper Coniacian-Campanian
Leti Island Kadarusman et al. (2020) in Roabiba-1, and Campanian-
reported 3 samples containing Cretaceous Maastrichtian in TBE-1X. In TBF-1X
and younger zircons, including 88Ma (location in Figure 7) a more substantial
(~Coniacian) and unspecified older ages volcanic interval is dated to the
(sample LK29); 85Ma and 37.5Ma Santonian-Maastrichtian, extending
(~Santonian and ~late Eocene: sample upwards into the Paleocene-lower Eocene.
LK45); and 29 zircons in the range 75- Unfortunately, none of these volcanic
20Ma (~Campanian and younger: sample successions encountered during drilling
LK96). On Kisar island Kadarusman et have been analysed geochemically, at least
al.’s (2020) sample KS44 contained 3 not in publicly available datasets. Other
Cretaceous zircons dated at ~95Ma (2 indications for Cretaceous-Paleogene
grains, ~Cenomanian) and 66Ma igneous activity in the Bird’s Head include
(~Maastrichtian). the Sorong Granite which is dated
radiometrically at 71.0±1.5Ma
It is particularly significant that although (~Campanian-Maastrichtian: Lunt &
the zircon ages from the eastern Banda Djaafar, 1991), and granite from the base
forearc islands are essentially similar to of the Salawati K-1X well which yielded
those from Timor and Sumba (Figure 4), radiometric ages of 79.3±1.1Ma on biotite,
the Tanimbar samples were collected and 71.0±1.5Ma on amphibole
primarily from the Ungar Formation, (~Campanian-Maastrichtian: Amri et al.,
which is an element of the Australian 1990). In the eastern Bird’s Head, a
continental margin succession, not part of granulite from the Wandamen Gneiss
an allochthonous succession. This seems complex yielded a radiometric age of
to provide a clear link between the 89.1Ma (~Coniacian) (Robinson et al.,
‘suspect’ (i.e., possibly allochthonous) 1990), interpreted by the authors as a
successions of Timor and Sumba and the possible igneous protolith age.
Australian continental margin.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 13


In Misool island the deepwater Waaf 2. The Eocene Dartollu Formation, which
Formation, dated to the Cenomanian-early stratigraphically succeeds the Haulasi
Campanian (Hasibuan & Rusmana, Formation, also locally contains reworked
2007), is described as highly tuffaceous fragments of Maubisse Group crinoidal
(Pigram et al., 1982). The tuffaceous limestones and vesicular lava clasts. The
intervals may be as old as Cenomanian- present writer has observed such an
Turonian (Vogler, 1941), slightly older outcrop at (9.25363°S, 125.27778°E) in
than the volcanism encountered in the SW Timor-Leste (Figure 5a & b).
offshore wells. The succeeding Fafanlap
Formation (Santonian-Maastrichtian: 3. Sidewall Core number 12, from the
Hasibuan & Rusmana, 2007) is also highly Betano-2 petroleum exploration well
tuffaceous, with the volcanism continuing drilled in southern East Timor in 1973, is
through a radical change in marine a Senonian (Late Cretaceous) reddish-
depositional environment, from bathyal to brown argillaceous limestone assignable
shallow marine (Pigram et al., 1982). The on age and lithology to the Borolalo
Late Cretaceous-Paleogene Daram Formation (Audley-Charles, 1968;
Formation contains sandstones of locally Charlton et al., 2020). This limestone
derived volcanic origin (Simbolon et al., contains lenticular concentrations of
1984). metamorphic grains, interpreted by
micropalaeontologist D.J. Carter (1973) as
deriving from the Lolotoi Complex. During
RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN THE KOLBANO the Late Cretaceous the Lolotoi Complex
AND PALELO ASSOCIATIONS IN TIMOR should, according to the allochthon model,
For the most part the Kolbano and Palelo have occupied a position in the Asian plate
Associations in Timor form entirely margin, and should not therefore have
distinct stratigraphic successions (Figure formed a sedimentary source in the
3). There are, however, several geological hinterland of the Australian-margin
observations that tend to blur this clear Borolalo Formation.
division:
4. On the northern slopes of Mount Mundo
1. As already mentioned, conglomerates in Perdido in SE Timor-Leste, Benincasa
the Haulasi Formation reportedly include (2015) recorded two samples of Eocene red
clasts derived from the Permian Maubisse mudstone/shale containing planktonic
Group, including fragments of Permian foraminiferal faunas, and with both
fossiliferous limestones (Carter et al., originating from bathyal or deeper
1976), and vesicular basalts resembling environments of deposition. One (sample
Permian Maubisse alkaline lavas (Earle, AB236, located at 8.71073°S,
1979). The Maubisse Group (or Formation) 126.34083°E) was assigned to the Kolbano
has clear palaeontological, stratigraphic Group; the second (AB234, at 8.71058°S,
and palaeomagnetic affinities to the 126.34053°E) to the Barique Group (or
Australian continental margin (as Formation), which is an element of the
summarised in Charlton et al., 2002), and Palelo Association. Assignment of the
the presence of Maubisse material second sample to the Barique Group was
reworked into Haulasi Formation is probably based on the occurrence of
problematic for the allochthonous model. relatively fresh volcanic material within
the sample, while the first was probably

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 14


assigned to the Kolbano Group on the indistinguishable from time-equivalent
absence of volcanic material. These two successions in the Kolbano Group.
similar rock types, outcropping less than
40m from one another, were, according to 6. In the Miomafo massif in West Timor,
the interpretations implicit in the van West (1941) described bedding planes
allochthonous model, derived from in Noni Formation cherts as frequently
entirely distinct tectonostratigraphic covered by manganese mineralisation.
terranes that would have been separated Manganese mineralisation is widely seen
by hundreds or thousands of kilometres in the Australian margin succession of
during the Eocene. Timor, including in the Triassic Aitutu
Formation and the Cretaceous Wai
5. Shallow marine limestones of the Bua/Nakfunu Formation, with the
Eocene Dartollu Formation and the Oligo- mineralisation developing during or soon
Miocene Noil Toko and Booi Formation after sedimentary deposition. It is a
(Palelo Association) interdigitate with coincidence that both the supposed
deeper marine limestones that appear Australian and Asian margin successions

a b

c d

Figure 5: (a) Outcrop of Dartollu Formation consisting of whitish-pink benthic foraminiferal


calcarenite/rudite enclosing clasts of porphyritic basalt, interpreted as derived from the Permian
Maubisse Formation. (b) From the same locality, a block of Maubisse Formation crinoidal limestone
enclosed within the Dartollu Limestone. Near Hasain village, Covalima, Timor-Leste (9.25363°S,
125.27778°E). (c) Outcrop of pillow basalt volcanics and (d) angular basaltic clasts enclosed in
pinkish limestone matrix of Kolbano Group type at the same locality. Noil Fatu, northern Kolbano
area of West Timor (9.79593°S, 124.49328°).

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 15


should develop similarly rich regional biogeography, Lunt (2003)
manganiferous mineralisation. identified two distinct benthic
foraminiferal faunas in the Eocene of the
7. In West Timor Sawyer et al. (1993) noted Indo-Pacific region that he considered
that some facies mapped within the Palelo demonstrated faunal provincialism with
Group were similar to Kolbano Sequence significant palaeotectonic implications. Of
samples. These included: the two faunas, one is typified by the
genera Assilina, Pellatispira and
• Lithological similarity between the Noni Biplanispira (‘APB’) and the other by the
Formation in the Molo region (central West genus Lacazinella. The APB fauna was
Timor) and the Nakfunu Formation in the interpreted as an Eocene equatorial
Kolbano area. grouping found primarily in Southeast
Asia and Pacific islands, while the
• Similarities between Paleocene aged Lacazinella fauna was interpreted as a
micrites and wackestones assigned to the higher latitude, subtropical grouping
Haulasi Formation east of Kefamenanu found primarily on the northern margin of
(north-central West Timor) and the Ofu Australia. The Dartollu Formation in
Formation in the Kolbano area. Timor contains an APB fauna, suggesting,
in Lunt’s model, an equatorial
• Lithologies assigned to the “Ofu Series” palaeolatitude, consistent with an
by de Waard (1957) east of Nikiniki that allochthonous origin for this formation.
include an interbedded micrite and pillow
lava on tectonic strike with a similar There are, however, some problems with
Cretaceous limestone containing matrix this model. Firstly, as Lunt (2003)
supported andesite(?) boulders. recognised, the division between the APB
and Lacazinella faunas is not perfect. In a
The locality east of Nikiniki (site of foraminiferal limestone from Papua New
Sawyer’s sample RKS-301: 9.79593°S, Guinea, elements of the two faunas co-
124.49328°) was re-visited by the present occur in the same rock unit, and indeed in
writer together with Timorese geologists one case were found within the same thin
Adept Titu Eki and Permenas Manilapai section. Furthermore, Assilina, an element
(Barka), and our observations concur with of the APB fauna, has been identified in
Sawyer’s interpretation that Kolbano the Sahul Shoals-1 exploration well on the
Group limestones were stratigraphically outer Australian continental margin
associated with volcanic rocks at this immediately south of Timor (sidewall cores
locality (Figure 5c & d). at 3815m depth (3 specimens) and at
4012m (1 specimen): Sahul Shoals-1 well
completion report, BOCAL, 1970,
EOCENE FAUNAL PROVINCIALITY
identifications by R. Wall). However, Lunt
The Dartollu Formation is a succession of (2003) cautioned that “Assilina can be
shallow marine limestones of Eocene age confused for flat forms of Operculina …
(Audley-Charles, 1968; Haig et al., 2019) especially by [oil] industry
that lie stratigraphically above the Haulasi biostratigraphers who are used to
Formation, and below or examining planktonic foraminifera”. A
contemporaneous with the Barique third discrepancy is that on Lunt’s
Volcanics (Figure 3). In a study of Eocene regional paleogeographic map (Lunt,

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 16


Figure 6: Subsidence curves for the Lynedoch-1 (Calder Graben south of the Tanimbar
islands: Figure 8) and Scott Reef-1 well (SW of Timor) illustrating a dramatic onset of
subsidence in the mid-Cretaceous and Paleogene respectively.

2003, Figure 5) several sites in the western greywacke-sandstone (Germeraad, 1946,


Pacific that contain an APB fauna locate at pp.29-30). The Triassic of Seram is
the same subtropical palaeolatitude as do considered directly correlatable with the
sites with Lacazinella faunas on the Triassic of Timor and is an Australian-
Australian continental margin. margin stratigraphic succession.

Two further possible discrepancies Although Lunt’s (2003) interpretation of


between Lunt’s provincial interpretation faunal provinciality in the Eocene is at
and regional geology concern the first sight an attractive proposition, it
occurrence of APB faunas within rocks probably does not delineate palaeotectonic
from Banda Arc islands that also show provinces sufficiently strongly to justify
stratigraphic ties to the Australian palaeo-plate boundaries, and thus
continental margin. The first example is probably does not greatly constrain the
the Dartollu Limestone in Timor, which, as northern/southern Tethys origin of the
mentioned above, at one locality contains Banda Terrane in Timor.
reworked fragments of the Maubisse
Formation that have an undisputed
Australian continental margin affinity. LATE CRETACEOUS-PALEOGENE
The second is a very similar case from SUBSIDENCE OF THE NW AUSTRALIAN
Seram island in the northern Banda Arc, CONTINENTAL MARGIN
where Eocene conglomerates contain It has long been assumed (including by the
Pellatispira (APB fauna) amongst other present writer: Charlton, 2012) that
benthic foraminifera (and with no mention following Late Jurassic oceanic rifting the
of Lacazina/Lacazinella), but also clasts of northwest Australian continental margin,
Triassic limestone and Triassic including the future Timor region, formed

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 17


Figure 7: Isopach thickness of the Jamieson Formation (late Albian-Cenomanian: see Figure 3)
on the eastern Northwest Shelf of Australia. During this short interval of deposition (~12m.y.)
more than 1100m of predominantly shaly sediments were deposited in neritic environments at
the axis of the Malita Graben, contemporaneous with less than 50m of sedimentation over the
northern Ashmore Platform. Thicknesses >900m are shaded blue.

a relatively simple, distal passive Scott Reef-1 well to the SW of Timor, where
continental margin with a northward reefal and shallow marine depositional
progression from shelf to slope and environments have been maintained
continental rise environments (e.g. during the accumulation of more than
Audley-Charles, 1986), although perhaps 3000m of sedimentary section since the
developed on distinct marginal plateaus Eocene (Figure 6). Similarly, more than
analogous to the Scott and Exmouth 1000m of subsidence is recorded in wells
Plateaus of the present-day western drilled in the Malita Graben to the SE of
Australian margin (Charlton, 1989; Haig, Timor during deposition of the Jamieson
2012). In most such interpretations a Formation in the late Albian and
stable and quiescent passive margin Cenomanian – a period of only about
tectonic setting is inferred from the Early 12m.y. duration (Figure 7). Neither of
Cretaceous through to the Miocene, these dramatic subsidence phases appear
during the accumulation of the Kolbano consistent with a structurally quiescent
Association in Timor (Figure 3). However, passive margin setting.
indications that this apparently long-
standing tectonic quiescence may have
been overstated include, for instance, the
remarkable subsidence recorded in the

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 18


In order to assess the pattern of 1 wells are shown in Figure 6, while
subsidence on the northwest Australian generalised subsidence curves for several
continental margin since the Jurassic, a wells respectively west and east of Timor
series of subsidence curves have been are shown in Figure 9. Many wells show a
constructed for the wells shown in Figure characteristic steepening in the
8, covering an area extending from subsidence curve during the Late
southwest of Timor, through the former Cretaceous or Paleogene, indicating
Timor-Leste–Australia Joint Petroleum accelerated subsidence during that time,
Development Area (previously also known although the precise onset of accelerated

Figure 8: Timing for the onset of rapid subsidence recorded in wells around the northwest
Australian continental margin (northern Australia and eastern Indonesia) from the ‘mid’
Cretaceous to the Paleogene.

as the Indonesia-Australia Zone of Co- subsidence varies regionally. The earliest


operation), to the eastern Australian onset of rapid subsidence occurred during
continental margin around the Calder the early Albian at Evans Shoal-1 but
Graben, and then northwards into eastern commenced as late as late Palaeocene at
Indonesia on the western edge of the Dillon Shoals-1 south of Timor. The timing
Arafura Shelf and the Bird’s Head for the onset of rapid subsidence shows
structural block. Examples of subsidence significant regional grouping, however,
curves for the Scott Reef-1 and Lynedoch-

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 19


with distinct subsidence phases indicated volcanic successions may be genetically
on Figure 8. tied to the Australian margin rather than
to the Asian margin. The southern Banda
forearc volcanism is also precisely
SYNTHESIS contemporaneous with volcanism in the
The distribution of zircon ages dated to the Australian-affinity Bird’s Head-Misool
Cretaceous from sandstone and structural domain, and this provides a
metamorphic rocks collected in the further link to the Australian continental
southern Banda forearc (Figure 4) shows a margin. Taken together with the
strong degree of congruence between the apparently marginal/backarc basin
various island groups. This is particularly geochemistry of the volcanics (Standley,
remarkable considering that the Tanimbar 2007) and the evidence from the Aileu
samples were collected primarily from the Complex in Timor for Australian
Ungar Formation, which is considered continental margin rifting in the Late
part of the Australian continental margin Cretaceous (Berry and McDougall, 1986;
succession (Charlton et al., 1991), while Harris and Long, 2000), this all suggests
the samples from Sumba and most of the an origin for the volcanism in a zone of
samples from Timor derive from the backarc rifting behind an island arc
‘suspect’ Banda Terrane successions, terrane that broke away northward from
widely considered to derive from the Asian the NW continental margin of Australia
continental margin. Instead, the during the Late Cretaceous and Paleogene.
congruence of ages suggests that the
Sumba and Banda Terrane (Timor)

Figure 9: Representative subsidence curves for the NW Australian margin east and west of Timor
(the Sunrise-1 subsidence curve is shown on both graphs for comparison).

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 20


The effects of this rifting
event are also apparent in
the subsidence curves of
petroleum exploration wells
drilled on the outer
Australian ‘passive’
continental margin to the
south and east of the Timor-
Tanimbar-Seram Troughs
(Figures 6-9). Figure 4
suggests that the main
volcanic phase commenced
during the Aptian and may
have increased in intensity
through the Santonian-
Campanian peak of zircon
ages in Figure 4, and into
the Paleogene based on
continuing volcanism in
Timor (Metan and Barique
volcanics) and Sumba
(Abdullah et al., 2000).
Figures 8 & 9 suggest that
strong subsidence
commenced on the
Australian margin
immediately east of Timor
during the Early Albian,
with younger initiations of
subsidence at various times
at different locations
throughout the Late
Cretaceous and Paleogene.
Continental margin
subsidence was particularly
Figure 10: Continental margin rifting in eastern Australia
strong in the area of the during the Cretaceous (Bryan, 2005).
Sahul Platform and Malita-
Calder Graben within a few
thickness for a sedimentary succession
million years either side of the Early-Late
deposited through an interval of about 40
Cretaceous boundary, during deposition
million years (Figure 3). The Darwin
to the Jamieson Formation (Figure 7). In
Formation itself, Aptian-Albian in age and
wells such as Chuditch-1 on the Sahul
immediately preceding the Jamieson
Platform the entire Late Jurassic and
Formation, is a strikingly different
Early Cretaceous succession below the
lithological interval from the underlying
Darwin Formation is highly condensed, in
condensed neritic section, being
this well only totalling about 13m

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 21


characterised by planktonic foraminiferal Cretaceous calc-alkaline volcanism is also
limestones and radiolarites that indicate found in the Whitsunday volcanic
moderately deep marine environments, province of eastern Australia (Ewart et al.,
apparently suggesting significant 1992; Bryan et al., 2000). These arc-like
oceanisation of the outer continental volcanics were erupted during the early
margin of Australia at that time. stages of a continental rifting phase that
led eventually to the opening of the Coral
Igneous activity in the Bird’s Head-Misool Sea off the eastern margin of Australia.
region initiated shortly after the Magmatism in the Whitsunday volcanic
commencement of rifting on the NW province is dated between about 130-
Australian margin, dating from the 95Ma (Early Cretaceous, ~Barremian-
Coniacian-Santonian and continuing into Albian), with a main phase of igneous
the Paleogene (Fraser et al., 1993). activity in the range 120-105Ma (Aptian-
Albian: Ewart et al. 1992; Bryan et al.,
In summary, it appears that there was a 1997).
previously unrecognised phase of
continental margin rifting on the The final stages of this eastern Australian
northwest continental margin of Australia volcanism coincide with the initiation of
(Timor to western New Guinea) that volcanism on the north-western margin of
commenced in the late Early Cretaceous Australia, and it seems quite possible that
(from the Aptian/Albian) and continued the two rifting phases were genetically
through to the Paleogene (until the late related.
Eocene). The geochemistry of volcanic
rocks erupted during this rifting phase
may suggest that an island arc terrane ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
rifted northward away from Australia, This paper was written following
leaving an extensive marginal basin discussions in the field with Adept Titu Eki
volcanic succession on its southern (Nusa Cendana University, Kupang) and
trailing edge, which is now represented in Timorese geologist Permenas Manilapai
the southern Banda forearc by, for (Barka) who together kindly guided me to
instance, the Banda Terrane volcanic key sections of the Banda Terrane in West
successions in Timor, and the Timor during fieldwork in October and
contemporaneous volcanics associated November 2022. I am also grateful to Hugo
with the Lasipu Formation in Sumba. Bucher (University of Zurich, Switzerland)
for stimulating discussions with his
A more detailed account of the rifting perspective from an older and much better
history of the SE Banda Arc region, known mountain belt, and for review
integrated with the known spreading comments by an anonymous referee.
history of the northern Indian Ocean
(Figure 2), will be presented in a separate
paper (Charlton, 2023). In the meantime, REFERENCES
it may be worth highlighting a very similar Abdullah, C.I., Rampnoux, J.-P., Bellon,
phase of backarc rifting that developed H., Maury, R.C. and Soeria-Atmadja, R.,
broadly contemporaneously on the 2000. The evolution of Sumba Island
eastern margin of Australia. As illustrated (Indonesia) revisited in the light of new
in Figure 10, a major succession of

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 22


data on the geochronology and Berry, R.F., Thompson, J., Meffre, S. and
geochemistry of the magmatic rocks. J. Goemann, K., 2016. U-Th-Pb monazite
Asian Earth Sci. 18, 533-546. dating and timing of arc-continent
collision in East Timor. Aust. J. Earth Sci.
Amri, C., Harahap, B.H., Pieters, P.E. and DOI: 10.1080/08120099.2016.1217930,
Bladon, G.M., 1990. Geology of the Sorong 11pp.
Sheet area, Irian Jaya. 1:250,000. GRDC.
Boger, S.D., Spelbrink, L.G., Lee, R.I.,
Audley-Charles, M.G., 1968. The geology Sandiford, M., Maas, R. and Woodhead,
of Portuguese Timor. Mem. Geol. Soc. J.D., 2017. Isotopic (U-Pb, Nd) and
Lond. 4. geochemical constraints on the origins of
the Aileu and Gondwana sequences of
Audley-Charles, M.G. and Carter, D.J., Timor. J. Asian Earth Sci. 134, 330-351.
1972. Palaeogeographical significance of
some aspects of Palaeogene and early Boudagher-Fadel, M.K., 2013.
Neogene stratigraphy and tectonics of the Biostratigraphic and Geological
Timor Sea region. Palaeogeog. Significance of Planktonic Foraminifera.
Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 11, 247-264. OVPR UCL, London. 2nd Edition.

Audley-Charles, M.G., Carter, D.J. and Bryan, S., 2005. The Early Cretaceous
Barber, A.J., 1974. Stratigraphic basis for Whitsunday silicic large igneous province
tectonic interpretations of the outer Banda of eastern Australia. International
Arc, eastern Indonesia. Proc. Indon. Petrol. Association of Volcanology and Chemistry
Assoc. 3, 25-44. of the Earth’s Interior, Large Igneous
Provinces Commission online article
Audley-Charles, M.G., Carter, D.J., http://www.largeigneousprovinces.org/0
Barber, A.J., Norvick, M.S. and 5aug.
Tjokrosapoetro, S., 1979. Reinterpretation
of the geology of Seram: implications for Bryan, S.E., Constantine, A.E., Stephens,
the Banda Arcs and northern Australia. J. C.J., Ewart, A., Schön, R.W. and Parianos,
Geol. Soc. Lond. 136, 547-568. J., 1997. Early Cretaceous volcano-
sedimentary successions along the
Benincasa, A., 2015. The ‘fatus’ of East eastern Australian continental margin:
Timor: stratigraphy and structure. PhD implications for the break-up of eastern
thesis, University of Western Australia. Gondwana. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 153,
85–102.
Berry, R.F. and Grady, A.E., 1981.
Deformation and metamorphism of the Bryan, S.E., Ewart, A., Stephens, C.J.,
Aileu Formation, north coast, East Timor, Parianos, J. and Downes, P.J., 2000. The
and its tectonic significance. J. Struct. Whitsunday Volcanic Province, central
Geol. 3, 143-167. Queensland, Australia: lithological and
stratigraphic investigations of a silicic-
Berry, R.F. and McDougall, I.A., 1986. dominated large igneous province. J. Volc.
40Ar/39Ar and K/Ar dating evidence from
Geotherm. Res. 99, 55-78.
the Aileu Formation, East Timor,
Indonesia. Chem. Geol. 59, 43-58.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 23


Carter, D.J. 1972a. Report on surface Charlton, T., Gandara, D., Freitas, D.,
samples from the Betano area. Timor Oil Guterres, M. and da Costa, N., 2018.
Palaeontological Report 18, unpublished. TIMOR GAP’s Onshore Block: a
preliminary assessment of prospectivity in
Carter, D.J., 1972b. Report on D. J. onshore Timor-Leste. PESGB-SEAPEX
Warwick’s samples from the Betano Asia-Pacific E&P Conference, 27-28 June
region. Timor Oil Palaeontological Report 2018, conference proceedings, 8pp.
19, unpublished.
Charlton, T., Gandara, D., Guterres, M.,
Carter, D.J., 1973. Report on Borehole Freitas, D. and da Costa Noronha, N.,
Betano No. 2. Timor Oil Palaeontological 2020. TIMOR GAP’s lithostratigraphic
Report 20, unpublished. framework for Timor-Leste. Unpublished
report, online at
Carter, D.J., Audley-Charles, M.G. and https://www.researchgate.net/publicatio
Barber, A.J., 1976. Stratigraphical n/374386686_Lithostratigraphic_framew
analysis of an island arc-continental ork_for_Timor-Leste.
margin collision zone in eastern
Indonesia. J. Geol. Soc. Lond. 132, 179- Charlton, T.R., de Smet, M.E.M.,
198. Samodra, H. and Kaye, S.J., 1991. The
stratigraphic and structural evolution of
Charlton, T.R., 1989. Stratigraphic the Tanimbar islands, eastern Indonesia.
correlation across an arc-continent J. SE Asian Earth Sci. 6(3/4), 343-358.
collision zone: Timor and the Australian
Northwest Shelf. Aust. J. Earth Sci. 36, Charlton, T.R. and Wall, D., 1994. New
263-274. biostratigraphic results from the Kolbano
area, southern West Timor: implications
Charlton, T., 2012. Permian-Jurassic for the Mesozoic-Tertiary stratigraphy of
palaeogeography of the SE Banda Arc Timor. J. SE Asian Earth Sci. 9(1/2), 113-
region. Berita Sedimentologi 24, 5-17. 122.

Charlton, T.R., 2023. Jurassic-Paleogene Clowes, E., 1997. Micropalaeontological


spreading history of the northern Indian analysis of the Kolbano Sequence
Ocean as a constraint on the evolution of (Jurassic to Pliocene), West Timor, and its
the north Australian continental margin. radiolarian fauna. Ph.D. thesis, London
Berita Sedimentologi 49 (2), 75-107. University.

Charlton, T.R., Barber, A.J., Harris, R.A., Costa, J., Kiyokawa, S., Ito, T., Tsutsumi,
Barkham, S.T., Bird, P.R., Archbold, N.A., Y. and Vilanova, V., 2020. U-Pb detrital
Morris, N.J., Nicoll, R.S., Owen, H.G., zircon age dating of central portion of East
Owens, R.M., Sorauf, J.E., Taylor, P.D., Timor: estimate stratigraphy of the Aileu
Webster, G.D. and Whittaker, J.E., 2002. Formation and depositional ages and
The Permian of Timor: its stratigraphy, source of sediments. Timorese Academic
palaeontology, and palaeogeography. Journal of Science and Technology 3, 12pp.
Journal Asian Earth Sci. 20, 719-774.
Earle, M.M., 1979. Mesozoic ophiolite and
blue amphibole on Timor and the

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 24


dispersal of eastern Indonesia. Nature Greater India: tectonic evolution of the
282, 375-378. west Australian margin. Geochem.
Geophys. Geosyst. (G3) 13(5), 25pp.
Elbrächter, M., Gottschling, M.,
Hildebrand-Habel, T., Keupp, H., Kohring, Haig, D.W., 2012. Stratigraphic
R., Lewis, J., Meier, K.J.S., Montresor, M., reconstruction of Timor-Leste.
Streng, M., Versteegh, G.J.M., Willems, H. Presentation at the First International
and Zonneveld, K., 2008. Establishing an Geological Congress of Geology of Timor-
agenda for calcareous dinoflagellate Leste, Dili, January 2012.
research (Thoracospaeraeae,
Dinophyceae) including a nomenclatural Haig, D.W., Mossadegh, Z.K., Parker, J.H.
synopsis of generic names. Taxon 57(4), and Keep, M., 2019. Middle Eocene neritic
1289-1303. limestone in the type locality of the
volcanic Barique Formation, Timor-Leste:
Ewart, A., Schön, R.W. and Chappell, microfacies and tectonostratigraphic
B.W., 1992. The Cretaceous volcanic- affinities. J. Asian Earth Sci. X 1, 100003,
plutonic province of the central 1-20.
Queensland (Austalia) coast – a rift-related
“calc-alkaline” province. Trans. R. Soc. Haile, N.S., Barber, A.J. and Carter, D.J.,
Edinburgh, Earth Sci. 83, 327-345. 1979. Mesozoic cherts on crystalline
schists in Sulawesi and Timor. J. Geol.
Fraser, T.H., Bon, J. and Samuel, L., Soc. Lond. 136, 65-70.
1993. A new dynamic Mesozoic
stratigraphy for the West Irian Jaya micro- Harris, R.A., 1991. Temporal distribution
continent Indonesia and its implications. of strain in the active Banda Orogen: a
Proc. IPA 22, 707-761. reconciliation of rival hypotheses. J. SE
Asian Earth Sci. 6, 373-386.
Fullerton, L.G., Sager, W.W. and
Handschumacher, D.W., 1989. Late Harris, R., 2006. Rise and fall of the
Jurassic-Early Cretaceous evolution of the Eastern Great Indonesian arc recorded by
eastern Indian Ocean adjacent to the assembly, dispersion and accretion of
Northwest Australia. J. Geophys. Res. 94, the Banda Terrane, Timor. Gondwana
2937-2953. Research 10, 207-231.

Germeraad, J.H., 1946. Geology of Central Harris, R.A. and Long, T., 2000. The Timor
Seran. Geological, petrographical and Ophiolite, Indonesia: model or myth? In:
palaeontological results of explorations Ophiolites and Ocean Crust: New Insights
carried out from September 1917 till June from Field Studies and the Ocean Drilling
1919 in the island of Ceram by L. Rutten Program, eds. Y. Dilek, E.M. Moores, D.
& W. Hotz, 3rd Series, No. 2, 135pp. J.H. Elthon & A. Nicolas. Geol. Soc. Am. Spec.
de Bussy, Amsterdam. Pap. 349, 327-335.

Gibbons, A.D., Barckhausen, U., van den Hasibuan, F. and Rusmana, E., 2007.
Bogaard, P., Hoernle, K., Werner, R., Cretaceous rocks of Misool archipelago,
Whittaker, J.M., and Müller, R.D., 2012. Indonesia. J. Sumber Daya Geologi 17(6),
Constraining the Jurassic extent of 420-435.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 25


Heine, C. and Muller, R.D., 2005. Late Munasri, 2019. Age determination for the
Jurassic rifting along the Australian Wai Bua Formation in Block C based on
Northwest Shelf: margin geometry and radiolaria. Unpublished report to TIMOR
spreading ridge configuration. Aust. J. GAP, 15p.
Earth Sci. 52, 27-39.
Munasri and Harsolumakso, A.H., 2020.
Kadar, A.P., 1978. Laporan pendahuluan Late Cretaceous radiolarians from the
penelitian stratigrafi formasi Noiltoko, Noni Formation, West Timor, Indonesia.
formasi Viqueque dan koral Kwarter di Berita Sedimentologi 45, 5-18.
Timor. Unpublished report H78-2, GRDC
Library. Munasri and Sashida, K., 2018. Tethyan
and non-Tethyan Early Cretaceous
Kadarusman, A., Sun L.C., Yu C.S. and radiolarian faunas from West Timor,
Maruyama, S., 2020. U-Pb zircon age Indonesia: palaeogeographic and tectonic
dating using LA ICP-MS at Institute Earth significance. Earth Evolution Sci. 12, 3-12.
Sciences Academia Sinica: metamorphic
rocks of the Banda Outer Arc. FOSI online Pigram, C.J., Challinor, A.B., Hasibuan,
presentation, F., Rusmana, E. and Hartono, U., 1982.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVK Lithostratigraphy of the Misool
Gl-QmYYQ. Archipelago, Irian Jaya, Indonesia. Geol.
Mijnb. 61, 245-279.
Keep, M. and Haig, D.W., 2010.
Deformation and exhumation in Timor: Pownall, J.M., Hall, R. and Wilkinson,
distinct stages of a young orogeny. I.M., 2013. Extreme extension across
Tectonophysics 483, 93-111. Seram and Ambon, eastern Indonesia:
evidence for Banda slab rollback. Solid
KOICA (Korean International Cooperation Earth 4, 277-314.
Agency), 2013. Geologic Map of the
Fohorem Quadrangle, Covalima District, Rafflesia Baru, P.T., 2020. Coloco study –
Republic of Timor-Leste [and] Explanation provisional results of biostratigraphy.
for the Fohorem Quadrangle, Covalima Unpublished report to TIMOR GAP.
District, Republic of Timor-Leste.
Unpublished report. Robinson, G.P., Ryburn, R.J., Harahap,
B.H., Tobing, S.L. and Achdan, A., 1990.
Lunt, P., 2003. Biogeography of some Geology of the Steenkool Sheet area, Irian
Eocene larger foraminifera, and their Jaya. 1:250,000. GRDC.
application in distinguishing geological
plates. Palaeontologia Electronica 6(10), Rosidi, H.M.D., Suwitodirdjo, K. and
22pp. Tjokrosapoetro, S., 1981. Geologic map of
the Kupang-Atambua Quadrangles,
Lunt, P. and Djaafar, R., 1991. Aspects of Timor. 1:250,000, (and accompanying
the stratigraphy of western Irian Jaya and brochure), GRDC.
implications for the development of sandy
facies. Proc. Indon. Petrol. Assoc. 20(1), Sani, K., Jacobson, M.L. and Sigit, R.,
107-124. 1995. The thin-skinned thrust structures

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 26


of Timor. Proc. Indon. Petrol. Assoc. 24, Waard, D. de, 1957. Contributions to the
277-293. geology of Timor, XII. The third geological
expedition, preliminary results. Indon. J.
Sawyer, R.K., Kartono Sani and Brown, S., Nat. Sci. 113, 7-42.
1993. Stratigraphy and sedimentology of
West Timor, Indonesia. Proc. Indon. Petrol. West, F.P. van, 1941. Geological
Assoc. 22, 1-20. investigations in the Miomaffo region
(Netherlands Timor). In: Geological
Simbolon, B., Martodjojo, S. and Expedition to the Lesser Sunda Islands
Gunawan, R., 1984. Geology and under the leadership of H.A. Brouwer 3, 1-
hydrocarbon prospects of the pre-Tertiary 131.
system of Misool. Proc. Indon. Petrol.
Assoc. 13, 317-340. Zimmermann, S. 2015. Provenance of
Mesozoic sandstones in the Banda Arc,
Standley, C.E., 2007. Banda forearc Indonesia. Ph.D. thesis, London
metamorphic rocks accreted to the University. 418pp.
Australian continental margin: detailed
analysis of the Lolotoi Complex of East Zimmermann, S. and Hall, R., 2019.
Timor. Master’s thesis, Brigham Young Provenance of Cretaceous sandstones in
University. the Banda Arc and their tectonic
significance. Gondwana Research 67, 1–
Standley, C.E. and Harris, R.E., 2009. 20.
Tectonic evolution of forearc nappes of the
active Banda arc-continent collision:
Origin, age, metamorphic history and
structure of the Lolotoi Complex, East
Timor. Tectonophysics 479(1-2), 66-94.

Tappenbeck, D., 1940. Geologie des


Mollogebirges und einiger benachbarter
Gebiete (Niederlandsch Timor). In:
Geological Expedition to the Lesser Sunda
Islands (edited H. Brouwer), 1, 1-105.
Thesis Amsterdam University, 105pp.

Vogler, J., 1941. Ober-Jura und Kreide


von Misol (Niedlandisch Ost-Indien).
Palaeontogr. Suppl. 4(4), 243-293.

Voorthuysen, J.H. van, 1940. Geologische


Untersuchungen im Distrikt Amfoan (NW
Timor). In: Geological Expedition to the
Lesser Sunda Islands under the
Leadership of H.A. Brouwer 2, 345-368.

Berita Sedimentologi, 2023 V. 49(2) 27

You might also like