You are on page 1of 4

TASK 1

Tzvetan Todorov's theory of the fantastic offers a valuable framework for understanding the nuances within
the genre, including the three subgenres: the uncanny, pure fantastic, and marvelous. These subgenres are
distinguished by the degree of hesitation, explanation, and the reliability of the narrator in relation to
supernatural or extraordinary events in the narrative.

1. The Uncanny:
The uncanny is characterized by hesitation. In this subgenre, the narrative presents supernatural or unusual
events, but both characters and readers remain uncertain about their authenticity. The narrator might be
unreliable, and explanations for the strange occurrences are often elusive.

Example: "The Haunting of Hill House" by Shirley Jackson


In Shirley Jackson's classic novel, the uncanny is vividly depicted. A group of people gathers in a supposedly
haunted mansion to study its paranormal activity. Throughout the story, the characters experience eerie and
inexplicable events. The uncertainty surrounding the supernatural happenings and the psychological unraveling
of the characters create a pervasive feeling of the uncanny. Jackson masterfully leaves readers questioning the
reliability of the narrator and the nature of the events, making it a prime example of this subgenre.
Plot: A small group of individuals, including Eleanor Vance, gathers in Hill House, a reputedly haunted
mansion, to investigate its paranormal activity. As they spend more time in the house, strange and unsettling
events occur, affecting the characters' sanity and the reader's perception of reality.

Todorov's Genres in "The Haunting of Hill House":


Hesitation: The narrative is marked by hesitation as characters and readers remain uncertain about the
authenticity of the supernatural occurrences. Initially, the characters are skeptical, but as they experience
increasingly bizarre events, they become convinced that something otherworldly is happening. This
uncertainty contributes to the feeling of the uncanny. For example, in "The Haunting of Hill House," the
characters express doubt and skepticism about the supernatural occurrences in the house. They question
whether the strange happenings are real or a product of their imagination. This is evident when Eleanor Vance,
one of the main characters, hesitates to fully accept the haunting until she experiences increasingly bizarre
events that challenge her skepticism.
Reliable or Unreliable Narrator: The narrator, Eleanor Vance, is considered unreliable due to her fragile
mental state. Her perspective of events is often distorted, and readers question her reliability in reporting the
supernatural incidents. Her mental instability adds to the ambiguity and doubt in the narrative. Her
unreliability is apparent when she starts to hear voices and has vivid, possibly hallucinatory, experiences. The
readers question her reliability as a narrator because her perspective is influenced by her psychological
instability.

Explanation Received or Unnecessary: The novel deliberately avoids providing a clear explanation for the
supernatural phenomena. Readers are left in a state of ambiguity, unsure whether the haunting is real or a
product of the characters' psyches. This lack of resolution maintains the unsettling feeling of the uncanny. For
instance, the inexplicable knocking and chilling manifestations in Hill House are never conclusively explained.
The absence of a rational explanation leaves the readers in a state of ambiguity, maintaining the unsettling and
uncanny atmosphere.

Shift in Narrative: A clear shift occurs in the narrative as the house's supernatural occurrences intensify, and
the characters' skepticism turns into belief. However, the novel does not offer a definitive explanation for the
events, preserving the feeling of the uncanny. For example, after experiencing a series of terrifying events,
Eleanor Vance's skepticism turns into belief. She becomes convinced that the house is haunted and that
malevolent forces are at play. However, the novel does not offer a definitive explanation for these events,
preserving the feeling of the uncanny throughout.

2. Pure Fantastic:
The pure fantastic is characterized by a lack of hesitation. In this subgenre, the narrative presents the
supernatural as undeniably real, and characters within the story accept its existence without doubt.

Example: "The Ocean at the End of the Lane" by Neil Gaiman


Neil Gaiman's novel is an excellent representation of the pure fantastic. The story revolves around a middle-
aged man who revisits his childhood home and reminisces about the extraordinary events that took place when
he was a young boy. These events include encounters with mysterious and magical beings. Importantly, there
is no ambiguity or hesitation about the existence of these supernatural elements. The characters, including the
protagonist, acknowledge and interact with the fantastical, making it a pure fantastic narrative.
Plot: A middle-aged man revisits his childhood home and reflects on the extraordinary events that occurred
when he was a young boy. These events involve encounters with magical beings, a pond that is a gateway to
another world, and a sinister entity from that other world.

Todorov's Genres in "The Ocean at the End of the Lane":


Hesitation: The narrative lacks hesitation, as both the characters and readers accept the existence of
supernatural elements without doubt. The protagonist, as a young boy, interacts with magical beings and
traverses through the otherworldly pond with unquestioning acceptance. The fantastical is seamlessly
integrated into the story. For instance, in "The Ocean at the End of the Lane," when the young protagonist
encounters the Hempstocks and their magical world, he accepts the existence of these supernatural elements
without any doubt or skepticism. The fantastical is seamlessly woven into the narrative.
Reliable or Unreliable Narrator: The narrator, the protagonist himself, is reliable in recounting his
experiences. He vividly recalls the fantastical events from his childhood, and his perspective is trustworthy in
conveying the magical elements. He describes his childhood memories and fantastical encounters vividly and
consistently. His perspective is trustworthy in conveying the magical elements of the story.
Explanation Received or Unnecessary: In this pure fantastic narrative, no explanation is required or offered
for the existence of the magical elements. They are taken for granted as part of the story's reality. The fantastic
elements are presented without the need for rationalization. The presence of the Hempstocks, the otherworldly
pond, and the sinister entity from that other world is taken for granted as part of the story's reality. The
fantastic elements are presented without the need for rationalization.

3. Marvelous:
The marvelous subgenre represents a narrative shift from the fantastic to the marvelous. In this category, what
initially appears to be a supernatural occurrence is ultimately revealed to have a rational explanation.

Example: "The Secret History" by Donna Tartt


Donna Tartt's novel showcases the marvelous subgenre. The story follows a group of students at an elite
college who become embroiled in a murder plot. At the beginning, there are elements that suggest the
supernatural - rituals, a secretive professor, and unexplained events. However, as the plot unfolds, these
occurrences are gradually explained through the characters' actions and psychological motivations. The shift
from the fantastic to the marvelous is evident as the initially mysterious events are clarified through logical and
human elements.
Plot: The story follows a group of students at an elite college who become embroiled in a murder plot. Initially,
there are elements that suggest the supernatural - rituals, a secretive professor, and unexplained events.
However, as the plot unfolds, these occurrences are gradually explained through the characters' actions and
psychological motivations.

Todorov's Genres in "The Secret History":


Hesitation: The narrative begins with elements that suggest the supernatural, leading to a degree of hesitation.
The characters and readers are unsure about the true nature of the events, and they question whether there is a
supernatural element at play. The rituals and the enigmatic professor create an atmosphere of uncertainty. The
narrative begins with elements that suggest the supernatural, such as the rituals and the enigmatic professor.
The characters and readers are unsure about the true nature of these events. For example, the students' rituals
and their secretive professor hint at a mysterious and potentially supernatural element, creating an atmosphere
of hesitation.

Reliable or Unreliable Narrator: The narrator, Richard, is considered reliable in presenting the events as he
perceives them. However, his perspective is limited, and he struggles to comprehend the motivations and
actions of his peers. This limited perspective contributes to the sense of ambiguity. He describes the actions
and interactions of his peers and the events at the college accurately from his point of view. However, his
limited perspective contributes to the sense of ambiguity as he struggles to fully understand the motivations
and actions of his peers.

Explanation Received or Unnecessary: As the story progresses, the initially mysterious events are gradually
explained through psychological and human elements, such as the characters' motivations and actions. The
supernatural elements, which were initially suggested, are revealed to be grounded in the characters'
psychological and emotional experiences, marking a shift from the fantastic to the marvelous. The explanation
is rooted in human behavior and choices. As the story progresses, the initially mysterious events are gradually
explained through psychological and human elements. For example, the rituals and actions of the characters
are revealed to be motivated by their own choices and desires, not supernatural forces. The supernatural
elements initially suggested are ultimately grounded in human behavior and choices, making any additional
explanation unnecessary. This marks a shift from the fantastic to the marvelous.

You might also like